UBC Theses and Dissertations
Professional autonomy and resistance : medical politics in British Columbia, 1964-1993 Farough, D.
The issues surrounding health care and health care policy are of great concern to politicians and the public alike. Government efforts in restructuring medicare, the "jewel" of Canada's social safety net, also affects the medical profession. It has been argued that this once powerful and dominant profession is experiencing a decline in its powers and authority. Is this decline inevitable or can the medical profession adapt to government reforms in such way as to maintain and even strengthen its power base? This dissertation examines the themes of professional autonomy and professional resistance. The changing composition, and possibly the decline, of the medical profession's clinical, economic, and political autonomy, is analyzed through an historical case study of the British Columbia Medical Association (BCMA). Minutes from the BCMA's Board of Directors and Executive, along with interviews with doctors active in BCMA politics, and a media review, are used to generate a portrait of the social forces influencing medical politics in British Columbia from 1964 to 1993 and of the BCMA's relations with the various provincial governments of that period. The negotiating strategies of the BCMA and the decisions behind these strategies are the focal point for an examination of professional resistance, an area neglected in sociology. The dissertation looks at the external and internal conflicts that impact on the resistance tactics of the BCMA and at the various successes and defeats the medical profession experiences in its bid to maintain professional autonomy. During the time period under study, government intervention becomes more frequent and invasive. The BCMA has the least success in protecting the political dimension of professional autonomy and most success in controlling aspects of clinical autonomy. The vast variety of resistance strategies at its disposal distinguishes it from labour groups and most other professions. Forced to accept measures it once fought against, the BCMA's efforts become focused on ensuring that reform measures are under the control of doctors (rather than government) to the greatest extent possible. Although the BCMA has lost aspects of professional autonomy, it remains one of the few professional organizations today that can force compromise from the state.
Item Citations and Data