Medicine, Faculty of
Population and Public Health (SPPH), School of
DSpace
UBCV
Chaudhry, Rabia Mushtaq
Master of Science - MSc
University of British Columbia
Introduction: This research explores the impact of Medical Student and Resident Doctors' (MSaRD) organizations on the health policy process in Pakistan, focusing on their adaptability and advocacy in a politically constrained environment. It explores how these entities have navigated the ban on student politics and leveraged digital platforms to influence health policy, highlighting their evolution from traditional activism to digital engagement. Methods: Adopting a mixed-methods approach, the study combines qualitative content analysis with natural language processing of diverse data types collected from social media. Qualitative content analysis was used for an interpretative examination of the content to identify underlying themes and patterns, while NLP, a computational technique, was applied to systematically process and analyze the entire volumes of textual data for patterns and trends to validate the qualitative analysis. The investigation covered two primary research questions: the organizational landscape of MSaRD in Pakistan and their framing of their opposition to the National Licensing Examination (NLE). Data collection encompassed social media posts, policy documents, media interviews, news articles, images and videos in Urdu and English. Results: Findings reveal a dynamic advocacy landscape where MSaRD organizations actively contribute to health policy discourse. Despite legal restrictions, these organizations utilize digital media to mobilize, advocate, and influence health reforms. Their strategic framing of the NLE, demonstrates their significant role in shaping public and policy discourse, reflecting their growing influence in Pakistan's health sector. Conclusion: MSaRD organizations in Pakistan have emerged as pivotal players in the health policy arena, attempting to bridge the gap between medical professionals and policy formulation. Their transition to digital advocacy platforms signifies a broader shift in health policy advocacy, underscoring the importance of recognizing and integrating these groups into the formal health policy process. The study advocates for a reevaluation of political engagement policies in healthcare, suggesting that MSaRD's contributions could lead to more inclusive and representative health policy outcomes.
ROLE OF MEDICAL STUDENT AND RESIDENT DOCTORS'REPRESENTATIVE ORGANIZATIONS IN HEALTH POLICY PROCESSIN PAKISTANb\RabLa MXVKWaT CKaXdKU\M-PKLO., TKe UQLYeUVLW\ RI LaKRUe, 2021A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OFTHE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OFMASTER OF SCIENCELQTHE FACULTY OF GRADUATE AND POSTDOCTORAL STUDIES(PRSXOaWLRQ aQd PXbOLc HeaOWK)THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA(VaQcRXYeU)ASULO 2024 RabLa MXVKWaT CKaXdKU\, 2024May TKe IROORZLQJ LQdLYLdXaOV ceUWLI\ WKaW WKe\ KaYe Uead, aQd UecRPPeQd WR WKe FacXOW\ RI GUadXaWeaQd PRVWdRcWRUaO SWXdLeV IRU acceSWaQce, WKe WKeVLV eQWLWOed:____________________________________________________________________________VXbPLWWed b\ _________________________ LQ SaUWLaO IXOILOOPeQW RI WKe UeTXLUePeQWV IRUWKe deJUee RI ________________________________________________________________LQ ________________________________________________________________E[amining CommiWWee:____________________________________________________________________________SXSeUYLVRU____________________________________________________________________________SXSeUYLVRU\ CRPPLWWee MePbeU____________________________________________________________________________SXSeUYLVRU\ CRPPLWWee MePbeU____________________________________________________________________________SXSeUYLVRU\ CRPPLWWee MePbeU____________________________________________________________________________AddLWLRQaO E[aPLQeULLRabia Mushtaq ChaudhryRole Of Medical Student And Resident Doctors' Representative Organizations In Health Policy Process In PakistanMaster of SciencePopulation and Public HealthVeena Sriram, Assitant Professor, School of Population and Pubic Health, UBCSorcha Brophy, Assitant Professor, Mailman School of Pubic Health, Columbia UniversityRyan Essex, Research Fellow, School of Health Sciences, University of GreenwichJerry Spiel, Professor, School of Population and Pubic Health, UBCSusan Cox, Professor, School of Population and Pubic Health, UBCrr i gel, Professor, Scho l of Population and Public Health, UBCAbsWracWInWrodXcWion: TKLV UeVeaUcK e[SORUeV WKe LPSacW RI MedLcaO SWXdeQW aQd ReVLdeQW DRcWRUV'(MSaRD) RUJaQL]aWLRQV RQ WKe KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVV LQ PaNLVWaQ, IRcXVLQJ RQ WKeLU adaSWabLOLW\aQd adYRcac\ LQ a SROLWLcaOO\ cRQVWUaLQed eQYLURQPeQW. IW e[SORUeV KRZ WKeVe eQWLWLeV KaYeQaYLJaWed WKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aQd OeYeUaJed dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV WR LQIOXeQce KeaOWK SROLc\,KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKeLU eYROXWLRQ IURP WUadLWLRQaO acWLYLVP WR dLJLWaO eQJaJePeQW.MeWhods: AdRSWLQJ a PL[ed-PeWKRdV aSSURacK, WKe VWXd\ cRPbLQeV TXaOLWaWLYe cRQWeQW aQaO\VLVZLWK QaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ RI dLYeUVe daWa W\SeV cROOecWed IURP VRcLaO PedLa. QXaOLWaWLYecRQWeQW aQaO\VLV ZaV XVed IRU aQ LQWeUSUeWaWLYe e[aPLQaWLRQ RI WKe cRQWeQW WR LdeQWLI\ XQdeUO\LQJWKePeV aQd SaWWeUQV, ZKLOe NLP, a cRPSXWaWLRQaO WecKQLTXe, ZaV aSSOLed WR V\VWePaWLcaOO\SURceVV aQd aQaO\]e WKe eQWLUe YROXPeV RI We[WXaO daWa IRU SaWWeUQV aQd WUeQdV WR YaOLdaWe WKeTXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV. TKe LQYeVWLJaWLRQ cRYeUed WZR SULPaU\ UeVeaUcK TXeVWLRQV: WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQaO OaQdVcaSe RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ aQd WKeLU IUaPLQJ RI WKeLU RSSRVLWLRQ WR WKeNaWLRQaO LLceQVLQJ E[aPLQaWLRQ (NLE). DaWa cROOecWLRQ eQcRPSaVVed VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV, SROLc\dRcXPeQWV, PedLa LQWeUYLeZV, QeZV aUWLcOeV, LPaJeV aQd YLdeRV LQ UUdX aQd EQJOLVK.ResXlWs: FLQdLQJV UeYeaO a d\QaPLc adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe ZKeUe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV acWLYeO\cRQWULbXWe WR KeaOWK SROLc\ dLVcRXUVe. DeVSLWe OeJaO UeVWULcWLRQV, WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV XWLOL]e dLJLWaOPedLa WR PRbLOL]e, adYRcaWe, aQd LQIOXeQce KeaOWK UeIRUPV. TKeLU VWUaWeJLc IUaPLQJ RI WKe NLE,dePRQVWUaWeV WKeLU VLJQLILcaQW UROe LQ VKaSLQJ SXbOLc aQd SROLc\ dLVcRXUVe, UeIOecWLQJ WKeLUJURZLQJ LQIOXeQce LQ PaNLVWaQ'V KeaOWK VecWRU.LLLConclXsion: MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ KaYe ePeUJed aV SLYRWaO SOa\eUV LQ WKe KeaOWKSROLc\ aUeQa, aWWePSWLQJ WR bULdJe WKe JaS beWZeeQ PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV aQd SROLc\ IRUPXOaWLRQ.TKeLU WUaQVLWLRQ WR dLJLWaO adYRcac\ SOaWIRUPV VLJQLILeV a bURadeU VKLIW LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ adYRcac\,XQdeUVcRULQJ WKe LPSRUWaQce RI UecRJQL]LQJ aQd LQWeJUaWLQJ WKeVe JURXSV LQWR WKe IRUPaO KeaOWKSROLc\ SURceVV. TKe VWXd\ adYRcaWeV IRU a UeeYaOXaWLRQ RI SROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQW SROLcLeV LQKeaOWKcaUe, VXJJeVWLQJ WKaW MSaRD'V cRQWULbXWLRQV cRXOd Oead WR PRUe LQcOXVLYe aQdUeSUeVeQWaWLYe KeaOWK SROLc\ RXWcRPeV.LYLa\ SXmmar\TKLV VWXd\ e[aPLQeV WKe UROe RI PedLcaO VWXdeQW aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRU JURXSV LQ LQIOXeQcLQJ KeaOWKSROLc\ LQ PaNLVWaQ. DeVSLWe UeVWULcWLRQV RQ SROLWLcaO acWLYLWLeV, WKeVe JURXSV KaYe becRPe Ne\SOa\eUV LQ WKe KeaOWK VecWRU. UVLQJ VRcLaO PedLa daWa, WKe UeVeaUcK e[SORUed KRZ WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV RSeUaWe aQd cRPPXQLcaWe SeUceLYe WKeLU SOace aQd adYRcac\ SURceVV LQ WKeKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP RI PaNLVWaQ. TKe ILQdLQJV VKRZ WKaW WKeVe JURXSV aUe acWLYeO\ LQYROYed LQVKaSLQJ KeaOWK SROLcLeV WKURXJK RQOLQe SOaWIRUPV, eIIecWLYeO\ YRLcLQJ cRQceUQV aQd SXVKLQJ IRUUeIRUPV. TKe VWXd\ KLJKOLJKWV WKe JURZLQJ LPSRUWaQce RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ WKe KeaOWK SROLc\dRPaLQ, VXJJeVWLQJ WKaW WKeLU eIIRUWV caQ Oead WR PRUe LQcOXVLYe aQd eIIecWLYe KeaOWK caUe SROLcLeV.IQ VLPSOe WeUPV, WKLV VWXd\ UeYeaOV WKaW PedLcaO VWXdeQW aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRU JURXSV LQ PaNLVWaQ aUeQRW MXVW SaUWLcLSaQWV bXW cUXcLaO LQIOXeQceUV LQ KeaOWK SROLc\, adeSWO\ XVLQJ VRcLaO PedLa WRcKaOOeQJe aQd UeVKaSe WKe KeaOWK SROLc\ dLVcRXUVe.YPrefaceWLWK dLUecWLRQ IURP P\ VXSeUYLVLQJ cRPPLWWee (DU. VeeQa SULUaP, DU. JeUU\ SSLeJeO, DU. SRUcKaBURSK\ aQd DU. R\aQ EVVe[), I cRQceLYed, cRQdXcWed, aQd ZURWe WKLV MaVWeU RI ScLeQce WKeVLV.EWKLcV aSSURYaO IRU WKLV VWXd\ ZaV VecXUed IURP WKe BeKaYLRXUaO ReVeaUcK EWKLcV BRaUd(BREB) CeUWLILcaWe ID #H21-02379.YLTable of ConWenWsAbsWracW ........................................................................................................................................iiiLa\ SXmmar\.................................................................................................................................YPreface ...........................................................................................................................................YiTable of ConWenWs.........................................................................................................................YiiLisW of Tables..................................................................................................................................[LisW of FigXres...............................................................................................................................[iLisW of AbbreYiaWions.................................................................................................................. [iiChapWer 1: InWrodXcWion................................................................................................................ 11.1 OYeUYLeZ..............................................................................................................................11.2 BacNJURXQd.........................................................................................................................31.2.1 GRYeUQaQce RI KeaOWKcaUe LQ PaNLVWaQ.........................................................................31.2.2 SWXdeQW SROLWLcV aQd LWV LQIOXeQce RQ SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQ PaNLVWaQ: A KLVWRULcaOaccRXQW................................................................................................................................. 61.2.3 RROe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQ PaNLVWaQ LQ WKe SaVW................ 91.2.4 TKe cXUUeQW adYRcac\ VceQaULR RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ......................101.3 LLWeUaWXUe UeYLeZ................................................................................................................121.3.1 DeILQLQJ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV...........................................................................................121.3.2 SWXdeQW UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ YV VWXdeQW acWLYLVP............................................................... 121.3.3 RROe RI MSaRD LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQ HLJK-IQcRPe CRXQWULeV.............161.3.4 RROe RI MSaRD LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQ SRXWK AVLa................................19YLL1.4 GaSV LQ WKe OLWeUaWXUe..........................................................................................................221.5 RaWLRQaOe............................................................................................................................ 231.6 ReVeaUcK aLP......................................................................................................................241.7 ReVeaUcK TXeVWLRQV.............................................................................................................251.8 SWXd\ RbMecWLYeV.................................................................................................................26ChapWer 2: MeWhodolog\..............................................................................................................272.1 ReVeaUcK deVLJQ aQd PeWKRdRORJLcaO aSSURacK................................................................. 272.2 PRVLWLRQaOLW\ VWaWePeQW.......................................................................................................272.3 DaWa cROOecWLRQ................................................................................................................... 292.3.1 RQ.1: LaQdVcaSe RI RUJaQL]aWLRQV UeSUeVeQWLQJ MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ...................... 292.3.2 RQ.2: IVVXe IUaPLQJ b\ WKe Ne\ VWaNeKROdeUV (MSaRD)...........................................322.4 DaWa PaQaJePeQW aQd eWKLcaO cRQVLdeUaWLRQV.................................................................... 332.5 DaWa aQaO\VLV...................................................................................................................... 352.5.1 RQ.1: LaQdVcaSe RI RUJaQL]aWLRQV UeSUeVeQWLQJ MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ...................... 372.5.1.1 QXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV..........................................................................................372.5.1.2 NaWXUaO LaQJXaJe PURceVVLQJ (NLP)............................................................... 392.5.2 RQ2: IVVXe IUaPLQJ b\ WKe Ne\ VWaNeKROdeUV (MSaRD)............................................41ChapWer 3: ResXlWs - Landscape of organi]aWions represenWing MSaRD in PakisWan...........433.1 OYeUYLeZ RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV.............................................................................433.2 FUaPeZRUN WR VWXd\ WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV.................................................................453.3 SWUXcWXUe RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV.............................................................................. 46YLLL3.3.1 LeadeUVKLS VWUXcWXUe RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV...................................................473.3.2 WLQJV RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV......................................................................... 483.3.3 EOecWRUaO SURceVV RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV........................................................ 483.4 FXQcWLRQLQJ RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV......................................................................... 503.4.1 GRYeUQaQce RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV................................................................ 503.4.1.1 ALP aQd RbMecWLYeV RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV............................................513.4.1.2 OUJaQL]aWLRQaO UXOeV aQd SULQcLSOeV................................................................. 523.4.1.3 IQWeUQaO d\QaPLcV RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV..............................................543.4.1.4 E[WeUQaO d\QaPLcV - E[SaQVLRQ aPLdVW e[WeUQaO SURSaJaQda.......................... 563.4.2 CRPPXQLcaWLRQ ZLWK WKe LQWeUQaO VWaNeKROdeUV.........................................................583.4.3 RROe aQd VeUYLceV b\ WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV.......................................................593.5 IVVXeV WKaW MSaRD adYRcaWe IRU........................................................................................603.5.1 EdXcaWLRQaO............................................................................................................... 613.5.1.1 MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe AdPLVVLRQ TeVWV (MDCAT)............................... 623.5.1.2 UQdeUJUadXaWe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ....................................................................643.5.1.3 PRVW GUadXaWe (PG) PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ............................................................ 663.5.2 AdPLQLVWUaWLYe..........................................................................................................673.5.2.1 LacN RI UXOe RI OaZ...........................................................................................673.5.2.2 CRUUXSWLRQ........................................................................................................683.5.2.3 PRRU JRYeUQaQce...............................................................................................693.5.3 HeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV................................................................................................... 70YLLLix3.5.3.1 EPSOR\PeQW aQd SURPRWLRQV...........................................................................703.5.3.2 WRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV..........................................................................................723.5.4 HeaOWKcaUe UeVRXUceV................................................................................................. 763.5.5 SRcLaO aZaUeQeVV aQd VRcLaO MXVWLce...........................................................................773.5.6 OYeUaOO cRPSaULVRQ..................................................................................................783.6 TKe AdYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV........................................................... 843.6.1 CRaOLWLRQ....................................................................................................................853.6.2 NRQ-dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV.......................................................................................... 873.6.3 DLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV..................................................................................................883.6.4 OYeUaOO cRPSaULVRQ RI VWUaWeJLeV ePSOR\ed b\ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV.................... 903.6.5 SXPPaUL]LQJ WKe bURadeU SLcWXUe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV.....................................95ChapWer 4: ResXlWs - IssXe framing b\ Whe ke\ sWakeholders (MSaRD).................................. 974.1 FUaPLQJ RI WKe LVVXe b\ MSaRD........................................................................................974.1.1 CRQIXVLRQ RYeU GRYeUQPeQW'V decLVLRQV...................................................................984.1.2 DLVaSSRLQWPeQW aQd IUXVWUaWLRQ...............................................................................1004.1.3 FLQaQcLaO LQVWabLOLW\ aV KeaOWKcaUe SURIeVVLRQaOV.....................................................1014.1.4 EPLJUaWLRQ...............................................................................................................1024.1.5 LacN RI WUXVW LQ NLE............................................................................................... 1034.1.6 NLE, a VXSeUILcLaO VROXWLRQ WR V\VWePLc LVVXeV........................................................1044.1.7 NLE, a PeaVXUe RI cRPSeWeQc\.............................................................................. 1064.1.8 LacN RI WUXVW LQ PMC..............................................................................................106YLLLx4.2 FUaPLQJ RI dePaQdV b\ MSaRD..................................................................................... 1084.2.1 DePaQd IRU caQceOOaWLRQ aV a VWaQd aJaLQVW VWUXcWXUaO cKaOOeQJeV.......................... 1094.2.2 AdYRcac\ IRU SURVSecWLYe aSSOLcaWLRQ aQd IaLUQeVV LQ SROLc\ cKaQJeV................... 1104.2.3 CaOO IRU IaLU SUeSaUaWLRQ aQd cRQVLdeUaWe LPSOePeQWaWLRQ...................................... 1104.2.4 DePaQd IRU eWKLcaO OeadeUVKLS aQd WUaQVSaUeQW JRYeUQaQce....................................1114.3 FUaPLQJ RI adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV b\ MSaRD................................................................... 1124.4 FUaPLQJ RI WKe GRYeUQPeQW'V UeVSRQVe WR MSaRD adYRcac\........................................ 1154.4.1 CRPSOe[ eQJaJePeQW aPLdVW adYRcac\ aQd dLVVeQW............................................... 1164.4.2 SWaWe YLROeQce aJaLQVW SeaceIXO adYRcac\............................................................... 1174.4.3 DeILaQce aJaLQVW aXWKRULWaULaQ LPSRVLWLRQ.............................................................. 118ChapWer 5: DiscXssion...............................................................................................................1205.1 NaYLJaWLQJ YXOQeUabLOLW\, PaUJLQaOL]aWLRQ aQd aJeQc\ - TKe cRPSOe[ SRVLWLRQ RI MSaRDLQ PaNLVWaQ'V KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP.............................................................................................. 1205.2 AdaSWLQJ WR cKaQJe - TKe eYROYLQJ adYRcac\ RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWV LQ PaNLVWaQ...............1235.3 TKe LQdLVSeQVabOe adYRcaWeV - TKe VWUaWeJLc UeVLVWaQce aQd adYRcac\ RI MSaRD LQPaNLVWaQ'V cXUUeQW eQYLURQPeQW.............................................................................................. 1255.4 TKe aPSOLILed YRLceV - TKe LQIOXeQce RI MSaRD'V dLJLWaO adYRcac\ RQ KeaOWK SROLc\ LQPaNLVWaQ..................................................................................................................................1285.5 MSaRD¶V adYRcac\ LQ PaNLVWaQ WKURXJK DeOOa PRUWa'V OeQV.............................................1305.6 SWaWe'V aSSURacK WR SURIeVVLRQaO SURWeVW - XQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKe d\QaPLcV...........................1315.7 ReLQVWaWLQJ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ SaNLVWaQ - PUeSRVLWLRQ IRU a SaWK WRYLLLxiePSRZeUPeQW aQd UeIRUP LQ KeaOWKcaUe aQd edXcaWLRQ......................................................... 1345.8 SWUeQJWKV aQd OLPLWaWLRQV..................................................................................................1365.9 PROLc\ LPSOLcaWLRQV aQd caOO WR acWLRQ.............................................................................. 1395.10 RecRPPeQdaWLRQV IRU IXWXUe UeVeaUcK........................................................................... 1415.11 CRQcOXVLRQ..................................................................................................................... 142Bibliograph\............................................................................................................................... 145Appendices..................................................................................................................................163ASSeQdL[ A - LLVW RI SRcLaO MedLa PRVWV b\ MSaRDV RQ RQ.1: SWUXcWXUe, FXQcWLRQ,AdYRcac\ IVVXeV aQd AdYRcac\ SWUaWeJLeV............................................................................163ASSeQdL[ B - LLVW RI SRcLaO MedLa PRVWV b\ MSaRDV RQ RQ.2: FUaPLQJ RI NLE..............204ASSeQdL[ C - AQ E[aPSOe RI DeILQLQJ VecWRUV LQ NLP AQaO\VLV........................................ 207ASSeQdL[ D - TRS 100 WRUdV NLP AQaO\VLV........................................................................ 2081. BaU GUaSK RI TRS 100 WRUdV.......................................................................................2082. HeaWPaS UVLQJ WKe TRS 100 WRUdV AbRYe................................................................. 2093. ReILQed TRS 100 WRUdV UVLQJ NVLYR......................................................................... 2104. HeaWPaS UVLQJ WKe ReILQed TRS 100 WRUdV AbRYe....................................................211ASSeQdL[ E - Te[W RI RecUXLWPeQW EPaLO.............................................................................. 212ASSeQdL[ F - IQIRUPed VeUbaO CRQVeQW aQd PaUWLcLSaQW IQIRUPaWLRQ....................................213YLLLxiiLisW of TablesTabOe 1 - SRcLaO MedLa PaJeV RI WKe MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV IQcOXded LQ WKe SWXd\......................31TabOe 2 - LeadeUVKLS SWUXcWXUe RI MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV............................................................. 47TabOe 3 - HeaOWKcaUe ReVRXUceV IVVXeV HLJKOLJKWed b\ MSaRD....................................................76TabOe 4 - CRaOLWLRQ PaUWQeUV RI MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV..................................................................85TabOe 5 - NRQ-DLVUXSWLYe SWUaWeJLeV EPSOR\ed b\ MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV...................................87TabOe 6: TKe VaULRXV FUaPeV RI MSaRD RQ WKeLU AdYRcac\ PURceVV RQ NLE PROLc\............... 113[LLLLisW of FigXresFLJXUe 1 - GeRJUaSKLcaO PURPLQeQce RI MSaRD...........................................................................43FLJXUe 2 - TKe FUaPeZRUN RI TKePeV........................................................................................... 46FLJXUe 3 - TKePeV aQd SXb TKePeV RI FXQcWLRQ RI MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV................................. 52FLJXUe 4 - IQWeUacWLRQ RI TKePeV aQd SXbWKePeV RI IVVXeV MSaRD AdYRcaWe FRU...................... 62FLJXUe 5 - BaU GUaSK RI TRS 25 IVVXeV HLJKOLJKWed b\ MSaRD................................................... 79FLJXUe 6 - BaU GUaSK RI TRS 25 IVVXeV b\ EacK MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQ.........................................80FLJXUe 7 - HeaW MaS RI CRVLQe SLPLOaULW\ IQde[ BaVed RQ AdYRcac\ IVVXeV RI VaULRXV MSaRDOUJaQL]aWLRQV................................................................................................................................. 83FLJXUe 8 - TKe VaULRXV AdYRcac\ SWUaWeJLeV EPSOR\ed b\ MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV..................... 84FLJXUe 9 - CRPSaULVRQ RI DLVUXSWLYe SWUaWeJLeV EPSOR\ed b\ MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV................ 92FLJXUe 10 - HeaW MaS RI CRVLQe SLPLOaULW\ IQde[ BaVed RQ AdYRcac\ SWUaWeJLeV EPSOR\ed b\MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV................................................................................................................... 93FLJXUe 11 - TKe VaULRXV CRdeV UQdeU WKe TKUee MaLQ CaWeJRULeV RQ FUaPLQJ RI NLE LVVXe...... 98FLJXUe 12 - TKe VaULRXV FUaPeV RQ WKe DePaQdV RI MSaRD RQ WKe NLE PROLc\...................... 108FLJXUe 13 - TKe VaULRXV FUaPeV RI MSaRD RQ WKeLU AdYRcac\ OYeU WKe NLE PROLc\...............112FLJXUe 14 - FUaPeV RI MSaRD RI WKe GRYeUQPeQW'V ReVSRQVe...................................................116[LYLisW of AbbreYiaWionsAIMS AVVRcLaWLRQ RI IQWeUQeV aQd MedLcaO SWXdeQWVAMA APeULcaQ MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQBMA BULWLVK MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQCIR CRPPLWWee RI IQWeUQV aQd ReVLdeQWVDHQ DLVWULcW Head QXaUWeUDSF DePRcUaWLc SWXdeQW FedeUaWLRQDWM DRcWRUV ZaNe XS MRYePeQWETEA EdXcaWLRQ WeVWLQJ aQd eYaOXaWLRQ aXWKRULW\FORDA FedeUaWLRQ RI ReVLdeQW DRcWRUV¶ AVVRcLaWLRQIJT IVOaPL JaPLaW TaOebaJI JaPaW-L-IVOaPLKMU KK\abXU MedLcaO UQLYeUVLW\KPK KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZaLMICV LRZ aQd PLddOe-LQcRPe cRXQWULeVMCPS MePbeUVKLS RI CROOeJe RI PK\VLcLaQV aQd SXUJeRQV PaNLVWaQ[YMDCAT MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe AdPLVVLRQ TeVWVMS MedLcaO SXSeULQWeQdeQWMSaRD MedLcaO SWXdeQW aQd ReVLdeQW DRcWRUV'NHS NaWLRQaO HeaOWK S\VWePNLE NaWLRQaO LLceQVLQJ E[aPLQaWLRQNLP NaWXUaO LaQJXaJe PURceVVLQJNSF NaWLRQaO SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQOPD OXWSaWLeQW DeSaUWPeQWPDA PURYLQcLaO DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQPG PRVW GUadXaWePMC PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO CRPPLVVLRQPMDC PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CRXQcLOPMSUP PULYaWe MedLcaO SWXdeQWV UQLRQ PaNLVWaQPSF PURJUeVVLYe SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQPTI PaNLVWaQ TeKUeeN-e-IQVaaISPSC SLQdK PXbOLc SeUYLce CRPPLVVLRQ¶V[YLTHQ TeUWLaU\ HeadTXaUWeUUK UQLWed KLQJdRPUSA UQLWed SWaWeV RI APeULcaYDA YRXQJ DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ[YLxviiChapWer 1: InWrodXcWion1.1 OYerYieZIQ WKe LQWULcaWe WaSeVWU\ RI PaNLVWaQ'V KeaOWKcaUe OaQdVcaSe, WKe UROeV RI PedLcaO VWXdeQW aQdUeVLdeQW dRcWRUV' (MSaRD) UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV KaYe becRPe LQcUeaVLQJO\ SURQRXQced,SURYLdLQJ a IUeVK OeQV WKURXJK ZKLcK WR e[aPLQe WKe eYROYLQJ d\QaPLcV RI KeaOWK SROLc\SURceVVeV LQ WKaW cRQWe[W. TKLV VWXd\ VeeNV WR e[SORUe WKe UROe RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ WKeSROLc\PaNLQJ ecRV\VWeP, aJaLQVW WKe bacNdURS RI a bOaQNeW baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ.TKe adYeQW RI VRcLaO PedLa KaV SURSeOOed WKeVe JURXSV LQWR a SURPLQeQW SRVLWLRQ RI LQIOXeQcedeVSLWe UeJXOaWRU\ cRQVWUaLQWV, addLQJ QeZ dLPeQVLRQV aQd QXaQceV WR WKeLU adYRcac\ SURceVV.SRPe UeceQW SROLc\ debaWeV LQYROYLQJ MSaRD LQcOXde LVVXeV VXcK aV PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQdWUaLQLQJ, UePXQeUaWLRQ, ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV aQd KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV¶ VaIeW\, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKedLUecW LPSacW RI WKeVe UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV RQ KeaOWK SROLc\ decLVLRQV.1TKLV VWXd\ cRQWULbXWeV WR WKe XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe UROe RI MSaRD LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV,VKeddLQJ OLJKW RQ WKe cUXcLaO UROe WKe\ SOa\ LQ adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKe ULJKWV aQd LQWeUeVWV RI KeaOWKZRUNeUV. ReVLdeQW dRcWRUV RccXS\ a XQLTXe aQd cULWLcaO SRVLWLRQ LQ WKe PedLcaO KLeUaUcK\,bULdJLQJ WKe JaS beWZeeQ beLQJ VWXdeQWV aQd IXOO\ OLceQVed SK\VLcLaQV. TKe\ aUe UeVSRQVLbOe IRU aZLde UaQJe RI dXWLeV, LQcOXdLQJ aVVeVVLQJ SaWLeQWV' PedLcaO, SK\VLcaO, aQd SV\cKRVRcLaOcRQdLWLRQV, SeUIRUPLQJ e[aPLQaWLRQV, aQd deYeORSLQJ WUeaWPeQW SOaQV. TKe\ cRQdXcW URXQdV,dRcXPeQW SaWLeQW SURJUeVV, RUdeU WeVWV aQd WUeaWPeQWV, aQd PaQaJe SaWLeQW dLVcKaUJe aQdaIWeUcaUe.2 TKe\ aUe aOVR WaVNed ZLWK ZULWLQJ YaULRXV PedLcaO QRWeV, edXcaWLQJ aQd cRXQVeOLQJSaWLeQWV, cRQdXcWLQJ PedLcaO SURcedXUeV, aQd aVVLVWLQJ LQ VXUJeULeV.2 TKXV, WKLV OLPLQaO SKaVeLQYROYeV bRWK OeaUQLQJ aQd SUacWLcLQJ PedLcLQe, UeTXLULQJ WKeP WR MXJJOe WKe UeVSRQVLbLOLWLeV RI1SaWLeQW caUe ZLWK RQJRLQJ edXcaWLRQ. AV VXcK, WKe d\QaPLcV aQd SROLWLcV WKaW aSSO\ WR VWXdeQWV aUeQRW eQWLUeO\ ILWWLQJ IRU UeVLdeQWV, ZKR aUe JUadXaOO\ aVVXPLQJ PRUe UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ aQd aXWRQRP\LQ WKe PedLcaO ILeOd. IW LV LPSRUWaQW WR UecRJQL]e aQd UeVSecW WKe dLVWLQcW cKaOOeQJeV aQd UROeV WKaWUeVLdeQW dRcWRUV ePbRd\ dXULQJ WKLV WUaQVLWLRQaO SeULRd. TKXV, WKe LQVLJKWV JaLQed IURP VWXd\LQJbRWK WKe MSaRD aUe eVVeQWLaO IRU cRPSUeKeQdLQJ WKe PXOWLIaceWed QaWXUe RI KeaOWK ZRUNIRUceSROLc\, aV WKeVe UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV eQJaJe LQ adYRcac\ eIIRUWV WKaW e[WeQd be\RQd WKeLULPPedLaWe cRQceUQV WR eQcRPSaVV bURadeU aVSecWV RI KeaOWK UeIRUP. TKLV bURadeU SeUVSecWLYeaOLJQV ZLWK WKe JORbaO WUeQd ZKeUe UeSUeVeQWaWLYe KeaOWK ZRUNeU RUJaQL]aWLRQV, LQcOXdLQJ WKRVe LQORZ aQd PLddOe-LQcRPe cRXQWULeV (LMICV), KaYe LQcUeaVLQJO\ beeQ UecRJQL]ed aV LQIOXeQWLaOSROLc\ acWRUV.3 TKe VWXd\ addV QXaQce WR WKe eYROYLQJ OaQdVcaSe RI KeaOWK SROLc\ b\ e[aPLQLQJWKe XQLTXe cKaOOeQJeV Iaced b\ MSaRD UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ a UeJXOaWRU\ eQYLURQPeQWPaUNed b\ a baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, XQdeUVcRULQJ WKe VLJQLILcaQce RI WKeLU UROe ZLWKLQ WKe OaUJeUWaSeVWU\ RI KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV.TKe aLP RI WKLV VWXd\ LV WR XQdeUVWaQd WKe UROe RI WKe MSaRD LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQPaNLVWaQ. SSecLILcaOO\, WKe VWXd\ VeeNV WR PaS RXW WKe OaQdVcaSe RI e[LVWLQJ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQVLQ PaNLVWaQ, aQd XQdeUVWaQd WKeLU SROLc\ dePaQdV, adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV aQd RUJaQL]aWLRQaOd\QaPLcV. TKe VWXd\ aOVR VeeNV WR XQdeUVWaQd KRZ MSaRD IUaPe WKeLU adYRcac\ WKURXJK aQLQ-deSWK aQaO\VLV RI TZLWWeU/X daWa UeJaUdLQJ a UeceQW QaWLRQZLde SURWeVW b\ MSaRD LQRSSRVLWLRQ WR a SURSRVed OLceQVLQJ e[aPLQaWLRQ caOOed WKe NaWLRQaO LLceQVLQJ E[aP (NLE).21.2 BackgroXnd1.2.1 GoYernance of healWhcare in PakisWanPaNLVWaQ, OLNe RWKeU LMICV, deOLYeUV LWV KeaOWKcaUe WKURXJK a PL[ed KeaOWK V\VWeP, cRPbLQLQJbRWK SXbOLc aQd SULYaWe SURYLdeUV.4 TKe SXbOLc KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP cRPSULVeV a WKUee-WLeU V\VWeP RISULPaU\, VecRQdaU\, aQd WeUWLaU\ OeYeOV.5BeIRUe WKe 18WK APeQdPeQW WR WKe 1973 CRQVWLWXWLRQ RI PaNLVWaQ, ZKLcK ZaV SaVVed LQ 2010, WKeKeaOWKcaUe JRYeUQaQce PRdeO LQ PaNLVWaQ Kad a ceQWUaOL]ed VWUXcWXUe.6 TKe IedeUaO JRYeUQPeQWKad a VLJQLILcaQW UROe LQ IRUPXOaWLQJ aQd LPSOePeQWLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLcLeV, aQd WKe MLQLVWU\ RIHeaOWK aW WKe IedeUaO OeYeO SOa\ed a Ne\ UROe LQ cRRUdLQaWLQJ KeaOWK-UeOaWed acWLYLWLeV.6 UQdeU WKLVPRdeO, WKe IedeUaO JRYeUQPeQW Kad cRQWURO RYeU YaULRXV aVSecWV RI KeaOWKcaUe, LQcOXdLQJ WKedeYeORSPeQW RI QaWLRQaO KeaOWK SROLcLeV, WKe aOORcaWLRQ RI UeVRXUceV, aQd WKe PaQaJePeQW RIceUWaLQ KeaOWK LQVWLWXWLRQV.6 TKe SURYLQcLaO JRYeUQPeQWV ZeUe LQYROYed LQ WKe LPSOePeQWaWLRQ RIKeaOWK SURJUaPV, bXW WKe RYeUaOO IUaPeZRUN ZaV OaUJeO\ dLUecWed IURP WKe ceQWeU.6TKe 18WK APeQdPeQW PaUNed a VLJQLILcaQW VKLIW LQ WKe JRYeUQaQce VWUXcWXUe b\ deYROYLQJ VeYeUaOSRZeUV, LQcOXdLQJ WKRVe UeOaWed WR KeaOWK WR WKe SURYLQcLaO JRYeUQPeQWV e[ceSW IRU WKe IedeUaOO\adPLQLVWeUed WeUULWRULeV.6 AV a UeVXOW, WKe UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ IRU KeaOWK VeUYLceV, SOaQQLQJ, aQdLPSOePeQWaWLRQ ZaV WUaQVIeUUed WR WKe SURYLQceV. EacK SURYLQce ZaV JLYeQ WKe aXWKRULW\ WR PaNeLWV RZQ KeaOWK SROLcLeV, aOORcaWe UeVRXUceV, aQd PaQaJe KeaOWKcaUe IacLOLWLeV ZLWKLQ LWVMXULVdLcWLRQ.6 TKLV deceQWUaOL]aWLRQ aLPed WR eQKaQce ORcaO decLVLRQ-PaNLQJ, UeVSRQVLYeQeVV WRUeJLRQaO QeedV, aQd eIILcLeQc\ LQ VeUYLce deOLYeU\. IW aOVR VRXJKW WR ePSRZeU SURYLQceV WR WaLORUKeaOWKcaUe VWUaWeJLeV accRUdLQJ WR WKeLU XQLTXe cKaOOeQJeV aQd SULRULWLeV. AIWeU WKe 18WK3aPeQdPeQW, WKe IedeUaO JRYeUQPeQW'V UROe LQ KeaOWK JRYeUQaQce becaPe PRUe IRcXVed RQcRRUdLQaWLRQ, VWaQdaUd VeWWLQJ, aQd VXSSRUWLQJ SURYLQceV LQ WKeLU KeaOWK LQLWLaWLYeV.7TKe VWaWXWRU\ bRd\ WKaW cRQWUROV aQd UeJXOaWeV PedLcaO dRcWRUV aQd deQWLVWV LQ PaNLVWaQ LV WKePaNLVWaQ MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CRXQcLO (PMDC), ZKLcK IaOOV XQdeU WKe IedeUaO JRYeUQPeQW¶VMXULVdLcWLRQ.8 TKe PMDC ZaV LQLWLaOO\ eVWabOLVKed aV PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO CRXQcLO LQ 1948 b\adRSWLQJ WKe BULWLVK IQdLaQ MedLcaO CRXQcLO AcW 1933 RQ WKe UecRPPeQdaWLRQV RI WKe 1947PaNLVWaQ HeaOWK CRQIeUeQce.8 IW ZaV OaWeU UeRUJaQL]ed XQdeU WKe PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO CRXQcLO AcW1951 ZKeUeb\ eacK SURYLQce KaV LWV RZQ PedLcaO cRXQcLO. IQ 1957, WKe WeVW PaNLVWaQ MedLcaOCRXQcLO ZaV IRUPed b\ PeUJLQJ WKe SLQdK MedLcaO CRXQcLO aQd WKe PXQMab MedLcaO CRXQcLO.8TKe PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO CRXQcLO OUdLQaQce 1962 eVWabOLVKed WKe SUeVeQW-da\ PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO aQdDeQWaO CRXQcLO aV a VWaWXWRU\ bRd\ LQ 1962 aQd aOO SURYLQcLaO cRXQcLOV ZeUe dLVVROYed.8 TKUeeaPeQdPeQWV ZeUe SaVVed WKeUeaIWeU aV WKe MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CRXQcLO (APeQdPeQW) AcW LQ1973, 1999 aQd 2012.8TKe RQJRLQJ SROLWLcaO LQVWabLOLW\ LQ PaNLVWaQ KaV beeQ a VeULRXV WKUeaW WR WKe cUXcLaO baOaQce RIQaWLRQaO SRZeUV aQd WKe cRXQWU\¶V VWabLOLW\.4 LLNe RWKeU UeJXOaWRU\ V\VWePV, WKe UeJXOaWRU\aUcKLWecWXUe IRU PedLcaO SUacWLce aQd PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ LQ PaNLVWaQ KaV beeQ LQ a SeULRd RIXSKeaYaO eVSecLaOO\ dXULQJ WKe OaVW IeZ \eaUV dXe WR SRZeU SROLWLcV aPRQJ YaULRXV LQYROYed VWaWeacWRUV VXcK aV SROLWLcLaQV, bXUeaXcUac\, aQd MXdLcLaU\ RI WKe cRXQWU\. PMDC ZaV dLVVROYed aQd aQeZ PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO CRPPLVVLRQ (PMC) ZaV cRQVWLWXWed PXOWLSOe WLPeV dXe WR SROLWLcaO ULIWVbeWZeeQ WZR OeadLQJ SROLWLcaO SaUWLeV, PaNLVWaQ MXVOLP LeaJXe NRRQ aQd PaNLVWaQTeKUeeN-e-IQVaaI (PTI).5 IQ OcWRbeU 2019, WKe PMDC ZaV dLVVROYed IRU WKe ILUVW WLPe aQd4UeSOaced ZLWK WKe PMC ZKeQ PUeVLdeQW DU. AULI AOYL (WKe aSSRLQWed SUeVLdeQW RI WKe WKeQ QeZO\eOecWed SaUW\, PTI) VLJQed WKe PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO CRPPLVVLRQ OUdLQaQce 2019 IRU WKe UeJXOaWLRQaQd cRQWURO RI WKe PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQ WR VWUeQJWKeQ baVLc aQd KLJKeU PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQdSUacWLce LQ bRWK WKe PedLcaO aQd deQWaO ILeOdV LQ PaNLVWaQ. OQ OcWRbeU 19, 2019 WKLV PRYe ZaVcRQWeVWed LQ WKe IVOaPabad HLJK CRXUW, OeadLQJ WR a VLJQLILcaQW OeJaO baWWOe WKaW cXOPLQaWed LQ WKecRXUW'V decLVLRQ WR UeVWRUe WKe PMDC. TKe cRUe RI WKe OeJaO cKaOOeQJe ZaV WKe OeJLWLPac\ RI WKeSUeVLdeQWLaO RUdLQaQce WKaW dLVVROYed WKe PMDC aQd eVWabOLVKed WKe PMC. PeWLWLRQeUV aUJXed WKaWWKe RUdLQaQce ZaV XOWUa YLUeV, PeaQLQJ LW ZaV be\RQd WKe OeJaO SRZeU RU aXWKRULW\ RI WKeSUeVLdeQW WR eQacW VXcK cKaQJeV ZLWKRXW SURSeU OeJLVOaWLYe SURceVV.6 OQ 16WK SeSWePbeU 2020,PMDC ZaV dLVVROYed aJaLQ b\ a MRLQW VeVVLRQ RI WKe SeQaWe aQd PaUOLaPeQW b\ SaVVLQJ WKe bLOO WRUeSOace PMDC b\ PMC WR eQVXUe VWaQdaUd PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ LQ PaNLVWaQ. DXULQJ WKe WLPe PMCZaV LQ SOace, LWV cRQVWLWXWLRQ ZaV cKaOOeQJed aW YaULRXV IRUa, aQd WKaW cUeaWed WRWaO cRQIXVLRQaPRQJ PedLcaO SUacWLWLRQeUV aQd VWXdeQWV.9 AV RI AXJXVW 2022, SeQaWe SWaQdLQJ CRPPLWWee RQHeaOWK aSSURYed WKe PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CRXQcLO APeQdPeQW BLOO, 2022 ZLWK aPaMRULW\ YRWe, aIWeU ZKLcK WKe OeJaO VWaWXV RI WKe PMC ceaVed WR e[LVW, UeVWRULQJ PMDC.10TKe Ne\ SRZeUV aQd UeVSRQVLbLOLWLeV WKaW PMDC KROd aUe eQXPeUaWed dRZQ beORZ;11● SWraWegic Planning: DeYeORSLQJ aQQXaO aQd VWUaWeJLc SOaQV IRU PedLcaO aQd deQWaOedXcaWLRQ aQd LQVWLWXWLRQV.● AccrediWaWion and CXrricXlXm: OYeUVeeLQJ accUedLWaWLRQ VWaQdaUdV aQd cXUULcXOa IRUXQdeUJUadXaWe SURJUaPV.● Admissions and E[aminaWions: SeWWLQJ UXOeV IRU adPLVVLRQV, e[aPLQaWLRQV, aQdUeJLVWUaWLRQ UeQeZaOV.5● RecogniWion and AssessmenW: RecRJQL]LQJ PedLcaO aQd deQWaO LQVWLWXWLRQV aQd aVVeVVLQJLQWeUQaWLRQaO SURJUaPV aQd TXaOLILcaWLRQV.● Professional OYersighW: DecLdLQJ RQ cRPSOaLQWV aJaLQVW PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV aQdaSSURYLQJ QeZ VSecLaOLVWV.● AdYisor\ Role: AdYLVLQJ JRYeUQPeQWV RQ PedLcaO aQd deQWaO edXcaWLRQ aQdcROOabRUaWLQJ LQWeUQaWLRQaOO\ WR LPSURYe VWaQdaUdV.1.2.2 SWXdenW poliWics and iWs inflXence on polic\ processes in PakisWan: A hisWoricalaccoXnWIQ WKLV VecWLRQ, I ZLOO bULeIO\ deVcULbe WKe LQVWLWXWLRQaO aQd SROLWLcaO eQYLURQPeQW IRU VWXdeQWSROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ, ZKLcK SURYLdeV LPSRUWaQW cRQWe[W IRU XQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKe UROe RI MSaRDRUJaQL]aWLRQV. SWXdeQW XQLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ KaYe KLVWRULcaOO\ SOa\ed a d\QaPLc UROe LQ VKaSLQJSROLWLcV aQd SROLc\ SURceVVeV, UeIOecWLQJ WKe eYROYLQJ VRcLR-SROLWLcaO OaQdVcaSe. FURP WKeLUIRUPaWLYe \eaUV SRVW-LQdeSeQdeQce WR WKe cRQWePSRUaU\ eUa, WKeVe XQLRQV KaYe beeQ Ne\ acWRUV LQadYRcaWLQJ IRU VWXdeQW ULJKWV, LQIOXeQcLQJ QaWLRQaO QaUUaWLYeV, aQd SaUWLcLSaWLQJ LQ bURadeUSROLWLcaO PRYePeQWV.12IQ 1947, WKe MXVOLP SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQ ePeUJed aV WKe VWXdeQW-ZLQJ RI WKe UXOLQJ MXVOLPLeaJXe dXULQJ PaNLVWaQ'V LQdeSeQdeQce. HRZeYeU, SRVW-1947, ZLWK WKe dLVLQWeJUaWLRQ RI WKeMXVOLP LeaJXe, MXVOLP SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQ IUaJPeQWed dXe WR LQWUa-SaUW\ cRQIOLcWV.13.14 IQUeVSRQVe, WKe DePRcUaWLc SWXdeQW FedeUaWLRQ (DSF) ZaV IRUPed LQ 1950 aW DRZ MedLcaO CROOeJeWR addUeVV acadePLc LVVXeV, eYROYLQJ LQWR a OeIW-ZLQJ RUJaQL]aWLRQ. TKe eaUO\ 1950V VaZ WKe DSFJaLQLQJ LQIOXeQce, eVSecLaOO\ LQ KaUacKL, LaKRUe, aQd RaZaOSLQdL. DSF'V 'CKaUWeU RI DePaQdV' LQ61953 Oed WR a QeZ XQLYeUVLW\ LQ KaUacKL, PaUNLQJ a YLcWRU\. SeeLQJ WKe JURZLQJ LQIOXeQce RI DSF,WKe NaWLRQaO SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQ (NSF) aV a SUR-JRYeUQPeQW eQWLW\ WR cRXQWeU OeIWLVW VeQWLPeQWZaV LQWURdXced LQ WKe OaWe 1950V. HRZeYeU, MaUWLaO OaZ LPSRVed b\ PUeVLdeQW IVNaQdeU MLU]aaQd PLOLWaU\ cKLeI A\Xb KKaQ Oed WR WKe baQ RI SROLWLcaO SaUWLeV, LQcOXdLQJ NSF. TKe 1960VbURXJKW IRUWK WKe ULVe RI IVOaPL JaPLaW TaOeba (IJT), RYeUVKadRZLQJ DSF aQd NSF. AIWeU WKe baQRQ SROLWLcaO SaUWLeV ZaV OLIWed LQ 1962, IJT RXVWed NSF IURP KaUacKL UQLYeUVLW\ aQd VRPe RWKeUcROOeJeV LQ KaUacKL, ZKLOe NSF UeWaLQed eOecWRUaO VXSUePac\ LQ PRVW RWKeU cROOeJeV. HRZeYeU,cRPSeWLWLRQ beWZeeQ IJT aQd NSF cRQYeUJed WR XQdeUPLQe WKe A\Xb UeJLPe LQ WKe OaWe 1960VeQdLQJ KLV UeLJQ LQ MaUcK 1960. 14AIWeU beLQJ eOecWed LQ WKe 1970V, WKe PaNLVWaQ PeRSOeV PaUW\ cUeaWed SROLcLeV WR UeJXOaWe VWXdeQWSROLWLcV RQ caPSXVeV.14 DeVSLWe UeJXOaUL]aWLRQ, a WUaQVIRUPaWLYe SeULRd IRU PaNLVWaQL VWXdeQWSROLWLcV beJaQ aIWeU 1974 aV VRPe cRQVWLWXeQcLeV SUeYLRXVO\ aOLJQed ZLWK WKe VWaWe'V PRdeUQLVWIVOaPLc YLVLRQ beJaQ WR aOLJQ ZLWK IVOaPLVW JURXSV aPLd ULVLQJ eWKQLc SROLWLcV aQd decOLQLQJVXSSRUW IRU OeIWLVW LdeaOV.14 TKe DSF IUaJPeQWed, aQd JaYe ULVe WR WKe PURJUeVVLYe SWXdeQWVFedeUaWLRQ (PSF) aOLJQed ZLWK WKe PaNLVWaQ PeRSOeV PaUW\. MeaQZKLOe, WKe IJT, WKe VWXdeQW-ZLQJRI WKe IVOaPLVW JaPaW-L-IVOaPL (JI), URVe WR eOecWRUaO SURPLQeQce, OeadLQJ WR aOOLaQceV aPRQJYaULRXV IacWLRQV, LQcOXdLQJ PSF, BaORcK SWXdeQWV OUJaQL]aWLRQ, aQd PaNKWXQ SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQ.IQ UeVSRQVe WR IJT'V dRPLQaQce, aQWL-IJT VWXdeQWV IRUPed WKe LLbeUaO SWXdeQWV OUJaQLVaWLRQ.14TKe 1977 JeQeUaO eOecWLRQV PaUNed a WXUQLQJ SRLQW aV WKe PaNLVWaQ PeRSOeV PaUW\ ORVW VXSSRUWIURP SURJUeVVLYe VWXdeQW JURXSV, aQd PaVV SURWeVWV accXVed PULPe MLQLVWeU BKXWWR RI eOecWLRQULJJLQJ.14 TKe VXbVeTXeQW PLOLWaU\ cRXS Oed b\ GeQeUaO ZLa LQLWLaWed a cUacNdRZQ RQ RSSRVLWLRQSaUWLeV, ZLWK IJT VXSSRUWLQJ ZLa. IQ WKe eaUO\ 1980V, VWXdeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV VWaUWed WR SURcXUe7ZeaSRQV, QRWabO\ aURXQd WKe WLPe RI WKe VWXdeQW XQLRQ eOecWLRQV LQ 1983, SURPSWLQJ cRQVLdeUabOeaOaUP.14 CRQVeTXeQWO\ LQ 1984, ZLa LPSRVed a baQ RQ VWXdeQW XQLRQV, cLWLQJ caPSXV YLROeQce.LaWeU, SXSUePe CRXUW RUdeUed a bOaQNeW baQ LQ 1988 RQ VWXdeQW XQLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ aIWeU WeUULWRULaOaQd eOecWRUaO YLROeQce eUXSWed beWZeeQ MXVOLP SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQ aQd IJT.14TKe eaUO\ 2000V ZLWQeVVed a decOLQe LQ WKe e[SOLcLW dLVSOa\ RI SRZeU LQ WKe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV ZLWK aVKLIW IURP dLVaUPed VWXdeQW SROLWLcV WKaW ZaV cRQILQed WR bXW IRU PRUe cRPSOe[ UeaVRQV UeOaWed WRWKe cKaQJLQJ OaQdVcaSe RI edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQV - VXcK aV LQcUeaVLQJ SULYaWL]aWLRQ RI WKeKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP.15.16 TKe decOLQe RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ UeIOecWV a JORbaO WUeQd WKaWZLWQeVVed a SeaN LQ WKe 1960V, IROORZed b\ a JUadXaO UecedLQJ IURP WKe PLd-1970V RQZaUdV.17.18TKe VXUJe LQ VWXdeQW acWLYLVP dXULQJ WKe 1960V ZaV a cRQVeTXeQce RI WKe LQcUeaVed eQUROOPeQWRI PLddOe aQd ORZeU-PLddOe-cOaVV LQdLYLdXaOV LQ cROOeJeV aQd XQLYeUVLWLeV ZRUOdZLde aIWeU WRUOdWaU II. DeVSLWe ecRQRPLc bRRPV LQ EXURSeaQ cRXQWULeV, WKe UQLWed SWaWeV RI APeULca (USA),aQd SRVW-cRORQLaO UeaOPV LQ AVLa aQd AIULca, edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQV VWUXJJOed WR accRPPRdaWeWKe LQIOX[, OeadLQJ WR ORJLVWLcaO aQd adPLQLVWUaWLYe cKaOOeQJeV aQd OeaYLQJ VWXdeQWVdLVJUXQWOed.17.18 IQ WKe 1960V, VWXdeQWV LQ PaNLVWaQ cKaQQeOed WKeLU dLVcRQWeQW WKURXJKSRZeU-dULYeQ OeIW-OeaQLQJ LdeRORJLeV. HRZeYeU, b\ WKe 1970V, a JUadXaO dLVLOOXVLRQPeQW ZLWKWKeVe OeIW-OeaQLQJ LdeaV SURPSWed a VKLIW WRZaUdV ULJKWLVW e[SUeVVLRQV RI dLVcRQWeQW. TKLV VKLIW ZaVLQIOXeQced b\ LPSURYed cRQdLWLRQV LQ edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQV JORbaOO\ aQd aQ LQcUeaVLQJ QXPbeURI SULYaWe cROOeJeV aQd XQLYeUVLWLeV.15.16FURP 2000V RQZaUdV, a SaOSabOe UeVWOeVVQeVV aPRQJ WKe \RXWK LQ PaNLVWaQ KaV ePeUJed. TKLVUeVWOeVVQeVV caQ be aWWULbXWed WR JRYeUQPeQWV aQd edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQV IaOOLQJ VKRUW LQ8accRPPRdaWLQJ WKe eYROYLQJ VRcLR-SROLWLcaO QeedV RI a QeZ JeQeUaWLRQ. TKRVe adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKeUeYLYaO RI VWXdeQW XQLRQV PaNe a cRPSeOOLQJ caVe, ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe LQadeTXac\ RI cXUUeQWV\VWePV, caOOLQJ IRU WKe UeLQVWaWePeQW RI VWXdeQW XQLRQV aV a SOaWIRUP WR QeJRWLaWe beWWeUacadePLc aQd UecUeaWLRQaO IacLOLWLeV, dePRQVWUaWLQJ a SeUVLVWeQW Qeed IRU SROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQW RQcaPSXVeV.15.161.2.3 Role of MSaRD organi]aWions in polic\ processes in PakisWan in Whe pasWTKe UROe RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV' UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ KeaOWK SROLc\SURceVVeV LQ PaNLVWaQ LV a VLJQLILcaQW aUea RI VWXd\ WR be e[SORUed. FURP WKe eVWabOLVKPeQW RI WKeMXVOLP SWXdeQWV FedeUaWLRQ aV WKe VWXdeQW-ZLQJ RI WKe UXOLQJ MXVOLP LeaJXe LQ 1947 WR WKeeYROYLQJ d\QaPLcV RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, PedLcaO VWXdeQWV KaYe beeQ LQWeJUaO WR VKaSLQJ WKeSROLWLcaO dLVcRXUVe.14 TKe IRUPaWLRQ RI WKe DSF LQ 1950, LQLWLaWed b\ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aW DRZMedLcaO CROOeJe, XQdeUVcRUeV WKe LQWeUVecWLRQ RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd SROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQW.19DSF'V YLcWRU\ LQ adYRcaWLQJ IRU a QeZ XQLYeUVLW\ LQ KaUacKL VKRZcaVed WKe SRWeQWLaO LPSacW RIRUJaQL]ed VWXdeQW PRYePeQWV. BeVLdeV eQJaJePeQW RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWV LQ addUeVVLQJ acadePLcSURbOePV, DSF'V LQIOXeQce e[SaQded acURVV cLWLeV, cRQWULbXWLQJ WR a bURadeU OeIW-ZLQJ \RXWKPRYePeQW, e[ePSOLI\LQJ WKe SRWeQWLaO LPSacW RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWV RQ SROLc\-UeOaWed dLVcXVVLRQV.HRZeYeU, LQLWLaOO\ ePeUJLQJ aV YLbUaQW dePRcUaWLc eQWLWLeV, VWXdeQW XQLRQV, UeSUeVeQWed b\RUJaQL]aWLRQV OLNe DSF aQd NSF, dXULQJ WKe 1960V aQd RQZaUdV, PedLcaO VWXdeQWV, aORQJ ZLWKWKeLU cRXQWeUSaUWV, acWLYeO\ SaUWLcLSaWed LQ SURWeVWV aJaLQVW A\Xb KKaQ'V UeJLPe.14.19 AV SUeYLRXVO\dLVcXVVed, WKe ULVe RI IJT RYeUVKadRZed DSF aQd NSF, LPSacWLQJ WKe SROLWLcaO OaQdVcaSe RIPedLcaO LQVWLWXWLRQV aV ZeOO. AV SROLWLcaO LdeRORJLeV VKLIWed aQd VWXdeQW SROLWLcV XQdeUZeQWWUaQVIRUPaWLRQV, PedLcaO VWXdeQWV IRXQd WKePVeOYeV QaYLJaWLQJ cRPSOe[ WeUUaLQV. TKe baQ RQ9VWXdeQW XQLRQV LQ 1984, aQd VXbVeTXeQWO\ LQ 1992 KeaYLO\ aIIecWed WKe TXaOLW\ RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWOeadeUVKLS, cRQWULbXWLQJ WR a bURadeU decOLQe LQ VWXdeQW acWLYLVP.19.20 AQ e[ceUSW IURP WKe baQ:AW WKe WLPe Rf adPLVVLRQ WR aQ edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQ, WKe VWXdeQW aQd KLV SaUeQWV VKaOO JLYe aQXQdeUWaNLQJ WKaW WKe VWXdeQW VKaOO QRW LQdXOJe LQ SROLWLcV aQd Lf Ke YLROaWeV, Ke ZLOO be e[SeOOedfURP WKe LQVWLWXWLRQ ZLWKRXW aQ\ fXUWKeU QRWLce.1.2.4 The cXrrenW adYocac\ scenario of MSaRD organi]aWions in PakisWanIQ UeceQW \eaUV, PedLcaO VWXdeQWV OLNe WKeLU RWKeU VWXdeQWV LQ PaNLVWaQ KaYe beeQ SaUW RI WKeUeQeZed caOOV IRU WKe UeVWRUaWLRQ RI VWXdeQW XQLRQV. TKe dePaQd UeIOecWV a VKaUed VeQWLPeQWaPRQJ dLYeUVe VWXdeQW JURXSV, ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe Qeed IRU a dePRcUaWLc VSace IRU VWXdeQWV,LQcOXdLQJ WKRVe LQ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ.21 MSaRD QRZ e[LVW LQ a XQLTXe, QXaQced eQYLURQPeQWZKeUe deVSLWe WKe WUadLWLRQaO VWXdeQW SROLWLcV baQ, MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV cRQWLQXe WR e[LVW aQdRSeUaWe RQ WKe JURXQd.TKe adYeQW RI VRcLaO PedLa KaV UeYROXWLRQL]ed WKe adYRcac\ SURceVV acURVV WKe JORbe b\SURYLdLQJ a SRZeUIXO SOaWIRUP IRU UaLVLQJ aZaUeQeVV, PRbLOL]LQJ VXSSRUW, aQd dULYLQJ cKaQJe.22 IWeQabOeV adYRcaWeV WR VKaUe LQIRUPaWLRQ ZLdeO\ aQd UaSLdO\, UeacKLQJ a JORbaO aXdLeQce ZLWKPLQLPaO UeVRXUceV. TKURXJK VRcLaO PedLa, LQdLYLdXaOV aQd RUJaQL]aWLRQV caQ KLJKOLJKW LVVXeV,VKaUe VWRULeV, aQd caOO IRU acWLRQ, eQJaJLQJ bRWK WKe SXbOLc aQd SROLc\PaNeUV LQ PeaQLQJIXOdLaORJXe. TKLV LPPedLac\ aQd UeacK IacLOLWaWe WKe IRUPaWLRQ RI RQOLQe cRPPXQLWLeV aQdPRYePeQWV, ePSRZeULQJ WKeLU YRLceV.23.24 A UeceQW LQWeUeVWLQJ caVe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQVSOa\LQJ WKeLU UROe LQ WKe SROLc\ SURceVV RI KeaOWKcaUe, OeYeUaJLQJ VRcLaO PedLa ZaV WKe NLE. TKLV10e[aP ZaV LQWURdXced LQ 2019 IRU PedLcaO aQd deQWaO JUadXaWeV WR addUeVV WKe deILcLeQcLeV LQ WKePedLcaO edXcaWLRQaO V\VWeP RI PaNLVWaQ.25 NLE ZaV WKe QeZ IRUP RI e[LW e[aP IRU PedLcaO aQddeQWaO JUadXaWeV SURSRVed WR be cRQdXcWed acURVV PaNLVWaQ ZLWK aQ aLP WR SOace a TXaOLW\-cKecNRQ WKe WeacKLQJ VWaQdaUdV RI PedLcaO VcKRROV aQd XQLYeUVLWLeV acURVV WKe cRXQWU\. UQdeU SecWLRQ21 RI WKe PMC OUdLQaQce 2019, LW ZaV Pade PaQdaWRU\ WR SaVV WKe NLE WR RbWaLQ a SURYLVLRQaOaQd IXOO OLceQVe WR SUacWLce LQ PaNLVWaQ. DeVSLWe SRVLWLYe LQWeQW beKLQd WKe LQWURdXcWLRQ RI NLEaQd WKe SUeYaOeQce RI VLPLOaU WRROV WR aVVeVV WKe eOLJLbLOLW\ RI dRcWRU¶V UeVLdeQc\ LQ PaQ\ RWKeUcRXQWULeV VXcK aV USMLE aQd NBDE LQ WKe USA, LQ PaNLVWaQ LW UeceLYed a YeU\ PL[edUeVSRQVe.25SXSSRUWeUV RI WKe NLE VWaWed WKaW LW ZLOO be a WRRO WR XQLIRUPO\ aVVeVV WKe PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOVIURP acURVV WKe cRXQWU\ WR LQcUeaVe WKe TXaOLW\ RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd KeaOWKcaUe VeUYLceV LQPaNLVWaQ, addUeVVLQJ RQe RI WKe UeTXLUePeQWV RI WKe WRUOd FedeUaWLRQ RI MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ. IWZaV beOLeYed WKaW RQO\ WKRVe PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV ZKR dePRQVWUaWe adeTXaWe OeYeO RINQRZOedJe aQd VNLOOV ZLOO be aOORZed WR eQWeU WKe SUacWLce LPSURYLQJ WKe VWaQdLQJ RI PaNLVWaQLJUadXaWeV QaWLRQaOO\ aQd LQWeUQaWLRQaOO\ eQVXULQJ WKe VaIeW\ RI WKe SaWLeQWV.10.11 AQRWKeU aUJXPeQWZaV WKaW PMC aV a UeJXOaWRU\ bRd\ Pa\ XVe WKe daWa RbWaLQed IURP NLE WR LdeQWLI\ aQd UeJXOaWeWKe XQdeUSeUIRUPLQJ cROOeJeV. FLQaOO\, LW ZaV KRSed WKaW a XQLIRUP OLceQVLQJ e[aPLQaWLRQ Pa\LQcUeaVe SXbOLc WUXVW LQ WKe cRXQWU\¶V PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP aV UeIOecWed LQ aSXbOLc SROO cRQdXcWed b\ WKe GeQeUaO MedLcaO CRXQcLO LQ WKe UQLWed KLQJdRP (UK), VKRZLQJWZR-WKLUdV RI WKe UeVSRQdeQWV ZeUe LQ IaYRU RI a VLQJOe aVVeVVPeQW VWUaWeJ\ IRU KaYLQJ cRQILdeQceLQ UeceQWO\ JUadXaWed dRcWRUV.26 OQ WKe RWKeU VLde, WKeUe ZaV a VeULRXV RSSRVLWLRQ WR WKe SROLc\IURP ZLWKLQ WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ RQ WKe OeJaO IURQW aQd WKURXJK SXbOLc dePRQVWUaWLRQV,11LQcOXdLQJ VRcLaO PedLa caPSaLJQV aQd cRXQWU\ZLde URad SURWeVWV Oed PaLQO\ b\ MSaRD VXcK aVYRXQJ DRcWRUV¶ AVVRcLaWLRQ (YDA) PaNLVWaQ. MedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd dRcWRUV RSSRVLQJ LWcRQVLdeUed LW WR be aQ e\eZaVK WR PaVN WKe aOUead\ e[LVWLQJ VWUXcWXUaO deILcLeQcLeV LQ WKe cXUUeQWKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP LQ WKe cRXQWU\. TKRVe RSSRVLQJ LW aUJXed WKaW PMC VKRXOd addUeVV WKeVWUXcWXUaO LVVXeV ILUVW WR addUeVV WKe VWaQdaUd RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ beIRUe eQIRUcLQJ PRUe e[aPVRQ WKe PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd dRcWRUV.27 AIWeU WZR \eaUV RI SURWeVWLQJ, WKe NLE ZaV abROLVKed LQOcWRbeU 2022 b\ PMDC aIWeU LWV UeLQVWaWePeQW LQ AXJXVW 2022. 281.3 LiWeraWXre reYieZ1.3.1 Defining sWXdenW poliWicsAccRUdLQJ WR AOWbacK (2006), VWXdeQW SROLWLcV eQcRPSaVVeV WKe YaULRXV PRYePeQWV aQdRUJaQL]aWLRQV aW WKe SRVWVecRQdaU\ OeYeO WKaW ZLeOd LQIOXeQce RYeU SROLWLcV, cXOWXUe, aQd VRcLeW\.KOePeQþLþ aQd PaUN (2018) e[WeQd WKLV deILQLWLRQ b\ ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe aVVRcLaWLRQ RI VWXdeQWSROLWLcV ZLWK WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ RI WKe VWXdeQW bRd\ aQd LWV LQIOXeQce RQ KLJKeU edXcaWLRQLQVWLWXWLRQV, V\VWePV, aQd WKe ZLdeU VRcLeW\.29 deOOa PRUWa eW aO. (2020) add QXaQce b\ deILQLQJVWXdeQW SROLWLcV aV a cRPbLQaWLRQ RI RUJaQL]aWLRQaO VWUXcWXUeV, acWLRQ UeSeUWRLUeV, aQd PaVWeUIUaPeV ePSOR\ed b\ VWXdeQWV WR adYaQce WKeLU cOaLPV. TKeVe deILQLWLRQV cROOecWLYeO\acNQRZOedJe WKe cRPSOe[ LQWeUSOa\ beWZeeQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, KLJKeU edXcaWLRQ V\VWePV, aQdLQVWLWXWLRQV, XQdeUVcRULQJ WKe deJUee RI aXWRQRP\ LQKeUeQW LQ VWXdeQW RUJaQL]LQJ.291.3.2 SWXdenW represenWaWion Ys sWXdenW acWiYismSWXdeQW UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ, aV aUWLcXOaWed b\ KOePeQþLþ aQd PaUN (2018), LQYROYeV eQJaJLQJ LQcOaLP-PaNLQJ WKURXJK IRUPaO UeSUeVeQWaWLRQaO VWUXcWXUeV. TKLV RIWeQ LQcOXdeV VecXULQJ a VeaW LQ12WKe XQLYeUVLW\ JRYeUQLQJ bRd\ RU becRPLQJ a PePbeU RI WKe NaWLRQaO HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ CRXQcLO.TKe VWUaWeJLeV ePSOR\ed LQ UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ aUe cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ SaUWLcLSaWLRQ LQ bRaUd SROLWLcV,eQcRPSaVVLQJ cRQWULbXWLRQV WR PeeWLQJV RI JRYeUQLQJ bRdLeV, WaVN IRUceV, cRPPLWWeeV, aQdacWLYLWLeV UeOaWed WR ORbb\LQJ aQd LVVXe adYRcac\.30 IQ eVVeQce, UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ SURYLdeV VWXdeQWVZLWK a IRUPaOL]ed aYeQXe WR aUWLcXOaWe WKeLU cRQceUQV ZLWKLQ eVWabOLVKed decLVLRQ-PaNLQJVWUXcWXUeV.30 IQ cRQWUaVW, acWLYLVP, aV SRUWUa\ed b\ BaUQeV aQd KaaVe (1979) LQYROYeV IRUPV RIcRQWeQWLRXV SROLWLcV XVLQJ SURWeVWV, bR\cRWWV, aQd caPSaLJQV aV SULPaU\ IRUPV RI acWLYLVP.AcWLYLVP ePSRZeUV VWXdeQWV WR eQJaJe LQ cOaLP-PaNLQJ be\RQd WKe cRQILQeV RI IRUPaO decLVLRQVWUXcWXUeV, RIWeQ OeYeUaJLQJ WKe SRZeU RI cROOecWLYe acWLRQ WR bULQJ aWWeQWLRQ WR LVVXeV WKaW Pa\ beRYeUORRNed ZLWKLQ WUadLWLRQaO cKaQQeOV. AcWLYLVWV RSeUaWe RQ WKe SUePLVe WKaW VRcLeWaO cKaQJe caQbe LQVWLJaWed b\ cKaOOeQJLQJ eVWabOLVKed QRUPV aQd eQJaJLQJ LQ dLUecW IRUPV RI SURWeVW.24 BRWKAOWbacK (2006) aQd KOePeQþLþ aQd PaUN (2018) UecRJQL]e VWXdeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV aV eQWLWLeV ZLWKWKe SRWeQWLaO WR LPSacW SROLWLcaO decLVLRQV dLUecWO\ RU LQdLUecWO\ WKURXJK LQYROYePeQW LQ bRWKacWLYLVP aQd UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ. SWXdeQW LQWeUeVW aQd cRPPXQLW\ JURXSV RQ caPSXV RIWeQ KaUbRUSROLWLcaO aJeQdaV. IQdLYLdXaOV aVVXPLQJ OeadeUVKLS UROeV ZLWKLQ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV e[eUcLVeSROLWLcaO aJeQc\ WKURXJK SURJUaPPLQJ VXcK aV eYeQWV, SXbOLcaWLRQV, aQd SeUIRUPaQceV.MRUeRYeU, cROOabRUaWLRQ ZLWK UeSUeVeQWaWLYe JRYeUQPeQWV aQd acWLYLVW LQLWLaWLYeV aOORZV WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV WR bULdJe WKe JaS beWZeeQ IRUPaO UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ aQd JUaVVURRWV acWLYLVP.29.30HLVWRULcaOO\, VWXdeQW SROLWLcV KaV beeQ SLYRWaO LQ LQIOXeQcLQJ JORbaO SROLWLcaO PRYePeQWV.31OIILcLaO VWXdeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV, LQLWLaOO\ VeUYLQJ aV WUaLQLQJ JURXQdV, caQ eYROYe LQWR LQIOXeQWLaOaQd eYeQ PLOLWaQW PRYePeQWV.31 E[WUa-cXUULcXOaU RUJaQL]aWLRQV RIIeU SOaWIRUPV IRU dLYeUVeacWLYLWLeV, IRVWeULQJ KROLVWLc deYeORSPeQW. UQRIILcLaO VWXdeQW PRYePeQWV, WKRXJK VPaOOeU, SOa\ a13cUXcLaO UROe LQ dULYLQJ UadLcaO aJeQdaV aQd LQIOXeQcLQJ WKe bURadeU VWXdeQW cRPPXQLW\.31 TKXVWKe LPSacW RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV UeVRQaWeV RQ PXOWLSOe OeYeOV. TKLV cRPSOe[ LQWeUSOa\ aPRQJ WKeVeVWXdeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV XQdeUVcRUeV WKe RYeUOaS RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aQd acWLYLVP, VKRZcaVLQJ WKecRPSOe[LW\ RI WKeVe d\QaPLcV aV PRUe WKaQ MXVW bLQaU\ cKRLceV. AcWLYLVWV IUeTXeQWO\ ePSOR\cRQIURQWaWLRQaO WacWLcV WR JaLQ a VeaW RI LQIOXeQce, ZKLOe LQdLYLdXaOV LQ eOecWed SRVLWLRQV PLJKWaOVR eQJaJe LQ, RU beQeILW IURP, acWLYLVP.31 TKLV dePRQVWUaWeV WKaW WKe UeOaWLRQVKLS beWZeeQacWLYLVP aQd IRUPaO UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ ZLWKLQ WKeVe JURXSV LV PXOWLIaceWed, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKe QXaQcedRYeUOaS RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aQd acWLYLVP. OYeUOaSSLQJ PePbeUVKLSV aQd LdeaV KLJKOLJKW WKeLPSRUWaQce RI LQYeVWLJaWLQJ SeUVRQaO cRQWacWV aQd LdeRORJLeV ZLWKLQ WKe VWXdeQW cRPPXQLW\.FacWRUV RXWVLde WKe acadePLc dRPaLQ caQ UeVKaSe VeePLQJO\ UeVSecWabOe RUJaQL]aWLRQV,ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe LQWULcaWe d\QaPLcV aW SOa\. CRQVeTXeQWO\, VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, LQ LWV dLYeUVe IRUPV,ePeUJeV aV a d\QaPLc IRUce ZLWK WKe SRWeQWLaO WR VKaSe QRW RQO\ WKe acadePLc eQYLURQPeQW bXWaOVR WKe bURadeU VRcLeWaO aQd SROLWLcaO OaQdVcaSe JORbaOO\.31.32deOOa PRUWa eW.aO (2020) KaYe dLVcXVVed WKe YaULRXV IRUPV RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV XVLQJ a IUaPeZRUNbaVed RQ WZR dLPeQVLRQV.33 TKe ILUVW dLPeQVLRQ aVVeVVeV WKe e[WeQW RI VWXdeQW acceVV WRdecLVLRQ-PaNLQJ LQVWaQceV ZLWKLQ WKe KLJKeU edXcaWLRQ VecWRU, eQcRPSaVVLQJ bRWK XQLYeUVLW\JRYeUQaQce aQd WKe bURadeU JRYeUQaQce RI KLJKeU edXcaWLRQ.33 TKe VecRQd dLPeQVLRQ, WeUPed"VWXdeQW SROLWLcV," e[SORUeV WKe dLYeUVe IRUPV RI VWXdeQW acWLYLVP, LUUeVSecWLYe RI IRUPaOL]aWLRQ RUVWaWe UecRJQLWLRQ. IW cRQWeQdV WKaW WKe VWUeQJWK aQd WUadLWLRQ RI SROLWLcaO acWLYLVP ZLWKLQ VWXdeQWcXOWXUe VLJQLILcaQWO\ VKaSe WKe QaWXUe RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, LQIOXeQcLQJ WKe WacWLcV aQd dePaQdV RIWKe VWXdeQW PRYePeQW.33 AddLWLRQaOO\, WKLV dLPeQVLRQ e[aPLQeV ZKeWKeU VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LVRUJaQL]ed ceQWUaOO\ aQd QaWLRQaOO\, cOaLPLQJ WR UeSUeVeQW WKe eQWLUe VWXdeQW bRd\ aQd WaUJeWLQJ14ceQWUaO aQd QaWLRQaO aXWKRULWLeV, RU LI LW RSeUaWeV RQ a PRUe ORcaOL]ed VcaOe, addUeVVLQJ VSecLILcLVVXeV ZLWKLQ LQdLYLdXaO XQLYeUVLWLeV RU UeJLRQV.33 BaVed RQ WKLV IUaPeZRUN WKe\ KaYe caWeJRUL]edVWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQWR IRXU caWeJRULeV ZKLcK aUe aV IROORZV:33 LRZ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ, cRRUdLQaWed ILeOd HLJK LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ, IUaJPeQWed ILeOd HLJK LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ, cRRUdLQaWed ILeOd LRZ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ, IUaJPeQWed ILeOdTKe deJUee RI LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ aQd WKe VcRSe RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV²ZKeWKeU WKe\ aUe ceQWUaOL]edRU ORcaOL]ed²aIIecW WKeVe eOePeQWV SURIRXQdO\. IQ eQYLURQPeQWV ZKeUe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aUeKLJKO\ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed, VXcK aV LQ EQJOaQd aQd QXebec, RUJaQL]aWLRQV WeQd WR eQJaJe LQ PRUePRdeUaWe IRUPV RI acWLYLVP, OeYeUaJLQJ eVWabOLVKed cKaQQeOV RI acceVV WR LQIOXeQcedecLVLRQ-PaNLQJ SURceVVeV.33 TKeVe JURXSV RIWeQ adRSW a VWUaWeJLc aSSURacK, XWLOL]LQJ WKeLU VWabOeUeVRXUceV aQd OeJaO IUaPeZRUNV WR QaYLJaWe WKe SROLWLcaO OaQdVcaSe eIIecWLYeO\.33 OQ WKe RWKeUKaQd, LQ SOaceV ZLWK ORZ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ aQd IUaJPeQWed VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, OLNe CKLOe aQd IWaO\,WKeUe LV a WeQdeQc\ WRZaUdV PRUe PLOLWaQW aQd cRQIURQWaWLRQaO IRUPV RI acWLYLVP.33 TKe OLPLWedIRUPaO aYeQXeV IRU LQIOXeQcLQJ SROLc\ aQd decLVLRQ-PaNLQJ eQcRXUaJe WKeVe JURXSV WR adRSWPRUe UadLcaO PeWKRdV RI SURWeVW aQd adYRcac\.33 FXUWKeUPRUe, WKe cXOWXUaO bacNdURS RI VWXdeQWSROLWLcV SOa\V a VLJQLILcaQW UROe LQ VKaSLQJ KRZ VWXdeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV PRbLOL]e, eVWabOLVK WKeLUaJeQdaV, aQd deILQe WKeLU JRaOV.33 TKLV cXOWXUaO LQIOXeQce caQ WUaQVceQd RUJaQL]aWLRQaO bRXQdaULeVaQd SeUVLVW acURVV JeQeUaWLRQV, aIIecWLQJ WKe VW\Oe aQd LQWeQVLW\ RI VWXdeQW acWLYLVP.33 TKeSUeVeQce RU abVeQce RI IRUPaOL]ed SOaWIRUPV IRU SROLWLcaO e[cKaQJe aPRQJ VWXdeQWV aOVRVLJQLILcaQWO\ LPSacWV WKe QaWXUe RI VWXdeQW acWLYLVP.33 SXcK SOaWIRUPV caQ IacLOLWaWe cRRUdLQaWed15acWLRQV aQd KeOS XQLI\ dLVSaUaWe JURXSV, OeadLQJ WR PRUe eIIecWLYe aQd cRKeUeQW PRYePeQWV, aVeYLdeQced LQ WKe KLVWRULcaO e[aPSOeV IURP CKLOe aQd QXebec33. CRQYeUVeO\, WKe OacN RI VXcKSOaWIRUPV caQ UeVXOW LQ a IUaJPeQWed aQd OeVV eIIecWLYe VWXdeQW SROLWLcaO OaQdVcaSe, aV VeeQ LQEQJOaQd aQd IWaO\.33TR VXPPaUL]e, VWXdeQW SROLWLcV caQ e[WeQd be\RQd WKe cRQILQeV RI UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ WKURXJK VWXdeQWJRYeUQPeQWV aQd ePbUace WKe PXOWLIaceWed QaWXUe RI VWXdeQW acWLYLVP. IW eQcRPSaVVeV VWXdeQWOeadeUVKLS e[KLbLWed WKURXJK WKe SROLWLcaO acWLYLWLeV RI VWXdeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV aQd WKe VLJQLILcaQWUROe VWXdeQWV SOa\ LQ LQVWLWXWLRQaO deYeORSPeQW WKURXJK SaLd aQd YROXQWeeU ZRUN. AV VWXdeQWVQaYLJaWe WKe OaQdVcaSe RI KLJKeU edXcaWLRQ, WKeLU LQYROYePeQW LQ SROLWLcV becRPeV a QXaQcedLQWeUSOa\ beWZeeQ IRUPaOL]ed UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ, JUaVVURRWV acWLYLVP, aQd WKe d\QaPLc LQLWLaWLYeVXQdeUWaNeQ b\ VWXdeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV. IQ WKLV SaSeU, I KaYe dUaZQ XSRQ WKe deOOa PRUWa eW.aO (2020)IUaPeZRUN aV SaUW RI WKe aQaO\VLV, WR be e[SOLcaWed LQ WKe dLVcXVVLRQ.331.3.3 Role of MSaRD in healWhcare polic\ processes in High-Income CoXnWriesTKLV VecWLRQ e[SORUeV WKe UROe RI MSaRD LQ VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ SURceVVeV, IRcXVLQJ RQ WKeUK aQd WKe USA. TKeVe cRXQWULeV KaYe beeQ VeOecWed dXe WR WKeLU dLVWLQcWLYe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV,WKe KLVWRULcaO aQd cRQWePSRUaU\ acWLYLVP RI MSaRD, aQd WKeLU YaU\LQJ aSSURacKeV WR KeaOWKcaUeSROLc\ aQd adYRcac\. AQ addLWLRQaO UeaVRQ IRU WKLV VeOecWLRQ LV WKe LQIOXeQce RI WKeLU KeaOWKcaUePRdeOV RQ PaNLVWaQ'V SROLcLeV. PMDC WKaW ZaV LQLWLaOO\ baVed RQ WKe BULWLVK IQdLaQ MedLcaOCRXQcLO LV VWUXcWXUed XSRQ WKe UK'V PedLcaO UeJXOaWRU\ IUaPeZRUN.8 MeaQZKLOe, cRQWePSRUaU\KeaOWK SROLc\ LQ PaNLVWaQ, SaUWLcXOaUO\ eYLdeQW LQ WKe NLE debaWe, dUaZV cOeaU LQVSLUaWLRQ IURP WKeUS KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKe VLJQLILcaQce RI WKeVe cRXQWULeV LQ WKLV cRQWe[W.16UK: IQ WKe UK, WKe LQYROYePeQW RI MSaRD LQ VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ SURceVVeV LV WLJKWO\ZRYeQ LQWR WKe bURadeU IabULc RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV. IQ WKe cRQWe[W RI KLJKO\ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed VWXdeQWacWLYLVP LQ EQJOaQd, ZKeUe VWXdeQW XQLRQV aQd JRYeUQaQce VWUXcWXUeV KaYe a Va\ LQ KLJKeUedXcaWLRQ decLVLRQV, WKeVe VWXdeQW XQLRQV KROd a XQLTXe SRVLWLRQ WR QeJRWLaWe ZLWK aXWKRULWLeV.TUadLWLRQaOO\, VWXdeQW acWLYLVP LQ EQJOaQd KaV beeQ PRUe ORcaOL]ed, IRcXVLQJ RQ LVVXeV VSecLILc WRLQdLYLdXaO cROOeJeV aQd XQLYeUVLWLeV UaWKeU WKaQ KaYLQJ a VWURQJ QaWLRQaO cRRUdLQaWLRQ.34 ReVLdeQWdRcWRUV RQ WKe RWKeU KaQd adYRcaWe aORQJ ZLWK bURadeU cRQVWLWXeQcLeV OLNe SUacWLcLQJ SK\VLcLaQVWKURXJK YaULRXV RUJaQL]aWLRQV VXcK aV WKe GeQeUaO MedLcaO CRXQcLO, BULWLVK MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQ(BMA) aQd DRcWRUV VRWe.35.36.37 ReceQW SURWeVWV b\ BMA KLJKOLJKW a QeZ WUeQd WRZaUdV PLOLWaQc\LQ WKeLU adYRcac\ SURceVV a WUeQd cRQWUaVWLQJ WR PaNLVWaQ. 38.39SRPe Ne\ LVVXeV WKaW WKe MSaRD LQ WKe UK KaYe SeUVLVWeQWO\ adYRcaWed IRU aUe beWWeU ZRUNLQJcRQdLWLRQV, UedXced ZRUNLQJ KRXUV, aQd WKe RYeUaOO ZeOO-beLQJ RI PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV. ReSRUWVRI MXQLRU dRcWRUV daWe bacN WR WKe 1980V IRU ORQJ ZRUNLQJ KRXUV. ReceQWO\, LQ OcWRbeU 2024, WKeUeZaV a VWULNe b\ cRQVXOWaQWV aQd MXQLRU dRcWRUV WaUJeWLQJ WKe NHS IRU Sa\ UeVWRUaWLRQ.40.41MRYePeQWV OLNe WKe 2011 dRcWRUV' VWULNe aJaLQVW SeQVLRQ cKaQJeV aQd WKe 2016¶V LPSOePeQWaWLRQRI WKe MXQLRU dRcWRUV' cRQWUacW ZKLcK BMA cRQWeVWed WLOO 2019, KLJKOLJKW WKe eQdXULQJ cKaOOeQJeVaQd WeQVLRQV ZLWKLQ WKe PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQ UeJaUdLQJ cRPSeQVaWLRQ aQd cRQWUacWXaO WeUPV.42.43TKeUe KaV aOVR beeQ acWLYLVP aURXQd LVVXeV SeUWaLQLQJ WR WKe RYeUaOO KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\ V\VWePaQd ZeOObeLQJ RI WKe SXbOLc. SaYe RXU NHS UaOO\ LQ 2012 LV RQe VXcK caVe LQ ZKLcK BMASURWeVWed aJaLQVW WKe HeaOWK aQd SRcLaO CaUe BLOO WR VKRZcaVe WKeLU RSSRVLWLRQ WR VXbVWaQWLaOcKaQJeV LQ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ aQd deOLYeU\ RI KeaOWK VeUYLceV LQ WKe UK.44 ReceQWO\, WKeUe aOVR KaYebeeQ acWLYe dLVcXVVLRQV RQ WKe VWUXcWXUe RI WUaLQLQJ, cXUULcXOXP cKaQJeV, aQd cRQceUQV abRXW WKe17TXaOLW\ RI edXcaWLRQ WR PeeW WKe eYROYLQJ dePaQdV RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU, aORQJ ZLWKKLJKOLJKWLQJ dLVSaULWLeV LQ KeaOWK RXWcRPeV aPRQJ bOacN aQd PLQRULW\ eWKQLc.45USA: TKe KLVWRU\ RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd SK\VLcLaQ WUaLQeeV LQ WKe USA UeIOecWV a MRXUQe\ RILQcUeaVLQJ acWLYLVP, beJLQQLQJ ZLWK WKe AVVRcLaWLRQ RI IQWeUQeV aQd MedLcaO SWXdeQWV (AIMS) LQWKe 1930V, ZKLcK adYRcaWed IRU KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUPV aQd cXUULcXOaU cKaQJeV.46 AIMS IacedVcUXWLQ\ aQd RSSRVLWLRQ, SaUWLcXOaUO\ dXULQJ WKe 1950V ZKeQ LWV OeIWLVW aIILOLaWLRQV ZeUe cRQWeVWedb\ WKe APeULcaQ MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQ (AMA).46-48 TKe IRUPaWLRQ RI WKe CRPPLWWee RI IQWeUQVaQd ReVLdeQWV (CIR) LQ WKe 1970V PaUNed a SLYRWaO WXUQ, VROLdLI\LQJ UeVLdeQW SK\VLcLaQV'adYRcac\ IRU beWWeU ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV aQd IaLU Sa\.49 DeVSLWe LQLWLaO UeVLVWaQce aQd OeJaOcKaOOeQJeV, VXcK aV WKe 1976 NaWLRQaO LabRU ReOaWLRQV BRaUd UXOLQJ aJaLQVW UeVLdeQWXQLRQL]aWLRQ, CIR acKLeYed VLJQLILcaQW UeIRUPV LQ ZRUN KRXUV IROORZLQJ WKe WUaJLc deaWK RI LLbb\ZLRQ.50-51 TKe COVID-19 SaQdePLc IXUWKeU KLJKOLJKWed WKe PedLcaO V\VWeP'V VWUaLQV, OeadLQJ WR aVXUJe LQ CIR PePbeUVKLS aQd a UeQeZed IRcXV RQ KeaOWKcaUe adYRcac\.52SRPe PRYePeQWV LQ WKe OaWe 20WK ceQWXU\, VXcK aV UeVLdeQW ZRUN KRXUV UeIRUP aQd adYRcac\ IRUJUadXaWe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ IXQdLQJ, UeIOecW RQJRLQJ eIIRUWV b\ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd UeVLdeQWV WRVKaSe SROLcLeV addUeVVLQJ WKeLU edXcaWLRQ, ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV, aQd SaWLeQW caUe.53-55 IQ Ma\ 2023,PePbeUV RI CIR RUJaQL]ed a 3-da\ VWULNe SURWeVWLQJ Sa\ dLVSaULWLeV, XOWLPaWeO\ UeacKLQJ aWeQWaWLYe deaO ZLWK VaOaU\ LQcUeaVeV WR addUeVV WKe Sa\ dLVSaULW\.56 TKe LQWeUVecWLRQaOLW\ RI SROLWLcaOacWLYLVP ZLWK MSaRD'V eQJaJePeQW LQ VRcLeWaO cKaOOeQJeV LV eYLdeQW WKURXJK YaULRXV SURWeVWVaJaLQVW SROLce bUXWaOLW\ aQd UacLaO LQMXVWLce LQ 2014.57.58.59181.3.4 Role of MSaRD in healWhcare polic\ processes in SoXWh AsiaIQ LMICV, VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LV deeSO\ LQIOXeQced b\ KLVWRULcaO, LQVWLWXWLRQaO, aQd SROLWLcaO IacWRUV,LQcOXdLQJ WKe LPSacW RI cRORQLaOLVP aQd SRVW-cRORQLaO JRYeUQaQce. SWXdeQWV LQ LMICV RIWeQ VeeWKePVeOYeV aV KeLUV WR a OeJac\ RI UeVLVWaQce, URRWed LQ WKeLU acWLYe SaUWLcLSaWLRQ LQ LQdeSeQdeQcePRYePeQWV. TKLV KLVWRULcaO LQYROYePeQW KaV Oed WR a OaVWLQJ VeQVe RI SROLWLcaO eIILcac\, PaNLQJVWXdeQWV SLYRWaO acWRUV LQ SROLWLcaO acWLYLVP.60India: TKURXJKRXW IQdLa'V KLVWRU\, VWXdeQW PRYePeQWV KaYe SOa\ed a cUXcLaO UROe LQ WKe cRXQWU\'VVRcLaO aQd SROLWLcaO eYROXWLRQ.61.62 IQ WKe cRORQLaO SeULRd, WKeVe PRYePeQWV, PaLQO\ Oed b\XSSeU-caVWe aQd cOaVV VWXdeQWV, ZeUe cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ cRQIURQWaWLRQaO WacWLcV aJaLQVW BULWLVKUXOe.61.62 IQ cRQWUaVW, WKe SRVW-LQdeSeQdeQce eUa VaZ a dLYeUVLILcaWLRQ LQ WKe VWXdeQW SRSXOaWLRQdXe WR WKe e[SaQVLRQ RI XQLYeUVLWLeV, OeadLQJ WR a VKLIW WRZaUdV PRUe SeaceIXO SURWeVWV, deVSLWeVRPe cRQWLQXed YLROeQce. TKe QaWXUe RI VWXdeQW acWLYLVP LQ IQdLa aOVR YaULeV acURVV dLIIeUeQWUeJLRQV, UeIOecWLQJ WKe dLYeUVe cKaUacWeU RI VWXdeQW eQJaJePeQW LQ IQdLa'V eYROYLQJ acWLYLVPOaQdVcaSe.61SLPLOaUO\, WKe UROe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ IQdLa aOVR KaYe eYROYed RYeUWLPe. SLWXaWed LQ WKecRQWe[W RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ IQdLa, MSaRD LQ WKe SaVW LQYROYed LQ bRWK VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aQdacWLYLVP aV eYLdeQW b\ WKe ILUVW VWXdeQWV¶ VWULNe LQ XQdLYLded IQdLa WRRN SOace LQ 1920 LQ KLQJEdZaUd MedLcaO CROOeJe, LaKRUe, aJaLQVW acadePLc dLVcULPLQaWLRQ beWZeeQ IQdLaQ aQd EQJOLVKSXSLOV.62 HRZeYeU, cXUUeQWO\ MSaRD PaLQO\ ceQWeU WKeLU adYRcac\ aURXQd KeaOWKcaUe LVVXeV.63SRPe Ne\ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ IQdLa VXcK aV WKe FedeUaWLRQ RI ReVLdeQW DRcWRUV¶AVVRcLaWLRQ (FORDA), FedeUaWLRQ RI AOO IQdLa MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQ, aQd IQdLaQ MedLcaO19AVVRcLaWLRQ - JXQLRU DRcWRUV¶ NeWZRUN, KaYe SOa\ed a VLJQLILcaQW UROe LQ adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKe ULJKWVaQd ZeOO-beLQJ RI PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV.63 TKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV addUeVV LVVXeV VXcK aVKaUaVVPeQW, abXVe, aQd QeJOecW RI UeVLdeQWV, KaYe acWLYeO\ eQJaJed LQ PRbLOL]aWLRQ eIIRUWV,XWLOL]LQJ VRcLaO PedLa WR aPSOLI\ WKeLU RXWUeacK.64-66 EQVXULQJ WKe VaIeW\ RI dRcWRUV, SaUWLcXOaUO\SURWecWLRQ aJaLQVW YLROeQW aWWacNV, KaV beeQ a cRQVLVWeQW SULRULW\ IRU WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV. 64-66CRQceUQV abRXW VWaIILQJ VKRUWaJeV, KLJK SaWLeQW YROXPeV, aQd LQadeTXaWe LQYeVWPeQW LQ WKe KeaOWKVecWRU KaYe beeQ LdeQWLILed aV IacWRUV cRQWULbXWLQJ WR SaWLeQW dLVVaWLVIacWLRQ aQd SRWeQWLaOeVcaOaWLRQV RI YLROeQce aJaLQVW KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV. TKe JURXSV KaYe UeVSRQded ZLWK VWUaWeJLcacWLRQV, LQcOXdLQJ WRNeQ VWULNeV aQd dePaQdV IRU a SURWecWLYe acW IURP WKe ceQWUaOJRYeUQPeQW.64-66 AdYRcaWLQJ IRU LPSURYePeQWV LQ ZRUN KRXUV, Sa\, aQd beQeILWV KaV beeQ aceQWUaO IRcXV. NRWabO\, FORDA RUcKeVWUaWed a VLJQLILcaQW VWULNe LQ 2015, VSaUNLQJ a dLaORJXeZLWK KeaOWK PLQLVWU\ RIILcLaOV.67 IQ 2021 aQd 2022, FORDA aQd RWKeU RUJaQL]aWLRQV RUJaQL]edVeYeUaO VRcLaO PedLa-dULYeQ SURWeVWV aQd VWULNeV aJaLQVW LVVXeV ZLWK WKe NaWLRQaO EQWUaQce cXPEOLJLbLOLW\ TeVW PRVWJUadXaWe, IRcXVLQJ RQ deOa\V LQ cRXQVeOLQJ, caOOV IRU e[aP SRVWSRQePeQW, aQddePaQdV IRU e[WeQded eOLJLbLOLW\ cULWeULa.68-71Bangladesh: SLPLOaU WR IQdLa, WKe bURadeU VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ BaQJOadeVK aOVR VKRZ aQ LQWeUSOa\RI VWXdeQW UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ aQd acWLYLVP WKaW LV ZeOO LQWeUWZLQed ZLWK WKe cRXQWU\'V QaWLRQaO SROLWLcV.HLVWRULcaOO\ VWXdeQWV KaYe SOa\ed a VLJQLILcaQW UROe LQ PaMRU VRcLaO PRYePeQWV VXcK aV WKeLLbeUaWLRQ VWUXJJOe LQ 1971 aQd WKe UeVWRUaWLRQ RI SaUOLaPeQWaU\ dePRcUac\ LQ WKe eaUO\ 1990V.LLNe RWKeU eQWLWLeV VXcK aV OabRUeUV, QRQ-JRYeUQPeQWaO RUJaQL]aWLRQV aQd UeOLJLRXV JURXSV,VWXdeQWV aOVR ePSOR\ adYRcac\ WacWLcV VXcK aV JeQeUaO VWULNeV (KaUWaO), bORcNadeV, UaOOLeV,PaUcKeV, KXPaQ cKaLQV, VLW-LQV, KXQJeU VWULNeV, YLJLOV, VLeJeV aQd cKaUJeV.72 IQ WKe cRQWe[W RI WKe20cRXQWU\'V OaUJeU VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, MSaRD UROe LQ SROLc\ SURceVVeV aOVR WaNe WKe VaPe dLUecWLRQ,aYaLOLQJ WKe VaPe VWUaWeJLeV WR adYaQce WKeLU cRQceUQ RQ LVVXeV OLNe OacN RI edXcaWLRQaO UeVRXUceVRU LQcUeaVed edXcaWLRQ Wa[, RQOLQe edXcaWLRQ aQd Iee ZaLYeU dXULQJ COVID-19, VaIeW\ aQdVecXULW\ RI KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV, ORZ VaOaULeV aQd cRPSeQVaWLRQ, aQd JRYeUQPeQW SROLcLeV RQKeaOWKcaUe VXcK aV LQcUeaVLQJ WKe LQWeUQVKLS SeULRd IURP RQe \eaU WR WZR \eaUV.72-79IQ JXO\ aQd AXJXVW 2023, Oed b\ MSaRD, a 10-da\ SURWeVW eUXSWed LQ BaQJOadeVK IROORZLQJ aWUaJLc accLdeQW RQ JXO\ 29, ZKeUe WZR \RXQJ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV ZeUe NLOOed LQ a bXV Uace QeaU WKeAUPed FRUceV MedLcaO CROOeJe LQ KXUPLWROa. TKe LQcLdeQW aQd WKe dLVPLVVLYe UeVSRQVe IURP WKeSKLSSLQJ MLQLVWeU aQd TUaQVSRUW OeadeU, ZKR WULYLaOL]ed WKe WUaJed\, VSaUNed ZLdeVSUead SXbOLcRXWUaJe, aPSOLILed WKURXJK VRcLaO PedLa.80 TKe SURWeVWV JaLQed PRPeQWXP RQ JXO\ 30, ZLWKVWXdeQWV dePaQdLQJ WKe UeVLJQaWLRQ RI WKe SKLSSLQJ MLQLVWeU aQd MXVWLce IRU WKe YLcWLPV, OeadLQJWR OaUJe-VcaOe dePRQVWUaWLRQV aQd URad bORcNadeV. TKe VLWXaWLRQ eVcaOaWed ZLWK cRQIURQWaWLRQVbeWZeeQ SURWeVWeUV aQd OaZ eQIRUcePeQW, UeVXOWLQJ LQ LQMXULeV aQd IXUWKeU SXbOLc XQUeVW.80 B\AXJXVW 1, SURWeVWeUV beJaQ cKecNLQJ YeKLcOeV IRU OLceQVeV, e[SRVLQJ QXPeURXV YLROaWLRQV. TKeJRYeUQPeQW UeVSRQded ZLWK aWWePSWV WR TXeOO WKe PRYePeQW, bXW SURWeVWV cRQWLQXed, e[SaQdLQJbe\RQd DKaNa. TeQVLRQV KeLJKWeQed ZLWK aWWacNV RQ SURWeVWeUV, deWeQWLRQV RI LQIOXeQWLaO ILJXUeV,aQd LQWeUQeW VORZdRZQV, cXOPLQaWLQJ LQ VLJQLILcaQW cOaVKeV aQd LQMXULeV b\ AXJXVW 4.80 DeVSLWeWKe JRYeUQPeQW'V eIIRUWV WR cRQWURO WKe VLWXaWLRQ, LQcOXdLQJ deWaLQLQJ MRXUQaOLVWV aQd aSSURYLQJ acRQWURYeUVLaO dUaIW OaZ RQ URad VaIeW\, SURWeVWV SeUVLVWed, ZLWK RSSRVLWLRQ WR bRWK WKe OaZ'VOeQLeQc\ aQd WKe bURadeU LVVXeV RI URad VaIeW\ aQd JRYeUQaQce. TKe PRYePeQW beJaQ WR ZaQe b\AXJXVW 7, bXW LWV LPSacW cRQWLQXed WR UeVRQaWe, dUaZLQJ LQWeUQaWLRQaO cULWLcLVP aQd KLJKOLJKWLQJ21WKe cRPSOe[ LQWeUSOa\ RI SXbOLc dLVVeQW, JRYeUQPeQWaO UeVSRQVe, aQd WKe TXeVW IRU MXVWLce LQBaQJOadeVK.801.4 Gaps in Whe liWeraWXreTKe e[LVWLQJ OLWeUaWXUe'V OLPLWaWLRQV RQ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ, SaUWLcXOaUO\ SRVW WKe1984 baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, XQdeUOLQe a bURadeU cKaOOeQJe LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ UeVeaUcK. WKLOeLW'V XQOLNeO\ WR ILQd e[KaXVWLYe KLVWRULcaO accRXQWV RI MSaRD LQ aQ\ cRQWe[W, WKe caVe RI PaNLVWaQXQLTXeO\ LOOXVWUaWeV WKe SRWeQWLaO LPSacW aQd LPSRUWaQce RI WKeVe eQWLWLeV LQ VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUeSROLcLeV. TKe OacN RI cRPSUeKeQVLYe UeVeaUcK LQWR WKe VWUaWeJLeV, UROeV, aQd LPSacWV RI MSaRD,eVSecLaOO\ LQ a SRVW-baQ eQYLURQPeQW, VLJQLILeV a PLVVed RSSRUWXQLW\ WR XQdeUVWaQd WKePecKaQLVPV RI SROLc\ adYRcac\ aQd UeIRUP. TKe eYROYLQJ OaQdVcaSe, PaUNed b\ WKe caOO WRUeYLYe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aQd WKe adYeQW RI dLJLWaO adYRcac\ WRROV, IXUWKeU ePSKaVL]eV WKe Qeed WRVcUXWLQL]e KRZ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV QaYLJaWe aQd LQIOXeQce WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU. TKLV aQaO\VLVLV QRW MXVW abRXW ILOOLQJ a KLVWRULcaO JaS bXW abRXW JUaVSLQJ WKe VLJQLILcaQW, \eW RIWeQ RYeUORRNed,LQIOXeQce RI RUJaQL]ed adYRcac\ RQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ PaNLQJ. UQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKe d\QaPLcV RIMSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ caQ SURYLde cULWLcaO LQVLJKWV LQWR WKeLU SRWeQWLaO UROeV aQd VWUaWeJLeV, VKeddLQJOLJKW RQ WKe bURadeU LPSOLcaWLRQV IRU KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ deYeORSPeQW aQd UeIRUP. TKeUeIRUe,e[SORULQJ WKeVe dLPeQVLRQV LV eVVeQWLaO IRU a QXaQced cRPSUeKeQVLRQ RI MSaRD'V cRQWePSRUaU\UeOeYaQce aQd eIILcac\ LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ adYRcac\, eVSecLaOO\ LQ cRQWe[WV ZKeUe SROLWLcaO aQddLJLWaO OaQdVcaSeV aUe UaSLdO\ cKaQJLQJ.221.5 RaWionaleTKe UaWLRQaOe IRU WKe VWXd\ RQ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ, eVSecLaOO\ SRVW WKe 1984 baQ RQVWXdeQW SROLWLcV, LV SUedLcaWed RQ WKe Qeed WR XQdeUVWaQd WKe QXaQced UROe WKeVe eQWLWLeV SOa\ LQKeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ adYRcac\ aQd UeIRUP. TKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ KaV Oed WR aVLJQLILcaQW YRLd LQ WKe KLVWRULcaO QaUUaWLYe aQd aQaO\VLV RI MSaRD'V cRQWULbXWLRQV, ZKLcK OLNeO\e[WeQdV WR WKeLU LQIOXeQce RQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLcLeV. TKe VWXd\'V UaWLRQaOe UeYROYeV aURXQd VeYeUaONe\ SRLQWV:HisWorical conWe[W and change: TKe baQ'V LPSRVLWLRQ LQ 1984 PaUNed a SLYRWaO cKaQJe LQ WKeSROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQW RI VWXdeQWV aQd SURIeVVLRQaOV LQ WKe PedLcaO ILeOd. TKLV SeULRd RI SROLWLcaOdRUPaQc\ PaNeV LW cULWLcaO WR e[SORUe KRZ MSaRD adaSWed WKeLU VWUaWeJLeV IRU adYRcac\ LQ acRQVWUaLQed eQYLURQPeQW aQd KRZ WKeVe VWUaWeJLeV eYROYed ZLWK WKe LQWeJUaWLRQ RI dLJLWaOadYRcac\ WRROV.ImpacW on healWhcare polic\: MSaRD KaYe KLVWRULcaOO\ beeQ cUXcLaO IRU OeadeUVKLS aQdadYRcac\ LQ KeaOWKcaUe, SOa\LQJ UROeV WKaW OLNeO\ e[WeQd be\RQd WKeLU LPPedLaWe acadePLc aQdcOLQLcaO VeWWLQJV. B\ e[aPLQLQJ WKe e[WeQW aQd QaWXUe RI WKeLU LQIOXeQce, WKe VWXd\ aLPV WRKLJKOLJKW WKeLU cRQWULbXWLRQV WR VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLcLeV, LdeQWLI\LQJ JaSV LQ VeUYLce deOLYeU\,aQd adYRcaWLQJ IRU UeIRUPV.ConWemporar\ ReleYance: WLWK WKe JORbaO VKLIW WRZaUdV PRUe SaUWLcLSaWRU\ IRUPV RISROLc\-PaNLQJ aQd WKe UeVXUJeQce RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, WKeUe LV a UeQeZed LQWeUeVW LQ XQdeUVWaQdLQJKRZ MSaRD caQ OeYeUaJe WKeLU SRVLWLRQ WR LQIOXeQce KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\. TKLV LQcOXdeV WKeLU23SRWeQWLaO WR XVe dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV IRU adYRcac\, QeWZRUNLQJ, aQd PRbLOL]LQJ VXSSRUW IRU KeaOWKSROLc\ UeIRUPV.Broader ImplicaWions for HealWhcare Polic\ DeYelopmenW: TKe VWXd\ e[aPLQeV WKe UROe aQdLPSacW RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ WR SURYLde LQVLJKWV WKaW cRXOd JXLde KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ deYeORSPeQWaQd UeIRUP VWUaWeJLeV. B\ aQaO\]LQJ WKLV VSecLILc cRQWe[W, WKe ILQdLQJV aLP WR LQIRUP aQdLQIOXeQce VLPLOaU KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV JORbaOO\, eQKaQcLQJ SROLc\-PaNLQJ SURceVVeV aQdadYRcaWLQJ IRU eIIecWLYe UeIRUPV acURVV dLIIeUeQW UeJLRQV.IQ VXPPaU\, WKe UaWLRQaOe IRU WKLV VWXd\ KLQJeV RQ e[SORULQJ WKe KLVWRULcaO, cXUUeQW, aQd SRWeQWLaOLPSacW RI MSaRD LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ adYRcac\ LQ PaNLVWaQ. IW aLPV WR ILOO a VLJQLILcaQW JaS LQWKe OLWeUaWXUe aQd SURYLde a cRPSUeKeQVLYe XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI KRZ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV cRQWULbXWeWR VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLcLeV, WKXV RIIeULQJ YaOXabOe LQVLJKWV IRU SROLc\PaNeUV, KeaOWKcaUeSURIeVVLRQaOV, aQd adYRcac\ JURXSV.1.6 Research aimTKe aLP RI WKLV VWXd\ LV WR e[aPLQe WKe KLVWRULcaO deYeORSPeQW, cXUUeQW d\QaPLcV, aQd LPSacW RIMSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV RQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ IUaPeZRUN LQ PaNLVWaQ. IW VeeNV WR aQaO\]e WKeeYROXWLRQ RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKe WUaQVLWLRQ IURP dePRcUaWLc eQJaJePeQW WR WKecKaOOeQJeV SRVed b\ baQV aQd WKe VKLIW WRZaUdV dLJLWaO acWLYLVP. TKe VWXd\ aLPV WR XQdeUVWaQdKRZ MSaRD1. QaYLJaWe WKeVe cRPSOe[ VRcLR-SROLWLcaO eQYLURQPeQWV2. OeYeUaJe dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV IRU adYRcac\24WR VKaSe KeaOWK SROLc\ debaWeV aQd RXWcRPeV. TKURXJK WKeVe WZR aLPV, WKe VWXd\ deYeORSVbURadeU LQVLJKWV abRXW WKe UROe RI MSaRD'V adYRcac\ LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV, bRWK ZLWKLQPaNLVWaQ aQd LQ WKe cRQWe[W RI JORbaO KeaOWK SROLc\, SaUWLcXOaUO\ LQ LMICV. TKe VWXd\ VKLQeV aOLJKW RQ WKe VLJQLILcaQW LQIOXeQce RI VWXdeQW acWLYLVP RQ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ, KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV,aQd WKe RYeUaOO KeaOWK aQd ZeOO-beLQJ RI SRSXOaWLRQV, aQd cRQWULbXWeV WR WKe OLWeUaWXUe RQ WKe UROeRI KeaOWK ZRUNeU UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ JORbaO KeaOWK SROLc\.1.7 Research qXesWionsFROORZLQJ aUe WKe WZR UeVeaUcK TXeVWLRQV RI WKLV VWXd\:1. WhaW are Whe cXrrenW roles and characWerisWics of organi]aWions represenWingMSaRD in PakisWan aW Whe proYincial and naWional leYel?L. WKaW LV WKe VWUXcWXUe RI WKeVe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV aQd KRZ dReV eacK RI WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV IXQcWLRQ LQ WKe bacNdURS RI WKe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV baQ RI 1984.LL. WKaW aUe WKe adYRcac\ LVVXeV, aJeQdaV aQd VWUaWeJLeV IRU eacK RI WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ WKe cXUUeQW dLJLWaOL]ed eUa?2. HoZ did proWesWing docWors and medical sWXdenWs frame Wheir opposiWion Wo Whe NLEin PakisWan in 2021?L. WKaW dR WKeVe IUaPLQJ aSSURacKeV cRQYe\ UeJaUdLQJ WKe VWUXcWXUaO YXOQeUabLOLW\RI UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV aQd PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aV ZRUNeUV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe aQdPedLcaO edXcaWLRQ V\VWeP?LL. WKaW LQVLJKWV dReV WKLV SURWeVW SURYLde abRXW WKe SRVLWLRQ RI PaNLVWaQL dRcWRUV LQ aJORbaO cRQWe[W?251.8 SWXd\ objecWiYesTKe RbMecWLYe RI WKLV VWXd\ LV WR cRPSUeKeQd WKe LQWeUWZLQed UeOaWLRQVKLS beWZeeQ MSaRDSROLWLcV aQd KeaOWK SROLc\ LQ PaNLVWaQ, cRQVLdeULQJ WKe KLVWRULcaO VLJQLILcaQce RI VWXdeQW acWLYLVPaQd WKe eYROYLQJ VWUaWeJLeV LQ WKe dLJLWaO aJe. IW VeeNV WR SURYLde a cRPSUeKeQVLYe aQaO\VLV WKaWQRW RQO\ e[SOaLQV WKe ORcaO VLJQLILcaQce RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLcLeVbXW aOVR cRQWULbXWeV WR WKe JORbaO dLVcRXUVe RQ WKe SaUWLcLSaWLRQ RI PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV LQ SROLc\adYRcac\ ZLWKLQ dLYeUVe SROLWLcaO aQd VRcLaO cRQWe[WV WKURXJK WKe IROORZLQJ:1. IQYeVWLJaWe WKe KLVWRULcaO WUaMecWRU\ RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ, IRcXVLQJ RQ WKeWUaQVLWLRQ IURP dePRcUaWLc URRWV WR WKe LPSRVLWLRQ RI baQV, aQd WKe VXbVeTXeQWadaSWaWLRQV ZLWKLQ VWXdeQW acWLYLVP, VSecLILcaOO\ aPRQJ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV.2. E[aPLQe WKe cXUUeQW IXQcWLRQLQJ RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV ZLWKLQ WKe QXaQcedeQYLURQPeQW RI cOaLPed QRQ-SaUWLVaQ acWLYLVP, aQd WKe UROe RI dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV LQIRVWeULQJ cRPPXQLcaWLRQ, PRbLOL]aWLRQ, aQd adYRcac\ eIIRUWV.3. IQYeVWLJaWe WKe Za\V LQ ZKLcK MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV SaUWLcLSaWe LQ aQd LQIOXeQce WKeKeaOWK SROLc\-PaNLQJ SURceVV LQ PaNLVWaQ, ZLWK WKe JRaO RI LdeQWLI\LQJ WKe VWUXcWXUaOcKaOOeQJeV WKe\ eQcRXQWeU aQd WKe VWUaWeJLeV WKe\ ePSOR\ IRU adYRcac\ RI LPSURYePeQWVLQ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ, KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV, aQd SXbOLc KeaOWK RXWcRPeV.4. E[WeQd WKe LQVLJKWV JaLQed IURP WKe PaNLVWaQL cRQWe[W WR a bURadeU JORbaO IUaPeZRUN,eVSecLaOO\ LQ LMICV, WR XQdeUVWaQd WKe UROeV aQd LPSacWV RI KeaOWK ZRUNeU UeSUeVeQWaWLYeRUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ LQIOXeQcLQJ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV RQ a ZLdeU VcaOe.26ChapWer 2: MeWhodolog\2.1 Research design and meWhodological approachTKLV VWXd\ ePSOR\V a PL[ed-PeWKRdV aSSURacK (TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV aQd QaWXUaO OaQJXaJeSURceVVLQJ) WR e[SORUe WKe UROe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ WKe KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVV LQ PaNLVWaQXVLQJ VRcLaO PedLa.81.82 TKe cRUe daWa IRU RXU VWXd\ cRQVLVWV RI VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV (FacebRRN aQdTZLWWeU/X) SRVWV IURP MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ dXULQJ WKe VSecLILed SeULRd IRU eacK RQ (dLVcXVVed LQVecWLRQ 2.3). TKe cRQWeQW RI WKeVe SRVWV LQcOXded RIILcLaO SUeVV UeOeaVeV, aQQRXQcePeQWV,dRcXPeQWV, QeZV aUWLcOeV, aQd LQWeUYLeZV LQ bRWK VRcLaO aQd PaVV PedLa IRU daWa aQaO\VLV.AQaO\]LQJ WKeVe VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV aOORZ XV WR e[aPLQe WKe LVVXeV RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP aQdIUaPLQJ RI WKeVe LVVXeV b\ WKe adYRcaWLQJ KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNIRUce.83 WLWK dLJLWaOL]aWLRQ, VRcLaOPedLa KaV becRPe a cUXcLaO UeVeaUcK WRRO IRU WKRVe aLPLQJ WR XQdeUVWaQd KRZ SaUWLcLSaQWV LQSURWeVW aQd SROLWLcaO PRYePeQWV SeUceLYe aQd aUWLcXOaWe LVVXeV.84 TKLV SOaWIRUP LV eVSecLaOO\VLJQLILcaQW IRU KeaOWK UeVeaUcK, RIIeULQJ LQVLJKWV LQWR cRPPXQLW\ SeUVSecWLYeV RQ KeaOWK LVVXeVaQd SULRULWLeV.85 TKe UeOeYaQce RI VRcLaO PedLa WR RXU VWXd\ LV XQdeUVcRUed b\ LWV ZLdeVSUead XVeaPRQJ MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ ZKR OeYeUaJe WKe SOaWIRUP IRU RUJaQL]LQJ aQd SURPRWLQJ SURWeVWacWLYLWLeV.2.2 PosiWionaliW\ sWaWemenWHROdLQJ a BacKeORU'V LQ DeQWaO SXUJeU\ aQd a MaVWeU RI PKLORVRSK\ LQ PXbOLc HeaOWK, cRXSOedZLWK P\ decade-ORQJ cOLQLcaO e[SeULeQce aQd WeacKLQJ e[SeULeQce RI ILYe \eaUV aW a deQWaO VcKRROLQ PaNLVWaQ, SURIRXQdO\ LQIRUPV P\ aQaO\VLV RI WKe UROe RI MSaRD LQ WKe PaNLVWaQ KeaOWK SROLc\OaQdVcaSe. M\ ILUVWKaQd e[SeULeQceV aQd RbVeUYaWLRQV RI WKe VWUXcWXUaO LQcRPSeWeQcLeV ZLWKLQ WKe27KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, cRXSOed ZLWK WKe cKaOOeQJeV Iaced b\ MSaRD, SURYLde Pe ZLWK a XQLTXeSeUVSecWLYe WKaW VKaSeV bRWK WKe PRWLYaWLRQ aQd dLUecWLRQ RI WKLV UeVeaUcK.HaYLQJ beeQ edXcaWed LQ PaNLVWaQ'V KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, I KaYe QaYLJaWed WKe VaPe SaWKZa\V WKaWcXUUeQW MSaRD WUaYeUVe, e[SeULeQcLQJ WKe V\VWePLc baUULeUV aQd edXcaWLRQaO cKaOOeQJeV WKaWLPSacW WKeLU SURIeVVLRQaO MRXUQe\. M\ ZRUN e[SeULeQce ZLWKLQ WKLV cRQWe[W KaV IXUWKeU e[SRVedPe WR WKe SUacWLcaO UeaOLWLeV RI KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\, ZKeUe VWUXcWXUaO LQcRPSeWeQcLeV RIWeQ KLQdeUWKe SURYLVLRQ RI TXaOLW\ caUe aQd WKe SURIeVVLRQaO deYeORSPeQW RI KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV. AV aWeacKeU, I KaYe eQJaJed dLUecWO\ ZLWK WUaLQeeV aQd MSaRD, XQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKeLU aVSLUaWLRQV,IUXVWUaWLRQV, aQd WKe V\VWePLc LVVXeV WKaW aIIecW WKeLU WUaLQLQJ aQd IXWXUe UROeV aV KeaOWKcaUeSURYLdeUV. TKLV LQVLdeU SeUVSecWLYe aOORZV Pe WR ePSaWKL]e ZLWK WKe VXbMecWV RI WKLV VWXd\ aQdUecRJQL]e WKe QXaQceV RI WKeLU e[SeULeQceV aQd VWUXJJOeV. IW aOVR VeQVLWL]eV Pe WR WKe cRPSOe[LWLeVRI KeaOWK SROLc\ adYRcac\ LQ PaNLVWaQ, ZKeUe YaULRXV VRcLR-SROLWLcaO aQd ecRQRPLc IacWRUVLQWeUVecW WR VKaSe WKe KeaOWKcaUe OaQdVcaSe. M\ SRVLWLRQaOLW\, WKeUeIRUe, QRW RQO\ eQULcKeV WKeVWXd\ ZLWK cRQWe[WXaO XQdeUVWaQdLQJ bXW aOVR JXLdeV WKe UeVeaUcK WRZaUdV aUeaV WKaW aUe cULWLcaOO\UeOeYaQW \eW SRVVLbO\ RYeUORRNed LQ bURadeU aQaO\VeV.HRZeYeU, I acNQRZOedJe WKaW P\ cORVe WLeV WR WKe KeaOWKcaUe cRPPXQLW\ LQ PaNLVWaQ PLJKWLQWURdXce bLaVeV LQWR WKe UeVeaUcK SURceVV. TR PLWLJaWe WKLV, I ZaV cRPPLWWed WR ePSOR\LQJULJRURXV PeWKRdRORJLcaO aSSURacKeV aQd PaLQWaLQLQJ UeIOe[LYLW\ WKURXJKRXW WKe VWXd\. TKLVLQYROYeV cRQWLQXRXVO\ e[aPLQLQJ KRZ P\ e[SeULeQceV aQd SeUVSecWLYeV LQIOXeQce WKe UeVeaUcKSURceVV, IURP daWa cROOecWLRQ WR aQaO\VLV aQd LQWeUSUeWaWLRQ. BXW I aOVR beOLeYe WKaW P\ SRVLWLRQ aVbRWK aQ LQVLdeU aQd a UeVeaUcKeU SOaceV Pe LQ a XQLTXe SRVLWLRQ ZLWK a UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ WR bULdJe28JaSV LQ XQdeUVWaQdLQJ beWZeeQ MSaRD, SROLc\-PaNeUV, aQd WKe bURadeU SXbOLc. IW eQabOeV Pe WRWUaQVOaWe WKe OLYed e[SeULeQceV RI MSaRD LQWR LQVLJKWV WKaW caQ LQIRUP SROLc\ dLVcXVVLRQV aQdcRQWULbXWe WR WKe IRUPXOaWLRQ RI VWUaWeJLeV WKaW addUeVV WKe XQdeUO\LQJ LVVXeV ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ'VKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP.IQ VKRUW, P\ SRVLWLRQaOLW\ aV a KeaOWKcaUe SURIeVVLRQaO ZLWK e[WeQVLYe e[SeULeQce LQ PaNLVWaQ'VKeaOWKcaUe VecWRU SURYLdeV a IRXQdaWLRQ RI ePSaWK\, LQVLJKW, aQd cULWLcaO LQTXLU\ IRU WKLV VWXd\. IWdULYeV a UeVeaUcK aJeQda WKaW VeeNV QRW RQO\ WR dRcXPeQW aQd aQaO\]e bXW aOVR WR cRQWULbXWe WRPeaQLQJIXO cKaQJe LQ WKe KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVV, ZLWK a SaUWLcXOaU IRcXV RQ WKe UROe aQd cKaOOeQJeVRI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ.2.3 DaWa collecWionTZR VeWV RI VRcLaO PedLa daWa WKaW cRQWaLQed PXOWLSOe IRUPV RI daWa VXcK aV VRcLaO PedLa SRVWVZLWK aWWacKed SROLc\ dRcXPeQWV aQd SUeVV LQWeUYLeZV aQd QeZV aUWLcOeV LQ bRWK UUdX aQd EQJOLVKZeUe cROOecWed VeSaUaWeO\ IRU bRWK RQ.1 aQd RQ.2.2.3.1 RQ.1: Landscape of organi]aWions represenWing MSaRD in PakisWanMSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV ZeUe V\VWePaWLcaOO\ LdeQWLILed acURVV PaNLVWaQ aW WKe SURYLQcLaO aQdQaWLRQaO OeYeO, ZLWK a VSecLILc ePSKaVLV RQ WKeLU acWLYLW\ RQ VRcLaO PedLa SOaWIRUPV. TKe LQLWLaOVWeS LQYROYed cRQdXcWLQJ a PedLa VeaUcK WR XQdeUVWaQd ZKLcK JURXSV aUe UeIeUeQced LQ aUWLcOeV,aQd WKeQ VXSSOePeQWed WKLV ZLWK JURXSV WKaW KaYe a SUeVeQce RQ VRcLaO PedLa ZLWKLQ WKe OaVW VL[PRQWKV IURP Ma\ 1, 2023 WR OcWRbeU 30, 2023. IdeQWLILeUV LQ WKe SRVWV, VXcK aV ORJRV, SURPLQeQWPePbeUV, cRQWacWV, SKRWRV, aQd LQWeUYLeZV LQ PaVV PedLa RU QeZV aUWLcOeV, ZeUe XWLOL]ed WR29eVWabOLVK WKe aXWKeQWLcLW\ RI WKe VeOecWed SaJeV. TKe YeULILcaWLRQ RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV' VRcLaOPedLa SaJeV ZaV a cULWLcaO VWeS WR eQVXUe WKe UeOLabLOLW\ RI WKe daWa cROOecWed. TKLV SURceVVLQYROYed VeYeUaO Ne\ acWLRQV:DirecW OXWreach: I UeacKed RXW WR WKe adPLQLVWUaWRUV RI eacK VRcLaO PedLa SaJe WR cRQILUP LWVaXWKeQWLcLW\.VerificaWion of Claims: PaJeV WKaW cOaLPed WR be RIILcLaO ZeUe VcUXWLQL]ed IRU eYLdeQceVXSSRUWLQJ WKeLU aVVeUWLRQ. FRU LQVWaQce, PULYaWe MedLcaO SWXdeQWV UQLRQ PaNLVWaQ (PMSUP) KaV aYeULILed TZLWWeU SaJe, ZKLOe DRcWRUV ZaNe XS MRYePeQW (DWM), aQd YaULRXV YDA SaJeVe[SOLcLWO\ VWaWe WKe\ aUe RIILcLaO SaJeV.Cross-Referencing: TKe aXWKeQWLcLW\ RI WKe SaJeV aQd WKe OeadeUVKLS PeQWLRQed ZeUe IXUWKeUYeULILed WKURXJK WKeLU SUeVeQce LQ RWKeU UeVRXUceV. TKLV LQcOXded e[aPLQLQJ aQ\ IRUP RI OLQNbeWZeeQ WKeVe SaJeV, VXcK aV IROORZV RU PeQWLRQV RI eacK RWKeU, aV ZeOO aV WKeLU aSSeaUaQceV LQPaVV PedLa LQWeUYLeZV, QeZV aUWLcOeV, RU Zeb aUWLcOeV.E[clXsion of InaXWhenWic SoXrces: PaJeV LdeQWLILed aV dXSOLcaWeV RU WKRVe IaLOLQJ WR UeVSRQd WRWKe LQTXLULeV ZeUe e[cOXded IURP WKe VWXd\.TKLV cRPSUeKeQVLYe YeULILcaWLRQ SURceVV ZaV LQVWUXPeQWaO LQ eQVXULQJ WKe VeOecWed VRcLaO PedLaSaJeV ZeUe JeQXLQe aQd UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV. TKe WabOe beORZ VKRZV WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQV WKaW ZeUe VeOecWed IRU daWa cROOecWLRQ LQcOXded WKe IROORZLQJ aORQJ ZLWK WKe RIILcLaO30ZebVLWeV aQd WKe SRVWV cROOecWed IURP eacK RUJaQL]aWLRQ. IW'V LPSRUWaQW WR QRWe WKaW VRPe RI WKeVeZebVLWeV Pa\ be LQacWLYe, QeceVVLWaWLQJ UeOLaQce RQ aOWeUQaWLYe VRXUceV OLNe FacebRRN RU TZLWWeUIeedV IRU daWa cROOecWLRQ. SLQce WKe SRVWV ZeUe KaQd cROOecWed, UeSeaWed SRVWV ZLWK VLPLOaUPeaQLQJ RU LUUeOeYaQW SRVWV ZeUe e[cOXded dXULQJ daWa cROOecWLRQ.Table 1 - Social Media Pages of Whe MSaRD Organi]aWions InclXded in Whe SWXd\Organi]aWion PosWs CollecWed Official WebpagesPULYaWe MedLcaO SWXdeQWV UQLRQ PaNLVWaQ(PMSUP)204WZLWWeU.cRP/SPVXS_RIILcLaOIacebRRN.cRP/PMSUP.OIILcLaODRcWRUV WaNe-XS MRYePeQW (DWM) 70WZLWWeU.cRP/DWMOIILcLaOIacebRRN.cRP/DWMPaNLVWaQPURYLQcLaO DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ (PDA) 177WZLWWeU.cRP/PDA_KPIacebRRN.cRP/PDAKPKYRXQJ DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ (YDA) SLQdK 106WZLWWeU.cRP/YRXQJSLQdKIacebRRN.cRP/SURILOe.SKS?Ld=100070370040746&PLbe[WLd=ZbWKZL31Organi]aWion PosWs CollecWed Official WebpagesYRXQJ DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ (YDA) PXQMab 145WZLWWeU.cRP/SXQMab\daIacebRRN.cRP/YDAPRIILcLaOYRXQJ DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ (YDA) KK\beUPaNKWXQNKZa (KPK)212WZLWWeU.cRP/\daNS_RIILcLaOIacebRRN.cRP/YDAKPYRXQJ DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ (YDA)BaORcKLVWaQ187WZLWWeU.cRP/YdaBaORcKLVWaQIacebRRN.cRP/YDABaORcKLVWaQTRWaO 11012.3.2 RQ.2: IssXe framing b\ Whe ke\ sWakeholders (MSaRD)TKLV SaUW RI WKe daWa cROOecWLRQ ZaV cRQdXcWed b\ a WeaP Oed b\ DU. BURSK\ (RQe RI WKecRPPLWWee PePbeUV IRU WKLV MSc SURMecW), aV a SaUW RI a OaUJeU SURMecW abRXW SK\VLcLaQ WUaLQeeSURWeVWV LQ FUaQce, IQdLa, Me[LcR aQd PaNLVWaQ. TKURXJK aQ LQLWLaO UeYLeZ RI WZeeWV UeVSRQdLQJ WRNLE SURWeVWV LQ PaNLVWaQ, WKe UeVeaUcK WeaP LdeQWLILed 4 KaVKWaJV XVed PRVW IUeTXeQWO\ WR SURWeVWNLE beWZeeQ 11 MaUcK 2020 aQd 10 MaUcK 2022: #CKePLcaOSSUa\RQDRcWRUV, #ZeUeMecWNLE,#ReVLJQAOLRa]aPMC, #PURWeVWAJaLQVWNLE. TKe WeaP XVed WKe AcadePLc TZLWWeU API WRcRQdXcW a UeWURVSecWLYe VeaUcK RI WKe eQWLUe SXbOLc WZeeW aUcKLYe XVLQJ WKeVe 4 KaVKWaJV. AcXVWRP P\WKRQ-VcULSWed daWa e[WUacWLRQ WRRO ZaV deYeORSed WR aJJUeJaWe aOO WZeeWV, aORQJ ZLWK32WKeLU PeWadaWa aQd XVeU LQIRUPaWLRQ, LQWR aQ LQLWLaO JSON ILOe. ReWZeeWV OacNLQJ RULJLQaO cRQWeQWZeUe RPLWWed IURP WKe aQaO\VLV (LW LV QRWeZRUWK\ WKaW ZKLOe a OaUJe SRUWLRQ RI WKe cROOecWed WZeeWVZeUe UeWZeeWV, WKe\ eacK LQcOXded VRPe IRUP RI addLWLRQaO cRPPeQWaU\). TKLV SURceVV aPaVVed aWRWaO RI 54,064 WZeeWV IURP PaNLVWaQ. SXbVeTXeQWO\, aQ RXWSXW ILOe cRQVLVWLQJ RI a UaQdRP VaPSOeRI 1,000 WZeeWV ZaV SUeSaUed IRU IXUWKeU LQ-deSWK TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV.2.4 DaWa managemenW and eWhical consideraWionsIQ WKLV VWXd\'V PeWKRdRORJ\, Ze SULRULWL]ed WKe eWKLcaO cRQVLdeUaWLRQ RI SURWecWLQJ WKe LdeQWLWLeV RIaOO LQdLYLdXaOV VXcK aV MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQ OeadeUV aQd aQ\ RWKeU Ne\ ILJXUeV. TR WKLV eQd, aOOTXaOLWaWLYe daWa ZaV de-LdeQWLILed beIRUe beLQJ XSORaded WR OQeDULYe IRU e[cOXVLYe acceVV b\ WKeUeVeaUcK VXSeUYLVRU\ cRPPLWWee. TKe de-LdeQWLILcaWLRQ SURceVV LQYROYed V\VWePaWLcaOO\ UeYLeZLQJSUeVV UeOeaVeV, aQQRXQcePeQWV, dRcXPeQWV, QeZV aUWLcOeV, aQd LQWeUYLeZ WUaQVcULSWV WR LdeQWLI\aQd UePRYe RU RbVcXUe aQ\ dLUecW LdeQWLILeUV, VXcK aV QaPeV aQd VSecLILc MRb WLWOeV. IQdLUecWLdeQWLILeUV WKaW cRXOd SRWeQWLaOO\ be XVed LQ cRPbLQaWLRQ ZLWK RWKeU LQIRUPaWLRQ WR LdeQWLI\LQdLYLdXaOV ZeUe aOWeUed. TKLV LQcOXded PRdLI\LQJ deWaLOV RI SUecLVe ORcaWLRQV, aQd e[acW daWeVPeQWLRQed LQ WKe cROOecWed PaWeULaOV. TKLV de-LdeQWLILcaWLRQ SURceVV ZaV QRW RQO\ a cUXcLaO VWeS LQeQVXULQJ WKe SULYac\ aQd cRQILdeQWLaOLW\ RI WKe LQdLYLdXaOV' LdeQWLWLeV bXW aOVR aLPed aW PLWLJaWLQJaQ\ SRWeQWLaO bLaVeV WKaW cRXOd LQIOXeQce WKe aQaO\VLV aQd ZULWLQJ SKaVeV dXe WR WKe UecRJQLWLRQ RIKLJK-SURILOe QaPeVTR PaLQWaLQ WKe LQWeJULW\ RI WKe daWa ZKLOe VaIeJXaUdLQJ WKe LdeQWLWLeV LQYROYed, I PeWLcXORXVO\PaQaJed aQ E[ceO VSUeadVKeeW WKaW OLQNed WKe de-LdeQWLILed cRdeV WR WKe acWXaO QaPeV. TKLVVSUeadVKeeW ZaV NeSW RIIOLQe RQ a OaSWRS WKaW ZaV SaVVZRUd-SURWecWed, eQVXULQJ aQ addLWLRQaO33Oa\eU RI VecXULW\. OQO\ I Kad acceVV WR WKLV VSUeadVKeeW ZaV VWULcWO\ OLPLWed WR Pe, IXUWKeUePSKaVL]LQJ WKe cRPPLWPeQW WR cRQILdeQWLaOLW\. TKLV aSSURacK ZaV WaNeQ WR baOaQce WKe Qeed IRUdaWa accXUac\ aQd cRPSOeWeQeVV ZLWK RXU eWKLcaO UeVSRQVLbLOLWLeV, eQVXULQJ WKaW WKe aQaO\VLVUePaLQV IRcXVed RQ WKe cRQWeQW aQd cRQWe[W RI WKe daWa, UaWKeU WKaQ WKe SRWeQWLaOO\ LQIOXeQWLaOLdeQWLWLeV RI WKe LQdLYLdXaOV PeQWLRQed.IQ UeceQW dLVcXVVLRQV aPRQJ LQWeUQeW UeVeaUcKeUV, WKeUe KaV beeQ aQ LQcUeaVed aWWeQWLRQ RQ WKeeWKLcaO cRQVLdeUaWLRQV RI XVLQJ RQOLQe SRVWV LQ UeVeaUcK SURMecWV, SaUWLcXOaUO\ UeJaUdLQJ WKeSURWecWLRQ RI LQdLYLdXaOV ZKRVe daWa LV XWLOL]ed.86-88 IQ WKe cRQWe[W RI WKe KeLJKWeQed eWKLcaOVcUXWLQ\ b\ LQWeUQeW UeVeaUcKeUV, a Ne\ eWKLcaO dLOePPa aULVeV IURP baOaQcLQJ WKe LQYaOXabOeLQVLJKWV JaLQed IURP aQaO\]LQJ RQOLQe SRVWV aJaLQVW WKe LPSeUaWLYe WR SURWecW LQdLYLdXaO SULYac\.89TKLV dLOePPa LV IXUWKeU cRPSRXQded b\ WKe SeUYaVLYe QaWXUe RI dLJLWaO IRRWSULQWV, ZKeUe WKe daWaLQdLYLdXaOV OeaYe RQOLQe caQ be bRWK UeYeaOLQJ aQd SeUPaQeQW.87-89 ReVeaUcKeUV aUe WKXV IacedZLWK WKe cKaOOeQJe RI QaYLJaWLQJ WKLV cRPSOe[ OaQdVcaSe, ZKeUe WKe e[WUacWLRQ RI PeaQLQJIXO daWaIRU VRcLeWaO beQeILW PXVW be ZeLJKed aJaLQVW WKe SRWeQWLaO IRU KaUP WKURXJK SULYac\ bUeacKeV RUPLVXVe RI LQIRUPaWLRQ.87-89 TKe XVe RI aXWRPaWed VcUaSLQJ aQd RWKeU daWa cROOecWLRQ PeWKRdV\LeOdV YaVW aPRXQWV RI SXbOLc RU VePL-SXbOLc LQIRUPaWLRQ, \eW LW dReV QRW eTXaWe WR LQdLYLdXaOV'cRQVeQW IRU WKeLU LQIRUPaWLRQ WR be XVed LQ UeVeaUcK.87-89 TKXV, WKe eWKLcaO cRQVLdeUaWLRQV e[WeQdbe\RQd SULYac\ cRQceUQV WR LQcOXde LVVXeV RI cRQVeQW, aQd WKe SRWeQWLaO IRU Ue-LdeQWLILcaWLRQ RIde-LdeQWLILed daWa.87-89 GLYeQ WKaW RQOLQe SRVWV aUe RIWeQ VKaUed LQ SXbOLc RU VePL-SXbOLc IRUXPVZLWKRXW WKe e[SOLcLW LQWeQWLRQ RI becRPLQJ UeVeaUcK daWa, WKe TXeVWLRQ RI ZKaW cRQVWLWXWeVLQIRUPed cRQVeQW LQ VXcK cRQWe[WV becRPeV PXUN\.87-89 TKeUeIRUe, LW LV cUXcLaO WR VaIeJXaUd WKeSULYac\ RI LQdLYLdXaOV LQYROYed. IQ WKLV VWXd\, PeaVXUeV KaYe beeQ WaNeQ WR PLQLPL]e SRWeQWLaO34KaUP WR VRcLaO PedLa XVeUV b\ aQRQ\PL]LQJ RXU daWaVeW, e[cOXdLQJ XVeUQaPeV aQd LdeQWLILabOeLQIRUPaWLRQ, aQd b\ UeSKUaVLQJ aQd WUaQVOaWLQJ e[ceUSWV. AOWKRXJK VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV aUecRQVLdeUed SXbOLc b\ WKe TUL-CRXQcLO PROLc\ SWaWePeQW JXLdeOLQeV, aQd WKe XVe RI WKLV daWaVXSSRUWV WKe RbMecWLYeV RI SURWeVWeUV WR e[SRVe WKe cKaOOeQJeV Iaced b\ PedLcaO WUaLQeeV.90.91 WeacNQRZOedJe RXU eWKLcaO RbOLJaWLRQ WR SURWecW WKe SaUWLcLSaQWV IURP SRVVLbOe cRQVeTXeQceV, VXcKaV ePSOR\eU UeWaOLaWLRQ, eVSecLaOO\ LQ WKe cRQWe[W RI PaNLVWaQ ZKeUe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LV baQQed.TKXV, WKe de-LdeQWLILcaWLRQ SURceVV ZaV JLYeQ VWURQJ cRQVLdeUaWLRQ, WKURXJK RXU ULJRURXVde-LdeQWLILcaWLRQ SURceVV, eQVXULQJ WKaW aOO daWa XVed LQ WKe VWXd\ UePaLQV aQRQ\PRXV aQdUeVSecWV WKe cRQILdeQWLaOLW\ RI aOO LQdLYLdXaOV LQYROYed WR XSKROd WKe eWKLcaO VWaQdaUdV LQ KaQdOLQJVeQVLWLYe daWa.FXUWKeU SUecaXWLRQV LQcOXde RPLWWLQJ aQ\ VRcLaO PedLa TXRWeV IURP RXU UeSRUWLQJ WKaW ZeUedeOeW ed LQ WKe SeULRd IURP ZKeQ WKe daWa ZaV cROOecWed WLOO WKe VXbPLVVLRQ RI WKe ILQaOPaQXVcULSW. CRQVLdeUaWLRQ ZLOO be JLYeQ WR WKe UeSRUWLQJ aQd dLVVePLQaWLRQ RI WKe ILQdLQJV. NRQaPeV RU LdeQWLI\LQJ LQIRUPaWLRQ ZLOO be LQcOXded LQ SXbOLc UeSRUWV RI WKLV UeVeaUcK WR aYRLd WKeSRWeQWLaO IRU VWLJPaWL]aWLRQ, KaUP, RU PLVUeSUeVeQWaWLRQ RI cRPPXQLWLeV RU LQdLYLdXaOV. ReVXOWVZLOO be UeSRUWed LQ aJJUeJaWe WR eQVXUe aQRQ\PLW\ (IRU e[aPSOe, Ze ZLOO RQO\ XVe WKe WeUPVPXOWLOaWeUaO aJeQc\ ZKeQ UeIeUULQJ WR WKe LQVWLWXWLRQaO aIILOLaWLRQ RI a deLdeQWLILed UeVSRQdeQW).AOO daWa ZLOO be deVWUR\ed ILYe \eaUV aIWeU WKe ILUVW SXbOLcaWLRQ.2.5 DaWa anal\sisTKe daWa aQaO\VLV IRU WKLV VWXd\ ZaV cRQdXcWed XVLQJ a PL[ed-PeWKRdV aSSURacK, cRPbLQLQJWKePaWLc aQaO\VLV IRU TXaOLWaWLYe daWa aQd QaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ, VSecLILcaOO\ ZRUd35IUeTXeQc\ aQaO\VLV aQd cRVLQe cRUUeOaWLRQ, WR aQaO\]e WKe VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV. NaWXUaO OaQJXaJeSURceVVLQJ LV a bUaQcK RI aUWLILcLaO LQWeOOLJeQce WKaW deaOV ZLWK WKe LQWeUacWLRQ beWZeeQ cRPSXWeUVaQd KXPaQV XVLQJ QaWXUaO OaQJXaJe. IW LV XVed WR V\VWePaWLcaOO\ aQaO\]e OaUJe YROXPeV RI We[WdaWa b\ aSSO\LQJ aOJRULWKPV aQd cRPSXWaWLRQaO WecKQLTXeV WR LdeQWLI\ SaWWeUQV, e[WUacW LQVLJKWV,aQd TXaQWLI\ YaULRXV aVSecWV RI WKe We[W daWa, VXcK aV VeQWLPeQW aQaO\VLV, WRSLc PRdeOLQJ, RU WUeQdLdeQWLILcaWLRQ.92 ML[ed-PeWKRdV aSSURacK KaV VeeQ a ULVe LQ SRSXOaULW\ LQ KeaOWKcaUe aPLdJURZLQJ cRPSOe[LWLeV LQ KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\ ZRUOdZLde. B\ LQWeJUaWLQJ PL[ed PeWKRdVUeVeaUcKeUV caQ e[aPLQe a YaULeW\ RI YLeZSRLQWV aQd LdeQWLI\ cRQQecWLRQV aPRQJ WKe cRPSOe[aVSecWV RI RXU PXOWL-Oa\eUed UeVeaUcK LQTXLULeV VXcK aV WKLV VWXd\.93IQ WKLV VWXd\, WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV ZaV caUULed RXW aV a cROOabRUaWLYe eIIRUW beWZeeQ WKe UeVeaUcKeUaQd WKe daWa UaWKeU WKaQ UeO\LQJ RQ a SUe-e[LVWLQJ WKeRU\, IROORZLQJ WKe LQWeUSUeWaWLYe aSSURacKRXWOLQed b\ BUaXQ aQd COaUNe (2006).94 TKLV PeWKRd ePSKaVL]eV eYROYLQJ WKePeV aQd VWRULeVIURP a d\QaPLc aQd WKRXJKWIXO LQWeUacWLRQ ZLWK WKe daWa, JRLQJ be\RQd MXVW VXPPaUL]LQJ LW. B\aSSO\LQJ UeIOe[LYe WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV, WKe VWXd\ deOYed deeSO\ LQWR WKe daWa, LQWeUSUeWLQJ LWV deeSeUPeaQLQJV aQd ZKaW WKeVe LPSO\, be\RQd PeUeO\ UeLWeUaWLQJ ZKaW ZaV VaLd. TKLV eQVXUed acRQVLVWeQW aQd WKeRUeWLcaOO\ VRXQd aSSURacK, ZKeWKeU WKURXJK LQdXcWLYe RU dedXcWLYeSeUVSecWLYeV. AV a UeVXOW, LW SURYLded a deWaLOed e[aPLQaWLRQ RI WKe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV RI MSaRD aVVeeQ LQ VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV, UeYeaOLQJ WKe Ne\ WKePeV, VWRULeV, aQd dULYLQJ IRUceV beKLQd WKeLUacWLYLWLeV. TKe aQaO\VLV caUeIXOO\ dLIIeUeQWLaWed beWZeeQ cRdeV aQd WKePeV, VXb-WKePeV aQdWKePeV, aQd dRPaLQ VXPPaULeV aQd WKePeV, aOO RUJaQL]ed aURXQd a Ne\ cRQceSW WKaW bURXJKWcOaULW\ aQd VWUXcWXUe WR WKe WKePaWLc IUaPeZRUN. TKXV, WKe WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV VKed OLJKW RQ WKeLQWULcaWe aQd ULcK dLVcXVVLRQV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe cRPPXQLW\, JLYLQJ deeS LQVLJKWV LQWR WKe36cRQWeQW, cRQWe[W, aQd VXbWOeWLeV RI MSaRD'V adYRcac\ ZRUN.95 IQ cRQWUaVW, XWLOL]LQJ QaWXUaOOaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ IRU ZRUd IUeTXeQc\ aQaO\VLV aQd cRVLQe cRUUeOaWLRQ, RIIeUed aQ RbMecWLYePeaVXUe RI WKe SUeYaOeQce RI VSecLILc WeUPV aQd WKe UeOaWLRQVKLSV beWZeeQ dLIIeUeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQVbaVed RQ VKaUed LVVXeV aQd VWUaWeJLeV. TKLV SURYLded a bURadeU RYeUYLeZ RI WKe adYRcac\OaQdVcaSe, cRPSOePeQWLQJ WKe LQ-deSWK e[SORUaWLRQ acKLeYed WKURXJK WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV.TRJeWKeU, WKe PL[ed-PeWKRdV aSSURacK aOORZed IRU a PXOWLIaceWed e[SORUaWLRQ RI WKe VWXd\¶VRbMecWLYeV, OeYeUaJLQJ WKe deWaLOed, cRQWe[W-ULcK LQVLJKWV RI WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV aORQJVLde WKeRbMecWLYe, VcaOabOe aQaO\VLV SURYLded b\ TXaQWLWaWLYe PeWKRdV. TKLV cRPbLQaWLRQ eQULcKed RXUXQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV, eQabOLQJ a PRUe cRPSUeKeQVLYe e[SORUaWLRQ RI WKecRPSOe[ KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\ cKaOOeQJeV addUeVVed LQ WKLV VWXd\.2.5.1 RQ.1: Landscape of organi]aWions represenWing MSaRD in PakisWan2.5.1.1 QXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLVTKe UeVeaUcK PeWKRdRORJ\ LQYROYed a cRPSUeKeQVLYe SURceVV RI daWa cROOecWLRQ, RUJaQL]aWLRQ,aQd aQaO\VLV aLPed aW XQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKe RSeUaWLRQV, adYRcac\ LVVXeV, aQd VWUaWeJLeV RI MSaRDRUJaQL]aWLRQV. IQLWLaOO\, aOO VRXUceV ZeUe aQRQ\PL]ed aQd PeWLcXORXVO\ caWaORJed LQ aQ e[ceOVKeeW VWRUed LQ a SaVVcRde OQeDULYe IROdeU. TKLV dLJLWaO caWaORJ ZaV PeWKRdLcaOO\ RUJaQL]ed b\aWWULbXWeV VXcK aV RUJaQL]aWLRQ, daWe, W\Se RI cRQWeQW (We[W, LPaJe, eWc.), ZLWK PXOWLSOe WabVdedLcaWed WR dLIIeUeQWLaWLQJ YaULRXV IRUPV RI daWa, LQcOXdLQJ VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV, SROLc\dRcXPeQWV, aQd PedLa UeSRUWV.TR JaLQ a deeS XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe cROOecWed PaWeULaOV, I eQJaJed LQ aQ e[WeQVLYe UeYLeZ RI WKeSRVWV, eQVXULQJ a WKRURXJK IaPLOLaULW\ ZLWK WKe daWa. TKLV e[WeQVLYe eQJaJePeQW ZLWK WKe daWa37ZaV cULWLcaO WR eQVXUe a WKRURXJK XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe PaWeULaO, Oa\LQJ WKe JURXQdZRUN IRU adeWaLOed aQaO\VLV. TKe cRUe RI WKe TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV ZaV WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV, LPSOePeQWedWKURXJK a K\bULd cRdLQJ VWUaWeJ\. TKLV aSSURacK ZaV cKRVeQ WR accRPPRdaWe WKe cRPSOe[LW\ RIWKe daWa, LQWeJUaWLQJ bRWK LQdXcWLYe aQd dedXcWLYe cRdLQJ SURceVVeV. IQdXcWLYe cRdLQJ ZaVaSSOLed IRU LdeQWLI\LQJ ePeUJLQJ WKePeV UeOaWed WR WKe LVVXeV Iaced b\ MSaRD, aQd WKeLURUJaQL]aWLRQaO VWUXcWXUe aQd IXQcWLRQ. DedXcWLYe cRdLQJ ZaV XWLOL]ed IRU aQaO\]LQJ VWUaWeJLcaVSecWV RI MSaRD'V adYRcac\ eIIRUWV. AIWeU I deYeORSed aQ LQLWLaO cRdebRRN aV a IRXQdaWLRQaOWRRO IRU WKe cRdLQJ SURceVV, IacLOLWaWLQJ WKe V\VWePaWLc LdeQWLILcaWLRQ aQd aQQRWaWLRQ RI UeOeYaQWdaWa VeJPeQWV, WKe cRdeV ZeUe ILUVW UeYLeZed b\ DU.SULUaP, (SXSeUYLVRU) WR eQVXUe SUeOLPLQaU\accXUac\ aQd cRQVLVWeQc\. SXbVeTXeQWO\, I cRQdXcWed a cRPSUeKeQVLYe aQaO\VLV RQ WKe IXOO daWaVeWJXLded b\ WKe ILQaOL]ed cRdebRRN ZLWK WKe UeVeaUcK VXSeUYLVRU\ cRPPLWWee²cRPSULVLQJ IRXUPePbeUV²SeUIRUPLQJ UeOLabLOLW\ cKecNV WR eQVXUe WKe accXUac\ aQd cRQVLVWeQc\ RI WKe cRdLQJSURceVV. BaVed RQ WKeVe cRdeV, a cOeaU IUaPeZRUN (TabOe 1) ZaV deYeORSed IRU IXUWKeU WKePaWLcaQaO\VLV. TKLV Oa\eUed aSSURacK WR YaOLdaWLRQ ZaV LQVWUXPeQWaO LQ PaLQWaLQLQJ WKe PeWKRdRORJLcaOULJRU RI WKe aQaO\VLV, eQVXULQJ WKaW WKe WKePaWLc IUaPeZRUN deYeORSed ZaV URbXVW aQd UeIOecWLYeRI WKe daWa.BaVed RQ WKLV aQ aQaO\WLcaO IUaPeZRUN IRcXVed RQ dLVVecWLQJ eacK MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQ acURVVWKUee SULQcLSaO caWeJRULeV:1. SWUXcWXUe aQd FXQcWLRQ2. AdYRcac\ IVVXeV3. AdYRcac\ SWUaWeJLeV38aV deSLcWed LQ FLJXUe 1, ZeUe deYeORSed. WLWKLQ WKeVe PaLQ caWeJRULeV, cRdeV IURP aOORUJaQL]aWLRQV ZeUe aJJUeJaWed LQWR SRWeQWLaO WKePeV, IacLOLWaWLQJ a cURVV-RUJaQL]aWLRQaO WKePaWLcaQaO\VLV. TKLV ULJRURXV UeYLeZ SURceVV ZaV UecXUVLYe, LQYROYLQJ cRQVWaQW UeeYaOXaWLRQ RI WKecRded daWa aQd WKe eQWLUe daWaVeW WR UeILQe aQd accXUaWeO\ UeSUeVeQW ePeUJLQJ WKePeV. FRU eacKLdeQWLILed WKePe, cOeaU deILQLWLRQV aQd QaPeV ZeUe eVWabOLVKed, caSWXULQJ WKe eVVeQce RIMSaRD'V eQJaJePeQW LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ adYRcac\. TKe cRPSOe[LW\ aQd YROXPe RI WKe daWa XQdeUeacK WKePe QeceVVLWaWed WKe cUeaWLRQ RI VXb-WKePeV, eQabOLQJ a PRUe QXaQced e[SORUaWLRQ RI WKedaWa'V d\QaPLcV. TKe cXOPLQaWLRQ RI WKLV aQaO\VLV SURdXced a deWaLOed QaUUaWLYe, aUWLcXOaWLQJ WKeLdeQWLILed WKePeV aQd VXb-WKePeV UeSUeVeQWed aV ILJXUeV LQ WKe UeVXOWV VecWLRQ aQd IXUWKeUeQULcKed ZLWK LOOXVWUaWLYe TXRWeV IURP WKe daWaVeW. NVLYR 14 ZaV XVed WR cRQdXcW WKe TXaOLWaWLYeaQaO\VLV.2.5.1.2 NaWXUaO LaQJXaJe PURceVVLQJ (NLP)FROORZLQJ TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV, XVLQJ QaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ, Ze ePSOR\ed ZRUd IUeTXeQc\aQaO\VLV aQd cRVLQe cRUUeOaWLRQ (cRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ LQde[) WecKQLTXeV WR e[SORUe WKe WUeQdV aQdSaWWeUQV LQ WKe eQWLUe daWaVeW RI VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV Pade b\ YaULRXV MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV acURVVPaNLVWaQ. TKLV aSSURacK ZaV aLPed WR XQcRYeU WKe SUedRPLQaQW WKePeV aQd WeUPV ZLWKLQ WKeLUadYRcac\ LVVXeV aQd aVVeVV WKe UeOaWLRQaO d\QaPLcV beWZeeQ WKe adYRcac\ PeVVaJeV aQdVWUaWeJLeV RI dLIIeUeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV. WRUd IUeTXeQc\ aQaO\VLV VWaQdV aV a KLJKO\ e[SORUed aQdXWLOL]ed VWaWLVWLcaO WecKQLTXe ZLWKLQ WKe UeaOP RI TXaQWLWaWLYe OLQJXLVWLcV.96 B\ aVVeVVLQJ WKeIUeTXeQcLeV RI ZRUdV LQ a We[W, WKLV aQaO\VLV RIIeUV LQVLJKWV LQWR WKe XVaJe SaWWeUQV WKURXJKcRPSXWaWLRQaO PeWKRdV aQd VWaWLVWLcaO WecKQLTXeV.96 IQ WKLV VWXd\ I XVed R VWaWLVWLcaO VRIWZaUe WRcRQdXcW ZRUd IUeTXeQc\ aQaO\VLV RQ WKe cRUSXV RI cROOecWed VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV cROOecWed IURP aOO39RUJaQL]aWLRQV. TKLV SURceVV LQYROYed cRXQWLQJ WKe RccXUUeQceV RI eacK ZRUd acURVV aOO SRVWV,ZKLOe SXUSRVeIXOO\ e[cOXdLQJ cRPPRQ VWRSZRUdV WR eQVXUe WKe UeOeYaQce RI WKe daWa aQaO\]ed.TKe ZRUdV ZLWK WKe VLPLOaU PeaQLQJV ZeUe aJJUeJaWed XQdeU WKe VaPe YecWRU, aQ e[aPSOe RIZKLcK caQ be IRXQd LQ ASSeQdL[ D. FURP WKLV aQaO\VLV, Ze LdeQWLILed aQd cRPSLOed a OLVW RI WKeKXQdUed PRVW cRPPRQO\ XVed ZRUdV, ZKLcK VeUYed WR KLJKOLJKW WKe ceQWUaO WRSLcV aQd WeUPVSUeYaOeQW LQ WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV' VRcLaO PedLa adYRcac\ eIIRUWV. TKLV OLVW ZaV cULWLcaO LQXQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKe IRcXV aUeaV aQd SULRULWLeV RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ WKeLU SXbOLccRPPXQLcaWLRQV. UVLQJ WKeVe KXQdUed PRVW cRPPRQ WeUPV, cRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ LQde[ XVLQJ RVWaWLVWLcaO VRIWZaUe ZeUe aSSOLed RQ VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV WR eYaOXaWe VLPLOaULW\ beWZeeQ dLIIeUeQWRUJaQL]aWLRQV. CRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ LQde[ LV a PeaVXUe XVed LQ We[W aQaO\VLV WR TXaQWLI\ WKe VLPLOaULW\beWZeeQ WZR We[WV RU dRcXPeQWV, dLVUeJaUdLQJ WKeLU VL]e.97 IW LV a cUXcLaO PeWULc LQ daWa aQaO\VLVaQd QaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ, e[WeQVLYeO\ XVed acURVV YaULRXV aSSOLcaWLRQV LQcOXdLQJ VeaUcKaOJRULWKPV, UecRPPeQdaWLRQ V\VWePV, We[W PLQLQJ, VeQWLPeQW aQaO\VLV, aQd dRcXPeQWcOXVWeULQJ.97 IW RIIeUV a UeOLabOe PeWKRd IRU aVVeVVLQJ WKe VePaQWLc VLPLOaULW\ beWZeeQ dRcXPeQWV,daWaVeWV, RU LPaJeV, IacLOLWaWLQJ accXUaWe UecRPPeQdaWLRQV, caWeJRUL]aWLRQV, aQd XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RIWe[W-baVed cRQWeQW.97 AV WKe aPRXQW RI We[W aYaLOabOe RQ WKe Zeb cRQWLQXeV WR JURZ, UeVeaUcKeUVaUe LQcUeaVLQJO\ XWLOL]LQJ WKLV UeVRXUce IRU dRcXPeQW aQd We[W aQaO\VLV.98TKe VaPe PeWKRd RI ZRUd IUeTXeQc\ aQaO\VLV aQd cRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ LQde[ ZaV aOVR VSecLILcaOO\ePSOR\ed WR aQaO\]e WKe WRS WZeQW\-ILYe PRVW cRPPRQ ZRUdV UeOaWed WR adYRcac\ LVVXeV aQdVWUaWeJLeV XVed b\ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV. FUeTXeQc\ JUaSKV ZeUe JeQeUaWed IRU bRWK VeWV RI WeUPV WRIacLOLWaWe a YLVXaO cRPSaUaWLYe aQaO\VLV beWZeeQ WKe dLIIeUeQW MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV, YaOLdaWed b\cRVLQe VLPLOaULW\. OYeUaOO, WKe SXUSRVe RI WKe TXaQWLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV ZaV WR LdeQWLI\ dLVcRXUVe40SaWWeUQV acURVV WKe YaULRXV RUJaQL]aWLRQV aQd XQdeUVWaQd WKe deJUee RI aOLJQPeQW LQ WKeLUadYRcac\ PeVVaJeV. B\ aQaO\]LQJ WKe WKePaWLc cRQWeQW RI WKeLU SRVWV WKURXJK cRVLQe cRUUeOaWLRQ,Ze ZeUe abOe WR aVceUWaLQ WKe VLPLOaULWLeV aQd dLYeUJeQceV LQ WKe adYRcac\ aSSURacKeV aQdSULRULWLeV aPRQJ WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV2.5.2 RQ2: IssXe framing b\ Whe ke\ sWakeholders (MSaRD)IQ WKLV VWXd\, Ze LQYeVWLJaWe WKe IUaPLQJ RI LVVXeV b\ MSaRD ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP LQPaNLVWaQ WKURXJK WKe e[SORUaWLRQ RI SURWeVWV b\ MSaRD XVLQJ TZLWWeU/X SRVWV RQ NLE SROLc\.TKe aQaO\VLV ZaV VWUXcWXUed WR XQcRYeU WKe QaUUaWLYeV, WKePeV, aQd SeUVSecWLYeV WKaW MSaRDaUWLcXOaWe UeJaUdLQJ KeaOWKcaUe cKaOOeQJeV, SROLc\ adYRcac\, aQd V\VWePLc UeIRUPV. TKe cRQceSWRI IUaPLQJ RULJLQaWeV IURP cRJQLWLYe SV\cKRORJ\ aQd aQWKURSRORJ\ aQd KaV beeQ adRSWed b\YaULRXV dLVcLSOLQeV WR aQaO\]e KRZ WRSLcV aUe cRPPXQLcaWed aQd LQWeUSUeWed. GRIIPaQ (1974)LQWURdXced IUaPLQJ aV a Za\ LQdLYLdXaOV XQdeUVWaQd WKeLU ZRUOd, a cRQceSW OaWeU aSSOLed WR PaVVPedLa aQaO\VLV b\ RWKeUV OLNe EQWPaQ (1993).99 FUaPLQJ LQYROYeV WKe LQcOXVLRQ RU e[cOXVLRQ RILQIRUPaWLRQ, LQIOXeQcLQJ aXdLeQce LQWeUSUeWaWLRQ aQd XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI LVVXeV.99TKe cRUe RI RXU PeWKRdRORJ\ ZaV aQ LQdXcWLYe IUaPLQJ aQaO\VLV, ZKLcK aOORZed XV WR deULYeIUaPeV dLUecWO\ IURP WKe daWa, UaWKeU WKaQ LPSRVLQJ SUecRQceLYed caWeJRULeV dUaZLQJ IURPSePeWNR aQd VaONeQbXUJ (2000).100 TKLV aSSURacK ZaV cKRVeQ WR caSWXUe WKe bUeadWK aQd deSWKRI WKe dLVcRXUVe VXUURXQdLQJ MSaRD'V UROeV LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\, acNQRZOedJLQJ WKaW QeZIUaPeV cRXOd ePeUJe IURP WKe d\QaPLc aQd eYROYLQJ QaWXUe RI VRcLaO PedLa dLVcXVVLRQV. TKecRdLQJ SURceVV beJaQ ZLWK a SUeOLPLQaU\ UeYLeZ RI a VXbVeW RI WKe daWaVeW deYeORSLQJ LQLWLaOcRdeV XVLQJ NVLYR baVed RQ UecXUULQJ WRSLcV, VeQWLPeQWV, aQd UeSUeVeQWaWLRQV RI MSaRD LQ WKe41cRQWe[W RI KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\. TKLV LWeUaWLYe SURceVV LQYROYed cRQWLQXRXV dLVcXVVLRQ aQdUeILQePeQW RI cRdeV XQWLO a cRPSUeKeQVLYe cRdLQJ VcKePe ZaV eVWabOLVKed ZLWK WKe JXLdaQce RI acRPPLWWee RI IRXU PePbeUV. TKe ILQaOL]ed cRdLQJ VcKePe WKaW JeQeUaWed 31 dRPLQaQW cRdeV ZaVWKeQ aSSOLed WR WKe eQWLUe daWaVeW WR cKaUacWeUL]e WKe dLVcRXUVe aURXQd WKe NLE SROLc\ LQ PaNLVWaQ.Ne[W, a deWaLOed WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV ZaV cRQdXcWed RQ WKe cROOecWed TZLWWeU/X daWa IRcXVLQJ RQ WKedLVcRXUVe aURXQd WKe NLE LVVXe, dePaQdV, adYRcac\ eIIRUWV, aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V UeacWLRQV WRWKe SURWeVWV b\ MSaRD aJaLQVW WKe NLE SROLc\. TKLV cRPSUeKeQVLYe e[aPLQaWLRQ aLPed WReOXcLdaWe WKe VSecLILc cRQceUQV, dePaQdV RI WKe MSaRD ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ'V KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, aQdaddLWLRQaOO\, WKeLU acWLYe SaUWLcLSaWLRQ aQd WKe RbVWacOeV WKe\ eQcRXQWeUed LQ YRLcLQJ WKeLULQWeUeVWV. TKURXJK WKLV eQKaQced aQaO\VLV, Ze VRXJKW WR cRQVWUXcW a QXaQced XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKed\QaPLcV beWZeeQ MSaRD'V adYRcac\ PRYePeQWV aQd SROLc\ UeVSRQVeV, VKeddLQJ OLJKW RQ WKebURadeU LPSOLcaWLRQV IRU KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ aQd PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ LQ PaNLVWaQ.42ChapWer 3: ResXlWs - Landscape of organi]aWions represenWing MSaRD inPakisWan3.1 OYerYieZ of Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsTKLV VecWLRQ SURYLdeV a bULeI deVcULSWLRQ RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV WKaW ZeUe LQcOXded LQ WKLVVWXd\, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKeLU VcRSe, SULPaU\ IRcXV, aQd JeRJUaSKLcaO SURPLQeQce RQ WKe PaS LQFLJXUe 1.101 TKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV SOa\ a VLJQLILcaQW UROe LQ UeSUeVeQWLQJ WKe LQWeUeVWV RI MSaRD,acURVV WKe cRXQWU\, aObeLW ZLWK QRWabOe dLIIeUeQceV LQ WKeLU RSeUaWLRQaO VcRSe aQd UeJLRQaO acWLYLW\.OUJaQL]aWLRQV UeSUeVeQWLQJ MSaRD e[WeQd be\RQd e[cOXVLYe IRcXV RQ WKLV JURXS; eQWLWLeV OLNeDWM aQd PDA, ZLWK bURadeU cRQVWLWXeQcLeV VXcK aV SUacWLcLQJ SK\VLcLaQV, aOVR adYRcaWe IRUMSaRD LQWeUeVWV aPRQJ WKeLU dLYeUVe aJeQdaV.FigXre 1 - Geographical Prominence of MSaRD43PriYaWe Medical SWXdenWs Union of PakisWan (PMSUP) LV a QaWLRQZLde RUJaQL]aWLRQ SULPaULO\caWeULQJ WR WKe LQWeUeVWV aQd ZeOIaUe RI SULYaWe PedLcaO VWXdeQWV. WKLOe LW KROdV a QaWLRQaOSUeVeQce, LWV acWLYLWLeV aUe SUedRPLQaQWO\ cRQceQWUaWed LQ WKe PXQMab UeJLRQ. TKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ LVdLVWLQJXLVKed b\ LWV IRcXV RQ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV, adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKeLU ULJKWV aQd LQWeUeVWV ZLWKLQWKeLU edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQV aQd bURadeU PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\.DocWors Wake Up MoYemenW (DWM) SRVLWLRQV LWVeOI aV a QaWLRQaO RUJaQL]aWLRQ, UeSUeVeQWLQJ abURad VSecWUXP RI WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\, LQcOXdLQJ VWXdeQWV, UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV, aQd SUacWLcLQJSK\VLcLaQV. DeVSLWe LWV QaWLRQaO cOaLPV, DWM'V RSeUaWLRQaO acWLYLWLeV aQd adYRcac\ eIIRUWV aUeSULPaULO\ IRcXVed ZLWKLQ WKe PXQMab SURYLQce. I cRXOd QRW ILQd LQIRUPaWLRQ RQ ZKeQ DWM RUPMSUP ZeUe IRXQded.ProYincial DocWors AssociaWion (PDA) IRXQded LQ 1986, LV XQLTXe LQ LWV SURYLQcLaO IRcXV,RSeUaWLQJ e[cOXVLYeO\ ZLWKLQ WKe KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa (KPK) UeJLRQ. IW VeUYeV aOO WKUeecaWeJRULeV RI WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\²VWXdeQWV, UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV, aQd SUacWLcLQJSK\VLcLaQV²PaNLQJ LW a cRPSUeKeQVLYe UeSUeVeQWaWLYe bRd\ aW WKe SURYLQcLaO OeYeO. PDA'VacWLYLWLeV aUe WaLORUed WR addUeVV WKe VSecLILc QeedV aQd cKaOOeQJeV Iaced b\ WKe PedLcaOcRPPXQLW\ ZLWKLQ KPK, dLVWLQJXLVKLQJ LW IURP RUJaQL]aWLRQV ZLWK a bURadeU JeRJUaSKLcaOPaQdaWe.YoXng DocWors AssociaWion (YDA) IRXQded LQ 2009 VWaQdV RXW aV a QaWLRQaO RUJaQL]aWLRQ ZLWKeVWabOLVKed, LQdeSeQdeQW cKaSWeUV LQ eacK SURYLQce, LQcOXdLQJ SLQdK, PXQMab, KK\beUPaNKWXQNKZa (KPK), aQd BaORcKLVWaQ. EacK SURYLQcLaO cKaSWeU RSeUaWeV LQdeSeQdeQWO\,44UeIOecWLQJ WKe dLYeUVe KeaOWKcaUe OaQdVcaSeV aQd cKaOOeQJeV VSecLILc WR WKeLU UeVSecWLYe UeJLRQV,\eW WKe\ cROOabRUaWe RQ VKaUed LVVXeV, RIIeULQJ PXWXaO VXSSRUW VXcK aV NLE.SRPe RWKeU MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV WKaW ZeUe LdeQWLILed LQcOXded, MedLcaO SWXdeQW OUJaQL]aWLRQ,MedLcaO SWXdeQW AVVRcLaWLRQ RI PaNLVWaQ, aQd PaNLVWaQ IVOaPLc MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQ, ZeUe QRWLQcOXded LQ WKe SULPaU\ IRcXV dXe WR a OacN RI VLJQLILcaQW UeOeYaQW VRcLaO PedLa acWLYLW\ dXULQJ WKeVWXd\ SeULRd.3.2 FrameZork Wo sWXd\ Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsTKe IUaPeZRUN deSLcWed LQ FLJXUe 2 RXWOLQeV a cRPSUeKeQVLYe VWUXcWXUe WR LQYeVWLJaWe WKeOaQdVcaSe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ. IW LV deVLJQed WR aQaO\]e YaULRXV aVSecWV RI WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV WKURXJK a PXOWL-WKePaWLc OeQV. TKe IUaPeZRUN LV dLYLded LQWR WKUee PaLQ VecWLRQV:1. SWUXcWXUe & FXQcWLRQ2. IVVXeV3. SWUaWeJLeVEacK VecWLRQ ZLOO be e[SORUed WKURXJK IXUWKeU WKePeV aQd VXbWKePeV. B\ XWLOL]LQJ WKLV IUaPeZRUNWR XQdeUVWaQd WKe OaQdVcaSe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ, UeVeaUcKeUV caQ dLVVecW WKeLQWULcaWe deWaLOV RI KRZ WKeVe eQWLWLeV RSeUaWe, WKe cKaOOeQJeV WKe\ Iace, aQd WKe PeWKRdV WKe\ XVeWR RYeUcRPe WKeP. IW ZLOO aOVR KeOS LQ LdeQWLI\LQJ WKe SRWeQWLaO aUeaV IRU LPSURYePeQW aQdLQWeUYeQWLRQ WR VXSSRUW MSaRD LQ WKeLU SURIeVVLRQaO MRXUQe\. TKLV cRPSUeKeQVLYe aSSURacK ZLOOQRW RQO\ SURYLde a deWaLOed XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe cXUUeQW VWaWe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV bXW ZLOOaOVR aVVLVW LQ IRUPXOaWLQJ SROLcLeV aQd VWUaWeJLeV WKaW cRXOd be ePSOR\ed WR VXSSRUW WKe JURZWKaQd deYeORSPeQW RI WKe PedLcaO ILeOd LQ PaNLVWaQ.453.3 SWrXcWXre of Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsFLJXUe 2 UeSUeVeQWV WKe RYeUaOO VWUXcWXUe aQd IXQcWLRQ RI MSaRD WKURXJK WKe WKePeV JeQeUaWedIURP WKe cROOecWed daWa. We ZLOO dLVcXVV WKe VWUXcWXUe aQd IXQcWLRQ VeSaUaWeO\ WR beWWeU XQSacNaQd XQdeUVWaQd WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV. SWUXcWXUe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV ZLOO be VWXdLed XQdeUWKUee WKePeV:1. LeadeUVKLS2. WLQJV3. EOecWRUaO PURceVVFigXre 2 - The FrameZork of Themes463.3.1 Leadership sWrXcWXre of Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsTKe RUJaQL]aWLRQaO VWUXcWXUeV RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV UeIOecW a WaLORUed aSSURacK WR OeadeUVKLSaQd JRYeUQaQce. OYeUaOO, YDA aQd PDA VKaUe JUeaW VLPLOaULWLeV LQ WKeLU OeadeUVKLS VWUXcWXUe.WKLOe aOO YDA cKaSWeUV aQd PDA VKaUe a KLeUaUcKLcaO deVLJQ, WKe YaULaWLRQ LQ cabLQeW VL]e aQdVSecLILc UROeV acURVV SURYLQceV VXJJeVWV a deJUee RI cXVWRPL]aWLRQ [TabOe 2]. BRWK RUJaQL]aWLRQVKaYe OeadeUVKLS cabLQeWV ZLWK cOeaU UROeV aQd UeVSRQVLbLOLWLeV RXWOLQed IRU eacK SRVLWLRQ. BRWKRUJaQL]aWLRQV KaYe IXUWKeU KRVSLWaO-OeYeO cKaSWeUV aQd eacK IacLOLW\-OeYeO cKaSWeU KaV a VLPLOaUKLeUaUcKLcaO OeadeUVKLS WeaP WR addUeVV LVVXeV aW WKe ORcaO OeYeO. AOO RI WKe YDA SURYLQcLaOcKaSWeUV aQd PDA aUe acWLYeO\ e[SaQdLQJ ZLWKLQ SURYLQceV, e[aPSOeV RI ZKLcK ZLOO be eYLdeQWWKRXJK YaULRXV SRVWV LQ WKe XScRPLQJ VecWLRQV. TKeUe LV QR cOeaU LQIRUPaWLRQ aYaLOabOe RQ WKeVWUXcWXUe RI PMSUP aQd DWM.Table 2 - Leadership SWrXcWXre of MSaRD Organi]aWionsYDA PXnjab YDA KPK YDA Sindh YDA BalochisWan PDAPaWURQ LQ CKLeI PaWURQ LQ CKLeI PaWURQ LQ CKLeI OUJaQL]eU PaWURQ LQ CKLeICKaLUPaQ CKaLUPaQ PUeVLdeQW DeSXW\ OUJaQL]eU PUeVLdeQWPUeVLdeQW PUeVLdeQWSeQLRU VLcePUeVLdeQWOUJaQL]LQJMePbeUVSeQLRU VLcePUeVLdeQWVLce PUeVLdeQW VLce PUeVLdeQWV GeQeUaO SecUeWaU\ VLce PUeVLdeQWGeQeUaO SecUeWaU\ GeQeUaO SecUeWaU\DeSXW\ GeQeUaOSecUeWaU\GeQeUaOSecUeWaU\47YDA PXnjab YDA KPK YDA Sindh YDA BalochisWan PDAJRLQW SecUeWaU\ DeSXW\ GeQeUaOSecUeWaU\IQIRUPaWLRQSecUeWaU\JRLQW SecUeWaU\FLQaQce SecUeWaU\ FLQaQce SecUeWaU\ PUeVV SecUeWaU\FLQaQceSecUeWaU\IQIRUPaWLRQSecUeWaU\IQIRUPaWLRQSecUeWaU\SRcLaO MedLaIQ-cKaUJeIQIRUPaWLRQSecUeWaU\SSRUWV SecUeWaU\ SSRUWV SecUeWaU\3.3.2 Wings of Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsYDA KPK dLVWLQJXLVKeV LWVeOI b\ KaYLQJ dLVWLQcW dLYLVLRQV IRU WUaLQeeV, KRXVe RIILceUV, aQdVWXdeQWV, eacK ZLWK LWV RZQ VSecLILc VecWLRQ IRU ZRPeQ. EacK ZLQJ KaV aQ e[WeQVLYe OeadeUVKLScabLQeW [ASSeQdL[ A, 1]. YDA PXQMab, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ aQd PDA dR QRW KaYe VeSaUaWe ZLQJVIRU KRXVe RIILceUV, VWXdeQWV RU ZRPeQ, KRZeYeU WKe\ KaYe eOecWed ZRPeQ LQ WKe JeQeUaOOeadeUVKLS cabLQeW, [ASSeQdL[ A, 2]. TKeUe ZaV QR LQIRUPaWLRQ IRXQd UeJaUdLQJ WKe SUeVeQce RUVWUXcWXUe RI IXUWKeU ZLQJV IRU YDA SLQdK, DWM RU PMSUP RU WKe UROe aQd LQYROYePeQW RIZRPeQ LQ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV.3.3.3 ElecWoral process of Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsYDA aQd PDA KaYe aUWLcXOaWed cOeaU eOecWRUaO SURceVVeV. EOecWLRQV aUe KeOd ZLWKLQ eacK SURYLQceWKURXJK IacLOLW\-OeYeO cKaSWeUV. YDA PXQMab, ZLWK OeadeUVKLS eOecWed IURP KRVSLWaOV acURVV cLWLeV,48cXOPLQaWeV LQ a GeQeUaO CRXQcLO WKaW UeSUeVeQWV WKe eQWLUe SURYLQce. A QRWabOe JaWKeULQJ b\ YDAPXQMab'V OeadeUVKLS XQdeUVcRUed WKe LPSRUWaQce RI XQLW\ aQd WKe UeMecWLRQ RI aQ\QRQ-cRQVWLWXWLRQaO acWLYLWLeV, [ASSeQdL[ A, 3]. YDA KPK KaV a cRPSUeKeQVLYe eOecWRUaO V\VWePZLWK VeSaUaWe cabLQeWV IRU dLIIeUeQW PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ OeYeOV aQd JeQdeUV, ePSKaVL]LQJdLYeUVLW\ aQd dePRcUaWLc JRYeUQaQce. TKLV LQcOXdeV cabLQeW UeRUJaQL]aWLRQV XSRQ cRQVeQVXV[ASSeQdL[ A, 4].4. ³FURP WKe KRXVe Rf YDA IKD. A PeeWLQJ ZaV KeOd WRda\ LQ WKe SUeVeQce Rf PaWURQ LQ cKLef YDA KPK,PUeVLdeQW YDA KP, PaWURQ LQ cKLef YDA IKD, E[ cKaLUPaQ YDA IKD, PUeVLdeQW YDA KTH«..WLWK WKeSeUPLVVLRQ Rf PUeVLdeQW YDA KP WKe UeRUJaQL]aWLRQ cabLQeW Rf YDA IKD ZaV dRQe. AQd ZLWK WKeXQaQLPRXV decLVLRQ Rf aOO WKe PePbeUV Rf WKe PeeWLQJ WKe fROORZLQJ PePbeUV aUe aQQRXQced WR KROd WKeWRUcK Rf YDA IKD.´YDA BaORcKLVWaQ LV acWLYeO\ e[SaQdLQJ ZLWK OeadeUVKLS VWUXcWXUeV beLQJ PeWKRdLcaOO\ VeOecWedaQd a VXcceVVIXO PePbeUVKLS dULYe KLJKOLJKWLQJ cRQILdeQce LQ LWV cXUUeQW cabLQeW. PDA PLUURUVYDA'V eOecWRUaO aSSURacK bXW LQcRUSRUaWeV a bURadeU PL[ RI PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV, LQcOXdLQJVeQLRU dRcWRUV, WKaW aUe a PL[ RI bRWK PaOe aQd IePaOe dRcWRUV IURP acURVV WKe PedLcaO aQd deQWaOdeSaUWPeQWV. YDA SLQdK ZaV WKe RQO\ RUJaQL]aWLRQ WKaW UeSRUWed LQWeUQaO cRQIOLcW RYeU WKeeOecWLRQ UeVXOWV aQd LV WKe RQO\ RUJaQL]aWLRQ WKaW KaV IRUPed aQ eOecWLRQ cRPPLVVLRQ WR RYeUVeeWKe eOecWLRQ SURceVV [ASSeQdL[ A, 5]. TKe YDA SLQdK EOecWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ aQQRXQcedWZR-\eaUO\ eOecWLRQV IRU PUeVLdeQW aQd GeQeUaO SecUeWaU\ SRVWV, LQYROYLQJ 11 WeacKLQJ KRVSLWaOV LQSLQdK. TKe SURceVV LQcOXded deadOLQeV IRU QRPLQaWLRQV aQd YRWeU OLVW VXbPLVVLRQV, ePSKaVL]LQJdePRcUaWLc SaUWLcLSaWLRQ acURVV WKe SURYLQce. CRQIOLcW aURVe beWZeeQ WZR SaQeOV, YDA SKaK49LaWLI aQd YDA DePRcUaWV, OeadLQJ WR WeQVLRQV aQd SUePaWXUe cOaLPV RI YLcWRU\ RQ VRcLaO PedLa.TKe EOecWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ dLVcRXUaJed WKeVe acWLRQV aQd caOOed IRU a PeeWLQJ WR UeVROYe WKedeadORcN, aLPLQJ WR XQLI\ WKe aVVRcLaWLRQ IRU LWV beWWeUPeQW. DeVSLWe RQJRLQJ YRWLQJ aQd VRcLaOPedLa cRQWURYeUVLeV, WKe cRPPLVVLRQ LQVLVWed RQ cRPSOeWLQJ WKe eOecWLRQ SURceVV dePRcUaWLcaOO\,ZLWK WKe ILQaO UeVXOWV SeQdLQJ aW WKe WLPe RI daWa cROOecWLRQ [ASSeQdL[ A, 6].3.4 FXncWioning of Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsFLJXUe 3 VKRZV WKe RYeUaOO WKePeV aQd VXb-WKePeV RQ KRZ WKeVe MSaRD IXQcWLRQ. I ZLOO dLVcXVVeacK WKePe:(1) GRYeUQaQce(2) CRPPXQLcaWLRQ ZLWK WKe IQWeUQaO SWaNeKROdeUV(3) RROeV aQd SeUYLceaQd WKeLU VXb-WKePeV LQ WKe XScRPLQJ IeZ VecWLRQV.3.4.1 GoYernance of Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsTR XQdeUVWaQd KRZ MSaRD JRYeUQ WKeLU RUJaQL]aWLRQV, I ZLOO VWXd\ WKeP WKURXJK WKe IROORZLQJVXb-WKePeV:(L) ALP aQd ObMecWLYeV(LL) OUJaQL]aWLRQaO RXOeV aQd PULQcLSaOV(LLL) IQWeUQaO D\QaPLc(LY) E[WeUQaO D\QaPLcV aV VKRZQ LQ FLJXUe 3503.4.1.1 ALP aQd RbMecWLYeV RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQVTKe TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV' aLPV aQd RbMecWLYeV LQdLcaWeV a dedLcaWed eIIRUWWRZaUdV adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKe ULJKWV RI MSaRD, ZLWK cOaLPV WR QRQ-SaUWLVaQ aSSURacK LQ aSROLWLcaOO\ cKaUJed eQYLURQPeQW. TKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV VeeN WR LQIOXeQce aQd cKaQJe SROLcLeVaIIecWLQJ WKe MSaRD'V cRPPXQLW\, addUeVV VWUXcWXUaO LQcRPSeWeQcLeV LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP,aQd IRVWeU VROLdaULW\ aPRQJ PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV aQd VWXdeQWV acURVV PaNLVWaQ. A PRUe deWaLOedUeYLeZ RI WKe LVVXeV WKaW WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV addUeVV LV aYaLOabOe LQ WKe "IVVXeV" VecWLRQ 3.5. AQe[aPSOe RI WKeLU aLPV aQd RbMecWLYeV caQ be IRXQd LQ ASSeQdL[ A, 7. WKLOe WKe cRPPLWPeQW WRQRQ-SaUWLVaQ adYRcac\ LV VWaWed, WKe acWLRQV aQd SXbOLc VWaWePeQWV RI VRPe RUJaQL]aWLRQV VXJJeVWa QXaQced UeOaWLRQVKLS ZLWK SROLWLcaO eQWLWLeV aQd ILJXUeV ZKLcK cRXOd LQIOXeQce WKeLU VWUaWeJLeVaQd LPSacW RQ WKe MSaRD'V cRPPXQLW\. OQe VXcK e[aPSOe LV DWM ZKLcK VKRZV a WLOW WRZaUdVRQe QaWLRQaO SROLWLcaO SaUW\, PaNLVWaQ MXVOLP LeaJXe - NRRQ, KaLOLQJ WKeLU SROLcLeV aQdSeUIRUPaQce aQd RSeQO\ cULWLcL]LQJ WKe RWKeU SaUW\ PTI.8. "MU.SeQaWRU! NRWKLQJ LV ZURQJ LQ WKe QRWLfLcaWLRQ & WKe fee LV aOVR WKe VaPe aV ZaV LQ \RXU WeQXUe &KaV QRW beeQ LQcUeaVed. We VWLOO UePePbeU \RXU aWWLWXde & deOa\LQJ WacWLcV WR KLQdeU WKe UeVWRUaWLRQ RfPMDC. AOO WKe bOacN OaZV OLNe NLE/MTI KaYe beeQ XQdRQe WKaW ZaV LPSRVed b\ PTI - DWM"YDA aQd PDA RQ WKe RWKeU KaQd UeaIILUPV LWV LdeQWLW\ aV a QRQ-SaUWLVaQ aQd QRQ-adPLQLVWUaWLYeRUJaQL]aWLRQ, IRcXVLQJ RQ adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKe ULJKWV aQd ZeOIaUe RI dRcWRUV ZLWKRXW eQJaJLQJ LQSROLWLcaO RU adPLQLVWUaWLYe cRQIOLcWV [ASSeQdL[ A, 9].51FigXre 3 - Themes and SXb Themes of FXncWion of MSaRD Organi]aWions3.4.1.2 OUJaQL]aWLRQaO UXOeV aQd SULQcLSOeVYDA XSKROdV cOeaU aQd ZeOO-deILQed SROLcLeV RQ RUJaQL]aWLRQaO UXOeV aQd SULQcLSOeV WR e[eUcLVeLQWeJULW\, accRXQWabLOLW\, aQd WKe ZeOIaUe RI LWV PePbeUV. IW PaQdaWeV cROOabRUaWLYedecLVLRQ-PaNLQJ, UeTXLULQJ WKe OeadeUVKLS WR JaLQ WKe cRQILdeQce RI RWKeU PePbeUV, ZLWKdecLVLRQV aJaLQVW WKe PaMRULW\ beLQJ QXOOLILed. TKe OeadeUVKLS cabLQeW RI eacK KRVSLWaO acWV aV adLUecW UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RI WKe SURYLQcLaO cabLQeW, eQVXULQJ decLVLRQV aUe Pade ZLWK WKe ceQWUaOSURYLQcLaO cabLQeW'V cRQILdeQce. PROLc\ VWaWePeQWV aQd SUeVV UeOeaVeV, eVSecLaOO\ cRQceUQLQJLVVXeV Iaced b\ dRcWRUV aQd SaWLeQWV LQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV, PXVW UeceLYe aSSURYaO IURP WKe52SURYLQcLaO cabLQeW. TKe SURYLQcLaO cabLQeW UeWaLQV WKe aXWKRULW\ WR PaNe aPeQdPeQWV WR WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQaO VWUXcWXUe, ZKLcK aUe bLQdLQJ RQ aOO ZLQJV aQd cKaSWeUV acURVV WKe SURYLQce.AccRUdLQJ WR WKeLU VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV, VXJJeVWLRQV IURP aOO UeJLVWeUed PePbeUV aUe WaNeQVeULRXVO\, SURPRWLQJ LQcOXVLYLW\ aQd PePbeU eQJaJePeQW LQ VWUeQJWKeQLQJ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ.10." YDA BaORcKLVWaQ* TKe Kead Rf WKe RUJaQL]LQJ bRd\ ZLOO be WKe RUJaQL]eU bXW LQ aOO LWV decLVLRQV WKeRUJaQL]eU ZLOO KaYe WR WaNe cRQfLdeQce LQ RWKeU RUJaQL]LQJ PePbeUV LQcOXdLQJ WKe deSXW\ RUJaQL]eU, aQ\decLVLRQ WaNeQ b\ WKe RUJaQL]eU aJaLQVW WKe PaMRULW\ Rf WKe deSXW\ RUJaQL]eUV aQd WKe RUJaQL]LQJ PePbeUVZLOO be QXOOLfLed. WLOO JR. 3. TKe RUJaQL]LQJ bRd\ ZLOO UeSUeVeQW WKe SURYLQcLaO cabLQeW dLUecWO\ LQ eacKKRVSLWaO. 4. IQ caVe Rf aQ\ SURbOeP LQ WKe KRVSLWaO, aQ\ decLVLRQ WaNeQ b\ PaMRULW\ RSLQLRQ b\ WKeOUJaQL]LQJ BRd\ ZLOO KaYe WR be WaNeQ b\ WKe PURYLQcLaO CabLQeW LQ cRQfLdeQce, aOO decLVLRQV WaNeQZLWKRXW WaNLQJ WKe PURYLQcLaO CabLQeW LQ WUXVW ZLOO KaYe QR cRQVWLWXWLRQaO aQd PRUaO VWaWXV.*"YDA KaV VKRZQ WR WaNe decLVLYe acWLRQ aJaLQVW PePbeUV WKaW ZeUe IRXQd JXLOW\ RI VSUeadLQJIaOVe LQIRUPaWLRQ, eQJaJLQJ LQ cRUUXSWLRQ, aQd PLVXVLQJ WKeLU SRVLWLRQV. TKLV LQcOXded WKeUePRYaO RI OeadeUVKLS SRVLWLRQV aQd WKe LPSRVLWLRQ RI ILQaQcLaO SeQaOWLeV IRU PLVcRQdXcW.11. "OQ WKe baVLV Rf UeSeaWed cRPSOaLQWV aJaLQVW SURSaJaQda PaVWeUV b\ dRcWRUV & KeaOWK SURfeVVLRQaOVRf SLQdK Ze aUe UeOeaVLQJ WKLV SUeVV UeOeaVe. FaNe ID¶V PaVWeU DU. X LV KeUe b\ de - VeaWed fURP VLceCKaLUPeQ YDA SINDH SRVLWLRQ. He ZaV JLYeQ VKRZ caXVe aQd ZaV ZaUQed aJaLQVW SURSaJaWLRQ Rf faOVeLQfRUPaWLRQ, fRUcefXO ORbb\LQJ, PLVXVe Rf KLV SRVLWLRQ aJaLQVW RWKeU dRcWRUV. He LV fRXQd JXLOW\ aQdLQYROYed LQ PXOWLSOe XQe[SOaLQabOe cRUUXSWLRQ VcaQdaOV. He KaV SOa\ed WKe PRVW cUXcLaO UROe LQ daPaJLQJRXU aVVRcLaWLRQ - YDA SLQdK"53TKe aVVRcLaWLRQ aOVR eQIRUceV a cOeaU SROLc\ aJaLQVW KROdLQJ VLPXOWaQeRXV OeadeUVKLS SRVLWLRQV LQYDA aQd KRVSLWaO/XQLYeUVLW\ adPLQLVWUaWLRQV, ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe VeSaUaWLRQ RI RUJaQL]aWLRQaO aQdadPLQLVWUaWLYe UeVSRQVLbLOLWLeV WR SUeYeQW cRQIOLcWV RI LQWeUeVW [ASSeQdL[ A, 11]. OYeUaOO, YDAacURVV dLIIeUeQW UeJLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ aSSeaUV WR XSKROd a VWUXcWXUed aSSURacK WR RUJaQL]aWLRQ,decLVLRQ-PaNLQJ, cRPPXQLcaWLRQ, aQd OeadeUVKLS, ZLWK a VWURQJ ePSKaVLV RQ LQWeJULW\,accRXQWabLOLW\, aQd PePbeU ZeOIaUe. TKeUe ZaV QRW PXcK LQIRUPaWLRQ UeJaUdLQJ WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQaO UXOeV aQd SULQcLSOeV RI PDA, DWM aQd PMSUP.3.4.1.3 IQWeUQaO d\QaPLcV RI WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQVTKe LQWeUQaO d\QaPLcV RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ LV cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ a cRPSOe[OaQdVcaSe RI cRPPLWPeQW WR adYRcac\, XQLW\, RccaVLRQaO LQWeUQaO dLVSXWeV aQd SROLWLcaOaIILOLaWLRQV. IQ WKe caVe RI YDA VSecLILcaOO\, deVSLWe WKe LQdeSeQdeQce RI SURYLQcLaO bUaQcKeV,WKeUe LV aQ eYLdeQW VeQVe RI LQWeUcRQQecWLYLW\ aQd PXWXaO VXSSRUW aPRQJ dLIIeUeQW YDA bUaQcKeV.TKLV LV LOOXVWUaWed b\ WKe cROOabRUaWLYe dLVcXVVLRQV aQd e[cKaQJe RI LdeaV WKaW WRRN SOace dXULQJaQ aOO PaNLVWaQ WRXU RI WKe GeQeUaOV SecUeWaU\ YDA SLQdK LQ JXO\ 2023 aLPed aW XQLWLQJ eIIRUWVaQd VKaULQJ VWUaWeJLeV IRU addUeVVLQJ cRPPRQ cKaOOeQJeV [ASSeQdL[ A, 12]. DeVSLWe WKe VWURQJePSKaVLV RQ XQLW\ aQd cRQWLQXRXV eIIRUWV, WKeUe LV VRPe eYLdeQce RI LQWeUQaO dLVSXWeV,SaUWLcXOaUO\ aURXQd eOecWLRQV aQd OeadeUVKLS SRVLWLRQV aV RbVeUYed LQ WKe SRVWV RQ WKe eOecWRUaOSURceVV RI YDA SLQdK [ASSeQdL[ A, 6]. PROLWLcaO LQcOLQaWLRQ RI RQe cKaSWeU ZaV cRQVLdeUed RQeRI WKe caXVeV RI WKe dLVSXWe.13. "ReceQW eYeQWV KaYe e[SRVed WKe WUXe QaWXUe Rf ceUWaLQ LQdLYLdXaOV cOaLPLQJ WR UeSUeVeQW YDA SLQdKXQdeU WKe SKaK LaWLf SaQeO«.. IW aSSeaUV WKaW WKe VR-caOOed YDA SKaK LaWLf SaQeO'V acWLRQV Pa\ KaYe beeQ54dULYeQ PRUe b\ SROLWLcaO SRLQW-VcRULQJ WKaQ WKe JeQXLQe ZeOfaUe Rf PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd KeaOWKcaUe LQ WKeUeJLRQ. We beOLeYe WKaW WUaQVSaUeQc\ aQd accRXQWabLOLW\ VKRXOd be WKe cRUQeUVWRQeV Rf aQ\ UeVSRQVLbOeaVVRcLaWLRQ, eVSecLaOO\ RQe WKaW deaOV ZLWK WKe cULWLcaO fLeOd Rf KeaOWKcaUe. "TKe deadORcN WKaW ePeUJed LQ YDA SLQdK eOecWLRQV XQdeUVcRUeV WKe LQWeUdeSeQdeQce aQdaccRXQWabLOLW\ aPRQJ YDA cKaSWeUV acURVV PaNLVWaQ, aV YDA PXQMab, KP, aQd BaORcKLVWaQcORVeO\ PRQLWRU WKe VLWXaWLRQ.14. "FURP WKe ZaOO Rf YDA EOecWLRQ cRPPLVVLRQ PAGE DeadORcN LV VWLOO LQ SOace LQ WKe eOecWLRQV Rf YDASLQdK«.. IW LV LPSeUaWLYe RQ bRWK WKe SaQeOV WR VKRZ XQdeUVWaQdLQJ aQd ZLVdRP aQd WaNe YDA SLQdK WRWKe ULJKW dLUecWLRQ Rf KLVWRU\. RePePbeU, YDA PXQMab, YDA KP, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ KaYe WKeLU e\eV RQ YDASLQdK eOecWLRQV."YDA PXQMab KaV aOVR UeSRUWed dLVaJUeePeQWV UeJaUdLQJ OeadeUVKLS eOecWLRQV [ASSeQdL[ A, 15].YDA PXQMab OeadeUVKLS YLVLWed a DLVWULcW Head QXaUWeU (DHQ) HRVSLWaO WR dLVcXVV WKe XScRPLQJeOecWLRQV RI WKe IacLOLW\ ZLWK WZR JURXSV, addUeVVLQJ WKe SaVW eYeQWV, cRPPXQLW\ e[SecWaWLRQV,aQd aQ\ LVVXeV RU JULeYaQceV. AIWeU WKe dLVcXVVLRQV aQd cRQVXOWaWLRQ ZLWK ceQWUaO OeadeUVKLS, aXQaQLPRXV VWaWePeQW ZaV LVVXed ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe SURKLbLWLRQ RI XQOaZIXO acWLYLWLeV aW WKe IacLOLW\,aV a PePbeU RI WKe YDA PXQMab'V GeQeUaO CRXQcLO. A cRPPLWWee ZaV aOVR IRUPed WR UecRPPeQdSURcedXUeV IRU WKe eOecWLRQ SURceVV. [ASSeQdL[ A, 15].TKe aSSURacK WR UeVROYLQJ WKeVe dLVSXWeV RIWeQ LQYROYed dLaORJXe, cRQVXOWaWLRQ ZLWK ceQWUaOOeadeUVKLS, aQd eIIRUWV WR UeacK a XQaQLPRXV decLVLRQ, LQdLcaWLQJ a SURcedXUaO aQd dePRcUaWLcaSSURacK WR cRQIOLcW UeVROXWLRQ ZLWKLQ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV aV caQ be VeeQ LQ WKe YDA PXQMab'V55OeadeUVKLS'V YLVLW WR DHQ HRVSLWaO [ASSeQdL[ A, 15] aQd YDA SLQdK'V [ASSeQdL[ A, 11] LVVXLQJVKRZ caXVe QRWLceV aQd VeeNLQJ e[SOaQaWLRQV. IQ WKLV VWXd\¶V daWa VeW, Ze dLd QRW RbVeUYe aQ\eYLdeQce RI cRQIOLcWV (aOWKRXJK WKe\ PLJKW KaYe RccXUUed) IURP YDA KPK, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ,PDA, DWM aQd PMSUP,3.4.1.4 E[WeUQaO d\QaPLcV - E[SaQVLRQ aPLdVW e[WeUQaO SURSaJaQdaTKe TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV RI WKe e[SaQVLRQ RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ WKe Iace RI e[WeUQaOSURSaJaQda UeYeaOV a PXOWLIaceWed aSSURacK WR QaYLJaWLQJ cKaOOeQJeV, bXLOdLQJ UeVLOLeQce, aQde[WeQdLQJ WKeLU LQIOXeQce acURVV WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP LQ PaNLVWaQ. TKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV, QRWabO\WKe YDA acURVV YaULRXV SURYLQceV, KaYe dePRQVWUaWed VWUaWeJLc adaSWabLOLW\, XQLW\, aQd SURacWLYeeQJaJePeQW WR cRXQWeUacW SURSaJaQda aQd VROLdLI\ WKeLU SUeVeQce aQd adYRcac\ eIIRUWV. TKeRUJaQL]aWLRQV' QRQ-SaUWLVaQ cOaLPV aUe MX[WaSRVed aJaLQVW WKe UeaOLW\ RI RSeUaWLQJ ZLWKLQ aSROLWLcaOO\ VeQVLWLYe cRQWe[W, ZKeUe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV caQ LQadYeUWeQWO\ aOLJQ ZLWK RU RSSRVeJRYeUQPeQW SROLcLeV. TKLV d\QaPLc caQ aWWUacW cULWLcLVP, SURSaJaQda, aQd UeVLVWaQce IURPJRYeUQPeQWaO bRdLeV, LPSacWLQJ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV' eIIecWLYeQeVV aQd SXbOLc SeUceSWLRQ.16. "YRXQJ dRcWRUV KaYe aOZa\V UaLVed WKeLU YRLce aJaLQVW cRUUXSWLRQ, becaXVe Rf ZKLcK WKe SUeYLRXVJRYeUQPeQW aOVR WaUJeWed \RXQJ dRcWRUV. TRda\, ZKeQ \RXQJ dRcWRUV UaLVed WKeLU YRLce fRU WKeLUcRPPXQLW\ aQd aJaLQVW cRUUXSWLRQ, WKe MedLcaO SXSeULQWeQdeQW (MS) Rf X KRVSLWaO bOaPed WKe cabLQeW Rf\RXQJ dRcWRUV «.. YDA KPK VWaQdV VLde b\ VLde ZLWK LWV ORcaO RUJaQL]aWLRQ, aQd LV QRW Uead\ WRcRPSURPLVe RQ cRUUXSWLRQ aQd SeRSOe'V ULJKWV. SWa\ XQLWed. SWa\ VWURQJ SSRNeVSeUVRQ YDAKK\beUPaNKWXQNKZa"56MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV KaYe IUeTXeQWO\ UeSRUWed eQcRXQWeULQJ SURSaJaQda aQd VPeaU caPSaLJQV.AccRUdLQJ WR MSaRD, WKeVe caPSaLJQV ZeUe bRWK LQWeUQaOO\ (aV dLVcXVVed LQ SecWLRQ 3.4.1.3) aQde[WeUQaOO\ RULJLQaWed, LQcOXdLQJ aOOeJaWLRQV RI QeJOLJeQce aQd PLVcRQdXcW, aV ZeOO aV SROLWLcaOLQWeUIeUeQce.17. " NXPeURXV faNe SURfLOeV, JURXSV aQd SaJeV aUe beLQJ UXQ b\ VRPe Rf WKe bURWKeUV b\ VRPe Rf WKeVeQLRU aQd cRQWeVWLQJ RffLcLaOV «.. AdYeUWLVLQJ WKLV bOLQd SURSaJaQda Rf bOacNPaLOLQJ aQd cKaUacWeUaVVaVVLQaWLRQ ZLOO QRW be acceSWed aW aQ\ cRVW. We UeTXeVW aOO WKe dRcWRUV Rf SLQdK WR VWa\ aZa\ fURP WKLVSURSaJaQda. We ZLOO bULQJ WKe fXOO WUaQVSaUeQW UeSRUW LQ fURQW Rf \RX aOO ZKeQ WKe LQYeVWLJaWLRQ UeVXOWV aUeUeceLYed - YDA SLQdK"TKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV cRPbaW WKeVe cKaOOeQJeV b\ LVVXLQJ SXbOLc cRQdePQaWLRQV, SURWeVWLQJ,eQJaJLQJ OeJaO aYeQXeV (e.J., ILOLQJ cRPSOaLQWV ZLWK WKe FedeUaO IQYeVWLJaWLRQ AJeQc\), aQdSURPLVLQJ WUaQVSaUeQc\ LQ WKeLU UeVSRQVeV WR VaIeJXaUd WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV' UeSXWaWLRQV aQdPaLQWaLQ SXbOLc WUXVW. [ASSeQdL[ A, 23]18. "YDA UeMecWV WKe deaWK aQd LQcLdeQW Rf a SaWLeQW bURXJKW WR X KRVSLWaO aV QeJOLJeQce Rf dRcWRUV aQdWKe aWWePSWV WR SaLQW LW aV UeOLJLRXV e[WUePLVP fRU SeUVRQaO SXUSRVeV ««. AOaV, WKe Za\ WKe V\VWePaWLccaPSaLJQ aJaLQVW dRcWRUV LV beLQJ cRQdXcWed aJaLQVW WKe dRcWRUV fRU WKe SaVW 2 da\V LV YeU\ Vad. YRXQJdRcWRUV aUe dePaQdLQJ WUaQVSaUeQW LQYeVWLJaWLRQ fURP WKe KLJKeU RUdeUV fURP WKe fLUVW da\ aQd aUe Uead\WR cRRSeUaWe LQ eYeU\ Za\ fRU WUaQVSaUeQW LQYeVWLJaWLRQ. IW LV YeU\ Vad WR Va\ WKaW WKLV LQcLdeQW LV LQfOaPedb\ VRPe faPe KXQJU\ aQd PRQe\ ZRUVKLSSeUV VR-caOOed MRXUQaOLVWV b\ JLYLQJ LW a cRPSOeWeO\ UeOLJLRXVcRORU - YDA PXQMab"57YDA BaORcKLVWaQ'V VXSSRUW IRU WKe MS RI a KRVSLWaO aJaLQVW QeJaWLYe SURSaJaQda aV a cROOecWLYeVWaQce aJaLQVW e[WeUQaO SUeVVXUeV aQd SROLWLcaO LQWeUIeUeQce. [ASSeQdL[ A, 19]. DeVSLWe IacLQJUeVLVWaQce, MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV KaYe SXUVXed VWUaWeJLc e[SaQVLRQ ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP,eVWabOLVKLQJ QeZ OeadeUVKLS cabLQeWV aQd eQJaJLQJ LQ RaWK-WaNLQJ ceUePRQLeV WR IRUPaOL]e WKeLUSUeVeQce LQ addLWLRQaO KRVSLWaOV aQd UeJLRQV [ASSeQdL[ A, 20]. TKLV JURZLQJ LQIOXeQce LQ SaUWcaQ be aVVRcLaWed ZLWK WKeLU cRPPXQLcaWLRQ, eQJaJePeQW aQd LPaJe bXLOdLQJ VWUaWeJLeV ZKLcKZLOO be dLVcXVVed LQ WKe Qe[W VecWLRQ.3.4.2 CommXnicaWion ZiWh Whe inWernal sWakeholdersTKe cRPPXQLcaWLRQ VWUaWeJLeV ZLWK LQWeUQaO VWaNeKROdeUV (PedLcaO VWXdeQWV, KRXVe RIILceUV,UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV aQd OaUJeU KeaOWKcaUe IUaWeUQLW\) b\ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQXQdeUVcRUeV a Oa\eUed aSSURacK WR eQJaJePeQW, WUaQVSaUeQc\, aQd adYRcac\. FURP WKe VRcLaOPedLa SRVWV, WKeVe VWUaWeJLeV aLP WR IRVWeU XQLW\, dLVVePLQaWe LQIRUPaWLRQ, aQd PRbLOL]e VXSSRUWIRU YaULRXV caXVeV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe cRPPXQLW\. MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV OeYeUaJe a ZLde aUUa\RI cRPPXQLcaWLRQ cKaQQeOV WR UeacK WKeLU LQWeUQaO VWaNeKROdeUV, LQcOXdLQJ VRcLaO PedLaSOaWIRUPV, SUeVV UeOeaVeV, IRUPaO aQd LQIRUPaO JaWKeULQJV, aQd dLUecW ZaUd URXQdV. SRcLaO PedLaSOa\V a cULWLcaO UROe LQ VWUXcWXULQJ, RUJaQL]LQJ, JURZWK, aQd IXQcWLRQLQJ, eQabOLQJ WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV WR cRPbaW SURSaJaQda, KLJKOLJKW adYRcac\ eIIRUWV, aQd VKaUe WKeLU SeUVSecWLYeV RQYaULRXV LVVXeV. WKLOe, eYeQWV VXcK aV RaWK-WaNLQJ ceUePRQLeV, Wea SaUWLeV, aQd ceOebUaWLRQV VeUYeQRW RQO\ aV SOaWIRUPV IRU IRUPaO aQQRXQcePeQWV bXW aOVR aV RSSRUWXQLWLeV IRU LQIRUPaOLQWeUacWLRQV, IRVWeULQJ a VeQVe RI caPaUadeULe [ASSeQdL[ A, 21].5822." OQ WKe LQVWUXcWLRQV Rf WKe GeQeUaO CRXQcLO Rf YDA KPK, WRda\ YDA «.. GURXS Rf TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaOdLd a ZaUd-WR-ZaUd URXQd aQd WRRN LWV dRcWRUV cRPPXQLW\ LQ cRQfLdeQce fRU a SeacefXO SURWeVW WRPRUURZ.YRXQJ dRcWRUV ZLOO bR\cRWW eOecWLYe VeUYLceV acURVV KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa fURP WRPRUURZ aJaLQVW QRQ-KLNeLQ VaOaULeV Rf WUaLQee PedLcaO RffLceUV aQd KRXVe RffLceUV. AOO WUaLQee PedLcaO RffLceUV aQd KRXVe RffLceUVaUe LQfRUPed WKaW fURP WRPRUURZ QR dRcWRU VKRXOd VeUYe LQ ZaUd RU OPD."CRPPXQLcaWLRQ VWUaWeJLeV aUe aOVR ePSOR\ed WR e[SUeVV VROLdaULW\ aQd VXSSRUW IRU PePbeUVIacLQJ cKaOOeQJeV RU LQMXVWLceV. B\ SXbOLcO\ VWaQdLQJ ZLWK aIIecWed LQdLYLdXaOV RU JURXSV, MSaRDRUJaQL]aWLRQV VLJQaO WKeLU UeadLQeVV WR adYRcaWe RQ beKaOI RI WKeLU PePbeUV aQd cRQIURQW LVVXeVKead-RQ [ASSeQdL[ A, 23]. TKeVe PXOWLdLPeQVLRQaO VWUaWeJLc cRPPXQLcaWLRQ aQd eQJaJePeQWVeePLQJO\ PaNe WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV ZeOO-cRQQecWed aQd ZeOO-LQIRUPed RQ WKe LVVXeV WKaW WKeMSaRD Iace. TKe VeOecWLRQ RI LVVXeV IRU adYRcac\ aSSeaUV WR be dULYeQ b\ VeYeULW\, WKe YROXPeRI cRPSOaLQWV, aQd cRQVXOWaWLRQV ZLWKLQ ORcaO aQd ceQWUaO SURYLQcLaO cabLQeWV [ASSeQdL[ A,24.25].3.4.3 Role and serYices b\ Whe MSaRD organi]aWionsTKe UROe aQd VeUYLceV SURYLded b\ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV KLJKOLJKW a Oa\eUed aSSURacK WRVXSSRUWLQJ KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV, aXWKRULWLeV, aQd WKe JeQeUaO SXbOLc. TKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV, ZKLOeSULPaULO\ IRcXVed RQ adYRcac\ IRU KeaOWKcaUe LVVXeV, YDA aOVR eQJaJeV LQ YROXQWeeU VRcLaOVeUYLceV aQd LQLWLaWLYeV aLPed aW eQKaQcLQJ WKe RYeUaOO ZeOO-beLQJ RI WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ aQdWKe JeQeUaO SRSXOace. YDA SLQdK LQ cROOabRUaWLRQ ZLWK WKe PaNLVWaQ NaY\ RUJaQL]ed a caUeeUcRXQVeOLQJ eYeQW aQd YDA PXQMab RUJaQL]ed a WabOe WeQQLV eYeQW aW CKLOdUeQ¶V HRVSLWaO.[ASSeQdL[ A, 26]5926. "VaULRXV effRUWV ZeUe Pade aQd DU. A UefeUUed WKe SaWLeQW WR DU. X, a caQceU VSecLaOLVW. TKe SaWLeQWZaV WUaQVSRUWed b\ UeVcXe aPbXOaQce 1122 ZLWK WKe KeOS Rf H\deUabad SLQdK GRYeUQPeQW. DU. X LV adRcWRU aV ZeOO aV a VRcLaO ZRUNeU aQd LV aOVR a SaUW Rf WKe YRXQJ DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ. DXULQJ WKe fORRdVaQd UaLQV Rf 2022, YRXQJ DRcWRUV PUeVLdeQW DU. X cRQdXcWed 142 PedLcaO caPSV LQ dLffeUeQW dLVWULcWV RfSLQdK."TKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ'V eIIRUWV WR bULdJe cRPPXQLcaWLRQ beWZeeQ VWaWe aXWKRULWLeV aQd KeaOWKcaUeRUJaQL]aWLRQV dePRQVWUaWe WKeLU UROe LQ LQIOXeQcLQJ KeaOWK SROLcLeV aQd WKeLU LPSacW aV aVWaNeKROdeU LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV [ASSeQdL[ A, 27]. TKe caOO IRU IeedbacN RQ PedLcaOedXcaWLRQ SROLc\ b\ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ IXUWKeU LQdLcaWeV YDA'V LQYROYePeQW LQ VKaSLQJ WKeedXcaWLRQaO OaQdVcaSe IRU IXWXUe KeaOWKcaUe SURIeVVLRQaOV b\ UeIOecWLQJ WKe QeedV aQd LQVLJKWV RIWKRVe dLUecWO\ LPSacWed [ASSeQdL[ A, 28].3.5 IssXes WhaW MSaRD adYocaWe forIQ WKLV VecWLRQ I KaYe LdeQWLILed ILYe dLVWLQcW WKePeV WKaW eQcaSVXOaWe WKe bUeadWK aQd deSWK RILVVXeV WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV acWLYeO\ eQJaJe LQ. FLJXUe 4 UeSUeVeQWV WKe WKePeV:(1) EdXcaWLRQaO(2) AdPLQLVWUaWLYe(3) HeaOWKcaUe WRUNeUV(4) IQIUaVWUXcWXUe(5) SRcLaO AZaUeQeVV aQd JXVWLceaQd WKe VXb WKePeV WKaW UeIOecW WKe dLYeUVe \eW LQWeUcRQQecWed aUeaV ZKeUe MSaRD aUe acWLYeO\VeeNLQJ WR PaNe a WaQJLbOe dLIIeUeQce.603.5.1 EdXcaWionalTKe edXcaWLRQaO LVVXeV WKaW MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ adYRcaWe IRU aUe caWeJRUL]ed LQWKUee caWeJRULeV baVed RQ WKe OeYeO RI edXcaWLRQ:(L) MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe AdPLVVLRQ TeVWV (MDCAT)(LL) UQdeUJUadXaWe MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ(LLL) PRVW JUadXaWe (PG) MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ61FigXre 4 - InWeracWion of Themes and SXbWhemes of IssXes MSaRD AdYocaWe For3.5.1.1 MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe AdPLVVLRQ TeVWV (MDCAT)MDCAT LV WKe eQWUaQce e[aPLQaWLRQ cRQdXcWed b\ WKe PMDC WKaW VeUYeV aV a JaWeZa\ IRUadPLVVLRQV LQWR bRWK SXbOLc aQd SULYaWe PedLcaO aQd deQWaO cROOeJeV acURVV WKe cRXQWU\. TKLV62VecWLRQ RI WKe VWXd\ LOOXVWUaWeV WKe cRPSOe[ cKaOOeQJeV WKaW MSaRD KaYe addUeVVed LQ RXU daWaVeWcRQceUQLQJ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ LQ PaNLVWaQ. I ZLOO e[SORUe WKe XQdeUO\LQJ LVVXeV LQ WKe OLJKW RI WKeMDCAT cRQdXcWed LQ 2023.A cRQceUQ UaLVed b\ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV eVSecLaOO\ DWM LV WKe baUULeUV WKaW WKe QRZ UeVWRUedPMDC IaceV dXe WR SROLWLcaO LQWeUIeUeQce RI RWKeU SRZeU acWRUV WR SeUIRUP LWV UeVSRQVLbLOLWLeVcaXVLQJ LQcRKeUeQW IXQcWLRQLQJ aQd WKXV cRQIXVLRQ aPRQJ VWXdeQWV. TKLV caQ be VeeQ WKURXJK WKeVcKedXOLQJ RI WKe MDCAT e[aP WKaW ZaV cRQIOLcWLQJ ZLWK WKe 12WK JUade bRaUd e[aPV acURVV WKecRXQWU\ aQd WKXV SURWeVWV ZeUe Pade OeadLQJ WR UeVcKedXOLQJ RI WKe e[aP RQ 10WK SeSWePbeU.HRZeYeU, OaWeU WKeUe ZeUe UeSRUWV WKaW WKe e[aP Pa\ be deOa\ed IXUWKeU dXe WR SUeVVXUe IURP WKeHeaOWK MLQLVWU\ ZKLcK PMDC eYeQWXaOO\ UeIXVed aQd WKe e[aP ZaV cRQdXcWed RQ 10WKSeSWePbeU, 2023. [ASSeQdL[ A, 29-31]32. "PMDC KaV UefXVed WR acceSW WKe LOORJLcaO dLUecWLRQV Rf WKe HeaOWK MLQLVWeU WR deOa\ MDCAT fXUWKeU.IW ZLOO be QRZ cRQYeQed RQ WKe VLQJOe aOUead\ aQQRXQced daWe QaWLRQZLde WKaW LV RQ 10WK SeSWePbeU 2023.We dLd aQQRXQce ZeOO befRUe WLPe WKaW WKeUe ZLOO be QR deOa\. - DWM"AIWeU WKe e[aP ZaV cRQdXcWed, PRVW MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV eUXSWed ZLWK cRPSOaLQWV RILUUeJXOaULWLeV LQ WKe e[aPLQaWLRQ SURceVV. OQ RQe VLde WKeUe ZeUe cRPSOaLQWV abRXW WKe SRRU aQdLUUeJXOaU VWaQdaUd RI aVVeVVPeQWV. OQ WKe RWKeU, WKeUe ZeUe VeYeUaO cRPSOaLQWV RI PaVVLYecKeaWLQJ LQ WKe e[aP IURP bRWK SLQdK aQd KPK, UaLVLQJ VeULRXV TXeVWLRQV RQ WKe IaLUQeVV,WUaQVSaUeQc\ aQd WKXV WKe cUedLbLOLW\ RI WKe MDCAT e[aPLQaWLRQ SURceVV. IQ SLQdK, WKeUe ZeUeUeSRUWV RI SaSeU OeaN ZKLcK Oead WR PaVVLYe SURWeVW b\ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV, SaUeQWV, VRcLaO ZRUNeUV,63aQd \RXQJ dRcWRUV aVVRcLaWed ZLWK YDA SLQdK aQd PaNLVWaQ, eYeQWXaOO\ caXVLQJ SRVWSRQePeQWRI WKe e[aP [ASSeQdL[ A, 33.34]35. "We YDA SLQdK VWaQd aJaLQVW WKe VOaXJKWeU Rf PeULW, WR eQVXUe PeULW LPPedLaWe LQTXLU\ VKRXOd beLQLWLaWed aQd WKRVe UeVSRQVLbOe fRU OeaNLQJ WKe SaSeU VKRXOd be KeOd accRXQWabOe. FRU WKe VaNe Rf WKefXWXUe Rf WKRXVaQdV Rf VWXdeQWV, aQ LPSaUWLaO cRPPLWWee VKRXOd be Pade aQd UeVXOWV VKRXOd be ZLWKKeOd WLOOWKe cRPPLWWee JLYeV LWV fLQaO YeUdLcW aQd eQVXUeV PeULW QRZ aQd LQ fXWXUe - YDA SLQdK"WKLOe LQ KPP, PaQ\ VWXdeQWV ZeUe caXJKW XVLQJ BOXeWRRWK WR cKeaW LQ WKe e[aP. 219 VWXdeQWVZeUe OaWeU OeJaOO\ LQdLcWed, MaLOed aQd baQQed IURP WaNLQJ MDCAT IRU WZR \eaUV.102 TKLV Oed WRIXUWKeU WUXVW deILcLW aPRQJ WKe VWXdeQWV LQ WKe e[aP SURceVV aQd WKe edXcaWLRQ WeVWLQJ aQdeYaOXaWLRQ aXWKRULW\ (ETEA) RI KPK OeadLQJ WR a UeWeVW WKaW ZaV cRQdXcWed XQdeU KK\abXUMedLcaO UQLYeUVLW\ (KMU) [ASSeQdL[ A, 36]. YDA KPK caPSaLJQed aJaLQVW WKe LVVXe PRUeVWURQJO\ WKaQ WKe PDA accRUdLQJ WR RXU daWaVeW.37. " TKe WUaQVSaUeQc\ Rf PaNLVWaQ'V WRS PedLcaO eQWUaQce WeVW KaV beeQ UXLQed fRU WKe SaVW feZ \eaUV. IfRXU PRVW LQcRPSeWeQW LQVWLWXWLRQV caQQRW WaNe aQ e[aP SURSeUO\, KRZ ZLOO WKe ZRUOd LQVWLWXWLRQV beOLeYeWKeP? IPSUeVVed SeRSOe dR WKe VaPe WKLQJ. #RecRQdXcWMDCAT2023 #RecRQdXcWETEA2023#RecRQdXcWMDCAT - YDA KPK"3.5.1.2 UQdeUJUadXaWe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQTKe TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV RI LVVXeV LQ XQdeUJUadXaWe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ, aV adYRcaWed b\ MSaRDRUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ, KLJKOLJKWV VeYeUaO Ne\ cRQceUQV WKaW LPSacW WKe TXaOLW\, IaLUQeVV, aQdacceVVLbLOLW\ RI XQdeUJUadXaWe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ. TKeVe cRQceUQV VSaQ IURP e[aPLQaWLRQ64SURceVVeV WR SROLc\ LPSOePeQWaWLRQV, aQd e[WeQd WR WKe ZeOIaUe aQd ULJKWV RI bRWK VWXdeQWV aQdIacXOW\.TKe cRQceUQV WKaW MSaRD KaYe UeJaUdLQJ XQdeUJUadXaWe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aUe LUUeJXOaULWLeV LQWKe e[aPLQaWLRQ SURceVV aQd deOa\V LQ WKe UeVXOWV RI SURIeVVLRQaO e[aPV, VLPLOaU WR MDCAT. TKeLPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI SROLcLeV ZLWKRXW SURSeU cRQVXOWaWLRQ ZLWK PedLcaO VWXdeQWV RU adeTXaWeWUaQVLWLRQLQJ PeaVXUeV KaV beeQ a SRLQW RI cRQWeQWLRQ. NRWabOe aPRQJ WKeVe cKaQJeV LV WKe VKLIWIURP aQ aQQXaO WR a PRdXOaU V\VWeP, ZKLcK ZaV PeW ZLWK UeVLVWaQce aQd OeJaO cKaOOeQJeV IURPVWXdeQWV adYRcaWLQJ IRU a PRUe cRQVLdeUed aSSURacK WKaW UeVSecWV WKeLU cXUUeQW acadePLcVWUXcWXUe. [ASSeQdL[ A, 38]39. " FLUVW \eaU deWaLQed VWXdeQWV fURP WKe aQQXaO V\VWeP ZLOO be VKLfWed WR PRdXOaU fURP Qe[W \eaU. TKeUeZaV LQWeQVe dLVcXVVLRQ LQ WKe PeeWLQJ abRXW KRZ WKe aQQXaO adPLWWed VWXdeQWV aUe beLQJ VKLfWed WR WKePRdXOaU. We KaYe LQdLcaWed WR JR WR WKe HLJK CRXUW RQ WKLV - PMSUP"AQRWKeU e[aPSOe LV WKe LQWURdXcWLRQ RI WKe "E[aPLQaWLRQ TRRONLW '' LQ 2023, ZKLcK VaZ WKeabROLWLRQ RI LQWeUQaO e[aPLQeUV LQ SURIeVVLRQaO e[aPV abUXSWO\, VSaUNLQJ debaWe aPRQJ MSaRD.DWM VXSSRUWed WKe SROLc\ cRQVLdeULQJ LW a PRYe WRZaUdV QeXWUaOLW\ aQd IaLUQeVV LQ e[aPLQaWLRQ,ZKLOe PMSUP YLeZed LW aV dLVaVWURXV, aUJXLQJ WKaW LW ZRXOd Oead WR a decOLQe LQ WKe TXaOLW\ RIaVVeVVPeQWV [ASSeQdL[ A, 40.41]. YDA PXQMab KaV UaLVed cRQceUQV abRXW WKe dLVUXSWLRQVWePPLQJ IURP WKe cRQIOLcW beWZeeQ WKe PMDC aQd WKe PMC, aQd LWV LPSacW RQ WKe RYeUaOOOaQdVcaSe RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ LQ WKe cRXQWU\. DWM KLJKOLJKWed WKe LQcUeaVe LQ WXLWLRQ IeeV b\SULYaWe PedLcaO cROOeJeV ZLWKRXW a cRUUeVSRQdLQJ LQcUeaVe LQ VWLSeQdV IRU KRXVe RIILceUV aQd65IacXOW\ cRQVLdeULQJ LW ILQaQcLaO e[SORLWaWLRQ RI MSaRD [ASSeQdL[ A, 42]. OWKeU cRQceUWV UaLVedZeUe WKe VaIeW\ RI VWXdeQWV aQd WKe UeVSecW aQd ULJKWV RI WeacKeUV. IQcLdeQWV RI PLVWUeaWPeQW b\adPLQLVWUaWLYe VWaII aQd WKe OacN RI acWLRQ aJaLQVW VXcK beKaYLRU ZaV UeSRUWed b\ YDA SLQdK.TKe aUUeVW RI WeacKeUV aQd WKe PLVWUeaWPeQW b\ JRYeUQPeQW ePSOR\eeV SURPSWed SURWeVWV aQdVROLdaULW\ IURP YDA PXQMab [ASSeQdL[ A, 43.44]. CaOOV IRU LPSURYed UeVRXUceV IRU PedLcaOedXcaWLRQ aQd cOLQLcaO VNLOOV, SaUWLcXOaUO\ YRLced b\ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ. [ASSeQdL[ A, 45]3.5.1.3 PRVW GUadXaWe (PG) PedLcaO edXcaWLRQYDA aQd PDA ZeUe WKe WZR PaLQ RUJaQL]aWLRQV WKaW UaLVed LVVXeV UeJaUdLQJ WKe SRVW JUadXaWePedLcaO edXcaWLRQ PMSUP dReV QRW IRcXV RQ PG PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ LVVXeV, ZKLOe DWM KaLOedWKe SROLc\ cKaQJe UeJaUdLQJ MePbeUVKLS RI CROOeJe RI PK\VLcLaQV aQd SXUJeRQV PaNLVWaQ(MCPS) SURSRVed b\ WKe UeVWRUed PMDC XQdeU WKe JRYeUQPeQW RI PaNLVWaQ MXVOLP LeaJXeNRRQ.46."AfWeU decadeV, MCPS WUaLQLQJ SROLc\ KaV beeQ UedeVLJQed aV QRWLfLed, LW ZLOO be ceQWUaOL]ed aQd WKeUeZLOO be PeULW baVed LQdXcWLRQ OLNe FCPS, LW ZLOO be SaLd aOVR. - DWM"TKe cRQceUQV UaLVed b\ YDA aQd PDA ceQWeU PaLQO\ aURXQd WKe OacN RI aYaLOabLOLW\ RI PGWUaLQLQJ VXSeUYLVRUV LQ PRVW GUadXaWe MedLcaO IQVWLWXWe [ASSeQdL[ A, 47]. TKeUe KaV aOVR beeQcULWLcLVP RI WKe HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ¶V QeZ SROLc\ UeJaUdLQJ M-PKLO aQd PKD VWaWLQJWKaW VWXdeQWV SXUVXLQJ M-PKLO aQd PKD caQQRW VLPXOWaQeRXVO\ be ePSOR\ed . IQ PaNLVWaQ, M-PKLOaQd PKD dR QRW IaOO XQdeU PMDC¶V dRPaLQ bXW HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ¶V dRPaLQ ZKLcK66LV a deSaUWPeQW aQd UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ RI PXQMab GRYeUQPeQW aIWeU 18WK APeQdPeQW [ASSeQdL[ A,48].1033.5.2 AdminisWraWiYeTKLV LVVXe ZLOO be dLVcXVVed XQdeU WKe WKUee IROORZLQJ VXb WKePeV:(L) LacN RI UXOe RI OaZ(LL) CRUUXSWLRQ(LLL) PRRU GRYeUQaQce3.5.2.1 LacN RI UXOe RI OaZTKe PaLQ cRQceUQ WKaW aOO RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV KaYe UaLVed LV WKe OacN RI UXOe RI OaZ WKaWLQWeUacWV ZLWK PaQ\ RWKeU LVVXeV aV caQ be VeeQ LQ FLJXUe 4. LaUJeU LVVXeV VXcK aV LQaSSURSULaWeaSSRLQWPeQWV LQ Ne\ SRVLWLRQV (VXcK aV UeJXOaWRU\ aJeQcLeV, KRVSLWaOV aQd PedLcaO cROOeJeV),SROLWLcaO LQWeUIeUeQce aQd cRQIOLcW aPRQJ acWRUV LQ SRVLWLRQV RI SRZeUV, cRUUXSWLRQ aQd SRRUSeUIRUPaQce aUe VRPe Ne\ LVVXeV WKaW VWeP IURP WKe OacN RI UXOe. We ZLOO e[SORUe WKe LVVXeV RIcRUUXSWLRQ aQd SRRU SeUIRUPaQce LQ WKe XScRPLQJ VecWLRQV. HRZeYeU, LW LV cUXcLaO WR XQdeUVWaQdWKaW aOWKRXJK Ze aUe e[SORULQJ WKe YaULRXV WKePeV aQd VXb WKePeV RI WKe LVVXeV WKaW MSaRDadYRcaWe XQdeU YaULRXV VecWLRQV, WKe\ aUe LQ UeaOLW\ VWURQJO\ LQWeUcRQQecWed aQd VKRXOd beRbVeUYed aV VXcK.TKe YeU\ dLUecW LPSacWV RI OacN RI UXOe RI OaZ WKaW caQ be VeeQ aUe WKe OacN RI PeULW, LQaSSURSULaWeaSSRLQWPeQWV aQd cRQIOLcW beWZeeQ SRZeU acWRUV RYeU WKe e[WeQW RI WKeLU aXWKRULWLeV OeadLQJ WRcRUUXSWLRQ, SRRU JRYeUQaQce aQd WKe cRQVeTXeQW cKaRV ZKLcK caQ be VeeQ LQ bRWK WKe edXcaWLRQ67aQd cOLQLcaO dRPaLQV. TKe e[aPSOeV RI WKeVe LVVXeV LQ WKe edXcaWLRQ dRPaLQ aUe aOUead\dLVcXVVed LQ deWaLO LQ SecWLRQ 3.5.1. BeORZ LV a SRVW IURP YDA SLQdK WKaW deSLcWV WKLV ZKROe ZebRI LQWeUcRQQecWed LVVXeV aQd WKeLU WUaQVceQdLQJ LPSacWV RQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP. [ASSeQdL[ A,49]49. "TZR RffLcLaOV fURP WKe DeSaUWPeQW Rf HeaOWK aUe fLJKWLQJ ZLWK eacK RWKeU WR eVWabOLVK WKeLU aXWKRULW\aW X HRVSLWaO aQd Y UQLYeUVLW\«..TKe cXUUeQW adPLQLVWUaWLRQ LV WKUeaWeQLQJ dRcWRUV aQd SRVWJUadXaWeV(PGV), ZaUQLQJ WKaW Lf WKe\ VSeaN RXW, WKe\ ZLOO be aSSUeKeQded b\ WKe LQVWLWXWLRQV aQd UXVWLcaWed. IV WKLV aXQLYeUVLW\ RU VRPe baQaQa UeSXbOLc?..... BRWK WKe cXUUeQW aQd SUeYLRXV adPLQLVWUaWLRQV KaYe WKe VaPeaJeQda, ZKLcK LV RQO\ fRcXVed RQ VeOf-SURPRWLRQ aQd adYaQcePeQW."3.5.2.2 CRUUXSWLRQFLQaQcLaO cRUUXSWLRQ LV a UecXUUeQW WKePe WKaW aSSeaUV LQ YaULRXV IRUPV acURVV PedLcaO edXcaWLRQVXcK aV LPSRVLQJ KeaY\ ILQeV RQ VWXdeQWV RU cRUUXSWLRQ LQ PRQeWaU\ IXQdV. [ASSeQdL[ A, 50].FLQaQcLaO cRUUXSWLRQ LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe bXdJeW WKaW LV dLVWULbXWed acURVV WKe V\VWeP KaV IaUUeacKLQJ aQd PXOWL-Oa\eUed LPSacWV cRPSURPLVLQJ WKe VaIeW\ aQd ZeOObeLQJ RI WKe KeaOWKcaUeZRUNeUV aQd aOVR WKe TXaOLW\ aQd acceVV WR KeaOWKcaUe IacLOLWLeV. TKe SRVW beORZ JLYeV a VQLSSeW RIWKe deWaLOed SRVW LQ ASSeQdL[ A, 51 WKaW SaLQWV a deWaLOed SLcWXUe RI cRUUXSWLRQ aQd LWV LPSacW LQWKe e[LVWLQJ KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP LQ PaNLVWaQ.51."YDA DG KKaQ /PXQMab: DXe WR WKe LQcRPSeWeQce Rf WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ LQ TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO «. aSaWLeQW adPLWWed WR WKe ICU ORVW WKeLU OLfe dXe WR aQ R[\JeQ c\OLQdeU e[SORVLRQ«.68DXe WR WKe LQcRPSeWeQW adPLQLVWUaWLRQ, WKe KRVSLWaO KaV becRPe a deaWK WUaS. TKUee \eaUV aJR, SaWLeQWVdLed dXe WR WKe ceVVaWLRQ Rf R[\JeQ VXSSO\. AfWeUZaUdV, WKe SRZeU VXSSO\ ZaV LQWeUUXSWed LQ WKe ICU, aQdfRU VL[ KRXUV, dRcWRUV aQd VWaff SURYLded aUWLfLcLaO UeVSLUaWLRQ WR WKe SaWLeQWV RQ WKeLU RZQ, ZKLOe WKeadPLQLVWUaWLRQ UePaLQed VLOeQW VSecWaWRUV«..A PaQ QaUURZO\ eVcaSed deaWK afWeU a OLfW aW WKe WUaXPaceQWeU PaOfXQcWLRQed a ZeeN aJR.AQ eOecWULc cabOe ZRUWK 8 PLOOLRQ fURP WKe QeZ bXLOdLQJ ZaV VWROeQ. NR UeVXOW Rf LWV LQYeVWLJaWLRQ eLWKeU.EacK WLPe, aQ LQQRceQW MXQLRU dRcWRU LV Pade a VcaSeJRaW aQd dLVPLVVed fURP WKeLU MRb."OWKeU IRUPV RI ILQaQcLaO cRUUXSWLRQ LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP KaYe beeQ UeSRUWed abRXW WKeWa[aWLRQ SROLc\ ZKeUe UeVLdeQWV aQd dRcWRUV ZeUe IRUced WR Sa\ Wa[eV XQdeU a SROLc\ WKaW WKe HLJKCRXUW Kad WaNeQ a VWa\ RQ [ASSeQdL[ A, 52].3.5.2.3 PRRU JRYeUQaQceYDA SLQdK, UeSRUWed RI LOOeJaO cOLQLcV RSeUaWLQJ XQdeU XQTXaOLILed LQdLYLdXaOV, OeadLQJ WR SaWLeQWKaUP aQd ORVV RI OLIe. TKLV VLWXaWLRQ ZaV e[aceUbaWed b\ WKe OacN RI acWLRQ IURP WKe SLQdKGRYeUQPeQW, HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW, aQd HeaOWK CRPPLVVLRQ, ZKLcK ZeUe accXVed RI IaLOLQJ WRcOaPS dRZQ RQ VXcK PaOSUacWLceV [ASSeQdL[ A, 53]. YDA PXQMab addUeVVed YaULRXV LVVXeV VXcKaV, deOa\ LQ WKe aSSURYed HeaOWK PURIeVVLRQaO AOORZaQce, adPLQLVWUaWLYe LUUeJXOaULWLeV, VeYeUedLIILcXOWLeV LQ WUeaWPeQW dXe WR VWaII VKRUWaJeV, YacaQc\ PaQaJePeQW aQd UeVRXUce aOORcaWLRQ LQKRVSLWaOV [ASSeQdL[ A, 54]. TKe JRYeUQPeQW LQ KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa, ZaV cULWLcL]ed b\ YDAaQd PDA IRU WKe PLVPaQaJePeQW RI KeaOWK IacLOLW\ caUdV, ZLWK a dLVSURSRUWLRQaWe aOORcaWLRQ RIIXQdV WR SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV aW WKe e[SeQVe RI JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV. TKLV PLVaOORcaWLRQ beQeILWed69SULYaWe eQWLWLeV ZKLOe XQdeUPLQLQJ WKe TXaOLW\ aQd acceVVLbLOLW\ RI KeaOWKcaUe LQ SXbOLcLQVWLWXWLRQV. [ASSeQdL[ A, 55]55. "FUee PedLcaO facLOLWLeV aUe beLQJ WaNeQ aZa\ fURP SRRU SeRSOe LQ KPK. SWRS bOacNPaLOLQJ RQ KeaOWKfacLOLW\ caUdV WRda\.«..HeaOWK facLOLW\ caUdV aUe beLQJ aZaUded WR SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV. BeQefLWV Rf 46 bLOOLRQUXSeeV RXW Rf 52 bLOOLRQ UXSeeV KaYe beeQ JLYeQ WR SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV.«.WKeUe aUe WKeVe bLOOLRQV Rf UXSeeVJRLQJ aQd ZK\? WK\ aUe WKeVe bLOOLRQV Rf UXSeeV beLQJ beQefLWed WR WKeVe SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV? WK\ LV SRRUWUeaWPeQW aQd VXbVWaQdaUd PedLcLQeV beLQJ JLYeQ WR SaWLeQWV?TKeUe LV QR cKecN aQd baOaQce fURP WKeJRYeUQPeQW aQd WKe KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW, QR TXeVWLRQLQJ, ZK\??? - PDA"SLPLOaUO\, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ, UeSRUWed a dLUe OacN RI eVVeQWLaO PedLcaO LQIUaVWUXcWXUe, LQcOXdLQJQRQ-IXQcWLRQaO CT VcaQ, MRI, aQd caWK Oab PacKLQeV aW a KRVSLWaO IRU RYeU WZR aQd a KaOI \eaUVdXe WR WKe QeJOLJeQce aQd LQcRPSeWeQce RI KRVSLWaO adPLQLVWUaWLRQ aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW, VeYeUeO\LPSacWLQJ SaWLeQW caUe [ASSeQdL[ A, 56] IQ VKRUW, YaULRXV LVVXeV KLJKOLJKWLQJ V\VWePLc IaLOXUeV,QeJOLJeQce, aQd LQeIILcLeQcLeV ZeUe UeSRUWed b\ MSaRD acURVV WKe cRXQWU\.3.5.3 HealWhcare ZorkersTKLV LVVXe ZLOO be dLVcXVVed XQdeU WKe IROORZLQJ WZR VXb WKePeV L. EPSOR\PeQW aQd PURPRWLRQV,LL. WRUNLQJ CRQdLWLRQV3.5.3.1 EPSOR\PeQW aQd SURPRWLRQVTKe SUeVV UeOeaVeV aQd VWaWePeQWV IURP MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV acURVV dLIIeUeQW SURYLQceV LQPaNLVWaQ KLJKOLJKW VeYeUaO cULWLcaO LVVXeV cRQceUQLQJ ePSOR\PeQW LQdXcWLRQ, SURPRWLRQ, VaOaU\,aQd LQceQWLYeV IRU PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV. NXPeURXV cRQceUQV VXUURXQdLQJ WKe KeaOWKcaUe cLYLO70VeUYLce MRb V\VWeP acURVV aOO SURYLQceV RI WKe cRXQWU\ ZeUe UeSRUWed. YDA SLQdK RXWULJKWO\UeMecWed WKe SLQdK PXbOLc SeUYLce CRPPLVVLRQ¶V (SPSC) LQWeUYLeZ SURceVV IRU deQWaO VXUJeRQVdXe WR VLJQLILcaQW cRQceUQ UeJaUdLQJ WUaQVSaUeQc\ aQd PeULWRcUac\ LQ WKe UecUXLWPeQW SURceVV.[ASSeQdL[ A, 57] SPSC LV a VWaWXWRU\ bRd\ PaQdaWed WR e[aPLQe, VeOecW aQd UecRPPeQd WRSLQdK GRYeUQPeQW SeUVRQQeO IRU UecUXLWPeQW LQ e[ecXWLYe cLYLO VeUYLce SRVLWLRQV. TKe dePaQd IRUUe-LQWeUYLeZV ZLWK a WUaQVSaUeQW LQTXLU\ RQ aOOeJaWLRQV RI cRUUXSWLRQ, IaYRULWLVP, aQd a OacN RILQWeJULW\ LQ VeOecWLQJ caQdLdaWeV ZeUe Pade.57. "YDA SLQdK cRPSOeWeO\ UeMecWV LQWeUYLeZV WaNeQ b\ SPSC Rf deQWaO VXUJeRQV aQd dePaQdVUe-LQWeUYLeZV ZLWK WUaQVSaUeQW LQTXLU\«.. OQ RQe KaQd, WKeUe LV aOUead\ VeYeUe LQMXVWLce ZLWK deQWaOVXUJeRQV. 50 VeaWV ZeUe NeSW, RXW Rf ZKLcK WZR VeaWV ZeUe cXW, caQdLdaWeV ZKR VcRUed PRUe WKaQ 90 PaUNVaOVR faLOed. OQ WKe RWKeU KaQd, 2900 caQdLdaWeV fRU 50 VeaWV aSSeaUed LQ WKe WeVW. HaSSeQed...! - YDASLQdK"YDA PXQMab accXVed WKe GRYeUQPeQW RI PXQMab RI deOa\LQJ WKe SURPRWLRQ SURceVV IRU aVVRcLaWeSURIeVVRUV LQ WKe SXbOLc PedLcaO cROOeJeV, XVLQJ deOa\ WacWLcV, aQd SUeIeUULQJ UeWLUed SURIeVVRUVIRU aSSRLQWPeQWV LQ VSecLaOL]ed ILeOdV [ASSeQdL[ A, 58] TKe caOO IRU YROXQWeeU dRcWRUV WR aVVLVW aWWKe SLQdK SecUeWaULaW SRLQWV WR V\VWePLc LQeIILcLeQcLeV LQ KaQdOLQJ SURPRWLRQ SURceVVeV[ASSeQdL[ A, 59]. CRQceUQV RYeU WKe OacN RI YacaQcLeV aQd WKe caOO IRU WKe cUeaWLRQ RI QeZSRVLWLRQV IRU dRcWRUV ZeUe UeSRUWed b\ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ [ASSeQdL[ A, 60]. YDA BaORcKLVWaQOLQNed LW WR a cULWLcaO VKRUWaJe RI ePSOR\PeQW RSSRUWXQLWLeV IRU PedLcaO JUadXaWeV dXe WRQRQ-UeOeaVe RI SRVWV IRU SRVWJUadXaWe WUaLQeeV aQd KRXVe RIILceUV, OeadLQJ WR XQSaLd SRVLWLRQV aQde[SORLWaWLRQ RI dRcWRUV. AOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV KeaYLO\ cULWLcL]ed WKe OeJLVOaWLRQ WKaW e[WeQded WKe71UeWLUePeQW aJe IURP 60 WR 65 \eaUV, IRU LWV adYeUVe LPSacW RQ WKe caUeeU SURJUeVVLRQ RI \RXQJeUdRcWRUV.3.5.3.2 WRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQVIQ WKLV VecWLRQ, WKe WKUee PaLQ cRQceUQV WKaW MSaRDa KaYe UaLVed aUe ORZ VaOaULeV aQdLQcUePeQWV, VaIeW\ aQd VecXULW\, ZRUNSOace KaUaVVPeQW aQd bXOO\LQJ.TKe cKaOOeQJeV cRQceUQLQJ VaOaULeV aQd LQcUePeQWV IRU MSaRD acURVV YaULRXV SURYLQceV LQPaNLVWaQ UaQJed IURP XQUeOeaVed VaOaULeV, dLVcUeSaQcLeV LQ Sa\ acURVV SURYLQceV, dePaQdV IRUVaOaU\ KLNeV LQ OLQe ZLWK LQIOaWLRQ, aQd XQPeW SURPLVeV UeJaUdLQJ HeaOWK PURIeVVLRQaO AOORZaQceVaQd Ke\ PeUIRUPaQce IQdLcaWRUV [ASSeQdL[ A, 61]. YDA PXQMab dePaQded VaOaU\ SaULW\ ZLWKWKeLU cRXQWeUSaUWV LQ SLQdK aQd KPK, KLJKOLJKWLQJ UeJLRQaO Sa\ dLVSaULWLeV aV a VLJQLILcaQW LVVXe.PeUVLVWeQW LVVXeV UeOaWed WR aSSRLQWPeQW SURceVVeV aQd XQPeW dePaQdV IRU VaOaU\ LQcUePeQWV KaYeOed WR SURORQJed VWULNeV, QRWabO\ a 12-da\ cRPSOeWe OPD VWULNe LQ RQe cLW\ aQd cRQWLQXRXVSURWeVWV aW aQRWKeU KRVSLWaO RI a dLIIeUeQW cLW\ dXe WR XQSaLd VaOaULeV IRU WZR PRQWKV [ASSeQdL[ A,61]. YDA SLQdK VWURQJO\ adYRcaWed IRU WKe LPPedLaWe UeOeaVe RI VaOaULeV IRU dRcWRUV LQ RQeKRVSLWaO, aQd caOOed IRU eTXaO Sa\ aW aQRWKeU KRVSLWaO LQdLcaWLQJ LQcRQVLVWeQcLeV LQ UePXQeUaWLRQacURVV WKe SURYLQce [ASSeQdL[ A, 62]. SLPLOaU VLWXaWLRQV aUe UeSRUWed IURP KPK aQd BaORcKLVWaQ[ASSeQdL[ A, 63].SaIeW\ aQd VecXULW\ RI KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV LV aQRWKeU UecXUUeQW cRQceUQ WKaW MSaRD KaYe VWURQJO\adYRcaWed IRU. TKe PRVW cRPPRQ XQdeUO\LQJ caXVeV WKaW KaYe ePeUJed IURP RXU daWaVeW acURVVaOO SURYLQceV SeUWaLQLQJ WR WKLV LVVXe aUe:72 LacN RI adeTXaWe VecXULW\ PeaVXUeV LQ KRVSLWaOV; CRUUXSWLRQ ZLWKLQ KRVSLWaO adPLQLVWUaWLRQV aQd WKe LQYROYePeQW RI e[WeUQaO IRUceV LQWKUeaWeQLQJ KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV; AbVeQce RI VWULcW SXQLWLYe PeaVXUeV aJaLQVW WKRVe ZKR KaUaVV RU aVVaXOW KeaOWKcaUeZRUNeUV; TKe OacN RI eIIecWLYe OeJaO IUaPeZRUNV RU WKe LPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI e[LVWLQJ OaZV WR SURWecWKeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV.AOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV KaYe UaLVed JUaYe cRQceUQV RYeU WKe WUeQd RI aJJUeVVLRQ WRZaUdV KeaOWKcaUeSURIeVVLRQaOV b\ KLJKOLJKWLQJ LQVWaQceV RI SK\VLcaO YLROeQce aJaLQVW dRcWRUV. TKe\ aWWULbXWed WKeOacN RI adeTXaWe VecXULW\ PeaVXUeV LQ KRVSLWaOV aV a VLJQLILcaQW IacWRU cRQWULbXWLQJ WR WKeVeLQcLdeQWV, SURPSWLQJ VRPe dRcWRUV WR cRQVLdeU OeaYLQJ WKe cRXQWU\ IRU VaIeU ZRUN eQYLURQPeQWV[ASSeQdL[ A, 64]. IQcLdeQWV RI KaUaVVPeQW aJaLQVW IePaOe KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV ZeUe SaUWLcXOaUO\KLJKOLJKWed b\ YDA KPK aQd PDA [ASSeQdL[ A, 65]. WKeQ YDA PXQMab adYRcaWed aJaLQVWWKUeaWV aQd SK\VLcaO YLROeQce RI MSaRD LQ a KRVSLWaO, LW Oed WR PaVV UeVLJQaWLRQV aQd a SURORQJedVWULNe [ASSeQdL[ A, 66]. TKe LQYROYePeQW RI LQdLYLdXaOV IRUPaOO\ aQd LQIRUPaOO\ cRQQecWed WRWKRVe LQ SRZeU LQ WKUeaWeQLQJ dRcWRUV KLJKOLJKWV a VLJQLILcaQW bUeacK RI VecXULW\ ZLWKLQ KeaOWKcaUeIacLOLWLeV. TKe VLWXaWLRQ ZaV IXUWKeU e[aceUbaWed b\ LQadeTXaWe UeVSRQVe IURP WKe KRVSLWaO'VadPLQLVWUaWLRQ aQd aOOeJed cRUUXSWLRQ, OeadLQJ WR a caOO IRU WKe UeSOacePeQW RI WKe PaQaJePeQWaQd SXQLWLYe acWLRQV aJaLQVW WKRVe VXSSRUWLQJ XQeWKLcaO SUacWLceV. SLPLOaUO\, WKe UeSRUWV RI KPKSROLce PRdLI\LQJ FIRV WR RPLW accXVaWLRQV Pade b\ KRVSLWaO VWaII aJaLQVW aWWacNeUV [ASSeQdL[ A,65]. MSaRD LQ YaULRXV ORcaWLRQV LQ SLQdK aOVR UeSRUW IacLQJ RSSUeVVLRQ aQd YLROeQce IURPPXOWLSOe VRXUceV, LQcOXdLQJ SaWLeQW UeOaWLYeV, SROLWLcaO acWLYLVWV, MRXUQaOLVWV, cLYLO VRcLeW\, aQd eYeQ73KRVSLWaO PaQaJePeQW. SSecLILc LQcLdeQWV, VXcK aV WKe PLVWUeaWPeQW RI a dRcWRU b\ a VeQLRUPedLcaO RIILceU, XQdeUVcRUeV WKe KRVWLOe ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV Iaced b\ VRPe KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV[ASSeQdL[ A, 67].67. " YRXQJ dRcWRUV VeUYLQJ LQ X HRVSLWaO aUe YLcWLPV Rf YaULRXV W\SeV Rf RSSUeVVLRQ aQd YLROeQce. OQ WKeRQe KaQd, dXe WR QRQ-aYaLOabLOLW\ Rf facLOLWLeV aQd PedLcLQeV LQ WKe KRVSLWaO, WKe WRUWXUe JLYeQ b\ WKeaWWeQdaQWV Rf WKe SaWLeQWV, SROLWLcaO acWLYLVWV, MRXUQaOLVWV aQd cLYLO VRcLeW\ dXULQJ WKe dXW\ aQd RQ WKe RWKeUKaQd, WKe \RXQJ dRcWRUV aUe WRUWXUed b\ WKe PaQaJePeQW. - YDA SLQdK"YDA BaORcKLVWaQ KaYe UeSRUWed IacLQJ UeYeQJe acWLRQV IURP WKe KRVSLWaO adPLQLVWUaWLRQ LQaWWePSWV WR e[SRVe cRUUXSWLRQ RI WKe KRVSLWaO adPLQLVWUaWLRQ, OeadLQJ WR WR[Lc, abXVLYe ZRUNLQJeQYLURQPeQW IRU KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUVWRUNSOace KaUaVVPeQW aQd bXOO\LQJ VWaQdV RXW aV VLJQLILcaQW, UecXUUeQW WKePeV ZLWKLQ WKeVSecWUXP RI LVVXeV MSaRD acWLYeO\ cKaPSLRQ. TKe SULPaU\ dULYeUV RI ZRUNSOace KaUaVVPeQW aQdbXOO\LQJ eQcRXQWeUed b\ MSaRD acURVV aOO SURYLQceV aUe OLVWed beORZ. TKeVe IacWRUV Oead WRZRUNSOace KaUaVVPeQW aQd bXOO\LQJ LQ WKe IRUP RI XQIaLU WUaQVIeUV, VXVSeQVLRQV aQd WeUPLQaWLRQVaVLde IURP IaOVe OeJaO SURceedLQJV VXcK aV FIRV aQd cRXUW caVeV. AdPLQLVWUaWLYe OYeUUeacK aQd MLVXVe RI PRZeU; SecXULW\ FaLOXUeV; LeJaO aQd S\VWePLc BLaV.YDA SLQdK UeSRUWed WKe VXVSeQVLRQ RI dRcWRUV b\ WKe aXWKRULWLeV aV aQ acW RI aJe-ROd RSSUeVVLRQZLWKLQ WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\. TKe caXVe RI WKe LQcLdeQW ZaV WKe SeUceLYed PLVXVe RI74adPLQLVWUaWLYe SRZeUV, ZKeUe OeJLWLPaWe UeTXeVWV IRU WKe SURWecWLRQ RI dRcWRUV' ULJKWV aUe LJQRUedRU PLVcRQVWUXed, OeadLQJ WR SXQLWLYe acWLRQV VXcK aV XQIaLU VXVSeQVLRQV [ASSeQdL[ A, 68]. YDAPXQMab UeJaUded WKe LQcLdeQW RI WKe abdXcWLRQ aQd NLOOLQJ RI a dRcWRU aOOeJedO\ b\ PePbeUV RI WKeVWaWe'V CRXQWeU-TeUURULVP DeSaUWPeQW a JUaYe LQVWaQce RI KaUaVVPeQW aQd LQWLPLdaWLRQ aJaLQVWPedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV [ASSeQdL[ A, 69]. ReSRUWV RI IaOVe FIRV aJaLQVW dRcWRUV IRU LQcLdeQWV VXcKaV WKe dLVaSSeaUaQce RI QeZbRUQV ZeUe aOVR cKaOOeQJed b\ YDA PXQMab [ASSeQdL[ A, 70]. YDAKPK WKURXJK WKe LQcLdeQW RI PRdLILcaWLRQ RI SROLce UeSRUWV WR e[cOXde cKaUJeV Pade b\ KRVSLWaOVWaII aJaLQVW aJJUeVVRUV, aOVR LQdLcaWed V\VWePLc bLaV aQd OeJaO V\VWeP¶V VKRUWcRPLQJV [ASSeQdL[A, 65].70. "CaVe Rf faNe FIRV aJaLQVW dRcWRUV. FIRV ZeUe UeJLVWeUed aJaLQVW dRcWRUV fRU WKe dLVaSSeaUaQce RfQeZbRUQ babLeV LQ WZR cLWLeV, KRZeYeU, WKe babLeV ZeUe OaWeU UecRYeUed fURP WKe VaPe faPLO\. OQ WKeVSecLaO VXJJeVWLRQ Rf PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab, CKLef MLQLVWeU PXQMab KaV LVVXed cRXQWeU FIR RUdeUVaJaLQVW WKeVe faPLOLeV fRU KaUaVVLQJ dRcWRUV aQd fLOLQJ faNe FIRV.YDA BaORcKLVWaQ, UaLVed cRQceUQV UeJaUdLQJ PLVbeKaYLRU ZLWK PedLcaO VWaII b\ VecXULW\SeUVRQQeO dXULQJ VIP YLVLWV, aQd WKe JeQeUaO dLVUXSWLRQ caXVed b\ SROLWLcaO YLVLWV aQd VIPSURWRcROV LQ KRVSLWaOV.71. "YDA BaORcKLVWaQ: DeVSLWe beLQJ a dRcWRU LQ «.. HRVSLWaO, QXeWWa, WKe MLQLVWeU Rf HeaOWK eQWeUedZLWK WKe eQWLUe VecXULW\ SeUVRQQeO bUeaNLQJ WKe SURWRcRO Rf WKe RSeUaWLRQ WKeaWeU aQd PLVbeKaYLQJ ZLWK WKedRcWRU RQ dXW\. SWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKe cXUUeQW cRUUXSW aQd XVeOeVV JRYeUQPeQW WKaW LV caXVLQJ daPaJe LQWKe eQYLURQPeQW Rf JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV."753.5.4 HealWhcare resoXrcesTKe e[aPLQaWLRQ RI KeaOWKcaUe UeVRXUceV cKaOOeQJeV Iaced b\ MSaRD acURVV PaNLVWaQ UeYeaOV acRQceUQLQJ SaWWeUQ RI V\VWePLc IaLOXUeV, LQIUaVWUXcWXUaO deILcLeQcLeV LQcOXdLQJ PedLcaO aQdcOLQLcaO UeVRXUceV, OacN RI KXPaQ UeVRXUce aQd adPLQLVWUaWLYe QeJOecW WKaW VLJQLILcaQWO\ LPSedeWKe TXaOLW\ RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\.Table 3 - HealWhcare ResoXrces IssXes HighlighWed b\ MSaRDProYince IssXesSLQdK(YDA)AbVeQce RI KRVWeOV IRU SRVWJUadXaWe dRcWRUVIQadeTXaWe PedLcaO IacLOLWLeV aQd ePeUJeQc\ VeUYLceV. [ASSeQdL[ A, 72]PXQMab(YDA,DWM,PMSUP)RRRI cROOaSVe LQcLdeQW LQ a PedLcaO cROOeJe UeVXOWLQJ LQ IaWaOLW\. [ASSeQdL[ A, 73]HRVSLWaOV OacNLQJ eVVeQWLaO aPeQLWLeV (aLU cRQdLWLRQLQJ, eOecWULcLW\).IQIUaVWUXcWXUe deILcLeQcLeV aIIecWLQJ SaWLeQW caUe aQd VWaII ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV.[ASSeQdL[ A, 74]KPK (YDA)PDAAbVeQce RI adeTXaWe KRVWeO IacLOLWLeV IRU KRXVe RIILceUV aQd PedLcaO RIILceUV.MaOIXQcWLRQLQJ CT VcaQ PacKLQeV.LacN RI PedLcLQeV aQd WeVWV LQ KRVSLWaOV. [ASSeQdL[ A, 75]BaORcKLVWaQ(YDA)BXUQLQJ RI JRYeUQPeQW PedLcLQeV deVSLWe VKRUWaJeV. [ASSeQdL[ A, 76]PRRU VWaWe RI caUdLRORJ\ VeUYLceV.MaOIXQcWLRQLQJ RI aQJLRJUaSK\ PacKLQeV, LRQJ-VWaQdLQJ OacN RI PedLcLQeV, VecXULW\,aQd eVVeQWLaO IacLOLWLeV LQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV. [ASSeQdL[ A.56]76TKe cROOecWLYe aQaO\VLV RI WKeVe LVVXeV UeYeaOV a VWaUN dLVcRQQecW beWZeeQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP'VadPLQLVWUaWLYe IXQcWLRQV aQd WKe QeedV RI LWV IURQWOLQe ZRUNeUV aQd SaWLeQWV. WKLOe WKeUe aUeLVROaWed eIIRUWV WRZaUdV LPSURYePeQW, aV QRWed LQ BaORcKLVWaQ ZLWK WKe SURSRVaO WR XSJUadeKRVSLWaOV WR WeacKLQJ VWaWXV, WKeVe aUe RYeUVKadRZed b\ WKe RYeUZKeOPLQJ cKaOOeQJeV WKaW SeUVLVWdXe WR V\VWePLc QeJOecW aQd PLVPaQaJePeQW.3.5.5 Social aZareness and social jXsWiceTKe UeSRUWV IURP YaULRXV SURYLQceV LQ PaNLVWaQ KLJKOLJKW a UaQJe RI VRcLaO aZaUeQeVV aQd VRcLaOMXVWLce LVVXeV WKaW MSaRD aUe adYRcaWLQJ IRU. TKe UeSRUWV IURP YaULRXV SURYLQceV LQ PaNLVWaQKLJKOLJKW a UaQJe RI KeaOWK aZaUeQeVV LVVXeV WKaW MSaRD aUe adYRcaWLQJ IRU. YDA SLQdK UaLVedaZaUeQeVV abRXW WKe eSLdePLc RI cRQMXQcWLYLWLV aQd RUJaQL]ed VePLQaUV RQ WRUOd HeSaWLWLV Da\2023 LQ KaUacKL WR adYRcaWe IRU UeVeaUcK, aZaUeQeVV, aQd eIIRUWV WRZaUdV WKe eOLPLQaWLRQ RI WKLVJORbaO KeaOWK cKaOOeQJe. IQ PeVKaZaU, KPK, YDA aQd PDA dLVcXVVed eQKaQcLQJ SaWLeQW caUe b\addUeVVLQJ LVVXeV VXcK aV XQLQWeUUXSWed eOecWULcLW\ VXSSO\ aQd IacLOLWaWLQJ SaWLeQW acceVV WRcRQVXOWaQWV. SLPLOaUO\, YDA PXQMab, YDA KPK aQd PDA cULWLTXed WKe LQVXUaQce SROLcLeV,adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKeLU UeIRUPV LQ WKe UeVSecWLYe SURYLQceV.IQ WeUPV RI VRcLaO MXVWLce, YDA SLQdK e[SUeVVed VROLdaULW\ ZLWK PaNLVWaQL CKULVWLaQV, adYRcaWLQJIRU UeOLJLRXV eTXaOLW\, Seace, bURWKeUKRRd, aQd WKe eUadLcaWLRQ RI e[WUePLVP. YDA PXQMabSaUWLcLSaWed LQ SURWeVWV aJaLQVW LQIOaWLRQ, XQePSOR\PeQW, aQd SROLcLeV aIIecWLQJ JRYeUQPeQWePSOR\eeV, LQcOXdLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SURIeVVLRQaOV, UeIOecWLQJ a bURadeU adYRcac\ IRU VRcLaO MXVWLce,aLPLQJ IRU IaLU WUeaWPeQW, ULJKWV, aQd cRQdLWLRQV IRU aOO JRYeUQPeQW ePSOR\eeV. IQ BaORcKLVWaQ,LQcLdeQWV RI OLQJXLVWLc dLVcULPLQaWLRQ LQ KeaOWKcaUe ZeUe KLJKOLJKWed, ZLWK YDA BaORcKLVWaQ77adYRcaWLQJ IRU SaWLeQW WUeaWPeQW ZLWKRXW dLVcULPLQaWLRQ aQd cRQdePQLQJ aWWLWXdeV WKaW IRVWeUdLYLVLRQ ZLWKLQ VRcLeW\.3.5.6 OYerall comparisonIQ WKLV VecWLRQ, Ze ZLOO cRQcLVeO\ cRPSaUe aQd VXPPaUL]e WKe VLPLOaULWLeV aQd dLIIeUeQceV aPRQJWKe YaULRXV RUJaQL]aWLRQV baVed RQ WKe baUcKaUWV aQd cRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ VcRUe.TKe ILUVW baUcKaUW (FLJXUe 5) UeSUeVeQWV WKe WRS 25 LVVXeV WKaW WKe YaULRXV MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQVLQ PaNLVWaQ KaYe adYRcaWed IRU. TKe WZR PaLQ cRQceUQV - AdPLQLVWUaWLRQ aQd IQcRPSeWeQc\ aUeVXSSOePeQWLQJ WKe UeVXOWV RI WKe TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV (FLJXUe 4). TKeVe WZR PRVW cRPPRQ LVVXeVVXSSRUW WKaW MSaRD aUe IUeTXeQWO\ deaOLQJ ZLWK adPLQLVWUaWLYe cKaOOeQJeV, IURP ZKLcK VWePV aYaVW UaQJe RI RWKeU LVVXeV WKURXJKRXW WKe YaULRXV OeYeOV RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP²IURP QaWLRQaOOeYeO bXUeaXcUac\ WR ORcaO adPLQLVWUaWLYe baUULeUV LQ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd SaWLeQW caUe. WKLOeFLJXUe 6 SUeVeQWV a cRPSaUaWLYe aQaO\VLV RI WKe WRS 25 LVVXeV WKaW WKe YaULRXV MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQadYRcaWe.78FLJXUH 5 - BaU GUaSK OI TRS 25 IVVXHV HLJKOLJKWHG B\ MSaRD FLJXUH 6 - BaU GUaSK OI TRS 25 IVVXHV B\ EaFK MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQ0AOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV e[ceSW PMSUP aQd DWM KaYe KLJKOLJKWed ³AdPLQLVWUaWLRQ´ aV WKe PRVWcRPPRQ LVVXeV (FLJXUe 6), e[ceSW PMSUP. DWM KaV KLJKOLJKWed LW WKe PRVW aPRQJ RWKeULVVXeV KRZeYeU WKe RYeUaOO cRXQW LV ORZ (9), ZKLOe IRU PMSUP LW LV QRW WKe PRVW KLJKOLJKWed LVVXebXW LWV cRXQW LV VLPLOaU WR DWM (8). TKe LVVXeV PMSUP KaV KLJKOLJKWed WKe PRVW aUe³E[aPLQaWLRQ´ (58), WKeQ ³IQcRPSeWeQc\´ (24) UeIeUULQJ WR WKe LQcRPSeWeQce RI WKe aXWKRULWLeVaPRQJ edXcaWLRQaO ³IQVWLWXWLRQ´ (13). TKLV UeIOecWV WKeLU XQLTXe IRcXV RQ e[aPLQaWLRQ aQdLQVWLWXWLRQV LQdLcaWLQJ a WaUJeWed adYRcac\ WRZaUdV LPSURYLQJ WKe edXcaWLRQ V\VWeP IRU PedLcaOVWXdeQWV aV WKe UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RI WKaW cRKRUW VSecLILcaOO\.³CRUUXSWLRQ´ LV aQRWKeU IUeTXeQW LVVXe PeQWLRQed b\ YDA aQd PDA bXW WKe IUeTXeQc\ LV VWaUNO\KLJK IRU bRWK RUJaQL]aWLRQV IURP KPK, PDA (47) aQd YDA KPK (20). ³FacLOLWLeV´ LV WKe WRScRQceUQ IRU YDA BaORcKLVWaQ, bXW QRW aV PXcK IRU RWKeU RUJaQL]aWLRQV, UeIOecWLQJ VSecLILcUeJLRQaO cKaOOeQJeV UeOaWed WR WKe LQIUaVWUXcWXUe RI KeaOWKcaUe VeUYLceV LQ WKe SURYLQce. OYeUaOO,ZKLOe WKeUe aUe VKaUed cRQceUQV aPRQJ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV, SaUWLcXOaUO\ UeJaUdLQJ WKeadPLQLVWUaWLRQ RI KeaOWKcaUe aQd PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ, eacK RUJaQL]aWLRQ aOVR KaV dLVWLQcW SULRULWLeVWKaW aUe VKaSed b\ WKe VSecLILc QeedV aQd cLUcXPVWaQceV RI WKeLU UeJLRQ RU IRcXV aUeaV aV RbVeUYedLQ FLJXUe 6.TKe KeaW PaS (FLJXUe 7) VKRZLQJ cRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ VcRUeV RIIeUV IXUWKeU LQVLJKW LQWR WKecRPSaULVRQ RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV baVed RQ WKe LVVXeV WKaW WKe\ adYRcaWe IRU. PMSUP, dLVSOa\VORZ VLPLOaULW\ ZLWK aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV eVSecLaOO\ ZLWK PDA (0.16). TKLV YaOLdaWeV WKe UeVXOWV RI WKeTXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV aQd cRPSaUaWLYe aQaO\VLV RQ LVVXeV LQ FLJXUe 6, VXJJeVWLQJ LWV XQLTXeadYRcac\ aJeQda ZKLcK LV VSecLILcaOO\ WaUJeWed WRZaUdV XQdeUJUadXaWe edXcaWLRQ LVVXeV. PDA81aQd YDA KPK KaYe WKe KLJKeVW VLPLOaULW\ VcRUe (0.91) acURVV WKe bRaUd, LPSO\LQJ QeaUO\LdeQWLcaO adYRcac\ LVVXeV VXJJeVWLQJ UeJLRQaO VLPLOaULWLeV, aJaLQ UeIOecWLYe RI WKe SUeYLRXV UeVXOWV.YDA SLQdK KaV VWURQJ VLPLOaULWLeV ZLWK YDA KPK (0.86), a JRRd deJUee RI cRPPRQaOLW\ ZLWKYDA PXQMab aQd PDA (0.78) aQd a cRQVLdeUabOe aOLJQPeQW ZLWK DWM (0.77) RQ LVVXeV. YDAPXQMab VKaUeV a VXbVWaQWLaO QXPbeU VLPLOaULW\ ZLWK YDA KPK aQd DWM (0.72), bXW VOLJKWO\ OeVVZLWK PDA (0.65) aQd YDA BaORcKLVWaQ (0.66) VXJJeVWLQJ VRPe VKaUed cRQceUQV bXW aOVR VRPedLVWLQcW SULRULWLeV. YDA BaORcKLVWaQ KaV PRdeUaWe VLPLOaULW\ (0.58 - 0.68) ZLWK PRVWRUJaQL]aWLRQV e[ceSW IRU PMSUP (0.16). TKLV LQdLcaWeV VRPe cORVeO\ aOLJQed LVVXeV ZLWK RWKeURUJaQL]aWLRQV bXW VRPe dLVWLQcW UeJLRQaO LVVXeV VXcK aV UeVRXUceV aQd IacLOLWLeV aV UeIOecWed LQ WKe(FLJXUe 6). SLPLOaUO\, DWM KaV PRdeUaWe VLPLOaULW\ acURVV WKe bRaUd, LQdLcaWLQJ a baOaQced VeWRI cRPPRQ LVVXeV ZLWK RWKeU RUJaQL]aWLRQV (0.62 - 0.77) IW VKaUeV WKe PRVW VLPLOaULW\ RQ LVVXeVZLWK YDA SLQdK.82FLJXUH 7 - HHaW MaS OI CRVLQH SLPLOaULW\ SFRUHV BaVHG RQ AGYRFaF\ IVVXHV RI VaULRXV MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV33.6 The AdYocac\ sWraWegies of MSaRD organi]aWionsTKe YaULRXV VWUaWeJLeV WKaW MSaRD ePSOR\ ZLOO be e[SORUed XQdeU WKUee PaLQ WKePeV:1. CRaOLWLRQ2. NRQ-dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV3. DLVUXSWLYe SWUaWeJLeV."CRaOLWLRQ" aPRQJ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LV VWXdLed VeSaUaWeO\ aV LW LQIOXeQceV bRWK QRQ-dLVUXSWLYeaQd dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV.FigXre 8 - The VarioXs AdYocac\ SWraWegies Emplo\ed b\ MSaRD Organi]aWions843.6.1 CoaliWionTKe cRaOLWLRQ VWUaWeJLeV aPRQJ YaULRXV KeaOWKcaUe RUJaQL]aWLRQV VKRZcaVe a XQLILed eIIRUW WRaddUeVV VSecLILc LVVXeV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU acURVV dLIIeUeQW UeJLRQV RI PaNLVWaQ. TKeVeSaUWQeUVKLSV dePRQVWUaWe a VWUaWeJLc cROOabRUaWLRQ aPRQJ dRcWRUV, QXUVeV, SaUaPedLcV, aQd RWKeUKeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV WR adYRcaWe IRU cRPPRQ caXVeV VXcK aV SURWeVW aJaLQVW adPLQLVWUaWLRQacWLRQV, dePaQdV IRU eTXaO VaOaU\ LQcUeaVeV, SRVWSRQePeQW RI e[aPLQaWLRQV, LPSURYePeQW RIKRVSLWaO cRQdLWLRQV, aQd UeVLVWaQce aJaLQVW QeJaWLYe SURSaJaQda. TabOe 4 beORZ RXWOLQeV KRZeacK RUJaQL]aWLRQ KaV SaUWQeUed XS ZLWK YaULRXV RWKeU eQWLWLeV RU JURXSV.Table 4 - CoaliWion ParWners of MSaRD Organi]aWionsOrgani]aWion CoaliWion ParWners AcWions and AdYocac\DWM MedLcaO cROOeJe VWXdeQWVPURWeVWed aJaLQVW WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ'V LOOeJaO acWLRQVaQd XVe RI IRUce aW a PedLcaO cROOeJe. [ASSeQdL[ A,77]DWM & YDAPXQMabLad\ KeaOWK ZRUNeUV,QXUVeV, SaUaPedLcaO VWaIIOUJaQL]ed SURWeVWV dePaQdLQJ eTXaO VaOaU\ LQcUeaVeVIROORZLQJ WKe 2023 bXdJeW. [ASSeQdL[ A, 78]YDA PXQMabYRXQJ NXUVeV AVVRcLaWLRQPXQMab, KeaOWK deSaUWPeQWRUJaQL]aWLRQVCaOOed a SUeVV cRQIeUeQce WR addUeVV cRUUXSWLRQ,LQcRPSeWeQce, aQd PLVcRQdXcW LQ WKe KeaOWKdeSaUWPeQW, dePaQdLQJ accRXQWabLOLW\ aQd UeIRUPV.[ASSeQdL[ A, 66]YDA PXQMab AOO PaNLVWaQ COeUNV SWaJed SURWeVWV RYeU LQIOaWLRQ, XQePSOR\PeQW,85Organi]aWion CoaliWion ParWners AcWions and AdYocac\AVVRcLaWLRQ, YaULRXVJRYeUQPeQW ePSOR\eeV¶RUJaQL]aWLRQVePSOR\ee SROLcLeV, aQd dePaQded VeUYLce VWUXcWXUeUeIRUPV aQd VecXULW\ bLOO LPSOePeQWaWLRQV, OeadLQJ WRa VLW-LQ. [ASSeQdL[ A, 79]PDA & YDAKPKYDA aQd PDA WRJeWKeUNXUVLQJ aVVRcLaWLRQV,SaUaPedLcaO VWaIIaVVRcLaWLRQVSWaQce aJaLQVW KaUaVVPeQW aOOeJaWLRQV ZLWKLQKeaOWKcaUe IacLOLWLeV [ASSeQdL[ A, 80]. AddUeVVedKaUaVVPeQW aOOeJaWLRQV aQd RUJaQL]ed SURWeVWV aJaLQVWQRQ-Sa\PeQW RI VaOaULeV aQd V\VWePLc LVVXeV LQKeaOWKcaUe. [ASSeQdL[ A, 81] FRUPed WKe GUaQdSXUJLcaO SSecLaOWLeV CRRUdLQaWLRQ CRXQcLO. [ASSeQdL[A, 82]YDABaORcKLVWaQPaNLVWaQ MedLcaOAVVRcLaWLRQ BaORcKLVWaQ,YaULRXV KeaOWKcaUe aQdQXUVLQJ aVVRcLaWLRQVFRUPed aQ aOOLaQce WR LPSURYe cRQdLWLRQV LQ QXeWWaKRVSLWaOV aQd UeVLVW QeJaWLYe SURSaJaQda. [ASSeQdL[A, 83]YDA SLQdKSWXdeQWV, SaUeQWV, VRcLaOZRUNeUV, \RXQJ dRcWRUVAdYRcaWed IRU WKe SRVWSRQePeQW RI WKe MDCATSLQdK e[aPLQaWLRQ, UeVXOWLQJ LQ a deOa\. [ASSeQdL[ A,34]YDA GLOJLW YDA SLQdK, YDA KPKCROOabRUaWed WR bULQJ aWWeQWLRQ WR UeJLRQaO KeaOWKcaUeLVVXeV. [ASSeQdL[ A, 84]863.6.2 Non-disrXpWiYe sWraWegiesTKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV ePSOR\ a YaULeW\ RI QRQ-dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV VXcK aV PeeWLQJV,dLaORJXe, V\PbROLc acWLRQV (e.J., ZeaULQJ bOacN ULbbRQV), UeTXeVWV WKURXJK SUeVV UeOeaVeV, OeWWeUV,SeWLWLRQV, YLdeR PeVVaJeV WKURXJK VRcLaO aQd PaVV PedLa, ZaUQLQJV aQd XOWLPaWXPV WR JaUQeUaWWeQWLRQ WRZaUdV WKe LVVXeV RI LQWeUeVW, aQd XVLQJ OeJaO aYeQXeV. TKe e[SORUaWLRQ RI WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV VKRZcaVe a VWUaWeJLc aSSURacK WR adYRcac\, VWaUWLQJ IURP addUeVVLQJ ORcaO aQdLPPedLaWe cRQceUQV aW WKe KRVSLWaO RU XQLYeUVLW\ OeYeO, eVcaOaWLQJ WR cLW\ RU UeJLRQaO aXWKRULWLeV aVQeeded, eQJaJLQJ ZLWK SURYLQcLaO KeaOWK deSaUWPeQWV aQd XOWLPaWeO\ LQYRNLQJ IedeUaOaccRXQWabLOLW\ deSaUWPeQWV IRU bURadeU V\VWePLc LVVXeV. TKe XVe RI SXbOLc VWaWePeQWV aQd VRcLaOPedLa eQJaJePeQW VSaQV acURVV aOO OeYeOV, VeUYLQJ aV aQ LPSRUWaQW WRRO WR aPSOLI\ WKeLU PeVVaJe.Table 5 - Non-DisrXpWiYe SWraWegies Emplo\ed b\ MSaRD Organi]aWionsSWraWeg\ LeYel/Organi]aWion E[ampleMeeWLQJV /DLVcXVVLRQ /NeJRWLaWLRQVLRcaO AdPLQLVWUaWLRQ - AOODLVcXVVLRQV ZLWK VcKRRO/KRVSLWaO adPLQLVWUaWLRQ[ASSeQdL[ A, 85.86]PURYLQcLaO GRYeUQPeQW - ALLNeJRWLaWLRQV ZLWK SURYLQcLaO KeaOWK aQdUeJXOaWRU\ deSaUWPeQWV [ASSeQdL[ A, 87.88] .FedeUaO GRYeUQPeQW - YDAKPK, PDA, YDA PXQMabEQJaJePeQWV ZLWK IedeUaO eQWLWLeV [ASSeQdL[ A,89].PeWLWLRQV YDA SLQdK PeWLWLRQV IRU MDCAT UeRUJaQL]aWLRQ [SecWLRQ87SWraWeg\ LeYel/Organi]aWion E[ample3.5.1.1]LeJaO CaVeV AOOLeJaO acWLRQV aJaLQVW adPLQLVWUaWLYePLVPaQaJePeQW [ASSeQdL[ A, 90]. [ASSeQdL[A, 91].SRcLaO MedLa AOOSRcLaO PedLa caPSaLJQV aQd adYRcac\[ASSeQdL[ A, 92].MaVV MedLa AOOMaVV PedLa eQJaJePeQWV WR aPSOLI\ YRLce[ASSeQdL[ A, 93]S\PbROLc /PeaceIXO PURWeVWVYDA PXQMab, YDA SLQdK,YDA KPK, PDA, YDABaORcKLVWaQS\PbROLc acWLRQV OLNe ZeaULQJ bOacN ULbbRQV,SeaceIXO SURWeVWV [ASSeQdL[ A, ]WaUQLQJV AOOWaUQLQJV RI OeJaO caVeV aQd SXbOLc SURWeVWV[SecWLRQ 3.5.1.2]3.6.3 DisrXpWiYe sWraWegiesAOO MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV ePSOR\ VLPLOaU dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV, FLJXUe 8. PMSUP aQQRXQced WKeLQLWLaWLRQ RI a SURWeVW PRYePeQW acURVV PXQMab WR cKaOOeQJe aQd dePaQd UeYLVLRQV WR WKe QeZe[aPLQaWLRQ [ASSeQdL[ A, 94]. WKLOe DWM RUJaQL]ed cRPSOeWe bR\cRWWV RI OXWSaWLeQWDeSaUWPeQW (OPD) VeUYLceV acURVV WKe cRXQWU\, eVSecLaOO\ LQ PXQMab, aV a IRUP RI SURWeVW aJaLQVW88WKe ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV LQ KRVSLWaOV [ASSeQdL[ A, 95]. AddLWLRQaOO\, WKe\ aOVR RUcKeVWUaWed cOaVVbR\cRWWV aW a PedLcaO cROOeJe XQWLO WKeLU dePaQdV UeJaUdLQJ UeQRYaWLRQ RI WKe VWXdeQW KRVWeOVZeUe PeW [ASSeQdL[ A, 96]. DWM aOVR VXSSRUWed IRUeLJQ PedLcaO JUadXaWeV b\ SURWeVWLQJRXWVLde PMDC LQ IVOaPabad aJaLQVW WKe 70% NaWLRQaO ReVLdeQc\ E[aP SaVVLQJ cULWeULa,adYRcaWLQJ IRU LW WR be UedXced WR 50%. BRWK PMSUP bXW eVSecLaOO\ DWM ePSOR\ dLVUXSWLYeadYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV WKaW aUe cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ dLUecW acWLRQV VXcK aV SURWeVWV aQd VeUYLce bR\cRWWV.YDA SLQdK Pade a caOO IRU SURWeVW UeJaUdLQJ WKe MDCAT SaSeU OeaN ZLWK a ZLde UaQJe RISaUWLcLSaQWV VXcK aV PedLa, OaZ\eUV, cRPPXQLW\ PePbeUV, VWXdeQWV, aQd dRcWRUV RI aOO UaQNV[ASSeQdL[ A, 97].TKe deWaLOed SRVW, 98, IURP ASSeQdL[ A LV LOOXVWUaWLYe RI WKe YDA PXQMab'V VWUaWeJLc XVe RIdLVUXSWLYe WacWLcV [ASSeQdL[ A, 98]. TR VSRWOLJKW LVVXeV OLNe LQadeTXaWe IacLOLWLeV aQdadPLQLVWUaWLYe LQcRPSeWeQce, YDA PXQMab LQLWLaWed OPD VWULNeV. TKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ eVcaOaWed LWVSURWeVW acWLRQV WR LQcOXde VWULNeV ZLWKLQ cUXcLaO KRVSLWaO deSaUWPeQWV. IQ a VLJQLILcaQW eVcaOaWLRQ,YDA PXQMab WKeQ RUcKeVWUaWed WKe cROOecWLYe UeVLJQaWLRQ RI dRcWRUV, LQcOXdLQJ VeQLRU VWaII, LQSURWeVW aJaLQVW PLVbeKaYLRU aQd abXVe. TKe aVVRcLaWLRQ IXUWKeU LQWeQVLILed LWV acWLRQV b\cRPSOeWeO\ VKXWWLQJ dRZQ KRVSLWaO deSaUWPeQWV. YDA PXQMab UeJXOaUO\ LVVXeV ZaUQLQJV aQdXOWLPaWXPV WR WKe aXWKRULWLeV, SUeVVLQJ IRU LPPedLaWe UeVSRQVeV WR a UaQJe RI dePaQdV VXcK aVeQacWPeQW RI VecXULW\ OeJLVOaWLRQ, LPSURYePeQWV LQ ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV, aQd WKe UeVROXWLRQ RIadPLQLVWUaWLYe JULeYaQceV, SRVLWLRQLQJ XOWLPaWXPV aV a SUecXUVRU WR PRUe e[WeQVLYe SURWeVWacWLRQV. TKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ'V VWUaWeJ\ RI e[WeQdLQJ SURWeVWV acURVV PXQMab, aV dePRQVWUaWed b\acWLRQV OLNe WKe cROOecWLYe UeVLJQaWLRQ LQ KaVXU aQd VXbVeTXeQW ZaUQLQJV, ZaV aLPed aWcRQVROLdaWLQJ VXSSRUW aQd LQcUeaVLQJ SUeVVXUe RQ aXWKRULWLeV WR eQJaJe [ASSeQdL[ A, 99].89YDA KPK aQd PDA aOVR ePSOR\ VLPLOaU dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV WR addUeVV YaULRXV LVVXeV dLVcXVVedLQ VecWLRQ 3.5. TKe\ cRQdXcWed SURORQJed bR\cRWWV RI ZaUd URXQdV, OPD aQd eOecWLYe VeUYLceV WRYRLce WKeLU cRQceUQV [ASSeQdL[ A, 100]. YDA KPK aQd PDA aOVR caOOed IRU OPD VWULNeV acURVVWKe SURYLQce, VLJQaOLQJ a VLJQLILcaQW eVcaOaWLRQ LQ WKeLU SURWeVW acWLRQV. TKe WKUeaW RU acWXaOLPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI KRVSLWaO VKXWdRZQV, aV LQdLcaWed b\ WKe UeVSRQVe WR WKe SURIeVVLRQaO Wa[ LVVXeLQ DI KKaQ, UeSUeVeQWV RQe RI WKe PRVW e[WUePe IRUPV RI SURWeVW [ASSeQdL[ A, 52]. YDA KPKaOVR ePSOR\ed PRUe aJJUeVVLYe aSSURacKeV VXcK aV bORcNLQJ PaMRU URadV LQ RQe cLW\ ZLWK aZaUQLQJ WR VLW-LQ LQ IURQW RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe cRPPLVVLRQ dXe WR WKe LQacWLRQ RU LQadeTXaWe UeVSRQVeIURP WKe cRQceUQed aXWKRULWLeV [ASSeQdL[ A, 101].TKe YDA RI BaORcKLVWaQ ePSOR\ed VLPLOaU dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV WR addUeVV aQd bULQJ aWWeQWLRQ WRa P\ULad RI LVVXeV aIIecWLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SURIeVVLRQaOV aQd WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP LQ WKe UeJLRQ.BeVLdeV VWUaWeJLeV OLNe OPD aQd eOecWLYe VeUYLceV bR\cRWWV [ASSeQdL[ A, 102]. YDA BaORcKLVWaQaQQRXQced a WRNeQ VWULNe RI a IeZ KRXUV aJaLQVW WKe QeJOLJeQce RI a KRVSLWaO adPLQLVWUaWLRQ,VeUYLQJ aV a ZaUQLQJ WR WKe aXWKRULWLeV [ASSeQdL[ A, 103]. IW aOVR bR\cRWWed WeacKLQJ dXWLeV LQPedLcaO cROOeJeV LQ UeVSRQVe WR addLWLRQaO dXWLeV aQd KaOWed aOORZaQceV [ASSeQdL[ A, 104], YDABaORcKLVWaQ PRbLOL]ed dRcWRUV ZaUd b\ ZaUd aQd dLVWULcW b\ dLVWULcW IRU SRWeQWLaO SURYLQce-ZLdeSURWeVWV [ASSeQdL[ A, 105].3.6.4 OYerall comparison of sWraWegies emplo\ed b\ MSaRD organi]aWionsTR e[SORUe WKe RYeUaOO WeQdeQc\ RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ WR XVe dLVUXSWLYe YeUVXV QRQ-dLVUXSWLYeVWUaWeJLeV, I ZLOO cRQVLdeU WKe cRXQWV RI WKe VWUaWeJLeV VKRZQ LQ WKe baU cKaUW beORZ. AOO SK\VLcaOSURWeVWV aUe dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV (FLJXUe 5), ZKLOe WKe UeVW aUe QRQ-dLVUXSWLYe.90FLJXUe 9 SUeVeQWV a cRPSaULVRQ RI YaULRXV RUJaQL]aWLRQV baVed RQ WKe IUeTXeQc\ RI bRWKdLVUXSWLYe aQd QRQ-dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV WKe\ ePSOR\. IQ UeYLeZLQJ WKe daWa, LW aSSeaUV WKaWdLIIeUeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV KaYe YaU\LQJ SUeIeUeQceV IRU ceUWaLQ VWUaWeJLeV, bRWK dLVUXSWLYe aQdQRQ-dLVUXSWLYe. SWaUWLQJ ZLWK QRQ-dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV, Ze Vee WKaW "DePaQd" LV WKe PRVWcRPPRQO\ XVed QRQ dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJ\ b\ aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV, ZKLcK LQdLcaWeV a SUeIeUeQce IRUaVVeUWLQJ QeedV RU ULJKWV VWUaLJKWIRUZaUdO\. "DLVcXVVLRQ" aSSeaUV WR be aQRWKeU SUeIeUUed PeWKRdIRU PRVW RI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV e[ceSW DWM aQd PMSUP, ZKLcK cRQYeUVeO\ XVeV WKUeaWeQLQJWeUPV VXcK aV ³cRQVeTXeQce´ PRUe. "CRaOLWLRQ" aQd "UQLW\" VKRZ cRQVLdeUabOe IUeTXeQc\,eVSecLaOO\ IRU YDA BaORcKLVWaQ aQd YDA PXQMab, VXJJeVWLQJ aQ LQcOLQaWLRQ WRZaUdV cROOecWLYeacWLRQ aQd VWUeQJWK LQ QXPbeUV. "LeJaO" acWLRQV aQd "PeWLWLRQ" aUe e[cOXVLYe WR YDA SLQdK LQWKLV daWaVeW. SWUaWeJLeV OLNe ³ReTXeVW´ aQd ³PeaceIXO /S\PbROLc SURWeVW´ aUe QRW cRPPRQO\ XVedb\ aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV e[ceSW KPK ZKLcK KaV a UeOaWLYeO\ KLJKeU IUeTXeQc\.FRU dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV, WKe WeUP "PURWeVW" LV PRVW IUeTXeQWO\ XVed b\ aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV."BR\cRWW" LV aQRWKeU IUeTXeQWO\ XVed WacWLc b\ aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV e[ceSW YDA SLQdK. "SWULNe" LV aOeVV IUeTXeQWO\ ePSOR\ed VWUaWeJ\ aPRQJ aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV e[ceSW YDA KPK. "SLWWLQJ" UeIeUULQJWR SURWeVW VLW-LQV' aUe QRW WKe PRVW cRPPRQ, bXW WKe\ aUe XVed b\ VeYeUaO RUJaQL]aWLRQV, OLNe YDASLQdK aQd YDA SLQdK. AcURVV aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV, WKe WeUP ³CRXQWU\´ UeIeUULQJ WR ZaUQLQJV RIcRXQWU\ ZLde SURWeVW LV LQdLcaWed, WKRXJK LW dReV QRW KaYe a KLJK cRXQW. TKe WeUP ³SKXWdRZQ´ LVaOVR XVed acURVV aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV e[ceSW PMSUP aQd DWM. YDA SLQdK¶V XVeV LW UeOaWLYeO\ OeVVaV cRPSaUed WR aOO RWKeU RUJaQL]aWLRQV. ³WaUd´ URXQdV LV a VWUaWeJ\ WKaW aSSeaUV WR be e[cOXVLYeWR YDA. OYeUaOO, ZKeQ dLVUXSWLYe WR QRQ-dLVUXSWLYe VWUaWeJLeV aUe cRPSaUed, WKe QRQ-dLVUXSWLYeVWUaWeJLeV RYeUaOO, aUe IaYRUed RYeU dLVUXSWLYe.91FLJXUH 9 - CRPSaULVRQ RI DLVUXSWLYH SWUaWHJLHV EPSOR\HG E\ MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV 2FLJXUH 10 - HHaW MaS OI CRVLQH SLPLOaULW\ SFRUHV EaVHG RQ AGYRFaF\ SWUaWHJLHV HPSOR\HG E\ MSaRD OUJaQL]aWLRQV 3BaVed RQ WKe KeaWPaS LQ FLJXUe 10, WKe cRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ RI VWUaWeJLeV beWZeeQ YaULRXV MSaRDRUJaQL]aWLRQV, Ze caQ dLVcXVV WKe RYeUaOO VLPLOaULW\ LQ VWUaWeJ\ XVaJe. TKe KLJKeVW VLPLOaULW\ VcRUeLV beWZeeQ YDA KPK aQd YDA PXQMab ZLWK a VcRUe RI 0.94, LQdLcaWLQJ WKe\ KaYe YeU\ VLPLOaUVWUaWeJLc aSSURacKeV. TKLV LV IROORZed cORVeO\ b\ YDA KPK'V VLPLOaULW\ ZLWK PDM, aOVR KLJK aW0.91, VXJJeVWLQJ WKaW YDA KPK VKaUeV VXbVWaQWLaO VWUaWeJLc cRPPRQaOLWLeV ZLWK bRWK WKeVeRUJaQL]aWLRQV. PMSUP VKRZV a KLJK VLPLOaULW\ ZLWK aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV, eVSecLaOO\ ZLWK DWM aW0.90, ZKLcK VXJJeVWV WKaW PMSUP'V VWUaWeJLc aSSURacK LV TXLWe cRQVLVWeQW ZLWK WKaW RI DWM.YDA BaORcKLVWaQ KaV a KLJK VLPLOaULW\ ZLWK PRVW RUJaQL]aWLRQV (0.72- 0.87). YDA SLQdK, RQ WKeRWKeU KaQd, VeePV WR KaYe WKe PRVW dLVWLQcW VWUaWeJ\ ZLWK WKe ORZeVW VLPLOaULW\ VcRUeV acURVV WKebRaUd, WKe ORZeVW beLQJ ZLWK DWM aW 0.57 ZKLcK caQ be YaOLdaWed LQ WKe baUcKaUW (FLJXUe 9)LRRNLQJ aW WKe cRUUeOaWLRQ, Ze caQ Vee WKaW WKeUe LV JeQeUaOO\ a KLJK deJUee RI VLPLOaULW\ acURVVPRVW RUJaQL]aWLRQV, aV LQdLcaWed b\ WKe SUedRPLQaQce RI \eOORZ aQd JUeeQ VKadeV, ZKLcKcRUUeVSRQd WR KLJKeU VLPLOaULW\ VcRUeV. TKLV VXJJeVWV WKaW ZKLOe eacK RUJaQL]aWLRQ Pa\ KaYeXQLTXe eOePeQWV WR LWV VWUaWeJLc aSSURacK, WKeUe LV a VLJQLILcaQW aPRXQW RI RYeUOaS LQ WKe VWUaWeJLeVePSOR\ed b\ WKeVe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV. TKe KLJK VLPLOaULW\ VcRUeV aOVR VXJJeVW WKaW WKeUe LVOLNeO\ a VKaUed SOa\bRRN RU VeW RI WacWLcV WKaW aUe cRQVLdeUed eIIecWLYe b\ MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ,UeJaUdOeVV RI WKeLU UeJLRQaO cKaSWeU RU VSecLILc RUJaQL]aWLRQaO LdeQWLW\. IQ VXPPaU\, ZKLOe WKeUeaUe LQdLYLdXaO QXaQceV WR eacK RUJaQL]aWLRQ'V aSSURacK, WKe RYeUaOO WUeQd VKRZV a VWURQJaOLJQPeQW LQ WKe VWUaWeJLeV RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV acURVV PaNLVWaQ.943.6.5 SXmmari]ing Whe broader picWXre of MSaRD organi]aWionsAOO MSaRD ZeUe cRPSaUed LQ WKLV SaUW RI WKe aQaO\VLV XVLQJ WKe eQWLUe daWaVeWV. I KaYedeWeUPLQed WKe VLPLOaULWLeV aQd dLIIeUeQceV aPRQJ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV RQ WKe adYRcac\ LVVXeV LQVecWLRQ 3.5.6, UeIOecWLQJ WKeLU XQLTXe LVVXe-VSecLILc RU VKaUed adYRcac\ aJeQdaV. TKe cRPSaULVRQRI WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV baVed RQ WKeLU adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV ZaV cRQdXcWed LQ VecWLRQ 3.6.4. TKecRVLQe VLPLOaULW\ KeaWPaS (FLJXUe 10) VKRZV a KLJK VLPLOaULW\ LQde[, ZKLcK cRUUeVSRQdV ZLWK WKecRPPRQaOLWLeV LQ adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV UeIOecWed LQ WKe TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV aQd WKe cRPSaUaWLYebaU JUaSKV (FLJXUe 9).Ne[W, aQ LQLWLaO cRPSaULVRQ ZaV cRQdXcWed XVLQJ IUeTXeQc\ aQaO\VLV [ASSeQdL[ C, 1] aQd cRVLQeVLPLOaULW\ LQde[ KeaWPaS [ASSeQdL[ C, 2] RQ WKe eQWLUe daWaVeW XVLQJ VWRS ZRUdV, UeYeaOLQJ aQRYeUaOO YeU\ ORZeU VLPLOaULW\ LQde[ (0.24 - 0.64) aPRQJ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV. TKLV UeVXOW aSSeaUedcRXQWeULQWXLWLYe JLYeQ WKe e[SecWed VLPLOaULWLeV LQ adYRcac\ aSSURacKeV aQd VRPe LVVXeV aPRQJWKeVe eQWLWLeV, ZLWK a IeZ dLVWLQcW LVVXe IRcXVeV aV dLVcXVVed SUeYLRXVO\ LQ VecWLRQV 3.5.6 aQd3.6.4. TR UeILQe WKe aQaO\VLV, WKe WRS 100 UeOeYaQW ZRUdV ZeUe e[WUacWed XVLQJ NVLYR [ASSeQdL[C, 3], OeadLQJ WR a VXbVeTXeQW KeaWPaS WKaW e[KLbLWed a UeOaWLYeO\ KLJKeU VLPLOaULW\ LQde[ aPRQJWKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV (0.43-0.75) [ASSeQdL[ C, 4]. TKLV UeILQed WRS 100 ZRUdV KeaWPaS UeIOecWV aVLPLOaULW\ LQde[ WKaW adMXVWV IRU WKe VcRUeV RQ LVVXeV (0.21 - 0.72) aQd VWUaWeJLeV (0.57 - 0.94),accRPPRdaWLQJ IRU WKe RYeUaOO YaULaWLRQV aQd VLPLOaULWLeV LQ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV.TKXV, WKe WKUee KeaWPaSV²WRS 100 ZRUdV, WRS 25 LVVXeV, aQd WRS 25 VWUaWeJLeV²cROOecWLYeO\SUeVeQW a cRKeVLYe aQd UeIOecWLYe SLcWXUe RI WKe adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe. TKe KeaWPaS IRU VWUaWeJLeVKLJKOLJKW WKe aQWLcLSaWed KLJK VLPLOaULW\ LQde[, YaOLdaWed b\ WKe cRPSaUaWLYe aQaO\VLV, ZKeUeaV95WKe LVVXeV KeaWPaS deSLcWV WKe YaULaWLRQ aPRQJ RUJaQL]aWLRQV, LOOXVWUaWLQJ WKeLU VKaUed aQdWaLORUed adYRcac\ IRcXV. TKe WRS 100 ZRUdV KeaWPaS VeUYeV aV a bULdJLQJ aQaO\VLV, LOOXVWUaWLQJWKe adMXVWPeQW beWZeeQ WKe bURad aQd VSecLILc OeQVeV RI WKe VWXd\.96ChapWer 4: ResXlWs - IssXe framing b\ Whe ke\ sWakeholders (MSaRD)TKe IUaPLQJ aQaO\VLV ZaV cRQdXcWed RQ WKe daWaVeW WKaW cRPSULVed 1,000 WZeeWV, eQULcKed ZLWK aYaULeW\ RI PXOWLPedLa cRQWeQW LQcOXdLQJ QeZVSaSeU cOLSSLQJV, QeZV cKaQQeO YLdeRV, LPaJeV, aQdRWKeU YLdeRV IURP SURWeVWLQJ MSaRD RQ WKe LVVXe RI NLE. NLE, aV a QeZ IRUP RI e[LW e[aPIURP PedLcaO aQd deQWaO VcKRRO, ZaV LQWURdXced LQ 2019 b\ PMC WR addUeVV deILcLeQcLeV LQ WKecRXQWU\'V PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ V\VWeP. AOWKRXJK WKe NLE ZaV LQWeQded WR aOLJQ WKe TXaOLW\ RIPedLcaO edXcaWLRQ ZLWK LQWeUQaWLRQaO aVVeVVPeQWV OLNe WKe USMLE aQd NBDE LQ WKe USA, LWUeceLYed PL[ed UeVSRQVeV ZLWKLQ WKe cRXQWU\. TKe URRWV RI WKe debaWe RYeU WKe NLE ZeUe aOVRLQWeUWZLQed ZLWK WKe bURadeU SROLWLcaO LQVWabLOLW\ LQ WKe cRXQWU\, ZKLcK Oed WR WKe dLVbaQdPeQW aQdVXbVeTXeQW UeIRUPaWLRQ RI WKe PMDC aQd WKe PMCbeWZeeQ 2019 WR 2022 aV aOUead\ dLVcXVVed LQCKaSWeU 1.4.1 Framing of Whe issXe b\ MSaRDAQaO\]LQJ WKe YaULRXV IUaPeV aURXQd WKe NLE SROLc\ LQ PaNLVWaQ UeYeaOV a PXOWL-dLPeQVLRQaOcULWLTXe RI bRWK WKe SROLc\ LWVeOI aQd WKe bURadeU PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd KeaOWKcaUe UeJXOaWRU\eQYLURQPeQW. TKeVe IUaPeV KLJKOLJKW VLJQLILcaQW cRQceUQV aPRQJ MSaRD, abRXW WKe e[aP'VLPSOePeQWaWLRQ, IaLUQeVV, aQd LPSOLcaWLRQV IRU WKeLU IXWXUe. OYeUaOO, WKeVe IUaPeV SaLQW a SLcWXUeRI VLJQLILcaQW dLVcRQWeQW aQd dLVLOOXVLRQPeQW ZLWK WKe NLE, PMC, aQd bURadeU JRYeUQPeQWaORYeUVLJKW RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd SUacWLce LQ PaNLVWaQ. FLJXUe 11 WKe baU JUaSK UeSUeVeQWLQJ WKeYaULRXV cRdeV XQdeU WKe WKUee PaLQ caWeJRULeV RQ IUaPLQJ RI NLE LVVXe;1. DLVWUaXJKW2. DLVWUXVW LQ WKe SWaWe3. LacN RI WUXVW LQ NLE SROLc\.97TKe IRXUWK caWeJRU\ "NLE, a PeaVXUe RI cRPSeWeQc\" cRQWaLQLQJ RQO\ 3 WZeeWV LV QRW LQcOXded LQWKLV JUaSK.FigXre 11 - The VarioXs Codes Under Whe Three Main CaWegories on Framing of NLE issXe4.1.1 ConfXsion oYer GoYernmenW's decisionsTKe cRQIXVLRQ RYeU WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V decLVLRQV UeJaUdLQJ WKe NLE aPRQJ VRPe MSaRD LQPaNLVWaQ ZaV SaOSabOe IURP WKe UeacWLRQV aQd VeQWLPeQWV e[SUeVVed LQ WKe X daWaVeW. TKe SRVWV98LOOXVWUaWe a bURad VSecWUXP RI cRQceUQV, IURP SURcedXUaO aQd SROLc\ cRQIXVLRQ WR RXWULJKWIUXVWUaWLRQ aQd dLVLOOXVLRQPeQW ZLWK WKe JRYeUQPeQW aQd WKe PMC. APRQJ MSaRD WKeUe ZaV aVWURQJ VeQWLPeQW WKaW WKe NLE LV XQQeceVVaU\ aQd UedXQdaQW, JLYeQ WKe e[WeQVLYe WeVWLQJ aQdeYaOXaWLRQ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aOUead\ XQdeUJR WKURXJK MDCAT, SURIeVVLRQaO e[aPV, aQd KRXVeMRbV [ASSeQdL[ B, 1]."5 SURf e[aPV b\ a ceQWUaOL]ed XQLYeUVLW\ LQcOXdLQJ WKeRU\ & YLYa b\ LQWeUQaO & e[WeUQaO e[aPLQeUV. 1\eaU Rf HRXVe MRb & VWLOO NLE ? ARE WE A JOKE TO YOU? "TKe UKeWRULcaO TXeVWLRQ, "ARE WE A JOKE TO YOU?" eQcaSVXOaWeV WKe IUXVWUaWLRQ RYeU KaYLQJWR Iace \eW aQRWKeU e[aPLQaWLRQ KXUdOe, ZKLcK ZaV VeeQ aV beOLWWOLQJ WKe cRPSUeKeQVLYe WUaLQLQJaQd aVVeVVPeQW WKaW WKe\ KaYe aOUead\ cRPSOeWed. APRQJ MSaRD WKeUe ZaV aOVR a SeUceSWLRQWKaW WKe JRYeUQPeQW, LQcOXdLQJ WKe PMC, ZaV QRW aOLJQed ZLWK WKe LPPedLaWe aQd ORQJ-WeUPQeedV RI WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\, eVSecLaOO\ LQ WKe cRQWe[W RI a JORbaO KeaOWK cULVLV OLNeCOVID-19. PKUaVeV OLNe "DRcWRUV aUe fLJKWLQJ aJaLQVW CRURQa aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW LV fLJKWLQJaJaLQVW dRcWRUV" aQd cULWLcLVPV RI WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V IRcXV RQ QRQ-KeaOWKcaUe LVVXeV ("CULcNeWPaWWeUV a ORW WR a PM dXULQJ PaQdePLc") [ASSeQdL[ B, 2] aQd WKe SRVW beORZ XQdeUVcRUe abeOLeI WKaW WKe KeaOWK aQd ZeOIaUe RI IURQWOLQe PedLcaO ZRUNeUV aUe beLQJ VLdeOLQed."DRcWRUV aUe fLJKWLQJ aJaLQVW CRURQa aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW LV fLJKWLQJ aJaLQVW dRcWRUV.We aUe cRQfXVed LQ WKe ORYe Rf VRLO! TKe\ KaYe WaNeQ RXW ORaQV WKaW ZeUe QRW eYeQ RbOLJaWRU\!"994.1.2 DisappoinWmenW and frXsWraWionTRJeWKeU, WKLV IUaPe ZaV e[SUeVVed WKe PRVW WKURXJK WKe TXRWeV IURP MSaRD, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKeePRWLRQaO aQd SV\cKRORJLcaO WROO WKe NLE aQd bURadeU PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ SROLcLeV KaYe RQ WKRVeZLWKLQ WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ LQ PaNLVWaQ. TKLV IUaPe eQcRPSaVVeV VeYeUaO cULWLcaO WKePeV VXcKaV SK\VLcaO aQd SV\cKRORJLcaO e[KaXVWLRQ, cRQceUQV RYeU PeQWaO KeaOWK aQd caUeeU SURJUeVVLRQ,aQd V\VWePLc SUeVVXUeV. TKe IeaU RI IaLOLQJ, WKe SUeVVXUe RI cRQWLQXRXV e[aPV, aQd WKe XQceUWaLQW\aURXQd caUeeU SURJUeVVLRQ cRQWULbXWe WR a cOLPaWe RI deVSaLU, ZLWK VRPe TXeVWLRQLQJ WKe IXWXUebeQeILWV RI WKeLU PedLcaO caUeeU LQ PaNLVWaQ."5 YeaUV LQ MBBS 1 YeaU HRXVeJRb 3 YeaUV LQ PeULSKeU\ 5 YeaUV LQ SSecLaOL]aWLRQ NRZ SXW #NLE LQ WKLVeTXaWLRQ = 1-2 YeaUV TRWaO = 15 YeaUV MeaQZKLOe RWKeU PURfeVVLRQaOV ZLWK WKe VaPe effRUW aQd WLPe eaUQPRUe-bRWK UeVSecW aQd MRQe\. SR WKLQN befRUe RSWLQJ BLR LQ FVc. #ZeUeMecWNLE"TKe LQWeQVe VWUeVV RI cRQWLQXRXV e[aPV RYeU ILYe \eaUV, cRPSRXQded b\ WKe addLWLRQ RI WKe NLE,ZaV OeadLQJ WR VeYeUe deSUeVVLRQ ZLWK VRPe eYeQ cRQWePSOaWLQJ VXLcLde, KLJKOLJKWLQJ a cULVLV RIPeQWaO KeaOWK ZeOO-beLQJ LQ WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\. [ASSeQdL[ B, 3]"DRcWRUV aOUead\ face deSUeVVLRQ dXe WR WKe VWUeVV Rf WKe 5-\eaU e[aPV. SRPe eYeQ cRQWePSOaWe VXLcLde,ZKLOe RWKeUV aUe dULYeQ WR deSUeVVLRQ b\ WKe feaU Rf faLOLQJ a VXbMecW. NRZ, ZLWK aQRWKeU e[aP WKaW VeUYeVQR SXUSRVe, ZKaW beQefLW LV WKeUe fRU QeZ dRcWRUV LQ KaYLQJ WR WaNe FCPS e[aPV?HLJKOLJKWLQJ WKe JUXeOLQJ ZRUN KRXUV ("AQ aYeUaJe dRcWRU KaV WZR 32-KRXU VKLfWV LQ a ZeeN« WeaUeQ¶W URbRWV, Ze aUe KXPaQV!") SRLQWV WR aQ XQVXVWaLQabOe ZRUN cXOWXUe LQ KeaOWKcaUe WKaWe[aceUbaWeV SK\VLcaO aQd SV\cKRORJLcaO e[KaXVWLRQ, PaNLQJ WKe SURVSecW RI addLWLRQaO e[aPV100VeeP eYeQ PRUe daXQWLQJ. E[SUeVVLRQV RI dLVaSSRLQWPeQW aQd beWUa\aO WRZaUdV WKe JRYeUQPeQWaQd WKe PMC ("SKaPe RQ \RX IPUaQ KKaQ. VKaPe PMC.") UeIOecW a ORVV RI IaLWK LQ WKeVeLQVWLWXWLRQV' ZLOOLQJQeVV RU abLOLW\ WR VXSSRUW WKe KeaOWK aQd ZeOO-beLQJ RI PedLcaO SUacWLWLRQeUV.TKe XVe RI VORJaQV aQd YLVXaOV, VXcK aV a JUaSKLc deSLcWLQJ a dRcWRU cRQWePSOaWLQJ VXLcLde ZLWKWKe caSWLRQ "Ze UeMecW NLE, dRcWRUV' OLYeV PaWWeU", aQd WKe SOea "POeaVe! Ze aUe aOVR KXPaQ,"ZeUe XVed WR caOO IRU ePSaWK\, UecRJQLWLRQ, aQd V\VWePLc cKaQJe.4.1.3 Financial insWabiliW\ as healWhcare professionalsSRPe MSaRD IaUPed cRQceUQV RYeU WKe aIIRUdabLOLW\ RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ, WKe ecRQRPLcYLabLOLW\ RI SXUVXLQJ a PedLcaO caUeeU, aQd WKe bURadeU LPSOLcaWLRQV RI WKeVe IacWRUV RQ acceVV WRKeaOWKcaUe SURIeVVLRQV. TKe PeQWLRQ RI aQ LQIRJUaSKLc abRXW deSeQdeQc\ RQ IaPLO\ WKURXJKRXWWKe edXcaWLRQ-WR-dRcWRU SLSeOLQe KLJKOLJKWV WKe VLJQLILcaQW ILQaQcLaO VWUaLQ SOaced RQ VWXdeQWV aQdWKeLU IaPLOLeV. QXRWeV OLNe "I caQ¶W VWXd\, aQd I dRQ'W KaYe WKe PRQe\ IRU IeeV" aQd "NRW eYeU\RQecaQ aIIRUd WKe Iee RI WKeVe addLWLRQaO aQd XVeOeVV e[aPV!!" UeIOecW WKe dLUecW ILQaQcLaO baUULeUVSRVed b\ WKe NLE. TKe IUaPLQJ RI WKe NLE aV a QeZ VcKePe b\ WKe JRYeUQPeQW, VXJJeVWV aSeUceSWLRQ RI WKe e[aP aV SaUW RI aQ ecRQRPLc VWUaWeJ\ UaWKeU WKaQ aQ edXcaWLRQaO RU SURIeVVLRQaOVWaQdaUd PeaVXUe."TKe\ caQ'W PaNe WKe JRYeUQPeQW WR Sa\ WKe dRcWRUV VR WKe\ KaYe SXW RXW WKLV QeZ VcKePe Rf NLE, SeRSOeZRQ'W VWXd\ PedLcLQe, QRU ZRXOd WKe\ becRPe dRcWRUV, QRU ZRXOd WKeUe be a Qeed WR Sa\ WKeP"TKe e[SUeVVLRQ "CRYeU WKe ZKROe MBBS V\OOabXV aQd Sa\ 20N fRU a WeVW ZKLcK ZLOO JLYe \RX a36-KRXU KecWLc MRb ZRUWK 45N SeU PRQWK (LQ VRPe caVeV WRWaOO\ XQSaLd). IW'V MXVW ORVV afWeU ORVV."101LOOXVWUaWeV WKe SeUceLYed SRRU UeWXUQ RQ LQYeVWPeQW IRU PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ, ZKeUe WKe ILQaQcLaO aQdSeUVRQaO cRVWV RI becRPLQJ a dRcWRU aUe QRW cRPPeQVXUaWe ZLWK WKe UeZaUdV.4.1.4 EmigraWionTKLV IUaPe caSWXUeV WKe dLVLOOXVLRQPeQW aQd IUXVWUaWLRQ RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ, OeadLQJ VRPe WRcRQVLdeU RU acWXaOL]e ePLJUaWLRQ aV a UeVSRQVe WR WKe cKaOOeQJeV WKe\ Iace ZLWKLQ WKe cRXQWU\'VPedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP. TKe SRVWV KLJKOLJKW VeYeUaO Ne\ WKePeV WKaW cRQWULbXWeWR WKLV VeQWLPeQW, RQe RI ZKLcK LV WKaW PaQ\ dRcWRUV Kad KLJK KRSeV IRU cKaQJe XQdeU WKe PTIJRYeUQPeQW bXW IeOW OeW dRZQ b\ SROLcLeV aIIecWLQJ WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\, SURPSWLQJ WKeP WRVWaWe WKeLU LQWeQWLRQ WR OeaYe WKe cRXQWU\."I SeUVRQaOO\ NQRZ dR]eQV Rf dRcWRUV ZKR Kad KLJK KRSeV fRU PTI, bXW LQ WKeVe 3 \eaUV WKe\ OefW WKecRXQWU\ ZLWK VXcK bad KeaUWV. TKLV LV a WUaJed\, \RXU beVW aQd ZRUWK\ SeRSOe aUe OeaYLQJ WKe cRXQWU\. "IQVWaQceV RI bUXWaOLW\ aJaLQVW SeaceIXOO\ SURWeVWLQJ MSaRD ZeUe cLWed aV e[aPSOeV RI WKeXQdeUYaOXaWLRQ RI KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV LQ PaNLVWaQ, cRQWUaVWLQJ ZLWK WKe JORbaO WUeQd RI KRQRULQJWKeP dXULQJ WKe SaQdePLc [ASSeQdL[ B, 4.5]. TKeUe ZaV a cOeaU cRQceUQ abRXW WKe "bUaLQ dUaLQ"RI PedLcaO WaOeQW dXe WR RSSUeVVLYe cRQdLWLRQV aQd WKe VeaUcK IRU beWWeU RSSRUWXQLWLeV abURad,SRVLQJ VLJQLILcaQW ULVNV WR PaNLVWaQ'V KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP [ASSeQdL[ B, 6.7]. MaQ\ TXRWeVe[SUeVVed aQ e[LVWeQWLaO cULVLV aPRQJ PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV, ZKR aUe TXeVWLRQLQJ WKe YLabLOLW\ RIWKeLU caUeeUV LQ PaNLVWaQ XQdeU cXUUeQW JRYeUQPeQW SROLcLeV aQd VRcLeWaO aWWLWXdeV [ASSeQdL[ B,8]102"AQd WKeQ WKe\ aVN ZK\ WKe dRcWRUV NeeS OeaYLQJ PaNLVWaQ. TKeUe'V OLWeUaOO\ 1 dRcWRU fRU eYeU\ 1764 SeRSOeLQ KeUe, aQd WKeLU WURXbOeV MXVW dRQ'W eQd. PMDC > PMC."4.1.5 Lack of WrXsW in NLETKLV IUaPe UeIOecWV WKe VNeSWLcLVP aQd PLVWUXVW aPRQJ PaQ\ MSaRD WRZaUdV WKe NLE LQPaNLVWaQ. TKe SRVWV eOXcLdaWe YaULRXV dLPeQVLRQV RI dLVWUXVW, KLJKOLJKWLQJ cRQceUQV RYeU WKee[aP'V OeJLWLPac\, SXUSRVe, aQd LPSOLcaWLRQV IRU WKe PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQ. MaQ\ MSaRD UeMecWedWKe aVVeUWLRQ WKaW WKe NLE ZaV deVLJQed IRU WKeLU beWWeUPeQW, LQWeUSUeWLQJ LW LQVWead aV a PeaVXUeWKaW VeUYeV WKe LQWeUeVWV RI WKe PMC RU RWKeU eQWLWLeV aW WKe e[SeQVe RI WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ -aV LPSOLed LQ ("IW'V MXVW \RX VaWLVf\LQJ \RXU YLOOaLQRXV eJR"). MaQ\ YLeZed WKe NLE aV aQXQMXVWLILed aQd LQWROeUabOe LPSRVLWLRQ b\ ZKaW WKe\ UeIeU WR aV WKe "PMC PafLa,". TKXV, WKeUeZeUe aVVeUWLRQV WKaW WKe NLE LV LOOeJaO aQd UeSUeVeQWV a "bOacN OaZ," VXJJeVWLQJ OeJaO aQd eWKLcaOcRQceUQV abRXW WKe e[aP'V LPSRVLWLRQ aQd adPLQLVWUaWLRQ." NLE LV aQ XQMXVWLfLed, LOOeJaO & QRW WROeUaWed e[aP SXW RQ XQdeUJUadXaWeV b\ WKe PMC PafLa. AOO aUeUeTXeVWed WR UaLVe WKeLU YRLce aJaLQVW LQMXVWLce, NLE, PMC."MaQ\ cRQVLdeUed NLE c\QLcaOO\ aV a PecKaQLVP IRU WKe PMC WR JeQeUaWe UeYeQXe, UaWKeU WKaQ aOeJLWLPaWe aVVeVVPeQW RI PedLcaO cRPSeWeQce. TKe UeTXLUePeQW IRU VSecLaOLVWV OLNe J\QecRORJLVWVaQd QeXURVXUJeRQV WR WaNe WKe VaPe e[aP ZaV cULWLcL]ed aV LOORJLcaO, LQdLcaWLQJ a RQe-VL]e-ILWV-aOOaSSURacK aQd a UeaVRQ WR beOLeYe WKaW LW LV a SROLc\ Pade IRU ILQaQcLaO JaLQV. [ASSeQdL[ B, 9]"NLE LV PMC'V SOaQ ORRW PedLcV aQd bULQJ e[WUa bXUdeQ RQ WKeP ZKLcK LV WRWaOO\ baVeOeVV VaYe PedLcV ZeUeMecW NLE #PURWeVWAJaLQVWNLE"103IQWeUeVWLQJO\, VRPe aOVR YLeZed NLE aV a cKaOOeQJe WR WKe cUedLbLOLW\ RI PedLcaO cROOeJeV aQdXQLYeUVLWLeV, VXJJeVWLQJ LW XQdeUPLQeV WKe YaOXe RI e[LVWLQJ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd deJUeeV. TKeMSaRD e[SUeVVed a VeQVe RI dePRUaOL]aWLRQ, IeeOLQJ WKaW WKeLU KaUd ZRUN aQd WKe LQWeUQaWLRQaOVWaQdLQJ RI PaNLVWaQ'V PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ ZeUe beLQJ XQdeUPLQed b\ WKe NLE."IW'V KaUd ZRUN, QRW a MRNe!! IW'V RQe Rf WKe PRVW aSSUecLaWed PedLcaO V\VWePV LQ WKe ZRUOd aQd \RX SXW aTXeVWLRQ PaUN RQ LW b\ WaNLQJ NLE. @DU_YaVPLQRaVKLd @DUMXUadPTI #ZeUeMecWPMC #ZeUeMecWNLE"GRLQJ eYeQ IXUWKeU, VRPe MSaRD VXJJeVWed WKaW PedLcaO OeadeUV LQcOXdLQJ WKe PUeVLdeQW RIPaNLVWaQ (a deQWLVW) aQd SROLc\PaNeUV, LQcOXdLQJ WKRVe ZLWK PMDC deJUeeV, VKRXOd aOVR WaNe WKeNLE XQdeUVcRULQJ a caOO IRU accRXQWabLOLW\ aQd a cULWLTXe RI WKe SeUceLYed dRXbOe VWaQdaUdVZLWKLQ WKe PedLcaO UeJXOaWRU\ IUaPeZRUN."YRX'Ue dRXbWLQJ aOO PMDC deJUee KROdeUV' cUedLbLOLW\ ZRUOdZLde LQcOXdLQJ PUeVLdeQW PaNLVWaQ@AULfAOYL, PUeVLdeQW @SPc_RUJ, @MLQLVWeU HeaOWK WKeQ WKe\ VKRXOd aOVR JLYe NLE. IW'V a bLJ TXeVWLRQPaUN RQ \RXU PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ V\VWeP."4.1.6 NLE, a sXperficial solXWion Wo s\sWemic issXesTKLV IUaPe deOYeV LQWR WKe cULWLTXeV OeYLed b\ MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ, ZKR aUJXed WKaW WKe NLEVeUYeV aV a VXSeUILcLaO VROXWLRQ WR V\VWePLc LVVXeV ZLWKLQ WKe cRXQWU\'V KeaOWKcaUe edXcaWLRQ aQdVeUYLce deOLYeU\ V\VWePV. MaQ\ MSaRD e[SUeVVed a cRQceUQ WKaW LQVWead RI IRcXVLQJ RQeQKaQcLQJ WKe LQIUaVWUXcWXUe RI KRVSLWaOV aQd cROOeJeV RU LPSURYLQJ WKe TXaOLW\ RI KeaOWKcaUedeOLYeU\, WKe JRYeUQPeQW aQd WKe PMC KaYe cKRVeQ WR LPSRVe addLWLRQaO e[aPLQaWLRQV RQVWXdeQWV aQd JUadXaWeV. MSaRD cRQVLdeUed WKLV aSSURacK aV PLVaOLJQed ZLWK WKe acWXaO QeedV RI104LPSURYLQJ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, VLdeVWeSSLQJ cUXcLaO LVVXeV VXcK aV XQdeUIXQded KRVSLWaOV,LQVXIILcLeQW PedLcaO VXSSOLeV, aQd WKe Qeed IRU beWWeU SaWLeQW caUe SURWRcROV."IQVWead Rf LPSRVLQJ XQQeceVVaU\ e[aPV OLNe NLE RQ PedLcaO JUadXaWeV aQd VWXdeQWV, ZKR aUe aOUead\XQdeU VWUeVVfXO cRQdLWLRQV, GOVT VKRXOd addUeVV WKe cRUe LVVXeV Rf KRVSLWaOV aQd cROOeJeV WR UaLVe WKeVWaQdaUd Rf WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP LQ PaNLVWaQ."TKXV, WKeUe ZaV a VWURQJ caOO IRU a PRUe cRPSUeKeQVLYe eYaOXaWLRQ V\VWeP WKaW e[WeQdV be\RQdWKe VWXdeQWV WR LQcOXde e[aPLQeUV, edXcaWRUV, aQd SUacWLcLQJ SK\VLcLaQV. TKe MSaRD aOVR aUJXedIRU a KROLVWLc aSSURacK WR UeIRUP acURVV aOO OeYeOV RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\,UaWKeU WKaQ IRcXVLQJ QaUURZO\ RQ VWXdeQW aVVeVVPeQW WKURXJK WKe NLE. [ASSeQdL[ B, 10]"HRZ abRXW \RX bULQJ a V\VWeP WR eYaOXaWe \RXU e[aPLQeUV? HRZ abRXW \RX bULQJ a V\VWeP WR eYaOXaWe\RXU WeacKeUV? \RXU dRcWRUV? QRW MXVW VWXdeQWV beLQJ eYaOXaWed LQ QeZ Za\V WLPe aQd WLPe aJaLQ."WLWK VWaWePeQWV OLNe "E[aP OLNe APeULca FacLOLWLeV OLNe SRPaOLa", MSaRD KLJKOLJKWed aVLJQLILcaQW dLVSaULW\ beWZeeQ WKe VWaQdaUdV SXUSRUWedO\ XSKeOd b\ WKe NLE aQd WKe UeaOLWLeV RIPaNLVWaQ¶V KeaOWKcaUe VeUYLceV aQd PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ LQIUaVWUXcWXUe. DUaZLQJ cRPSaULVRQV WRKeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV LQ cRXQWULeV OLNe WKe UK aQd USA, WKe\ aUJXe WKaW WKe NLE¶V beQcKPaUNV dRQRW accRXQW IRU WKe YaVW dLIIeUeQceV LQ UeVRXUceV, LQIUaVWUXcWXUe, aQd TXaOLW\ RI caUe [ASSeQdL[ B,11]. TKeUe ZaV aOVR a VeQWLPeQW aPRQJ MSaRD WKaW UaWKeU WKaQ LQVWLWXWLQJ PeaQLQJIXO UeIRUPV WRLPSURYe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ TXaOLW\ aQd KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\ VWaQdaUdV, WKe IRcXV RQ WKe NLEdLYeUWV aWWeQWLRQ aQd UeVRXUceV aZa\ IURP eVVeQWLaO LPSURYePeQWV.105"SR \RX'Ue baVLcaOO\ Va\LQJ WKaW 5 SURfeVVLRQaO e[aPV \RX WRRN Kad QR cUedLbLOLW\ VR \RX ZaQW NLEQRZ???? SWaUW cKaQJLQJ V\VWeP fURP baVLcV aQd WKeQ cRPe WR WKe WRS"4.1.7 NLE, a measXre of compeWenc\IQWeUeVWLQJO\, VRPe MSaRD KaYe a cRQWUaVWLQJ IUaPe WR WKe SUeYLRXVO\ dLVcXVVed cULWLTXeV RI WKeNLE b\ VRPe VWaNeKROdeUV. IW UeIOecWV a deIeQVe RI VWaQdaUdV aQd accRXQWabLOLW\ LQ WKe PedLcaOSUacWLce IUaPe, VXJJeVWLQJ WKaW WKe NLE LV a QeceVVaU\ PeaVXUe WR eQVXUe WKe cRPSeWeQce RIPedLcaO SUacWLWLRQeUV beIRUe WKe\ aUe aOORZed WR SUacWLce PedLcLQe. TKLV IUaPe LPSOLcLWO\cULWLcL]eV WKRVe RSSRVLQJ WKe NLE, VXJJeVWLQJ WKaW WKeLU UeVLVWaQce PLJKW VWeP IURP a OacN RIcRQILdeQce LQ WKeLU RZQ cRPSeWeQce RU aQ XQZLOOLQJQeVV WR be KeOd WR ULJRURXV VWaQdaUdV. TKePeQWLRQ RI "e[SeULPeQWLQJ ZLWK WKe OLYeV Rf SRRU SeRSOe" LQYRNeV a PRUaO aUJXPeQW WKaW IUaPeVWKe RSSRVLWLRQ WR WKe NLE aV SRWeQWLaOO\ eQdaQJeULQJ SaWLeQW ZeOIaUe."If \RX aUe WUXO\ cRPSeWeQW, WKeQ ZK\ aUe \RX afUaLd Rf WaNLQJ WKe NaWLRQaO LLceQVLQJ E[aP? WK\ LV LW WKaW\RX ZaQW WR SUacWLce RQ WKe OLYeV Rf SRRU SeRSOe, e[SeULPeQWLQJ ZLWK WKeLU OLYeV?"4.1.8 Lack of WrXsW in PMCTKLV IUaPe cRQWaLQV a ZLde aUUa\ RI cULWLTXeV aJaLQVW WKe PMC aUWLcXOaWed b\ MSaRD. IWXQdeUVcRUeV a dLVLOOXVLRQPeQW ZLWK WKe JRYeUQaQce aQd SROLcLeV RI WKe PMC, VSRWOLJKWLQJ KRZWKeVe eOePeQWV deWULPeQWaOO\ LQIOXeQce PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd WKe SURIeVVLRQaO OaQdVcaSe LQPaNLVWaQ. TKe OacN RI WUXVW LQ PMC Pa\ be RQe RI WKe RWKeU UeaVRQV IRU QRW acceSWLQJ NLE.MSaRD UaLVed cRQceUQV abRXW WKe TXaOLILcaWLRQV aQd UeOeYaQce RI PMC OeadeUVKLS, e[ePSOLILedb\ WKe aSSRLQWPeQW RI a QRQ-PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaO, a OaZ\eU, aV a YLce SUeVLdeQW RI a PedLcaO106UeJXOaWRU\ aXWKRULW\. TKLV ZaV VeeQ aV a IXQdaPeQWaO PLVPaWcK, TXeVWLRQLQJ WKe abLOLW\ RI VXcKOeadeUVKLS WR XQdeUVWaQd aQd addUeVV WKe QeedV RI WKe PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQ eIIecWLYeO\."A OaZ\eU LV VLce PUeVLdeQW Rf RXU UeJXOaWRU\ aXWKRULW\-PMC. CaQ a dRcWRU be WKe PUeVLdeQW Rf WKePaNLVWaQ BaU AVVRcLaWLRQ?"TKe VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV UeIOecW a IUaPe RI V\VWePLc QeJOecW aQd PLVPaQaJePeQW b\ WKe PMC,VXJJeVWLQJ a OacN RI SURSeU SOaQQLQJ aQd cRQVLdeUaWLRQ IRU WKe LPSOLcaWLRQV RI WKe NLE RQPedLcaO VWXdeQWV' IXWXUeV, ZKLcK added WR WKe OacN RI WUXVW LQ PMC."TKLV e[aP ZRQ'W LPSURYe \RXU TXaOLW\ Rf edXcaWLRQ. IQVWead LW ZLOO cUeaWe dLffLcXOWLeV fRU WKe KeaOWK VecWRU.DecLVLRQV aUe QeYeU LPSOePeQWed RYeUQLJKW. e.J. UK JRYW decLded WR UeSOace PLAB ZLWK UKMLA LQ 2018ZKLcK LV WR be LPSOePeQWed LQ 2024"PMC ZaV aOVR cULWLcL]ed IRU WKe OacN RI VLJQLILcaQW SeUIRUPaQce LPSURYePeQWV RU addUeVVLQJ WKecRUe LVVXeV IacLQJ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ aQd SUacWLce. AccXVaWLRQV RI ILQaQcLaO LUUeJXOaULWLeV IXUWKeUeURded WUXVW, WKXV decOaULQJ LW LOOeJaO aV SUeYLRXVO\ dLVcXVVed LQ SecWLRQ 4.1.5 [ASSeQdL[ B,12.13]. CULWLcLVPV e[WeQd WR WKe RSeUaWLRQaO aVSecWV RI WKe PMC'V SROLcLeV, LQcOXdLQJ WKeadPLQLVWUaWLRQ RI WKe NLE. CRQceUQV abRXW LQVXIILcLeQW SUeSaUaWLRQ WLPe, WKe LQcOXVLRQ RIQRQ-V\OOabXV TXeVWLRQV, aQd WUaQVSaUeQc\ UeJaUdLQJ WKe e[aP cRQWeQW XQdeUVcRUed a OacN RI WUXVWLQ WKe IaLUQeVV aQd eIILcac\ RI WKe e[aPLQaWLRQ SURceVV [ASSeQdL[ B, 14]. TKeUe VeePed WR be aVWURQJ deVLUe aPRQJ a VecWLRQ RI MSaRD, QRWabO\ DWM IRU WKe UeVWRUaWLRQ RI PMDC aQd WKeabROLVKPeQW RI WKe PMC.107"TKe MedLcaO SecWRU & SWXdeQWV Rf PaNLVWaQ aUe KRSLQJ WKURXJKRXW WKe QaWLRQ WKaW LQ WRda\'V PaUOLaPeQWVeVVLRQ caOOed b\ WKe PUeVLdeQW Rf PaNLVWaQ, WKe UeVWRUaWLRQ Rf PMDC aQd abROLVKPeQW Rf PMC'V bLOO ZLOOJeW aSSURYed. @ (PaUOLaPeQW OSSRVLWLRQ PePbeU)"IQ WKLV IUaPe aQRWKeU Ne\ SOa\eU aUe WKe PePbeUV RI WKe RSSRVLWLRQ LQ PaUOLaPeQW (aV RbVeUYed LQWKe SRVW abRYe), SOa\LQJ a VLJQLILcaQW UROe aV aOOLeV aQd adYRcaWeV IRU WKe cRQceUQV RI MSaRDUeJaUdLQJ WKe PMC.4.2 Framing of demands b\ MSaRDFLJXUe 12 UeSUeVeQWV WKe cRdeV WKaW JeQeUaWed IURP WKe LQLWLaO TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV aQd ZeUeIXUWKeU aQaO\]ed WR deYeORS WKe YaULRXV WKePeV RQ WKe IUaPLQJ RI dePaQdV WKaW MSaRD Kad RQWKe NLE LVVXeV.FigXre 12 - The VarioXs Frames on Whe Demands of MSaRD on Whe NLE Polic\1084.2.1 Demand for cancellaWion as a sWand againsW sWrXcWXral challengesFRU a OaUJe QXPbeU RI MSaRD, WKLV dePaQd ZaV URRWed LQ a VeQVe RI SeUceLYed LQMXVWLce,YLeZLQJ WKe e[aP aV aQ XQacceSWabOe LPSRVLWLRQ RQ WKeLU ULJKWV aQd SURIeVVLRQaO IUeedRP.[ASSeQdL[ B, 15]."We ZLOO aWWaLQ fUeedRP. We ZLOO VQaWcK fUeedRP. IW LV RXU ULJKW, fUeedRP. UQacceSWabOe, UQacceSWabOe,NLE LV XQacceSWabOe."WKLOe VRPe baVed WKeLU dePaQd WR caQceO NLE RQ OeJaO JURXQdV, eVSecLaOO\ WKe JUadXaWeV ZKRcRPSOeWed WKeLU edXcaWLRQ beIRUe WKe e[aP'V LPSOePeQWaWLRQ."FRUcLQJ NLE RQ JUadXaWeV LV aJaLQVW WKe cRQVWLWXWLRQ Rf WKe IVOaPLc ReSXbOLc Rf PaNLVWaQ, aQd LW dReVQ'WaSSO\ WR aQ\ adPLVVLRQ WKaW KaSSeQed befRUe SeSWePbeU 2020. XQfaLU aQd LOOeJaO LPSRVLWLRQ Rf NLE"TKLV dePaQd XQdeUVcRUed a cROOecWLYe VWaQd aJaLQVW ZKaW LV VeeQ aV aQ RSSUeVVLYe SROLc\, ZLWKVWaWePeQWV ePSKaVL]LQJ VROLdaULW\ aPRQJ PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV aQd VWXdeQWV LQ UeVLVWLQJ WKeNLE [ASSeQdL[ B, 16]. TKe dePaQd aOVR caUULed LPSOLcaWLRQV IRU SROLWLcaO eQWLWLeV, SaUWLcXOaUO\WKe UXOLQJ SaUW\, VLJQaOLQJ SRWeQWLaO SROLWLcaO UeSeUcXVVLRQV VKRXOd WKe cRQceUQV RI WKe PedLcaOcRPPXQLW\ cRQWLQXe WR be LJQRUed."If \RX dRQ'W UeMecW NLE, Ze ZLOO UeMecW PaNLVWaQ TeKUeeN e IQVaaf aQd VR-caOOed PMC"1094.2.2 AdYocac\ for prospecWiYe applicaWion and fairness in polic\ changesTKLV dePaQd IUaPe XQdeUVcRUeV a SULQcLSOed VWaQce aJaLQVW UeWURVSecWLYe aSSOLcaWLRQ RI WKe NLEUeTXLUePeQWV, adYRcaWLQJ IRU a cOeaU dePaUcaWLRQ WKaW e[ePSWV cXUUeQW aQd SaVW VWXdeQWV IURPQeZ UeJXOaWLRQV. TKe dePaQd KLJKOLJKWV WKe OeJaO SULQcLSOe WKaW OaZV VKRXOd QRW be aSSOLedUeWURVSecWLYeO\, eVSecLaOO\ ZKeQ VXcK aSSOLcaWLRQ XQIaLUO\ LPSacWV LQdLYLdXaOV ZKR cRPPLWWed WRa cRXUVe RI acWLRQ XQdeU a dLIIeUeQW VeW RI e[SecWaWLRQV [ASSeQdL[ B, 17]. TKe aUJXPeQW ZaVUeLQIRUced b\ LQWeUQaWLRQaO VWaQdaUdV VeW b\ RUJaQL]aWLRQV OLNe WKe WRUOd FedeUaWLRQ RI MedLcaOEdXcaWLRQ, ZKLcK VSecLI\ NLE UeTXLUePeQWV IRU IXWXUe JUadXaWeV, QRW cXUUeQW RU SaVW VWXdeQWV."LaZ caQ'W be LPSOePeQWed RQ UeWURVSecWLYe baWcKeV. TKe WRUOd FedeUaWLRQ Rf MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ WRUOdFedeUaWLRQ Rf MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ Rf UeTXLUePeQW Rf NLE LV fRU baWcKeV GUadXaWLQJ afWeU 2023."SRPe MSaRD aUJXed WKaW VWXdeQWV ZKR eQWeUed PedLcaO SURJUaPV ZeUe QRW LQIRUPed abRXW WKeNLE aW WKe WLPe RI adPLVVLRQ, PaNLQJ LWV VXddeQ LPSRVLWLRQ a bUeacK RI WUXVW aQd a YLROaWLRQ RIWKeLU ULJKW WR PaNe LQIRUPed decLVLRQV abRXW WKeLU edXcaWLRQ aQd caUeeU SaWKV."NLE PaNeV QR VeQVe. We ZeUeQ'W LQfRUPed abRXW WKLV ZKeQ Ze ZeUe WaNLQJ adPLVVLRQ LQ MBBS. ASSO\QeZ UXOeV RQ QeZ baWcKeV ZKR NQRZ abRXW WKLV befRUe adPLVVLRQ."4.2.3 Call for fair preparaWion and consideraWe implemenWaWionTKe WKLUd dePaQd UeIOecWV a PRdeUaWe UeVSRQVe IURP VRPe MSaRD aPLdVW WKe bURadeU cULWLTXeVRI WKe NLE LPSOePeQWaWLRQ LQ PaNLVWaQ. TKeUe ZeUe a IeZ SRVWV PaNLQJ a SOea IRU addLWLRQaOSUeSaUaWLRQ WLPe aQd cRQVLdeUaWLRQ RI WKe e[aP'V WLPLQJ aQd cRQWeQW, ZKLcK MSaRD aUJXed ZaVcRPSURPLVed b\ WKe UXVKed LPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI WKe NLE.110"We aUeQ'W aVNLQJ \RX WR caQceO LW, Ze'Ue MXVW aVNLQJ fRU WLPe ZKLcK LV RXU ULJKW #deOa\PdcaW2021"CULWLTXeV e[WeQded WR WKe cRQWeQW RI WKe NLE, ZLWK cRQceUQV WKaW WKe e[aP LQcOXdeV TXeVWLRQV QRWcRYeUed b\ WKe PedLcaO V\OOabXV, IXUWKeU ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe Qeed IRU a deOa\ WR addUeVV WKeVedLVcUeSaQcLeV [ASSeQdL[ A, 28]. AV dLVcXVVed eaUOLeU, WKe MSaRD beQcKPaUNed WKe NLE SROLc\aJaLQVW WKe LQWeUQaWLRQaO VWaQdaUd VXcK aV LPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI UKMLA LQ WKe UK, adYRcaWLQJ IRUa JUadXaO aSSURacK WKaW aOORZV IRU SURSeU adaSWaWLRQ aQd SUeSaUaWLRQ. [ASSeQdL[ A, 32]. IQ VKRUW,WKLV IUaPe UeIOecWV a QXaQced VWaQce WKaW UecRJQL]eV WKe SRWeQWLaO YaOXe RI VWaQdaUdL]ed WeVWLQJZKLOe adYRcaWLQJ IRU cRQdLWLRQV WKaW eQVXUe aOO caQdLdaWeV aUe adeTXaWeO\ SUeSaUed aQd eYaOXaWedIaLUO\.4.2.4 Demand for eWhical leadership and WransparenW goYernanceA YeU\ SURPLQeQW dePaQd b\ MSaRD ZaV RI accRXQWabLOLW\ ZKLcK ZaV aUWLcXOaWed aJaLQVW abacNdURS RI aOOeJed cRUUXSWLRQ, PLVPaQaJePeQW, aQd WKe SeUceLYed XQILWQeVV RI PMC OeadeUVKLS.TKe caOO IRU WKe UeVLJQaWLRQ RI Ne\ PMC ILJXUeV LV a dLUecW aSSeaO IRU accRXQWabLOLW\, YLeZed aV aQeceVVaU\ VWeS WR UeVWRUe WUXVW aQd eQVXUe WKe PMC LV Oed b\ LQdLYLdXaOV ZLWK WKe UeTXLVLWeNQRZOedJe aQd eWKLcaO VWaQdaUdV WR JRYeUQ WKe PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQ eIIecWLYeO\."TKRVe ZKR dRQ'W YaOXe WKeLU SURfeVVLRQaOV KaYe QR ULJKW WR JRYeUQ WKLV cRXQWU\ aQd PMC cKaLUPaQVKRXOd UeVLJQ LPPedLaWeO\"TKe IUaPLQJ aOVR LQcOXdeV a dePaQd IRU accRXQWabLOLW\ UeJaUdLQJ SROLc\ decLVLRQV SeUceLYed aVXQcRQVWLWXWLRQaO RU deWULPeQWaO WR WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\'V LQWeUeVWV.111"If WU\LQJ WR SURYe WKe NLE cRQVWLWXWLRQaO bULQJV fRUWK VRPeWKLQJ XQcRQVWLWXWLRQaO, WKeQ UeVLJQaWLRQ LV WKebeVW RSWLRQ."4.3 Framing of adYocac\ sWraWegies b\ MSaRDTKLV VecWLRQ SUeVeQWV a cRPSUeKeQVLYe RYeUYLeZ RI WKe PXOWLIaceWed adYRcac\ aSSURacKeVePSOR\ed b\ MSaRD aJaLQVW WKe NLE LQ PaNLVWaQ. TKLV VecWLRQ deOLQeaWeV WKe YaULRXV VWUaWeJLeVWKaW MSaRD aSSO\ WR WKeLU adYRcac\ SURceVV, eVSecLaOO\ cRQceUQLQJ NLE. TKe FLJXUe 13 beORZVKRZV YaULRXV cRdeV aQd WKe UeIeUeQced WZeeWV baVed RQ ZKLcK WKe IaUPLQJ aQaO\VLV RQ VWUaWeJLeVZaV cRQdXcWed.FigXre 13 - The VarioXs Frames of MSaRD on Wheir AdYocac\ OYer Whe NLE Polic\112TKe WabOe beORZ VXPPaUL]eV WKe YaULRXV IUaPeV aQd WKe cRdeV ZLWK e[aPSOeV RI eacK IURP WKeVRcLaO PedLa SRVWV RI MSaRD WKaW ZeUe XVed WR cRQdXcW WKLV IUaPLQJ aQaO\VLV RQ WKe adYRcac\SURceVV RI MSaRD RQ NLE PROLc\.Table 6: The VarioXs Frames of MSaRD on Wheir AdYocac\ Process on NLE Polic\Themes SXbWhemes E[ample QXoWe & PosW NXmberFRUPV RI BR\cRWWBR\cRWW RI OPDVeUYLceV"AfWeU SeUYLceV HRVSLWaO LaKRUe, PeVKaZaU, AbbaVLSKaKeed, JLQQaK HRVSLWaO SLQdK, OPD VeUYLceV KaYebeeQ bR\cRWWed LQ AOOLed aQd CLYLO HRVSLWaO FaLVaOabad,PXQMab"BR\cRWW RI NLEUeJLVWUaWLRQ"We ZLOO UeTXeVW aOO VWXdeQWV acURVV WKe bRaUd QRW WRUeJLVWeU \RXUVeOf fRU NLE."BR\cRWW RI SROLWLcaOSaUWLeV"BXW Ze ZRQ'W MXVW e[SUeVV RXU UeJUeW abRXW \RX,@IPUaQKKaQPTI. We ZLOO VeQd \RX KRPe aQd ZRQ'WeYeQ WaNe WKe NLE! IQ VKaa AOOaK."PXbOLc PURWeVWVaQd MRbLOL]aWLRQMaUcKeV aQd VLW-LQV"WaON RXWVLde NLE e[aP ceQWeU#CKePLcaOSSUa\OQDRcWRUV", ³YLdeR Rf fePaOeSURWeVWRUV PaUcKLQJ aQd KROdLQJ VLJQ - SWXdeQWV ReMecWNLE"TKUeaWV WR bURadeQSURWeVW PRYePeQW"AfWeU SeUYLceV HRVSLWaO LaKRUe, PeVKaZaU, AbbaVLSKaKeed, JLQQaK HRVSLWaO SLQdK, OPD VeUYLceV KaYe113Themes SXbWhemes E[ample QXoWe & PosW NXmberbeeQ bR\cRWWed LQ AOOLed aQd CLYLO HRVSLWaO FaLVaOabad,PXQMab"HLJKOLJKWLQJJRYeUQPeQW LQacWLRQ"DR ZKaW \RX caQ ZLWK XV bXW WKe fLUe \RX aUe fXeOLQJ LVQRW LQ aQ\RQe'V LQWeUeVW. We KaYe beeQ SURWeVWLQJ fRU WKeOaVW WZR \eaUV bXW WKe JRYeUQPeQW LV QRW Uead\ WR OLVWeQWR XV."SWUaWeJLc eVcaOaWLRQRI SURWeVWV" "TKLV LV RQO\ LaKRUe, WKe Qe[W VLW-LQ ZLOO be acURVVPaNLVWaQ MedLcaO CRPPLVVLRQ, IVOaPabad"ASSeaO IRUDLaORJXe aQdReVLVWaQceWKURXJKCRQIURQWaWLRQCaOOV IRU dLaORJXe"YRX caOO dRcWRUV cUeaP Rf WKe QaWLRQ aQd \eW \RX aUe QRWUead\ WR KROd dLaORJXeV ZLWK WKeP..."IQWeQW IRU dLUecWcRQIURQWaWLRQ"NRZ bULcNV ZLOO be aQVZeUed b\ VWRQeV #Sa\NRTRNLE#PURWeVWAJaLQVWNLE"UVe RI SReWLc aQdV\PbROLc e[SUeVVLRQV"AOO cURZQV ZLOO be WRVVed. AOO WKURQeV ZLOO beRYeUWKURZQ @SPc_RUJ"UQLW\ aQd MRUaOPeUVXaVLRQ LQAdYRcac\EQcRXUaJePeQW aQdIUaWeUQaO SUeVVXUe"SaOXWe WR aOO WKRVe ZKR aUe SaUWLcLSaWLQJ LQ WKe SURWeVW.TKe UeaO KeUReV. MRUe SRZeU WR \RX"ASSeaO IRU cROOecWLYeacWLRQ"SWXdeQWV Rf PXQMab MedLcaO CROOeJe aQd DU. A]LP aUeWKe WUXVWeeV aQd JXaUaQWRUV Rf WUadLWLRQ."IQVSLUaWLRQaO aQd "AOO VeaVRQV VRaNed LQ bORRd ZLOO WeVWLf\ WKaW \RX VWRRd!114Themes SXbWhemes E[ample QXoWe & PosW NXmberSReWLc PeVVaJLQJ TKe daZQ Rf WKe VXQ ZLOO WeVWLf\!"FUaPLQJ SaUWLcLSaWLRQaV a PRUaO VWaQce"DRcWRUV aUe beLQJ WRUWXUed. WRQ'W \RX VSeaN XS aJaLQVWWKLV LQMXVWLce?"SRcLaO aQd MaVVMedLa AdYRcac\DLJLWaO PRbLOL]aWLRQWKURXJK VRcLaO PedLa"We aUe WUeQdLQJ JX\V! KeeS RQ dRLQJ WZeeWV, UeWZeeWVaQd TXRWe WZeeWV. We Qeed a KeaY\ MedLa CaPSaLJQbefRUe beLQJ RQ RRadV."TaJJLQJ LQIOXeQWLaOILJXUeV"AULfAOYL @SPc_RUJ @SMQXUeVKLPTI @IPUaQKKaQPTI@LTUaUXOKaVVaQ @MaULa_MePRQ @WaVeePBadaPL@LaPKaP]aabbaVL @AVad_UPaU @ZaNaWaTaU@PRPLQVaTLb @bLOaObLQVaTLb #WeReMecWNLE"EQJaJePeQW ZLWKSROLWLcaO RSSRVLWLRQ"We aUe cRQWacWLQJ RSSRVLWLRQ SaUOLaPeQWaULaQV.#TXPMaVLKaHR"OUJaQL]ed SXbOLcdePRQVWUaWLRQVaORQJVLde RQOLQecaPSaLJQV"MedLcaO VWXdeQWV Rf IVOaPabad ZLOO SURWeVW aJaLQVW NLEWRPRUURZ aW 9aP RXWVLde WKe IVOaPabad SUeVV cOXb#PURWeVWAJaLQVWNLE"4.4 Framing of Whe GoYernmenW's response Wo MSaRD adYocac\FLJXUe 14 UeSUeVeQWV a JUaSK RQ WKe LQLWLaO IUaPeV WKaW ePeUJed WRZaUdV WKe GRYeUQPeQW¶VUeVSRQVe WR WKe adYRcac\ SURceVV RI MSaRD UeJaUdLQJ WKe NLE PROLc\.115FigXre 14 - Frames of MSaRD of Whe GoYernmenW's Response4.4.1 Comple[ engagemenW amidsW adYocac\ and dissenWTKe JRYeUQPeQW'V VWUaWeJ\ RI WaNLQJ MSaRD RQ bRaUd WKURXJK dLaORJXe aQd eQJaJePeQW LQUeVSRQVe WR WKe NLE cRQWURYeUV\ dePRQVWUaWeV aQ aWWePSW WR PLWLJaWe dLVVeQW b\ SURYLdLQJIRUXPV IRU dLVcXVVLRQ aQd e[SOaQaWLRQ. TKLV VWUaWeJ\, KRZeYeU, ZaV PeW ZLWK YaULed SeUceSWLRQVb\ WKe MSaRD, UaQJLQJ IURP caXWLRXV RSWLPLVP WR RXWULJKW VNeSWLcLVP. TKe PMC'V LQLWLaWLYe WRRUJaQL]e ZRRP VeVVLRQV aQd RWKeU OLYe Q&A RSSRUWXQLWLeV ZaV SUeVeQWed aV aQ eIIRUW WR cOaULI\WKe NLE'V UaWLRQaOe, deYeORSPeQW SURceVV, aQd aQWLcLSaWed beQeILWV IRU WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\aQd WKe bURadeU SRSXOace [ASSeQdL[ B, 18]. TKe PMC'V VWaWePeQWV aQd acWLRQV, VXcK aV PeeWLQJZLWK YDA PXQMab'V deOeJaWLRQ, VeePV WR VLJQaO aQ RSeQQeVV WR VWaNeKROdeU eQJaJePeQW."PMC beOLeYeV LQ WKe LPSRUWaQce Rf LQWeUacWLQJ ZLWK aOO LWV VWaNeKROdeUV fRU WKe beWWeUPeQW Rf KeaOWKcaUeedXcaWLRQ aQd OLceQVLQJ LQ PaNLVWaQ!"116SRPe YRLceV ZLWKLQ WKe MSaRD cRPPXQLW\ e[SUeVVed IUXVWUaWLRQ RYeU WKe dUaZQ-RXW QaWXUe RIWKe eQJaJePeQWV aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V bURadeU KaQdOLQJ RI WKeLU SURWeVWV, SRLQWLQJ WR a SeUceLYedXQZLOOLQJQeVV WR eQJaJe LQ PeaQLQJIXO dLaORJXe aQd UeVRUWLQJ WR IRUceIXO PeaVXUeV aJaLQVWSURWeVWRUV [ASSeQdL[ B, 19]. TKe abVeQce RI PMC UeSUeVeQWaWLYeV aW cULWLcaO dLVcXVVLRQV,eVSecLaOO\ aIWeU WKe XVe RI YLROeQce aQd IRUce XVed RQ SURWeVWLQJ MSaRD, IXUWKeU IXeOeddLVcRQWeQW."WKeUe WKe VWaWe RQce aJaLQ YLROaWed WKe dLJQLW\ Rf ZRPeQ dRcWRUV LQ ZKLWe cRaWV. NR PMC UeSUeVeQWaWLYeZaV SUeVeQW fRU WKe dLVcXVVLRQ ZLWK SeacefXO dRcWRUV."4.4.2 SWaWe Yiolence againsW peacefXl adYocac\MaMRULW\ RI MSaRD IUaPed WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V IRUceIXO UeVSRQVe WR WKeLU SeaceIXO adYRcac\, aVVWaWe aJJUeVVLRQ. TKe QaUUaWLYe ePSKaVL]ed WKe PeQWaO aQd SK\VLcaO WROO RI WKe PMC'V acWLRQV RQWKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\, UeYeaOLQJ a SeUceLYed dLVUeJaUd IRU WKeLU ZeOIaUe aQd ULJKWV."fLUVW WKe\ WRUWXUe \RX PeQWaOO\ ZLWK WKeLU LQeffecWXaO aQd fXWLOe SROLcLeV, aQd ZKeQ \RX WU\ WR RSSRVe WKeP,WKe\ WRUWXUe \RX SK\VLcaOO\. WeOcRPe WR PaNLVWaQ eYeU\bRd\."TKURXJK VRcLaO PedLa SRVWV, SKRWRV, aQd YLdeRV, MSaRD dRcXPeQW LQVWaQceV RI SROLce YLROeQce,LQcOXdLQJ WKe XVe RI cKePLcaO VSUa\V aQd SK\VLcaO IRUce."#CKePLcaOSSUa\OQDRcWRUV SXOSKXULc acLd RQ XV, We cRQdePQ WKLV acW. TKLV JRYeUQPeQW faLOed WRdeOLYeU. BaUbaULc acW."117TKe LPaJeU\ RI SURWeVWRUV, SaUWLcXOaUO\ WKRVe LQ ZKLWe Oab cRaWV, VXIIeULQJ XQdeU SROLce acWLRQZKLOe cRQWLQXLQJ WR VWaQd ILUP aJaLQVW WKe NLE, SaLQWV a SLcWXUe RI YLcWLPKRRd aQd UeVLVWaQce."aWWacKed LPaJe Rf SURWeVWRU XVLQJ KLV ZKLWe Oab cRaW WR cOeaQ WKe face Rf a feOORZ SURWeVWRU, SURbabO\ KXUWdXe WR SROLce bUXWaOLW\"TKe UeSeaWed LQVWaQceV RI cKePLcaO VSUa\ aWWacNV aQd WKe VXbVeTXeQW KeaOWK UeSeUcXVVLRQV IRU WKeSURWeVWRUV Oed WR a dePaQd IRU accRXQWabLOLW\. [ASSeQdL[ B, 20]. TKe UeVSRQVe WR VWaWe YLROeQceVeePed WR IXUWKeU VROLdLI\ WKe MSaRD'V UeVROYe, ZLWK RUJaQL]aWLRQV OLNe DWM-PaNLVWaQcRQdePQLQJ WKe acWLRQV aQd SURPLVLQJ WR RXWOLQe IXWXUe cRXUVeV RI acWLRQ."DWM-PaNLVWaQ VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKe XVe Rf cKePLcaO VSUa\ RQ dRcWRUV SeacefXOO\ SURWeVWLQJ aJaLQVWNLE RXWVLde NLE E[aPLQaWLRQ CeQWeU GaUdeQ TRZQ, LaKRUe."4.4.3 Defiance againsW aXWhoriWarian imposiWionTKLV IUaPe caSWXUeV WKe MSaRD'V SeUceSWLRQ RI WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V acWLRQV aV QRW RQO\XQdePRcUaWLc bXW aOVR YLROeQWO\ eQIRUced, OeadLQJ WR a bURad VSecWUXP RI adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeVURRWed LQ UeVLVWaQce, OeJaO aUJXPeQWaWLRQ, aQd caOOV IRU XQLW\ aJaLQVW WKe LPSRVLWLRQ. A ORW RIMSaRD aUWLcXOaWed WKeLU VWUXJJOe aJaLQVW WKe NLE ZLWKLQ a bURadeU QaUUaWLYe RI ILJKWLQJ aJaLQVWaXWKRULWaULaQLVP. B\ OabeOLQJ WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V aSSURacK aV "dLcWaWRUVKLS" aQd "bOacN OaZ," WKe\QRW RQO\ UeMecW WKe NLE bXW aOVR cRQWeVW WKe OeJLWLPac\ RI WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V PeWKRd RI SROLc\LPSRVLWLRQ, IUaPLQJ LW aV aQWLWKeWLcaO WR dePRcUaWLc JRYeUQaQce. [ASSeQdL[ B, 21]"TKLV LV QRW dePRcUac\, TKLV LV DICTATORSHIP."118SRPe MSaRD'V aWWePSWed WR IXUWKeU IRUWLI\ WKeLU UeVLVWaQce b\ XVLQJ OeJaO aQd cRQVWLWXWLRQaO aUJXPeQWV,aVVeUWLQJ WKaW WKe LPSRVLWLRQ RI WKe NLE RQ JUadXaWeV UeWURacWLYeO\ LV bRWK XQIaLU aQd LOOeJaO."FRUcLQJ NLE RQ JUadXaWeV LV aJaLQVW WKe cRQVWLWXWLRQ Rf WKe IVOaPLc ReSXbOLc Rf PaNLVWaQ, aQd LW dReVQ'WaSSO\ WR aQ\ adPLVVLRQ WKaW KaSSeQed befRUe SeSWePbeU 2020."TKe ePaLOV WKaW PMC VeQW WR WKe VWXdeQWV IRU NLE UeJLVWUaWLRQ, VRPe MSaRD SeUceLYed LW aV aPaQLSXOaWLYe VWUaWeJ\ ePSOR\ed b\ WKe aXWKRULWLeV."PMC LV UeVRUWLQJ WR dLUW\ WacWLcV b\ VeQdLQJ ePaLOV WR VWXdeQWV WR UeJLVWeU fRU WKe NLE. POeaVe dR QRWUeJLVWeU \RXUVeOf, RWKeUZLVe, WKe\ ZLOO aUJXe LQ cRXUW WKaW VWXdeQWV aUe Uead\ fRU WKe NLE."119ChapWer 5: DiscXssionBXLOdLQJ XSRQ WKe UeVeaUcK aLPV aQd RbMecWLYeV RXWOLQed eaUOLeU LQ SecWLRQ 1, WKLV dLVcXVVLRQdeOYeV LQWR WKe PXOWLIaceWed UROe RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ aQdadYRcac\ ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ'V cRPSOe[ VRcLR-SROLWLcaO OaQdVcaSe. TKe VWXd\'V e[SORUaWLRQ RIMSaRD'VV KLVWRULcaO deYeORSPeQW, cXUUeQW d\QaPLcV, aQd dLJLWaO acWLYLVP VeWV WKe VWaJe IRU aQXaQced aQaO\VLV RI WKeLU LPSacW RQ KeaOWK SROLc\ debaWeV aQd RXWcRPeV. B\ addUeVVLQJ WKeUeVeaUcK TXeVWLRQV SeUWaLQLQJ WR WKe cKaUacWeULVWLcV, VWUXcWXUe, adYRcac\ LVVXeV, aQd VWUaWeJLeV RIMSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV, WKLV dLVcXVVLRQ VKedV OLJKW RQ WKeLU SOace, UROe aQd LPSacW LQ KeaOWK SROLc\SURceVVeV. E[SORULQJ IUaPLQJ aSSURacKeV adRSWed b\ SURWeVWLQJ dRcWRUV aQd PedLcaO VWXdeQWVaJaLQVW WKe NLE LQ 2021 aOVR SURYLdeV YaOXabOe LQVLJKWV LQWR WKeLU PLQdVeW, SeUceSWLRQV aQde[SecWaWLRQV aV Ne\ acWRUV WKURXJK a VSecLILc SROLc\ debaWe cRQceUQLQJ WKe KeaOWKcaUe aQdPedLcaO edXcaWLRQ V\VWeP RI PaNLVWaQ.5.1 NaYigaWing YXlnerabiliW\, marginali]aWion and agenc\ - The comple[ posiWion ofMSaRD in PakisWan's healWhcare s\sWemTKLV VWXd\ KLJKOLJKWV WKe cRPSOe[ d\QaPLcV RI YXOQeUabLOLW\, PaUJLQaOL]aWLRQ aQd aJeQc\,caSWXULQJ WKe QXaQced e[SeULeQceV RI MSaRD ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ'V cRQWePSRUaU\ KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP.TKeVe dLPeQVLRQV LQWeUWZLQe WR VKaSe WKeLU SURIeVVLRQaO MRXUQe\, SeUVRQaO ZeOO-beLQJ, aQd WKeLUcaSacLW\ WR adYRcaWe IRU V\VWePLc KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUPV. DeVSLWe beLQJ LQWeJUaO WR KeaOWKcaUedeOLYeU\ aQd UeSUeVeQWLQJ WKe IXWXUe RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNIRUce, MSaRD RIWeQ eQcRXQWeUV\VWePLc RbVWacOeV WKaW e[SRXQdV WKeLU cKaOOeQJLQJ SRVLWLRQ LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe KLeUaUcK\.120MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ OLNe PaQ\ cRXQWULeV acURVV WKe JORbe aUe cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ YXOQeUabLOLW\,aULVLQJ IURP LQWeUWZLQed V\VWePLc LVVXeV VXcK aV cRUUXSWLRQ, SRRU JRYeUQaQce, aQd OacN RI UXOe RIOaZ.104.105 TKeVe V\VWePLc LVVXeV UeQdeU WKeP YXOQeUabOe WR a UaQJe RI ULVNV, LQcOXdLQJ XQIaLUWUeaWPeQW, caUeeU SURJUeVVLRQ baUULeUV, aQd XQVaIe ZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV.104.105 TKeVe YXOQeUabLOLWLeVaUe cRPSRXQded b\ WKeLU SRVLWLRQ ZLWKLQ WKe PedLcaO KLeUaUcK\, ZKeUe WKe\ aUe RIWeQ aW WKe PeUc\RI WRS-dRZQ adPLQLVWUaWLYe aQd SROLc\ decLVLRQV WKaW dLUecWO\ LPSacW WKeLU edXcaWLRQ,ePSOR\PeQW, aQd RYeUaOO ZeOO-beLQJ, XOWLPaWeO\ aIIecWLQJ WKe TXaOLW\ RI KeaOWK caUedeOLYeUed.106.107 FXUWKeUPRUe, WKeLU SURIeVVLRQaO RbOLJaWLRQ WR SaWLeQW caUe SOaceV WKeP LQ VLWXaWLRQVZKeUe WKe\ PXVW QaYLJaWe WKe eWKLcaO dLOePPaV aQd SeUVRQaO ULVNV aVVRcLaWed ZLWK LQadeTXaWeKeaOWKcaUe UeVRXUceV aQd LQIUaVWUXcWXUe deILcLeQcLeV.108TKLV VWXd\ VKRZV WKaW deVSLWe WKeLU YXOQeUabOe aQd cRPSOe[ SRVLWLRQ [SecWLRQ 3.4], MSaRD LQPaNLVWaQ adYRcaWe IRU a ZLde UaQJe RI LVVXeV [SecWLRQ 3.5, 3.6] WKaW KLJKOLJKW WKeLU UROe aV aJeQWVRI cKaQJe ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, ZKLcK accRUdLQJ WR M.LXIW (2017) LV a Ne\ SURIeVVLRQaOUeVSRQVLbLOLW\.109 TKeLU ILUVWKaQd e[SeULeQceV ZLWK V\VWePLc IaLOXUeV LQ SaWLeQW caUe aQd KeaOWKcaUedeOLYeU\ ePSRZeU WKeP aV YLWaO adYRcaWeV IRU cKaQJe, ePSKaVL]LQJ WKe QeceVVLW\ IRU UeIRUPV WKaWWacNOe WKe URRW caXVeV RI WKeVe cKaOOeQJeV.110 TKeLU SURacWLYe aSSURacK [SecWLRQ 3.6] QRW RQO\dePRQVWUaWeV VLJQLILcaQW aJeQc\ bXW aOVR aOLJQV ZLWK WKe CaQMEDS IUaPeZRUN, ZKLcK RXWOLQeVeVVeQWLaO SK\VLcLaQ cRPSeWeQcLeV. TKLV IUaPeZRUN KLJKOLJKWV WKe UROe RI HeaOWK AdYRcaWeV,XUJLQJ SK\VLcLaQV WR XVe WKeLU e[SeUWLVe WR acWLYeO\ SURPRWe WKe KeaOWK RI LQdLYLdXaOV,cRPPXQLWLeV, aQd SRSXOaWLRQV.110.111 B\ LQWeJUaWLQJ WKeVe cRPSeWeQcLeV, MSaRD e[ePSOLILeVePeUJLQJ OeadeUVKLS aQd a cRPPLWPeQW WR adYaQcLQJ KeaOWKcaUe, IXOILOOLQJ WKeLU UROeV aV MedLcaOE[SeUWV, HeaOWK AdYRcaWeV, aQd PURIeVVLRQaOV. 110121TKe LVVXeV MSaRD eQcRXQWeU aUe UeIOecWLYe RI bURadeU V\VWePLc LVVXeV ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ'VKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, LQcOXdLQJ LQeTXLWLeV LQ KeaOWKcaUe acceVV, TXaOLW\, aQd deOLYeU\.111 MSaRD,deVSLWe beLQJ eVVeQWLaO WR KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\ aQd WKe IXWXUe ZRUNIRUce, RIWeQ e[SeULeQcePaUJLQaOL]aWLRQ ZLWKLQ YaULRXV aVSecWV RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP, LQcOXdLQJ SROLc\ PaNLQJSURceVV. TKXV, ZKLOe WKe\ adYRcaWe IRU cKaQJe, WKe\ eQcRXQWeU dLIILcXOWLeV LQ beLQJ SaUW RI WKeIRUPaO decLVLRQ-PaNLQJ SURcedXUeV. TKLV PaUJLQaOL]aWLRQ LV eYLdeQW LQ WKe OacN RI cRQVLdeUaWLRQJLYeQ WR WKeLU LQSXW RQ edXcaWLRQaO UeIRUPV, ZRUNSOace cRQdLWLRQV, aQd KeaOWKcaUe SUacWLceV. SXcKe[cOXVLRQ QRW RQO\ XQdeUPLQeV WKe SRWeQWLaO cRQWULbXWLRQV RI MSaRD WR KeaOWKcaUe LPSURYePeQWbXW aOVR SeUSeWXaWeV a c\cOe RI V\VWePLc LQeIILcLeQcLeV b\ LJQRULQJ IURQWOLQe LQVLJKWV LQWR SaWLeQWcaUe aQd KeaOWKcaUe deOLYeU\ cKaOOeQJeV.112 HaVVaQ eW aO (2020) VXSSOePeQW WKLV VWXd\¶V ILQdLQJVb\ aUJXLQJ WKaW WKe aJJUeVVLRQ dLVSOa\ed b\ \RXQJ dRcWRUV LQ PaNLVWaQ, PaQLIeVWLQJ WKURXJKSURWeVWV, VWULNeV, aQd abVeQWeeLVP RUJaQL]ed b\ WKe YRXQJ DRcWRUV MRYePeQW, LV a UeVXOW RIcRQVcLRXV decLVLRQV LQIOXeQced b\ WKe FUXVWUaWLRQ-AJJUeVVLRQ K\SRWKeVLV aV SURSRVed b\ DROOaUdeW aO.1 TKe aXWKRUV cRQQecW WKLV beKaYLRUaO SaWWeUQ WR WKe WKeRU\ RI VRcLaO PRYePeQWV, VXJJeVWLQJWKaW WKeVe acWLRQV b\ \RXQJ dRcWRUV aUe deOLbeUaWe UeVSRQVeV WR IUXVWUaWLRQV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKV\VWeP, ZKLOe beLQJ aZaUe RI WKe LPSacW RI WKeLU acWLRQ RQ WKe aOUead\ cULVLV-VWULcNeQ KeaOWKV\VWeP. LaUJeO\ cRQVLVWeQW ZLWK WKe ILQdLQJV KeUe, WKLV SaSeU cRQcOXdeV WKaW WR UeVROYe WKe KeaOWKV\VWeP cULVLV, LW LV cUXcLaO IRU WKe \RXQJ dRcWRUV aQd SROLc\PaNeUV WR eQJaJe LQ QeJRWLaWLRQV WRILQd a PXWXaOO\ aJUeeabOe VROXWLRQ.AOWKRXJK PaQ\ KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV SRVVeVV YaOXabOe LQVLJKWV IURP WKeLU e[SeULeQceV, WKe\ RIWeQOacN WKe VNLOOV LQ SROLc\ aQaO\VLV, cRPPXQLcaWLRQ, aQd caPSaLJQLQJ WR adYRcaWe IRU cKaQJeeIIecWLYeO\.113 WKLOe LW LV cUXcLaO WR SURYLde MSaRD ZLWK WKe WUaLQLQJ aQd edXcaWLRQ Qeeded IRU122eIIecWLYe SROLc\ eQJaJePeQW, addUeVVLQJ WKe OacN RI RSSRUWXQLWLeV IRU WKeLU LQYROYePeQW LQLQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed cKaQJe SURceVVeV LV eTXaOO\ LPSRUWaQW.113 TKeUeIRUe, aORQJVLde eQKaQcLQJ WKeLUSROLWLcaO OLWeUac\ WKURXJK YLVLbOe SaWKZa\V, VXcK aV XQdeUJUadXaWe cRXUVeV aQd LQWeUQVKLSV, LW LVLPSeUaWLYe WR cUeaWe VWUXcWXUed aYeQXeV VXcK aV XQLRQV aQd UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV IRU WKeLUdLUecW SaUWLcLSaWLRQ LQ decLVLRQ-PaNLQJ SURceVVeV. IQWeJUaWLQJ SROLc\ edXcaWLRQ LQWR PedLcaOWUaLQLQJ ZLOO QRW RQO\ ePSRZeU SK\VLcLaQV WR cRQWULbXWe PRUe eIIecWLYeO\ WR KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUP bXWaOVR eQVXUe WKaW SROLcLeV aUe JURXQded LQ WKe SUacWLcaO e[SeULeQceV aQd QeedV RI KeaOWKcaUeSURYLdeUV aQd WKeLU SaWLeQWV.113.114 HRZeYeU, LW LV cUXcLaO WR acNQRZOedJe WKaW KeaOWK ZRUNeUV Pa\QRW aOZa\V adYRcaWe IRU SROLcLeV WKaW aOLJQ ZLWK WKe beVW LQWeUeVWV RI SaWLeQWV RU cRPPXQLWLeV.TKeUeIRUe, aORQJVLde eTXLSSLQJ MSaRD ZLWK SROLWLcaO OLWeUac\ LW LV cULWLcaO WR cXOWLYaWe a VeQVe RIeWKLcaO UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ aQd cRPPXQLW\ accRXQWabLOLW\ LQ PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV WR aOORZ WKeP WKebeWWeU XVe RI WKeLU SRVLWLRQ aQd VWUeQJWK LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV.115 IQ VXP, WKLV aSSURacK RYeUaOOZLOO QRW RQO\ ePSRZeU MSaRD WR cRQWULbXWe PRUe PeaQLQJIXOO\ WR KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUP bXW Pa\aOVR PLWLJaWeV WKe WeQdeQc\ WRZaUdV UadLcaO acWLRQV VWePPLQJ IURP IeeOLQJV RIdLVeQIUaQcKLVePeQW aQd e[cOXVLRQ IURP WKe SROLc\-PaNLQJ UeaOP, a UecRPPeQdaWLRQ aSW IRU WKecXUUeQW VLWXaWLRQ RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ.112.1165.2 AdapWing Wo change - The eYolYing adYocac\ of medical sWXdenWs in PakisWanTKe OaQdVcaSe RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ KaV e[SeULeQced a SURIRXQd WUaQVIRUPaWLRQIROORZLQJ WKe 1984 baQ, ZKLcK ZaV LPSOePeQWed WR TXeOO caPSXV YLROeQce aQd UeVWRUeedXcaWLRQaO Seace. TKLV baQ eQWaLOV a SURKLbLWLRQ RQ SROLWLcaO acWLYLWLeV aQd WKe IRUPaWLRQ RIVWXdeQW XQLRQV LQ edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQV acURVV WKe cRXQWU\.20 FRU MSaRD, WKLV baQ KaV Oed WR adecOLQe LQ cRQVSLcXRXV SROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQWV, SURPSWLQJ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV WR UecRQVLdeU WKeLU123VWUaWeJLeV LQ OLJKW RI SRWeQWLaO acadePLc cRQVeTXeQceV.117 TKe UeVXOWV RI WKLV VWXd\ LQdLcaWe WKaWMSaRD'VV cXUUeQW adYRcac\ UeIOecWV a VWUaWeJLc VKLIW WRZaUdV LQYROYePeQW LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\aQd acadePLa. TKLV eYROXWLRQ LV cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ a PRYe aZa\ IURP WKe dLUecW, SROLWLcaOO\cKaUJed acWLRQV W\SLcaOO\ aVVRcLaWed ZLWK QaWLRQaO SaUWLeV. HRZeYeU, LW LV LPSRUWaQW WR UecRJQL]eWKaW WKe Qeed IRU VXcK RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ VKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUPV Pa\ e[LVW LQdeSeQdeQWO\ RIaQ\ VSecLILc SROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQW. MSaRD'VV UROe cRXOd be IXQdaPeQWaOO\ dULYeQ b\ a bURadeUPaQdaWe WR LQIOXeQce KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ aQd acadePLc dLVcRXUVe. TKXV LW Pa\ QRW be ZURQJ WRcRQcOXde WKaW WKLV UecaOLbUaWed IRcXV WRZaUd KeaOWKcaUe adYRcac\, LV QRW PeUeO\ a UeVSRQVe WR WKeUeVWULcWLRQV bXW aOVR a VWUaWeJLc eYROXWLRQ WR PaLQWaLQ WKeLU SOace aQd LQIOXeQce aV Ne\VWaNeKROdeUV LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP RI PaNLVWaQ ZLWKLQ WKe QeZ bRXQdaULeV.HRZeYeU, deVSLWe WKeVe cKaQJeV, WKe dePRcUaWLc eWKRV UePaLQV LQWacW ZLWKLQ WKeLU RUJaQL]aWLRQV,aQ eOePeQW UeWaLQed IURP WKe IabULc RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV IURP WKe SaVW LQ PaNLVWaQ. TKe MSaRDRUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ e[ePSOLI\ WKe cRQceSW RI SUeILJXUaWLYe SROLWLcV WKURXJK WKeLUcRPPLWPeQW WR dePRcUac\, WUaQVSaUeQc\, aQd accRXQWabLOLW\ QRW RQO\ LQWeUQaOO\ bXW aOVR LQ WKeLUadYRcac\ eIIRUWV ZLWKLQ WKe OaUJeU KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP.118 DeVSLWe RSeUaWLQJ LQ a QaWLRQaO cRQWe[WZKeUe WKeVe SULQcLSOeV Pa\ QRW be cRQVLVWeQWO\ RbVeUYed RU LPSOePeQWed, WKe MSaRD KaYeSURacWLYeO\ eVWabOLVKed a IUaPeZRUN ZLWKLQ WKeLU RUJaQL]aWLRQV WKaW ePSKaVL]eV dePRcUaWLcdecLVLRQ-PaNLQJ, eQVXULQJ IaLU UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ aQd SaUWLcLSaWLRQ IRU aOO PePbeUV.119 TKLV SURacWLYeVWaQce b\ WKe MSaRD cRQWUaVWV ZLWK WKe SUeYaLOLQJ VWaWe PecKaQLVPV aQd VKRZcaVeV a deOLbeUaWeeIIRUW WR PRdeO WKe YaOXeV WKe\ beOLeYe VKRXOd XQdeUSLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU aQd JRYeUQaQcePRUe bURadO\. B\ dRLQJ VR, WKe\ aUe cUeaWLQJ a PLcURcRVP RI WKe VRcLeW\ WKe\ aVSLUe WR UeaOL]e,ZKeUe eWKLcaO beKaYLRU aQd UeVSRQVLbOe JRYeUQaQce aUe SaUaPRXQW.118 TKeLU acWLRQV VeUYe aV a124UeaO-ZRUOd aSSOLcaWLRQ RI SUeILJXUaWLYe SROLWLcV, dePRQVWUaWLQJ WKaW LW LV SRVVLbOe WR ePbRd\ aQdadYaQce WKe SULQcLSOeV RI a dePRcUaWLc aQd accRXQWabOe VRcLeW\, eYeQ LQ cRQWe[WV ZKeUe WKeVeYaOXeV aUe cKaOOeQJed. MRUeRYeU, WKe MSaRD eIIRUWV WR adYRcaWe IRU WKeVe SULQcLSOeV acURVV WKeKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP UeIOecW a bURadeU YLVLRQ RI VRcLaO cKaQJe, e[WeQdLQJ WKeLU LQIOXeQce be\RQdWKeLU LPPedLaWe RUJaQL]aWLRQaO bRXQdaULeV. TKLV aSSURacK QRW RQO\ VWUeQJWKeQV WKe LQWeJULW\ aQdeIIecWLYeQeVV RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU bXW aOVR cRQWULbXWeV WR WKe OaUJeU PRYePeQW WRZaUdV a PRUedePRcUaWLc aQd WUaQVSaUeQW VRcLeW\ LQ PaNLVWaQ.5.3 The indispensable adYocaWes - The sWraWegic resisWance and adYocac\ of MSaRDin PakisWan's cXrrenW enYironmenWTKLV VWXd\ [SecWLRQ 4.3] VKRZV WKaW MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ aWWacK JUeaW YaOXe WR WKeLU adYRcac\,VeeLQJ LW aV a cRPSOe[ eIIRUW JURXQded LQ eWKLcaO UeaVRQLQJ, WKRXJKWIXO VWUaWeJLeV, aQd cRPPXQLW\LQYROYePeQW. TKeVe aVSecWV ZLOO be IXUWKeU e[SORUed LQ WKLV VecWLRQ aKead. TKe adYRcac\SURceVVeV RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ caQ be cULWLcaOO\ aQaO\]ed WKURXJK WKe OeQV RI WKe bURadeUcRQceSW RI SK\VLcLaQ UeVLVWaQce WR LQMXVWLce, aV RXWOLQed LQ WKe VcRSLQJ UeYLeZ b\ WK\We eW aO(2023).120 EOOaZa\ aQd W\aWW (2021) ZLWKLQ WKe deILQLWLRQ RI SURIeVVLRQaO adYRcac\ VLJQLI\ WKeLPSRUWaQce RI cROOecWLYe acWLRQ LQ LQVWaQceV RI SK\VLcLaQ UeVLVWaQce, LOOXVWUaWLQJ KRZ cRQceUWedeIIRUWV caQ aPSOLI\ WKe LPSacW RI adYRcac\ aJaLQVW V\VWePLc LQMXVWLceV.121 TKLV SULQcLSOe LV YLYLdO\PLUURUed LQ WKe MSaRD'V VWUaWeJLc PRbLOL]aWLRQ aJaLQVW NLE LQ PaNLVWaQ. FRU MSaRD LQPaNLVWaQ, VXcK acWLRQV Pa\ UeSUeVeQW a XQLILed IURQW, cKaOOeQJLQJ WKe SROLcLeV aQd decLVLRQV WKaWMSaRD cRQVLdeU XQIaYRUabOe, UeIOecWLQJ a deeS-VeaWed beOLeI LQ WKe SRZeU RI cROOecWLYe acWLRQ WReIIecW cKaQJe. MRUaO aJeQc\, aV dLVcXVVed LQ WKe VcRSLQJ UeYLeZ, LV WKe eWKLcaO IRXQdaWLRQ WKaWdULYeV SK\VLcLaQV WR UeVLVW SROLcLeV aQd SUacWLceV SeUceLYed aV KaUPIXO.120 TKLV eWKLcaO LPSeUaWLYe125LV eTXaOO\ eYLdeQW LQ MSaRD'VV caPSaLJQ, ZKeUe WKe\ SRVLWLRQ WKeLU UeVLVWaQce be\RQdSURIeVVLRQaO VeOI-LQWeUeVW, aQcKRULQJ LW LQ bURadeU cRQceUQV abRXW WKe TXaOLW\ RI PedLcaO edXcaWLRQaQd SUacWLce, VRcLaO MXVWLce, aQd WKeLU LPSacW RQ SaWLeQW caUe. IQ VKRUW, WKLV UeIOecWV WKaW MSaRDSRVLWLRQV WKeLU adYRcac\ ZLWKLQ aQ eWKLcaO IUaPeZRUN, aLPLQJ WR OeJLWLPL]e aQd JaOYaQL]e WKeLUcRPPXQLW\ WRZaUdV XQLILed UeVLVWaQceTKe YaULRXV VWUaWeJLeV ePSOR\ed b\ WKe MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ QRW RQO\ LOOXPLQaWe WKe SRZeUd\QaPLcV ZLWKLQ WKe cRXQWU\'V KeaOWKcaUe aQd edXcaWLRQaO VecWRUV bXW aOVR XQdeUVcRUe a VWUaWeJLceQJaJePeQW WR VZa\ SROLc\ decLVLRQV aQd WKe VKaSe RI WKe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ. TKLV VWUaWeJLceQJaJePeQW LV UeIOecWLYe RI SLdQe\ TaUURZ'V cRQceSW RI WKe "UeSeUWRLUe RI acWLRQ," ZKeUePRYePeQWV dUaZ IURP a cROOecWLYe WRRObR[ RI WacWLcV WR QaYLJaWe aQd QeJRWLaWe ZLWKLQ eVWabOLVKedSRZeU VWUXcWXUeV.122 TKe adYRcac\ PeWKRdV RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ UeVRQaWe ZeOO ZLWK WKe 31EIIecWLYe SWUaWeJLeV & MeWKRdV KLJKOLJKWed b\ DaQ JaVSeU, ecKRLQJ TaUURZ¶V SeUVSecWLYe RQ KRZVRcLaO PRYePeQWV VWUaWeJLcaOO\ adaSW WKeLU acWLRQV baVed RQ WKe cRQWe[W.122.123IQ OLJKW RI WKe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV baQ LQ WKe cRXQWU\, WKURXJK bR\cRWWLQJ, SXbOLc SURWeVWV, aQd dLJLWaOadYRcac\, MSaRD aUe cRQIURQWLQJ WKe eQWUeQcKed SRZeU KLeUaUcKLeV aQd WKe VWaWXV TXR, a dLUecWePbRdLPeQW RI TaUURZ¶V RbVeUYaWLRQ WKaW PRYePeQWV XWLOL]e WKeLU UeSeUWRLUe WR eIIecWXaWecKaQJe.122 TKe UeVLVWaQce aJaLQVW WKe LPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI NLE b\ MSaRD e[ePSOLILeV QRW PeUeO\a dLVVeQW aJaLQVW a VSecLILc SROLc\ bXW a bURadeU VWUaWeJLc VWaQce aJaLQVW ceQWUaOL]eddecLVLRQ-PaNLQJ SURceVVeV, dePRQVWUaWLQJ a SURacWLYe eQJaJePeQW ZLWKLQ WKeLU UeSeUWRLUe RIacWLRQ, aV deVcULbed b\ TaUURZ.122 EVVe[¶V (2023) dLVcXVVLRQ RQ SK\VLcLaQV' WeQdeQc\ WR cRQIURQW126V\VWePLc LQMXVWLceV ecKReV WKe QeceVVLW\ ZLWKLQ TaUURZ¶V IUaPeZRUN IRU PRYePeQWV WR ePSOR\dLUecW acWLRQ aV a PeaQV RI addUeVVLQJ aQd UecWLI\LQJ V\VWePLc LVVXeV.122.124DUaZLQJ IURP WKe 31 eIIecWLYe VWUaWeJLeV, LW LV eYLdeQW WKaW adYRcac\ dePaQdV a QXaQcedQaYLJaWLRQ beWZeeQ RSSRVLQJ IRUceV: cKaOOeQJLQJ aXWKRULW\ ZKLOe VeeNLQJ cRQVWUXcWLYedLaORJXe.123 TKLV VWUaWeJLc QaYLJaWLRQ RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ aOLJQV ZLWK TaUURZ'V LQVLJKWV, ZKeUeWKe baOaQce beWZeeQ cRQIURQWaWLRQ aQd dLaORJXe LV cUXcLaO IRU adYaQcLQJ a PRYePeQW'VRbMecWLYeV, SaUWLcXOaUO\ LQ WKe LQWULcaWe OaQdVcaSe RI KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ aQd edXcaWLRQ UeIRUP WKaWMSaRD aUe QaYLJaWLQJ.122 WK\We eW aO. (2023) aQd DaQ JaVSeU ePSKaVL]e WKe cULWLcaO UROe RIYLVLbLOLW\ LQ SK\VLcLaQ UeVLVWaQce PRYePeQWV, XQdeUVcRULQJ WKe VWUaWeJLc XWLOL]aWLRQ RI SXbOLcdePRQVWUaWLRQV aQd VRcLaO PedLa, ZKLcK LV aOVR cRQVLVWeQW ZLWK TaUURZ¶V QRWLRQ WKaW YLVLbLOLW\ LV aNe\ eOePeQW LQ WKe UeSeUWRLUe RI acWLRQ, aLPLQJ WR aPSOLI\ VSecLILc caXVeV aQd LQIOXeQceKeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ WUaQVIRUPaWLRQ.120.122.123 TKe MSaRD'VV eIIRUWV WR eQJaJe SROLWLcaO ILJXUeV,XWLOL]LQJ dLUecW aSSeaOV RU VRcLaO PedLa, dePRQVWUaWe aQ acXWe XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe SROLWLcaOeQJaJePeQW¶V VLJQLILcaQce LQ SROLc\ UeIRUP, UeVRQaWLQJ ZLWK WKe abRYe aUJXPeQW RQ WKeLPSRUWaQce RI ePSOR\LQJ a dLYeUVLILed VeW RI WacWLcV ZLWKLQ WKe UeSeUWRLUe RI cROOecWLYe acWLRQ.B\ SURPRWLQJ WKeLU caXVe WKURXJK PedLa aQd aOLJQLQJ LW ZLWK bURadeU cRQceUQV abRXW PedLcaOedXcaWLRQ aQd SaWLeQW caUe, MSaRD aUe QRW RQO\ LQYLWLQJ SXbOLc VcUXWLQ\ aQd debaWe bXW aOVRe[eUW SUeVVXUe RQ SROLc\PaNeUV WR UeaVVeVV RU aPeQd e[LVWLQJ SROLcLeV. TKLV WacWLc RI OeYeUaJLQJSXbOLc eQJaJePeQW aQd VcUXWLQ\ dRYeWaLOV ZLWK TaUURZ¶V aVVeUWLRQ aV ZeOO aV WKe VcRSLQJ UeYLeZ,WKaW PaNLQJ UeVLVWaQce YLVLbOe aQd eQJaJLQJ a ZLdeU aXdLeQce aUe SLYRWaO LQ e[eUWLQJ LQIOXeQce RQSROLc\ aQd IRVWeULQJ accRXQWabLOLW\.120.125 IQ VXPPaU\, VWUaWeJLeV WKaW WKe\ ePSOR\, WRJeWKeU cUeaWe127a d\QaPLc aQd adaSWLYe aSSURacK WR adYRcac\ WKaW LV aQ LQWULcaWe baOaQce beWZeeQ dLUecW acWLRQ,dLaORJXe, SXbOLc PRbLOL]aWLRQ, aQd VecXULQJ SROLWLcaO bacNLQJ WR IXOILOO WKeLU aJeQdaV. TKLVaSSURacK QRW RQO\ PLUURUV WKe JORbaO SaWWeUQV RI SK\VLcLaQ UeVLVWaQce bXW aOVR KLJKOLJKWV WKeXQLYeUVaO cKaOOeQJeV aQd VWUaWeJLc QXaQceV ZLWKLQ KeaOWKcaUe adYRcac\, XQdeUOLQLQJ WKe SUacWLcaOaSSOLcaWLRQ RI TaUURZ¶V cRQceSW LQ UeaO-ZRUOd VceQaULRV.FXUWKeUPRUe, WKe bacNdURS RI WKe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV baQ LQ PaNLVWaQ QeceVVLWaWeV a UeeYaOXaWLRQ RIWKe VcRSe RI SURIeVVLRQaO adYRcac\ ZLWKLQ WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\. IQ WKLV cRQWe[W, WKe dLVcXVVLRQRI WKe OeJLWLPac\ RI UeVLVWaQce aQd SURIeVVLRQaO UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ LQ WKe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV JLYeV aXQLTXe SeUVSecWLYe RQ WKe adYRcac\ SURceVV RI MSaRD. TKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQcUeaWeV aQ eQYLURQPeQW ZKeUe eQJaJLQJ LQ SURWeVWV, RUJaQL]LQJ bR\cRWWV, RU eYeQ OeYeUaJLQJVRcLaO PedLa IRU adYRcac\ SXUSRVeV caQ be VeeQ aV SROLWLcaO acWV, VXbMecWLQJ SaUWLcLSaQWV WRSRWeQWLaO UeSULVaOV IURP edXcaWLRQaO LQVWLWXWLRQV RU aXWKRULWLeV. TKe MSaRD'VV UeVLVWaQce WKXVacTXLUeV aQ added Oa\eU RI eWKLcaO cRPSOe[LW\. TKeLU eIIRUWV WR QaYLJaWe WKe baQ ZKLOe adYRcaWLQJXQdeUVcRUe a VWUaWeJLc baOaQcLQJ acW beWZeeQ cRPSOLaQce ZLWK e[LVWLQJ UeJXOaWLRQV aQd WKe PRUaOLPSeUaWLYe WR cKaOOeQJe SROLcLeV SeUceLYed aV XQMXVW. WLWKLQ WKLV cRQVWUaLQed OaQdVcaSe, MSaRD'VadYRcac\ UeIOecWV QRW MXVW a ILJKW aJaLQVW a VSecLILc SROLc\ bXW aOVR a bURadeU cRQWeVWaWLRQ aJaLQVWV\VWePLc baUULeUV WR VWXdeQW aQd SURIeVVLRQaO eQJaJePeQW LQ SROLc\ dLVcRXUVe.5.4 The amplified Yoices - The inflXence of MSaRD's digiWal adYocac\ on healWhpolic\ in PakisWanTKe JeQeUaO eOecWLRQ RI 2024 LQ PaNLVWaQ VWaQdV aV a VePLQaO caVe VWXd\ dePRQVWUaWLQJ WKeSURIRXQd LQWeJUaWLRQ RI VRcLaO PedLa LQWR WKe IabULc RI QaWLRQaO SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ, VKRZcaVLQJ128KRZ dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV KaYe becRPe LQdLVSeQVabOe WRROV IRU SROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQW, PRbLOL]aWLRQaQd adYRcac\.126.127 TKURXJK LQQRYaWLYe WacWLcV VXcK aV YLUWXaO UaOOLeV, WKe XVe RI aUWLILcLaOLQWeOOLJeQce WR dLVVePLQaWe PeVVaJeV, aQd WKe cUeaWLRQ RI SeeU-WR-SeeU cRPPXQLcaWLRQ QeWZRUNV,SROLWLcaO eQWLWLeV ZeUe abOe WR b\SaVV WUadLWLRQaO PedLa cRQVWUaLQWV, dLUecWO\ eQJaJe ZLWK a\RXQJeU, PRUe WecK-VaYY\ eOecWRUaWe, aQd VLJQLILcaQWO\ LQIOXeQce YRWeU beKaYLRU aQdSeUceSWLRQV.127 TKLV VWUaWeJLc ePbUace RI dLJLWaO WRROV VLJQLILeV a UecRJQLWLRQ RI VRcLaO PedLa'VSRZeU WR VKaSe SROLWLcaO dLVcRXUVe aQd RXWcRPeV, KLJKOLJKWLQJ LWV UROe aV a cULWLcaO baWWOeJURXQdIRU SROLWLcaO adYRcac\ LQ PaNLVWaQ aQd JORbaOO\.128.129-131TKLV dLJLWaO d\QaPLVP ZLWKLQ WKe SROLWLcaO VSKeUe PLUURUV WKe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV RI MSaRD. TKeadYRcac\ SURceVV RI MSaRD LV cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ LWV VWUaWeJLc XVe RI VRcLaO PedLa WR PRbLOL]eVXSSRUW, dLVVePLQaWe LQIRUPaWLRQ, aQd eQJaJe LQ SXbOLc dLVcRXUVe. B\ OeYeUaJLQJ SOaWIRUPV OLNeTZLWWeU/X, FacebRRN, aQd WKaWVASS, MSaRD UaLVe aZaUeQeVV abRXW LVVXeV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUeV\VWeP, RUJaQL]e SURWeVWV, aQd caOO IRU SROLc\ cKaQJeV, dePRQVWUaWLQJ VRcLaO PedLa'V eIILcac\ aV aWRRO IRU adYRcac\ aQd cROOecWLYe acWLRQ. TKe KeLJKWeQed SROLWLcaO cRQVcLRXVQeVV, IacLOLWaWed b\ WKeXbLTXLWRXV XVe RI dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV, VLJQLILeV a JURZLQJ SROLWLcaO acWLYLW\ LQ WKe cRXQWU\.126.127 FRUMSaRD, WKLV WUeQd LPSOLeV WKe adYRcac\ UROe RI MSaRD caQQRW be dLVeQWaQJOed IURP WKeKeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ SURceVV, aV WKeLU eIIRUWV aUe SaUW aQd SaUceO RI a OaUJeU PRYePeQW WRZaUdV aPRUe eQJaJed, LQIRUPed, aQd acWLYe cLWL]eQU\ caSabOe RI LQIOXeQcLQJ SROLc\ decLVLRQV.1295.5 MSaRD¶s adYocac\ in PakisWan WhroXgh Della PorWa's lensASSO\LQJ DRQaWeOOa deOOa PRUWa eW aO.'V IUaPeZRUN (2020) WR WKe adYRcac\ RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQLQ UeVSRQVe WR WKe cRQVWUaLQWV aQd RSSRUWXQLWLeV SUeVeQWed b\ WKeLU SROLWLcaO aQd LQVWLWXWLRQaOeQYLURQPeQW SaLQWV aQ LQWeUeVWLQJ caQYaV RI VWUaWeJLc bXW SRWeQWLaOO\ PLOLWaQW adYRcac\.TKe baVeOLQe IRU WKe MSaRD'VV adYRcac\ eIIRUWV LQ PaNLVWaQ LV cKaUacWeUL]ed b\ ORZLQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ, ZKeUe WKeUe aUe VcaQW IRUPaO cKaQQeOV IRU WKeLU YRLceV LQ WKe decLVLRQ-PaNLQJSURceVVeV cRQceUQLQJ WKeLU edXcaWLRQ aQd SURIeVVLRQaO IXWXUeV.33 TKLV OacN RI UecRJQL]ed aQdVWUXcWXUed PecKaQLVPV IRU eQJaJePeQW ZLWK SROLc\PaNeUV OeadV WR adYRcac\ WKaW LV QRWePbedded ZLWKLQ WKe LQVWLWXWLRQaO IabULc RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe aQd KLJKeU edXcaWLRQ VecWRUV. TKLVQeceVVLW\ KaV JLYeQ ULVe WR a VWUaWeJLc XVe RI bRWK dLVUXSWLYe aQd QRQ-dLVUXSWLYe WacWLcV. DLUecWSURWeVWV, UaOOLeV, aQd VLW-LQV LQdLcaWe a ZLOOLQJQeVV WR eQJaJe LQ PRUe PLOLWaQW IRUPV RI UeVLVWaQce,UePLQLVceQW RI WKe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ cRXQWULeV OLNe CKLOe aQd IWaO\, ZKeUe VLPLOaU cRQdLWLRQV RIORZ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ SUeYaLO.33 TKe ePbedded WUadLWLRQ RI acWLYLVP LQ WKe VWXdeQW cXOWXUeVLJQLILcaQWO\ VKaSeV WKe MSaRD'VV aSSURacK, ZKLcK LV OLNeO\ a UeVSRQVe WR WKe KLVWRULcaOWUadLWLRQV RI SROLWLcaO acWLYLVP ZLWKLQ WKe PaNLVWaQL cRQWe[W.33TKe adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe RI MSaRD LV JeQeUaOO\ IUaJPeQWed, ZLWK YaULRXV JURXSV RI VWXdeQWV aQdUeVLdeQW dRcWRUV RSeUaWLQJ LQdeSeQdeQWO\ acURVV dLIIeUeQW SURYLQceV.33 TKLV IUaJPeQWaWLRQ PLJKWbe dXe WR dLYeUVe ORcaO LVVXeV, YaULed LQVWLWXWLRQaO cXOWXUeV, RU VSecLILc cKaOOeQJeV Iaced b\dLVWLQcW JURXSV ZLWKLQ WKe MSaRD cRPPXQLW\, OeadLQJ WR PXOWLSOe, VRPeWLPeV dLYeUJeQW,adYRcac\ eIIRUWV aQd aJeQdaV. DeVSLWe WKLV bacNdURS RI IUaJPeQWaWLRQ aQd ORZLQVWLWXWLRQaOL]aWLRQ, WKeUe aUe cULWLcaO MXQcWXUeV ZKeUe WKe MSaRD cRPPXQLW\ cRaOeVceV LQWR a130PRUe ceQWUaOL]ed PRYePeQW.33 TKe XQLILed RSSRVLWLRQ WR WKe NLE LV a SULPe e[aPSOe. TKLV LVVXe,SeUKaSV dXe WR LWV IaU-UeacKLQJ LPSOLcaWLRQV IRU aOO PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV acURVVWKe cRXQWU\, KaV PaQaJed WR JaOYaQL]e a cRRUdLQaWed aQd cROOecWLYe UeVSRQVe. TKe NLEcRQWURYeUV\ SURYLded a UaOO\LQJ SRLQW WKaW WUaQVceQded ORcaO cRQceUQV aQd IUaJPeQWed eIIRUWV,XQLWLQJ WKe MSaRD LQ a ceQWUaOL]ed, QaWLRQaO caPSaLJQ. TKLV ceQWUaOL]aWLRQ VXJJeVWV WKaW ZKLOeWKe RYeUaOO adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe IRU MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ LV ORZO\ LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed aQd IUaJPeQWed,WKe caSacLW\ IRU cROOecWLYe acWLRQ RQ a OaUJeU VcaOe LV SUeVeQW aQd caQ be acWLYaWed ZKeQ WKecRPPXQLW\ IaceV a cRPPRQ aQd VLJQLILcaQW WKUeaW.TKe aUJXPeQW, WKeUeIRUe, LV WKaW ZKLOe WKe da\-WR-da\ adYRcac\ RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ Pa\ VeePdLVSeUVed aQd RSeUaWeV RXWVLde WKe IRUPaO LQIOXeQce RI edXcaWLRQaO aQd KeaOWKcaUe JRYeUQaQceVWUXcWXUeV, WKe SRWeQWLaO IRU ceQWUaOL]aWLRQ e[LVWV aQd PaQLIeVWV ZKeQ WKe VWaNeV aUe KLJK, aVeYLdeQced b\ WKeLU cRQceUWed UeVSRQVe WR WKe NLE. TKLV dLcKRWRP\ RI IUaJPeQWaWLRQ aQdRccaVLRQaO ceQWUaOL]ed acWLRQ XQdeUVcRUeV WKe IOe[LbLOLW\ aQd adaSWabLOLW\ RI WKe MSaRDcRPPXQLW\. IW VXJJeVWV WKaW WKeUe LV aQ XQdeUO\LQJ XQLW\ aQd a WeQdeQc\ RI PLOLWaQc\ WKaW caQ beKaUQeVVed WR addUeVV WKeLU aJeQdaV.5.6 SWaWe's approach Wo professional proWesW - XndersWanding Whe d\namicsTKe JRYeUQPeQW'V UeVSRQVe WR WKe adYRcac\ RI MSaRD UeJaUdLQJ WKe NLE, ZKeQ aQaO\]ed LQ WKecRQWe[W RI WKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ, RIIeUV LQVLJKW LQWR WKe cRPSOe[ d\QaPLcV RIaXWKRULW\, cRQWURO, aQd cLYLO OLbeUWLeV ZLWKLQ WKe cRXQWU\.131TKe JRYeUQPeQW'V UeVSRQVe WR WKe adYRcac\ RI MSaRD aJaLQVW WKe NLE LQ PaNLVWaQ, LOOXVWUaWeV acRPSOe[ VWUaWeJ\ RI PaQaJLQJ dLVVeQW aQd cRQWUROOLQJ SXbOLc QaUUaWLYe. TKe JRYeUQPeQW eQJaJeVZLWK MSaRD WKURXJK cRQWUROOed IRUXPV VXcK aV ZRRP VeVVLRQV RIIeULQJ LQcOXVLYeQeVV aQdUeVSRQVLYeQeVV ZKLOe NeeSLQJ dLVVeQW ZLWKLQ PaQaJeabOe bRXQdV. FXUWKeUPRUe, WKe VWaWe¶VVeOecWLYe eQJaJePeQW IRcXVeV RQ MXVWLI\LQJ WKe NLE ZLWKRXW addUeVVLQJ bURadeU LVVXeV RI SROLc\WUaQVSaUeQc\ aQd KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP IOaZV. MaQaJePeQW RI VSeecK aWWLWXdeV aQd SULQcLSOeV LV aWacWLc ZLdeO\ SUacWLced LQ cRQWePSRUaU\ cXOWXUe aQd SROLWLcV RI eYeQ cRXQWULeV WKaW decOaUeIUeedRP RI VSeecK aV a IXQdaPeQWaO ULJKW, VXcK aV WKe USA. ZLcN (2018) VWaWeV WKaW LQ WKe USA,dLVVeQW LV PaQaJed b\ bRWK SXbOLc aQd SULYaWe eQWLWLeV acURVV YaULRXV VeWWLQJV, IURP VWaWe KRXVeVaQd cROOeJe caPSXVeV WR NFL VWadLXPV.132 AdPLQLVWUaWRUV aW QXPeURXV cROOeJeV aQd XQLYeUVLWLeVKaYe WaNeQ acWLRQ aJaLQVW RIIeQVLYe aQd dLVUXSWLYe VSeecK b\ VWXdeQWV, IacXOW\, aQd YLVLWRUV. TKe\KaYe LPSOePeQWed aQd eQIRUced cRPSUeKeQVLYe cRdeV WKaW e[WeQd WKe UeJXOaWRU\ IUaPeZRUN IURPbe\RQd caPSXV bRUdeUV WR ZLWKLQ WKe caPSXV SUePLVeV.132 SLPLOaUO\, IQ IQdLa, a QeLJKbRULQJcRXQWU\, WKe IUeedRP WR YRLce dLVVeQW LV IacLQJ JURZLQJ cKaOOeQJeV, LQIOXeQced b\ WKeJRYeUQPeQW'V UeVSRQVe WR bRWK YLROeQW aQd QRQ-YLROeQW RSSRVLWLRQ. AORQJVLde RYeUW VXSSUeVVLRQ,a ZRUU\LQJ SaWWeUQ KaV ePeUJed ZKeUe LQdLYLdXaOV aQd RUJaQL]aWLRQV SUeIeU WR VeOI-ceQVRU WRaYRLd SRWeQWLaO UeSeUcXVVLRQV RI e[SUeVVLQJ dLVVeQW.133 IQ PaNLVWaQ, WKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcVIXUWKeU OLPLWV VWXdeQWV' abLOLW\ WR e[SUeVV dLVVeQW aQd eQJaJe LQ SROLWLcaO adYRcac\, PaNLQJJRYeUQPeQW-Oed dLaORJXeV a cRQWUROOed aOWeUQaWLYe WKaW PaLQWaLQV JRYeUQPeQW aXWKRULW\ aQdUeVWULcWV bURadeU SROLWLcaO e[SUeVVLRQ. TKLV SaWeUQaOLVWLc aSSURacK KaV Oed WR IeeOLQJV RIdLVeQIUaQcKLVePeQW aPRQJ VWXdeQWV LQ PaNLVWaQ LQcOXdLQJ MSaRD, VWaUWLQJ adYRcac\ aURXQdUeeQacWLQJ RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ.12.20.134 IQ 2019, SWXdeQWV¶ SROLdaULW\ MaUcK ZaVRUJaQL]ed LQ RYeU 50 cLWLeV RI PaNLVWaQ aQd adPLQLVWeUed aUeaV.135 MXOWLSOe RUJaQL]aWLRQV IURP132acURVV WKe cRXQWU\ LQcOXdLQJ YDA caPe WRJeWKeU XQdeU WKe baQQeU RI SWXdeQW AcWLRQCRPPLWWee.135 TKLV cRPPLWWee ZaV IRUPed b\ WKe UeSUeVeQWaWLYeV IURP SURJUeVVLYe VWXdeQWRUJaQL]aWLRQV acURVV PaNLVWaQ aQd LWV adPLQLVWeUed aUeaV IRU WKe ILUVW WLPe LQ ILIW\ ILYe \eaUV WRSUeVeQW aQ aJeQda RI QLQe baVLc dePaQdV.135 ReVWRUaWLRQ RI WKe VWXdeQW XQLRQV ZaV aW WKe WRS RIWKLV QLQe SRLQWV cKaUWeU RI dePaQd.135 IQ OLJKW RI WKeVe PRbLOL]aWLRQV, WKe cULWLcaO TXeVWLRQ aULVeV:WLOO WKe JRYeUQPeQW SeUceLYe WKeVe acWLRQV aV a OeJLWLPaWe dePaQd IRU cKaQJe RU cRQWLQXe WRe[eUcLVe VWULQJeQW cRQWURO RYeU SROLWLcaO acWLYLWLeV? TKLV dLOePPa XQdeUVcRUeV WKe bURadeUcKaOOeQJe RI ZKeWKeU WKe VWXdeQW-Oed adYRcac\, aV eSLWRPL]ed b\ WKe SWXdeQWV¶ SROLdaULW\ MaUcKaQd WKe IRUPaWLRQ RI WKe SWXdeQW AcWLRQ CRPPLWWee, caQ Oead WR WaQJLbOe SROLc\ UeIRUPV. TKXV,WKe eIIecWLYeQeVV RI VXcK eQJaJePeQW VWUaWeJLeV LQ JeQXLQeO\ addUeVVLQJ VWXdeQW cRQceUQV aQdeQacWLQJ V\VWePLc cKaQJe KLQJeV RQ WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V ZLOOLQJQeVV WR XQdeUWaNe VXbVWaQWLYedLaORJXe aQd LPSOePeQW PeaQLQJIXO UeIRUPV. ReIOecWLQJ RQ WKe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV RI MSaRD aQdWKe bURadeU UeaOP RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ KLJKOLJKWV WKe VLJQLILcaQW cKaOOeQJeV RIQaYLJaWLQJ SROLc\ adYRcac\, SXbOLc dLVVeQW, aQd SROLWLcaO e[SUeVVLRQ ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ'V UeVWULcWedSROLWLcaO OaQdVcaSe.TKe VWaWe'V KaUVK UeacWLRQ WR WKe SeaceIXO SURWeVWV b\ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd UeceQW JUadXaWeVaJaLQVW WKe NLE LQ PaNLVWaQ VKRZV a cRPPRQ JORbaO SUacWLce ZKeUe SROLce RIWeQ XVecURZd-cRQWURO ZeaSRQV, RU "OeVV-OeWKaO" ZeaSRQV, WR deaO ZLWK SURWeVWV.136 TKe PLVXVe RI WKeVeZeaSRQV IUeTXeQWO\ caXVeV KaUP, OeadLQJ WR LQMXULeV, dLVabLOLWLeV, aQd deaWKV.136 TKLV LV UeIOecWedLQ WKLV VWXd\ b\ WKe XVe RI WeaU JaV, baWRQ cKaUJeV, aQd cKePLcaO VSUa\LQJ WR VXSSUeVV dLVVeQW.136TKLV LPPedLaWe VXSSUeVVLRQ UeIOecWV a SUeIeUeQce IRU cRQWUROOLQJ dLVVeQW UaWKeU WKaQ eQJaJLQJZLWK WKe XQdeUO\LQJ LVVXeV. SXcK acWLRQV QRW RQO\ caXVe JUaYe SK\VLcaO KaUP bXW aOVR KaYe133SV\cKRORJLcaO LPSacWV, cUeaWLQJ aOaUPLQJ eIIecWV RQ IXWXUe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV b\ LQVWLOOLQJ IeaU RIUeSULVaO aPRQJ SRWeQWLaO dLVVeQWeUV.136.137 TKLV VLWXaWLRQ LV e[aceUbaWed b\ WKe baQ RQ VWXdeQWSROLWLcV, IXUWKeU OLPLWLQJ aYeQXeV IRU SROLWLcaO dLVcRXUVe aQd adYRcac\. TKe YLROeQW VXSSUeVVLRQ RISeaceIXO adYRcac\ cRQWUadLcWV dePRcUaWLc SULQcLSOeV RI IUee VSeecK, SeaceIXO aVVePbO\, aQd WKeSeaceIXO UeVROXWLRQ RI cRQIOLcWV.138 TKLV eQYLURQPeQW RI LQWLPLdaWLRQ cRXOd VWLIOe dLaORJXe aQdLQQRYaWLRQ LQ KeaOWKcaUe aQd XQdeUPLQe WKe WUXVW QeceVVaU\ IRU eIIecWLYe KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUP aQdSROLc\ deYeORSPeQW. IQ OLJKW RI WKLV, WKe UeVLVWaQce RI MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ UeSUeVeQWV a bURadeUVWUXJJOe IRU aXWRQRP\, ULJKWV, aQd IaLU WUeaWPeQW ZLWKLQ aQ aXWKRULWaULaQ-OeaQLQJ SROLc\IUaPeZRUN, eVSecLaOO\ LQ OLJKW RI WKe cRQVWUaLQWV LPSRVed b\ WKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV. AQLVLQ(2015) cOaLPV WKaW UeSUeVVLRQ dLUecWed aW OaUJe VRcLaO PRYePeQWV W\SLcaOO\ OeadV WR aQ LQcUeaVe LQdLVVLdeQW PRbLOL]aWLRQ, LUUeVSecWLYe RI WKe PRYePeQW'V VWUaWeJ\ aQd WUaLWV. FXUWKeUPRUe, WKeVeeIIecWV aUe aPSOLILed ZKeQ WKe PRYePeQW aLPV IRU UeJLPe cKaQJe aQd SRVeV a VLJQLILcaQWWKUeaW.139 TKLV LV UeIOecWed LQ WKe SeUVLVWeQW SUeVeQce aQd eYROXWLRQ RI WKeVe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQVaQd WKe LdeRORJ\ WKaW WKe\ JURXQd WKeLU UeVLVWaQce LQ.5.7 ReinsWaWing insWiWXWionali]ed sWXdenW poliWics in pakisWan - PreposiWion for a paWhWo empoZermenW and reform in healWhcare and edXcaWionTKe debaWe VXUURXQdLQJ WKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ, eVSecLaOO\ LQ WKe cRQWe[W RIMSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV, SURYLdeV aQ LQWeUeVWLQJ OeQV WR e[aPLQe WKe LQWeUSOa\ beWZeeQ JRYeUQaQce,SURIeVVLRQaO adYRcac\, aQd edXcaWLRQaO UeIRUP. TKLV dLVcXVVLRQ MX[WaSRVeV WKe LQLWLaO RbMecWLYeVRI WKe baQ²cXUbLQJ PLOLWaQc\ aQd eQVXULQJ edXcaWLRQaO VWabLOLW\²aJaLQVW WKe XQLQWeQdedcRQVeTXeQceV LW KaV Kad RQ VWXdeQW UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ, OeadeUVKLS deYeORSPeQW, aQd SROLc\ adYRcac\.DUaZLQJ RQ LQVLJKWV IURP WKe SUeYLRXV aUJXPeQWV aQd WKe deWaLOed e[SORUaWLRQ RI MSaRD'V134adYRcac\ UROeV, WKLV dLVcXVVLRQ deOYeV LQWR WKe LPSOLcaWLRQV RI WKe baQ IRU dePRcUaWLceQJaJePeQW, KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUP, aQd WKe PedLcaO edXcaWLRQaO OaQdVcaSe.IQLWLaOO\, WKe baQ RQ VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aLPed WR eUadLcaWe PLOLWaQW WeQdeQcLeV ZLWKLQ VWXdeQW JURXSV,a JRaO WKaW, WR VRPe e[WeQW, VeePV WR KaYe beeQ acKLeYed aV dLVcXVVed eaUOLeU. HRZeYeU, WKLVPeaVXUe KaV aOVR LQadYeUWeQWO\ VWLIOed WKe cRQVWUXcWLYe SROLWLcaO eQJaJePeQW aQd OeadeUVKLSSRWeQWLaO RI VWXdeQWV, LQcOXdLQJ WKRVe LQ cULWLcaO ILeOdV OLNe PedLcLQe. TKe ePeUJeQce aQdRSeUaWLRQaO d\QaPLcV RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV XQdeUVcRUe a VLJQLILcaQW JaS OeIW b\ WKe abVeQceRI IRUPaO VWXdeQW SROLWLcV. TKeVe eQWLWLeV KaYe XQdeUWaNeQ UROeV aNLQ WR LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed VWXdeQWSROLWLcV RbVeUYed LQ HICV VXcK aV WKe UK eQJaJLQJ LQ SROLc\ adYRcac\, QeJRWLaWLRQV, aQdKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP UeIRUPV²acWLYLWLeV ceQWUaO WR WKe eWKRV RI VWXdeQW JRYeUQaQce.IQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed VWXdeQW SROLWLcV UeIeUV WR IRUPaOO\ VWUXcWXUed aQd UecRJQL]ed VWXdeQW eQJaJePeQWLQ JRYeUQaQce aQd SROLc\-PaNLQJ.140OQ WRS, WKe JURZLQJ WUeQd RI SROLWLcaO aZaUeQeVV aQd acWLYe eQJaJePeQW aPRQJ MSaRD KaV QRWRQO\ SRVLWLRQed WKeP aV Ne\ VWaNeKROdeUV LQ KeaOWKcaUe UeIRUP. TKe OacN RI IRUPaO UecRJQLWLRQIRU LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed VWXdeQW UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ, aV e[ePSOLILed b\ MSaRD, ULVNV PaUJLQaOL]LQJ WKeVecUXcLaO YRLceV. TKLV PaUJLQaOL]aWLRQ QRW RQO\ LPSedeV PeaQLQJIXO UeIRUPV ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ'VKeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP bXW aOVR UeVWULcWV WKe SURIeVVLRQaO deYeORSPeQW aQd cLYLc eQJaJePeQW RI IXWXUeKeaOWKcaUe OeadeUV, bUeedLQJ UeVeQWPeQW. TKe cKaOOeQJeV aUWLcXOaWed b\ MSaRD²UaQJLQJ IURPZRUNLQJ cRQdLWLRQV WR SROLc\ LQIOXeQce²PLUURU WKe V\VWePLc LVVXeV QeceVVLWaWLQJ UeIRUP. TKecRPSaULVRQ ZLWK cRXQWULeV VXcK aV WKe UK ZKeUe LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]ed VWXdeQW SROLWLcV SOa\ aVLJQLILcaQW UROe LQ JRYeUQaQce, adYRcac\, aQd edXcaWLRQaO accRXQWabLOLW\ LOOXPLQaWeV a SRWeQWLaO135SaWKZa\ IRU PaNLVWaQ: a UeJXOaWed IUaPeZRUN WKaW OeJLWLPL]eV VWXdeQW SROLWLcV ZLWKLQ QRQ-PLOLWaQW,cRQVWUXcWLYe SaUaPeWeUV, eQVXULQJ a SURacWLYe, eQJaJed VWXdeQW bRd\ caSabOe RI cRQWULbXWLQJ WRV\VWePLc LPSURYePeQWV.140I aUJXe WKaW adYRcaWLQJ IRU WKe UeJXOaWed UeLQVWaWePeQW RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ LQYROYeVacNQRZOedJLQJ WKe PXOWLIaceWed beQeILWV RI VXcK eQJaJePeQW. TKLV aSSURacK ZRXOd QRW RQO\eOLPLQaWe PLOLWaQW eOePeQWV bXW aOVR ePSRZeU VWXdeQWV ZLWK OeJLWLPaWe adYRcac\ cKaQQeOV.IPSOePeQWLQJ a UeJXOaWRU\ IUaPeZRUN WKaW aOORZV IRU WKe IRUPaO RSeUaWLRQ RI VWXdeQWRUJaQL]aWLRQV, LQcOXdLQJ MSaRD, cRXOd IRVWeU RSeQ dLaORJXe ZLWK aXWKRULWLeV, eQULcK SROLc\debaWeV, aQd eQcRXUaJe QRQ-dLVUXSWLYe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV. MRUeRYeU, WKLV PRdeO SURPRWeV WKeLQWeJUaWLRQ RI SURIeVVLRQaO eWKLcV, OeadeUVKLS VNLOOV, aQd cLYLc UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ LQWR WKe SURIeVVLRQaOLdeQWLW\ RI KeaOWKcaUe SUacWLWLRQeUV, aOLJQLQJ PaNLVWaQ PRUe cORVeO\ ZLWK beWWeU JRYeUQaQcePRdeOV. TKLV VWUaWeJ\ acNQRZOedJeV WKe LQdLVSeQVabOe UROe RI MSaRD aQd VLPLOaU JURXSV LQcKaPSLRQLQJ KeaOWKcaUe LPSURYePeQWV aQd edXcaWLRQaO UeIRUPV. B\ IacLOLWaWLQJ a PRUedePRcUaWLc, UeVSRQVLYe JRYeUQaQce VWUXcWXUe, WKLV aSSURacK SURPLVeV a KeaOWKLeU, PRUe LQcOXVLYeedXcaWLRQaO ecRV\VWeP WKaW YaOXeV VWXdeQW cRQWULbXWLRQV WR SROLc\ dLVcRXUVe aQd VRcLeWaO ZeOIaUe.5.8 SWrengWhs and limiWaWionsWKLOe RXU VWXd\ RIIeUV YaOXabOe LQVLJKWV LQWR WKe adYRcac\ d\QaPLcV RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQPaNLVWaQ, LW LV eVVeQWLaO WR acNQRZOedJe ceUWaLQ PeWKRdRORJLcaO cRQVWUaLQWV WKaW Pa\ LQIOXeQce WKeLQWeUSUeWaWLRQ RI RXU ILQdLQJV. TKLV VWXd\'V PeWKRdRORJ\ SULPaULO\ XWLOL]ed VRcLaO PedLa aQaO\VLVWR XQdeUVWaQd WKe acWLYLWLeV aQd LPSacW RI WKe MSaRD. HRZeYeU, LW dLd QRW LQcRUSRUaWe dLUecWLQWeUYLeZV ZLWK MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV PePbeUV, SULPaULO\ dXe WR WKeLU UeOXcWaQce WR eQJaJe LQ136LQWeUYLeZV. TKLV RPLVVLRQ PeaQV Ze PLJKW KaYe PLVVed JaLQLQJ deeSeU LQVLJKWV LQWR WKeLUPRWLYaWLRQV, SeUVRQaO e[SeULeQceV aQd LQWeUQaO YLeZSRLQWV, ZKLcK aUe cULWLcaO IRU a PRUe QXaQcedXQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe. TKe dLUecW dLaORJXe PLJKW KaYe UeYeaOed WKe LQWeUQaOd\QaPLcV aQd decLVLRQ-PaNLQJ SURceVVeV ZLWKLQ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV PRUe cOeaUO\, RIIeULQJ aULcKeU, PRUe cRPSUeKeQVLYe XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKeLU adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV aQd LPSacWV.AddLWLRQaOO\, WKe UeOLaQce RQ VRcLaO PedLa daWa aV WKe SULPaU\ VRXUce SUeVeQWV a OLPLWaWLRQ, aV LWPa\ QRW IXOO\ caSWXUe WKe bUeadWK RI acWLYLWLeV aQd VeQWLPeQWV ZLWKLQ WKe MSaRD cRPPXQLW\.TKLV aSSURacK WeQdV WR KLJKOLJKW WKe PRUe YRcaO aQd YLVLbOe aVSecWV RI adYRcac\, SRWeQWLaOO\RYeUORRNLQJ WKe VXbWOeU, beKLQd-WKe-VceQeV eIIRUWV WKaW aUe eTXaOO\ LPSRUWaQW.AQRWKeU OLPLWaWLRQ LV WKe WePSRUaO IRcXV RI WKLV VWXd\, ZKLcK LV SULPaULO\ ceQWeUed RQ a VSecLILcSeULRd, OLPLWLQJ WKe VcRSe RI WUacNLQJ WKe ORQJ-WeUP RXWcRPeV RI MSaRD'VV adYRcac\ eIIRUWV.TKLV WLPeIUaPe cRQVWUaLQW PeaQV Ze cRXOd QRW IXOO\ IROORZ WKURXJK RQ WKe eIIecWLYeQeVV aQdOaVWLQJ LPSacW RI WKeLU adYRcac\ acWLRQV, ZKLcK LQWURdXceV a bLaV LQ aVVeVVLQJ WKe VXVWaLQabLOLW\aQd VXcceVV RI WKeLU LQLWLaWLYeV. CRQVeTXeQWO\, ZKLOe WKe VWXd\ SURYLdeV a VQaSVKRW RI MSaRD'VVacWLYLWLeV aQd WKeLU LPPedLaWe eIIecWV, LW Pa\ QRW caSWXUe WKe eYROXWLRQ RI WKeVe eIIRUWV RU WKeLUORQJ-WeUP LQIOXeQce RQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ aQd SUacWLce. AOVR, ZKLOe WKe VWXd\'V IRcXV RQ PaNLVWaQ,SaUWLcXOaUO\ aJaLQVW WKe bacNdURS RI WKe VWXdeQW SROLWLcV baQ, SURYLdeV aQ LQ-deSWK e[aPLQaWLRQ, LWdReV QRW SUecOXde WKe JeQeUaOL]abLOLW\ RI LWV cRQcOXVLRQV. TKe LQVLJKWV JaLQed caQ be aQaO\WLcaOO\JeQeUaOL]ed, aOORZLQJ RWKeUV WR LQWeUSUeW WKeP WKURXJK WKe OeQV RI WKeLU RZQ cRQWe[WV aQdKeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV ZLWK dLIIeULQJ VRcLR-SROLWLcaO d\QaPLcV.137IQ WeUPV RI VeOecWLRQ bLaV, ZKLOe RXU VWXd\ cRPSUeKeQVLYeO\ VeOecWed aOO UeOeYaQW SRVWV dXULQJ WKeVWXd\ SeULRd IURP WKe MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQcOXded LQ WKe UeVeaUcK, Ze Iaced OLPLWaWLRQV ZLWKRUJaQL]aWLRQV WKaW ZeUe QRW acWLYe RQ VRcLaO PedLa. TKeVe OeVV acWLYe RU VLOeQW eQWLWLeV Kad WR bee[cOXded IURP WKe aQaO\VLV, ZKLcK Pa\ LPSacW WKe UeSUeVeQWaWLYeQeVV RI RXU ILQdLQJV. TKLVe[cOXVLRQ cRXOd SRWeQWLaOO\ RYeUORRN WKe cRQWULbXWLRQV aQd SeUVSecWLYeV RI WKeVe JURXSV, OeadLQJWR aQ LQcRPSOeWe SLcWXUe RI WKe MSaRD'V adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe.WKLOe WKe VWXd\ KaV ceUWaLQ OLPLWaWLRQV, WKe\ aUe cRXQWeUbaOaQced b\ LWV cRQVLdeUabOe VWUeQJWKV.TKe VWXd\'V SULPaU\ VWUeQJWK LV LWV cRPSUeKeQVLYe e[SORUaWLRQ RI MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV WKURXJKVRcLaO PedLa SRVWV, ZKLcK LV eQULcKed b\ WKe LQcOXVLRQ RI SROLc\ dRcXPeQWV, LQWeUYLeZV, QeZVSLeceV, aQd SKRWRV.141 TKLV e[WeQVLYe daWaVeW eQabOeV a WULaQJXOaWed aSSURacK, RIIeULQJ a bURadaQd deWaLOed YLeZ RI WKe adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe. SXcK aQ LQcOXVLYe daWa cROOecWLRQ VWUaWeJ\ caSWXUeVa ZLde VSecWUXP RI cRPPXQLcaWLRQV aQd acWLYLWLeV, SUeVeQWLQJ a ULcK SLcWXUe RI MSaRD'VVeQJaJePeQW aQd SXbOLc dLVcRXUVe LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU. FXUWKeU VWUeQJWKeQLQJ WKe VWXd\ LV WKeaSSOLcaWLRQ RI IUaPLQJ aQaO\VLV, ZKLcK SURYLdeV deeSeU LQVLJKWV LQWR KRZ MSaRD SeUceLYe WKeLUUROeV, WKeLU adYRcac\ eIIRUWV, aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW'V UeVSRQVe.142 TKe URbXVWQeVV RI WKe VWXd\ LVVLJQLILcaQWO\ eQKaQced b\ LWV PL[ed-PeWKRdV deVLJQ, ZKLcK LQWeJUaWeV TXaOLWaWLYe aQaO\VLV ZLWKQaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ (NLP). TKLV aSSURacK IacLOLWaWeV a deWaLOed e[SORUaWLRQ RI cRPSOe[WKePeV aQd WUeQdV, ZLWK NLP VeUYLQJ aV a SRZeUIXO WRRO WR YaOLdaWe aQd eQULcK WKe TXaOLWaWLYeILQdLQJV. B\ V\VWePaWLcaOO\ aQaO\]LQJ OaUJe YROXPeV RI We[W daWa, NLP LdeQWLILeV XQdeUO\LQJSaWWeUQV RIIeULQJ a PRUe RbMecWLYe aQd cRPSUeKeQVLYe XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe adYRcac\ eIIRUWV aQdWKeLU UeVRQaQce LQ WKe SXbOLc VSKeUe. MRUeRYeU, WKe VWXd\'V deSWK RI cRQWe[WXaO aQd KLVWRULcaOaQaO\VLV Oa\V a VROLd IRXQdaWLRQ IRU LQWeUSUeWLQJ WKe cXUUeQW d\QaPLcV aQd SURMecWLQJ IXWXUe WUeQdV138LQ MSaRD'VV adYRcac\ eIIRUWV. OYeUaOO, WKe VWXd\ dLVWLQJXLVKeV LWVeOI WKURXJK LWV PeWKRdRORJLcaOULJRU, e[WeQVLYe aQd dLYeUVe daWaVeW, aQd WKe deSWK RI LWV IUaPLQJ aQd PXOWLdLPeQVLRQaO aQaO\VLV.TKeVe eOePeQWV cROOecWLYeO\ eQVXUe a WKRURXJK aQd LQVLJKWIXO e[SORUaWLRQ RI WKe VWUaWeJLeV,SeUceSWLRQV, aQd LPSacWV RI MSaRD RQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ debaWeV aQd RXWcRPeV. TKe VWXd\'VcRPSUeKeQVLYe aSSURacK QRW RQO\ VKedV OLJKW RQ WKe cXUUeQW adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe bXW aOVRcRQWULbXWeV VLJQLILcaQWO\ WR WKe bURadeU dLVcRXUVe RQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ aQd adYRcac\, PaNLQJ acRPSeOOLQJ caVe IRU WKe LPSRUWaQce aQd UeOeYaQce RI MSaRD'V eIIRUWV LQ VKaSLQJ WKe KeaOWKSROLc\ SURceVV.5.9 Polic\ implicaWions and call Wo acWion1. I caOO XSRQ SROLc\PaNeUV WR LQVWLWXWLRQaOL]e MSaRD adYRcac\ b\ IRUPaOO\ LQWeJUaWLQJMSaRD LQWR WKe KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ IUaPeZRUN. IQVWLWXWLRQaO VXSSRUW PXVW be e[WeQded WRMSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV, JUaQWLQJ WKeP WKe UeVRXUceV aQd SOaWIRUPV QeceVVaU\ WR eQJaJeVXbVWaQWLYeO\ LQ SROLc\ deOLbeUaWLRQ aQd decLVLRQ-PaNLQJ. TKLV IRUPaO UecRJQLWLRQOeJLWLPL]eV WKeLU cRQWULbXWLRQV aQd eQKaQceV WKeLU LQIOXeQce LQ adYRcaWLQJ IRU KeaOWKcaUeUeIRUP.2. I SURSRVe WUaLQLQJ MSaRD LQ AdYRcac\ LLWeUac\ IRU a DLJLWL]ed WRUOd, ePSKaVL]LQJeWKLcaO eQJaJePeQW, UeaOLVWLc e[SecWaWLRQV, aQd WKe UeVSRQVLbOe XVe RI dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV IRUSROLc\ UeIRUP. AddLWLRQaOO\, I adYRcaWe WKaW JORbaO QeWZRUNV aPRQJ UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV aQdVWXdeQW aVVRcLaWLRQV VKRXOd be bXLOW IRU e[cKaQJe RI NQRZOedJe, beVW SUacWLceV, aQdLQQRYaWLYe adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV LQ KeaOWKcaUe. TKeVe QeWZRUNV ZLOO eQabOe WKe VKaULQJ RIdLYeUVe e[SeULeQceV aQd cROOabRUaWLYe eIIRUWV, VWUeQJWKeQLQJ WKe cROOecWLYe LPSacW RQKeaOWKcaUe SROLc\.1393. FXUWKeUPRUe, I SURSRVe a cRPSUeKeQVLYe KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeU VecXULW\ bLOO aQd SROLc\ WRSURWecW KeaOWKcaUe ZRUNeUV IURP SK\VLcaO YLROeQce. TKLV OeJLVOaWLRQ VKRXOd PaQdaWeVeYeUe cRQVeTXeQceV IRU SeUSeWUaWRUV aQd cUeaWe a URbXVW V\VWeP IRU UeSRUWLQJ aQdaddUeVVLQJ LQcLdeQWV RI YLROeQce aJaLQVW MSaRD WR SUeVeUYe WKe LQWeJULW\ aQdIXQcWLRQaOLW\ RI WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP LQ PaNLVWaQ.4. PROLcLeV PXVW addUeVV ZRUNSOace KaUaVVPeQW cRPSUeKeQVLYeO\ acURVV aOO OeYeOV. AW WKePacUR OeYeO, QaWLRQaO SROLcLeV PXVW VeW IRUWK cOeaU deILQLWLRQV aQd cRQVeTXeQceV RIKaUaVVPeQW. AW WKe PeVR OeYeO, KeaOWKcaUe LQVWLWXWLRQV PXVW adRSW aQd eQIRUce VWULQJeQWaQWL-KaUaVVPeQW SROLcLeV. AW WKe PLcUR OeYeO, LQdLYLdXaO WUaLQLQJ aQd VXSSRUW V\VWePV PXVWbe LPSOePeQWed WR eQabOe MSaRD WR LdeQWLI\, UeSRUW, aQd addUeVV KaUaVVPeQW, eQVXULQJ aVaIe aQd UeVSecWIXO ZRUNSOace IRU aOO.5. RecRJQL]LQJ WKe PeQWaO WROO RQ MSaRD, I SURSRVe WKe eVWabOLVKPeQW RI a MeQWaO HeaOWKAOORZaQce. TKLV ILQaQcLaO VXSSRUW acNQRZOedJeV WKe SV\cKRORJLcaO bXUdeQ bRUQe b\KeaOWKcaUe SURYLdeUV aQd IacLOLWaWeV acceVV WR PeQWaO KeaOWK VeUYLceV, cRQWULbXWLQJ WR WKeLURYeUaOO ZeOO-beLQJ aQd VXVWaLQLQJ WKeLU caSacLW\ WR SURYLde cRPSaVVLRQaWe caUe.6. I VWURQJO\ caOO IRU a "S\VWeP RI AccRXQWabLOLW\ aQd RaWLQJ" LQ KeaOWKcaUe ZKeUe SaWLeQWVaQd SeeUV eYaOXaWe dRcWRUV aQd adPLQLVWUaWRUV. TKeVe eYaOXaWLRQV ZRXOd be SXbOLcO\acceVVLbOe, cRQWULbXWLQJ WR a cROOecWLYe UaWLQJ IRU eacK KRVSLWaO. TKe JRaO LV WR eQcRXUaJeWUaQVSaUeQc\ aQd LPSURYePeQW LQ KeaOWKcaUe VeUYLceV, ZLWK WKe added beQeILW RIePSRZeULQJ SaWLeQWV WR PaNe LQIRUPed cKRLceV abRXW WKeLU caUe. TKe SROLc\ aOVR LQcOXdeVVXSSRUW IRU KeaOWKcaUe SURIeVVLRQaOV WR LPSURYe WKeLU VeUYLceV baVed RQ IeedbacN, aQd acRPPLWPeQW WR UeJXOaUO\ UeYLeZ WKe V\VWeP WR eQVXUe LW UePaLQV IaLU aQd eIIecWLYe.1407. TKeUe VKRXOd be deYeORSPeQW aQd dLVVePLQaWLRQ RI cRPSUeKeQVLYe JXLdeOLQeV WR eQVXUeWKe V\VWePaWLc aQd eIIecWLYe LPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI QeZ SROLcLeV. TKeVe JXLdeOLQeV VKRXOdLQcOXde PeaVXUabOe RbMecWLYeV, WLPeOLQeV IRU e[ecXWLRQ, aQd cOeaU PeWULcV IRU eYaOXaWLQJVXcceVV, WKeUeb\ JXaUaQWeeLQJ WKaW SROLc\ LQLWLaWLYeV aUe QRW RQO\ eQacWed bXW aUe aOVReIIecWLYe aQd VXVWaLQabOe.5.10 RecommendaWions for fXWXre researchSeYeUaO VXJJeVWLRQV ePeUJe IURP WKLV VWXd\'V ILQdLQJV aQd OLPLWaWLRQV:1. LRQJLWXdLQaO SWXdLeV: FXWXUe UeVeaUcK VKRXOd cRQVLdeU ORQJLWXdLQaO deVLJQV WR WUacN WKeeYROXWLRQ RI MSaRD'V adYRcac\ eIIRUWV aQd WKeLU ORQJ-WeUP LPSacW RQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\aQd RXWcRPeV. TKLV aSSURacK ZRXOd aOORZ UeVeaUcKeUV WR aVVeVV WKe VXVWaLQabLOLW\ aQdeIIecWLYeQeVV RI WKeVe adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV RYeU WLPe.2. E[SaQdLQJ IQWeUYLeZeeV: IQcOXdLQJ LQWeUYLeZV ZLWK a bURadeU UaQJe RI MSaRD PePbeUVaQd RWKeU VWaNeKROdeUV LQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP VXcK aV bXUeaXcUac\ aQd SaWLeQWV cRXOdSURYLde a PRUe cRPSUeKeQVLYe YLeZ RI WKe adYRcac\ OaQdVcaSe. TKLV ZRXOd KeOS LQXQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKe LQWeUQaO d\QaPLcV, PRWLYaWLRQV, aQd cKaOOeQJeV aQd LPSacW RI adYRcac\eIIRUWV RI MSaRD.3. CRPSaUaWLYe SWXdLeV: CRQdXcWLQJ cRPSaUaWLYe VWXdLeV beWZeeQ MSaRD LQ PaNLVWaQ aQdWKRVe LQ RWKeU cRXQWULeV cRXOd RIIeU LQVLJKWV LQWR WKe JORbaO cRQWe[W RI MSaRD'VVadYRcac\. TKLV cRXOd KeOS LdeQWLI\ XQLTXe aQd cRPPRQ cKaOOeQJeV aQd VWUaWeJLeV acURVVdLIIeUeQW KeaOWKcaUe aQd SROLWLcaO V\VWePV.4. CRPSUeKeQVLYe AQaO\VLV: FXWXUe UeVeaUcK VKRXOd cRQdXcW a cRPSUeKeQVLYe aQaO\VLV WRTXaQWLWaWLYeO\ PeaVXUe WKe LPSacW RI MSaRD'V adYRcac\ RQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ cKaQJeV,141SaWLeQW RXWcRPeV, aQd eWKLcaO LPSOLcaWLRQV. TKLV cRXOd aLd LQ aVVeVVLQJ WKe eIIecWLYeQeVVRI WKeLU adYRcac\ eIIRUWV aQd VWUeQJWKeQ WKe caVe IRU WKeLU IRUPaO LQcOXVLRQ LQSROLc\-PaNLQJ SURceVVeV.5. DLJLWaO AdYRcac\ E[SORUaWLRQ: GLYeQ WKe LPSRUWaQce RI dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV LQ MSaRD'VadYRcac\, IXUWKeU UeVeaUcK cRXOd e[SORUe WKe VSecLILcV RI dLJLWaO adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV,LQcOXdLQJ WKeLU UeacK, eQJaJePeQW, aQd LQIOXeQce RQ SXbOLc aQd SROLc\-PaNeU RSLQLRQV.6. IQ-deSWK PROLc\ AQaO\VLV: AQaO\]LQJ WKe VSecLILc SROLcLeV LQIOXeQced RU VKaSed b\MSaRD'V adYRcac\ eIIRUWV cRXOd SURYLde a cOeaUeU SLcWXUe RI WKeLU UROe LQ KeaOWK caUeUeIRUP. TKLV cRXOd LQcOXde caVe VWXdLeV RI VXcceVVIXO adYRcac\ caPSaLJQV aQd WKeLUcRQWULbXWLRQV WR SROLc\ cKaQJeV.7. EWKLcaO aQd SRcLR-SROLWLcaO CRQVLdeUaWLRQV: ReVeaUcK LQWR WKe eWKLcaO aQd VRcLRSROLWLcaOdLPeQVLRQV RI MSaRD'V adYRcac\ cRXOd RIIeU deeSeU LQVLJKWV LQWR WKe cRPSOe[LWLeV RIadYRcaWLQJ ZLWKLQ UeVWULcWed RU cKaOOeQJLQJ eQYLURQPeQWV, OLNe WKRVe ZLWK baQV RQ VWXdeQWSROLWLcV.B\ addUeVVLQJ WKeVe aUeaV, IXWXUe UeVeaUcK caQ bXLOd XSRQ WKe ILQdLQJV RI WKLV VWXd\ WR IXUWKeUeQKaQce RXU XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI WKe UROe aQd LPSacW RI MSaRD LQ KeaOWKcaUe SROLc\ aQd adYRcac\,bRWK ZLWKLQ PaNLVWaQ aQd LQ WKe bURadeU JORbaO cRQWe[W.5.11 ConclXsionTKe VWXd\ KaV UeYeaOed a VLJQLILcaQW eYROXWLRQ LQ WKe OaQdVcaSe RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ,SaUWLcXOaUO\ cRQceUQLQJ MSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV. FURP WKe KLVWRULcaO URRWV RI PLOLWaQW SUeVeQce bXWZLWK LQWeUQaO dePRcUaWLc eQJaJePeQW WR WKe cKaOOeQJeV SRVed b\ baQV, MSaRD KaYe adaSWed142VWUaWeJLcaOO\, VKLIWLQJ WKeLU IRcXV WRZaUdV KeaOWKcaUe adYRcac\ aQd SROLc\ eQJaJePeQW. TKLVadaSWaWLRQ UeIOecWV QRW RQO\ UeVLOLeQce bXW aOVR a NeeQ aZaUeQeVV RI QaYLJaWLQJ VRcLR-SROLWLcaOcRQVWUaLQWV WR cRQWLQXe e[LVWLQJ aQd adYRcaWLQJ ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP. TKe e[aPLQaWLRQ RIMSaRD RUJaQL]aWLRQV' cXUUeQW IXQcWLRQLQJ KLJKOLJKWV WKeLU cXUUeQW QRQ-SaUWLVaQ acWLYLVP ZKLOeeIIecWLYeO\ XWLOL]LQJ dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV IRU cRPPXQLcaWLRQ aQd adYRcac\. TKe VWXd\ XQdeUVcRUeVWKe SLYRWaO UROe RI dLJLWaO SOaWIRUPV LQ aPSOLI\LQJ WKeLU YRLceV, PRbLOL]LQJ VXSSRUW, aQd eQJaJLQJLQ SXbOLc dLVcRXUVe, VKRZcaVLQJ a VRSKLVWLcaWed aSSURacK WR adYRcac\ WKaW aOLJQV ZLWK JORbaOWUeQdV LQ dLJLWaO acWLYLVP. TKe LQYeVWLJaWLRQ LQWR MSaRD'V SaUWLcLSaWLRQ LQ KeaOWK SROLc\-PaNLQJUeYeaO WKaW deVSLWe IacLQJ VWUXcWXUaO baUULeUV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe V\VWeP , MSaRD dePRQVWUaWeVLJQLILcaQW aJeQc\ LQ adYRcaWLQJ IRU LPSURYePeQWV LQ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ, KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV, aQdSXbOLc KeaOWK RXWcRPeV. TKeLU adYRcac\ eIIRUWV aQd WKe deVLUe WR VKaSe KeaOWK SROLc\ debaWeV aQdRXWcRPeV, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKeLU cUXcLaO UROe aV cKaQJe aJeQWV ZLWKLQ WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU. TKee[WeQVLRQ RI LQVLJKWV WR a bURadeU JORbaO IUaPeZRUN ePSKaVL]eV WKe XQLYeUVaO UeOeYaQce RIMSaRD'V acWLYLVP aQd adYRcac\ eIIRUWV. TKe VWXd\'V ILQdLQJV SURYLde YaOXabOe OeVVRQV IRU KeaOWKZRUNeU UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ LMICV, KLJKOLJKWLQJ WKe LPSRUWaQce RI VWUaWeJLcadaSWaWLRQ, dLJLWaO eQJaJePeQW, aQd SURacWLYe SROLc\ adYRcac\ LQ LQIOXeQcLQJ KeaOWK SROLc\SURceVVeV aQd dULYLQJ SRVLWLYe cKaQJe RQ a ZLdeU VcaOe. IQ cRQcOXVLRQ, WKe VWXd\'V cRPSUeKeQVLYee[aPLQaWLRQ RI MSaRD'V acWLYLVP aQd adYRcac\ XQdeUVcRUeV WKeLU LQdLVSeQVabOe UROe LQ VKaSLQJKeaOWKcaUe SROLc\, adYRcaWLQJ IRU UeIRUPV aLPed aW PeaQLQJIXO cRQWULbXWLRQV LQ KeaOWKcaUeV\VWePV. B\ addUeVVLQJ WKe RbMecWLYeV aQd UeVeaUcK TXeVWLRQV, WKLV VWXd\ cRQWULbXWeV YaOXabOeLQVLJKWV WR WKe dLVcRXUVe RQ KeaOWK ZRUNeU UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV, dLJLWaO acWLYLVP, aQdSROLc\ adYRcac\ ZLWKLQ KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV, bRWK LQ PaNLVWaQ aQd JORbaOO\.143IQ cORVLQJ, WKLV WKeVLV KaV VSRWOLJKWed WKe cUXcLaO LQIOXeQce RI MSaRD LQ dULYLQJ KeaOWKcaUeSROLc\ cKaQJeV LQ PaNLVWaQ. TKLV VWXd\ ePSKaVL]eV WKe LPSRUWaQce RI IXOO\ LQYROYLQJ MSaRD LQVKaSLQJ KeaOWKcaUe SROLcLeV, VXJJeVWLQJ a VKLIW WRZaUdV a PRUe LQcOXVLYe aQd d\QaPLc aSSURacK LQWKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU. MRYLQJ IRUZaUd, WKe LQVLJKWV IURP WKLV UeVeaUcK VKRXOd JXLde WKe Za\ WRVXbVWaQWLaO KeaOWKcaUe LPSURYePeQWV aQd WKe ePSRZeUPeQW RI PedLcaO SURIeVVLRQaOV aV Ne\SOa\eUV LQ UeIRUP. TKe eYROXWLRQ RI MSaRD LQWR SURPLQeQW adYRcaWeV LQ KeaOWKcaUe PLUURUV abURadeU VKLIW WRZaUdV JUeaWeU IaLUQeVV, e[SeUWLVe, aQd VXVWaLQabLOLW\ LQ JORbaO KeaOWKcaUe V\VWePV,SaYLQJ WKe Za\ IRU a KeaOWKLeU aQd PRUe eTXLWabOe IXWXUe.144Bibliograph\1. HaVaQ M, IPUaQ S, WaVLI SA. FUXVWUaWLRQ-AJJUeVVLRQ LeadLQJ WR HeaOWK CULVLV: CaVe RI PaNLVWaQLYRXQJ DRcWRUV¶ MRYePeQW. PaNLVWaQ SRc ScL ReY. 2020 MaU 31;4(1):493-506.2. CRQWULbXWRU WE. WebMD. [cLWed 2024 MaU 31]. WKaW IV a ReVLdeQW DRcWRU? AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.ZebPd.cRP/a-WR-]-JXLdeV/ZKaW-LV-UeVLdeQW-dRcWRU3. SULUaP V, BURSK\ SA, SKaUPa K, EOLaV MA, MLVKUa A. AVVRcLaWLRQV, XQLRQV aQd eYeU\WKLQJ LQbeWZeeQ: cRQWe[WXaOL]LQJ WKe UROe RI UeSUeVeQWaWLYe KeaOWK ZRUNeU RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ SROLc\. BMJGORbaO HeaOWK. 2023 SeS 1;8(9):e012661.4. NLVKWaU S. TKe PL[ed KeaOWK V\VWePV V\QdURPe. BXOO WRUOd HeaOWK OUJaQ. 2010 JaQ;88(1):74±5.5. MXKaPPad Q, ELPaQ H, Fa]aO F, IbUaKLP M, GRQdaO MF. HeaOWKcaUe LQ PaNLVWaQ: NaYLJaWLQJCKaOOeQJeV aQd BXLOdLQJ a BULJKWeU FXWXUe. CXUeXV. 15(6):e40218.6. SXbOLVKeU E. WRUOd HeaOWK OUJaQL]aWLRQ - ReJLRQaO OIILce IRU WKe EaVWeUQ MedLWeUUaQeaQ. [cLWed2024 Feb 8]. HeaOWK SROLc\, JRYeUQaQce aQd OeadeUVKLS. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWS://ZZZ.ePUR.ZKR.LQW/SaN/SURJUaPPeV/KeaOWK-SROLc\-JRYeUQaQce-aQd-OeadeUVKLS.KWPO7. ZaLdL SA, BLJdeOL M, LaQJORLV EV, RLa] A, OUU DW, IdUeeV N, eW aO. HeaOWK V\VWePV cKaQJeV aIWeUdeceQWUaOL]aWLRQ: SURJUeVV, cKaOOeQJeV aQd d\QaPLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ. BMJ GORb HeaOWK. 2019 JaQ30;4(1):e001013.8. IQWeUQaWLRQaO HLJKeU ScKRRO RI MedLcLQe (IHSM) [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://LVP.edX.NJ/eQ/UeVRXUce-deWaLO/100/9. RaSLd cKaQJeV aUe deOeWeULRXV IRU KeaOWK SURIeVVLRQ _ PaNLVWaQ JRXUQaO RI PK\VLRORJ\ [IQWeUQeW].[cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://SMS.SSV.RUJ.SN/LQde[.SKS/PJP/aUWLcOe/YLeZ/132510. PMC YLUWXaOO\ ceaVeV WR e[LVW [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WULbXQe.cRP.SN/VWRU\/2372793/SPc-YLUWXaOO\-ceaVeV-WR-e[LV14511. PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CRXQcLO AcW, 2022 [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://SaNLVWaQcRde.JRY.SN/eQJOLVK/UY2FTaJZ1-aSaUY2FTa-aSaUY2NSa5ONaQ%3D%3D-VJ-MMMMMMMMMMMMM12. JaYLd H. PaWURQaJe, PRSXOLVP, aQd PURWeVW: SWXdeQW PROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQL PXQMab. SRXWK AVLaMXOWLdLVcLSOLQaU\ AcadePLc JRXUQaO [IQWeUQeW]. 2019 Dec 15 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8];(22). AYaLOabOeIURP: KWWSV://MRXUQaOV.RSeQedLWLRQ.RUJ/VaPaM/649713. KKaQ HU, ZaPaQ S. PURVSecWV aQd IPSOLcaWLRQV RI SWXdeQWV PROLWLcV LQ EdXcaWLRQaO IQVWLWXWLRQV RIPaNLVWaQ. LLbeUaO AUWV aQd SRcLaO ScLeQceV IQWeUQaWLRQaO JRXUQaO (LASSIJ). 2020 NRY19;4(1):161±70.14. PaUacKa N. SWXdeQW PROLWLcV IQ PaNLVWaQ: FURP ReYROXWLRQ TR ReVWULcWLRQ - AQd A PRVVLbOeReYLYaO [IQWeUQeW]. TKe FULda\ TLPeV. 2022. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WKeIULda\WLPeV.cRP/16-Feb-2022/VWXdeQW-SROLWLcV-LQ-SaNLVWaQ-IURP-UeYROXWLRQ-WR-UeVWULcWLRQ-aQd-a-SRVVLbOe-UeYLYaO15. MaQQaQ, A. SWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ. E[ecXWLYe MBA ReVeaUcK PURMecWV [IQWeUQeW]. 2017 JaQ 1[cLWed 2024 Feb 7]; AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://LU.Lba.edX.SN/UeVeaUcK-SURMecWV-ePba/127/16. TKe E[SUeVV TULbXQe [IQWeUQeW]. 2022 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. BaQ RQ VWXdeQW XQLRQV caXVeV "SROLWLcaOdURXJKW" LQ PaNLVWaQ. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WULbXQe.cRP.SN/VWRU\/2342582/baQ-RQ-VWXdeQW-XQLRQV-caXVeV-SROLWLcaO-dURXJKW-LQ-SaNLVWaQ17. LeYLQe A, WLOVRQ KR. SWXdeQW acWLYLVP LQ WKe 1970V: TUaQVIRUPaWLRQ QRW decOLQe. HLJKeUEdXcaWLRQ. 1979 NRY;8(6):627-40.18. BaUNeU C. SRPe UeIOecWLRQV RQ VWXdeQW PRYePeQWV RI WKe 1960V aQd eaUO\ 1970V. ReYLVWa CUtWLcade CLrQcLaV SRcLaLV. 2008 JXQ 1(81):43-91.19. SWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ PaNLVWaQ: A ceOebUaWLRQ, OaPeQW & KLVWRU\ - DAWN.COM [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://ZZZ.daZQ.cRP/QeZV/111678214620. AKPed Z. PaUadLJP SKLIW. 2022 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. SWXdeQW UQLRQV LQ PaNLVWaQ. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.SaUadLJPVKLIW.cRP.SN/VWXdeQW-XQLRQV-SaNLVWaQ/21. QaUQL A. OUJaQLVLQJ, ReVLVWLQJ, BXLOdLQJ SROLdaULW\: TKe BUeZLQJ SWXdeQW MRYePeQW IQ PaNLVWaQ[IQWeUQeW]. SWXdeQW SWUXJJOe. 2020 [cLWed 2024 Feb 7]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://VWXdeQWVWUXJJOe.LQ/VWXdeQW-XQLRQ-UeVWRUaWLRQ-PRYePeQW-SaNLVWaQ-aZaLV-TaUQL/22. Oeed [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 21]. SRcLaO MedLa aQd OQOLQe AdYRcac\, a DRXbOe-EdJed SZRUd?AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.Oeed-LQLWLaWLYe.RUJ/bORJ/VRcLaO-PedLa-aQd-RQOLQe-adYRcac\-dRXbOe-edJed-VZRUd23. LaQe J. AVVRcLaWLRQ AdYLVeU. 2019 [cLWed 2024 MaU 21]. SRcLaO MedLa HaV CKaQJed WKe AdYRcac\LaQdVcaSe FRUeYeU. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.Qa\ORU.cRP/aVVRcLaWLRQadYLVeU/VRcLaO-PedLa-KaV-cKaQJed-WKe-adYRcac\-OaQdVcaSe-IRUeYeU/24. TKe PRZeU RI DLJLWaO AdYRcac\ (SSIR) [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 21]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://VVLU.RUJ/bRRNV/e[ceUSWV/eQWU\/WKe_SRZeU_RI_dLJLWaO_adYRcac\25. RaKLP, F. (2021). NATIONAL LICENSING EXAMINATION: ARE WE READY FOR IT?.KJMS, 14(3), 136.26. MM NeZV [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://PPQeZV.WY/ZKaW-LV-QOe-aQd-ZK\-aUe-dRcWRUV-SURWeVWLQJ-aJaLQVW-LW/27. AQaO\]LQJ NLE LQ PaNLVWaQ cRQWe[W - TKe FLQaQcLaO DaLO\ [IQWeUQeW]. 2021 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8].AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://WKeILQaQcLaOdaLO\.cRP/aQaO\VLQJ-QOe-LQ-SaNLVWaQ-cRQWe[W/28. JXQaLdL I. DAWN.COM. 06:41:39+05:00 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. PMDC abROLVKeV µe[LW e[aP¶ IRUPedLcaO JUadXaWeV RI ORcaO cROOeJeV. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://ZZZ.daZQ.cRP/QeZV/173665014729. KOePeQþLþ M. SWXdeQW PROLWLcV. IQ: EQc\cORSedLa RI IQWeUQaWLRQaO HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ S\VWePV aQdIQVWLWXWLRQV [IQWeUQeW]. DRUdUecKW: SSULQJeU NeWKeUOaQdV; 2020 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. S. 1±6.AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://dRL.RUJ/10.1007/978-94-017-9553-1_618-130. KOePeQþLþ M, YXQ PaUN B. SWXdeQW SROLWLcV: beWZeeQ UeSUeVeQWaWLRQ aQd acWLYLVP. IQ: CaQWZeOO B,CRaWeV H, KLQJ R, edLWRUV. HaQdbRRN RQ WKe PROLWLcV RI HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ [IQWeUQeW]. EdZaUdEOJaU PXbOLVKLQJ; 2018 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://cKLQa.eOJaURQOLQe.cRP/YLeZ/edcROO/9781786435019/9781786435019.00037.[PO31. PaUeNK B. PROLWLcaO TKeRU\ RI WKe SWXdeQW MRYePeQW: A HLVWRULcaO aQd PKLORVRSKLcaO AQaO\VLV.CURVVCXUUeQWV. 1971;21(1):53±86.32. AOWbacK PG. SWXdeQWV aQd PROLWLcV. CRPSaUaWLYe EdXcaWLRQ ReYLeZ. 1966;10(2):175±87.33. deOOa PRUWa D, CLQL L, GX]PiQ-CRQcKa C. SWXdeQW PROLWLcV. IQCRQWeVWLQJ HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ 2020JXQ 3 (SS. 97-128). BULVWRO UQLYeUVLW\ PUeVV.34. RRdULJXe]-APaW J, JeIIeU\ R. SWXdeQW SURWeVWV. TKUee SeULRdV RI XQLYeUVLW\ JRYeUQaQce. TULSOeC.CRPPXQLcaWLRQ, CaSLWaOLVP aQd CULWLTXe. 2017 Ma\ 29;15(2):526-42.35. EVVe[ R, BURSK\ SA, SULUaP V. SWULNeV, SaWLeQW RXWcRPeV, aQd WKe cRVW RI IaLOLQJ WR acW. bPM. 2023MaU 10;380.36. 8 RUJaQLVaWLRQV \RX¶OO eQcRXQWeU aV a dRcWRU LQ WKe UK ± TKe SaYY\ IMG [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024MaU 21]. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://WKeVaYY\LPJ.cR.XN/RUJaQLVaWLRQV-LQ-WKe-XN/37. X (IRUPeUO\ TZLWWeU) [IQWeUQeW]. 2024 [cLWed 2024 MaU 21]. DRcWRUVVRWe #TeOOTKePAJaLQ(@DRcWRUV_VRWe) / X. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://WZLWWeU.cRP/DRcWRUV_VRWe38. BULVWRZ P. TKe PLOLWaQW BMA LV dRLQJ dRcWRUV QR IaYRXUV. TKe TeOeJUaSK [IQWeUQeW]. 2023 AXJ 14[cLWed 2024 MaU 21]; AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.WeOeJUaSK.cR.XN/QeZV/2023/08/14/dRcWRUV-VKRXOd-TXLW-WKe-bPa-beIRUe-LWV-WRR-OaWe/14839. PKLOOLSV M. DRcWRUV PXVW ILJKW WKLV PLOLWaQW WaNeRYeU. 2024 MaU 21 [cLWed 2024 MaU 21]; AYaLOabOeIURP: KWWSV://ZZZ.WKeWLPeV.cR.XN/aUWLcOe/dRcWRUV-PXVW-ILJKW-WKLV-PLOLWaQW-WaNeRYeU-Z36Z[[80M40. SabeU IF. AO Ja]eeUa. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. NHS VWULNeV: WKaW aLOV UK KeaOWK VeUYLce? DRcWRUV¶SURWeVWV RU bXdJeW cXWV? AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.aOMa]eeUa.cRP/QeZV/2023/10/2/QKV-VWULNeV-ZKaW-aLOV-XN-KeaOWK-VeUYLce-dRcWRUV-SURWeVWV-RU-bXdJeW-cXWV41. McKee M, BOacN N. HRXUV RI WRUN RI JXQLRU HRVSLWaO DRcWRUV: IV TKeUe a SROXWLRQ? JRXUQaO RIMaQaJePeQW LQ MedLcLQe. 1991 JaQ 1;5(3):40±54.42. DRcWRUV cRQVLdeU ZKeWKeU WR bacN LQdXVWULaO acWLRQ RYeU SeQVLRQ cKaQJeV _ TKe BMJ [IQWeUQeW].[cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://ZZZ.bPM.cRP/cRQWeQW/342/bPM.d389643. JXQLRU dRcWRUV aJUee QeZ cRQWUacW WR eQd IRXU-\eaU dLVSXWe _ DRcWRUV _ TKe GXaUdLaQ [IQWeUQeW].[cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.WKeJXaUdLaQ.cRP/VRcLeW\/2019/MXQ/26/MXQLRU-dRcWRUV-aJUee-WR-82-Sa\-ULVe-eQdLQJ-IRXU-\eaU-dLVSXWe44. SaYe RXU NHS UaOO\: WKRXVaQdV PaUcK LQ KeaOWK bLOO SURWeVW _ NHS _ TKe GXaUdLaQ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.WKeJXaUdLaQ.cRP/VRcLeW\/2012/PaU/07/VaYe-QKV-UaOO\-KeaOWK-bLOO45. TKe UROe RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWV LQ VWXdeQW acWLYLVP: decRORQLVLQJ WKe PedLcaO cXUULcXOXP - TKe BMJ[IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://bORJV.bPM.cRP/bPM/2020/07/17/WKe-UROe-RI-PedLcaO-VWXdeQWV-LQ-VWXdeQW-acWLYLVP-decRORQLVLQJ-WKe-PedLcaO-cXUULcXOXP/46. FaOO aQd RLVe RI MLd-CeQWXU\ SWXdeQW HeaOWK AcWLYLVP: PROLWLcaO ReSUeVVLRQ, McCaUWK\LVP, aQdWKe AVVRcLaWLRQ RI IQWeUQeV aQd MedLcaO SWXdeQWV (1947±1953) _ JRXUQaO RI WKe HLVWRU\ RI149MedLcLQe aQd AOOLed ScLeQceV _ O[IRUd AcadePLc [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://acadePLc.RXS.cRP/MKPaV/aUWLcOe/74/2/127/548129247. APeULcaQ MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.aPa-aVVQ.RUJ/48. HaUPRQ RG. IQWeUQ aQd ReVLdeQW OUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ WKe UQLWed SWaWeV: 1934-1977. TKe MLObaQNMePRULaO FXQd QXaUWeUO\ HeaOWK aQd SRcLeW\. 1978;56(4):500±30.49. OXU HLVWRU\ - CRPPLWWee RI IQWeUQV aQd ReVLdeQWV [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.cLUVeLX.RUJ/RXU-KLVWRU\-2/50. JRKQ HV. PUacWLcLQJ PK\VLcLaQV: TKe IQWeUQ &aPS; ReVLdeQW E[SeULeQce LQ WKe SKaSLQJ RIAPeULcaQ MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ, 1945--2003. YaOe UQLYeUVLW\; 2013.51. ReVLdeQW WRUN HRXUV: TKe EYROXWLRQ RI a ReYROXWLRQ _ MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ aQd TUaLQLQJ _ JAMASXUJeU\ _ JAMA NeWZRUN [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://MaPaQeWZRUN.cRP/MRXUQaOV/MaPaVXUJeU\/IXOOaUWLcOe/39256652. SWaII JBG, JXQe 8 U, 2023, CRPPeQWV86 1:58 S P SKaUe RQ FacebRRN SKaUe RQ TZLWWeUVLeZ.BRVWRQGORbe.cRP. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. ReVLdeQWV, IeOORZV aW MaVV GeQeUaO BULJKaP YRWe WRXQLRQL]e - TKe BRVWRQ GORbe. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.bRVWRQJORbe.cRP/2023/06/08/PeWUR/UeVLdeQWV-IeOORZV-PaVV-JeQeUaO-bULJKaP-YRWe-XQLRQL]e/53. MaNLQJ SeQVe RI GUadXaWe MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ FXQdLQJ EMRA [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8].AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://ZZZ.ePUa.RUJ/ePUeVLdeQW/aUWLcOe/JPe-IXQdLQJ54. ReVLdeQW PK\VLcLaQV FURP DC HRVSLWaOV GaWKeU WR PURWeVW WRUNLQJ CRQdLWLRQV ± NBC4WaVKLQJWRQ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.QbcZaVKLQJWRQ.cRP/QeZV/ORcaO/UeVLdeQW-SK\VLcLaQV-IURP-dc-KRVSLWaOV-JaWKeU-WR-SURWeVW-ZRUNLQJ-cRQdLWLRQV/3210091/15055. YX A. 80-KRXU ZeeNV aQd URacKeV QeaU \RXU cRW? MRUe PedLcaO UeVLdeQWV XQLRQL]e. NPR[IQWeUQeW]. 2023 MaU 23 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]; AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.QSU.RUJ/VecWLRQV/KeaOWK-VKRWV/2023/03/23/1165539846/80-KRXU-ZeeNV-aQd-URacKeV-QeaU-\RXU-cRW-PRUe-PedLcaO-UeVLdeQWV-XQLRQL]e56. WRUOd SRcLaOLVW Web SLWe [IQWeUQeW]. 2023 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. BeKLQd WKe VKaUS ULVe LQ US UeVLdeQWSK\VLcLaQV RUJaQL]LQJ LQWR XQLRQV. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.ZVZV.RUJ/eQ/aUWLcOeV/2023/06/11/U]JK-M11.KWPO57. YaOe Ped VWXdeQWV MRLQ LQ QaWLRQaO ZKLWe cRaW dLe-LQ < YaOe ScKRRO RI MedLcLQe [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://PedLcLQe.\aOe.edX/QeZV/\aOe-PedLcLQe-PaJa]LQe/aUWLcOe/\aOe-Ped-VWXdeQWV-MRLQ-LQ-QaWLRQaO-ZKLWe-cRaW/58. MedLcaO VWXdeQWV XVe PRPeQWXP RI aQWL-UacLVP PRYePeQW WR adYRcaWe IRU cKaQJe _ AAMC[IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.aaPc.RUJ/QeZV/PedLcaO-VWXdeQWV-XVe-PRPeQWXP-aQWL-UacLVP-PRYePeQW-adYRcaWe-cKaQJe59. KULVWLQ CROOLeU: MLcKLJaQ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV ZaON RXW RI LQdXcWLRQ ceUePRQ\ WR SURWeVW Ne\QRWeVSeaNeU ZLWK aQWL-abRUWLRQ YLeZV _ CNN [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.cQQ.cRP/2022/07/26/XV/PedLcaO-VWXdeQW-abRUWLRQ-SURWeVW-XQLYeUVLW\-RI-PLcKLJaQ/LQde[.KWPO60. AOWbacK PG. SWXdeQW SROLWLcV LQ WKe TKLUd WRUOd. HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ. 1984 Dec;13(6):635-55.61. TKe HLVWRU\ RI SWXdeQW MRYePeQWV LQ IQdLa: A SRcLRORJLcaO AccRXQW - APLW KXPaU SaXUabK,2023 [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://MRXUQaOV.VaJeSXb.cRP/dRL/abV/10.1177/09754253221122759?MRXUQaOCRde=RaQa&MRXUQaOCRde=RaQa15162. SWXdeQWV¶ UQLRQ LQ IQVWLWXWLRQV RI HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ RI IQdLa: A CULWLcaO SWXd\ RI NeedV,SLJQLILcaQce aQd RROeV [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.UeVeaUcKJaWe.QeW/SXbOLcaWLRQ/350530629_SWXdeQWV'_UQLRQ_LQ_IQVWLWXWLRQV_RI_HLJKeU_EdXcaWLRQ_RI_IQdLa_A_CULWLcaO_SWXd\_RI_NeedV_SLJQLILcaQce_aQd_RROeV63. HISTORY _ FRUdaFRUda [IQWeUQeW]. 2019 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://Zeb.aUcKLYe.RUJ/Zeb/20190313123025/KWWS://IRUda.RUJ/abRXW/KLVWRU\/64. SULUaP V, MLVKUa A, BaUX R. WRUNeUV RU WaUULRUV? ReVLdeQW DRcWRUV¶ PURWeVWV aQd HeaOWKGRYeUQaQce LQ IQdLa ± TKe WLUe ScLeQce [IQWeUQeW]. 2021 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://VcLeQce.WKeZLUe.LQ/KeaOWK/UeVLdeQW-dRcWRUV-SURWeVWV-ULJKWV-KeaOWK-JRYeUQaQce-PedLcaO-eQWUaQce-e[aPV/65. HLQdXVWaQ TLPeV [IQWeUQeW]. 2015 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. GRYW KRVSLWaO dRcWRUV WR JR RQ LQdeILQLWeVWULNe IURP MaUcK 2. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.KLQdXVWaQWLPeV.cRP/deOKL/JRYW-KRVSLWaO-dRcWRUV-WR-JR-RQ-LQdeILQLWe-VWULNe-IURP-PaUcK-2/VWRU\-LINWDAZXFT8O\70C3WUQJL.KWPO66. FORDA INDIA [@FRUdaIQdLa]. A MeeWLQJ ZaV cRQYeQed b\ HRQ¶bOe #DGHS WRda\ RQVXbPLVVLRQ RI "SXJJeVWLYe MeaVXUeV WR SWRS VLROeQce AJaLQVW DRcWRUV" b\ #FORDA & ZaVaWWeQded b\ YaULRXV OIILcLaOV. We ZeUe aVVXUed WKaW QeceVVaU\ PeaVXUeV ZLOO be WaNeQ baVed RQWKe SXJJeVWLRQV & WRda\¶V dLVcXVVLRQ @PRKIZ @ANI KWWSV://W.cR/SQ1UIcX1Ga [IQWeUQeW]. TZLWWeU.2021 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WZLWWeU.cRP/FRUdaIQdLa/VWaWXV/141273101801289319167. SWaQdaUd B. DeOKL UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV caOO RII WKeLU VWULNe [IQWeUQeW]. 2015 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8].AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.bXVLQeVV-VWaQdaUd.cRP/aUWLcOe/QeZV-LaQV/deOKL-UeVLdeQW-dRcWRUV-caOO-RII-WKeLU-VWULNe-115062400032_1.KWPO15268. IQdLa TRda\ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. DeOKL: ReVLdeQW dRcWRUV RI WKUee KRVSLWaOV bR\cRWWURXWLQe VeUYLceV RYeU NEET-PG cRXQVeOLQJ deOa\. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.LQdLaWRda\.LQ/LQdLa/VWRU\/QeeW-SJ-cRXQVeOOLQJ-deOa\-UeVLdeQW-dRcWRUV-deOKL-1883675-2021-12-0369. HLVWRULc da\ IRU PedLcaO IUaWeUQLW\: FORDA RQ SC UXOLQJ. TKe TLPeV RI IQdLa [IQWeUQeW]. 2022 JaQ7 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]; AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WLPeVRILQdLa.LQdLaWLPeV.cRP/LQdLa/KLVWRULc-da\-IRU-PedLcaO-IUaWeUQLW\-IRUda-RQ-Vc-UXOLQJ/aUWLcOeVKRZ/88758692.cPV70. FORDA INDIA [@FRUdaIQdLa]. ReVSecWed SLU ReTXeVW \RX WR NLQdO\ WaNe a QRWe RI SOLJKW RI\RXQJ dRcWRUV aQd WaNe QeceVVaU\ PeaVXUeV WR e[SedLWe NEET PG 2022 cRXQVeOLQJ SURceVV.@MRHFW_INDIA @PaQVXNKPaQdYL\a @OIILceOI_MM @DJKVIQdLa @NMC_IND @ANI@PTI_NeZV @QdWY @TOIIQdLaNeZV @MLUURUNRZ KWWSV://W.cR/c9K8aLKSY2 [IQWeUQeW]. TZLWWeU.2022 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WZLWWeU.cRP/FRUdaIQdLa/VWaWXV/156487553825862451571. HLVWRULc da\ IRU PedLcaO IUaWeUQLW\: FORDA RQ SC UXOLQJ. TKe TLPeV RI IQdLa [IQWeUQeW]. 2022 JaQ7 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]; AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WLPeVRILQdLa.LQdLaWLPeV.cRP/LQdLa/KLVWRULc-da\-IRU-PedLcaO-IUaWeUQLW\-IRUda-RQ-Vc-UXOLQJ/aUWLcOeVKRZ/88758692.cPV72. JacNPaQ D. TKe WKUeaW RI VWXdeQW PRYePeQWV LQ BaQJOadeVK: IQMXVWLce, LQILOWUaWRUV aQd UeJLPecKaQJe.73. CKRZdKXU\ ST. AO Ja]eeUa. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. BaQJOadeVK VWXdeQWV SURWeVW edXcaWLRQ Wa[.AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.aOMa]eeUa.cRP/QeZV/2015/9/13/baQJOadeVK-VWXdeQWV-SURWeVW-edXcaWLRQ-Wa[15374. BaQJOadeVK PedLcaO VWXdeQWV VWaUW VWUeeW SURWeVWV, dePaQd RQOLQe cOaVVeV [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024Feb 8]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.aacUaR.RUJ/edJe/ePeUJeQW-QeZV/baQJOadeVK-PedLcaO-VWXdeQWV-VWaUW-VWUeeW-SURWeVWV-dePaQd-RQOLQe-cOaVVeV75. TKe BXVLQeVV SWaQdaUd [IQWeUQeW]. 2020 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. PROLce dLVSeUVe PedLcaO VWXdeQWV IURPSKaKbaJK LQWeUVecWLRQ. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.WbVQeZV.QeW/baQJOadeVK/SROLce-dLVSeUVe-PedLcaO-VWXdeQWV-VKaKbaJK-LQWeUVecWLRQ-15522476. TKe BXVLQeVV SWaQdaUd [IQWeUQeW]. 2023 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. KKXOQa MedLcaO CROOeJe VWXdeQWV,PedLcLQe WUadeUV VWaJe SURWeVWV IROORZLQJ cOaVK. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.WbVQeZV.QeW/baQJOadeVK/NKXOQa-PedLcaO-cROOeJe-VWXdeQWV-PedLcLQe-WUadeUV-VWaJe-SURWeVWV-IROORZLQJ-cOaVK-68326677. bdQeZV24.cRP [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. PURWeVWV URLO BSMMU aV SRVWJUadXaWe dRcWRUV VeeNKLJKeU aOORZaQce. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://bdQeZV24.cRP/baQJOadeVK/6Q]KPK0OM778. SXQ D. daLO\-VXQ. 2023 [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. BSMMU SRVW-JUadXaWe dRcWRUV SURWeVW IRU beWWeU Sa\.AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://ZZZ.daLO\-VXQ.cRP/SULQWYeUVLRQ/deWaLOV/70047179. TKe FLQaQcLaO E[SUeVV [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8]. MedLcaO VWXdeQWV cRQWLQXe SURWeVWV aJaLQVWWZR-\eaU LQWeUQVKLS. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WKeILQaQcLaOe[SUeVV.cRP.bd/QaWLRQaO/PedLcaO-VWXdeQWV-cRQWLQXe-SURWeVWV-aJaLQVW-WZR-\eaU-LQWeUQVKLS-156733605380. TKe ULVe aQd VLOeQcLQJ RI a PaVV VWXdeQW PRYePeQW _ TKe DaLO\ SWaU [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8].AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.WKedaLO\VWaU.QeW/QeZV/VWaU-ZeeNeQd/cRYeU-VWRU\/WKe-ULVe-aQd-VLOeQcLQJ-PaVV-VWXdeQW-PRYePeQW-161839015481. "PaUNV L, PeWeUV W. NaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ LQ PL[ed-PeWKRdV We[W aQaO\VLV: A ZRUNIORZaSSURacK. IQWeUQaWLRQaO JRXUQaO RI SRcLaO ReVeaUcK MeWKRdRORJ\. 2023 JXO 4;26(4):377-89.82. AbUaP MD, MaQcLQL KT, PaUNeU RD. MeWKRdV WR LQWeJUaWe QaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ LQWRTXaOLWaWLYe UeVeaUcK. IQWeUQaWLRQaO JRXUQaO RI QXaOLWaWLYe MeWKRdV. 2020 Dec28;19:1609406920984608.83. AULJR D, PaJRWR S, CaUWeU-HaUULV L, LLOOLe SE, NebeNeU C. UVLQJ VRcLaO PedLa IRU KeaOWK UeVeaUcK:MeWKRdRORJLcaO aQd eWKLcaO cRQVLdeUaWLRQV IRU UecUXLWPeQW aQd LQWeUYeQWLRQ deOLYeU\. DLJLWaOKeaOWK. 2018 Ma\;4:2055207618771757.84. MecKNRYa V, WLOVRQ SL. NRUPV aQd UaJe: GeQdeU aQd VRcLaO PedLa LQ WKe 2018 US PLd-WeUPeOecWLRQV. EOecWRUaO VWXdLeV. 2021 Feb 1;69:102268.85. SLQQeQbeUJ L, BXWWeQKeLP AM, PadUe] K, MaQcKeQR C, UQJaU L, MeUcKaQW RM. TZLWWeU aV a WRROIRU KeaOWK UeVeaUcK: a V\VWePaWLc UeYLeZ. APeULcaQ MRXUQaO RI SXbOLc KeaOWK. 2017 JaQ;107(1):e1-8.86. BecKPaQQ A, KLP JY. BLJ daWa: A IRcXV RQ VRcLaO PedLa UeVeaUcK dLOePPaV. HaQdbRRN RIUeVeaUcK eWKLcV aQd VcLeQWLILc LQWeJULW\. 2020:427-44.87. SRcLaO MedLa ReVeaUcK GURXS. UVLQJ VRcLaO PedLa IRU VRcLaO UeVeaUcK: AQ LQWURdXcWLRQ.GRYeUQPeQW SRcLaO ReVeaUcK: SRcLaO ScLeQce LQ GRYeUQPeQW. 2016.88. BeQLQJeU K, FU\ A, JaJR N, LeSSV H, NaVV L, SLOYeVWeU H. ReVeaUcK XVLQJ VRcLaO PedLa; XVeUV¶YLeZV. NaWCeQ SRcLaO ReVeaUcK. 2014 Feb 20;20.89. MaUNKaP A. FabULcaWLRQ aV eWKLcaO SUacWLce: QXaOLWaWLYe LQTXLU\ LQ aPbLJXRXV LQWeUQeW cRQWe[WV.IQIRUPaWLRQ, CRPPXQLcaWLRQ & SRcLeW\. 2012 ASU 1;15(3):334-53.90. GRYeUQPeQW RI CaQada IAP RQ RE. DReV ReVeaUcK UVLQJ SRcLaO MedLa POaWIRUPV ReTXLUeReVeaUcK EWKLcV BRaUd ReYLeZ? - GXLdaQce LQ ASSO\LQJ TCPS 2 (2022) [IQWeUQeW]. 2023 [cLWed2024 MaU 2]. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://eWKLcV.Jc.ca/eQJ/Ueb-ceU_VRcLaO-VRcLaX[.KWPO#a1115591. PULYac\ LQ PXbOLc?: TKe EWKLcV RI AcadePLc ReVeaUcK ZLWK PXbOLcO\ AYaLOabOe SRcLaO MedLa DaWa- GRRJOe SeaUcK [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 2]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.JRRJOe.cRP/VeaUcK?T=PULYac\+LQ+PXbOLc%3F%3A+TKe+EWKLcV+RI+AcadePLc+ReVeaUcK+ZLWK+PXbOLcO\+AYaLOabOe+SRcLaO+MedLa+DaWa&QeZZLQdRZ=1&Vca_eVY=44b162d9710c0caI&V[VUI=ACQVQ0_MeI88NK_ZA64TO]JI6-FK5II2bA%3A1709416446820&eL=_S_MZaUbMdO\0PEPYLO20AE&Yed=0aKUKEZLT0WIA\NaEA[VTGTQIHb\ZDRRQ4dUDCBA&XacW=5&RT=PULYac\+LQ+PXbOLc%3F%3A+TKe+EWKLcV+RI+AcadePLc+ReVeaUcK+ZLWK+PXbOLcO\+AYaLOabOe+SRcLaO+MedLa+DaWa&JV_OS=EJ[Qd3MWd2O6LXNOcQALXVB\aXZKY3NJaW4JUHVLbGOMP]RJVGKOIEV0aGOMc\BYZLBBY2FNZW1SY\BSZXNOYXJMaCB3aXRRIFB1YP[SY2[5IEF2YWOVYWJVZSBTb2NSYWZJTWVNaWEJRGF0YUJAUABYAHAAeAGQAQCYAQCJAQCTAQC4AQPIAQD4AQL4AQGYAJCJAJCYAZCSBZA&VcOLeQW=JZV-ZL]-VeUS92. HaR T, HXaQJ Z, LLaQJ L, WeQJ H, TaQJ B. HeaOWK QaWXUaO OaQJXaJe SURceVVLQJ: PeWKRdRORJ\deYeORSPeQW aQd aSSOLcaWLRQV. JMIR PedLcaO LQIRUPaWLcV. 2021 OcW 21;9(10):e23898.93. ML[ed PeWKRdV UeVeaUcK: e[SaQdLQJ WKe eYLdeQce baVe _ EYLdeQce-BaVed NXUVLQJ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed2024 MaU 2]. AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://ebQ.bPM.cRP/cRQWeQW/20/3/7494. FeUeda\ J, MXLU-CRcKUaQe E. DePRQVWUaWLQJ RLJRU UVLQJ TKePaWLc AQaO\VLV: A H\bULd ASSURacKRI IQdXcWLYe aQd DedXcWLYe CRdLQJ aQd TKePe DeYeORSPeQW. IQWeUQaWLRQaO JRXUQaO RI QXaOLWaWLYeMeWKRdV. 2006 MaU 1;5(1):80±92.95. B\UQe D. A ZRUNed e[aPSOe RI BUaXQ aQd COaUNe¶V aSSURacK WR UeIOe[LYe WKePaWLc aQaO\VLV. QXaOQXaQW. 2022 JXQ 1;56(3):1391±412.96. RaMSXW NK, GURYeU BA, RaWKL VK. WRUd IUeTXeQc\ aQd VeQWLPeQW aQaO\VLV RI WZLWWeU PeVVaJeVdXULQJ CRURQaYLUXV SaQdePLc [IQWeUQeW]. aUXLY; 2020 [cLWed 2024 MaU 2]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWS://aU[LY.RUJ/abV/2004.0392515697. DaWaSWa[ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 2]. WKaW LV CRVLQe SLPLOaULW\? A CRPSUeKeQVLYe GXLde.AYaLOabOe IURP: KWWSV://ZZZ.daWaVWa[.cRP/JXLdeV/ZKaW-LV-cRVLQe-VLPLOaULW\98. GXQaZaQ D, SePbLULQJ CA, BXdLPaQ MA. TKe IPSOePeQWaWLRQ RI CRVLQe SLPLOaULW\ WR CaOcXOaWeTe[W ReOeYaQce beWZeeQ TZR DRcXPeQWV. J PK\V: CRQI SeU. 2018 MaU;978:012120.99. FROe\ K, WaUd P, McNaXJKWRQ D. IQQRYaWLQJ QXaOLWaWLYe FUaPLQJ AQaO\VLV IRU PXUSRVeV RIMedLa AQaO\VLV WLWKLQ PXbOLc HeaOWK IQTXLU\. QXaO HeaOWK ReV. 2019 OcW 1;29(12):1810±22.100. SaPVXdLQ D. UQdeUVWaQdLQJ WKe MRdeOV RI FUaPLQJ AQaO\VeV ASSURacKeV LQ MedLa FUaPLQJSWXdLeV: IQ: PURceedLQJV RI WKe SecRQd IQWeUQaWLRQaO CRQIeUeQce RQ SRcLaO, EcRQRP\, EdXcaWLRQaQd HXPaQLW\ [IQWeUQeW]. RLaX, IQdRQeVLa: SCITEPRESS - ScLeQce aQd TecKQRORJ\ PXbOLcaWLRQV;2019 [cLWed 2024 MaU 2]. S. 385±9. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.VcLWeSUeVV.RUJ/DLJLWaOLLbUaU\/LLQN.aVS[?dRL=10.5220/0009159503850389101. PaNLVWaQ - CIA [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 ASU 1]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.cLa.JRY/UeVRXUceV/PaS/SaNLVWaQ/102. EdLWRU TNN. KK\beU MedLcaO UQLYeUVLW\ AQQRXQceV MDCAT ReVXOWV AIWeU BOXeWRRWKScaQdaO _ TNN [IQWeUQeW]. TNN _ TULbaO NeZV NeWZRUN. 2023 [cLWed 2024 MaU 27]. AYaLOabOeIURP:KWWSV://WQQeQJOLVK.cRP/NK\beU-PedLcaO-XQLYeUVLW\-aQQRXQceV-PdcaW-UeVXOWV-aIWeU-bOXeWRRWK-VcaQdaO/103. HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 ASU 1]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.Kec.PX/PSKLOSKd_aZaUd104. CRUUXSWLRQ LQ WKe KeaOWK VecWRU: A SURbOeP LQ Qeed RI a V\VWePV-WKLQNLQJ aSSURacK - PMC[IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.QcbL.QOP.QLK.JRY/SPc/aUWLcOeV/PMC9449116/105. NLVKWaU S. PaNLVWaQ'V KeaOWK VecWRU: dReV cRUUXSWLRQ OXUN. IVOaPabad: HeaUWILOe. 2007.157106. NaKeU N, HRTXe R, HaVVaQ MS, BaOabaQRYa D, AdaPV AM, AKPed SM. TKe LQIOXeQce RIcRUUXSWLRQ aQd JRYeUQaQce LQ WKe deOLYeU\ RI IURQWOLQe KeaOWK caUe VeUYLceV LQ WKe SXbOLc VecWRU: aVcRSLQJ UeYLeZ RI cXUUeQW aQd IXWXUe SURVSecWV LQ ORZ aQd PLddOe-LQcRPe cRXQWULeV RI VRXWK aQdVRXWK-eaVW AVLa. BMC PXbOLc HeaOWK. 2020 JXQ 8;20(1):880.107. SabLWRYa A, SaMXQ SZ, NLcKROVRQ S, MRVOeU F, PULebe S. JRb PRUaOe RI SK\VLcLaQV LQORZ-LQcRPe aQd PLddOe-LQcRPe cRXQWULeV: a V\VWePaWLc OLWeUaWXUe UeYLeZ RI TXaOLWaWLYe VWXdLeV.BMJ OSeQ. 2019 Dec 3;9(12):e028657.108. D]eQJ E, WacKWeU RM. EWKLcV LQ CRQIOLcW: MRUaO DLVWUeVV aV a RRRW CaXVe RI BXUQRXW. J GeQIQWeUQ Med. 2020 Feb;35(2):409±11.109. LXIW LM. TKe eVVeQWLaO UROe RI SK\VLcLaQ aV adYRcaWe: KRZ aQd ZK\ Ze SaVV LW RQ. CaQ MedEdXc J. 2017 JXQ 30;8(3):e109±16.110. CaQMEDS FUaPeZRUN [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.UR\aOcROOeJe.ca/eQ/caQPedV/caQPedV-IUaPeZRUN.KWPO111. TKe UeaOLW\ RI KeaOWK VecWRU LQ PaNLVWaQ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.QaWLRQ.cRP.SN/03-JXQ-2022/WKe-UeaOLW\-RI-KeaOWK-VecWRU-LQ-SaNLVWaQ112. LaLWeeUaSRQJ N, HXaQJ ES. TKe Sace RI cKaQJe LQ PedLcaO SUacWLce aQd KeaOWK SROLc\:cROOLVLRQ RU cRe[LVWeQce? J GeQ IQWeUQ Med. 2015;30(6):848-852.113. KKaWaQa SA, PaWWRQ EW, SaQJKaYL DM. PXbOLc SROLc\ aQd SK\VLcLaQ LQYROYePeQW: UePRYLQJbaUULeUV, eQKaQcLQJ LPSacW. TKe APeULcaQ JRXUQaO RI MedLcLQe. 2017 JaQ 1;130(1):8-10.114. KULVKQaPXUWK\ S, SROWaQ\ KA, MRQWe] K. IQcRUSRUaWLQJ HeaOWK PROLc\ aQd AdYRcac\CXUULcXOa IQWR UQdeUJUadXaWe MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ LQ WKe UQLWed SWaWeV. JRXUQaO RI MedLcaOEdXcaWLRQ aQd CXUULcXOaU DeYeORSPeQW. 2023 AXJ;10:23821205231191601.115. VR[ F. TKe ULVNV RI SURIeVVLRQaO SURWeVW. AMA JRXUQaO RI EWKLcV. 2011 OcW 1;13(10):726-30.158116. NVLaK C, SLaNZa M, NLQQRQL JP. BaUULeUV WR SUacWLcLQJ SaWLeQW adYRcac\ LQ KeaOWKcaUe VeWWLQJ.NXUVLQJ OSeQ. 2020 MaU;7(2):650-9.117. MXVKWaT AQ, APLU N, SRKLO F, AKPad MA. HLVWRU\ RI VWXdeQW SROLWLcV aQd LWV UeYLYaO LQPaNLVWaQ. PaNLVWaQ VLVLRQ. 2020 JXQ 1;21(1):131.118. PUeILJXUaWLYe SROLWLcV. IQ: WLNLSedLa [IQWeUQeW]. 2024 [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://eQ.ZLNLSedLa.RUJ/Z/LQde[.SKS?WLWOe=PUeILJXUaWLYe_SROLWLcV&ROdLd=1209589510119. TKe E[SUeVV TULbXQe [IQWeUQeW]. 2023 [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. WK\ PaNLVWaQ LV a IaLOLQJdePRcUac\. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://WULbXQe.cRP.SN/VWRU\/2418836/ZK\-SaNLVWaQ-LV-a-IaLOLQJ-dePRcUac\120. W\aWW TR, Ma TL, EOOaZa\ RH. PK\VLcLaQ UeVLVWaQce WR LQMXVWLce: a VcRSLQJ UeYLeZ. SRcLaOScLeQce & MedLcLQe. 2023 MaU 1;320:115727.121. EOOaZa\ RH, W\aWW TR. WKaW UROe VKRXOd UeVLVWaQce SOa\ LQ WUaLQLQJ KeaOWK SURIeVVLRQaOV?.AcadePLc MedLcLQe. 2021 NRY 1;96(11):1524-8122. TaUURZ S. C\cOeV RI cROOecWLYe acWLRQ: BeWZeeQ PRPeQWV RI PadQeVV aQd WKe UeSeUWRLUe RIcRQWeQWLRQ. SRcLaO VcLeQce KLVWRU\. 1993 JXO;17(2):281-307.123. JaVSeU D. 31 EIIecWLYe SWUaWeJLeV & MeWKRdV TKaW AdYRcaWeV REALLY UVe [IQWeUQeW]. SWUeeWCLYLcV. 2020 [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://VWUeeWcLYLcV.cRP/31-eIIecWLYe-VWUaWeJLeV-PeWKRdV-WKaW-adYRcaWeV-UeaOO\-XVe/124. EVVe[ R. A deOLbeUaWLYe IUaPeZRUN WR aVVeVV WKe MXVWLILabLOLW\ RI VWULNe acWLRQ LQ KeaOWKcaUe.NXUVLQJ EWKLcV. 2023 AXJ 4:09697330231183076.125. 23. BXcNOe\ S. AdYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV aQd aSSURacKeV: OYeUYLeZ SaSeU. AcceVVed RQOLQe aWKWWS://ZZZ. aSc. RUJ/eQ/QRdeO9456. 2009.159126. AUab NeZV [IQWeUQeW]. 2024 [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. SRcLaO PedLa eOecWLRQ: DLJLWaO SOaWIRUPVWaNe ceQWeUVWaJe LQ caPSaLJQ VWUaWeJ\ IRU PaNLVWaQ 2024 SROOV. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://aUab.QeZV/YZUK7127. McRRNVRQ. FLYe Za\V IPUaQ KKaQ¶V SaUW\ XVed WecKQRORJ\ WR RXWSeUIRUP LQ PaNLVWaQ¶VeOecWLRQV [IQWeUQeW]. AWOaQWLc CRXQcLO. 2024 [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.aWOaQWLccRXQcLO.RUJ/bORJV/QeZ-aWOaQWLcLVW/ILYe-Za\V-LPUaQ-NKaQV-SaUW\-XVed-WecKQRORJ\-WR-RXWSeUIRUP-LQ-SaNLVWaQV-eOecWLRQV/128. 26. SaaLda M. TKe RROe RI SRcLaO MedLa LQ SKaSLQJ PROLWLcaO DLVcRXUVe aQd PURSaJaQda.129. DeWeUP [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. HRZ SRcLaO MedLa LV TUaQVIRUPLQJ PROLWLcaOCRPPXQLcaWLRQ. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.deWeUP.cRP/bORJ/KRZ-VRcLaO-PedLa-LV-WUaQVIRUPLQJ-SROLWLcaO-cRPPXQLcaWLRQ/130. LLNe AOe[aQdULa OcaVLR-CRUWe] RQ TZLWcK, MLOOeQQLaO SROLWLcLaQV aUe cKaQJLQJ SROLWLcVWKURXJK VRcLaO PedLa. - TKe WaVKLQJWRQ PRVW [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.ZaVKLQJWRQSRVW.cRP/SROLWLcV/2020/11/02/OLNe-aRc-WZLWcK-PLOOeQQLaO-SROLWLcLaQV-aUe-XVLQJ-VRcLaO-PedLa-WUaQVIRUP-MRb/131. (9) TKe UROe RI VRcLaO PedLa LQ VKaSLQJ SROLWLcaO dLVcRXUVe aQd SXbOLc RSLQLRQ LQ WKe dLJLWaOaJe _ LLQNedIQ [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.OLQNedLQ.cRP/SXOVe/UROe-VRcLaO-PedLa-VKaSLQJ-SROLWLcaO-dLVcRXUVe-SXbOLc-RSLQLRQ-NaMLWKa/132. ZLcN T. MaQaJLQJ dLVVeQW. WaVK. UL ReY.. 2017;95:1423.133. BaVX S, SeQ S. SLOeQced YRLceV: XQUaYeOOLQJ IQdLa¶V dLVVeQW cULVLV WKURXJK KLVWRULcaO aQdcRQWePSRUaU\ aQaO\VLV RI IUee VSeecK aQd VXSSUeVVLRQ. IQIRUPaWLRQ & CRPPXQLcaWLRQVTecKQRORJ\ LaZ. 2023 AXJ 31:1-24.160134. PaNLVWaQ¶V WURXbOe ZLWK acceSWLQJ caPSXV SROLWLcV [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 MaU 29]. AYaLOabOeIURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.WUWZRUOd.cRP/PaJa]LQe/SaNLVWaQ-V-WURXbOe-ZLWK-acceSWLQJ-caPSXV-SROLWLcV-32797135. PaNLVWaQ: TKe SWXdeQWV¶ SROLdaULW\ MaUcK IRU SWXdeQW UQLRQV! - EXURSe SROLdaLUe SaQVFURQWLqUeV [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 ASU 1]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.eXURSe-VROLdaLUe.RUJ/VSLS.SKS?aUWLcOe51437136. MLVXVe RI CURZd-cRQWURO WeaSRQV aQd E[ceVVLYe FRUce [IQWeUQeW]. PHR. [cLWed 2024 MaU29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://SKU.RUJ/LVVXeV/ZeaSRQV/QRQ-OeWKaO-ZeaSRQV-XVed-ZLWK-e[ceVVLYe-IRUce/137. 37. McEYR\ M, CRUQe\ N, HaaU RJ. CURZd CRQWURO TecKQLTXeV: PeUVSecWLYeV RQ WKe T\SeaQd UVe RI WeaSRQV b\ PROLce AURXQd WKe WRUOd. IQFRUeQVLc aQd LeJaO MedLcLQe (SS. 815-830).CRC PUeVV.138. PaNLVWaQ: EQd cUacNdRZQ RQ VWXdeQW SURWeVWV - APQeVW\ IQWeUQaWLRQaO [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024MaU 29]. AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://ZZZ.aPQeVW\.RUJ/eQ/OaWeVW/SUeVV-UeOeaVe/2019/12/SaNLVWaQ-eQd-cUacNdRZQ-RQ-VWXdeQW-SURWeVWV/139. AQLVLQ A. VLROeQce beJeWV YLROeQce: WK\ VWaWeV VKRXOd QRW OeWKaOO\ UeSUeVV SRSXOaU SURWeVW.TKe IQWeUQaWLRQaO JRXUQaO RI HXPaQ RLJKWV. 2016 OcW 2;20(7):893-913.140. SWXdeQW PROLWLcV _ CRQWeVWLQJ HLJKeU EdXcaWLRQ: SWXdeQW MRYePeQWV aJaLQVW NeROLbeUaOUQLYeUVLWLeV _ PROLc\ PUeVV ScKROaUVKLS OQOLQe _ O[IRUd AcadePLc [IQWeUQeW]. [cLWed 2024 Feb 8].AYaLOabOe IURP:KWWSV://acadePLc.RXS.cRP/SROLc\-SUeVV-VcKROaUVKLS-RQOLQe/bRRN/38246/cKaSWeU-abVWUacW/333179753?UedLUecWedFURP=IXOOWe[W&ORJLQ=IaOVe161141. BeQLQJeU K, FU\ A, JaJR N, LeSSV H, NaVV L, SLOYeVWeU H. ReVeaUcK XVLQJ VRcLaO PedLa;XVeUV¶ YLeZV. NaWCeQ SRcLaO ReVeaUcK. 2014 Feb 20;20.142. WLQVORZ L. TKe VaJe eQc\cORSedLa RI cRPPXQLcaWLRQ UeVeaUcK PeWKRdV (VROV. 1-4).TKRXVaQd OaNV, CA: SAGE PXbOLcaWLRQV, IQc dRL. 2017;10:9781483381411.162AppendicesAppendi[ A - LisW of Social Media PosWs b\ MSaRDs on RQ.1: SWrXcWXre, FXncWion,AdYocac\ IssXes and AdYocac\ SWraWegies1. FURP TKe HRXVe Of YDA D.I.KKaQ: YDA DIKKaQ LV SOeaVed WR aQQRXQce WKe fLUVW eYeU cabLQeW Rf YDA(XYZ) FePaOe SWXdeQWV WLQJ. CabLQeW MePbeUV aUe YRXQJ, EQeUJeWLc, WLPe WaVWed aQd ZLOO VWUXJJOe fRUWKe beWWeUPeQW Rf MedLcaO VWXdeQWV ULJKWV, DRcWRUV cRPPXQLW\ aQd SaWLeQWV & dRcWRUV ULJKWV. YDAD.I.KKaQ aQd YDA (XYZ) beOLeYe WKaW WKe QeZ cabLQeW ZLOO fXUWKeU VWUeQJWKeQ WKe SLOOaUV Rf WKecRQVWLWXWLRQ. IQ VKa AOOaK WKe\ ZLOO QeYeU OeW dRZQ WKe WUXVW SXW LQ WKeP b\ YDA DINKaQ aQd YDA (XYZ).TKeLU NRPLQaWLRQ ZLOO fXUWKeU VWUeQJWKeQ YDA (XYZ) SWXdeQWV WLQJ & YDA DI KKaQ, YDA KP.LRQJ-OLYe XQLW\ LRQJ OLYe YDA. #PUeVLdeQW A, #YLce_SUeVLdeQW B, #cKaLUPaQ C, #YLce_cKaLUPaQ D,#JeQeUaO_VecUeWRU\ E, #deSXW\_JeQeUaO_VecUeWRU\ F, #VSRNe_SeUVRQ J,H, #fRcaO_SeUVRQ I,J,K,#eYeQW_RUJaQL]eUV L,M,N, #adYLVRUV O,P, #COaVV_cRRUdLQaWRUV Q,R,S #fLQaQce_VecUeWRU\ R,S,#MRLQW_VecUeWRU\ T,U,V, #LQfRUPaWLRQ_VecUeWRU\ W,X, #PedLa_RUJaQL]eUV 1,2,32. YDA PXQMab: UQdeU WKe OeadeUVKLS Rf YDA PXQMab, YDA, DLVWULcW NaQNaQa SaKLb OaLd WKe fRXQdaWLRQRf WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ aW THQ HRVSLWaO X. IQ WKLV UeJaUd, a ZRQdeUfXO ceUePRQ\ ZaV RUJaQL]ed WRda\ aWTHQ HRVSLWaO X fRU WKe QeZO\ eOecWed VLVWeUV' RaWK-WaNLQJ ceUePRQ\. TKe PUeVLdeQW Rf YDA PXQMab,DU.X, DU.Y TKe PUeVLdeQW YDA DLVWULcW NaQNaQa, DU.Z TKe CKaLUPaQ YDA DLVWULcW NaQNaQa, DU.A TKeSeQLRU VLce PUeVLdeQW YDA aQd a OaUJe QXPbeU Rf dRcWRUV, QXUVeV, SaUaPedLcV aQd PedLaUeSUeVeQWaWLYeV fURP DLVWULcW NaQNaQa aORQJ ZLWK DU. B WKe GeQeUaO SecUeWaU\ YDA DLVWULcW NaQNaQaSaUWLcLSaWed. OffLcLaOV Rf YDA PXQMab aQd DLVWULcW NaQNaQa cRQJUaWXOaWed aQd e[SUeVVed beVW ZLVKeV WRPUeVLdeQW SLQaQJOa HLOO DU. C aQd KLV QeZO\ eOecWed cabLQeW.. PUeVLdeQW THQ HRVSLWaO X DU. C WKaQNedaOO WKe JXeVWV aQd e[SUeVVed KLV cRPPLWPeQW WR ZRUN da\ aQd QLJKW ZLWK bUaYeU\ aQd cRXUaJe fRU WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQ.1633. YDA PXQMab: A ZRQdeUfXO aSSeaUaQce ZaV aUUaQJed b\ WKe PUeVLdeQW Rf YDA PXQMab aQd PUeVLdeQW RfSeUYLceV HRVSLWaO LaKRUe WRda\. PUeVLdeQW fURP Ma\R HRVSLWaO, CKaLUPaQ aQd SeQLRU PaWURQ fURPJLQQaK HRVSLWaO, PUeVLdeQW, SSRNeVPeUVRQ aQd SeQLRU GXaUdLaQ fURP GXMaUaW, GeQeUaO SecUeWaU\,SeQLRU VLce PUeVLdeQW aQd SeQLRU GXaUdLaQ fURP SaUJRdKa, PUeVLdeQW fURP GXMUaQZaOa, PUeVLdeQW fURPCKLOdUeQ'V HRVSLWaO LaKRUe, PUeVLdeQW SKeLNK Za\ed HRVSLWaO, PUeVLdeQW fURP DePRQW HRVSLWaO, FRUPeUPUeVLdeQW fURP DeUa GKa]L KKaQ, PUeVLdeQW fURP NaQNaQa SaKLb aQd WKe RWKeU dRcWRUV aWWeQded LQOaUJe QXPbeUV. TKe SaUWLcLSaQWV XQaQLPRXVO\ e[SUeVVed WKeLU cRPPLWPeQW WKaW WKe UeaO VWUeQJWK Rf WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQ OLeV LQ XQLW\ aQd WKaW eYeU\ SRVVLbOe effRUW ZLOO be Pade fRU XQLW\. AOO SaUWLcLSaQWVePSKaVL]ed WKaW LW LV eVVeQWLaO fRU XQLW\ WR SURPRWe PXWXaO WUXVW aQd bURWKeUKRRd. A faYRUabOe aQdQRQ-cRQVWLWXWLRQaO GeQeUaO CRXQcLO PeeWLQJ RU YRWLQJ ZLOO QRW RQO\ KaUP WKe XQLW\ bXW ZLOO VcaWWeU WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQ. AOO GeQeUaO CRXQcLO PUeVLdeQWV Pade a MRLQW decOaUaWLRQ WKaW WKe\ aUe XQLWed aQd ZRXOdQRW RQO\ RSSRVe bXW WRWaOO\ bR\cRWW aQ\ LOOeJaO PeeWLQJ4. FURP WKe KRXVe Rf YDA IKD. A PeeWLQJ ZaV KeOd WRda\ LQ WKe SUeVeQce Rf PaWURQ LQ cKLef YDA KPK,PUeVLdeQW YDA KP, PaWURQ LQ cKLef YDA IKD, E[ cKaLUPaQ YDA IKD, PUeVLdeQW YDA KTH.AOO WKe CabLQeW PePbeUV Rf YDA IKD aWWeQded WKe PeeWLQJ aQd LW VWaUWed b\ WKe YRWe Rf WKaQNV WR WKeSUeYLRXV cabLQeW Oed b\ DU.X aV SUeVLdeQW fRU WKeLU VXcceVVfXO WeQXUe. AQd deWaLOed dLVcXVVLRQ ZaV dRQe RQWKe cXUUeQW VceQaULR aOO RYeU WKe SURYLQce.WLWK WKe SeUPLVVLRQ Rf PUeVLdeQW YDA KP WKe UeRUJaQL]aWLRQ cabLQeW Rf YDA IKD ZaV dRQe. AQd ZLWK WKeXQaQLPRXV decLVLRQ Rf aOO WKe PePbeUV Rf WKe PeeWLQJ WKe fROORZLQJ PePbeUV aUe aQQRXQced WR KROd WKeWRUcK Rf YDA IKD - YDA KPK1645. YDA SLQdK PeeWLQJ ZaV KeOd beWZeeQ VeQLRU OeadeUVKLS aQd YDA H\deUabad cabLQeW cKaLUed b\ DU. X.AJeQda Rf WKe PeeWLQJ dLVcXVVed SaUWLcLSaWLRQ LQ WKe XScRPLQJ eOecWLRQV, fRUPaWLRQ Rf EOecWLRQCRPPLVVLRQeU aQd PePbeUV Rf EOecWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ aQd fRUPaWLRQ Rf a cRPPLWWee WR UeVROYe SURbOePVfaced b\ SRVW JUadXaWeV aQd KRXVe RffLceUV««.. TKeUefRUe, Ze ZLOO ZeOcRPe eYeU\ decLVLRQ WR bULQJQeZ faceV LQ WKe eQWLUe SLQdK aQd cRQdXcW WUaQVSaUeQW eOecWLRQV ZKLcK ZLOO be ZLWKLQ WKe VcRSe RfdePRcUaWLc V\VWeP. YDA SLQdK6. TRPRUURZ, RQ 22 AXJXVW, LV WKe cRPSOeWLRQ Rf WZR \eaUV Rf WKe CeQWUaO CabLQeW Rf YDA SLQdK aQd aOO WKebRdLeV Rf TeUWLaU\ CaUe HRVSLWaO. NRZ, IQVKaAOOaK, eOecWLRQV Rf YDA SLQdK aUe JRLQJ WR be KeOd,VcKedXOed b\ EOecWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ PePbeUV aQd bRWK JURXSV WKaW ZLOO be LVVXed afWeU cRQVXOWaWLRQ. BXWWKe FacebRRN SRVWV WKaW KaYe beeQ VKaUed b\ bRWK JURXSV fRU a feZ da\V aQd aUe WKURZLQJ PXd aW eacKRWKeU aUe cRQdePQabOe. YRX beWWeU WeOO YRWeUV \RXU JRRd deedV, LQfRUP \RXU PRYePeQW. TeOO WKeP \RXUSaUW\ SROLc\, RU Rf cRXUVe cULWLcL]e WKe RSSRVLQJ JURXS SRVLWLYeO\ bXW LW LV QRW ULJKW WR SeUVRQaOO\cKaUacWeUL]e WKe dRcWRUV Rf WKe RSSRVLQJ JURXS.. DefeaW WKe OeadeUV \RX dRQ'W OLNe ZLWK SRZeU Rf YRWe.DLUW\LQJ WKe OeadeUV ZLOO dLVJUace WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ aQd UePePbeU YDA LV WKe bRaW Rf dRcWRUV WKaW \RXaOO aUe RQ bRaUd, Lf Ze daPaJe LW, Ze aOO ZLOO VLQN WRJeWKeU. AcW ZLVeO\. DU. X aQd DU. Y KaYe beeQ addedWR WKe EOecWLRQ CRPPLVVLRQ WKURXJK cRQVXOWaWLRQ Rf bRWK JURXSV. IQVKaAOOaK, RQe RU WZR dRcWRUV ZLOO beadded WR WKe EOecWLRQ cRPPLVVLRQ VRRQ afWeU fXUWKeU cRQVXOWaWLRQ7. YDA SLQdK, ZLOO QRW OeW \RXQJ dRcWRUV becRPe KRSeOeVV aQd KRVWaJe afWeU OLVWeQLQJ WR WKe VWaQd RfdRcWRUV Rf X HRVSLWaO. YDA LV a SURPLQeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQ Rf dRcWRUV aQd ZLOO aOZa\V VWaQd fRU ULJKWV aQdSURWecWLRQ. YDA SLQdK1658. MU.SeQaWRU! NRWKLQJ LV ZURQJ LQ WKe QRWLfLcaWLRQ & WKe fee LV aOVR WKe VaPe aV ZaV LQ \RXU WeQXUe & KaVQRW beeQ LQcUeaVed.We VWLOO UePePbeU \RXU aWWLWXde & deOa\LQJ WacWLcV WR KLQdeU WKe UeVWRUaWLRQ RfPMDC. AOO WKe bOacN OaZV OLNe NLE/MTI KaYe beeQ XQdRQe WKaW ZaV LPSRVed b\ PTI - DWM9. We aUe aOVR WKaQNfXO WR \RX SLU @MaNUaPaLPc , \RX SURYed \RXUVeOf WKe PRVW cRPSeWeQW KeaOWK PLQLVWeUeYeU, OLNe aOZa\V a YeU\ KXPbOe SeUVRQaOLW\ ZKR UeVROYed WKe LVVXeV Rf WKe ZKLWe cRaW cRPPXQLW\. -DWM10. *YDA BaORcKLVWaQ* RQ RXOeV aQd ReJXOaWLRQV Rf OUJaQL]LQJ BRdLeV* QXeWWa: YDA BaORcKLVWaQ ZLOOVeOecW RUJaQL]LQJ bRdLeV LQ aOO KRVSLWaOV acURVV WKe SURYLQce VWeS b\ VWeS. SSRNeVSeUVRQ DU. AULf KKaQMXVa KKeO QXeWWa: WLWK WKe aSSURYaO Rf WKe PURYLQcLaO CabLQeW Rf YDA BaORcKLVWaQ, WKe fROORZLQJ UXOeVaQd UeJXOaWLRQV KaYe beeQ Pade fRU RUJaQL]LQJ bRdLeV acURVV BaORcKLVWaQ. 1- SWUXcWXUe Rf WKeOUJaQL]LQJ BRd\ - OUJaQL]eU, DeSXW\ OUJaQL]eU aQd 3 RU 5 OUJaQL]LQJ MePbeUV 2- TKe Kead Rf WKeRUJaQL]LQJ bRd\ ZLOO be WKe RUJaQL]eU bXW LQ aOO LWV decLVLRQV WKe RUJaQL]eU ZLOO KaYe WR WaNe cRQfLdeQceLQ RWKeU RUJaQL]LQJ PePbeUV LQcOXdLQJ WKe deSXW\ RUJaQL]eU, aQ\ decLVLRQ WaNeQ b\ WKe RUJaQL]eUaJaLQVW WKe PaMRULW\ Rf WKe deSXW\ RUJaQL]eUV aQd WKe RUJaQL]LQJ PePbeUV ZLOO be QXOOLfLed. WLOO JR. 3.TKe RUJaQL]LQJ bRd\ ZLOO UeSUeVeQW WKe SURYLQcLaO cabLQeW dLUecWO\ LQ eacK KRVSLWaO. 4. IQ caVe Rf aQ\SURbOeP LQ WKe KRVSLWaO, aQ\ decLVLRQ WaNeQ b\ PaMRULW\ RSLQLRQ b\ WKe OUJaQL]LQJ BRd\ ZLOO KaYe WR beWaNeQ b\ WKe PURYLQcLaO CabLQeW LQ cRQfLdeQce, aOO decLVLRQV WaNeQ ZLWKRXW WaNLQJ WKe PURYLQcLaO CabLQeWLQ WUXVW ZLOO KaYe QR cRQVWLWXWLRQaO aQd PRUaO VWaWXV. 5. NR RUJaQL]LQJ bRd\ Pa\ VKaUe aQ\ SROLc\VWaWePeQW RU PaNe aQ\ VWaWePeQW RQ LWV beKaOf, SROLc\ VWaWePeQW ZLOO be VKaUed RQO\ ZLWK WKe aSSURYaO RfWKe SURYLQcLaO VSRNeVSeUVRQ cabLQeW. 6- If aQ\ RUJaQL]LQJ bRd\ KaV WR LVVXe a SUeVV UeOeaVe UeJaUdLQJ WKeSURbOePV faced b\ dRcWRUV aQd SaWLeQWV LQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV, LW ZLOO be RbOLJed fRU WKe RUJaQL]LQJbRd\ WR SXW WKeLU SURbOePV LQ fURQW Rf WKe cabLQeW. AfWeU WKe aSSURYaO Rf WKe cabLQeW, WKe SURYLQcLaOVSRNeVSeUVRQ VKRXOd LVVXe a SUeVV UeOeaVe. VRLce aQd acWLRQV ZLOO be WaNeQ aW SURYLQcLaO OeYeO RQ WKe166SURbOePV Rf dRcWRUV aQd SaWLeQWV VLWWLQJ LQ WKe UePRWe aUeaV Rf BaORcKLVWaQ. 7- IQ RUdeU WR PaNe WKeRUJaQL]aWLRQaO VWUXcWXUe PRUe RUJaQL]ed aQd VWabOe, WKe SURYLQcLaO cabLQeW ZLOO PaNe aPeQdPeQWV fURPWLPe WR WLPe accRUdLQJ WR WKe cRQVWLWXWLRQ, ZKLcK ZLOO be PaQdaWRU\ RQ eYeU\ RUJaQL]LQJ bRd\ WRUecRJQL]e. 8- SXJJeVWLRQV Rf aOO UeJLVWeUed PePbeUV Rf YDA BaORcKLVWaQ ZLOO be WaNeQ VeULRXVO\ WRVWUeQJWKeQ WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQaO VWUXcWXUe. *SSRNeVSeUVRQ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ*11. OQ WKe baVLV Rf UeSeaWed cRPSOaLQWV aJaLQVW SURSaJaQda PaVWeUV (QaPeV PeQWLRQed beORZ ) b\ DUV &KeaOWK SURfeVVLRQaOV Rf SLQdK Ze aUe UeOeaVLQJ WKLV SUeVV UeOeaVe. FaNe ID¶V PaVWeU DU..X LV KeUeb\ de -VeaWed fURP VLce CKaLUPeQ YDA SINDH. He ZaV JLYeQ VKRZ caXVe & ZaV ZaUQed QRW WR SURSaJaWefaOVe , fRUcefXO ORbb\LQJ , PLVXVe Rf KLV SRVLWLRQ & SURSaJaWLRQ Rf faNe & faOVe LQfRUPaWLRQ aJaLQVW DUV,Ke LV fRXQd JXLOW\ & LQYROYed LQ PXOWLSOe XQe[SOaLQabOe cRUUXSWLRQ VcaQdaOV. He KaV SOa\ed a PRVWcUXcLaO UROe LQ daPaJLQJ RXU aVVRcLaWLRQ. He LV adYLVed WR UeWXUQ 1 PLOOLRQ UXSeeV bacN ZKLcK KebRUURZed LQ PaQLSXOaWLYe beKaYLRU RQ aVVXUaQce Rf MU. Y. DU. X¶V PaLQ UROe ZaV WR facLOLWaWe DUV RfSLQdK bXW Ke ZaV fRXQd JXLOW\ & Ke ZaV XQabOe WR UeSO\ LQ cRQWe[W WR WKe e[SOaQaWLRQ OeWWeU ZKLcK ZaVLVVXed WR KLP 1 PRQWK bacN. DU.Z LV KeUeb\ aSSRLQWed aV VICE CHAIRMAN YDA SINDH WLOOaQQRXQcePeQW Rf eOecWLRQV. DU.A, CRQVXOWaQW OUWKRSedLc SXUJeRQ (AVVLVWaQW SURff + facXOW\ PePbeU) LVKeUeb\ adYLVed WR cOeaU KLV SRVLWLRQ ZLWKLQ 72 KRXUV WKaW eLWKeU Ke ZaQWV WR cRQWLQXe aV YDA SLQdKdeVLJQaWRU RU Ke ZaQW WR cRQWLQXe RQ adPLQLVWUaWLYe SRVWV IW LV aOVR LPSRUWaQW dLOePPa WKaW MU B(AVVLVWaQW SURff + CPSP VXSeUYLVRU) LV KeUeb\ LVVXed ZLWK VKRZcaVe RQ baVLV Rf beLQJ LJQRUaQW &facLOLWaWLQJ cXOSULWV & cRUUXSW SeUVRQaOV LQ RXU SUeVWLJLRXV aVVRcLaWLRQ. FURP WKe RffLce Rf GeQeUaOSecUeWaU\ MU.B LV LVVXed ZLWK VKRZ caXVe QRWLce & cOeaU KLV SRVLWLRQ ZLWKLQ 48 KRXUV eOVe Ke VROeO\ ZLOObe UeVSRQVLbOe fRU KLV fXWXUe LQ aVVRcLaWLRQ. We aUe LQYLWLQJ PaWXUe DUV Rf SLQdK & e[LVWLQJ CCMEMBERS WR cRPe fRUZaUd fRU WKe QRPLQaWLRQ Rf INTERIM - CHAIRMAN YDA SINDH, LQ caVe MUOPeU SXOWaQ¶V UeSO\ WR KLV VKRZ caXVe LV QRW UeceLYed ZLWK LQ 48 KRXUV YDA LV QRQ-SROLWLcaO &QRQ-adPLQLVWUaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQ & Ze ZLOO cRQWLQXe WR ZRUN fRU WKe ULJKWV Rf dRcWRUV16712. DXULQJ RXU AOO PaNLVWaQ WRXU, GS YDA SLQdK aQd WeaP Kad WKe KRQRU Rf beLQJ LQYLWed WR WKe UeVLdeQce RfWKe PUeVLdeQW Rf WKe YDA LQ GLOJLW, DU. A, NQRZQ fRU KLV e[ceOOeQW SROLWLcaO acXPeQ, aSSUecLaWed RXUYLVLRQ Rf eVWabOLVKLQJ YDA PaNLVWaQ. We Kad a SOeaVaQW PeeWLQJ ZLWK KLP aQd WKe GLOJLW YDA WeaP,dLVcXVVLQJ WKe cKaOOeQJeV faced b\ dRcWRUV acURVV PaNLVWaQ aQd WKe LQMXVWLceV aQd RSSUeVVLRQ WKe\eQdXUe. We deOYed LQWR deWaLOed dLVcXVVLRQV RQ KRZ WR addUeVV WKeVe LVVXeV aQd fLQd VROXWLRQV. WeePSKaVL]ed WKe LPSRUWaQce Rf PRbLOL]LQJ YDA LQ eYeU\ SURYLQce WR WacNOe WKe SURbOePV faced b\ dRcWRUVQaWLRQZLde. We dLVcXVVed VWUaWeJLeV WR XQLWe YDA cKaSWeUV fURP dLffeUeQW SURYLQceV aQd VKaUed e[ceOOeQWLdeaV WKaW ZLOO be LPSOePeQWed afWeU cRQVXOWLQJ ZLWK RWKeU SURYLQceV«.. We ZLOO dLVcXVV KRZ WR XQLWeYDA cKaSWeUV aQd addUeVV WKe cKaOOeQJeV faced b\ dRcWRUV acURVV PaNLVWaQ. We ZLOO fLJKW fRU WKe ULJKWVRf dRcWRUV facLQJ LVVXeV aQd eQVXUe WKe SUeVeUYaWLRQ Rf WKe dLJQLW\ Rf WKe ZKLWe cRaW. - YDA SLQdK13. MDCAT SLQdK PRVWSRQePeQW aQd YDA SLQdK DePRcUaWLc PaQeO'V OeadeU SWaQce - TKe SRVWSRQePeQW RfWKe MDCAT SLQdK e[aPLQaWLRQ LV a VLJQLfLcaQW deYeORSPeQW WKaW KaV beeQ acKLeYed WKURXJK WKecROOecWLYe effRUWV Rf VWXdeQWV, SaUeQWV, VRcLaO ZRUNeUV, aQd \RXQJ dRcWRUV aVVRcLaWed ZLWK YDA SLQdKaQd PaNLVWaQ«.. IW LV a cOeaU dePRQVWUaWLRQ Rf WKe SRZeU Rf XQLW\ aQd WKe YRLce Rf WKe SeRSOe.FXUWKeUPRUe, UeceQW eYeQWV KaYe e[SRVed WKe WUXe QaWXUe Rf ceUWaLQ LQdLYLdXaOV cOaLPLQJ WR UeSUeVeQWYDA SLQdK XQdeU WKe SKaK LaWLf SaQeO«.. IW aSSeaUV WKaW WKe VR-caOOed YDA SKaK LaWLf SaQeO'V acWLRQVPa\ KaYe beeQ dULYeQ PRUe b\ SROLWLcaO SRLQW-VcRULQJ WKaQ WKe JeQXLQe ZeOfaUe Rf PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQdKeaOWKcaUe LQ WKe UeJLRQ. We beOLeYe WKaW WUaQVSaUeQc\ aQd accRXQWabLOLW\ VKRXOd be WKe cRUQeUVWRQeV RfaQ\ UeVSRQVLbOe aVVRcLaWLRQ, eVSecLaOO\ RQe WKaW deaOV ZLWK WKe cULWLcaO fLeOd Rf KeaOWKcaUe. TKe YDASLQdK DePRcUaWLc PaQeO UePaLQV cRPPLWWed WR LWV cRUe YaOXeV Rf VeUYLQJ WKe LQWeUeVWV Rf PedLcaOVWXdeQWV, \RXQJ dRcWRUV, aQd WKe KeaOWKcaUe VecWRU LQ SLQdK aQd PaNLVWaQ aV a ZKROe. We ZLOO cRQWLQXeRXU effRUWV WR eQVXUe a faLU aQd MXVW eQYLURQPeQW fRU aOO.16814. FURP WKe ZaOO Rf YDA EOecWLRQ cRPPLVVLRQ PAGE DeadORcN LV VWLOO LQ SOace LQ WKe eOecWLRQV Rf YDASLQdK. YeW, YaULRXV SRVWV aQd YLdeR VWaWePeQWV aUe beLQJ Pade RQ VRcLaO PedLa b\ bRWK SaQeOV SKaKLaWLf aQd DePRcUaWLc aQd aUe aQQRXQcLQJ WKe UeVXOWV Rf WKeLU cKRLce accRUdLQJ WR WKe EOecWLRQCRPPLVVLRQ«..IW LV LPSeUaWLYe RQ bRWK WKe SaQeOV WR VKRZ XQdeUVWaQdLQJ aQd ZLVdRP aQd WaNe YDASLQdK WR WKe ULJKW dLUecWLRQ Rf KLVWRU\. RePePbeU, YDA PXQMab, YDA KP, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ KaYe WKeLUe\eV RQ YDA SLQdK eOecWLRQV.15. YDA PXQMab: YDA PXQMab'V OeadeUVKLS YLVLWed DHQ HRVSLWaO X WRda\««. PUeVLdeQW fURP YDA X aQdKLV cRPSaQLRQV ZaUPO\ ZeOcRPed WKe JXeVWV. PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab aORQJ ZLWK KLV deOeJaWLRQ KadVeSaUaWe PeeWLQJV ZLWK bRWK JURXSV aQd dLVcXVVed LQ deWaLO WKe eYeQWV OeadLQJ XS WR eOecWLRQV LQ CLYLOHRVSLWaO X, WKe PaQdaWe Rf WKe cRPPXQLW\, aQd WKeLU RZQ UeVeUYaWLRQV aQd JULeYaQceV. AfWeU WKedLVcXVVLRQV beWZeeQ bRWK JURXSV aQd cRQVXOWaWLRQ ZLWK WKe ceQWUaO OeadeUVKLS, WKe fROORZLQJ VWaWePeQWLV LVVXed XQaQLPRXVO\ LQ WKe SUeVeQce Rf aOO VWaNeKROdeUV: SLQce CLYLO HRVSLWaO X LV a PePbeU RfGeQeUaO CRXQcLO YDA PXQMab, VR QR RQe caQ be aOORZed WR dR aQ\ XQOaZfXO acWLYLW\ KeUe«TR WKePePbeUV: TKe cRPPLWWee ZLOO SUeVeQW LWV RZQ UecRPPeQdaWLRQV fRU eOecWLRQ SURceVV, UeJLVWUaWLRQ,eOecWLRQ UXOeV, eOecWLRQ daWe aQd dLVSXWeV UeVROXWLRQ, NeeSLQJ LQ PLQd WKe fXWXUe Rf CLYLO HRVSLWaO X ZLOObe decLded. YDA PXQMab WKaQNV LWV ORcaO cRPPXQLW\ aQd aOO WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQaO RffLce KROdeUV ZKRQRW RQO\ acNQRZOedJed WKe SULQcLSOeV Rf WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ bXW aOVR e[SUeVVed fXOO cRQfLdeQce LQ eYeU\decLVLRQ Rf WKe CeQWUaO CRXQcLO.. PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab, CKaLUPaQ.16. YDA KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa YRXQJ DRcWRUV LV a UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQ Rf WKe SURYLQce, aQd WKecabLQeWV Rf YRXQJ DRcWRUV LQ aOO WKe KRVSLWaOV Rf WKe SURYLQce ZRUN da\ aQd QLJKW WR UedXce WKe ULJKWV RfdRcWRUV aQd SaWLeQWV. YRXQJ dRcWRUV KaYe aOZa\V UaLVed WKeLU YRLce aJaLQVW cRUUXSWLRQ, becaXVe RfZKLcK WKe SUeYLRXV JRYeUQPeQW aOVR WaUJeWed \RXQJ dRcWRUV. TRda\, ZKeQ \RXQJ dRcWRUV UaLVed WKeLUYRLce fRU WKeLU cRPPXQLW\ aQd aJaLQVW cRUUXSWLRQ, WKe MS Rf X HRVSLWaO bOaPed WKe cabLQeW Rf \RXQJ169dRcWRUV. YDA KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa ZRXOd OLNe WR JLYe a cOeaU PeVVaJe WR MS X HRVSLWaO WKaW WKe\ aUeRXU UeSUeVeQWaWLYeV aQd UePePbeU WKaW eYeU\ dRcWRU ZKR fLJKWV fRU WKeLU ULJKWV LV a \RXQJ dRcWRU. YDAKK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa VWaQdV VLde b\ VLde ZLWK LWV ORcaO RUJaQL]aWLRQ, aQd LV QRW Uead\ WR cRPSURPLVe RQcRUUXSWLRQ aQd SeRSOe'V ULJKWV. SWa\ XQLWed. SWa\ VWURQJ SSRNeVSeUVRQ YDA KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa17. IPSRUWaQW aQQRXQcePeQW NXPeURXV faNe SURfLOeV, JURXSV aQd SaJeV aUe beLQJ UXQ b\ VRPe Rf WKebURWKeUV b\ VRPe Rf WKe VeQLRU aQd cRQWeVWLQJ RffLcLaOV ZKLcK LV a cRPSOeWeO\ LQcRPSUeKeQVLbOe aQddeVSLcabOe YLROaWLRQ ZLWK UeJaUd WR YDA SLQdK. We aV a SeacefXO RUJaQL]aWLRQ cRQdePQ aOO WKeVeacWLYLWLeV aQd WKe FIA KaV UeJLVWeUed WKeVe cRQdePQaWLRQ cRPSOaLQWV. AdYeUWLVLQJ WKLV bOLQd SURSaJaQdaRf bOacNPaLOLQJ aQd cKaUacWeU aVVaVVLQaWLRQ ZLOO QRW be acceSWed aW aQ\ cRVW. We UeTXeVW aOO WKe dRcWRUVRf SLQdK WR VWa\ aZa\ fURP WKLV SURSaJaQda. We ZLOO bULQJ WKe fXOO WUaQVSaUeQW UeSRUW LQ fURQW Rf \RX aOOZKeQ WKe LQYeVWLJaWLRQ UeVXOWV aUe UeceLYed. - YDA SLQdK18. YDA PXQMab: YDA UeMecWV WKe deaWK aQd LQcLdeQW Rf a SaWLeQW bURXJKW WR X HRVSLWaO aV QeJOLJeQce RfdRcWRUV aQd aWWePSWV WR SaLQW LW aV UeOLJLRXV e[WUePLVP fRU SeUVRQaO SXUSRVeV bXW cRQdePQ LQ VWURQJZRUdV.We XQdeUVWaQd WKaW WKeUe aUe dLffeUeQW aVSecWV WR aQ\ LQcLdeQW RU LQcLdeQW. YRX VKRXOd QRW JLYe \RXURSLQLRQ XQWLO aOO aVSecWV aUe cRYeUed. We e[SUeVV RXU cRQdROeQceV WR WKe faPLO\ RQ WKe deaWK Rf WKe JLUOaQd SUa\ fRU SaWLeQce fRU WKeP.BXW aOaV, WKe Za\ WKe V\VWePaWLc caPSaLJQ aJaLQVW dRcWRUV LV beLQJ cRQdXcWed aJaLQVW WKe dRcWRUV fRU WKeSaVW 2 da\V LV YeU\ Vad. YRXQJ dRcWRUV aUe dePaQdLQJ WUaQVSaUeQW LQYeVWLJaWLRQ fURP WKe KLJKeU RUdeUVfURP WKe fLUVW da\ aQd aUe Uead\ WR cRRSeUaWe LQ eYeU\ Za\ fRU WUaQVSaUeQW LQYeVWLJaWLRQ. IW LV YeU\ Vad WR170Va\ WKaW WKLV LQcLdeQW LV LQfOaPed b\ VRPe faPe KXQJU\ aQd PRQe\ ZRUVKLSSeUV VR-caOOed MRXUQaOLVWV b\JLYLQJ LW a cRPSOeWeO\ UeOLJLRXV cRORU. - YDA PXQMab19. *YDA BaORcKLVWaQ*: YDA BaORcKLVWaQ fXOO\ VXSSRUWV WKe SRVLWLYe VWeSV WaNeQ b\ MS X HRVSLWaO QXeWWaWR LPSURYe WKe cRQdLWLRQ Rf X HRVSLWaO aQd e[SUeVVeV cRQceUQ RYeU WKe QeJaWLYe SURSaJaQda aJaLQVWWKeP aQd VWURQJO\ cRQdePQV WKLV faOVe SURSaJaQda. - SSRNeVPaQ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ20. YDA PXQMab: YDA PXQMab OaLd WKe fRXQdaWLRQ Rf WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ aW THQ HRVSLWaO Y. IQ WKLV UeJaUd, aVSOeQdLd ceUePRQ\ ZaV RUJaQL]ed WRda\ aW THQ HRVSLWaO Y fRU WKe RaWK WaNLQJ ceUePRQ\ Rf WKe QeZO\eOecWed cabLQeW. PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab, SSRNeVPeUVRQ Ma\R HRVSLWaO, PUeVLdeQW SeUYLceV HRVSLWaO«.««, aQd a OaUJe QXPbeU Rf dRcWRUV, QXUVeV, SaUaPedLcV aQd PedLa UeSUeVeQWaWLYeV LQcOXdLQJCKaLUPaQ, GeQeUaO SecUeWaU\ aQd PaWWeUQ-LQ-CKLef fURP THQ HRVSLWaO Y aWWeQded. PUeVLdeQW YDAPXQMab WRRN RaWK fURP PUeVLdeQW THQ HRVSLWaO Y aQd KLV cabLQeW, cRQJUaWXOaWed aQd e[SUeVVed JRRdZLVKeV. PUeVLdeQW THQ HRVSLWaO Y WKaQNed aOO WKe JXeVWV aQd e[SUeVVed KLV cRPPLWPeQW WR ZRUN da\aQd QLJKW ZLWK bUaYeU\ aQd cRXUaJe fRU WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ.21. YDA PXQMab: ReKab Rf WKe dRcWRUV ... LaVW feZ da\V, RQ WKe SROLWLcaO WeUPLQaWLRQ Rf dRcWRUV aW DHQHRVSLWaO Z, ZLWK fXOO SURWeVW aQd MRLQW effRUWV Rf YDA Z KRVSLWaO aQd CeQWUaO YDA PXQMab, aOO WKe dRcWRUVZeUe UeVWRUed ZLWKLQ 24 KRXUV... OQ WKLV aXVSLcLRXV RccaVLRQ, YDA Z KRVSLWaO aUUaQJed a Wea SaUW\ LQKRQRU Rf CeQWUaO YD PXQMab aQd caNe ZaV cXW««. ZeUe SUeVeQWed bRXTXeWV Rf fORZeUV. PUeVLdeQW YDAPXQMab VaLd WKaW YDA KaV aOZa\V VWRRd fRU WKe ULJKWV Rf dRcWRUV aQd ZLOO SURWecW LW LQ WKe fXWXUe.22. OQ WKe LQVWUXcWLRQV Rf WKe GeQeUaO CRXQcLO Rf YDA KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa, WRda\ YDA « GURXS RfTeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO dLd a ZaUd-WR-ZaUd URXQd aQd WRRN LWV dRcWRUV cRPPXQLW\ LQ cRQfLdeQce fRU aSeacefXO SURWeVW WRPRUURZ. YRXQJ dRcWRUV ZLOO bR\cRWW eOecWLYe VeUYLceV acURVV KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa171fURP WRPRUURZ aJaLQVW QRQ-KLNe LQ VaOaULeV Rf WUaLQee PedLcaO RffLceUV aQd KRXVe RffLceUV. AOO WUaLQeePedLcaO RffLceUV aQd KRXVe RffLceUV aUe LQfRUPed WKaW fURP WRPRUURZ QR dRcWRU VKaOO be ZaUded RUOPD. AOO Rf WKe XQSOeaVaQW eYeQWV TKe JRYeUQPeQW ZLOO WaNe UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ fRU RQ WLPe. SWa\ XQLWed. SWa\VWURQJ. YDA KPK23. YDA PXQMab AOKaPdXOLOOaK IVVXe Rf PaLd MaWeUQLW\ LeaYe ReVROYed We KaYe beeQ UeceLYLQJ cRPSOaLQWVRf SURbOePV face b\ OXU FePaOe PRVW GUadXaWe ReVLdeQWV UeJaUdLQJ MaWeUQLW\ LeaYeV IW ZaV YeU\dLffLcXOW fRU FePaOe DRcWRUV WR ZRUN XQSaLd VSecLaOO\ LQ cXUUeQW ZaYe Rf PULce KLNeV WR cRYeU XS WKeLUMaWeUQLW\ LeaYeV YDA PXQMab XQdeU OeadeUVKLS RffLcLaO PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab WRRN WKe LVVXe aQdPXOWLSOe PeeWLQJV ZeUe dRQe ZLWK RffLcLaOV Rf SSecLaOL]ed HeaOWKCaUe DeSaUWPeQW24. We KaYe decLded WR UaLVe YRLce aW WKe UeTXeVW Rf KXQdUedV Rf VWXdeQWV & WKeUe LV a UeaVRQ WKaW a feZbRaUdV KaYe VcKedXOed SUacWLcaO e[aPV WLOO 27AXJ-23. - DWM25. AV SeU WKe QRWLfLcaWLRQV WKaW Ze KaYe VeeQ, VRPe Rf RXU fULeQdV ZKR aUe JUadXaWeV fURP X PedLcaOVcKRRO aQd aUe cXUUeQWO\ dRLQJ WKeLU KRXVe MRb aW «.. CaPSXV aUe facLQJ aQ LVVXe. TKe\ KaYecRPSOaLQed WKaW RXU LQVWLWXWe RQO\ SURYLdeV a VaOaU\ Rf 45,000 PKR SeU PRQWK, ZKLOe WKe SXSUePe CRXUWKad RUdeUed aOO LQVWLWXWeV acURVV PaNLVWaQ WR LQcUeaVe WKe Sa\ fRU KRXVe RffLceUV. DeVSLWe WKe SXSUePeCRXUW'V QRWLce, WKe KRVSLWaO WR ZKLcK RXU fULeQdV aUe bRXQd LV VWLOO Sa\LQJ WKeP a ORZeU VaOaU\. TKLV LV aQLQMXVWLce WR RXU feOORZ VWXdeQWV, aQd Ze VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKe KRVSLWaO adPLQLVWUaWLRQ'V acWLRQV. We ZaQWWR LQfRUP WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ WKaW WRda\'V dRcWRUV aUe QRW KeOSOeVV, aQd WKe YDA VWaQdV ZLWK eacK dRcWRUWR addUeVV WKeLU LVVXeV. - YDA SLQdK26. TKe\ Va\ WKaW WKe SRRU aUe cUa]\ eLJKW WLPeV. A ZRPaQ ZaV ZaONLQJ aURXQd ZLWK KeU PLVVLQJ OLYeU LQ WKeKaUacKL KRVSLWaO fRU VeYeUaO da\V, VLWWLQJ LQ WKe ZaLWLQJ URRP Rf DRZ HRVSLWaO aW QLJKW ZLWK WeaUV172UROOLQJ dRZQ KeU e\eV aQd WKLQNLQJ abRXW WKe WUeaWPeQW Rf KeU bab\«..DU. A aQd KLV faPLO\, DU.C, WULedWR cRQWacW KLP, bXW WKe SeRSOe LQ WKe ZaLWLQJ URRP Rf DRZ HRVSLWaO VaLd WKaW WKe\ Kad OefW fRU WKeYLOOaJe..! VaULRXV effRUWV ZeUe Pade aQd DU. A UefeUUed WKe SaWLeQW WR DU. X, a caQceU VSecLaOLVW. TKeSaWLeQW ZaV WUaQVSRUWed b\ UeVcXe aPbXOaQce 1122 ZLWK WKe KeOS Rf H\deUabad SLQdK GRYeUQPeQW. DU.X LV a dRcWRU aV ZeOO aV a VRcLaO ZRUNeU aQd LV aOVR a SaUW Rf WKe YDA. DXULQJ WKe fORRdV aQd UaLQV Rf2022, YRXQJ DRcWRUV PUeVLdeQW DU. X cRQdXcWed 142 PedLcaO caPSV LQ dLffeUeQW dLVWULcWV Rf SLQdK. SLQdKQeedV \RXQJ SeRSOe OLNe DU. SaOeK CKaQdLR.27. TKe VWaff Rf aOO WKUee KRVSLWaOV aUe UaLVLQJ cRQceUQV RYeU WKe abVeQce Rf a BRaUd Rf GRYeUQRUV PeeWLQJLQ X TeacKLQJ IQVWLWXWe fRU WKe SaVW VeYeUaO PRQWKV. SSRNeVSeUVRQ YDA DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ DeVSLWe WKeeffRUWV Rf YDA DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ, WKe BRaUd Rf GRYeUQRUV LV XQabOe WR KROd a PeeWLQJ. SSRNeVSeUVRQYDA DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ NRW KaYLQJ a PeeWLQJ Rf WKe BRaUd Rf GRYeUQRUV LQ PRUe WKaQ VeYeQ PRQWKV LVQR OeVV WKaQ aQ eQeP\ ZLWK WKe SeRSOe Rf DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ. - YDA KPK28. PUeVLdeQW YDA BALOCHISTAN UeceLYed a OeWWeU fURP WKe DeSXW\ DLUecWRU TecKQLcaO HeaOWKDeSaUWPeQW BaORcKLVWaQ, aVNLQJ KLP WR VKaUe KLV LQVLJKW RQ WKe SROLc\ deYeORSPeQW Rf MedLcaOEdXcaWLRQ, IQ UeSO\ WR WKe DeSXW\ DLUecWRU TecKQLcaO Rf WKe HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW BaORcKLVWaQ PUeVLdeQWYDA BaORcKLVWaQ VKaUed KLV SURSRVaOV fRU WKe deYeORSPeQW Rf a PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ SROLc\.29. SWUXJJOe aOZa\V bULQJV fUXLW, aV WKe dePaQd Rf deOa\LQJ MDCAT LV QRW fRU JeWWLQJ PRUe WLPe fRU PRUeSUeSaUaWLRQ Rf MDCAT bXW WKe UeaVRQ LV a feZ bRaUdV KaYe VcKedXOed SUacWLcaO e[aPV WLOO 28WK AXJXVW2023. SR,PMDC PXVW deOa\ MDCAT 2023. #PMDC_DeOa\_MDCAT #DeOa\MDCAT2023. - DWM30. CRQJUaWXOaWLRQV! MDCAT 2023 KaV beeQ deOa\ed aQd RffLcLaOO\ QRWLfLed. #PMDC_DeOa\_MDCAT#DeOa\MDCAT2023. - DWM17331. We eQdRUVe @KLUPaQLAVLf . TKaW'V ZKaW Ze WULed WR cRQYLQce VWXdeQWV eaUOLeU. BXW, LW'V WRR OaWe QRZ.MaQ\ Rf WKe VWXdeQWV ZLOO VXffeU QRZ becaXVe Rf WKe LUUeVSRQVLbOe aWWLWXde Rf @DUNadeePMaQ . HRZ caQKe dLcWaWe PMDC WR cKaQJe MDCAT daWe, LW ZLOO be WKe ZRUVW MDCAT. #PMDC_DELAY_MDCAT. -DWM32. PMDC KaV UeMecWed WR acceSW WKe LOORJLcaO dLUecWLRQV Rf WKe HeaOWK MLQLVWeU WR deOa\ MDCAT fXUWKeU. IWZLOO be QRZ cRQYeQed RQ WKe VLQJOe aOUead\ aQQRXQced daWe QaWLRQZLde WKaW LV RQ 10WK SeSWePbeU 2023.We dLd aQQRXQce ZeOO befRUe WLPe WKaW WKeUe ZLOO be QR deOa\. #PMDC_DELAY_MDCAT- DWM33. TKe JUace PaUNV VKRXOd be JLYeQ WR aOO WKe VWXdeQWV fRU WKe ZURQJ Ne\/ RXW Rf V\OOabXV MCQV aQdWecKQLcaOO\ ZURQJ TXeVWLRQ SaSeU MCQV afWeU WKe UeOeYaQW aVVeVVPeQW.TKeUe'V QR aXWKeQWLcLW\ LQ WKeQeZV Rf SaSeU OeaNaJe,LW'V UeTXeVWed WR QRW VSUead VXcK faNe QeZV. @SPc_RUJ #MDCAT2023. - DWM34. MDCAT SLQdK PRVWSRQePeQW aQd YDA SLQdK DePRcUaWLc PaQeO'V OeadeU¶V SWaQce - TKe SRVWSRQePeQWRf WKe MDCAT SLQdK e[aPLQaWLRQ LV a VLJQLfLcaQW deYeORSPeQW WKaW KaV beeQ acKLeYed WKURXJK WKecROOecWLYe effRUWV Rf VWXdeQWV, SaUeQWV, VRcLaO ZRUNeUV, aQd \RXQJ dRcWRUV aVVRcLaWed ZLWK YDA SLQdKaQd PaNLVWaQ. We ZKROeKeaUWedO\ ZeOcRPe WKLV faLU decLVLRQ, aV LW KaV VafeJXaUded WKe fXWXUeaVSLUaWLRQV Rf WKRXVaQdV Rf PedLcaO VWXdeQWV LQ SLQdK. TKLV SRVWSRQePeQW VeUYeV aV a WeVWaPeQW WR WKedeWeUPLQaWLRQ aQd dedLcaWLRQ Rf WKRVe ZKR WLUeOeVVO\ adYRcaWed fRU WKe ZeOO-beLQJ aQd acadePLcSURVSecWV Rf RXU PedLcaO VWXdeQWV. IW LV a cOeaU dePRQVWUaWLRQ Rf WKe SRZeU Rf XQLW\ aQd WKe YRLce Rf WKeSeRSOe. - YDA SLQdK35. We YDA SLQdK VWaQd aJaLQVW WKe VOaXJKWeU Rf PeULW, WR eQVXUe PeULW LPPedLaWe LQTXLU\ VKRXOd beLQLWLaWed aQd WKRVe UeVSRQVLbOe fRU OeaNLQJ WKe SaSeU VKRXOd be KeOd accRXQWabOe. FRU WKe VaNe Rf WKefXWXUe Rf WKRXVaQdV Rf VWXdeQWV, aQ LPSaUWLaO cRPPLWWee VKRXOd be Pade aQd UeVXOWV VKRXOd be ZLWKKeOd174WLOO WKe cRPPLWWee JLYeV LWV fLQaO YeUdLcW aQd eQVXUeV PeULW QRZ aQd LQ fXWXUe. #PdcaWSaSeUOeaN. - YDASLQdK36. We UeMecW WKe ETEA WeVW dXe WR OacN Rf WUaQVSaUeQc\. IW LV a dLVaVWeU LQ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ.#NRMRUeBOXeWRRWKDRcWRUV37. TKe WUaQVSaUeQc\ Rf PaNLVWaQ'V WRS PedLcaO eQWUaQce WeVW KaV beeQ UXLQed fRU WKe SaVW feZ \eaUV. If RXUPRVW LQcRPSeWeQW LQVWLWXWLRQV caQQRW WaNe aQ e[aP SURSeUO\, KRZ ZLOO WKe ZRUOd LQVWLWXWLRQV beOLeYeWKeP? IPSUeVVed SeRSOe dR WKe VaPe WKLQJ. #RecRQdXcWMDCAT2023 #RecRQdXcWETEA2023#RecRQdXcWMDCAT38. UQLYeUVLW\ Rf HeaOWK ScLeQceV VKRXOd deOa\ WKe VXSSOePeQWaU\ SURRf b\ WZR ZeeNV NeeSLQJ LQ YLeZ WKeWLPe ORVV Rf WKe UeVXOW deOa\ Rf WKe VWXdeQWV. DXULQJ KLV RQe-\eaU WeQXUe, LQcRPSeWeQW VLce CKaQceOORUcKaQJed 6 cRQWUROOeU e[aPV. SWXdeQWV ZLWK WKe aQQXaO V\VWeP JR WR cRXUW aJaLQVW WaNLQJ cOaVVeV fURPQe[W \eaU XQdeU WKe PRdXOaU V\VWeP. - PMSUP39. * FLUVW \eaU aQQXaO V\VWeP deWaLQ VWXdeQWV ZLOO be VKLfWed WR PRdXOaU fURP Qe[W \eaU. OQ ZKLcK WKeUeZaV LQWeQVe dLVcXVVLRQ LQ WKe PeeWLQJ abRXW KRZ WKe aQQXaO adPLWWed VWXdeQWV aUe beLQJ VKLfWed WR WKePRdXOaU. We KaYe LQdLcaWed WR JR WR WKe HLJK CRXUW RQ WKLV. - PMSUP40. UHS KaV adRSWed QeZ LPSRUWed SROLc\ "E[aPLQeU TRRONLW" fRU MBBS/BDS SaSeU VeWWLQJ. NeZ SROLcLeVaUe beLQJ LPSOePeQWed ZLWKRXW WaNLQJ aQ\ PedLcaO RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQWR cRQfLdeQce. TKLV LV caXVLQJ VeYeUeaQ[LeW\ aPRQJ WKe VWXdeQWV. We VKRXOd QRW be fRUced WR SURWeVW. - PMSUP17541. We eQdRUVe UHS LaKRUe decLVLRQ WR eQd WKe UROe Rf LQWeUQaO e[aPLQeUV LQ SURfeVVLRQaO e[aPV &cRQdXcWLRQ Rf e[aPV b\ XQbLaVed e[aPLQeUV WR PaLQWaLQ QeXWUaOLW\. IW ZLOO eQd WKe faYRULWLVP & WKeJUXdJeV faced b\ PaQ\ VWXdeQWV. BXW,WKe cRQceUQV abRXW daWe VKeeWV VKRXOd be eQWeUWaLQed. - DWM42. TKe SULYaWe PedLcaO cROOeJeV KaYe LQcUeaVed WKeLU aQQXaO WXLWLRQ fee becaXVe Rf LQfOaWLRQ XS WR WKUeePLOOLRQ SeU aQQXP bXW KaYe QRW LQcUeaVed WKe VWLSeQdV Rf KRXVe RffLceUV, PGR'V, MO'V aQd cOLQLcaOfacXOW\. TKeUe'V QR aXWKRULW\ WR UeJXOaWe WKe LQcUeaVLQJ fee LQ PedLcaO cROOeJeV.- DWM43. We beOLeYe WKaW a XQLYeUVLW\'V PaLQ JRaO LV WR SURYLde edXcaWLRQ WR LWV VWXdeQWV, aORQJ ZLWK aOO QeceVVaU\VXSSRUW. If a VWXdeQW QeedV VRPeWKLQJ, WKe\ caQ aVN WKe deVLJQaWed cOeUN fRU KeOS. HRZeYeU, LW'VabVROXWeO\ ZURQJ fRU a cOeUN, ZKR JeWV SaLd WR ZRUN LQ a XQLYeUVLW\ PeaQW fRU VWXdeQWV' beQefLW, WR KaUPWKRVe YeU\ VWXdeQWV ZKR VXSSRUW WKeLU OLYeOLKRRd. RaLVLQJ a KaQd aJaLQVW VWXdeQWV aQd caXVLQJ WKePKaUP LV VKaPefXO aQd XQacceSWabOe«.. IW'V eVVeQWLaO WR PaNe LW cOeaU WKaW WKe XQLYeUVLW\ e[LVWV fRU WKeZeOO-beLQJ Rf VWXdeQWV, aQd aQ\ PLVWUeaWPeQW Rf WKeP ZLOO QRW be WROeUaWed. We Qeed WR cUeaWe aQeQYLURQPeQW ZKeUe VWXdeQWV dRQ'W OLYe LQ feaU. SWXdeQWV ZeUe VXbMecWed WR RSSUeVVLRQ; WKe\ ZeUe LQMXUedaQd QRW SURYLded ZLWK eVVeQWLaO WKLQJV, aQd LQ WKe eQd, SWXdeQWV ZeUe XQfaLUO\ VXVSeQded. TKLV LV WKeSeaN Rf cUXeOW\. TKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ VKRXOd KaYe fLUVW fLUed WKaW cOeUN LQVWead Rf WaNLQJ dLVcLSOLQaU\acWLRQ aJaLQVW WKe VWXdeQW. - YDA SLQdK44. YDA PXQMab: A deOeJaWLRQ Rf YDA PXQMab Oed b\ PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab SaUWLcLSaWed LQ WKe SURWeVWRXWVLde LaKRUe PUeVV COXb aJaLQVW WKe aUUeVW Rf WeacKeUV aQd WKe cUXeOW\ aQd baUbaULVP Rf JRYeUQPeQWePSOR\eeV«..AddUeVVLQJ WKe SURWeVW, PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab VaLd WKaW WeacKeUV aUe WKe aUcKLWecWV Rf WKeQaWLRQ ZLWKRXW ZKRP VRcLeW\ caQ QeYeU deYeORS. We VWaQd ZLWK WKe UeVSecW aQd ULJKWV Rf WeacKeUV aQddecOaUe WKaW Lf ZRUN ZLWKLQ 48 KRXUV LV QRW UeVSecWed b\ aOO WeacKeUV aQd a KLJK OeYeO cRPPLWWee LV QRWfRUPed WR aSSURYe dePaQdV.17645. PUeVLdeQW YDA BALOCHISTAN OeWWeU WR WKe SecUeWaU\ Rf WKe HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW Rf BaORcKLVWaQ ZLWK WKeVXbMecW "PURSRVaO fRU eQKaQcLQJ MedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ aQd COLQLcaO SNLOOV LQ BaORcKLVWaQ" , UeTXeVWLQJ KLPWR SURYLde FLQaQcLaO VXSSRUW fRU OYeUVeaV COLQLcaO EOecWLYeV WR WKe UQdeUJUadXaWe SWXdeQWV SXUVXLQJMedLcaO EdXcaWLRQ LQ WKe PXbOLc SecWRU MedLcaO CROOeJeV Rf BaORcKLVWaQ aQd PRVWJUadXaWe ReVLdeQWVZRUNLQJ LQ WKe PXbOLc SecWRU HRVSLWaOV Rf BaORcKLVWaQ. #MedLcaOEdXcaWLRQ #\daBaORcKLVWaQ#BaORcKLVWaQHeaOWKcaUe.46. AfWeU decadeV, MCPS WUaLQLQJ SROLc\ KaV beeQ UedeVLJQed aV QRWLfLed, LW ZLOO be ceQWUaOL]ed aQd WKeUeZLOO be PeULW baVed LQdXcWLRQ OLNe FCPS, LW ZLOO be SaLd aOVR. - DWM47. YDA KPK deOeJaWe PeW ZLWK KRQRUabOe HeaOWK MLQLVWeU UeJaUdLQJ UQ LQdXcWeeV/OefWRYeU caQdLdaWeV. HeZLOO caOO a PeeWLQJ afWeU WKe aUULYaO Rf CEO PGMI fURP HaMM ZLWKLQ a feZ da\V . He aVVXUed KLV fXOOVXSSRUW aQd SURPLVed WR VROYe WKLV LVVXe..48. YDA PXQMab: TKe YDA PXQMab VWURQJO\ cRQdePQV WKe aUbLWUaU\ acWLRQV aQd cRQVWaQWLPSOePeQWaWLRQ Rf QeZ SROLcLeV b\ WKe fRUPeU Head COeUN Rf WKe X HRVSLWaO LaKRUe, ZKR, WKURXJKUecRPPeQdaWLRQ, KaV WaNeQ cRQWURO Rf PXQMab'V OaUJeVW PedLcaO XQLYeUVLW\, ZKLcK LV cRQQecWed WR WKefXWXUe Rf PLOOLRQV Rf dRcWRUV, aQd LV cXUUeQWO\ WKe VLce CKaQceOORU Rf WKe UQLYeUVLW\ Rf HeaOWK ScLeQceVLaKRUe. HLVWRU\ LV a ZLWQeVV WKaW ZKeQeYeU XQTXaOLfLed SeRSOe aUe LPSRVed RQ aQ LQVWLWXWLRQ b\JRLQJ aJaLQVW PeULW, WKe UeVXOW KaV beeQ caWaVWURSKLc. TKLV LV WKe cRQdLWLRQ Rf LQVWLWXWLRQV WaNLQJ MBBSe[aPV aOO RYeU PXQMab fRU VRPe WLPe. TKe LQdLYLdXaO KaV LVVXed a QeZ QRWLfLcaWLRQ, bOaWaQWO\dLVUeJaUdLQJ WKe SROLcLeV Rf WKe GRYeUQPeQW Rf PXQMab, accRUdLQJ WR ZKLcK aQ\RQe ZKR deVLUeV WReQKaQce WKeLU edXcaWLRQaO VWaQdaUdV b\ SXUVXLQJ aQ MPKLO RU PKD PXVW fLUVW becRPe XQePSOR\ed. "ANLQJdRP Rf daUNQeVV XQdeU cKaRWLc UXOe." We TXeVWLRQ WKe PKaUaRK VeaWed RQ WKe VLce CKaQceOORU'VcKaLU: If aOO cadUeV aUe aOORZed WR LPSURYe WKeLU edXcaWLRQaO TXaOLfLcaWLRQV ZKLOe UeWaLQLQJ WKeLU MRbV,177WKeQ ZKaW faXOW OLeV ZLWK WKe dRcWRUV? We dePaQd fURP WKe HeaOWK MLQLVWeU Rf PXQMab, PURfeVVRU DU.JaYed ANUaP, WR WaNe LPPedLaWe acWLRQ WR cKaQJe WKLV SROLc\ aQd WR LQLWLaWe aQ LQTXLU\ aJaLQVW WKe VLceCKaQceOORU WR deWeUPLQe XQdeU ZKRVe LQfOXeQce Ke LV UXQQLQJ WKe LQVWLWXWLRQ accRUdLQJ WR KLV RZQZKLPV. OWKeUZLVe, dRcWRUV acURVV PXQMab ZLOO SURWeVW YLJRURXVO\."49. TZR RffLcLaOV fURP WKe DeSaUWPeQW Rf HeaOWK aUe fLJKWLQJ ZLWK eacK RWKeU WR eVWabOLVK WKeLU aXWKRULW\ aWX HRVSLWaO aQd Y UQLYeUVLW\ Rf MedLcaO aQd HeaOWK ScLeQceV. BRWK aUe NeeQ WR VKRZcaVe WKeLULQcRPSOeWe WaVNV. SLJQLfLcaQW daPaJe KaV aOUead\ beeQ dRQe WR WKe KRVSLWaO aQd WKe XQLYeUVLW\, ZLWKPeULW QRZKeUe LQ VLJKW. PaWLeQWV aUe QRW beLQJ SURYLded ZLWK PedLcaWLRQV, WKeUe aUe defLcLeQcLeV LQVecXULW\, aQd WKe VecXULW\ WeQdeUV KaYe beeQ RddO\ aVVLJQed WR TXeVWLRQabOe LQdLYLdXaOV ZKR aUeVXSSRVed WR eQVXUe WKe VafeW\ Rf XV dRcWRUV.TKe cXUUeQW adPLQLVWUaWLRQ LV WKUeaWeQLQJ dRcWRUV aQd SRVWJUadXaWeV (PGV), ZaUQLQJ WKaW Lf WKe\ VSeaNRXW, WKe\ ZLOO be aSSUeKeQded b\ WKe LQVWLWXWLRQV aQd UXVWLcaWed. IV WKLV a XQLYeUVLW\ RU VRPe baQaQaUeSXbOLc? MaQ\ dRcWRUV LQWeQd WR OeaYe WKe KRVSLWaO, aQd VeYeUaO facXOW\ PePbeUV aOVR SOaQ WR TXLW WKeLUMRbV becaXVe WKe\ dR QRW ZaQW WR ZRUN LQ WKe cXUUeQW cRQdLWLRQV Rf LUMHS. BRWK WKe cXUUeQW aQd SUeYLRXVadPLQLVWUaWLRQV KaYe WKe VaPe aJeQda, ZKLcK LV RQO\ fRcXVed RQ VeOf-SURPRWLRQ aQd adYaQcePeQW.We UeTXeVW BLOaZaO BKXWWR aQd WKe CKLef MLQLVWeU Rf SLQdK WR NLQdO\ LQWeUYeQe aQd UeVROYe WKLV LVVXe. WeaOVR aSSeaO WR WKe SXSUePe CRXUW WR WaNe VXR-PRWR acWLRQ. DXe WR WKeLU cRQfOLcW, a KaUdZRUNLQJ dRcWRU KaVdLed, a UeVXOW Rf WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ'V SUeVVXUe aQd WKUeaWV. If WKLV LV WKe WUeaWPeQW PeWed RXW WR aQadPLQLVWUaWRU, LPaJLQe ZKaW WKe RUdLQaU\ dRcWRUV aQd ZRUNLQJ VWaff PXVW be eQdXULQJ.YDA SLQdK17850. X CROOeJe LV LPSRVLQJ KeaY\ fLQeV RQ VWXdeQWV eYeU\ \eaU deVSLWe aWWeQdaQce beLQJ PRUe WKaQ 75% aQdZLWKRXW aQ\ SULRU QRWLce. TKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ dReV WKLV befRUe fLQaOL]LQJ adPLVVLRQV WR UHS, MXVW WR PaNePRQe\.We UeTXeVW SLU @MaNUaPaLPc WR WaNe acWLRQ.- DWM51. YDA DeUa GKa]L KKaQ/ PXQMab: DXe WR WKe LQcRPSeWeQce Rf WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ LQ a TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO,a SaWLeQW adPLWWed WR WKe ICU ORVW WKeLU OLfe dXe WR aQ R[\JeQ c\OLQdeU e[SORVLRQ. YDA DeUa GKa]L KKaQLV VaddeQed b\ WKLV WUaJLc LQcLdeQW aQd VWURQJO\ cRQdePQV WKLV adPLQLVWUaWLYe LQcRPSeWeQce.A SaWLeQW LVbeLQJ VKLfWed WR LaKRUe fRU WUeaWPeQW LQ VeULRXV cRQdLWLRQ.DXe WR WKe LQcRPSeWeQW adPLQLVWUaWLRQ, WKe KRVSLWaO KaV becRPe a deaWK WUaS. TRda\, WKe YDA KeOd aQePeUJeQc\ SUeVV cRQfeUeQce aQd dePaQded WKe MLQLVWeU Rf HeaOWK WR LPPedLaWeO\ UePRYe/WeUPLQaWe WKLVLQcRPSeWeQW aQd cRUUXSW SULQcLSaO fURP RffLce aQd eVWabOLVK a KLJK-OeYeO LQTXLU\ cRPPLWWee WR cRQdXcW aWUaQVSaUeQW LQYeVWLJaWLRQ LQWR WKLV PaWWeU aQd bULQJ WKRVe UeVSRQVLbOe WR MXVWLce.IW LV LPSRVVLbOe WR KaYe a cOeaQ aQd WUaQVSaUeQW LQTXLU\ XQdeU WKe WeQXUe Rf WKLV SULQcLSaO becaXVe WKLV LVWKe WKLUd LQcLdeQW LQ WKe OaVW WKUee \eaUV ZKeUe deaWKV KaYe RccXUUed dXe WR adPLQLVWUaWLYeLQcRPSeWeQce.TKUee \eaUV aJR, SaWLeQWV dLed dXe WR WKe ceVVaWLRQ Rf R[\JeQ VXSSO\.AfWeUZaUdV, WKe SRZeU VXSSO\ ZaV LQWeUUXSWed LQ WKe ICU, aQd fRU VL[ KRXUV, dRcWRUV aQd VWaff SURYLdedaUWLfLcLaO UeVSLUaWLRQ WR WKe SaWLeQWV RQ WKeLU RZQ, ZKLOe WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ UePaLQed VLOeQW VSecWaWRUV.TKLV LQTXLU\ aOVR \LeOded QR UeVXOWV.NRZ, a c\OLQdeU e[SORded LQ WKe NeSKURORJ\ ZaUd.A PaQ QaUURZO\ eVcaSed deaWK afWeU a OLfW aW WKe WUaXPa ceQWeU PaOfXQcWLRQed a ZeeN aJR.AQ HWC cabOe ZRUWK 8 PLOOLRQ fURP WKe QeZ bXLOdLQJ ZaV VWROeQ. NR UeVXOW Rf LWV LQYeVWLJaWLRQ eLWKeU.EacK WLPe, aQ LQQRceQW MXQLRU dRcWRU LV Pade a VcaSeJRaW aQd dLVPLVVed fURP WKeLU MRb. NRZ, WKeSaWLeQce Rf \RXQJ dRcWRUV KaV UeacKed LWV OLPLW. IW LV cUXcLaO WR UePRYe/WeUPLQaWe WKe SULQcLSaO fURP KLV179SRVLWLRQ befRUe cRYeULQJ XS WKLV adPLQLVWUaWLYe LQcRPSeWeQce, aQd Ze ZLOO SURWeVW aV PXcK aV QeceVVaU\fRU WKLV dePaQd.YDA DeUa GKa]L KKaQ dePaQdV WKe WeUPLQaWLRQ Rf WKe SULQcLSaO aQd aQ LPPedLaWe WUaQVSaUeQW LQTXLU\WKeUeafWeU, aQd XQWLO RXU dePaQdV aUe PeW, Ze aQQRXQce aQ RXWdRRU (OPD) VWULNe.YDA DeUa GKa]L KKaQ/ PXQMab52. YDA KPK #YDA_DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ (DIK): #PURfeVVLRQaO_Wa[ TKe dedXcWLRQ Rf SURfeVVLRQaO Wa[ KaVbeeQ VWa\ed b\ WKe KRQRUabOe PeVKaZaU HLJK CRXUW, bXW LURQLcaOO\, WKe E[cLVe aQd Ta[aWLRQ DeSaUWPeQWDIK LV KaUaVVLQJ, bOacNPaLOLQJ, aQd WKUeaWeQLQJ WKe FLQaQce DeSaUWPeQW Rf MedLcaO TeacKLQJ IQVWLWXWeV(MTI) DIK. TKe\ LQVLVW WKaW \RX PXVW dedXcW WKe 'WKXJ Wa[' fURP aOO dRcWRUV ZRUNLQJ aW MTI DIK,RWKeUZLVe WKe\ ZLOO aUUeVW \RX, deWaLQ KRVSLWaO aPbXOaQceV, aQd aUUeVW dRcWRUV. IW LV a JUeaW VKaPe RQWKe SaUW Rf WKe E[cLVe aQd Ta[aWLRQ DIK. IW LV a ORXd aQd cOeaU PeVVaJe WR WKe E[cLVe aQd Ta[aWLRQDeSaUWPeQW DI KKaQ, WKaW fLUVW Rf aOO, \RX aUe cRPPLWWLQJ cRQWePSW Rf cRXUW b\ VXcK acWLRQV, aQdVecRQdO\, Ze ZLOO QRW aOORZ VXcK 'WKXJ Wa[.' YDA KPK VWaQdV ZLWK WKe dRcWRUV cRPPXQLW\ Rf DI KKaQaQd YDA DIK aQd ZLOO eQdRUVe eYeU\ decLVLRQ Rf YDA DIK fRU dRcWRUV' dLJQLW\. IW KaV cRPe WR RXUQRWLce WKaW SeRSOe fURP WKe e[cLVe deSaUWPeQW KaYe cRPe WR WKe KRVSLWaO PXOWLSOe WLPeV WR WKUeaWeQ WKeFD fRU WKe 'WKXJ Wa[.' IW LV a ORXd aQd cOeaU PeVVaJe WKaW aOO dRcWRUV Rf MTI DIK VWaQd ZLWK FD aQd ZLOOVXSSRUW KLP aW eYeU\ VWeS. If aQ\ PLVKaS RccXUV, WKeQ WKe DHQ aQd X TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO ZLOO be cORVedaW WKaW PRPeQW XQWLO MXVWLce LV VeUYed aQd QR VeUYLceV ZLOO be SURYLded. OQO\ WKe E[cLVe DeSaUWPeQW DIKKaQ ZLOO be UeVSRQVLbOe fRU aOO WKe VXffeULQJ Rf WKe SRRU SeRSOe Rf DI KKaQ.53. DU. A RSeQed aQ LOOeJaO cOLQLc LQ LaUNaQa aQd VWaUWed WeOOLQJ KXPaQ OLYeV. DXe WR ZURQJ WUeaWPeQW, PaQ\SaWLeQWV beJaQ WR VXffeU fURP YaULRXV dLVeaVeV aQd AWa\L becaPe a VXUJeRQ aQd LV RSeUaWLQJ SUeJQaQWZRPeQ b\ JLYLQJ aQeVWKeVLa PedLcLQeV. SRPe WLPe aJR, a SeUVRQ ORVW WKe baWWOe Rf OLfe dXULQJ WKeRSeUaWLRQ. BXW WKe Vad WKLQJ LV WKaW WLOO daWe, QeLWKeU SLQdK GRYeUQPeQW, HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW QRU HeaOWK180CRPPLVVLRQ KaV WaNeQ aQ\ acWLRQ««. YDA SLQdK ASSeaO WR WKe SLQdK JRYeUQPeQW aQd RWKeUdeSaUWPeQWV WKaW VXcK a PafLa LV acWLYe aOO RYeU SLQdK. TaNe VWULcW acWLRQ aJaLQVW WKeP aQd VaYe WKe OLYeVRf SRRU SeRSOe. YDA SLQdK54. YDA PXQMab: UQdeU WKe OeadeUVKLS Rf YDA PXQMab«.. MeW ZLWK HeaOWK MLQLVWeU PXQMab fRU PULPaU\SecRQdaU\ aQd AddLWLRQaO SecUeWaU\ PULPaU\ SecRQdaU\ HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW. IQ WKe PeeWLQJ, WKefROORZLQJ ZeUe dLVcXVVed LQ deWaLO:TKe aSSURYed HeaOWK PURfeVVLRQaO AOORZaQce, deWaLOV WKe XQdXe deOa\ LQ SeUfRUPaQce LQdLcaWRUV aQd WKeaWPRVSKeUe Rf aQJeU aQd dLVWUXVW fRXQd LQ WKe cRPPXQLW\«« TKe YDA WeaP bULefed WKe SURbOePV LQ WKeKRVSLWaO aQd WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ VSecLaOO\ MS THQ KaPaOLa'V SKaUaRK aQd dePaQded KLV UePRYaO fURPWKe SRVW««DeVSLWe WKe YacaQcLeV LQ NaQNaQa SaKLb SKeLNKXSXUa aQd KaVXU, WKe VWaff VKRUWaJe LQ WKeKRVSLWaO LV caXVLQJ VeYeUe dLffLcXOWLeV LQ WUeaWPeQW.55. FUee PedLcaO facLOLWLeV aUe beLQJ WaNeQ aZa\ fURP SRRU SeRSOe LQ KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZaSWRS bOacNPaLOLQJ RQ KeaOWK facLOLW\ caUdV WRda\. TKe SROLc\ Rf SURYLdLQJ facLOLWLeV WR SRRU SeRSOe RQKeaOWK facLOLW\ caUdV 24 KRXUV RQO\ LQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV VKRXOd be adRSWed aQd WKe facLOLW\ Rf KeaOWKcaUd LQ aOO SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV VKRXOd be abROLVKed LPPedLaWeO\. OQO\ WKe WUeaWPeQW Rf WKRVe dLVeaVeV VKRXOdbe aOORZed RQ WKe HeaOWK FacLOLW\ CaUd ZKLcK aUe QRW SURYLded LQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV.HeaOWK facLOLW\ caUd PaLQ LV beLQJ aZaUded WR SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV. BeQefLWV Rf 46 bLOOLRQ UXSeeV RXW Rf 52bLOOLRQ UXSeeV KaYe beeQ JLYeQ WR SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV. WKaW LV WKe UeaVRQ WKaW WKe KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW LVZaVWLQJ SXbOLc Wa[ PRQe\ RQ SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV???? WKeUe aUe WKeVe bLOOLRQV Rf UXSeeV JRLQJ aQdZK\?????? WK\ aUe WKeVe bLOOLRQV Rf UXSeeV beLQJ beQefLWed WR WKeVe SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV?????? DeVSLWe WKe181WUeaWPeQW facLOLWLeV LQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV, KRZ ZeUe 133 SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV SURYLded??? WK\ LV SRRUWUeaWPeQW aQd VXbVWaQdaUd PedLcLQeV beLQJ JLYeQ WR SaWLeQWV???TKeUe LV QR cKecN aQd baOaQce fURP WKeJRYeUQPeQW aQd WKe KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW, QR TXeVWLRQLQJ, ZK\???If WKeVe 48 KRVSLWaOV dLd QRW KaYe VWaQdaUd facLOLWLeV, WKeQ ZK\ aQd WR ZKRP KaYe WKe\ beeQ SaLd bLOOLRQVRf UXSeeV b\ UeJLVWeULQJ RQ WKe caUd fRU a \eaU???? WKaW acWLRQ KaV beeQ WaNeQ aJaLQVW WKeP aQd WKecRQWUacWRUV JLYeQ WR WKeP??? HaV WKe UeTXLUed PRQe\ beeQ WaNeQ bacN fURP WKeP aQd deSRVLWed LQ WKeQaWLRQaO WUeaVXU\???TKeUe LV QR cKecN aQd baOaQce V\VWeP Rf WKe HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW WR LQTXLUe abRXW WKe PRQNe\ dLVWULbXWLRQLQ MTI KRVSLWaOV LQcOXdLQJ HeaOWK FacLOLW\ CaUd PURJUaP, HeaOWK FRXQdaWLRQ, HeaOWKcaUe CRPPLVVLRQ RUVLOeQce KaV beeQ NeSW RQ Va\LQJ aQ\WKLQJ???? BLOOLRQV Rf UXSeeV aUe JRLQJ fURP WKe JRYeUQPeQW WUeaVXU\aQd WKe SeRSOe aUe ZaLWLQJ fRU WUeaWPeQW, ZK\?? UQWLO ZKeQ???IW VKRXOd KaYe KaSSeQed WKaW Lf WKe dLVeaVeV fRU ZKLcK ZeUe QRW WUeaWed LQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV, WKeQ WKe\ZRXOd KaYe beeQ WUeaWed LQ SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV. WKaW LV WKe UeaVRQ WKaW LQVWead Rf SURYLdLQJ facLOLWLeV WRJRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV, SULYaWe KRVSLWaOV aUe beLQJ aZaUded??? HeaOWK caUdV ZeUe JLYeQ WR faYRULWeKRVSLWaOV b\ bXdJeWLQJ. AQd VXcK KRVSLWaOV ZeUe JLYeQ ZKeUe WKe\ dRQ'W eYeQ KaYe WKeLU RZQ dRcWRUV aQdWKe\ dRQ'W KaYe aQ\ VWaQdaUdV. SWUeeW cRacK KRVSLWaOV KaYe aOVR beeQ JLYeQ WKLV facLOLW\ MXVW fRU WKeLUcRPPLVVLRQ. TKLV V\VWeP VKRXOd be WeUPLQaWed LPPedLaWeO\. AOO WKe KeaOWK caUd PRQe\ aQd WUeaWPeQWfacLOLWLeV VKRXOd be JLYeQ WR JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV. IQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV, aOO facLOLWLeV ZeUe SURYLdedabVROXWeO\ fUee befRUe WKLV V\VWeP. PDA56. YDA BaORcKLVWaQ:QXeWWa: CT VcaQ, MRI aQd caWK Oab PacKLQeV Rf BROaQ MedLcaO CRPSOe[ HRVSLWaO QXeWWa QRW beLQJ182UeSaLUed VLQce WKe OaVW WZR aQd a KaOf \eaUV LV a cOeaU SURRf Rf WKe LQcRPSeWeQce Rf WKe KRVSLWaOadPLQLVWUaWLRQ aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW.SSRNeVSeUVRQ YRXQJ DRcWRUVQXeWWa: ScaUcLW\ Rf PedLcLQeV LQ BaORcKLVWaQ'V JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV, SRRU VecXULW\ VLWXaWLRQ aQdPaOfXQcWLRQLQJ Rf PacKLQeU\ KaYe beeQ UeSRUWed b\ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ PaQ\ WLPeV WR WKe KLJKeUaXWKRULWLeV, bXW fRU WKe OaVW WZR aQd a KaOf \eaUV aOO WKeVe SURbOePV KaYe QRW beeQ VROYed VeULRXVO\.KaUQa, WKe LQVeQVLWLYLW\ Rf WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ aQd WKe JRYeUQPeQW LV cOeaUO\ YLVLbOe.SSRNeVSeUVRQ YRXQJ DRcWRUVQXeWWa: CaWK Oab, CT VcaQ aQd MRI PacKLQeV LQ BROaQ MedLcaO CRPSOe[ HRVSLWaO QXeWWa aUePaOfXQcWLRQLQJ VLQce OaVW WZR aQd KaOf \eaUV aQd LQcRPSeWeQW adPLQLVWUaWLRQ LV QRW VeULRXV aW aOO WRUeSaLU WKeP, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ dePaQdV adPLQLVWUaWLRQ aQd JRYeUQPeQW LeW'V JeW aOO WKRVe PacKLQeVUeSaLUed aV VRRQ aV SRVVLbOe WR facLOLWaWe WKe facLOLW\ fRU SaWLeQWV aQd dRcWRUV.SSRNeVSeUVRQ YRXQJ DRcWRUVSSRNeVSeUVRQ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ57. YDA SLQdK cRPSOeWeO\ UeMecWV LQWeUYLeZV WaNeQ b\ SPSC Rf deQWaO VXUJeRQV aQd dePaQdV Ue-LQWeUYLeZVZLWK WUaQVSaUeQW LQTXLU\..! HRZ ORQJ ZLOO WKLV LQVWLWXWLRQ cRQWLQXe WR SOa\ ZLWK WKe fXWXUe Rf RXU \RXWKaQd KRZ ORQJ ZLOO SeRSOe be \eaUQLQJ fRU PeULW...!OQ RQe KaQd, WKeUe LV aOUead\ VeYeUe LQMXVWLce ZLWK deQWaO VXUJeRQV. 50 VeaWV ZeUe NeSW, RXW Rf ZKLcKWZR VeaWV ZeUe cXW, caQdLdaWeV ZKR VcRUed PRUe WKaQ 90 PaUNV ZeUe aOVR faLOed. OQ WKe RWKeU KaQd,2900 caQdLdaWeV fRU 50 VeaWV aSSeaUed LQ WKe WeVW. HaSSeQed...!If WKe GRYeUQPeQW Rf SLQdK KaV WR KXPLOLaWe deQWaO VXUJeRQV OLNe WKLV, WKeQ aOO SULYaWe cROOeJeV VKRXOd be183abROLVKed aQd WKLV deJUee VKRXOd be NeSW OLPLWed RU JLYe ePSOR\PeQW RSSRUWXQLWLeV WR deQWaO VXUJeRQV. -YDA SLQdK58. DXULQJ a SUeVV cRQfeUeQce, PUeVLdeQW YDA X HRVSLWaO LaKRUe ZaV aVNed ZKeWKeU UeWLUed SeRSOe ZLOOcRQWLQXe WR be SRVWed LQ X HRVSLWaO aJaLQ aQd aJaLQ LQ WKe DeSaUWPeQW Rf SSecLaOL]ed HeaOWK. OQ ZKLcKPUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab aQd PUeVLdeQW Rf X HRVSLWaO bRWK Kad WKe VaPe VWaQd WR SURWeVW VWURQJO\ aJaLQVWJLYLQJ cRQWUacWV WR DU. A RU RWKeU UeWLUed SeRSOe LQ aQ\ caVe. We ZLVK WR ZaUQ WKe DeSaUWPeQW Rf HeaOWKWR UefUaLQ fURP WKe adYeQWXUe Rf ePSOR\LQJ UeWLUed SURfeVVRUV LQ aQ\ caVe aQd eQVXUe aSSRLQWPeQW RfQeZ SURfeVVRUV b\ RUJaQL]LQJ deSaUWPeQWaO SURPRWLRQ cRPPLWWee PeeWLQJV aV VRRQ aV SRVVLbOe.OWKeUZLVe WKeUe ZLOO be a VWURQJ UeacWLRQ WR WKLV aOO RYeU PXQMab.«59. YDA SLQdK GeQeUaO VecUeWaU\ aORQJ ZLWK a WeaP PeW ZLWK KeaOWK RffLcLaOV, Ze aUe JUaWefXO fRU WKeWLUeOeVV effRUWV Pade b\ WKe KeaOWK PLQLVWeU «« aORQJ ZLWK VecWLRQ RffLceU C1 aQd C2 aQd WKe ZKROeWeaP ZKR KaYe dedLcaWed WKePVeOYeV WR SURPRWLQJ dRcWRUV ZLWKLQ RXU cRPPXQLW\. TKaQNV WR WKeLU KaUdZRUN, WKe da\ KaV fLQaOO\ cRPe ZKeQ PaQ\ deVeUYLQJ dRcWRUV aUe JeWWLQJ SURPRWed««HRZeYeU, ZePXVW aOVR UeTXeVW WKe dRcWRUV LQ JUade 17 aQd 18, ZKR KaYe QRW \eW VXbPLWWed WKeLU AQQXaO CRQfLdeQWLaOReSRUWV (ACR), ZKLcK aUe cUXcLaO fRU WKeLU SURPRWLRQV, WR dR VR SURPSWO\. TKLV ZLOO eQVXUe WKaW WKeLUMXQLRUV ZRQ'W be SURPRWed aKead Rf WKeP, aQd WKe\ UeceLYe WKeLU ULJKWfXO SURPRWLRQ. IQ WKLV cUXcLaOSURceVV, Ze LQYLWe YROXQWeeU dRcWRUV WR cRPe fRUZaUd aQd aVVLVW aW WKe SLQdK SecUeWaULaW, KeOSLQJ WRfXOfLOO WKe UeTXLUePeQWV QeceVVaU\ fRU dRcWRUV' SURPRWLRQV. WLWK WKeLU VXSSRUW, Ze caQ eQVXUe a VSeed\cRPSOeWLRQ Rf WKe SURPRWLRQ SURceVV aQd JXaUaQWee WKaW aOO deVeUYLQJ dRcWRUV JeW WKeLU ZeOO-eaUQedSURPRWLRQV. TRJeWKeU, Ze caQ fRVWeU a VWURQJ aQd PRWLYaWed PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ WKaW cRQWLQXeV WRSURYLde e[ceOOeQW KeaOWKcaUe VeUYLceV WR WKe SeRSOe - YDA SLQdK.18460. QXeWWa: CRQceUQV aUe beLQJ e[SUeVVed RYeU WKe QRQ-UeOeaVe Rf VWLSeQdV fRU SRVWJUadXaWe WUaLQeeV aQdKRXVe RffLceUV LQ QXeWWa. DeVSLWe SURYLdLQJ aOO WKe QeceVVaU\ daWa WR WKe HeaOWK aQd FLQaQceDeSaUWPeQWV, WKe FLQaQce DeSaUWPeQW UePaLQV RbVWLQaWe, QeLWKeU UeOeaVLQJ WKe SaVW dXeV QRU VKRZLQJLQWeUeVW LQ UeJXOaUL]LQJ WKe VWLSeQdV, ZKLcK LV WaQWaPRXQW WR RSSUeVVLRQ aQd KRVWLOLW\ WRZaUdV dRcWRUV. AcaVe LV RQJRLQJ LQ WKe BaORcKLVWaQ HLJK CRXUW WR UeJXOaUL]e WKeVe VWLSeQdV, aQd LQ WKLV UeJaUd, acRPPLWWee cRPSULVLQJ DU. 1 «. DU. 9 KaV beeQ fRUPed XQdeU WKe OeadeUVKLS Rf \RXQJ dRcWRUV WRadYRcaWe fRU WKLV caXVe. TKe YDA BaORcKLVWaQ dePaQdV WKaW WKe eVWeePed CKLef JXVWLce Rf BaORcKLVWaQHLJK CRXUW, WKe CKLef MLQLVWeU Rf BaORcKLVWaQ, WKe HeaOWK SecUeWaU\, aQd WKe FLQaQce SecUeWaU\ WaNeQRWLce Rf WKLV LVVXe aQd UeJXOaUL]e WKe VWLSeQdV. SSRNeVSeUVRQ YRXQJ DRcWRUV61. YDA PXQMab: TKeUe LV a cRPSOeWe RXWdRRU VWULNe VLQce OaVW 12 da\V LQ DHQ HRVSLWaO X UeJaUdLQJaSSRLQWPeQW Rf QRQ-UeOLJLRXV, LOOeJaO aQd SUefeUUed SULQcLSaO. DeVSLWe QeJRWLaWLRQV aQd aVVXUaQce fURPaOO WKe RUdeUV, QR SUacWLcaO acWLRQ KaV beeQ WaNeQ \eW.. TKeUefRUe, Ze aQQRXQce WKaW Lf WKLV SULQcLSaO LVQRW UePRYed fURP KLV SRVW ZLWKLQ 48 KRXUV, WKe VcRSe Rf WKe SURWeVW ZLOO be JUadXaOO\ VSUead acURVVLaKRUe fLUVW aQd WKeQ acURVV PXQMab. We VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKe OacN Rf VaOaULeV Rf dRcWRUV aQdVXSSRUW VWaff LQ HRVSLWaO Z, LaKRUe VLQce WZR PRQWKV aQd fXOO\ VXSSRUW WKe RQJRLQJ SURWeVWV fURP WKeSOaWfRUP Rf GUaQd HeaOWK AOOLaQce. We dePaQd WKe fedeUaO PLQLVWeU Rf KeaOWK WR UeOeaVe a bXdJeW fRU fXOOfRXU VaOaULeV RWKeUZLVe WUeaWPeQW LQ RWKeU KRVSLWaOV ZLOO be affecWed badO\.. YDA PXQMab KaV a cOeaUVWaQd RQ bLRPeWULc aWWeQdaQce aQd QR dRcWRU ZLOO aWWeQd bLRPeWULc aWWeQdaQce LQ aQ\ caVe XQWLO WKedePaQdV aUe aSSURYed. If aQ\ MS RU CEO WULeV WR KaUaVV aQ\ dRcWRU XVLQJ WKe SUeWe[W Rf bLRPeWULcV, KeZLOO be SXQLVKed.. CeQWUaO IQdXcWLRQ PROLc\ VKRXOd be Pade cRPSUeKeQVLYe aQd e[SOLcLW aQd aW WKeULJKW WLPe WKe QXPbeU Rf VeaWV VKRXOd be LQcUeaVed LQVWead Rf QeZ e[SeULPeQWV. DRcWRUV ZRUNLQJ RQAdKRc VKRXOd be UeJXOaUL]ed aQd JLYeQ a V\VWeP XQdeU ZKLcK WKe UeJXOaUL]aWLRQ SURceVV caQ be VWaUWedaV VRRQ aV SRVVLbOe. DLVcULPLQaWLRQ ZLWK dRcWRUV ZRUNLQJ LQ PHFMC VKRXOd be VWRSSed aQd WKe\VKRXOd aOVR be SaLd eTXaO WR UeJXOaU PedLcaO RffLceUV. MaQ\ SURPLVeV KaYe beeQ Pade UeJaUdLQJ185HeaOWK PURfeVVLRQaO AOORZaQce aQd Ke\ PeUfRUPaQce IQdLcaWRUV aQd PaQ\ cRQVWeOOaWLRQV KaYe beeQJLYeQ. NRZ LW LV WLPe WR VWaUW a decLVLYe VWUXJJOe fRU RXU ULJKWV. IQ WKLV UeJaUd, YDA PXQMab OcWRbeUGRLQJ WR KROd a GUaQd CRQYeQWLRQ aW SeUYLceV HRVSLWaO LQ WKe fLUVW ZeeN Rf ZKLcK RUJaQL]aWLRQaOSRVLWLRQV fURP acURVV PaNLVWaQ ZLOO SaUWLcLSaWe aQd aQQRXQce a QaWLRQZLde PRYePeQW ZLWK MRLQW acWLRQ..AfWeU WKe SUeVV cRQfeUeQce, WKe RffLce Rf YDA PXQMab, PeW ZLWK VLce CKaQceOORU KLQJ EdZaUdMedLcaO UQLYeUVLW\ PURfeVVRU MeKPRRd A\a] aQd SaVVed WKe bLOO WR deOLYeU WKe fLQaQcLaO SacNaJe Rf DU.NaVeeP SKaKeed WR KLV VXcceVVRUV. SWa\ XQLWed... SWa\ VWURQJ aQd VWURQJ..62. A deOeJaWLRQ Rf YDA SLQdK DePRcUaWV YLVLWed HRVSLWaO J. DXULQJ WKe YLVLW WR WKe KRVSLWaO, WKe\e[SUeVVed VROLdaULW\ ZLWK KRXVe RffLceUV aQd SRVW JUadXaWeV. AdYRcaWed fRU LPPedLaWe UeOeaVe RfVaOaULeV Rf KLV cROOeaJXeV aORQJ ZLWK dRcWRUV Rf HRVSLWaO J. PURWeVWV b\ HRVSLWaO J¶V dRcWRUV ZLOOcRQWLQXe WLOO WKeLU OeJLWLPaWe VaOaULeV aUe dLVWULbXWed. TKe eQWLUe YDA SLQdK OeadeUVKLS VWaQdV ZLWK WKePLQ JUeaW VROLdaULW\. TKe dLUecWRU aQd PedLcaO VXSeULQWeQdeQW KaV aVVXUed VaOaULeV Rf KRXVe RffLceUVZLWKLQ a ZeeN. FXUWKeU, WKe dRcWRUV Rf HRVSLWaO R, aSSeaOed fRU eTXaOLW\ LQ WKeLU UePXQeUaWLRQ, aQdVXbPLWWed a UeTXeVW WR WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ WR LQcUeaVe WKeLU VaOaULeV b\ RV.104,000, aV SeU WKe UaWeV RfRWKeU KRVSLWaOV LQ SLQdK.63. YDA X, MaUdaQ/KPK: TRda\ YDA X , MaUdaQ LQ aVVRcLaWLRQ ZLWK SaUaPedLcV aVVRcLaWLRQ,QXUVLQJ aQdVWaQdaUd IV aVVRcLaWLRQ SURWeVWed aJaLQVW QRQ-Sa\PeQW Rf VaOaULeV aQd bORcNed WKe PaLQ NRZVKeUaRRad. TKe VaOaULeV Rf aOO WKe facXOW\, KRXVe RffLceUV aQd RWKeU KeaOWK ePSOR\eeV Rf X MedLcaO CRPSOe[,Y MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe KaYe QRW beeQ SaLd \eW, WKe aJJUeVVLRQ Rf WKe FLQaQce DeSaUWPeQWcRQWLQXeV aQd WKe bXdJeW Rf X MedLcaO CRPSOe[ KaV QRW beeQ UeOeaVed \eW.We VWaQd VLde b\ VLde ZLWK YDA X, MaUdaQ, YDA Y MedLcaO CROOeJe aV ZeOO aV aOO WKe facXOW\, KRXVeRffLceUV, aQd aOO RWKeU KeaOWK ePSOR\eeV Rf DeQWaO CROOeJe. UQWLO WKeLU VaOaULeV aUe QRW UeOeaVed, Ze ZLOO186bR\cRWW aOO RXU eOecWRUaO VeUYLceV. AQd RXU RQO\ ePeUJeQc\ VeUYLceV ZLOO be UeVWRUed. FLQaOO\, RQce aJaLQZe UeTXeVW WKe FLQaQce DeSaUWPeQW WR UeOeaVe WKe bXdJeW Rf X MedLcaO CRPSOe[ aV VRRQ aV SRVVLbOe.64. We VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKe SK\VLcaO YLROeQce aJaLQVW WKe dRcWRU aW WKe HRVSLWaO LQ LaKRUe. TKLV LV QRW WKefLUVW VXcK LQcLdeQW WR KaSSeQ LQ WKe KRVSLWaOV aV WKeUe LV QRW adeTXaWe VecXULW\ LQ WKe KRVSLWaOV fRUdRcWRUV WKaW LV ZK\ dRcWRUV aUe beLQJ fRUced WR OeaYe WKe cRXQWU\. - DWM65. "YDA KPK: TKe YDA DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ KeOd aQ ePeUJeQc\ PeeWLQJ LQ WKe X HRVSLWaO CRQfeUeQceRRRP, aWWeQded b\ RffLcLaOV fURP WKe YDA«.COaVV FRXU AVVRcLaWLRQ SeUYaQW GURXS Rf DeUa IVPaLOKKaQ. ReVSRQdLQJ WR WKe VKRUW caOO fURP WKe YDA DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ, RffLcLaOV fURP aOO aVVRcLaWLRQVSaUWLcLSaWed«« AOO aVVRcLaWLRQV aQd KeaOWK VWaff VWURQJO\ cRQdePQed WKe SROLce'V aOWeUaWLRQ Rf WKeKRVSLWaO'V FIR, LQWeUSUeWLQJ WKe RPLVVLRQ Rf cKaUJeV PeQWLRQed b\ WKe KRVSLWaO LQ WKe FIR aV a VLJQ RfSROLce bLaV. TKe KRVSLWaO'V SeWLWLRQ LQcOXded cKaUJeV WKaW ZeUe UePRYed fURP WKe FIR:BeaWLQJ aQd aVVaXOWLQJ WKe Oad\ dRcWRU VWaff aQd deWaLQLQJ WKeP XQMXVWO\.HaUaVVLQJ aQd YeUbaOO\ abXVLQJ Oad\ dRcWRUV aQd VWaff.TKUeaWeQLQJ WR NLOO Oad\ dRcWRUV aQd VWaff aQd WaNLQJ acWLRQV WR eQdaQJeU WKeLU OLYeV.CaXVLQJ daPaJe aQd YaQdaOLVP WR JRYeUQPeQW SURSeUW\.IQWeUfeULQJ ZLWK JRYeUQPeQW ZRUN.AOO aVVRcLaWLRQV aQd KeaOWK VWaff VeQW a cOeaU PeVVaJe WR WKe SROLce WKaW Lf WKe SROLce dR QRW abaQdRQWKeLU bLaVed QaUUaWLYe, WKe\ ZLOO be KeOd UeVSRQVLbOe fRU WKe daPaJeV UeVXOWLQJ fURP WKe LQcLdeQW. AOOaVVRcLaWLRQV aQd KeaOWK VWaff aJUeed WKaW XQOeVV WKe SROLce LQcOXde aOO WKe cKaUJeV PeQWLRQed LQ WKeKRVSLWaO'V aSSOLcaWLRQ LQ WKe FIR, eOecWLYe VeUYLceV (OPD, ZaUd URXQdV, eOecWLYe RSeUaWLRQV) LQ aOO WKUeeKRVSLWaOV Rf DeUa IVPaLO KKaQ ZLOO be bR\cRWWed.FXUWKeUPRUe, Lf VecXULW\ JXaUdV aUe QRW deSOR\ed aW WKe ePeUJeQc\ ZRUNSOace (OabRU URRP aQd WUaXPaceQWeU) b\ WRPRUURZ, Ze ZLOO be cRPSeOOed WR aOVR bR\cRWW ePeUJeQc\ VeUYLceV. We KRSe RXU aXWKRULWLeV187ZLOO SURYLde VecXULW\ fRU WKe YDA aQd KeaOWK VWaff fRU WKe VaNe Rf SaWLeQWV aQd LQcOXde WKe cKaUJeV LQ WKeFIR.66. YDA PXQMab: YDA PXQMab KeOd aQ LPSRUWaQW SUeVV cRQfeUeQce LQ KaVXU WRda\ UeJaUdLQJ WKe aOOeJedPLVbeKaYLRU Rf MS Rf X HRVSLWaO ZLWK KLV VWaff«..FRU WKe OaVW 7 da\V, OPDV Rf VeYeUaO THQV acURVV WKe dLVWULcW aUe aOVR cORVed aORQJ ZLWK RWKeUdeSaUWPeQWV LQcOXdLQJ OPD Rf WKe KRVSLWaO. AfWeU 62 dRcWRUV, aOO WKe QXUVeV aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff Rf XHRVSLWaO aOVR VXbPLWWed WKeLU UeVLJQaWLRQV. TKe OeadeUVKLS Rf YDA PXQMab aOVR UeacKed X HRVSLWaOKaVXU WR e[SUeVV VROLdaULW\ ZLWK WKe dRcWRUV, QXUVeV aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff affecWed b\ MS. AOO WKedRcWRUV aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff Rf X HRVSLWaO KaYe beeQ VWaQdLQJ fLUP fRU 6 da\V.67. YRXQJ dRcWRUV VeUYLQJ LQ K HRVSLWaO aUe YLcWLPV Rf YaULRXV W\SeV Rf RSSUeVVLRQ aQd YLROeQce.OQ WKe RQe KaQd, dXe WR QRQ-aYaLOabLOLW\ Rf facLOLWLeV aQd PedLcLQeV LQ WKe KRVSLWaO, WKe WRUWXUe JLYeQ b\WKe RZQeUV Rf WKe SaWLeQWV, SROLWLcaO acWLYLVWV, MRXUQaOLVWV aQd cLYLO VRcLeW\ dXULQJ WKe dXW\ aQd RQ WKeRWKeU KaQd, WKe \RXQJ dRcWRUV aUe WRUWXUed b\ WKe PaQaJePeQW.E[acWO\ WRda\, aW 9:00 PM, FCPS PaVV DU. J, ZKR ZaV RQ dXW\ LQ WKe ePeUJeQc\ Rf K HRVSLWaO, ZaVcRQdePQed LQ KaUVK ZRUdV fRU WRUWXUe, LOO-WUeaWPeQW aQd LPPRUaOLW\ JLYeQ b\ MS. He Va\V WKaW \RX KaYebeeQ UeOeaVed fURP TaOXNa HRVSLWaO, ZK\ aUe \RX dRLQJ dXW\! WKLOe WKe SRZeUV aUe YeVWed LQ WKeSecUeWaU\ HeaOWK, MS K HRVSLWaO LV WaNLQJ LOOeJaO aQd XQcRQVWLWXWLRQaO VWeSV WR WaNe adYaQWaJe Rf WKeSRZeUV aQd LV eQJaJLQJ LQ XQeWKLcaO aQd LPPRUaO beKaYLRU ZLWK DU.J. - YDA SLQdK68. YDA SLQdK LV aQ RUJaQL]aWLRQ WKaW KaV cRQVLVWeQWO\ VXSSRUWed WKe ULJKWV Rf dRcWRUV««.fRU WKeLUOeJLWLPaWe SULYLOeJeV. TRda\ Ze fLQd RXUVeOYeV cRPSeOOed WR e[SUeVV RXU cRQceUQ aQd UeJUeW RYeU WKLVWURXbOLQJ VLWXaWLRQ. TKe UeceQW decLVLRQ b\ WKe VLce CKaQceOORU WR VXVSeQd WKe dRcWRUV KaV bURXJKW WROLJKW WKe aJe-ROd RSSUeVVLRQ WKaW KaV SOaJXed WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ fRU JeQeUaWLRQV. We ZLVK WR LVVXe188a VWeUQ ZaUQLQJ WR WKe VLce CKaQceOORU WKaW, XQWLO WKe QRWLfLcaWLRQ LV LPPedLaWeO\ ZLWKdUaZQ, YDA SLQdKZLOO QRW KeVLWaWe WR VWaUW SURWeVWV, a PRYe WKaW cRXOd SRWeQWLaOO\ caXVe PaVVLYe XQUeVW. IQ WKe SaVW, RXURUJaQL]aWLRQ KaV VXbPLWWed SeWLWLRQV WR VC, UeTXeVWLQJ SURWecWLRQ Rf dRcWRUV' ULJKWV. SadO\, LW VeePV WKaWRXU aSSeaOV KaYe beeQ PLVcRQVWUXed aV a VLJQ Rf ZeaNQeVV, UeVXOWLQJ LQ RXU feOORZ dRcWRUV. UQfaLUVXVSeQVLRQ KaV KaSSeQed. YDA SLQdK ZaQWV WR aVVXUe WKe VWXdeQWV Rf PedLcaO cROOeJe H WKaW WKe eQWLUePedLcaO cRPPXQLW\ VWaQdV ZLWK \RX LQ VROLdaULW\ dXULQJ WKLV dLffLcXOW WLPe. We XUJe VC WR VeULRXVO\cRQVLdeU RXU UeTXeVW, aQd WKe\ WLWKLQ 24 KRXUV fURP aSSeaO fRU WKe ZLWKdUaZaO Rf WKe cRQWURYeUVLaOQRWLfLcaWLRQ. FaLOXUe WR dR VR ZLOO fRUce XV WR e[SaQd WKe VcRSe Rf RXU SURWeVW, aQd LW ZLOO becRPe aQ eYeQVWURQJeU VLJQ Rf RXU cROOecWLYe dLVaJUeePeQW.69. YDA PXQMab: YDA PXQMab KeOd aQ LPSRUWaQW SUeVV cRQfeUeQce«« PaUWLcLSaQWV VaLd WKaW WKe\ VWURQJO\cRQdePQ WKe SaLQfXO LQcLdeQW aQd ZLOO QRW VLW caOPO\ XQWLO MXVWLce LV VeUYed. IQ WKe QaPe Rf aJeQcLeV DU.Q ZaV abdXcWed fURP KLV cOLQLc aQd WRUWXUed aQd NLOOed bUXWaOO\. TKe UeSRUW Rf WKLV cUXeOW\ LV a OLYLQJSURRf. We XQdeUVWaQd WKaW WKLV PXUdeU ZaV QRW cRPPLWWed b\ a VLQJOe LQdLYLdXaO bXW WKaW WKe eQWLUeCRXQWeU TeUURULVP DeSaUWPeQW LV eTXaOO\ LQYROYed LQ WKLV LQcLdeQW. LLfWLQJ fURP KRVSLWaO LQ WKe QaPe RfVecXULW\, deWeQWLRQ aQd WKeQ bUXWaOO\ PXUdeU UaLVeV TXeVWLRQV RQ WKe LQVWLWXWLRQ'V SURfeVVLRQaO WUaLQLQJaQd PRUaO YaOXeV. WKeWKeU LW LV SaKLZaO WUaJed\ RU JKaQJ WUaJed\, WKe UROe Rf CRXQWeU TeUURULVPDeSaUWPeQW KaV aOZa\V beeQ cULPLQaO. TKeVe PRYePeQWV Rf WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQ, ZKLcK aUe cUeaWed WRUedXce WeUURULVP, aUe ZRUVe WKaQ WeUURULVWV. We dePaQd fURP WKe KLJKeU aXWKRULWLeV WKaW VXcKdeSaUWPeQWV VKRXOd be cORVed fRUeYeU VR WKaW WKe SeRSOe caQ be SURWecWed aQd WKeLU OLYeV aQd SURSeUW\aUe SURWecWed. YDA PXQMab VWaQdV ZLWK WKe dRcWRU cRPPXQLW\ aQd Ze MXVWLf\ aQd acNQRZOedJe WKeLUeYeU\ dePaQd.. We dePaQd WKaW WKe cXOSULWV be VXPPRQed aQd SUeVeQWed ZLWKLQ 48 KRXUV VR WKaW WKecaVe caQ be bURXJKW WR a ORJLcaO cRQcOXVLRQ RQ aQ ePeUJeQc\ baVLV. If RXU dePaQdV aUe QRW acceSWed,WKe VcRSe Rf SURWeVW ZLOO be VSUead aOO RYeU PXQMab.18970. CaVe Rf faNe FIRV aJaLQVW dRcWRUV. FIRV ZeUe UeJLVWeUed aJaLQVW dRcWRUV fRU WKe dLVaSSeaUaQce RfQeZbRUQ babLeV LQ SaUJRdKa aQd SaKLZaO, KRZeYeU, WKe babLeV ZeUe OaWeU UecRYeUed fURP WKe VaPefaPLO\. OQ WKe VSecLaO VXJJeVWLRQ Rf PUeVLdeQW YDA PXQMab, CKLef MLQLVWeU PXQMab MU. KaV LVVXedcRXQWeU FIR RUdeUV aJaLQVW WKeVe faPLOLeV fRU KaUaVVLQJ dRcWRUV aQd fLOLQJ faNe FIRV.71. *YDA BaORcKLVWaQ *QXeWWa: DeVSLWe beLQJ a dRcWRU LQ X MedLcaO CRPSOe[ HRVSLWaO, QXeWWa, WKeMLQLVWeU Rf HeaOWK eQWeUed ZLWK WKe eQWLUe VecXULW\ SeUVRQQeO bUeaNLQJ WKe SURWRcRO Rf WKe RSeUaWLRQWKeaWeU aQd PLVbeKaYLQJ ZLWK WKe dRcWRU RQ dXW\. SWURQJO\ cRQdePQ,WKe cXUUeQW cRUUXSW aQd XVeOeVVJRYeUQPeQW LV caXVLQJ daPaJe LQ WKe eQYLURQPeQW Rf JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV. We UeTXeVW CKLef MLQLVWeUBaORcKLVWaQ WR WaNe QRWLce Rf WKLV LQcLdeQW aQd VXVSeQd aOO VecXULW\ SeUVRQQeO LQYROYed LQ WKe LQcLdeQWaQd aOO VecXULW\ SeUVRQQeO Rf BaORcKLVWaQ BeWWeU VecXULW\ VKRXOd be SURYLded WR JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV.*72. TKLV LV WKe RffLcLaO bXdJeW cRS\ Rf WKe CLYLO DLVWULcW HeadTXaUWeUV. EYeQ WKRXJK WKeUe aUe VR PaQ\UeVRXUceV, WKe SURbOePV aUe LQcUeaVLQJ da\ b\ da\ LQ WKe KRVSLWaO dXe WR WKe OacN Rf facLOLWLeV. SRPeWLPeVWKeUe aUe ePeUJeQc\ LVVXeV, VRPeWLPeV WKeUe LV QR eOecWULcLW\ eYeU\ da\, QR UPS VROaU V\VWeP facLOLW\, QRbeVW Oab facLOLW\ fRU SXbOLc ZeOfaUe, QR XQdeU XSdaWe, QR facLOLW\ fRU dRcWRUV WR VLW aQd JeW WUeaWPeQW LQ aJRRd eQYLURQPeQW. CaQ WUeaW, QR adeTXaWe VecXULW\ aUUaQJePeQWV, QR VZeeW dULQNLQJ ZaWeU facLOLW\, QRRSeUaWLRQ WKeaWeU facLOLW\, KRZeYeU, aOO WKLQJV aUe be\RQd XQdeUVWaQdLQJ, ZKeQ aQd KRZ ZLOO WKe KeaOWKdeSaUWPeQW Rf KaVKPRUe dLVWULcW, WKe V\VWeP ZLOO be RQ WKe ULJKW WUacN. We UeTXeVW WKe SecUeWaU\ HeaOWK,DLUecWRU GeQeUaO HeaOWK WR WaNe LPPedLaWe QRWLce Rf WKe OacN Rf facLOLWLeV aQd LQaSSURSULaWe beKaYLRU RfKeaOWK ZRUNeUV aQd WR eVWabOLVK a Seace-fULeQdO\ eQYLURQPeQW LQ WKe KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW Rf KaVKPRUedLVWULcW.19073. We aUe deeSO\ VaddeQed b\ WKe ORVV Rf WKe GaUdeQeU aW GLUOV HRVWeO Rf QaLd-e-A]aP MedLcaO CROOeJeBaKaZaOSXU afWeU JeWWLQJ LQMXUed b\ WKe YeU\ XQfRUWXQaWe LQcLdeQW Rf URRf cROOaSVed.OXU cRQdROeQceVaQd deeSeVW V\PSaWKLeV JR RXW WR KLV faPLO\. RIP #QAMC_NEEDS_RENOVATION74. FXOO SXSSRUW WR YDA PIMS aQd WeaP. EPeUJeQc\ PeeWLQJ Rf PIMS YRXQJ DRcWRUV: AQ LQdLcaWLRQ RfLQWeQVe SURWeVW b\ PIMS YRXQJ DRcWRUV aJaLQVW WKe abXVLYe beKaYLRU aQd WKUeaWeQLQJ Rf dRcWRUV RfacWLQJ Kead Rf PIMS' LQeOLJLbOe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ Rf PIMS* *. DePaQd fURP HeaOWK MLQLVWeU WR aSSRLQWTXaOLfLed E[ecXWLYe DLUecWRU LQ PIMS RQ SeUPaQeQW baVLV* SRPe WLPe aJR, YDA UaLVed LWV YRLce RQ WKecRQceUQV Rf SaWLeQWV dXe WR PaOfXQcWLRQLQJ Rf WKe aLU cRQdLWLRQLQJ V\VWeP Rf WKe KRVSLWaO, RQ ZKLcK WKefedeUaO PLQLVWeU aOVR WRRN acWLRQ. IQ addLWLRQ, WKe PULPe MLQLVWeU aOVR WRRN acWLRQ RQ VeOOLQJ WKe ZaVWeRf WKe KRVSLWaO. PIMS' dLVTXaOLfLed e[ecXWLYe dLUecWRU KaV VWaUWed WKUeaWeQLQJ MXQLRU dRcWRUV WR KLde WKeLUTXaOLfLcaWLRQV. EYeQ befRUe WKLV, VeQLRU dRcWRUV Rf PIMS aUe aOVR XSVeW ZLWK WKe bad beKaYLRU Rf DU. HaQd WKaW LV ZK\ WKe\ KaYe beeQ cRPSOaLQLQJ aJaLQVW KLP LQ WKe MLQLVWU\ Rf HeaOWK. YRXQJ dRcWRUV KaYedePaQded WR aSSRLQW a TXaOLfLed e[ecXWLYe dLUecWRU LQ PIMS LPPedLaWeO\.75. IQ JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV,PRVW Rf WKe KRXVe RffLceUV aUe dRLQJ 16-18 KRXUV Rf daLO\ dXWLeV ZLWKRXW Sa\.IQcUeaVLQJ PLVPaQaJePeQW LQ WKe JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV,OacN Rf facLOLWLeV & XQaYaLOabLOLW\ Rf PedLcLQeVaUe QRW WKe UeVSRQVLbLOLWLeV Rf dRcWRUV. IW'V WKe UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ Rf WKe JRYeUQPeQW.76. QXeWWa: 7 bLOOLRQ UXSeeV ZKLcK ZaV aSSURYed fRU WKe SXUcKaVe Rf PedLcLQeV aQd PacKLQeU\ LQJRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV Rf BaORcKLVWaQ dXe WR WKe SURWeVW Rf \RXQJ dRcWRUV, bXW cRXOd QRW be XVed dXe WRWKe LQcRPSeWeQce aQd LQVeQVLWLYLW\ Rf WKe SUeYLRXV JRYeUQPeQW, ZKLcK Oed WR WKe QXPbeU Rf SaWLeQWV ZLWKdRcWRUV eYeU\ da\. IQcLdeQWV Rf W\UaQQ\, WRUWXUe aQd YLROeQce aUe WaNLQJ SOace RQ WKe UeOaWLYeV Rf K.SSRNeVSeUVRQ YRXQJ DRcWRUV19177. OXU cRPSOeWe VROLdaULW\ ZLWK WKe PedLcaO VWXdeQWV Rf PXQMab MedLcaO CROOeJe V, FaLVaOabad SeacefXOO\SURWeVWLQJ aJaLQVW WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ.We aOVR cRQdePQ WKe XVe Rf fRUce RQ WKe VWXdeQWV RQ WKe LOOeJaOacWLRQ Rf VC MedLcaO CROOeJe V. We UeTXeVW@MaNUaPaLPcWR WaNe LPPedLaWe QRWLce.#SaYe_PMC78. TKeUe LV a OaUJe QXPbeU Rf Oad\ KeaOWK ZRUNeUV,QXUVeV,SaUaPedLcaO VWaff Rf KRVSLWaOV LQ WKe RQJRLQJSURWeVW Rf PXQMab ePSOR\eeV LQ LaKRUe aQd WKe\ OeJLWLPaWeO\ dePaQdLQJ WKe eTXaO VaOaULeV LQcUeaVe OLNefedeUaO aQd RWKeU SURYLQceV aV aQQRXQced LQ WKe bXdJeW-2379. YDA PXQMab: YDA PXQMab'V OeadeUVKLS aORQJ ZLWK APCA PaNLVWaQ aQd JRYeUQPeQW ePSOR\eeVUeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV acURVV PXQMab RXWVLde CLYLO SecUeWaULaW LaKRUe RQ LQfOaWLRQ,XQePSOR\PeQW, WaONLQJ WR WKe VN\, eOecWULcLW\ bLOOV, SeQVLRQ aQd caVKPeQW, ePSOR\ee-NLOOLQJ SROLcLeV,aOORZaQceV deVSLWe SURPLVeV IQdefLQLWe deOa\ LQ ( HPA KPI ) aQd VecXULW\ bLOO, aQd SURWeVWed fRU WKe WRWaOULJKWV Rf aOO JRYeUQPeQW ePSOR\eeV aQd KeOd a VLW-LQ..GRYeUQPeQW ePSOR\eeV fURP aOO RYeU PXQMab LQcOXdLQJ YDA PXQMab, YRXQJ NXUVeV AVVRcLaWLRQ PXQMab,APCA PaNLVWaQ, PXQMab TeacKeUV UQLRQ, PXQMab PaUaPedLcaO SWaff AVVRcLaWLRQ, PXQMab AOOLed HeaOWKPURfeVVLRQaOV, COeUN AVVRcLaWLRQ SaUWLcLSaWed LQ WKe SURWeVW.TKe SURWeVW VWaUWed fURP WKe TRZQ HaOO aV a UaOO\ aQd eQded aW WKe CLYLO SecUeWaULaW PaLQ JaWe.AfWeU WKe UaOO\, WKe ePSOR\eeV bXUQed LQfOaWLRQ aQd eOecWULcLW\ bLOOV aW WKe PaLQ JaWe Rf WKe cLYLOVecUeWaULaW.AddUeVVLQJ WKe UaOO\, WKe SUeVLdeQW Rf YDA PXQMab VaLd WKaW ZKaWeYeU WKe JRYeUQPeQW LV, WKe ULJKWV RfJRYeUQPeQW ePSOR\eeV KaYe aOZa\V beeQ URbbed aQd bORRdVKed aW QLJKW.NRZ LV WKe WLPe WR cUeaWe aQ aWPRVSKeUe Rf XQLW\ aPRQJ XV aQd ePSOR\eeV fURP acURVV PXQMab cRPe192WRJeWKeU aQd VWaUW a PRYePeQW fRU WKeLU ULJKWV acURVV WKe cRXQWU\ LQ aQ RUJaQL]ed PaQQeU.YDA PXQMab ZLOO QRW RQO\ UeVSRQd WR eYeU\ YRLce UaLVed fRU WKe ULJKW, bXW ZLOO aOVR MRLQ LW ZLWK fXOO fRUce.80. PDA R MedLcaO CRPSOe[ (PDA-R) YLVLWed WKe BXUQ aQd POaVWLc UQLW WRda\ aQd acNQRZOedJed WKeaOOeJaWLRQV OeYLed aJaLQVW DU. GIW'V NQRZQ WR aVN WKaW WKeUe KaYe beeQ PRUe WKaQ 5 KaUaVVPeQW caVeV LQ BXUQ aQd POaVWLc SXUJeU\ LQ WKeSaVW feZ PRQWKV. TKaW PeaQV VRPe QXUVeV aUe deQLed fXOO dXW\ aQd Lf WKe\ JR VRPeZKeUe WR dR WKeLUdXW\, WKe\ LPPedLaWeO\ cRPPLW a KaUaVVPeQW caVe aQd fXQQ\ WKLQJ LV WKaW. TKeUe aUe WZR caVeV LQ WKeVecaVeV aJaLQVW WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQV aV ZeOO. AOO Rf WKeVe caVeV KaYe aOVR XQdeUJRQe a deSaUWPeQWaOLQTXLU\ ZKLcK KaV QRW SURYeQ aQ\ NLQd Rf KaUaVVPeQW«.. NRZ, fUXVWUaWed RQ aOO VLdeV, WKeVe SeRSOe aUeWU\LQJ WR WKURZ WXUbaQV RQ VRcLaO PedLa.FeZ YLOe QXUVeV aUe SOa\LQJ WKLV JaPe LQ ZKLcK fePaOe QXUVeV aUe fRUced WR cRPPLW "KaUaVVPeQW caVeV"aQd aUe caXVLQJ dLVJUace WR WKe QXUVeV cRPPXQLW\ «.. HaUaVVPeQW ZLOO JLYe \RX QRWKLQJ bXW PeQWaOdLVWUeVV aQd dLVJUace. NXUVeV aUe AX[LOLaU\ VWaff aQd aOZa\V Ze UeVSecW WKeP bXW WKe JaPe VWaUWed b\ afeZ HaUaVVPeQW MafLa WKe\ aUe e[SRVLQJ WKePVeOYeV. We ZLOO QRW VLW VLOeQW RQ aQ\ faOVe accXVaWLRQ aQdZLOO QRW bacN dRZQ fURP aQ\ VacULfLce fRU WKe ULJKWV aQd KRQRU Rf dRcWRUV. TKe PDA deOeJaWLRQ WKaQNedYDA KPK aQd aSSUecLaWed WKe decLVLRQ Rf dRcWRUV WR fLJKW fRU WKeLU ULJKWV.PURYLQcLaO DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ81. YDA X, MaUdaQ/KPK: TRda\ YDA X , MaUdaQ LQ aVVRcLaWLRQ ZLWK SaUaPedLcV aVVRcLaWLRQ,QXUVLQJ aQdVWaQdaUd IV aVVRcLaWLRQ SURWeVWed aJaLQVW QRQ-Sa\PeQW Rf VaOaULeV aQd bORcNed WKe PaLQ NRZVKeUaRRad. TKe VaOaULeV Rf aOO WKe facXOW\, KRXVe RffLceUV aQd RWKeU KeaOWK ePSOR\eeV Rf X MedLcaO CRPSOe[,Y MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe KaYe QRW beeQ SaLd \eW, WKe aJJUeVVLRQ Rf WKe FLQaQce DeSaUWPeQWcRQWLQXeV aQd WKe bXdJeW Rf X MedLcaO CRPSOe[ KaV QRW beeQ UeOeaVed \eW. We VWaQd VLde b\ VLde ZLWKYDA X, MaUdaQ, YDA Y MedLcaO CROOeJe aV ZeOO aV aOO WKe facXOW\, KRXVe RffLceUV, aQd aOO RWKeU KeaOWK193ePSOR\eeV Rf DeQWaO CROOeJe. UQWLO WKeLU VaOaULeV aUe QRW UeOeaVed, Ze ZLOO bR\cRWW aOO RXU eOecWRUaOVeUYLceV. AQd RXU RQO\ ePeUJeQc\ VeUYLceV ZLOO be UeVWRUed. FLQaOO\, RQce aJaLQ Ze UeTXeVW WKe FLQaQceDeSaUWPeQW WR UeOeaVe WKe bXdJeW Rf X MedLcaO CRPSOe[ aV VRRQ aV SRVVLbOe.82. TRda\, aQ e[WUaRUdLQaU\ PeeWLQJ Rf UeSUeVeQWaWLYeV Rf aOO VXUJLcaO VSecLaOWLeV ZaV KeOd LQ SZaW. IQ WKePeeWLQJ, WKeUe ZaV a fUXLWfXO dLVcXVVLRQ RQ YaULRXV NLQdV Rf SURbOePV UeOaWed WR WKe HeaOWK FacLOLW\PURJUaP, LQcOXdLQJ e[SORLWLQJ WKe VeOf-eVWeeP Rf SaWLeQWV aQd dRcWRUV, KaUaVVLQJ WKeP LQ dLffeUeQW Za\VaQd PaNLQJ WKeP VXffeU fURP PeQWaO WRUWXUe.IQ WKe PeeWLQJ, VWULcW SURWecWLRQV ZeUe e[SUeVVed RQ WecKQLcaO aQd fLQaQcLaO LUUeJXOaULWLeV Rf WKe SURJUaP.CRQVLdeULQJ aOO WKeVe UeaVRQV, GUaQd VXUJLcaO VSecLaOLWLeV cRRUdLQaWLRQ cRXQcLO ZaV fRUPed. TKe cRXQcLOZLOO VRRQ KROd a JeQeUaO bRd\ PeeWLQJ Rf aOO VXUJLcaO VSecLaOWLeV Rf MaOaNaQd dLYLVLRQ LQ ZKLcK fXWXUeaJeQda ZLOO be fRUPXOaWed NeeSLQJ LQ PLQd WKe abRYe LVVXeV aQd SURbOePV.83. YDA BaORcKLVWaQ: QXeWWa: PUeVLdeQW Rf PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQ BaORcKLVWaQ, PeW ZLWK WKe PedLcaOVXSeULQWeQdeQW Rf aOO WKe RUJaQL]aWLRQV Rf WKe KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW aW WKe MS RffLce Rf S HRVSLWaO, QXeWWa,aQd aVNed WKeP WR WaNe VWeSV fRU WKe LPSURYePeQW Rf WKe KRVSLWaO ZLWKRXW aQ\ feaU. MS aJUeed WR VXSSRUWeYeU\ LQLWLaWLYe WKaW cRXOd LPSURYe WKe KRVSLWaO.IQ WKLV LPSRUWaQW PeeWLQJ, MedLcaO S HRVSLWaO, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ, PaNLVWaQ MedLcaO AVVRcLaWLRQ, HeaOWKMaQaJePeQW CadUe, GeQeUaO CadUe DRcWRUV AVVRcLaWLRQ BaORcKLVWaQ, YRXQJ NXUVeV AVVRcLaWLRQBaORcKLVWaQ, PaNLVWaQ PaUaPedLcaO SWaff FedeUaWLRQ BaORcKLVWaQ aQd PaNLVWaQ PaUaPedLcaO SWaffAVVRcLaWLRQ BaORcKLVWaQ SaUWLcLSaWed.YDA BaORcKLVWaQ fXOO\ VXSSRUWV WKe SRVLWLYe VWeSV WaNeQ b\ MS SaQdePaQ PURYLQcLaO HRVSLWaO QXeWWa WRLPSURYe WKe cRQdLWLRQ Rf S HRVSLWaO aQd e[SUeVVeV cRQceUQ RYeU WKe QeJaWLYe SURSaJaQda aJaLQVW WKePaQd VWURQJO\ cRQdePQV WKLV faOVe SURSaJaQda.194TR LPSURYe WKe cRQdLWLRQ Rf JRYeUQPeQW KRVSLWaOV aQd PaLQWaLQ a KeaOWK\ aWPRVSKeUe LQ JRYeUQPeQWKRVSLWaOV, Ze YaOXe WKe SRVLWLYe UROe Rf aOO RUJaQL]aWLRQV aQd WKeLU VXJJeVWLRQV aQd aUe Uead\ WR ZRUNZLWK eYeU\RQe LQ a beWWeU Za\, bXW WKe KRVSLWaO YDA ZLOO QRW aOORZ aQ\RQe WR VSRLO WKe eQYLURQPeQW aQdXQdeUPLQe WKe dLJQLW\ Rf dRcWRUV.TKe C HRVSLWaO Rf QXeWWa cRQdePQ WKe baVeOeVV aOOeJaWLRQV aQd QeJaWLYe SURSaJaQda aJaLQVW MS b\ aQRUJaQL]aWLRQ aQd PMA VWaQdV b\ WKe VLde Rf eYeU\ LQLWLaWLYe WaNeQ b\ WKe BaORcKLVWaQ MedLcaOSXSeULQWeQdeQW fRU WKe LPSURYePeQW Rf WKe KRVSLWaO, PaNLVWaQ.84. FURP WKe KRXVe Rf YDA KPK: YDA KPK JUeaWO\ aSSUecLaWeV DU.F, WKe PUeVLdeQW Rf YDA GLOJLW, fRU KLVXQZaYeULQJ cRPPLWPeQW WR VWUeQJWKeQLQJ WKe PedLcaO cRPPXQLW\. HLV WLUeOeVV dedLcaWLRQ WR aVVLVWLQJfeOORZ KeaOWKcaUe SURYLdeUV KaV QRW JRQe XQQRWLced.FXUWKeUPRUe, UeceQW cKaQJeV LQ OeJLVOaWLRQ KaYe caXJKW RXU aWWeQWLRQ, SaUWLcXOaUO\ WKe decLVLRQ WRe[WeQd WKe UeWLUePeQW aJe fURP 60 WR 65 \eaUV. WKLOe WKLV PRYe aLPV WR be beQefLcLaO, LW LQadYeUWeQWO\RbVWUXcWV WKe SURJUeVV Rf VeQLRU dRcWRUV aQd OLPLWV RSSRUWXQLWLeV fRU bXddLQJ PedLcaO SUacWLWLRQeUV. TKeZLdeVSUead LPSOLcaWLRQV Rf WKLV XQMXVW OaZ aUe OLNeO\ WR caVW a VKadRZ RYeU PaNLVWaQ'V PedLcaOOaQdVcaSe. IQ UeVSRQVe WR WKLV VeULRXV LVVXe, YDA KPK fLUPO\ RSSRVeV WKe SeUceLYed LQMXVWLce. TKeRUJaQL]aWLRQ ZaUPO\ aSSOaXdV YDA GLOJLW fRU WaNLQJ a cRXUaJeRXV VWaQce RQ WKLV PaWWeU aQd SOedJeVXQZaYeULQJ VXSSRUW. IQ XQLW\, dRcWRUV fURP WKe SURYLQce Rf KPK MRLQ fRUceV, SOedJLQJ WR aPSOLf\ WKeLUcROOecWLYe YRLce RQ eYeU\ SOaWfRUP WR YeKePeQWO\ cKaOOeQJe WKe eQfRUcePeQW Rf WKLV XQfaLU OaZ.85. YDA L, KPK: TRda\ YDA L Kad a deWaLOed PeeWLQJ ZLWK WKe BRaUd Rf JRYeUQRUV L HRVSLWaO PeVKaZaU.VaULRXV LVVXeV UeOaWed WR PaWLeQW caUe aQd dRcWRUV ZeUe dLVcXVVed LQ deWaLO aQd TKe KRQRUabOe BOGVSURPLVed WR UeVROYe WKeP RQ aQ XUJeQW baVLV.1) AccRPPRdaWLRQ UeOaWed LVVXeV Rf TUaLQLQJ MedLcaO OffLceUV aQd HRXVe RffLceUV ZLOO be UeVROYed VXcKaV MaOe TUaLQLQJ MedLcaO OffLceUV aOORWPeQW, UedXce dedXcWLRQV WR 15000 SeU PRQWK aQd fUee195accRPPRdaWLRQ fRU KRXVe RffLceUV. NR eOecWULcLW\ PeWeUV LQ aQ\ KRVWeO2) E[SUeVV LLQe fRU TUaLQLQJ MedLcaO OffLceUV aQd HRXVe RffLceUV KRVWeO fRU XQLQWeUUXSWed eOecWULcLW\VXSSO\2) HRVWeO 1 aQd 2 ZLOO be UeQaPed aV DRcWRUV KRVWeO3) PaWLeQWV ZLOO be facLOLWaWed aQd WKe QXPbeU Rf SaWLeQWV SeU cRQVXOWaQW ZLOO be LQcUeaVed.4) UQQeceVVaU\ deOa\ aQd WURXbOe LQ OPD VOLSV fRU SaWLeQWV ZLOO be abROLVKed aQd SaWLeQWV ZLOO befacLOLWaWed WR be VeeQ aW WKe eaUOLeVW SRVVLbOe b\ WKe cRQVXOWaQW5) FLQaQcLaO AXdLW aQd aXdLW Rf UecUXLWPeQWV aV ZeOO aV aZaUdLQJ Rf YaULRXV adPLQLVWUaWLYe SRZeUV WRLQeOLJLbOe SeUVRQQeO ZaV dePaQdedWe aUe YeU\ WKaQNfXO WR CKaLUPaQ BOG aQd PePbeU BOG DU N fRU WKeLU SRVLWLYe UeVSRQVe WR UeVROYe aOOLVVXeV aQd KLQdUaQceV cUeaWed fRU SaWLeQWV aQd dRcWRUV. YDA L ZLOO SURYLde aOO RXW VXSSRUW WR WKeadPLQLVWUaWLRQ aQd SROLc\ PaNeUV fRU RSWLPaO SaWLeQW caUe aQd facLOLWaWLRQ Rf dRcWRUV86. TRda\, YDA G PeW ZLWK WKe VLce CKaQceOORU aQd SUeVeQWed a cKaUWeU Rf dePaQdV fRU aOO RXU SeQdLQJLVVXeV. We cRQJUaWXOaWe aOO UePaLQLQJ PGV Rf 2023 ZKR'V UeJLVWUaWLRQ ZLWK TKe ReVeaUcK aQd TUaLQLQJMRQLWRULQJ CeOO ZeUe ZLWKKeOd dXe XQaYaLOabLOLW\ Rf VORWV, AOKaPdXOLOOaK aOO KaYe UeceLYed RTMCUeJLVWUaWLRQ \eVWeUda\ WKaW WRR fURP JaQXaU\« VeVVLRQ, Ze'Ue WKaQNfXO WR VC Vb fRU WKe effRUWV Ke SXW LQWKLV UeJaUd.TKe VLce CKaQceOORU Pade a cRPPLWWee fURP RXU cabLQeW ZKR ZLOO YLVLW ZaUdV aQd KLJKOLJKW WKe LVVXeVUeJaUdLQJ KRVSLWaO PaQaJePeQW, WUaLQLQJ UeOaWed LVVXeV aQd WKe\ ZLOO be LQ cRQWLQXRXV cRQWacW ZLWK WKeVLce CKaQceOORU WLOO aOO PaWWeUV ZLOO be UeVROYed.FRU fLQaQcLaO LVVXeV aQd UePaLQLQJ aUUeaUV Rf PGV, ULVN aOORZaQceV, RXU cRPPLWWee PePbeUV ZLOO PeeWZLWK DLUecWRU FLQaQce aQd SUeVeQW RXU UeVeUYaWLRQV & WKeQ a cRPbLQed PeeWLQJ ZLWK WKe VLce196CKaQceOORU VKaOO be KeOd accRUdLQJO\.FRU cafeWeULa Rf DRcWRUV, WKe VLce CKaQceOORU ZLOO YLVLW ZLWK XV WR VeOecW a VXLWabOe SOace.87. FLUVW Rf aOO, Ze cRQJUaWXOaWe WKe PedLcaO RffLceUV aQd deQWaO dRcWRUV RQ SaVVLQJ WKe ZULWWeQ e[aP aQde[WeQd RXU beVW ZLVKeV WR WKeP fRU WKeLU LQWeUYLeZV. AV Ze aOO NQRZ, WKe SROLc\ LQ WKe fLeOd Rf KeaOWKcaUeLV WR caOO WKUee caQdLdaWeV fRU aQ LQWeUYLeZ fRU eacK aYaLOabOe VeaW. TKLV WLPe aV ZeOO, WKe\ KaYe fROORZedWKe VaPe SROLc\ aQd caOOed caQdLdaWeV fRU LQWeUYLeZV baVed RQ WKe aYaLOabOe VeaWV LQ deQWaO aQd PedLcaOfLeOdV. We adYLVe RXU dRcWRUV WR SOeaVe VWa\ aZa\ fURP WKRVe ZKR WU\ WR WaNe bULbeV RU JeW LQYROYed LQaQ\ RWKeU PLVcRQdXcW. TKeVe aUe WKe VaPe LQdLYLdXaOV ZKR KaYe aOZa\V SULRULWL]ed WKeLU RZQ LQWeUeVWVaQd cRUUXSWLRQ.OXU YDA WeaP KaV aOUead\ PeW ZLWK WKe RffLcLaOV Rf SPSC (SLQdK PXbOLc SeUYLce CRPPLVVLRQ), aQd ZeaUe aOVR LQ cRQWacW ZLWK WKe WeaP Rf WKe CKLef MLQLVWeU Rf SLQdK. We NLQdO\ UeTXeVW WKaW cRQVLdeULQJ WKeVKRUWaJe Rf deQWaO dRcWRUV, aOO WKe caQdLdaWeV ZKR KaYe UeceLYed LQWeUYLeZ caOOV be JLYeQ RffeU RUdeUV.AddLWLRQaOO\, dXe WR WKe VKRUWaJe Rf deQWaO dRcWRUV, Ze KaYe cRQWacWed WKe CKLef MLQLVWeU'V WeaP WRaQQRXQce a QeZ deQWaO dRcWRUV' cRPPLVVLRQ aV VRRQ aV SRVVLbOe, VR WKaW WKe VKRUWaJe Rf deQWaO dRcWRUVLQ WKe eQWLUe SLQdK SURYLQce caQ be addUeVVed.We ZLOO aOVR LQfRUP WKe CKLef MLQLVWeU Rf SLQdK abRXW WKeSNE OLVW Rf 500 deQWaO dRcWRUV UeOeaVed b\ WKe DG RffLce, aQd Ze ZLOO e[eUW fXOO SUeVVXUe RQ SPSC WRaQQRXQce WKe cRPPLVVLRQ fRU deQWaO dRcWRUV VRRQ fRU UePaLQLQJ SRVWV.88. YDA H, PXQMab: YDA H, PXQMab e[SUeVVeV deeS cRQceUQ aQd aQJeU RYeU QRQ-Sa\PeQW Rf WZR PRQWKVVaOaULeV. IQ WKLV eUa Rf LQfOaWLRQ ZKeUe WKe VaOaULeV Rf WKeVe ePSOR\eeV aUe aOUead\ PXcK ORZeU WKaQRWKeU PedLcaO RffLceUV aQd dRcWRUV, LQVWead Rf LQcUeaVLQJ WKe VaOaULeV, deSULYaWLRQ Rf WKe baVLc ULJKW fRUWZR PRQWKV LV QRW RQO\ a SURRf Rf WKe LQcRPSeWeQce aQd SKaUaRKV Rf WKe deSaUWPeQW bXW XV. TKe\ WKLQNLW'V WaQWaPRXQW WR WKe ecRQRPLc PXUdeU Rf dRcWRUV..We dePaQd WKaW WKe SeUSeWUaWRUV Rf WKLV QeJOLJeQce VKRXOd be SXQLVKed aQd WKe VaOaULeV VKRXOd be197WUaQVfeUUed WR WKe dRcWRUV RQ aQ ePeUJeQc\ baVLV. MLQLVWeU HeaOWK PXQMab, SecUeWaU\ HeaOWK PXQMab aQddePaQd WKaW Lf RXU dePaQdV aUe QRW PeW, KRVSLWaOV acURVV PXQMab ZLOO be ORcNed aQd SURWeVWV ZLOOcRQWLQXe WLOO dePaQdV aUe aSSURYed.89. TKe KRVSLWaOV Rf KPK KaYe beeQ UXOed b\ WKe cRUUXSW PafLa fRU WKe OaVW 9 \eaUV. TKeVe SeRSOe KaYecRYeUed WKe PRQe\ Rf SRRU SeRSOe. BXW QR RQe ZRXOd aVN. We UeTXeVW NAB aQd FIA WR WaNe acWLRQaJaLQVW WKe cRUUXSW PafLa aQd bULQJ WKeP WR MXVWLce.90. PPH LV aQ LQVWLWXWLRQ WKaW KaV JLYeQ QRWKLQJ bXW fLQaQcLaO ORVV WR WKe KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW...! We UeTXeVWWKe HeaOWK SecUeWaU\ WR LQYeVWLJaWe WKe PaWWeU aQd eOLPLQaWe WKLV NLQd Rf eQYLURQPeQW aQd PaNe WKedRcWRUV Rf PaQaJePeQW cadUe LQ PPHI DM ZKR aW OeaVW NQRZ KRZ WR UeVSecW dRcWRUV. If WKLV LVVXe LV QRWUeVROYed aQd RXU VLVWeU dReV QRW JeW MXVWLce Ze ZLOO WaNe OeJaO acWLRQ aJaLQVW WKe PPHI PafLa. AQd ZeZLOO aOVR VXbPLW a SeWLWLRQ WR CEO PPHI VR WKaW WKeLU LUUeVSRQVLbOe RffLceUV caQ be UeLQfRUced aQd ZecaQ SURWecW WKe dLJQLW\ Rf RXU dRcWRUV..!91. PUeVV cRQfeUeQce Rf aOO dRcWRUV THQ KRVSLWaOV:TKe dePaQd fURP WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ WR fLOe aQ FIR RQ WKe MRXUQaOLVW aQd aWWeQdaQW ZLOO QRW be WaNeQbacN aW aQ\ cRVW, RWKeUZLVe WKe VeUYLce ZLOO bR\cRWW. AccRUdLQJ WR OeJaO adYLce, RQO\ FIRV aUe QRWeQRXJK, bXW QRQ-baLOabOe Sa\PeQWV XQdeU PEMRA aQd PECA AcW, defaPaWLRQ, KeaY\ fLQeV, caQceOOaWLRQRf OLceQVe, cORVXUe Rf Zeb SaJeV, QRQ-deJUee RU deJUee KROdeU LUUeVSRQVLbOe MRXUQaOLVWV. TKe LeJaOAdYLVRU KaV beeQ JLYeQ WKe JUeeQ VLJQaO WR WaNe VWeSV fRU OeJaO acWLRQ.AOO dRcWRUV KaYe beeQ LQVWUXcWed WR WaNe VcUeeQVKRWV Rf WKe VR caOOed MRXUQaOLVWV ZKR VKaUe abVROXWeO\LQcRUUecW UeSRUWLQJ Rf WKe LQcLdeQW aQd deJUadLQJ SRVWV fURP WKeLU VRcLaO PedLa accRXQWV, VR WKaW aOO WKeSeRSOe ZLWK dLJLWaO cRQWeQW caQ aOVR be bURXJKW WR OeJaO acWLRQ19892. Be Uead\ fRU WKe X WUeQdLQJ caPSaLJQ ZLWK QeZ KaVKWaJV RQ a daLO\ baVLV aW WKe aQQRXQced daWe aQdWLPe. OXU fLUVW WUeQdLQJ caPSaLJQ ZLOO VWaUW WRPRUURZ eYeQLQJ 6:00 SP & HaVKWaJ ZLOO be#PMDC_DeOa\_MDCATOQO\ XVe WKe abRYe KaVKWaJ QRW befRUe 6:00 SP WRPRUURZ. #DeOa\MDCAT202393. UHS VLce CKaQceOORU cRXOd QRW aQVZeU PMSUP PUeVLdeQW HaVaQ BaORcK'V SRLQWed TXeVWLRQV aQd OefWWKe SURJUaP aQd UaQ aZa\. IQVWead Rf acceSWLQJ KLV faLOXUe aQd LQcRPSeWeQce, Ke UefXVed bUa]eQO\. TKe\Va\ WKaW WKe UeVXOWV ZLOO be JLYeQ RQ WLPe. See WKe fXOO SURJUaP. @XKVOKURffLcLaO94. UHS KaV UeOeaVed WKe daWe VKeeW Rf aQQXaO e[aPV. We aQQRXQce WR VWaUW a SURWeVW PRYePeQW LQ WKeeQWLUe PXQMab UeJaUdLQJ WKe abROLWLRQ Rf e[WeUQaO ceQWeUV aQd LQWeUQaO e[aPLQeUV (cROOeJe Kead RfdeSaUWPeQW) fRU SUacWLcaOV/cOLQLcaO. TKLV decLVLRQ ZLOO bULQJ dLVaVWeU. AQd be deOa\ed WZR PRUe ZeeNV.95. CRPSOeWe OPD SeUYLceV bR\cRWW LV beLQJ RbVeUYed LQ aOO WKe KRVSLWaOV, THQ'V, BHU'V acURVV WKe cRXQWU\eVSecLaOO\ LQ PXQMab. AV WKe dRcWRUV KaYe decLded QRW WR SURYLde WKeLU VeUYLceV LQ VXcK a ZRUNLQJeQYLURQPeQW LQ WKe KRVSLWaOV. @MaNUaPaLPc #DRcWRUVOQSWULNe #SecXULW\FRUDRcWRUV96. TRda\, WKeUe LV a cRPSOeWe cOaVV bR\cRWW LQ QaLd-e-A]aP MedLcaO CROOeJe BaKaZaOSXU, WKeUe ZLOO be QRcOaVVeV WLOO WKe dePaQdV JeW fXOfLOOed. @MaNUaPaLPc #QAMC_NEEDS_RENOVATION97. A caOO fRU SURWeVW KaV beeQ JLYeQ WRda\, WedQeVda\ aW 12 R'cORcN LQ fURQW Rf X MedLcaO UQLYeUVLW\. YDASLQdK, VRcLaO PedLa fULeQdV, SULQW aQd eOecWURQLc PedLa, OaZ\eUV, cRPPXQLW\, VWXdeQWV, MXQLRUV, VeQLRUdRcWRUV WR aOO SaUWLcLSaWe LQ WKe SURWeVW. IQYLWaWLRQ LV UeTXeVWed WR WKe VLce CKaQceOORU Rf X MU, dePaQdMXVWLce WR WKe dRcWRUV Rf SLQdK, WaNe WKe WeVW aJaLQ, aOVR OeJaO acWLRQ VKRXOd be WaNeQ aJaLQVW WKRVe ZKRaUe LQYROYed LQ WKLV SURceVV.19998. YDA PXQMab: YDA PXQMab KeOd aQ LPSRUWaQW SUeVV cRQfeUeQce LQ KaVXU WRda\ UeJaUdLQJ WKe aOOeJedPLVbeKaYLRU Rf MS Rf X HRVSLWaO ZLWK KLV VWaff«..FRU WKe OaVW 7 da\V, OPDV Rf VeYeUaO THQV acURVV WKe dLVWULcW aUe aOVR cORVed aORQJ ZLWK RWKeUdeSaUWPeQWV LQcOXdLQJ OPD Rf WKe KRVSLWaO. AfWeU 62 dRcWRUV, aOO WKe QXUVeV aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff Rf XHRVSLWaO aOVR VXbPLWWed WKeLU UeVLJQaWLRQV. TKe OeadeUVKLS Rf YDA PXQMab aOVR UeacKed X HRVSLWaOKaVXU WR e[SUeVV VROLdaULW\ ZLWK WKe dRcWRUV, QXUVeV aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff affecWed b\ MS. AOO WKedRcWRUV aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff Rf X HRVSLWaO KaYe beeQ VWaQdLQJ fLUP fRU 6 da\V.MS LQ aVVRcLaWLRQ ZLWK WKe SROLce PafLa aUe WKUeaWeQLQJ dRcWRUV. MS UeceLYeV JLfWV fURP dRcWRUV LQ WKeQaPe Rf SecUeWaU\ A. MS HRVSLWaO KaV aOVR VWaUWed a VRcLaO PedLa caPSaLJQ aJaLQVW RXU dRcWRUV, QXUVeVaQd aOVR aWWacNed dRcWRUV, QXUVeV aQd SaUaPedLcV b\ RUdeULQJ JRRQV fURP RXWVLde, ZKRVe FIR KaV QRWbeeQ UeJLVWeUed \eW.We ZLOO QRW bacN dRZQ XQWLO MS KRVSLWaO LV UeSOaced. TKe ZKROe KRVSLWaO LV LQ fXOO SURWeVW, eYeU\ePSOR\ee LV RQ VWULNe ULVNLQJ KLV fXWXUe. EYeU\ SaWLeQW, dRcWRU aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff LV cU\LQJ RYeU QRQSURYLVLRQ Rf facLOLWLeV bXW MS X HRVSLWaO LV VWLOO VWaQdLQJ RQ LWV SKaUaRK.DeVSLWe JLYLQJ bLOOLRQV Rf bXdJeWV, WKe CKLef MLQLVWeU LV VWXcN LQ WKe YLVLRQ Rf LPSURYLQJ aQd XSJUadLQJRf PXQMab'V KRVSLWaOV.?99. YDA PXQMab TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO DG KKaQ VWaQdV ZLWK DG KKaQ RQ WKe LQKXPaQLW\ LQcLdeQW Rf R[\JeQc\OLQdeUV. AV a UeVXOW Rf WKLV WUaJLc LQcLdeQW, a Oad\ dRcWRU aQd a QXUVe KaYe eQWeUed WKe WUaXPa ceQWeUDG KKaQ LQ cULWLcaO cRQdLWLRQ. WKLOe RQe SaWLeQW LV LQ WKe ICU RQ a OLfe-aQd-deaWK VWUXJJOe. We dePaQdfURP RXU CKLef MLQLVWeU PXQMab WKaW1) TKe LQYeVWLJaWLRQ Rf WKLV LQcLdeQW VKRXOd be cRQdXcWed aW a cRPSOeWeO\ QeXWUaO VecUeWaULaW OeYeO. 2)LacN Rf UeJXOaU LQVSecWLRQ Rf c\OLQdeUV, WKe SUeVeQce Rf SRRU TXaOLW\ c\OLQdeUV aQd WKe faLOXUe Rf WKe fLUeaOaUP afWeU WKe accLdeQW LV a VeULRXV adPLQLVWUaWLYe faLOXUe RQ ZKLcK WKe Head Rf WKe IQVWLWXWLRQ200PULQcLSaO DU.R ZKR KaV beeQ VLWWLQJ fRU 5 \eaUV, VKRXOd be bURXJKW WR cRXUW LPPedLaWeO\. 3) TKeSURcXUePeQW cRPPLWWee LQYROYed LQ SXUcKaVLQJ defecWLYe JRRdV aQd eTXLSPeQW VKRXOd be aXdLWed.100. OQ WKe LQVWUXcWLRQV Rf WKe GeQeUaO CRXQcLO Rf YDA KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa, WRda\ YDA Q GURXS RfTeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO dLd a ZaUd-WR-ZaUd URXQd aQd WRRN LWV dRcWRUV cRPPXQLW\ LQ cRQfLdeQce fRU SeacefXOSURWeVW WRPRUURZ. YRXQJ dRcWRUV ZLOO bR\cRWW eOecWLYe VeUYLceV acURVV KK\beU PaNKWXQNKZa fURPWRPRUURZ aJaLQVW QRQ-KLNe LQ VaOaULeV Rf WUaLQee PedLcaO RffLceUV aQd KRXVe RffLceUV. AOO WUaLQeePedLcaO RffLceUV aQd KRXVe RffLceUV aUe LQfRUPed WKaW fURP WRPRUURZ QR dRcWRU VKaOO JR WR ZaUdeV RUOPD.101. PUeVV ReOeaVe YDA MaUdaQ: TRda\ YDA MaUdaQ LQ aVVRcLaWLRQ ZLWK SaUaPedLcVaVVRcLaWLRQ,QXUVLQJ aQd VWaQdaUd IV aVVRcLaWLRQ SURWeVWed aJaLQVW QRQ Sa\PeQW Rf VaOaULeV aQd bORcNedPaLQ NRZVKeUa RRad TKe VaOaULeV Rf aOO WKe facXOW\, KRXVe RffLceUV aQd RWKeU KeaOWK ePSOR\eeV RfMaUdaQ MedLcaO CRPSOe[, BacKa KKaQ MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe KaYe QRW beeQ SaLd \eW, WKeaJJUeVVLRQ Rf WKe FLQaQce DeSaUWPeQW cRQWLQXeV aQd WKe bXdJeW Rf MMC KaV QRW beeQ UeOeaVed \eW.102. QXeWWa: We VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKe PLVbeKaYLRU Rf DU. F aQd WKe SaUaPedLcaO VWaff RQ dXW\ b\ WKeLeYLeV FRUce aW TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO T OaVW QLJKW aQd WKUeaWeQLQJ WKeP b\ SOacLQJ a JXQ RQ WKeLU KeadV.LaVW QLJKW aW 1:30 a.P. a LeYL'V RffLcLaO ZaV bURXJKW WR WKe ePeUJeQc\ URRP Rf TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO T,ZKeUe RQ dXW\, DU. F aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff LPPedLaWeO\ VWaUWed KLV WUeaWPeQW, bXW WKeUe ZeUe QRPedLcLQeV fURP V\ULQJe aQd caQROa LQ WKe KRVSLWaO. DXe WR WKLV, WKe LQ-cKaUJe Rf LeYL'V FRUce VWaUWedabXVLQJ aQd PLVbeKaYLQJ ZLWK WKe dRcWRU aQd aW WKe VaPe WLPe, WKe dRcWRU ZaV WKUeaWeQed b\ SXWWLQJ aJXQ RQ KLV Kead.201DeSXW\ CRPPLVVLRQeU KKX]daU WR LQLWLaWe acWLRQ b\ fLOLQJ aQ FIR aJaLQVW WKe accXVed, YDA aQQRXQcebR\cRWW fURP OPD aQd EOecWLYe SeUYLceV WLOO WKe aUUeVW Rf WKe accXVed LQ BaORcKLVWaQ TeacKLQJ HRVSLWaO EZKLOe EPeUJeQc\ VeUYLceV ZLOO UePaLQ acWLYe, e[SaQdLQJ WKe SURWeVW SURceVV aQd WaNLQJ RWKeU dRcWRUV'RUJaQL]aWLRQV aQd SaUaPedLcaO VWaff'V RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQWR cRQfLdeQce, a MRLQW SURWeVW acWLRQ ZLOO beaQQRXQced.103. YDA BaORcKLVWaQ: QXeWWa: YRXQJ dRcWRUV RQ WRNeQ VWULNe fURP WRPRUURZ fURP 8 aP WR 10 aPaJaLQVW WKe QeJOLJeQce Rf WKe MedLcaO SXSeULQWeQdeQW aQd DLVWULcW HeadTXaUWeUV HRVSLWaO ZKRbadPLQLVWUaWLRQ, QRW SURYLdLQJ PedLcLQeV aQd facLOLWLeV WR SaWLeQWV, XQMXVWO\ KaUaVVLQJ dRcWRUV aQdKeaWLQJ XS WKe PaUNeW Rf cRUUXSWLRQ LQ WKe KRVSLWaO.MedLcaO SXSeULQWeQdeQW aQd DLVWULcW HeadTXaUWeUV HRVSLWaO KaYe ZaUQed WKe KLJKeU aXWKRULWLeV PaQ\WLPeV abRXW WKe dLVWULbXWLRQ Rf PedLcLQeV, cRUUXSWLRQ LQ aLd Rf PedLcLQeV aQd KaUaVVLQJ dRcWRUV ZLWKYaULRXV KaQdcXffV ZLWKRXW aQ\ UeaVRQ aQd KaYe aOVR dePaQded OeJaO acWLRQ aJaLQVW WKeP. YeV, bXW dXeWR QR acWLRQ WaNeQ aJaLQVW WKeP, YDA BaORcKLVWaQ aQQRXQceV a WRNeQ VWULNe fURP WRPRUURZ PRUQLQJ 8WR 10 aQd ZaUQ KLJKeU aXWKRULWLeV Lf WKeUe LV QR LPPedLaWe OeJaO acWLRQ aJaLQVW WKe PedLcaOVXSeULQWeQdeQW aQd WKe adPLQLVWUaWLRQ. If dRQe, WKe VcRSe Rf SURWeVW ZLOO be VSUead WR WKe ZKROeSURYLQce.104. SSRNeVSeUVRQ YDA BaORcKLVWaQ.*QXeWWa: HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW cRQVLdeUV dePRQVWUaWRUV/WeacKeUV RfX aQd Y MedLcaO CROOeJeV addLWLRQaO dXWLeV LQ WeacKLQJ KRVSLWaOV aORQJ ZLWK WeacKLQJ VeUYLceV LQ WKeLUcROOeJeV aV KRVWLOLW\ aQd VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKLV PRYe, edXcaWLRQ LQ LRUaOaL aQd JKaOaZaQ MedLcaOCROOeJe. AQQRXQce cRPSOeWe bR\cRWW Rf acWLYLWLeV, SURYLQce-ZLde bR\cRWW Rf VeUYLceV Lf LVVXeV aUe QRWaddUeVVed VeULRXVO\.DePRQVWUaWRUV LQ PedLcaO cROOeJeV aUe WaNLQJ WeacKLQJ VeUYLceV LQ cROOeJeV RQ a UeJXOaU baVLV. EYeQWKRXJK WKeUe LV QR aUUaQJePeQW fRU accRPPRdaWLRQ WKeUe aQd WKeLU KeaOWK SURfeVVLRQaO aOORZaQce KaV202aOVR beeQ VWRSSed fRU a ORQJ WLPe, bXW VWLOO dePRQVWUaWRUV LQ aOO WKUee PedLcaO cROOeJeV aUe WaNLQJ WKeLUVeUYLceV RQ UeJXOaU baVLV. TKe\ aUe JLYLQJ ZLQJV, bXW WKe KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW KaV JLYeQ QRWLfLcaWLRQ WRWaNe VeUYLceV LQ KRVSLWaOV, SXWWLQJ aQ eQd WR cUXeOW\ aQd abXVe. We VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ WKLV VWeS b\ WKeHeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW.YDA BaORcKLVWaQ ZaQWV WR PaNe LW cOeaU WR WKe DeSaUWPeQW Rf HeaOWK WKaW Ze dR QRW acceSW VXcKRQe-VLded aQd e[aJJeUaWed QRWLfLcaWLRQV, QRU ZLOO Ze VWa\ VLOeQW RQ LW.TKe HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW KaV beeQ XVLQJ dLffeUeQW WacWLcV fRU a ORQJ WLPe WR KXUW WKe SULYLOeJeV Rf WKeWeacKeUV Rf WKeVe WKUee PedLcaO cROOeJeV, ZKLcK Ze VWURQJO\ cRQdePQ.YDA BaORcKLVWaQ aQQRXQceV cRPSOeWe bR\cRWW Rf edXcaWLRQaO acWLYLWLeV aW X aQd Y MedLcaO CROOeJeaJaLQVW WKe QRWLfLcaWLRQ Rf RSSUeVVLRQ LVVXed b\ WKe HeaOWK DeSaUWPeQW, Lf WKe SURbOePV Rf WeacKeUV aUeQRW UeVROYed, acURVV WKe SURYLQce. I ZLOO be fRUced WR aQQRXQce a bR\cRWW Rf VeUYLceV,105. QXeWWa: YDA BaORcKLVWaQ JRYeUQPeQW dePaQdV WKe WLPeO\ dePaQd WKaW aOO WKeVe SURbOePV be WaNeQVeULRXVO\ aQd LPPedLaWeO\ VROYe WKeP, LQ WKLV UeJaUd, PeeWLQJV ZLOO be KeOd ZLWK RWKeU aXWKRULWLeVLQcOXdLQJ SecUeWaU\ HeaOWK, SXbOLc aQd KLJKeU aXWKRULWLeV ZLOO be LQfRUPed WKURXJK a SUeVV cRQfeUeQce.IW ZLOO be dRQe, ZaUd WR ZaUd, KRVSLWaO WR KRVSLWaO aQd dLVWULcW WR dLVWULcW dRcWRUV ZLOO be PRbLOL]ed, Lf WKeabRYe LVVXeV aUe QRW UeVROYed ZLWKLQ a PRQWK, WKeQ a SURWeVW PRYePeQW VKRXOd be VWaUWed afWeU PXWXaOcRQVXOWaWLRQ ZLWK RWKeU KeaOWK deSaUWPeQW RUJaQL]aWLRQV, fRU ZKLcK fXOO UeVSRQVLbLOLW\ ZLOO be RQ WKeJRYeUQPeQW.203Appendi[ B - LisW of Social Media PosWs b\ MSaRDs on RQ.2: Framing of NLE1. FLUVW, PaNLVWaQL VWXdeQWV WaNe WKe MDCAT (MedLcaO aQd DeQWaO CROOeJe AdPLVVLRQ TeVW) aQd WKeQWKe NLE (LQaWLRQ), ZK\?CULcNeW PaWWeUV PRUe WR a PM dXULQJ PaQdePLc WKaQ fURQW OLQe HeaOWK caUe ZaUULRUV fLJKWLQJ da\aQd QLJKW aJaLQVW COVID19 aQd GRYW'V bUXWaO SROLcLeV. DRcWRU cRPPXQLW\ ZaV QRW e[SecWLQJVXcK ZRUVW da\V LQ \RXU JRYeUQPeQW bXW \RX SURYed XV ZURQJ.2. TKe PaNLVWaQ PedLcaO edXcaWLRQ V\VWeP VeePV WR ZaQW WR e[aPLQe dRcWRUV fRU eYeQ WaNLQJ abUeaWK. TKe\ ZRQ'W OeW \RX bUeaWKe XQWLO \RX'Ye cOeaUed aQ e[aP. TKe\ cRQVWaQWO\ SUeVVXUe \RXZLWK e[aPV aW eYeU\ WXUQ, aQd WKeQ ZRQdeU ZK\ WKeVe SeRSOe becRPe SV\cKRV. CRPe RQ, \RX'UeWXUQLQJ VaQe SeRSOe cUa]\. #ZeUeMecWNLE3. AbXVLQJ \RXU CUeaP Rf WKe NaWLRQ. TKLV LV WKe ReaVRQ dRcWRUV LeaYe PaNLVWaQ becaXVe WKe\ aUeWUeaWed OLNe WKLV ! TKe bUXWaOLW\ Rf WKe JRYeUQPeQW KaV MXVW VWaUWed, dRcWRUV aQd WKe fXWXUe RfPaNLVWaQ aUe bOeedLQJ LQ LaKRUe. #PURWeVWAJaLQVWNLE #ReMecWNLE, aWWacKed SKRWRV Rf dRcWRUVUeceLYLQJ WUeaWPeQW fURP cXWV.4. IQ a SaQdePLc ZKeUe WKe ZRUOd LV KRQRULQJ fURQW OLQe PedLcaO ZRUNeUV, RQO\ LQ PaNLVWaQ dReV WKeVWaWe beaW XS PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd dRcWRUV SURWeVWLQJ SeacefXOO\ aJaLQVW aQ LOORJLcaO aQdXQQeceVVaU\ e[aP.5. WaNe XS befRUe WKe bUaLQ dUaLQ UeacKeV aQ aOaUPLQJ OeYeO. We YRWed fRU PTI cRQVLdeULQJ LW WR be aSaUW\ cRQceUQed fRU \RXWK. DRQW OeW RXU KRSeV dRZQ.2046. GLYe XV deaWK VeQWeQceV UaWKeU WKaQ WKLV VKLW NLE..VWRS SOa\LQJ ZLWK RXU ePRWLRQV.. SOeaVe VWRSbUaLQ dUaLQ.. dRQW SOa\ ZLWK WKe fXWXUe Rf PaNLVWaQ.7. WK\ aUe Ze aOZa\V Pade WR feeO WKaW cKRRVLQJ MBBS, eVSecLaOO\ beLQJ LQ PaNLVWaQ, ZaV QRW aZLVe decLVLRQ . WKeQ ZLOO WKe JRYeUQPeQW VLQceUeO\ VXSSRUW dRcWRUV?8. TKLV LV QRW MXVW aQ e[aP. IW LV a PeaQV WR e[WUacW PRQe\ eYeU\ 5 \eaUV. A J\QecRORJLVW aQd aQeXURVXUJeRQ ZLOO KaYe WR WaNe WKe VaPe e[aP eYeU\ 5 \eaUV. WKaW cRXOd be PRUe LOORJLcaO WKaQWKLV? #ZeUeMecWNLE9. PMC LV SaVVLQJ ULdLcXORXV UXOeV WR WRUWXUe PedLcaO VWXdeQWV.WK\ WR JLYe NLE Lf Ze SaVVed aOOSURffV KeUe LQ GRYW cRQWUROOed V\VWeP.If GRYW. LV dRXbWfXO abRXW aQ\ LQVWLWXWLRQ UaLVe LWV VWaQdaUdVRU bOacN OLVW WKaW...VLPSOe!10. YRXU KRVSLWaOV dR QRW fXQcWLRQ OLNe WKe NHS LQ WKe UK RU WKe VWaQdaUdV Rf WKe USA. SWRS WKLVcRPSaULVRQ Rf e[aPV ZKeQ WKe V\VWePV aUe PLOeV aSaUW!11. Sa\ QR WR cRUUXSW PMC ZKLcK LV SOa\LQJ ZLWK WKe OLYeV aQd caUeeU Rf WKRXVaQdV Rf fXWXUe DRcWRUV.12. FedeUaO JRYW. aXdLWRUV KaYe fRXQd PMC WR be JXLOW\ Rf LUUeJXOaULWLeV.13. FLUVW WKe\ dLdQ'W JLYe XV eQRXJK WLPe WR SUeSaUe, QRZ WR PaNe LW ZRUVe WKe\'Ue JLYLQJ TXeVWLRQVZKLcK aUeQ'W a SaUW Rf RXU V\OOabXV aV ZeOO.20514. LRJLcaOO\ aQd OaZfXOO\ Ze aUe RQ ULJKW! Ze dRQ'W Qeed a OaZ\eU WR JRYeUQ XV! #ZeReMecWNLE#ZeUeMecWPMC15. NRZ aQ\RQe ZLOO MRLQ RU UeJLVWeU #NLE. He/SKe LV QRW RQe Rf XV.16. PMC caQQRW LPSOePeQW LWV QeZ SROLcLeV RQ UeWURVSecWLYe baWcKeV WKaW JRW adPLVVLRQV XQdeUPMDC UXOeV aQd UeJXOaWLRQV 2018. IW caQ RQO\ be LPSOePeQWed RQ WKe VeVVLRQV WKaW JRW AdPLVVLRQXQdeU PMC RXOeV aQd ReJXOaWLRQV.17. JRLQ WKe ZRRP VeVVLRQ ZLWK DU. AUVKad TaTL WR JeW a cKaQce WR XQdeUVWaQd WKe UaWLRQaOe beKLQdWKe NLE...18. WK\ aUe \RX dUaJJLQJ WKe PaWWeU VR ORQJ WKaW WKe URad KaV WR be cORVed? CRQJUaWXOaWLRQV WRIPUaQ KKaQ fRU WKLV XQLTXe V\VWeP Rf cXUVLQJ!19. IW'V QRW eYeQ LOOeJaO bXW SaWKeWLc RQ VR PaQ\ JURXQdV WR XVe VXcK LUULWaQWV aQd cKePLcaOV!EYeU\WKLQJ ZLOO be UePePbeUed20. POeaVe VWRS MRLQLQJ NLE SUeSaUaWLRQ JURXSV aQd dRQ'W UeJLVWeU \RXUVeOf. IT'S HIGH TIME WETAKE A STAND FOR OURSELVES.206Appendi[ C - An E[ample of Defining VecWors in NLP Anal\sis207ASSHQGL[ D - TRS 100 WRUGV NLP AQaO\VLV1. BaU GUaSK RI WKH TRS 100 WRUGV202. HHaWPaS UVLQJ WKH TRS 100 WRUGV AERYH20 3. RHILQHG TRS 100 WRUGV UVLQJ NVLYR2104. HHaWPaS UVLQJ WKH RHILQHG TRS 100 WRUGV AERYH211Appendi[ E - Te[W of RecrXiWmenW EmailTKe beORZ We[W ZLOO be LQcOXded LQ cRUUeVSRQdeQce ZLWK SRWeQWLaO UeVSRQdeQWV ZKR aUe cRQQecWed ZLWK WKeUeVeaUcK WeaP ± WKe cRUUeVSRQdeQce accRPSaQ\LQJ WKLV We[W ZLOO be SeUVRQaOL]ed WR WKe UeVSRQdeQW aQdWKeLU SULRU LQWeUacWLRQV ZLWK UeVeaUcK WeaP PePbeUV.DeaU [NaPe RI PRWeQWLaO ReVSRQdeQW]:GUeeWLQJV. M\ QaPe LV RabLa CKaXdKU\, aQd I aP a UeVeaUcKeU aW WKe ScKRRO RI PRSXOaWLRQ aQd PXbOLcHeaOWK (SPPH), UQLYeUVLW\ RI BULWLVK CROXPbLa. I aP ZULWLQJ ZLWK UeJaUd WR a VWXd\ WKaW I aP cRQdXcWLQJaV SaUW RI P\ MSc WKeVLV aW SPPH.SSecLILcaOO\, Ze aUe cRQdXcWLQJ WKLV VWXd\ WR XQdeUVWaQd WKe UROe RI PedLcaO VWXdeQW aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV¶UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQ PaNLVWaQ. TKURXJK WKLV VWXd\, Ze aLP WR e[SORUeWKe Za\V LQ ZKLcK WKeVe JURXSV aUe RUJaQL]ed, WKeLU SROLc\ dePaQdV, adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV, aQd WKeRSSRUWXQLWLeV aQd baUULeUV WKaW WKe\ Iace.I ZoXld like Wo inYiWe \oX Wo parWicipaWe in an inWerYieZ Wo discXss \oXr YieZpoinWs on Whese Wopics.YRXU e[SeULeQce aW [RUJaQL]aWLRQ QaPe] aQd \RXU XQdeUVWaQdLQJ RI PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRU¶VRUJaQL]aWLRQV ZRXOd SURYLde Ne\ LQVLJKWV aQd \RXU SeUVSecWLYeV ZRXOd be LPSRUWaQW WR caSWXUe LQ WKLVZRUN. YRX ZLOO QRW be LdeQWLILed LQ WKe aQaO\VLV aQd ZULWLQJ SURdXced aV a UeVXOW RI WKLV VWXd\.II \RX aJUee WR SaUWLcLSaWe, Ze ZLOO UeTXeVW a ZRRP PeeWLQJ IRU aSSUR[. 30 PLQXWeV WR RQe KRXU aW a WLPeRI \RXU cKRRVLQJ. TKe LQWeUYLeZ ZLOO be cRQdXcWed b\ P\VeOI aQd DU. VeeQa SULUaP, a SURIeVVRU aW WKeUQLYeUVLW\ RI BULWLVK CROXPbLa. We ZLOO VKaUe a YeUbaO cRQVeQW IRUP YLa ePaLO SULRU WR LQLWLaWLQJ WKeLQWeUYLeZ. We ZLOO aOVR JLYe \RX a bURad RXWOLQe RI WKe WRSLcV WKaW Ze ZLOO VeeN WR cRYeU.POeaVe dR QRW KeVLWaWe WR OeW Pe NQRZ LI \RX KaYe aQ\ TXeVWLRQV RU cRQceUQV. TKaQN \RX IRU cRQVLdeULQJWKLV UeTXeVW aQd Ze ORRN IRUZaUd WR KeaULQJ IURP \RX.BeVW ZLVKeV,RabLa CKaXdKU\212Appendi[ F - Informed Verbal ConsenW and ParWicipanW InformaWionSWXd\ TiWle: Role of Medical SWXdenW and ResidenW DocWors' RepresenWaWiYe Organi]aWionsin HealWh Polic\ Processes in PakisWanPrincipal InYesWigaWor:VeeQa SULUaPAVVLVWaQW PURIeVVRU, ScKRRO RI PXbOLc PROLc\ aQd GORbaO AIIaLUV aQd ScKRRO RI PRSXOaWLRQ aQd PXbOLcHeaOWKUQLYeUVLW\ RI BULWLVK CROXPbLaCo-InYesWigaWors: Sorcha Broph\, R\an Esse[, Jerr\ SpiegelWhaW \oX shoXld knoZ aboXW Whis sWXd\● YRX aUe beLQJ aVNed WR MRLQ a UeVeaUcK VWXd\.● TKLV cRQVeQW IRUP e[SOaLQV WKe UeVeaUcK VWXd\ aQd \RXU SaUW LQ WKe VWXd\.● POeaVe Uead WKe cRQVeQW IRUP caUeIXOO\ aQd WaNe aV PXcK WLPe aV \RX Qeed.PXrpose of research sWXd\TKe JRaO RI WKLV UeVeaUcK VWXd\ LV WR XQdeUVWaQd WKe UROe RI PedLcaO VWXdeQW aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV¶UeSUeVeQWaWLYe RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQ PaNLVWaQ WKURXJK a OaQdVcaSe aQaO\VLV RI WKe Ne\UeSUeVeQWaWLYe JURXSV. We aUe e[SORULQJ RUJaQL]aWLRQaO VWUXcWXUeV, SROLc\ dePaQdV, adYRcac\ VWUaWeJLeV,RSSRUWXQLWLeV aQd baUULeUV Iaced b\ WKeVe RUJaQL]aWLRQV.213Wh\ \oX are being asked Wo parWicipaWeWe aUe LQYLWLQJ \RX WR SaUWLcLSaWe LQ RXU VWXd\ becaXVe RI \RXU UROe aV a cXUUeQW RU IRUPeU PePbeU RUOeadeU RI aQ RUJaQL]aWLRQ UeSUeVeQWLQJ PedLcaO VWXdeQWV aQd/RU UeVLdeQW dRcWRUV LQ PaNLVWaQ, RU aV \RXU UROeaV a Ne\ e[SeUW RU VWaNeKROdeU.SWXd\ procedXresII \RX aJUee WR MRLQ WKe VWXd\, Ze ZLOO aVN \RX WR WeOO XV abRXW \RXU e[SeULeQceV WKURXJK aQ LQWeUYLeZ,ZKLcK ZLOO WaNe SOace b\ ZRRP RU GRRJOe MeeW. IW ZLOO WaNe 45 WR 60 PLQXWeV aQd ZLOO be cRQdXcWed b\ DU.RabLa CKaXdKU\, WKe Oead UeVeaUcKeU cRQdXcWLQJ WKLV VWXd\. TKe LQWeUYLeZ ZLOO be cRQdXcWed LQ UUdX RUEQJOLVK. YRX aUe IUee WR VNLS aQ\ TXeVWLRQV WKaW \RX dR QRW IeeO cRPIRUWabOe aQVZeULQJ aQd Pa\ VWRS WKeLQWeUYLeZ aW aQ\ WLPe. TKe LQWeUYLeZ ZLOO be aXdLR-UecRUded SURYLded \RX JLYe XV \RXU cRQVeQW. II QRW, ZeZLOO WaNe deWaLOed QRWeV dXULQJ WKe cRQYeUVaWLRQ.IQ WKe eYeQW WKaW \RX YROXQWaULO\ VKaUe aQ\ dRcXPeQWV ZLWK XV IRU WKe SXUSRVeV RI WKLV VWXd\, WKeVedRcXPeQWV ZLOO be VaIeO\ VWRUed b\ RXU UeVeaUcK WeaP. II dRcXPeQWV aUe VKaUed b\ eQcU\SWed ePaLO, WKeVeZLOO be VWRUed RQ RXU UeVeaUcK WeaP¶V cORXd-baVed VeUYeU (OQeDULYe). II \RX VKaUe a SK\VLcaO cRS\ RI WKedRcXPeQWV, WKeVe ZLOO be VWRUed b\ WKe UeVeaUcK WeaP LQ a VecXUe ORcaWLRQ RQ WKe UBC caPSXV LQVaQcRXYeU, B.C.VolXnWar\ ParWicipaWionYRXU SaUWLcLSaWLRQ LQ WKLV VWXd\ LV YROXQWaU\. YRX caQ cKRRVe QRW WR WaNe SaUW LQ WKLV VWXd\ aQd LI \RX MRLQ,\RX Pa\ OeaYe WKe LQWeUYLeZ aW aQ\ WLPe. TKeUe ZLOO be QR cRQVeTXeQceV LI \RX decLde WR TXLW WKe UeVeaUcKVWXd\.214ProWecWing \oXr priYac\ dXring daWa collecWionTKe LQ-deSWK LQWeUYLeZ ZLOO be cRQdXcWed RYeU a SULYaWe SKRQe/YLUWXaO cRQYeUVaWLRQ WR OLPLW WKe SRVVLbLOLW\WKaW RWKeUV QRW LQYROYed LQ WKe dLVcXVVLRQ RYeUKeaU. NR VeQVLWLYe TXeVWLRQV ZLOO be aVNed LQ WKe LQWeUYLeZ.II WKe LQWeUYLeZ WaNeV SOace RYeU ZRRP, SOeaVe ORJ LQ XVLQJ RQO\ a QLcNQaPe RU a VXbVWLWXWe QaPe VR WKaW\RX caQQRW be LdeQWLILed. YRX Pa\ WXUQ RII \RXU caPeUa aQd \RX caQ aOVR PXWe \RXU PLcURSKRQe LI LW LVQRW UeTXLUed.DaWa confidenWialiW\DXULQJ WKe LQ-deSWK LQWeUYLeZ, Ze ZLOO cROOecW LQIRUPaWLRQ IURP \RX SeUWaLQLQJ WR \RXU SeUVSecWLYeV RQ WKeUROe RI PedLcaO VWXdeQW aQd UeVLdeQW dRcWRU RUJaQL]aWLRQV LQ KeaOWK SROLc\ SURceVVeV LQ PaNLVWaQ. OQO\ WKeVWXd\ WeaP ZLOO KaYe acceVV WR WKe LQIRUPaWLRQ Ze WaON abRXW WRda\. AOO VWXd\ PePbeUV KaYe beeQ WUaLQedWR NeeS WKe LQIRUPaWLRQ cRQILdeQWLaO. IQ a VeSaUaWe ILOe, Ze ZLOO VWRUe \RXU QaPe aQd SKRQe QXPbeU, aQdaVVLJQ \RX a VSecLaO cRde. OQO\ WKe VWXd\ WeaP ZLOO KaYe acceVV WR WKLV LQIRUPaWLRQ aQd WKe daWa ZLOO beeQcU\SWed. We ZLOO QRW cRQQecW \RXU QaPe RU aQ\ LdeQWLI\LQJ LQIRUPaWLRQ ZLWK WKLV LQWeUYLeZ. IQIRUPaWLRQIURP RXU LQWeUYLeZ aQd WKe aXdLR UecRUdLQJ ZLOO be VWRUed XQdeU WKLV cRde. AIWeU WKe aXdLR UecRUdLQJ LVWUaQVcULbed, Ze ZLOO deOeWe LW. NR QaPeV RU LdeQWLI\LQJ LQIRUPaWLRQ ZLOO be LQcOXded LQ aQ\ UeSRUWV IURPWKLV UeVeaUcK. NR SKRWRV RU YLdeRV ZLOO be WaNeQ. We ZLOO NeeS aOO UeVeaUcK IRUPV LQ SaVVZRUd-SURWecWedcRPSXWeU ILOeV WKaW RQO\ UeVeaUcK VWaII caQ acceVV.DaWa SharingAQ\ LQIRUPaWLRQ cROOecWed IURP WKLV UeVeaUcK VWXd\ ZLOO be XVed VROeO\ IRU UeVeaUcK SXUSRVeV. OQO\aXWKRUL]ed UeVeaUcK VWaII PePbeUV ZLOO KaYe acceVV WR dRcXPeQWV aQd LQIRUPaWLRQ UeOaWed WR WKe UeVeaUcK.SXPPaU\ RI ILQdLQJV IURP WKLV UeVeaUcK VWXd\ ZLOO be dLVVePLQaWed LQ WKe IRUP UeSRUWV RU SXbOLVKed LQVcLeQWLILc MRXUQaOV, bXW QR LQIRUPaWLRQ WKaW PLJKW LdeQWLI\ \RX ZLOO be SXbOLVKed.215Ongoing consenWWe PLJKW cRQWacW \RX IRU a IROORZ-XS LQWeUYLeZ beIRUe WKe VWXd\ cRQcOXdeV. TKLV IROORZ-XS LQWeUYLeZ ZLOOWaNe QR PRUe WKaQ 30 PLQXWeV. CRQVeQW SURYLded dXULQJ WKe ILUVW LQWeUYLeZ ZLOO be PaLQWaLQed IRU WKedXUaWLRQ RI WKe VWXd\. YRX caQ cKRRVe WR decOLQe SaUWLcLSaWLQJ LQ WKLV IROORZ- XS LQWeUYLeZ ± LW LV eQWLUeO\YROXQWaU\.WhaW happens if \oX leaYe Whe sWXd\ earl\?YRX Pa\ OeaYe WKLV UeVeaUcK VWXd\ aW aQ\ WLPe. II \RX cKRRVe WR OeaYe, Ze ZLOO RQO\ XVe LQIRUPaWLRQ WKaW\RX KaYe SURYLded WR UeVeaUcK VWaII XS WR WKaW SRLQW.CosW of parWicipaWion in Whe sWXd\TKeUe LV QR cRVW WR SaUWLcLSaWe LQ WKLV VWXd\. TKe RQO\ cRVW WR \RX IURP WKLV VWXd\ LV WKe WLPe WKaW \RX ZLOOVSeQd WaONLQJ ZLWK XV, ZKLcK ZLOO be beWZeeQ 45 ± 60 PLQXWeV.SWXd\ fXnding TKLV VWXd\ LV SaUWO\ IXQded b\ WKe CaQada ReVeaUcK CKaLUV PURJUaP (VeeQa SULUaP, TLeU 2CaQada ReVeaUcK CKaLU LQ GORbaO HeaOWK PROLc\).Who do I call if I haYe qXesWions or problems?II \RX KaYe aQ\ cRQceUQV RU cRPSOaLQWV abRXW \RXU ULJKWV aV a UeVeaUcK SaUWLcLSaQW aQd/RU \RXUe[SeULeQceV ZKLOe SaUWLcLSaWLQJ LQ WKLV VWXd\, cRQWacW WKe ReVeaUcK PaUWLcLSaQW CRPSOaLQW LLQe LQ WKe UBCOIILce RI ReVeaUcK EWKLcV aW 604-822-8598 RU LI ORQJ dLVWaQce e-PaLO RSIL@RUV.Xbc.ca RU caOO WROO IUee1-877-822-8598.216 If \oX haYe an\ qXesWions aboXW Whe sWXd\ or ZoXld like Wo change \oXr parWicipaWion sWaWXs in WhissWXd\, please conWacW:VeeQa SULUaPPULQcLSaO IQYeVWLJaWRUAVVLVWaQW PURIeVVRU, ScKRRO RI PXbOLc PROLc\ aQd GORbaO AIIaLUV aQd ScKRRO RI PRSXOaWLRQ aQd PXbOLcHeaOWKUQLYeUVLW\ RI BULWLVK CROXPbLaVaQcRXYeU, BCPERMISSION TO PROCEEDIQWeUYLeZeU: POeaVe aXdLR UecRUd WKe UeVSRQVeV Rf SaUWLcLSaQWV WR WKe TXeVWLRQV VeeNLQJ cRQVeQW beORZDo \oX consenW Wo parWicipaWe in Whe sWXd\?Yes NoIf \es, do \oX proYide \oXr consenW Wo aXdio record Whis conYersaWion?Yes No217
Thesis/Dissertation
eng
Population and Public Health
Vancouver : University of British Columbia Library
Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International
Graduate
Sriram, Veena
Role of medical student and resident doctors' representative organizations in health policy process in Pakistan
Text