UBC Theses and Dissertations
An evaluation of the Buddy/home Care Program : a palliative care program operated by AIDS Vancouver Leaney, Alison Ann
Acquired Immunodeficiency Syndrome (AIDS) is presenting a real challenge to our Canadian health care system. As the numbers of infected grow, the greater the realization that health care and social services as they currently exist, are unable to adequately address the overwhelming need. With a special emphasis on hospice/palliative care services, which are seen as essential and very appropriate in the care of persons with AIDS (PWAs), this study seeks to evaluate one such service - the Buddy/Home Care Program offered by AIDS Vancouver - as a means of improving this program and illustrating the need to establish others to achieve an integrated hospice/palliative care service. To evaluate the effectiveness of the Buddy/Home Care Program, four PWA Social Networks composed of four Persons With AIDS, five of their buddies, three Home Care Volunteers, two Buddy/Home Care Client Care Case Managers, and four Outside Agency Affiliated Persons, were interviewed using an interview guide approach. The interview guide was designed to tap the individual experiences of everyone associated with the Program, as well as their perceptions of the Program's strengths and weaknesses. Limitations in the study design and implementation arose from sampling, incomplete data, and researcher-related issues. Data analysis followed the dimensional model of the Glaser and Strauss grounded theory. The results are presented utilizing pertinent social network characteristics as a framework. First, each of the four PWA Social Networks are presented and described in relation to size and density. The networks vary in size from 12 to 25, and are characterized by low levels of density. Since the literature indicates that there is a positive association between network size and health status, it follows that the PWA with 12 individuals in his social network would have the lowest health status, while the PWA with 25 would have the highest. But this has not been found to be the case in this study. What is also unclear, is whether larger sized networks cause improved health, or whether health status determines network size. Although low density is far from the ideal prescribed by the hospice/palliative care approach, the literature is conflicting on the association between density and health status, suggesting that this low density is not necessarily undesirable. Second, an examination of the volunteer-client relationship subsystems reveals that the relationships fulfill the Client Care Case Managers expectations, in that the relationships between volunteers and clients range in intensity from being volunteer-client, to friend-friend, to parent-child oriented, and are characterized by a wide variety of emotional, informational, instrumental, and companionship support functions consistent with these relationship dynamics. And third, an examination of the volunteer-agency relationship subsystems reveals high levels of appreciation of informational support provided by the agency through its volunteer training, relatively infrequent contact between volunteers and Client Care Case Managers, variable experiences of emotional support received from Client Care Case Managers, minimal amounts of emotional support received from the Buddy Support Group, and some confusion about which staff members are responsible for volunteers pre- and post-assignment. Recommendations designed to improve volunteer-client and volunteer-agency relationships in the Buddy/Home Care Program, as well as others designed to promote the establishment of an integrated Canadian hospice/palliative care service are presented in conclusion.
Item Citations and Data