UBC Research Data

Data from: Climate and leaf traits, not latitude, explain variation in plant‐herbivore interactions across a species’ range Loughnan, Deirdre; Williams, Jennifer L.


1. Spatial variation in abiotic and biotic factors creates local contexts that influence the intensity of plant‐herbivore interactions. Some previous studies have accounted for the complexity of these interactions with latitudinal clines, while the absence of such clines in many other systems suggests other, often unknown, local community factors may instead explain the variation in herbivory across populations. 2. We investigated plant‐herbivore interactions across the entire range of a long‐lived tree (Quercus garryana), evaluating the relative importance of climate, latitude, population size, and insect feeding guilds in determining leaf phenotype and the extent and variation in insect herbivory. In this ecosystem, rain shadows create a nonlinear relationship between climate and latitude, allowing us to disentangle the effects of environmental factors. By performing similar analyses on trees grown in a common garden, we were able to assess the relative importance of environmental factors to leaf defence traits and herbivory. 3. Total herbivory varied significantly among populations, and was best explained by variation in spring precipitation, leaf traits, and tree population size, but not latitude. The relative importance of each of these factors changed over the growing season and with insect feeding guild. Conversely, damage in the common garden did not vary among trees from different origins when grown in a constant environment, leading us to believe variation in damage in natural populations is more likely the result of the local environments. 4. Leaf traits (trichome density and specific leaf area) varied significantly among populations, but neither showed an effect of latitude. Variation in both traits was best explained by tree size, and seasonal temperatures or precipitation. We found no variation in insect diversity among field populations, but abundance varied with mean summer precipitation and population size. 5. Synthesis: Seasonal precipitation consistently explained the geographic variation in the extent of herbivory to Q. garryana, while latitude and winter temperatures, factors that are commonly associated with latitudinal gradients in the intensity of species interactions, did not. Our findings highlight the importance of local climates and functional traits in shaping biotic interactions and intraspecific variation in plant‐insect interactions across large spatial scales.; Usage notes
Loughnan&Williams_HerbivorydataInsect herbivory data on Quercus garryana collected from both a common garden and natural populations spanning the entire latitudinal range of this tree species. Data was collected for immature leaves early in the growing season and for mature leaves at the end of the season. Damage by chewing, skeletonizing, and mining insects was visually estimated and total damage calculated. In addition, tree height, diameter at breast height, and a population size category were also recorded. See the README file and description of Methods in the paper for metadata.Loughnan&Williams_TraitdataTrait data collected from leaves used for herbivory estimates for both early and late season sampling periods. Traits measured include specific leaf area and trichome density. See the README file for metadata.Loughnan&Williams_InsectdataInsect herbivore community data collected during the spring sampling period. A subsample of the insect community was collected from a 50 cm segment of Q. garryana branch. The number of unique species and number of individual insects were recorded. See the README file for metadata.

Item Media

Item Citations and Data


CC0 Waiver

Usage Statistics