@prefix vivo: .
@prefix edm: .
@prefix ns0: .
@prefix dcterms: .
@prefix skos: .
vivo:departmentOrSchool "Applied Science, Faculty of"@en, "Mechanical Engineering, Department of"@en ;
edm:dataProvider "DSpace"@en ;
ns0:degreeCampus "UBCV"@en ;
dcterms:creator "Kardes, Nimet"@en ;
dcterms:issued "2009-12-11T18:57:45Z"@en, "2005"@en ;
vivo:relatedDegree "Master of Applied Science - MASc"@en ;
ns0:degreeGrantor "University of British Columbia"@en ;
dcterms:description "This thesis presents modeling of the mechanics and dynamics of circular milling operations. With the recent advances in CNC machine tools which have high contouring accuracy, the circular milling operations are used in high speed opening of pockets in die, mold and aerospace machining industry. While the cutter rotates around the spindle axis, it follows a circular-trochoidal path, avoiding momentary pauses to change feed directions. The cutter engagement conditions, hence the chip thickness, the cutting force directions and amplitudes, and the dynamic stability of the milling process continuously change in circular milling operations. This thesis presents the first research in modeling the mechanics and dynamics of circular milling operations in the literature. The kinematics of the chip removal generation is first modeled by considering the rigid body motions of the cutter and cutting edges. The time varying chip load and the resulting milling forces are predicted with experimental validation. The dynamic stability of the process is complicated by three factors. The system dynamics has two delay terms and two periodic behaviours. Additionally the parameters of the coupled differential equations have time varying coefficients. First, the stability of the system is solved by taking the averages of the periodic coefficients in the frequency domain. The stability law developed by Altintas and Budak are extended to the circular milling. Two alternative methods were studied to improve the frequency domain stability solution. The direct method proposed by Olgac and Sipahi, converged to the frequency domain solution since the assumptions were identical. The Time Finite Element method proposed by Stepan, Bayly and Mann is a numerical, time domain method where the time varying directional coefficients can be considered. To simplify the time finite element solution and decrease the computation time, only the most flexible mode in each direction was taken into account. The experiments were conducted to verify the proposed dynamic models and the simulation results obtained from frequency domain solution and time finite element method were compared against experimental results. Both methods gave reasonable results only for speed independent and low axial depth of cut region but they are not able to predict the stability of a circular milling operation accurately."@en ;
edm:aggregatedCHO "https://circle.library.ubc.ca/rest/handle/2429/16538?expand=metadata"@en ;
skos:note "MECHANICS A N D D Y N A M I C S OF C I R C U L A R M I L L I N G OPERATION by NIMET K A R D E S B.Sc , Istanbul Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey, 2002 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL F U L F I L L M E N T OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF M A S T E R OF APPLIED SCIENCE in THE F A C U L T Y OF G R A D U A T E STUDIES (Mechanical Engineering) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH C O L U M B I A March 2005 © Nimet Kardes, 2005 Abstract This thesis presents modeling of the mechanics and dynamics of circular milling operations. With the recent advances in CNC machine tools which have high contouring accuracy, the circular milling operations are used in high speed opening of pockets in die, mold and aerospace machining industry. While the cutter rotates around the spindle axis, it follows a circular-tro-choidal path, avoiding momentary pauses to change feed directions. The cutter engagement con-ditions, hence the chip thickness, the cutting force directions and amplitudes, and the dynamic stability of the milling process continuously change in circular milling operations. This thesis pre-sents the first research in modeling the mechanics and dynamics of circular milling operations in the literature. The kinematics of the chip removal generation is first modeled by considering the rigid body motions of the cutter and cutting edges. The time varying chip load and the resulting milling forces are predicted with experimental validation. The dynamic stability of the process is complicated by three factors. The system dynamics has two delay terms and two periodic behaviours. Additionally the parameters of the coupled dif-ferential equations have time varying coefficients. First, the stability of the system is solved by taking the averages of the periodic coefficients in the frequency domain. The stability law devel-oped by Altintas and Budak are extended to the circular milling. Two alternative methods were studied to improve the frequency domain stability solution. The direct method proposed by Olgac and Sipahi, converged to the frequency domain solution since the assumptions were identical. The Time Finite Element method proposed by Stepan, Bayly and Mann is a numerical, time domain method where the time varying directional coeffi-cients can be considered. To simplify the time finite element solution and decrease the computa-tion time, only the most flexible mode in each direction was taken into account. The experiments were conducted to verify the proposed dynamic models and the simulation results obtained from frequency domain solution and time finite element method were compared against experimental n results. Both methods gave reasonable results only for speed independent and low axial depth of cut region but they are not able to predict the stability of a circular milling operation accurately. iii Table of Contents Abstract ii Table of Contents iv List of Tables vi List of Figures vii Acknowledgement ix Nomenclature x 1.Introduction 1 2. Literature Review 3 2.1.Introduction 3 2.2. Mechanics of Milling Operation 3 2.3. Dynamics of Milling Operation 7 2.3.l.Tlusty's Approximate Solution 10 2.3.2.0pitz's Approximate Solution 12 2.3.3. Altintas & Budak's Frequency Domain Solution 15 2.3.4. Bayly's Time Domain Solution 16 2.3.5.Solution of a Linear Time Invariant Systems with a Time Delay u 17 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 19 3.1.Introduction , . 19 3.2.Geometric Modeling of Tool and Workpiece Intersection 21 iv 3.2.1 .Entry Transient Zone 22 3.2.2.Steady State Zone 25 3.2.3.Exit Transient Zone 26 3.3. Cutting Force Formulation 2 6 3.4.Simulations and Experimental Results 30 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 34 4.1. Introduction 34 4.2. Direct Method 35 4.3. Stability of a Single Degree of Freedom M i l l i n g Operation 42 4.4.Simulations 48 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 52 5.1. Introduction 52 5.2. Dynamics of Circular M i l l i n g 52 5.3. Analytical Chatter Stability 55 5.3.1. Frequency Domain Solution 55 5.3.2. Time Finite Element Analysis ( T F E A ) 61 5.4.Simulations and Experimental Results 70 6. Conclusion 77 6.1. Conclusion 77 6.2. Future Research Directions 79 Bibliography 80 v List of Tables Table 5.1 :Modal parameters in x direction 71 Table 5.2 :Modal parameters in y direction 71 Table 5.3 : Axial depth of cut and spindle speed values for cutting tests and simulations 72 Table 5.4 :Common cutting conditions 72 vi List of Figures-Figure 2.1 Mi l l ing operation 3 Figure 2.2 :Face, up and down milling 5 Figure 2.3 :Orthogonal and oblique cutting operations 6 Figure 2.4 :Dynamic chip generation in milling 8 Figure 2.5 :Regeneration mechanism in orthogonal cutting 8 Figure 2.6 :Tlusty's stability model for half immersion up milling 12 Figure 2.7 :Single degree of freedom interrupted turning model ' 16 Figure 3.1 :Formation of a slot by using circular milling ( Source: Sandvik Coromant) 19 Figure 3.2 :Top view of circular milling 20 Figure 3.3 :Tool positions during operation 27 Figure 3.4 :Cutting forces in tangential and radial direction 29 Figure 3.5 Simulated cutting forces in x and y directions 31 Figure 3.6 Measured cutting forces in x and y directions 31 Figure 3.7 Comparison of measured and simulated cutting forces at a small time window 32 Figure 3.8 :Variation of exit angle during the rotation of the tool around the workpiece 32 Figure 3.9 :Variation of chip thickness during the rotation of the tool around the workpiece 33 Figure 4.1 degenerative effect in milling operation 35 Figure 4.2 :A single degree of freedom milling system 43 Figure 4.3 Comparison of direct method with frequency domain solution 49 Figure 4.4 Comparison of direct method with experiments 50 Figure 5.1 :General representation of 2-DOF milling system 62 Figure 5.2 :Time finite element method developed for interrupted cutting operations 63 Figure 5.3 Simulated displacements for a stable circular milling operation cutting conditions (n= 1500 [rpm] and b=6 [mm], See Table 5.3) 73 vii Figure 5.4 :Simulated displacements for a stable circular milling operation cutting conditions (n=7200 [rpm] and b=ll [mm], See Table 5.3) 74 Figure 5.5 :Comparison of experimental and theoretical results 75 viii Acknowledgement I would like to express my sincere gratitude and appreciation to my research supervisor Dr. Yusuf Altintas for the valuable instruction, guidance, support and encouragement which he has provided throughout my research at University of British Columbia. I would like to thank Nesrin Altintas for her hospitality. I wish to thank my colleagues in the Manufacturing Automation Laboratory for sharing with me their knowledge and experience especially Doruk, Fuat and Kaan. I have a lot of good memo-ries that I will remember forever. I feel very lucky to share the life with my close friends, Evren, Bahar, Gokhan, Kivilcim and my boyfriend, liter, during my stay in Canada. They were with me especially during tough times and made my life easier and enjoyable. I would also like to thank my friends in Turkey for their continuous presence and support. Finally, I am deeply grateful to my beloved family, my mother Zuhal, my father Erol and my sister Demet for their lifelong love, encouragement, unwavering support and patience they have provided me throughout my entire life. This thesis and my all previous success are dedicated to them. ix Nomenclature ax directional milling coefficient in x direction ax() average directional milling coefficient in x direction aqi coefficients of trial functions [A], [B], [G] constant state matrice b axial depth of cut bum critical axial depth of cut c step over feed cx modal damping in x direction dxy. directional milling coefficient [D] directional milling coefficients matrix [DQ] average directional milling coefficients matrix / feed F resultant cutting force Fr radial cutting force Ft tangential cutting force Fx cutting force in the x direction Fy cutting force in the y direction h chip thickness h- t intended chip thickness int r X hm mean dynamic chip thickness [7] identity matrix j flute number k number of stability lobes kx modal stiffness in x direction Kc cutting force coefficient Ke edge force coefficient Kj-C feed cutting force coefficient Kje feed edge force coefficient Krc radial cutting force coefficient Kre radial edge force coefficient Kr ratio of radial to tangential force coefficient Ktc tangential cutting force coefficient Kte tangential edge force coefficient Ks resultant force coefficient me average number of teeth in cut mx modal mass in x direction n spindle speed «y number of elements np angular traverse speed along the tool path TV number of flutes q element number xi Rs radius of the slot Rc radius of the cutter st feed rate t time t i o c a i local time in an element Ts spindle period T period of tool's planetary motion tc time in cut tj- time spent during not cutting w number of revolutions z axial elevation a^- directional coefficients (i, j = x, y, z) (3 helix angle ^ damping ratio s phase shift between two waves i|/ phase shift y- trial functions (1=1,2,3,4) TJ test functions (p=l,2 ) Ax, Ay, Az vibrations in x, y and z directions Au vibrations in chip thickness direction A eigenvalue A 7 , A ^ imaginary and real part of eigenvalue xii [O] transfer function matrix Re(*) real part of the transfer function Im(O) imaginary part of the transfer function O 0 oriented transfer function *~~XX , Oyy direct transfer function in x and y directions 0 tool center position §st' §ex cutter entry and exit angles § p pitch angle § instantaneous immersion angle 4 » . immersion angle C))Q geometric mean of immersion angle x time delay and tooth passing period co angular velocity of the tool Q angular velocity of the tool around the workpiece con natural frequency coc chatter frequency cox tooth passing frequency xiii Chapter 1 Introduction Milling is one of the most common metal cutting processes in the aerospace and die & mold industries to produce wide variety of shapes from flat to angular and freeform surfaces. Periodic milling forces may cause deflections on the workpiece which lead to poor and wavy surface fin-ish. The aim? of the manufacturing research is to understand, model and predict the parameters which influence the surface quality, dimensional accuracy, machining cycle time and the cost which are important criteria in industry. The problems caused by periodic cutting forces and chat-ter vibrations can be avoided by selecting conservative depth of cut and spindle speed values and by increasing the dynamic stiffness of the machine tool-workpiece structure. However, such solu-tions result higher cost and loss in productivity. On the other hand, the process parameters can be optimized by mathematically modeling the interaction between the machine tool structure, work-piece, tool, cutting conditions and the machining process. Circular milling operation is a new machining strategy to empty pockets in die and mold industry, and to remove excess material from solid blanks to produce monolithic parts in the aero-space industry. In regular milling operation, the tool follows a straight or curved path with a con-stant immersion as long as the geometry of the workpiece remains constant along the tool path. In circular milling, the tool follows a circular trajectory in a plane. Due to kinematics of circular milling, the radial width of cut changes continuously which leads to time varying chip loads. Variation in chip load causes time and cutter position dependent periodic cutting forces in circular milling. Time varying chip loads may cause shifts in chatter stability lobes to higher axial depth of cut values for a given spindle speed value. The aim of this thesis is to model the mechanics and dynamics of circular milling operation which leads to the prediction of cutting forces and the chatter stability of the system. The thesis is organized as follows: 1 Chapter 1. Introduction 2 Chapter 2 covers the necessary background and the review of literature in milling process. Fundamentals of milling operation, previous models for prediction of cutting forces and chatter stability models are reviewed. Chapter 3 is dedicated to the mechanics of circular milling operations. Mechanics of circular milling is modeled. The generated static cutting forces are predicted and verified experimentally. In Chapter 4, an alternative numerical stability method, so-called the Direct Method, pro-posed by Sipahi et al. [31] for the stability analysis of linear time invariant time delay systems is presented. The chatter stability of single degree of freedom milling system is investigated by using the Direct method. The stability lobes simulated by using the Direct method is compared with the analytical, frequency domain solution presented by Altintas and Budak [11, 12]. The advantages and disadvantages of the Direct method are discussed. Dynamics of circular milling operation is explained in Chapter 5. Chatter stability of circular milling process is solved by implementing two different analytical solutions. The frequency domain solution proposed by Altintas and Budak [11, 12] and time finite element analysis intro-duced by Bayly et al. [7, 8] are applied. Chatter stability lobes are predicted and compared against the experimental results. The thesis is concluded with a summary of the performed study and possible future research directions. Chapter 2 Literature Review 2.1. Introduction Since milling operations are widely used in the manufacturing industry, significant research has been reported in the literature which is reviewed in this chapter. 2.2. Mechanics of Milling Operation Milling operation is an interrupted cutting process in which more than one point of the tool is contact with the workpiece. The workpiece is clamped on table and fed towards the rotating cutter with TV number of flutes placed in a rotating spindle ( See Figure 2.1 ). Rotational speed Figure 2.1 : Milling operation Unlike in the turning process, chip thickness changes continuously during milling operation due to rotation of the tool. Milling operation is classified into two groups namely face and periph-3 Chapter 2. Literature Review 4 eral ( end ) milling. In face milling operations, the entry § s ( and exit <|> angles of the tool are different from zero ( See Figure 2.2 ). There are two types of peripheral milling operation: con-ventional ( up ) and climb ( down ) milling. The entry angle § s t is zero and exit angle § is dif-ferent from zero in up milling operations. Thickness of the chip is zero at the beginning and increases as the tool rotates. The case is vice versa of up milling in down milling. The chip thick-ness takes its maximum value when the tool enters the workpiece and approaches to zero at the end of down milling operation. Since the cutting forces are a function of the chip thickness, the chip thickness generation is the main subject of early research [1, 9, 10, 28, 30]. Martellotti [22, 23] showed that actual path of the flute is an arc of trochoid and therefore the chip thickness has a complicated definition. He approximated the chip thickness h when the radius of the tool is larger than feed rate as follows: h = s(sm§ (2.1) where s( is the feed rate and (j) represents the instantaneous immersion angle. ( See Figure 2.2 ) When the dynamics of milling operation such as vibrations and tool jumping out of cut is consid-ered, the chip thickness expression given by Equation (2.1) can not explain the true kinematics. Altintas et al. [14, 21, 26] developed a more accurate kinematic model in time domain which dig-itizes the cutting surface and tool locations. The previously and presently cut surfaces are divided into small segments and by taking the difference between the two at each time step, more accurate chip thickness is evaluated. The model covers both the dynamics of the machine tool-workpiece structure and the kinematics of chip formation. Cutting forces are dependent not only the chip thickness but also axial depth of cut and cut-ting constants. The previous researchers, Tlusty&McNeil [35], Kline et al. [17], Sutherland and DeVor [32], and Montgomery, and Altintas [26], focused on the relation between the cutting forces arid cutting conditions. Armarego&Epp [6] developed a linear edge force model which is used in this thesis in order to calculate the cutting forces. Chapter 2. Literature Review 5 y Feed Face Milling y 4 Feed Up ( Conventional ) Milling y Feed Down ( Climb ) Milling Figure 2.2 : Face, up and down milling Chapter 2. Literature Review 6 In the model, cutting forces are defined in terms of axial depth of cut b, chip thickness h and cutting constants Kc, Ke: F = Kcbh+Keb (2.2) Cutting constants Kc, K£ are evaluated through either orthogonal to oblique transformation or using the mechanistic model [2, 17, 32, 35, 36]. In the orthogonal to oblique transformation cutting, the cutting velocity is straight. ( See Fig-ure 2.3 ) The cutting coefficients ( Kc, Ke ) are expressed in terms of tool geometry ( rake and helix angles ) and material properties ( friction angle, shear angle and shear stress ) [13]. The method is applicable when the cutting edge is sharp and the rake face of the tool is smooth. Orthogonal Cutting Oblique Cutting r| Chip-flow Rake face / a n 9 l e Figure 2.3 : Orthogonal and oblique cutting operations Chapter 2. Literature Review 7 Mechanistic model studied by Tlusty&McNeil [35], Kline et al. [17], Sutherland and DeVor [32], and Montgomery and Altintas [26], is more practical when the cutting edge has a very com-plex geometry. A set of milling experiments are conducted for specified workpiece material and tool geometry at different feed rates ( sf ) and the cutting forces are measured. Axial depth of cut b and radial width of cut (immersion ) are kept constant during the operation. By fitting a linear relationship to the experimental cutting force data as expressed in Equation (2.2), the average cut-ting coefficients Kc, Ke are identified. 2.3. Dynamics of Milling Operation When the vibrations of the machine tool-workpiece structure and its interactions with the cut-ting process are included, the process becomes dynamic. When the process becomes unstable, dynamic chatter vibrations occur which is one of the most severe problems in hindering produc-tivity in industry. Chatter, a self excited vibration, can be best explained by the \"regeneration of waviness\" phenomenon. When there is a relative vibration between tool and workpiece, the flute in cut generates undulations on the finished surface. The succeeding flute which also vibrates, cuts and leaves wavy surfaces. ( See Figure 2.4 ) The chip removed by the succeeding flute has a dynamic thickness because of the waviness on both sides of the chip. The dynamic chip thickness and hence the cutting forces may exponentially grow depending on the phase shift between the two subsequent waves while the machine tool-workpiece structure oscillates. Since the chatter is dependent on preceding pass of the flute, equation of motion of the milling operation has a time delay ( x ) term. The fundamental parameters, which affect the stability of dynamic cutting pro-cess are the time delay (i.e. period of the tooth evaluated from the spindle speed ) and depth of cut. Unless avoided, chatter leads to large growing dynamic cutting forces that cause poor surface finish and may damage the machine. Chapter 2. Literature Review 8 y X x-y Cross section at elevation z Figure 2.4 : Dynamic chip generation in mil l ing Tlusty [34] and Tobias [39] were the first researchers who studied the dynamics of the machining operations and explained chatter theory by regeneration phenomenon. Merritt [24] ver-ified the theory by using feed back control theory. The developed chatter stability theory is mainly valid for orthogonal cutting process in which the directions o f cutting forces and excitation are constant. ( See Figure 2.5 ) Figure 2.5 : Regeneration mechanism in orthogonal cutting Chapter 2. Literature Review 9 The model for chatter stability of milling operation is more complicated because of rotation of the tool with multiple flutes and coupled dynamics of the machine in orthogonal directions. Unlike in single point cutting, directional milling coefficients that determine the directions of cut-ting forces and excitation are time dependent. Assume that there is only one tooth which is at the radial immersion position (2.3) Fr 8 = atan— = atari AT where K is the ratio of radial to tangential cutting forces. The resultant cutting force on the tooth becomes: F(4») = KtJl +K2rbh($) = KJbhib) (2-4) where the resultant cutting force coefficient is Ks = KtcJ\\ + . When the tool has an approach angle, a three dimensional model of the milling force must be considered with a more detailed milling model as presented by Altintas [4]. The cutting forces in the feed and normal directions can be resolved as follows: FXW = -Fcos((|>-e), Fy(<|)) = Fsin(<|>-e) (2.5) Chapter 2. Literature Review • 10 The dynamic chip load created by the tooth and vibrations is [11, 12]: A((j)) = s?sin (2.6) where o) = co t is the angular position of the tooth for a spindle speed of co [rad/s]. Note that the static chip load ^sinc)^) is an input to the closed loop dynamics of the chatter, and does not affect the critical stability of the linear, dynamic machining system. Both vibration components (Ax, Ay) are dominated by the chatter vibration frequency (coc); so as the resultant cutting force, e.g. F(t) = Fei&ct. The vibrations at present t (x,y) and previous tooth period t-x (x^y^) can be expressed by [3]: x = ^xxdcoc)Fx(coc), x0 = e-^Oxx(mc)Fx(coc) y = %y(^c)Fy^ yo = e-^OyyiiasJFy'oiJ (2-7) Ax = x-xQ, Ay=y-yQ where xx and O are direct frequency response functions (FRF) of the structure in x and v directions, respectively. Since the cutting forces F and F are both dependent on the vibra-x y tions in the directions (x,y), the system has coupled dynamics. The stability of milling had been advanced steadily by Tlusty [37, 38], Opitz [27], Minis & Yanushevsky [25], Altintas & Budak [11, 12] as reviewed by Altintas [5]. 2.3.1. Tlusty's Approximate Solution Tlusty simplified the process by orienting the cutting forces from the directions of orthogonal springs to the direction of resultant cutting force as follows [37, 38]) Chapter 2. Literature Review 11 Ax = ( e - ^ T - l)0„(/coc)cos(<|) - Q)Fei)] xx yy {Fem<1} (2.9) The formulation given here orients vibrations and cutting forces from x, y spring directions to the direction of chip load §. D(§) is a periodic function and valid only between the entry § ( and exit angles § e x of cut. Tlusty used geometric mean of the immersion angle [37] ( See Figure 2.6 ), rather than taking an average value of [D((j))] as used by Opitz [27] and Week [41] as: ^0 = 0sin(<|)0 - 9) (2.11) Chapter 2. Literature Review which leads to time invariant and constant oriented frequency response function: (2.12) > x Figure 2.6 : Tlusty's stability model for half immersion up mil l ing 2.3.2. Opitz's Approximate Solution Unlike turning, the directional factors change as a function of spindle rotation, and they are 2TI periodic at cutter pitch angle § p = — . Opitz [27] used the average of the periodic directional function of the resultant force as opposed to geometric mean adopted by Tlusty. Chapter 2. Literature Review 13 \\-Do\\ = T - J [ sin())cos((t)-e) -cos ~cos(2(|>-0) I(sinG)(j) + icos(2(j)-e) (2.13) v v x y „ The oriented frequency response function of Opitz is also time invariant and constant, but different than Tlusty's approach. 0,2 V 0 + V 0 x xx y yy (2.14) Week [41] further considered the influence of direct and cross frequency response functions of the machine tool compliance similar to turning. However, while noting the time variation of the directional factors, he also averaged them and oriented all the vibrations at the cutting edge loca-tion. Hence, the time dependency from the chip thickness is still removed, and the chatter stability problem becomes a one-dimensional scalar problem since it is oriented in a fixed single direction like in turning. It can be solved by classical chatter theory presented earlier in 1950s by Tlusty [33] or Tobias [40]. The mean dynamic chip thickness becomes: hm = (e - , ' < n «T- \\)0QFeia^ (2.15) The average of the periodic function corresponds to the average of the dynamic chip thick-ness, which leads to mean dynamic resultant cutting force, Chapter 2. Literature Review 14 FemJ = Ksbhm = Ksb(e-ia^- l)O0Fe1^1 (2.16) For critical borderline stability analysis, the characteristic equation of the dynamic milling becomes, l + ( l - ^ T ) ^ A w O 0 ( / G ) c ) ( 2 - 1 7 ) where blim is the maximum axial depth of cut for chatter vibration free machining. The sta-bility lobes are then solved using the same formulation given for one dimensional theory [33, 40]: b l i m 2/C f#e(On(m )))mc 5 V v (Jv c''' e (2 18) 2&7i + s v 60 x = > n = — co TVx where coc [rad/sec] is the chatter frequency, x [sec] is the tooth passing period, /V is the number of teeth on the cutter, k is number of stability lobes and n [rev/min] is the spindle speed. i?e(O0) is the real part of the oriented frequency response function that can be evaluated by either approximations given in Equation (2.12) by Faassen [15] or in Equation (2.14) by Opitz [27]. Tlusty [37] adjusted the stability limit by scaling the system by an average number of teeth JV(<|> -<)>,) in cut, m - — — . Since Opitz and Week used the average resultant force direction by e 2n considering the pitch angle, m = 1 must be used in their models. The phase shift of the chatter waves can be found from: 7/w(O n) e = 3n + 2vi/->\\i/ ='atan — (2.19) i?e(12 w *21 l22 w q 1 *q2 w (w)* n revolution Figure 2.7 : Single degree of freedom interrupted turning model Chapter 2. Literature Review 17 where Ts is spindle period, tc defines time spent in cut, tj- = Ts- tc shows time spent during not cutting. Boundary conditions between elements were set by equating the displacement and velocity at the end of each element with the displacement and velocity at the beginning of the next element. The interrupted cutting operation is modeled as a discrete system. Equation of motion of the dis-crete system is rearranged in order to express the coefficients of the estimated displacement expression of an element at current pass a^ in terms of the coefficients at previous pass a™(~ 1 and intended chip thickness hi t: aw = [Q]aw-l + [S] (2.22) Magnitudes of the eigenvalues of [Q] matrix are determined for stability analysis of the dis-crete system. If the magnitudes are within the unit circle, the cutting is stable, and it is unstable otherwise. Later, Bayly's et al. [8] extended their work to two degrees of freedom interrupted systems. Two dimensional low immersion milling was used as an example. The rotation of the cutting forces in milling operation was considered as a function of immersion angle. The equation of motion was written in matrix-vector form in order to extend the model for multi degrees of free-dom systems easily. The time finite element method is explained in detail in Chapter 5. Time finite element method gives accurate results for low immersion interrupted cutting operations. The displacement and cutting forces can be simulated by using time finite element method but can not be predicted by frequency domain solution introduced by Altintas et al. [11,12]. 2.3.5. Solution of a Linear Time Invariant Systems with a Time Delay Sipahi et al. [31] presented an analytical solution for the stability of linear time invariant time delay systems. Time delay t in the equation of motion makes the system nonlinear. In order to Chapter 2. Literature Review 18 eliminate the nonlinearity, they replaced the time delay term e x s in the characteristic equation with a bilinear expression [29]) e~xs = (2-23) The solution is exact when the system is critically stable. They checked the stability of the new characteristic equation of the system by using Routh Hurwitz array. The details of the method and its application to milling system is explained in Chapter 4. Chapter 3 Mechanics of Circular Milling 3.1. Introduction Circular mil l ing is used for removing excess material from workpiece such as enlarging holes and forming slots in industry. The tool is following a circular toolpath in xy plane while the workpiece is being fed towards the tool as shown in Figure 3.1 Figure 3.1 : Formation of a slot by using circular mil l ing ( Source: Sandvik Coromant) The process is completed in xy plane with a constant axial depth of cut, followed by axial plung-ing to the workpiece at a fixed increment followed by circular mil l ing again. A s the tool travels around the circular path, the intersection of tool and workpiece changes as shown in Figure 3.2. 19 Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 20 View A: Entry transient View B: Exit transient Figure 3.2 : Top view of circular mil l ing Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 21 The tool follows a trochoidal trajectory [22,23,26], and has a time varying orientation along the cut which determines variation in chip load and the cutting forces. Circular milling operation is studied in three different zones shown in Figure 3.2 namely entry transient, steady state and exit transient zones. In this chapter, mathematical modeling of the tool-workpiece intersection is explained; prediction of cutting forces is discussed and consequently experimental validation of the mathematical model by using A17075-T6 is given. 3.2. Geometric Modeling of Tool and Workpiece Intersection The entry § s t and exit § e x angles of the tool, which change continuously in circular milling, must be identified to predict the chip load as well as the cutting forces. The entry bj + Rc not cutting yc>bl-Rc and xenbl-Rc and xen>xs Entry transient zone (y3 < bx and xe > xex) -» §st = 0 Steady state zone y3 b{ ): The tool enters the workpiece at point Pen, and its coordinates are given by substituting (y = bx ) into the tool expression given in Equation (3.1). {xs,ys) = (-c + jRf-Jlbx) (3.3) (Xe,ye) = (-c + jR^~bl-b2) (3.4) Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 23 V J (3.5) where cl =-2(Rs-Rc)sinQ c 0 = R}- 2RSRC + b2-2(Rs - Rc)bx cos 6 The larger of the two solutions from Equation (3.5) yields the x coordinate of the entry point Pen . By substituting the expression for the previous slot trajectory ( y2 = R2 - (x + c)2 ) given in Equation (3.1) into the tool expression in Equation (3.1), their intersection points (xi> y\\) a n < ^ F2^x2' yf) c a n ' 3 e f ° u n ( i a s a function of the step over feed c and angular position of the tool 0 with respect to circular slot center ( O ): x = Ay + B (3.6) where A=-2(Rs-Rc)cosQ B = -2c + 2(Rs-Rc)sind 2R2-c2 + 2RsRc 2c + 2(Rs-Rc)smQ By substituting x into the previous trajectory expression in Equation (3.1): y2 = R2-(Ay + B + c)2 a2y2 + axy + a 0 = 0 (3.7) Chapter, 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 24 where a2=A2+l ax = 2AB + 2Ac a0 = B2 + 2Bc + c2-R2 The quadratic equation has two roots which yields two intersection points P\\(x\\>y\\) a n d P2(xj,y-i) between the tool and circular slot segment ( See Figure 3.2 ): (xh2,yh2)=Ayx2 + B, * ^ (3-8) where A = a2 - 4a2aQ The tool does not cut any material behind its front periphery, hence the chip is not generated between P^x^y^) and P3(x3, y3) ( See Figure 3.2). The tool starts entering the work material at P3(x3,y3) and exits at P2(x2,y2) point. The coordinates of the tool center C and entry point P3 can be expressed in global slot coordinates as: (*3> ^ 3 ) = C^sinB, i^cosG) (xc,yc) = «Rs-Rc)smQ,(Rs-Rc)cosQ) A triangle is formed by Pen(xen, yen), P3(x3, y3), C(xc, yc) on the tool and the entry angle of the tool § s t into the workpiece at point P'en(xen, yen) is evaluated parametrically as: (,L\\nC + L\\r L2 1 _ „ 1 ~\"enC 3 C en3 i n i m $ s t ~ a c o s l 1 T T J (3-10) where Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 25 Lzc = J(x3-xc)2 + (y3-yc)2 LenC = J(xen-xc)2 + (yen-yc)2 Len3 = J(xen-x3)2 + (yen-y3'2 From the triangle connecting points P3(x3, y3), C(xc, yc), P2(x2, y2), the exit angle of the tool fyex at point P2(x2, y2) can be calculated as: where L2C = J(x2-xc)2 + (y2-yc)2 L23 = J(x2-x3)2 + (y2-y3)2 Points P3(x3, y3), C(xc, yc), P2(x2, y2) are expressed parametrically as a function of tool's angular position 8 in Equations (3.8) and (3.9). By incrementing ( 0 ) at discrete intervals, the variation of entry § s t and exit § e x angles can be evaluated from Equations (3.10) and (3.11). 3.2.2. Steady State Zone ( y3 < bx and xe > xex ): As the tool enters the steady state zone (y3 = bx ) the entry angle § s t becomes zero and dur-ing the rest of the cutting operation the entry angle fyst is always zero. The exit angle § e x can be evaluated as: ^2C + ^3C ^23 (3.12) Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 26 3.2.3. Exit Transient Zone (y3 < bx and( xe < xex) ): The entry angle § s t is always zero in this zone, while the exit angle § e x decreases which is shown at point Pex(xex, yex). (Figure 3.2 ) By substituting (y = -b2 ) to the tool expression in Equation (3.1), the x coordinate of the exit point can be evaluated as: (Xex> yex) r dx + Jd]-4d2d0 ^ ,-b (3.13) where d2 = 1 dx =-2(^- i? c ) s in6 d0 = R2-2RsRc + b2 + 2(Rs-Rc)b2cosQ The expression for the varying exit angle C where LexC = J(Xex-Xc)2 + iyeX-yc)2 Lex3 = J(xex-x3)2 + (yex-y3)2 3.3. Cutting Force Formulation The engagement conditions ( § s t , § e x ) leads to the prediction of varying chip thickness h at each tool location ( See Figure 3.3 ) as it rotates. The spindle speed ( n ) and angular traverse speed along the tool path ( np ) in [rad/sec] are given as follows: Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 27 to 2 n n Q = 2 n n £ 60 60 (3.15) J .y — \"\"*\"\"*'tif..,t \" ^ s H V 1 / C / w S 4 *-> C 10 , u , r t « « s w W ' ' ' ' \" Figure 3.3 : Tool positions during operation The feed / and feed rate st are measured along the feed axis of the tool ( xc ), which is tangent to the circular tool path as shown in Figure 3.2 and given by: f=n{R,-Rc) , 6 0 ' Nn (3.16) The tool is traversed along the circular path at uniform, discrete time intervals ( t ): Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 28 Q(k) = Q0 + Qkt, ^{(k) = §l0 + (okt k = 0,1,2,... (3.17) 6 0 and (j)10 are the initial positions of the tool and the first tooth respectively. The tool will be in the cutting zone and the tooth / will be cutting chip.only if the following conditions are met: where the entry fyst and exit § e x angles are identified along the path as given in the previous sec-tion. Otherwise the tooth will not cut any chip and contribute zero force to the process at that instance. Unless the width of cut varies, the process will be periodic both at the tooth passing fre-quency as well as at each frequency due to planetary motion. As an example, a cylindrical endmill with N flutes and (3 helix angle is considered. The instanta-neous immersion angle of tooth / , fy, at axial elevation z is expressed as ( See Figure 3.4 ) (3.18) ^ ( 6 ) < Uk) < < U 9 ) <>/*) = Mk)+v-mp+z tan (3 (3.19) The immersion dependent chip thickness /*• (Figure 3.1) cut by tooth /' is given by: hj = stsin§j(k) (3.20) The tangential Ftj and radial F • forces (Figure 3.4 ) acting on the tooth / are: Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 29 Ktch^Kte (3.21) Figure 3.4 : Cutting forces in tangential and radial direction B y scanning all the teeth which are cutting the material, instantaneous cutting forces acting on them can be projected in the global coordinate system of the machine as follows: N FX(Q, o» = X g^j)[(-Ftjcos^-FrJsin^)cosB + (F^.sin^-F^cos^Osine] J = l (3.22) N Fy(&,o» = X gC^H-Fy.cos^ . -F^ .s in^s inG + {Ftjsin^-Frjcosfy)cos9] y = i N FX(Q,$) = I g(bj)[-FtJcosty + B)-FrJsmWj + Q)] N Fy{B, (J)) = 2 g(> ilium\"\" : j | i .100 I i 1 1 1 ' ' i -> 219.6 219.8 220 220.2 220.4 220.6 220.8 221 221.2 Time [sec] Figure 3.5 : Simulated cutting forces in x and y directions Figure 3.6 : Measured cutting forces in x and y directions Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 400 Theoretical and Experimental Cutting Forces in x Direction 200 h 0 -200 -400 J _ J L A _ / L J L J L _ Theoretical Cutting Forces Experimental Cutting Forces 400 300 200 100 0 -100 220.9 220.91 220.92 220.93 220.94 220.95 220.96 220.97 220.98 220.99 221 Time [sec] Theoretical and Experimental Cutting Forces in y Direction - i 1 1 1— Theoretical Cutting Forces Experimental Cutting Forces 220.9 220.91 220.92 220.93 220.94 220.95 220.96 220.97 220.98 220.99 221 Time [sec] Figure 3.7 : Comparison of measured and simulated cutting forces at a small time window 35 Variation of Exit Angle 30 25 £ 20 - • O = 15 - / •4-1 X \" 1 0 y • 5 • 0 0 • • • 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 '160 180 Rotation Angle [deg] Figure 3.8 Variation of exit angle during the rotation of the tool around the workpiece Chapter 3. Mechanics of Circular Milling 33 Variation of Chip Thickness 0.2. , , , , • , Q . 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Rotation Angle [deg] Figure 3.9 : Variation of chip thickness during the rotation of the tool around the workpiece Chapter 4 Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 4.1. Introduction Rotating cutting forces that continuously change direction of oscillation are generated during milling operation. As periodic cutting forces excite one of the structural modes of the machine tool-workpiece structure, the cutting tool begins to vibrate and the flute in cut leaves a wavy sur-face on the workpiece. Each flute removes the existing surface and continue to leave a wavy sur-face behind ( See Figure 4.1), creating chips with waves on both sides. If two waves are in phase, dynamic chip thickness stays constant during milling operation and forced vibrations occur in the machine tool-workpiece structure. If there is a phase shift between these two waves, the dynamic chip thickness and the periodic dynamic cutting forces may increase exponentially, and the machine tool-workpiece structure experiences self excited vibrations called chatter. Chatter vibra-tions are dependent on the previous tooth pass, hence the mathematical representation of dynam-ics of milling operation contains a time delay term. A new analytical method, called Direct method, was developed for the stability of linear time invariant time delay systems by Sipahi et al. [31]. The difficulty in investigating the stability of time delay systems is that they have infinite number of roots, and up to now there have been no methods reported to find exact solution. Direct method is an exact and a general solution to stability of time delay systems, and it can be applied to milling process for assessment of stability lobes. In this chapter, Direct method is introduced, then steps followed for implementation to single degree of freedom (SDOF) milling operation are described. The stability lobes constructed from Direct method are compared to the stability lobes simulated by using frequency domain solution developed by Altintas et al. [12] and experimental results presented by Bayly et al. [8]. 34 Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 35 y CHATTER VIBRATION dynamic chip vibration marks left by tooth (j) I-kx FORCED VIBRATION constant chip load static chip (no vibration) Figure 4.1 : Regenerative effect in mil l ing operation 4.2. Direct Method A general time delay expression [31] in state space form given by following equation: where; x(n x 1) state vector, [d]n x „, [B]n x n , [ G ] n x n constant state matrices, [B]nxn state feedback matrix, [G]nxn derivative part o f control, x time delay ( x > 0 for causality reasons ) Dynamic behavior o f a time delay system is investigated by calculating roots of characteristic equation. B y taking Laplace transformation of Equation (4.1) the time delay expression can be represented in s-domain: x(t) = [A]x(t) + [B]x(t-T) + [G]x(t-x) (4.1) Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 36 sx(s) = [A]x(s) + [B]e~xsx(s) + [G]se~xsx(s) (4.2) (sI-[A]-[B]e-™-[G]se-™)x(s) = 0 (4.3) The characteristic equation of the time delay system is the determinant of Equation (4.3). Three different states are used to describe the dynamics of a system i.e. stable, unstable and criti-cally stable state. Critically stable conditions form a boundary between stable and unstable condi-tions. The main goal is to identify time delay values x at which the dynamic system is critically stable. D Subdivision method [19] is used in Direct method. According to D Subdivision method, there are regions, so-called pockets, in which the number of stable and unstable roots are fixed. Therefore the characteristic equation of the time delay system given by Equation (4.4) has at least one pair of purely imaginary roots s = ±corz while crossing the boundaries between these regions, co,. defines frequency in [Hz]. The time delay values x corresponding to the purely imag-inary roots s = ±cori represent transition from a stable state to an unstable state or vice versa. Equation (4.4) has infinite number of roots because of the time delay term e~xs. Therefore in order to simplify solution of the characteristic equation ( Equation (4.4)) time delay term e~TS can be replaced with a bilinear expression [29] shown below: CE(s, x) = det(sl- [A] - [B]e~xs - [G]se~xs) = 0 (4.4) e l-Ts l + Ts (4.5) The equality given by Equation (4.5) is exact and valid only when the time delay system is in crit-ically stable state (the time delay system has purely imaginary roots s = ±cori ). The relation between the time delay x (positive real number) and T (real number) is written as: Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 37 1 - ico T e m ' T = c o s c c > T - z ' s m c o / r , = r r 1 + i / Q + 1, / 0 + 2, / 0 + 3;' . . .oo , ' i s t h e smallest positive integer number that makes the time delay T given by Equation (4.9) greater than zero. After substitution of bilinear expression ( Equation (4.5) ) into the characteristic equation given by Equation (4.4), resultant characteristic equation which has n number of roots is obtained as a function of 5 and T: CE(s, T) = detl si- [A] - [B][ - [G]sf 1 T s l + Ts l + Ts (4.10) CE = det f s . . 0 ~An . •• ^ln f • -Bin -s ~Gn . • Gu 0 . • s . f^nl • V '' Bnn pm • • Gnn JJ Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 38 ( , In CE(s, T) = £ mrsln-r + £ brsn~r = 0 (4.11) a + r 5 ) \\ r 0 ; , r 0 where w r = mr(T) and 6 r is an integer. Equation (4.11) is multiplied by (1 + Ts)n to elim-inate the denominator, hence new characteristic equation becomes (2n)th order polynomial: 2n CEnew(s,T) = X ars2n~r = 0 (4.12) k = 0 where ar = ar(T). Although order of the characteristic equation of the time delay system ( Equation (4.11) ) increases, both equations ( Equation (4.11) and Equation (4.12) ) have the same imaginary axis crossings, furthermore Equation (4.12) is easier to solve. By using the coefficients of the characteristic equation given by Equation (4.12), elements of Routh-Hurwitz array [20] are formed to find the purely imaginary roots. The idea behind Routh-Hurwitz is to find number of unstable roots without solving the characteristic equation of time delay system. The information about stability of the time delay system can be obtained by using only the coefficients of the characteristic equation ( Equation (4.12) ). The new characteristic equation of the time delay system (Equation (4.12)) can be extended as follows: 2n 2n -1 , 2n-2 A , ^ a0s + a{s + a2s + ... + a2n_ xs + a2n = 0 (4.13) Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 39 Since the order of the characteristic equation of the time delay system ( Equation (4.13)) is 2n, Routh-Hurwitz array becomes ( 2 « + l ) x ( 2 n + l ) matrix. The general representation for Routh-Hurwitz array and calculation of the elements are as follows: a2 aA . • a2n • . . 0 . . 0 a l a3 a5 . • a2n- \\ • . . 0 . . 0 h b2 b 3 . . . 0 . . 0 . . 0 . . 0 h h2 h3 . . . 0 . . 0 . . 0 . . 0 u2 u2 . . . 0 . . 0 . . 0 . . 0 (4.14) (2 / i + 1) x ( 2 / i + 1) Sample calculations for some of the elements of Routh-Hurwitz array are given by following expressions [20]: Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 40 b. a\\a2-a0a3 a. ala4-a0a5 c, = bxa3 — a^b2 (4.15) di = clb2-c2bl The number of sign changes ( NS ) in the first column of the Routh-Hurwitz array in Equation (4.14) gives the number of unstable roots of the characteristic equation (NU) expressed by Equa-tion (4.13). Routh-Hurwitz array of a second order system is given as an example: -+n = 2^>NS = NU=2 Positive a2 a4 0 0 Negative a 3 0 0 0 Negative b2 0 0 0 Positive 0 0 0 0 Positive 0 0 0 0 j 5 x 5 There are two special cases that have to be taken into account when using Routh-Hurwitz array [20]. Some difficulties occur in the calculation of number of sign changes in the first column of Routh-Hurwitz array when only the first element of any one row is zero and the rest of the ele-ments are nonzero, or all the elements of one row are zero. To solve the first problem, zero in the first column of the row is replaced by a small positive integer number v or the characteristic equation of the system is multiplied by s + d where d is an arbitrary positive number. In the sec-Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 41 ond case, the zero row is handled by taking derivative of the equation formed by using the ele-ments of the row above the zero row, then the elements of zero row is replaced by the coefficients of the new equation. The elements in the first column of Routh-Hurwitz array given by Equation (4.14) are a func-tion of T. By scanning T from - co to oo various Routh-Hurwitz arrays are obtained representing the time delay system. The number of sign changes in the first column may change between sub-sequent T values. When the number of sign changes is different from the previous one, an imagi-nary axis crossing is assumed to occur. The characteristic equation given by Equation (4.13) has two purely conjugate imaginary roots if the difference in number of sign changes between subse-quent T values equals 2. If the difference is 1, one of the roots is equal to 0. The difference ( NSprevious - NScurrent ) can be either positive or negative. If the difference is positive, the dynamic time delay system may change its state from unstable to stable as following: Positive a2 a4 0 0 Negative a 3 0 0 0 Negative b2 0 0 0 Positive 0 0 0 0 Positive 0 0 0 0 Positive a 2 a 4 0 0 Positive s 3 0 0 0 Positive b2 0 0 0 Positive 0 0 0 0 Positive 0 0 0 0 5x5 •NS = NU=2 previous NS = NU=0^> T, present (4.16) 5x5 The purely imaginary roots of the characteristic equation (Equation (4.13)) is evaluated based on present T. If T is a negative real number, multiplication of a second order characteristic equation ( n = 2 in Equation (4.11)) by (1 + Ts)2 brings 2 unstable roots to the time delay system. In order to decide whether the state of dynamic system is stable or not, unstable roots coming from Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 42 negative T have to be considered during investigation of the stability. The second order system is stable if: NS = NU=0 and T>0 NS = NU=2 and T<0 The time delay x is found by substituting the obtained purely imaginary root co,. and present T values in Equation (4.9). Investigation of stability of a time delay system is concluded by calculat-ing the time delay x. 4.3. Stability of a Single Degree of Freedom Milling Operation Dynamics of a single degree of freedom ( SDOF ) milling system and application of Direct method to investigate stability of the system are explained in the section. Since milling operation is an intermittent cutting operation and the periodic cutting forces change direction of oscillation, dynamics of milling operation is very complicated. In general, at least two orthogonal degrees of freedom need to be taken into account. Depending on the machine tool-workpiece structure, milling system can be simplified to a single degree of freedom system. If modal parameters of machine-tool-workpiece structure in one direction are significantly higher than modal parameters in other directions, the system is rigid in all other directions and therefore considered to be a SDOF system. The system can also be assumed a SDOF system if the radial width of cut is small (low immersion angle ). A SDOF milling system shown in Figure 4.2 consists of mass mx, dash pot cx and spring kx elements. The tool rotates with a spindle speed of co [rad/sec], and the workpiece is fed towards the tool with a feed rate of st [mm/rev/tooth]. Immersion angle (cj) = §(t) = co*) is measured from positive y axis in clockwise direction, and radial width of cut is defined by entry § s t and exit § e x angles. The periodic cutting forces generated in tangential Ft-(t) and radial Frj-(t) direc-tions at tool-workpiece contact point are calculated as follows: Ftj(t) = Ktcbhj(t) Frj(t) = Krcbhj(t) (4.17) Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 43 / represents the flute number Ktc and Krc are empirical cutting force coefficients in tangential and radial directions, b is axial depth of cut, h is dynamic chip thickness = § + l)- (4.19) Time delay x is equal to the tooth passing period — in milling operation. Equation of motion of TYco the milling system can be described by projecting the periodic cutting forces in tangential Ftp) Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 44 and radial Frj(t) directions given by Equation (4.17) on x axis. The total periodic cutting force in x direction is obtained by summing forces generated by all flutes which are in cut: N Fx(t) = X g((t>,)[-^.(0cos(t);-Fry(0sin(t);] (4.20) 7=1 th To determine whether the /' flute is in cut or out of cut a step function g(y) is used: Sty) =1 ( 4 . 2 1 ) When the periodic cutting forces (Fx(t)) expressed in Equation (4.20) excite the machine tool-workpiece structure, the equation of motion for the milling system can be represented by: mxx(t) + cxx(t) + kxx(t) = Fx(t) (4.22) By substituting Equations (4.17), (4.18) and (4.20) into Equation (4.22): mxx(t) + cxx(t) + kxx(t) = ^Ktcbax(t){x(t)-x(t-x)} (4.23) where N ax(0 = I -gty)[sm2ty + Kr(l - cos2(|);)] (4-24) Kr = — is the ratio between radial (Krc) and tangential (K(c) cutting coefficients and ax(f) is time varying directional milling coefficient, which is periodic at tooth passing period. By consid-Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 45 ering only zero order term of its Fourier series expansion, the time variation of the directional coefficient is eliminated: «*o = -*\\\"x(t)dt (4.25) o axQ can be written as a function of instantaneous immersion angle § by substituting t by § into Equation (4.25): \"xo = T - ( 4 - 2 6 ) Resultant average directional milling coefficient fx^ becomes: axo = |^Q[cos2<|>-2£r<|>-.Krsin2<|>] (4.27) By substituting Equation (4.27) into Equation (4.23), the regenerative milling system dynamics is reduced to the following delayed differential equation: / M O + M O + M O = ^K(cbax0{x(t)-x(t-x)} (4.28) Direct method of Sipahi et al. [31] is applied to the milling system with flexibility in x direction. The structural displacement and velocity of the vibrating system are considered as states: Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 46 X\\(t) = x(t) x2(t) = xx(t) = x(t) (4-29) X2(t) = X j ( / ) = x(t) State space representation of the SDOF milling system is formed by substituting the states into Equation (4.28): 1 0 0 mv *i(0 x2(t) K + 2KtcbaxO ~Cx xx(t) x2(t) 0 0 X\\(t — x) x2(t - x) (4.30) In order to express the equation of motion in the form of x(t) = Ax(t) + Bx(t-x) + Gx(t-x) ( Equation (4.1) ), Equation (4.30) is multiplied by the inverse of 1 0 0 w v r 1 - l *i(0 1 0 x2(t) 0 mx_ k+-K,ha tcu^x0 Xl(t) x2(t) 1 0 0 0 0 2KtcbaxO 0 x^t-x) x2(t-x) (4.31) where [A] 2x2 0 1 M-kx + \\Ktcbaxo) ^r(-cx) mx 2 mx 2x2 [B] 2x2 - 0 0 2x2 2x2 0 0 0 0 2x2 Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation Since [G] is a zero matrix, the milling system is called a retarded time delay system and therefore characteristic equation of SDOF milling system can be found by substituting only [A] and [B] matrices into Equation (4.10): CE(s, T) = det CE(s, T) = det sl-0 r-k+-Ktrba} x 2 *c x l-Ts l + Ts 2x2 ' \\ K t M x 2x2. (4.32) = 0 To simplify the solution of the characteristic equation, Equation (4.32) is multiplied with (1 + Ts)2, and the new (2n)th = 4th order characteristic equation with a form similar to Equa-tion (4.13): 4 3 2 a0s +axs + a2s +a3s + a4 = 0 a^T2 CxT1 a , = - ^ + 2T mx a2 = _kxT2 + 2cxT-Ktcbax0T2 + 1 _ 2 k X T + C x - K t c b a x O T a4 = (4.33) By using the polynomial coefficients a0, ax, a2, a3, a4 given by Equations (4.33) and (4.15), the elements of Routh-Hurwitz array are evaluated: Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 48 a0 a2 a4 0 0 ax a3 0 0 0 bx b2 0 0 0 d, 0 0 0 0 (4.34) The elements of Routh-Hurwitz array given by Equation (4.34) are functions of (T) and axial depth of cut b. By scanning T from -co to oo for a desired axial depth of cut b, Routh-Hurwitz arrays are evaluated and the number of sign changes in the first column of each array is detected. For the corresponding T values, where the number of sign changes varies, the characteristic equa-tion of the SDOF milling system given by Equation (4.33) is solved based on the present value of T to find purely imaginary roots s = ±(ori. Minimum positive integer / 0 which makes the tooth passing period x greater than zero is found by substituting present value of T and corresponding positive value of cor into Equation (4.9), and by incrementing the / 0 by one, tooth passing period values of x are evaluated. Spindle speed (n), where the milling system behaves critically stable for the given axial depth of cut b, can be obtained as: (435) yVx The stability lobes of the SDOF milling system can be evaluated by repeating the given steps for the specified range of axial depth of cut b. 4.4. Simulations A MATLAB program has been developed to evaluate the validity and applicability of the method applied to the milling stability problem. The stability lobes are simulated by using both the Direct method and the frequency domain solution proposed by Altintas et al. [12] and com-pared against each other. Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 49 In the simulations, a cylindrical end mill having Rc = 9.525 [mm] radius with 2 flutes is used for slotting operation. A l 7050T6 is selected as workpiece. The dynamic parameters of the 4 SDOF milling system in x direction are natural frequency (£>nx = 500 [Hz], stiffness kx = 10 [N/mm] and damping ratio \\ x = 0.05. Since the stiffness values in y and z directions are assumed to be 10 times greater than the stiffness value in x direction, the milling system is consid-ered as rigid in y and z directions. The cutting coefficients in tangential and radial directions are Ktc = 900 [N/mm2], Krc = 270 [N/mm2]. Axial depth of cut b is scanned from 3 [mm] to 25 -2 -7 [mm] and T is swept from -6x10 to-1x10 .The step sizes for axial depth of cut b and T _7 are Ab = 2 [mm] and AT = 1 x 10 . The purely imaginary root of the characteristic equation s = (ori show chatter frequency coc for given axial depth of cut b and tooth period x. The simulated stability lobes are shown in Figure 4.3, where frequency domain solution and direct method are in consistent. Also, if point A ( b = 4.99742 [mm], n = 5000 [rpm] ) in Figure 4.3 is considered, both methods give the same chatter frequency coc = 550.6 [Hz] as well. Stability Lobes 25 H - ^ L b=4.99742 mm | n=5000 rpm I coci=550.66lHz j 0 02 04 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 Spindle Speed [rpm] 14 16 1.8 4 x 10 2 Figure 4.3 : Comparison of direct method with frequency domain solution Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 50 Stability lobes are also constructed for different cutting conditions in order to compare the Direct method with experimental results published by Bayly et al. [8]. In the experiments, a cylin-drical end mill having Rc = 9.525 [mm] radius with one flute was used. Modal parameters in x 3 direction were natural frequency a>nx = 146.5 [Hz], stiffness kx = 2.18 x 10 [N/mm] and damping ratio t,x - 0.0032. Setup of the experiment was designed in such a way that stiffness values in y and z directions are more than 20 times greater than the stiffness value in x direction. The cutting coefficients in tangential and radial directions were Ktc = 550 [N/mm2], Krc = 200 [N/mm ] respectively. The ratio between time in cut tc and total time was p = 0.162. In the simulation, scanning range for axial depth of cut b is from 0.3 [mm] to 3.9 [mm] and -1 -4 for T is from -3 x 10 to -1 x 10 . The step sizes for axial depth of cut b and T are Ab = 0.3 [mm] and A r = 5 x l 0 5 . The simulated stability lobes and experimental results are shown in Figure 4.4. They are in good agreement. Stability Lobes 1 1 1 Direct Method o Stable Cutting • Unstable Cutting • Stability Border 0 1 i i \\ i i L 2600 2800 3000 3200 3400 3600 3800 4000 Spindle Speed [rpm] Figure 4.4 : Comparison of direct method with experiments Chapter 4. Direct Method for Chatter Stability of Milling Operation 51 The disadvantage of the Direct method is its long computational time. The MATLAB pro-gram for Direct method takes approximately 1 day. The most time consuming part of Direct method is scanning of T values with very small increments between -co to oo for each axial depth of cut b value. Later, Sipahi & Olgac improved their method by including a new algorithm and the computational time for new method ( CTRC method ) is same as the frequency domain solution. Chapter 5 Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 5.1. Introduction Chatter is a self excited vibration originated by regenerative effect caused by phase shift between two successive waves left on both sides of the chip during circular milling operation. Since the poor surface finish, tool breakage, tool wear and large dynamic loads on machine tool structure are the main outcomes of chatter, dynamics of the circular milling operation has to be investigated in order to increase the quality of the process and material removal rate. Dynamics of regular milling operation has been summarized in Chapters 2 and 4. Dynamics of circular milling operations is more complicated than regular milling operations due to the planetary motion of the tool around the workpiece. Cutting forces are periodic not only at tooth passing period but also at period of circular motion of the tool around the workpiece. Although variation in entry § s t and exit <|> angles of the tool brings additional complexity to the dynamics, varying radial depth of cut may cause a shift in stability lobes. In this chapter, dynamic cutting forces are discussed and two analytical approaches, namely frequency domain solution presented by Altintas et al. [4] and time finite element method developed by Bayly et al. [8], are used to investigate the chatter stabil-ity of circular milling. Finally the theoretical stability lobes are compared with the experimental results. 5.2. Dynamics of Circular Milling Dynamic cutting forces excite the machine tool-workpiece structure in global x and y direc-tions and form dynamic displacements. Dynamic displacement in chip thickness direction is eval-uated in terms of tool's angular position, 9, instantaneous immersion angle <|>. of tooth /, and vibrations in global coordinates as follows: h(Q, fy) = JfSinCty) + Axsin(9 + fy) + A.ycos(9 + fy) (5.1) 52 Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 53 where h(fy) = stsinfy + Axc(t)sinfy + Ayc(t)cos^j Axc(t) = Ax(*)cos9-A>'(/)sin0 &yc(t) = Ax(0sin8 + Ay(Ocos0 5fsin((|).) defines the static part and Ax(/)sin(0 + <|>.) + Ay(*)cos(0 + fy) represents the dynamic part of chip thickness in Equation (5.1). h(fy) is the dynamic chip thickness in tool coordinates, xc and yc. Axc(t) = xc(t)-xc(t-x) and Ayc(t) = yc(t)-yc(t-x) express difference between dynamic displacements at previous and current cuts in xc and yc directions. Ax(t) = x(t)-x(t - x) and A.y(t) = y(t)-y(t - x) show the same difference in global coor-dinates. Since the static part has no effect on stability [3], s^s in^) can be eliminated from the chip thickness definition in Equation (5.1) and the resultant dynamic chip thickness expression becomes: Dynamic cutting forces acting on tooth / in global coordinates F •, Fy- can be evaluated as a function of cutting coefficients Ktc, Kr, axial depth of cut b, chip thickness h, angular position of the tool 0 and instantaneous immersion angle of tooth / as follows: h(Q,fy) = Ax(Osin(0 + ()>;) + A>;(Ocos(0+ ()>,.) (5.2) FX(Q, fy) = -Ktcbh(Q, fyHcosCe + .) + tfrsin(e + fy)] Fy(Q, fy) = -Ktcbh(Q, ());)[-sin(0 + fy) + /C rcos(0 + fy)] (5.3) By substituting Equation (5.2) into Equation (5.3): (5.4) Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 54 where E = 9 + (5.5) Total dynamic cutting forces Fx, Fy are calculated by summing the forces generated by each tooth j Fxj, Fyj in Equation (5.4): FX(Q, 4,) = £ Fxj j= i Fy(d, *) = x ^ (5.6) {F(0} = ^ C 6 [ D ( 0 ] { A ( 0 } (5.7) where [0(01 = ^xx ^xy dyx ^yy_ is directional milling coefficient matrix and drr, d „ „ d „ r , d,n. are directional milling coefficients in global coordinates which show the direction of excitation as the tool rotates during circular milling operation given by: Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 55 N dxxi^ )= £ gjfy) [~Kr - s i n 2 £ + Krcos2E] j= i N dxy(Q> ) = T.-gjty) [-l-Krsin2E-cos2E] j ° x (5.8) N dyx(Q, ((>) = X gjfy) [1 - cos2E-Krsin2E] j= i ^ ( 9 , ())) = ^ g/ty) [ - * r - t f r c o s 2 £ + s i n 2 £ ] 5.3. Analytical Chatter Stability In this section, two analytical models, namely frequency domain solution developed by Alt-intas et al. [12] and time finite element analysis proposed by Bayly et al. [8] are applied to the sta-bility of circular milling process. 5.3.1. Frequency Domain Solution The frequency domain solution introduced by Altintas et al. [12] is a practical method for the assessment of stability of milling operations that defines the dynamics in terms of material prop-erties, tool-workpiece intersections, tool geometry and frequency response function of machine tool structure [4]. The analytical model is based on linear system, and the circular milling dynam-ics need to be simplified based on the physics of the process. Directional milling coefficients are periodic at tooth passing period x as well as at period of the tool's planetary motion around the workpiece (T =' — = —). Since the problem is very p np Q complicated from mathematical point of view due to presence of double periodicity, the direc-tional matrix is expanded for the tooth passing period x:; Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 56 [D(t)]= X [Dr]eim^ r = - oo [Dr] = ±)[D(t)]e-iraSdt o In order to simplify the solution only the zero order term of Fourier series is considered: (5.9) [D0] = -)[D(t)]dt (5.10) x 0 Angular position of the tool around the workpiece 9 and time t are written in terms of instanta-neous immersion angle § to decrease the number of unknown variables in Equation (5.10): 9 = Qt, = cor —> 0 = — 4> = — <|> 0 0 H (5.11) dQ = —d§, dt = — d§ co co which leads to the following average directional factor: [Z) 0 ] = i- | Z ) ( « 4 (5-12) Main differences between frequency domain solution of circular milling and regular milling are varying entry § s t and exit § e x angles of the tool that determine the limits of integration in circular milling operation. Entry angle § s [ is assumed to be §st =. 0, and exit angle § e x is assumed to be §ex = m a x ( . § e x ) t 0 c a r r y o u t t n e integration. Exit angle § e x is taking its maximum value when Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 57 the tool is close to center of the circular slot as mentioned in Chapter 3. New immersion depen-dent average directional milling coefficients are given as follows: a a •yy 2 V / / + 1 H 2 r^H+l H Xy 2 W + 1 2 r V / / + l V ^ T T T T ) s i n f 2 4 , (2± i y ) + k f 7 7 7 T J cosl 2 * 2 V / / + 1 7/ 2 H+ 1 7Y 2V//+ 1 H JJ 2 r^H+l H (5,13) The resultant dynamic cutting forces are defined by substituting the zero order term of Fourier series [D 0] ( Equation (5.12)) into dynamic cutting forces expression in time domain given by Equation (5.7): {F(t)} = l-Ktcb[D0]{A(t)} (5.14) where axx axy *fyx (Xyy_ The vibrations {A(/co)} are written in terms of dynamic cutting forces {F(z'co)} and fre-quency response function of the machine tool structure [O(z'co)]. {F(zco)} = l-Ktcb[DQ-\\{A(m)} (5.15) Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 58 A * ( / C 0 ) I = ( l . g - I C D T ) ^ ^ ) ] , A y ( / c o ) J Fx(m) (5.16) where { A ( / c o ) } = j ^ i a ) 1 = ( l - e - ' W '^(°) } I A j / ( / a ) J I ^ ( / c o ) J [e F., (5.18) >e I-^Ktcb[D0](\\-e-'^)[O(icoc)] = 0 Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 59 The stability problem turns into an eigenvalue problem which is easier to solve for a given chatter frequency, co c , and has a nontrivial solution when the determinant equals to zero [3]: det[I+ A[00(icoc)]] = 0 (5.19) where TV A = -—Ktb( 1 - e ' ( ° c T ) is the eigenvalue of the characteristic equation of the system. [O 0 (zco c )] axx °\"xy ayx ayy_ is the oriented frequency response function matrix and characteristic equation becomes a second order polynomial: 1 0 + A axx axy _ 0 1 ayx v det h0A2 + h{Al + 1 = 0 0 %y(iac) = 0 (5.20) where h0 = ^ x x i ^ c ^ y y i ^ c ^ x x ^ y y - ^ y j h \\ = axx®Ji(»c) + ayy(I>yy(iuc) A = — L - ± J 2 = A + iAIm 2h0 R I m Chatter free critical axial depth of cut b l i m is given by: NKtc(l-e m x Figure 5.1 : General representation of 2-DOF milling system In order to obtain resultant equation of motion, tangential Ft- = Ktcbhj and radial F • = Krcbhj cutting forces acting on tooth / and dynamic chip thickness hj = sts'm$j+[x(t)-x(t-T)]sm§j + [y(t)-y(t-T)]cos§j expressions are substituted in Equation (5.28): [M]hO + [C]x(t) + [K]x(t) = [Kc() = I gfyX j= 1 -Ktc cos /-A\" r c sin2 - £ , c cos2 4»y—A r^c sin cos fy-A:,c sin2 fyj-Krc cos sin AT,C sin cos y- r^c cos2 J -AT/C cos <|) • sin fy-^-csm2 sin2 $rKrc cos sin J Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 63 Time finite element method subdivides the low immersion milling operation in two parts: cutting ( forced or chatter vibration ) and not cutting ( free vibration ). The method divides the time in cut into multiple finite time elements shown in Figure 5.2 and defines x and y displace-ments approximately at the beginning and end of each element during each pass as a linear combi-nation of polynomial trial functions. Displacement of the tool on qth element during wth pass of the tooth is: *w(0 yd*local) • i= 1 N N N N j ^ N C u t t i n g v e l o c i t y Ts t f t c a « } U2J W i 3 \"^} ( W - 1 ) t h r e v o l u t i o n a H H a O H a„J a. '21 J22 q 1 *nf3 ( w ) * n r e v o l u t i o n (5.30) Figure 5.2 : Time finite element method developed for interrupted cutting operations Velocity and acceleration on qth element during wth pass of the tooth are: 4 4 no = rco = x Ki • y tCiocai)* no = '\"\"co = I ^ • Y/( (5 .3 D J = 1 ( = 1 Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 64 where Qq\\i&q2>Qq3>Q'q4 a r e m e coefficients of the polynomials for qth element and tlocal expresses the local time in qth element during wth pass of the tooth: q-l hocaid) = t - w x - ^ t k (5-32) k= l where 0 < tlocal ^tq, t defines total time, tk is time length of kth element. If the length of all elements are same, tk can be given as follows: «y shows the total number of finite elements. Total time passed during cutting tc is: tc = X tk (5.34) k= 1 Ji(tlocal), cubic Hermite polynomials that are selected for their boundary conditions, given in Equation (5.30) are trial functions: Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 65 v uj v uj I ~~*2 0 px p2 flu A21 «22 anf\\ anf2 anF4 + C n Cl2 C21 C22 Cnj\\ C„f2 C„f3 CnF4 (5.43) where _ *11 Nn ^2 = NH N22 (4 x4) N23 N24_ _ 'Pl! Pn P2 = 'Pn Pu P21 P22 (4 x4) P23 PTA (4x4) (5.44) The dimension of global [TV] and [P] matrices in Equation (5.43) is (4«y+4) x (4nf+4) and the dimension of global [C] matrix is (4ny+ 4) x 1. Linear discrete dynamical system given by Equation (5.43) can be described as: aw = [Q]aw~l + [S] (5.45) Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 69 where [N]aw = [P]aw~l + [C] [Q] = [N]~i[P] [S] = [N]~i[C] By verifying magnitudes of eigenvalues of [Q] matrix, stability of 2D0F milling system is determined. If one of the magnitudes is greater than 1, the system is unstable. In order to investigate the stability of circular milling operations, the application of the time finite element method has to be explained. [Kc] and fQ in Equation (5.29) are different from reg-_ A ular 2-DOF milling operation because of the planetary motion of the tool. [Kc] and f0 are depen-dent on not only instantaneous immersion angle (j) but also angular position of the tool 9: y = i 2 tc -Kr - s'm2E + Krcos2E -\\-Krsin2E- cos2is 1 - cos2i?-.ft\",.sin2£ -K-Krcos2E + sin2£' (5.46) N /o(*) = I ^ ( ^ P t c - sin (()).) cosE - Kr sin ( 4 » . ) sinis sin ((()•) sinE - Krsm($j) cosE f In order to eliminate one of the variables, the relation between instantaneous immersion angle <|> and angular position of the tool 9 given by Equation (5.11) ( 9 = &,E = <)• + ^ ) is H H substituted in Equation (5.46). Exit angle § e x (immersion) is assumed to be constant during one tooth passing period and is calculated as mentioned in Chapter 3 for the starting condition of each tooth passing period ( 9 = Q?-^ ,r = 0, 1,2, ... -^-number of tooth passing periods ) while variation of co exit angle § e x is calculated by time finite element method. The planetary motion of the tool is modeled in time finite element method by summing up the successive rotations of the tool around itself to form the circular toolpath around the workpiece. Global [N], [P] and [C] matrices in Equation (5.43) are different for each tooth passing period since [Kc(§, 9)] and f0(§, 9) in Equation (5.46) are changing as the angular position of the tool 9 alters. Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 70 Although the immersion as well as time in cut tc varies during circular milling operation, the number of finite elements «y is kept constant for each tooth passing period by changing the length of elements tk from one tooth passing period to another to make the size of the global [TV], [P], [C] and hqi matrices given by Equation (5.43) equal. Time in cut tc is divided in such a way that all the finite elements have the same time length during one tooth passing period. The stability of the circular milling system is obtained by verifying magnitudes of the dynamic displacements at the end of one tooth passing period of the tool around the workpiece. If the dynamic displacements increase exponentially, the system behaves unstable, otherwise it is stable. The periodicity coming from successive revolutions of the tool around the workpiece is ignored during the simulations. 5.4. Simulations and Experimental Results In the previous sections, dynamics of circular milling operation have been introduced and two analytical approaches have been explained in detail. In order to verify the chatter stability models for circular milling, experiments were held for a range of axial depth of cut and spindle speed values, which are given in the Table 5.3. An end mill having Rc = 10 [mm] radius and N = 4 teeth was used. A l 7075T6 was used as the workpiece. The tangential and radial cutting force coefficients obtained experimentally by using mechanistic approach were Ktc = 796.077 [N/mm2] and Krc = 168.829 [N/mm2]. The step over feed c = 5.7738 [mm], the feed rate per tooth st = 0.1 [mm/rev/tooth], the width of the slot Rs = 25 [mm], the maximum immersion angle & m . r = 65° and the ratio between speeds H = 235.6 were determined as cutting condi-tions for the experiments. Chatter detection is made based on the ratio of dynamic over static chip thickness as well as the frequency content of both cutting force and tool vibration. The modal parameters in x and y directions given by the Table 5.1 and Table 5.2 are used in both the fre-quency domain and time finite element simulations: Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 71 Table 5.1 : Modal parameters in x direction Mode Natural Frequency co„ Damping Ratio £, Stiffness k Number [Hz] [N/mm] 1 486 0.0463 9.41 x 104 2 617 0.0138 38.06 x 10 4 3 714 0.0175 9.51 x 104 4 1007 0.0556 2.37 x 10 4 5 1380 0.0137 155.77 x 104 6 1874 0.0200 43.4 x 10 4 7 2270 0.0233 22.57 x 104 8 2770 0.0184 23.03 x 10 4 9 3010 0.0183 32.32 x 10 4 10 4059 0.0083 23.65 x 104 Table 5.2 : Modal parameters in y direction Mode Natural Frequency con Damping Ratio £, Stiffness k Number [Hz] [N/mm] 1 759 0.0315 4.43 x 104 2 980 0.0444 5.97 x 104 3 1695 0.0177 82.6 x 10 4 4 1909 0.0079 272.57 x 10 4 5 2045 0.0086 219.89 x 104 6 2395 0.0192 32.55 x 10 4 7 2770 0.0181 32.69 x 10 4 8 3010 0.0191 37.94 x 10 4 9 4045 0.0136 21.13 x 104 Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 72 Table 5.3 : Axial depth of cut (b) and spindle speed (n) values for cutting tests and simulations Test no Axial depth of cut b [mm] Spindle speed n [rpm] Stability (Experiment) Stability ( T F E A ) Stability (Frequency) 1 6 1511 S S S 2 6 1992 S S S 3 11 3000 S S US 4 11 3501 US s S 5 11 3750 S s S 6 11 4211 US us US 7 4188 S s s 8 11 4600 US us s 9 11 5201 us s s 10 5185 S s s 11 11 5850 S ' • s cs 12 11 6598 us us us 13 6594. s s cs 14 11 7205 us us us 15 11 7515 us us cs 16 8 7506 s s s 17 11 8024 us s s 18 8 8000 s s s S, US and CS are used for stable, unstable and critically stable cuts respectively in Table 5.3. Common cutting parameters are given in Table 5.4: Table 5.4 : Common cutting conditions Workpiece=Al 7075T6 N=4 teeth (endmill) Rc=10 [mm] K tc=796.077 [N/mm2] K rc=168.829 [N/mm2] Rs=25 [mm] c=5.7738 [mm] st=0.1 [mm/rev/tooth] KK235.6 Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 73 i 0 . 5 x 1 0 _£5 ' o 1 . 5 2 Time l sec ] \"d 1 1 5 0 . 5 > . . = 0 S - 0 . 5 E a> ° -1 -5 O 5 4 . 5 4 3 . 5 3 2 . 5 2 1 . 5 1 0 . 5 ' x 1 0 0 . 5 1 1 . 5 2 2 . 5 3 T i m e [sec] F F T of D i sp lacement in y Direct ion ( T F E A ) 2 c o T \" 8 7 1 7 4 2 6 1 3 4 8 4 3 5 5 2 2 1 0 0 0 F r e q u e n c y [Hz] 1 5 0 0 x 1 0 F F T of Cutt ing F o r c e s in y Direct ion ( M a l D A Q ) z 1 0 3 c o T 0 2 5 1 0 0 2 0 0 3 0 0 4 0 0 5 0 0 F r e q u e n c y [Hz] Figure 5.3 : Simulated displacements for a stable circular milling operation cutting (n=1500 [rpm] and b=6 [mm], See Table 5.3 ) conditions Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 5 0.5 x 0 0.3 0.4 0.5 Time [sec] 1 0 .5 -0 .5 ! — 0.3 0.4 0.5 Time [sec] x l 08 F F T of Displacement in y Direction (TFEA) 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1 .5 1 0 4 0 1 2 6 0 1 5 0 0 2 0 0 0 2 5 0 0 300C Frequency [Hz] F F T of Cutting Forces in y Direction (MalDAQ) 5 x l O XL c ° n y _ 1 JLLJ 4 8 0 7 4 0 1 0 0 0 1 2 2 0 1 5 0 0 2 0 0 0 Frequency [Hz] Figure 5.4 : Simulated displacements for a stable circular milling operation cutting conditions ( n-7200 [rpm] and b=l 1 [mm], See Table 5.3 ) Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 75 In order to simplify the solution and shorten the simulation time & required memory for time finite element analysis, only one mode is taken into account from each direction. The 4 t h mode of x direction and the 1 s t mode of y direction are considered as they are the most flexible modes in these directions. The time finite element simulation results for stable ( test 1 ) and unstable (test 14 ) cutting and FFT's are given as an example in Figure 5.3 and Figure 5.4. The chatter frequency for the unstable cutting condition obtained from time finite element analysis is coc = 1260 [Hz] as shown in Figure 5.4. The chatter frequency in the experimental result for the same cutting condition is coc = 1220 [Hz]. Since the time length of the elements are different for each tooth passing period, the data are resampled in order to take FFT. The differ-ence between the chatter frequencies is coming from the resampling of the data obtained from the displacement simulation. Stability Lobes 0 10 15 20 30 3537.542 46 52 58.5 66 7275 80 90 2 Spindle Speed [rpm] x 10 Figure 5.5 : Comparison of experimental and theoretical results The experimental and simulation results are compared in Figure 5.5. The continuous curve, the stability curve is predicted in frequency domain by averaging time varying directional factors. Chapter 5. Dynamics of Circular Milling Operation 76 Although the directional factors vary both in tooth and circular feed periods, their average leads to linear frequency domain solution which is computationally efficient and practical. However the frequency domain solution does not lead to accurate prediction of stability pockets and can be considered only for speed independent or low axial depth of cut region around 8 [mm]. The time finite element simulation considers the time varying directional factors but does not show any improvement over frequency domain solution either. Although it is computationally several orders of magnitude more costly. Chapter 6 Conclusion 6.1. Conclusion Mechanics and chatter stability of circular milling operations are studied in the thesis. First, the mechanics of circular milling is developed by modelling the kinematics of cutter motion and intersection with the workpiece. The dynamically changing cutter engagement condi-tions are mathematically modelled as a function of cutter radius, orbital radius of the tool path, spindle speed, step-over feed of the path, and feed rate. Since the immersions, the cutter engage-ment conditions, change continuously during circular milling, chip thickness and cutting forces vary with cutter position and time. The operation is simulated at discrete time intervals and the immersions, chip thickness and the cutting forces are predicted for chatter vibration free cutting conditions. The chip load and the static cutting forces are calculated and compared well against experimental results. The circular milling has double periodicity with two time delays and time varying directional factors. The stability problem belongs to delayed differential equations with time varying param-eters. First, the stability of milling with single delays is investigated by investigating the applica-bility of direct stability method proposed by Olgac and Sipahi [31] for time invariant, delayed differential equations. In direct method, the equation of motion for the milling system is defined in state space, and the time delay term is replaced by a bilinear expression [29] which is valid when the system is critically stable. Routh-Hurwitz array is formed by using the coefficients of the characteristic equation, which leads to the stability check of the system for each trial cutting speed and depth of cut. It is shown that Direct Method leads to the same solution with Frequency Domain stability law proposed by Altintas and Budak [11, 12], but with higher computational cost. Direct method still uses the frequency domain mathematical model of the process where time varying, periodic directional factors are assumed to be constant by averaging them. It is not possible to extend the direct method to the case where parameters are time variant, which is the 77 Chapter 6. Conclusion 78 fundamental issue in circular milling. Hence, the stability of the circular milling is studied in fre-quency domain by extending the method proposed by Altintas and Budak [11, 12], as well as time domain method presented by Bayly et al. [7, 8]. The dynamics of the circular milling is modelled in time domain by considering the structural vibrations in two orthogonal directions. The dynamic model consists of two coupled differential equations with time varying parameters which are periodic at the tooth passing frequency as well as circular path frequency. Typically, the circular path frequency is at least an order of magnitude less than the tooth passing frequency. The cutting forces which excite the structure have a delay term which is equal to the tooth period. The stability is studied in frequency domain by linearizing the process as follows. The time variation of directional factors are opened to Fourier Series by considering the double periodicity. The circular path frequency is assumed to be a known integer ratio of the tooth passing frequency. By taking the average of the directional factors at tooth and circular path periods, the equation of motion became time invariant and linear. Also, the time var-iation of the immersion is neglected by considering the worst immersion which becomes highest at the center of the path. The stability of the process is solved by extending the chatter law pre-sented by Budak and Altintas [11, 12]. The stability lobes obtained from the frequency domain solution did not lead to perfect agreement with experimental results due to approximations made to linearize the system dynamics. In order to include the time varying dynamics of the process, the stability is solved numeri-cally in time domain. The time finite element analysis presented by Bayly et al. [7, 8] is applied to circular milling. The time in cut is divided into multiple finite elements, and displacements on each element are defined in terms of shape functions and boundary conditions. The system becomes a linear discrete map and the stability is tested by checking the magnitudes of the eigen-values. Dynamic displacements are simulated and used to determine the stability. Only the most flexible modes in x and y directions are chosen in order to reduce the running time and complex-ity of the MATLAB program. The displacement simulations are compared against the experimen-tal results and they are not in good consistency because of the assumptions made to simplify the solution. As the time finite element method is a linear analysis, the method neglects the saturation of the process such as tool jumping out of cut. By taking the difference between the displacements Chapter 6. Conclusion 79 of successive passes and checking whether the tool is in cut, saturation of the process may be implemented to time finite element analysis. After determining the elements where the tool jumps out of cut, free vibration equations are substituted into the equation of motion matrix of circular milling and the simulation is repeated for new conditions. Both frequency domain solution and time finite element method give reasonable results at low axial depth of cut b values but time finite element method is more time inefficient. Time finite element leads to exact numerical solution but the matrix sizes become unmanageable if more than one structural mode is considered in each direction. The prediction may improve all active modes are considered. However even a simulation of a single mode in each direction takes about twenty five minutes on Pentium IV CPU with 1.50 GHz clock frequency. Hence the required computational cost and matrix sizes do not make time finite element approach feasible in stability lobes. Therefore the circular milling dynamics can be analyzed by the proposed fre-quency domain solution or computationally efficient, more accurate and new stability laws must be studied. 6.2. Future Research Directions The mechanics of circular milling requires further research by considering the helical plunge motion of the cutter, which makes the process three dimensional. Only a two dimensional case is studied in this thesis. The helical-circular milling is used as an alternative to boring and straight plunge milling operations. The chatter stability of the circular milling requires further investigation where the double periodicity and time varying directional factors can be more accurately considered. The study belongs to solution of delayed differential equations with time varying parameters, which is still an unsolved problem in the literature. Instead of linearizing the process, time domain simulation of the circular milling may need to be developed to verify the feasibility of various, approximate analytical solutions. Bibliography [1] Airey, J., Oxford, C. J., 1921, \"On the Art of Milling\", Transactions of ASME, Vol. 43, pp. 549. [2] Altintas, Y., Spence, A., \"End Milling Force Algorithms For Cad Systems\", Annals of CIRP, Vol. 50(1), pp. 169-175. [3] Altintas, Y., 2000, \"Manufacturing Automation - Metal Cutting Mechanics, Machine Tool Vibrations, and CNC Design\", Cambridge University Press. [4] Altintas, Y., 2001, \"Analytical Prediction of Three Dimensional Chatter Stability in Mill-ing\", Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers, International Journal Series C: Mechanical Systems, Machine Elements and Manufacturing, Vol. 44(3), pp. 717-723. [5] Altintas, Y., Week, M. , 2004, \"Chatter Stability of Metal Cutting and Grinding\", CIRP Annals, Vol. 53/2, pp. 619-642. [6] Armarego, E. J. A., Epp, C. J., 1970, \"An Investigation of Zero Helix Peripheral Up-Mill-ing\", International Journal of Machine Tool Design and Research, Vol. 10, pp. 273-291. [7] Bayly, P. V., Halley, J. E., Mann, B. P., Davies, M . A., \"Stability of Interrupted Cutting by Temporal Finite Element Analysis\", Transactions of the ASME, Vol. 125, pp. 220-225. [8] Bayly, P. V., Schmitz, T. L., Gabor, S., Mann, B. P., Peters, D. A., Insperger, T., \"Effects of Radial Immersion and Cutting Direction on Chatter Instability in End-Milling\", Pro-ceedings of the International Mechanical Engineering Conference and Exposition (IMECE 2002 ), New Orleans, LA. [9] Boston, O. W., Kraus, C. E., 1932, \"Elements of Milling\", Transactions of ASME, Vol. 54, pp. 74-104. 80 Bibliography 81 [10] Boston, O. W,, Kraus, C. E., 1932, \"Elements of Milling-Part II\", Transactions of ASME, Vol. 56, pp. 355-371. [11] Budak, E., 1994, \"Mechanics and Dynamics of Milling Thin Walled Structures\", Ph.D. Thesis, University of British Columbia. [12] Budak, E., Altintas, Y., 1995, \"Analytical Prediction of Stability Lobes in Milling\", CIRP Annals, Vol. 44, No.l , pp. 357-362. [13] Budak, E., Altintas, Y., Armarego E. J. A., 1996, \"Prediction of Milling Force Coefficients from Orthogonal Cutting Data\", Transactions of ASME, Vol. 118, pp. 216-224. [14] Campomanes, M . L., \"Dynamics of Milling Flexible Structures\", Master's Thesis, Univer-sity of British Columbia. [15] Faassen, R. P. PL, Van de Wouw, N. , Oosterling, J. A. J., Nijmeijer, EL, 2003, \"Prediction of Regenerative Chatter by Modelling and Analysis of High Speed Milling\", Int. J. Machine Tools and Manufac. [16] Hou, L. J., Peters, D. A., 1994, \"Application of Triangular Space-time Finite Elements to Problems of Wave Propagation\", Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 173, No. 5,pp. 611-632. [17] Kline, W. A., DeVor, R. E., Zdeblick, W. J., 1980, \"A Mechanistic Model for the Force System in End Milling with Application to Machining Airframe Structures\", In North American Manufacturing Research Conference Proceedings Society of Manufacturing Engineers, Vol. 18, pp. 297, Dearborn, MI. [18] Koenigsberger, F., Tlusty, J., 1967, \"Machine Tool Structures-Vol I: Stability Against Chatter\", Pergamon Press. [19] Kolmanovskii, V. B., Niculescu, S., \"On the Liapunov-Karasovskii Functionals for Stabil-ity Analysis of Linear Delay Systems\", Int. J. Control, 72(4), 374-384. Bibliography 82 [20] Kuo, C. B., 1987, \"Automatic Control Systems\", Prentice-Hall. [21] Lee, P., 1995, \"Mechanics and Dynamics of Ball End Milling\", Master's Thesis, Univer-sity of British Columbia. [22] Martellotti, M . E., 1941, \"An Analysis of the Milling Process\", Transactions of ASME, pp. 677-700. [23] Martellotti, M . E., 1945, \"An Analysis of the Milling Process Part II: Down Milling\", Transactions of ASME, Vol. 67, pp. 233-251 [24] Merritt, H. E., 1965, \"Theory of Self-Excited Machine Tool Chatter\", ASME Journal of Engineering for Industry, Vol. 87, pp. 447-454. [25] Minis, I., Yanushevsky, T., 1993, \"A New Theoretical Approach for the Prediction of Machine Tool Chatter in Milling\", ASME Journal of Engineering for Industry, Vol. 115, pp. 1-8. [26] Montgomery, D., Altintas, Y., 1991, \"Mechanism of Cutting Force and Surface Generation in Dynamic Milling\", Transactions of ASME Journal of Engineering for Industry, Vol. 113, pp. 160-168. [27] Opitz, H., 1969, \"Investigation and Calculation of the Chatter Behavior of: Lathes and Milling Machines\", Annals of CIRP, Vol. 18, pp. 335-342. [28] Parsons, F., 1923, \"Power Required for Cutting Metal\", Transactions of ASME, Vol. 49, pp.193-227. [29] Rekasius, Z. V., 1980, \"A Stability Test for Systems with Delays\", in Proc. Joint Auto-matic Control Conference, Paper No. TP9-A. [30] Sawin, N . N. , \"Theory of Milling Cutters\", Mechanical Engineering, Vol. 48, pp. 1203-1209. Bibliography 83 [31] Sipahi, R., 2000, \"A Unique Treatment of Time Delay System Stability: The Direct Method\", Master's Thesis, University of Connecticut. [32] Sutherland, J. W., DeVor, R. E., 1986, \"An Improved Method for Cutting Force and Sur-face Prediction in Flexible End Milling System\", Transactions of ASME Journal of Engi-neering for Industry, Vol. 108, pp. 269-279. [33] Tlusty, J., Polacek, M , 1957, \"Besipiele der behandlung der selbsterregten Schwingung der Werkzeugmaschinen\", FoKoMa, Hanser Verlag, Munchen. [34] Tlusty, J., 1965, \"A Method of Analysis of Machine Tool Stability\", Proceeding MTDR, pp. 5-14. [35] Tlusty, J., McNeil, P., 1970, \"Dynamics of Cutting Forces in End Milling\", Annals of the CIRP,Vol. 24, pp. 21-25. [36] Tlusty, J., Ismail, F., 1981, \"Basic Nonlinearity in Machining Chatter\", Annals of the CIRP, Vol. 30, pp. 21-25. [37] Tlusty, J., \"Personal Communications, September 1999-May 2000\", Machine Tool Research Center, University of Florida, Gainesville. [38] Tlusty, J., 2000, \"Manufacturing Processes and Equipment\", Prentice Hall. [39] Tobias, S. A., 1965, \"Machine Tool Vibration\", Blackie and Sons Ltd. [40] Tobias, S. A., Fiswick, W., 1958, \"Theory of Regenerative Machine Tool Chatter\", Engi-neering, London, Vol. 258. [41] Week, M. , Staimer, D., 2002, \"Parallel Kinematic Machine Tools - Curent State and Future Potentials\", CIRP Annals, Vol. 2, pp. 671-683. "@en ;
edm:hasType "Thesis/Dissertation"@en ;
vivo:dateIssued "2005-05"@en ;
edm:isShownAt "10.14288/1.0080692"@en ;
dcterms:language "eng"@en ;
ns0:degreeDiscipline "Mechanical Engineering"@en ;
edm:provider "Vancouver : University of British Columbia Library"@en ;
dcterms:rights "For non-commercial purposes only, such as research, private study and education. Additional conditions apply, see Terms of Use https://open.library.ubc.ca/terms_of_use."@en ;
ns0:scholarLevel "Graduate"@en ;
dcterms:title "Mechanics and dynamics of circular milling operations"@en ;
dcterms:type "Text"@en ;
ns0:identifierURI "http://hdl.handle.net/2429/16538"@en .
*