- Library Home /
- Search Collections /
- Open Collections /
- Browse Collections /
- UBC Theses and Dissertations /
- Kymlicka and the aboriginal right
Open Collections
UBC Theses and Dissertations
UBC Theses and Dissertations
Kymlicka and the aboriginal right Sandford, Christie
Abstract
This thesis is concerned with two central questions. The first is theoretical and asks, "Can a direct appeal be made to the foundational principles of liberalism to support collective rights?" The second question is practical and asks: "Would such a defense serve the interests of contemporary Canadian Aboriginal claims to special constitutionally recognized collective rights known as the Aboriginal Right?" I utilize Will Kymlicka's defense of minority rights as the theoretical framework in assessing this first question and in assessing the latter, I refer to various reported Aboriginal conceptions of the so-called Aboriginal Right which have been formalized by Aboriginal people themselves through constitutional addresses, Royal Commission hearings, discussion papers and legal claims. Part I of the thesis involves an enquiry into the nature of the revisions that Kymlicka proposes to make to liberal theory, and asks whether, in making such changes, he is able to retain identification with the so-called "modern" liberals, with whom Kymlicka identifies himself, and consistently defend the kind of group minority rights of the sort actually being claimed in Canadian society today. I conclude that Kymlicka argument fails in two respects: it fails to do the work required of it by modern liberals and it ultimately fails to do the work required by the standards of Kymlicka own theory. In Part II, I argue that even if it were theoretically possible to protect the good of culture in the way that Kymlicka hopes, such a defense of collective rights fails in the most important respect: that is, it cannot do the work required of it by the Aboriginal people for whom it was designed.
Item Metadata
Title |
Kymlicka and the aboriginal right
|
Creator | |
Publisher |
University of British Columbia
|
Date Issued |
1996
|
Description |
This thesis is concerned with two central questions. The first is theoretical and asks,
"Can a direct appeal be made to the foundational principles of liberalism to support
collective rights?" The second question is practical and asks: "Would such a defense
serve the interests of contemporary Canadian Aboriginal claims to special
constitutionally recognized collective rights known as the Aboriginal Right?" I utilize
Will Kymlicka's defense of minority rights as the theoretical framework in assessing this
first question and in assessing the latter, I refer to various reported Aboriginal
conceptions of the so-called Aboriginal Right which have been formalized by Aboriginal
people themselves through constitutional addresses, Royal Commission hearings,
discussion papers and legal claims.
Part I of the thesis involves an enquiry into the nature of the revisions that Kymlicka
proposes to make to liberal theory, and asks whether, in making such changes, he is able
to retain identification with the so-called "modern" liberals, with whom Kymlicka
identifies himself, and consistently defend the kind of group minority rights of the sort
actually being claimed in Canadian society today. I conclude that Kymlicka argument
fails in two respects: it fails to do the work required of it by modern liberals and it
ultimately fails to do the work required by the standards of Kymlicka own theory.
In Part II, I argue that even if it were theoretically possible to protect the good of culture
in the way that Kymlicka hopes, such a defense of collective rights fails in the most
important respect: that is, it cannot do the work required of it by the Aboriginal people
for whom it was designed.
|
Extent |
5826190 bytes
|
Geographic Location | |
Genre | |
Type | |
File Format |
application/pdf
|
Language |
eng
|
Date Available |
2009-03-06
|
Provider |
Vancouver : University of British Columbia Library
|
Rights |
For non-commercial purposes only, such as research, private study and education. Additional conditions apply, see Terms of Use https://open.library.ubc.ca/terms_of_use.
|
DOI |
10.14288/1.0087579
|
URI | |
Degree | |
Program | |
Affiliation | |
Degree Grantor |
University of British Columbia
|
Graduation Date |
1997-05
|
Campus | |
Scholarly Level |
Graduate
|
Aggregated Source Repository |
DSpace
|
Item Media
Item Citations and Data
Rights
For non-commercial purposes only, such as research, private study and education. Additional conditions apply, see Terms of Use https://open.library.ubc.ca/terms_of_use.