UBC Undergraduate Research

An Investigation into Polystyrene Recycling at UBC Gu, Ricky; Lee, Oscar; Salehzadah, Yusef 2010

You don't seem to have a PDF reader installed, try download the pdf

Item Metadata

Download

Media
[if-you-see-this-DO-NOT-CLICK]
APSC262_Styrofoam_Group3_CLEAN%20FINAL.pdf [ 98.18kB ]
[if-you-see-this-DO-NOT-CLICK]
Metadata
JSON: 1.0108209.json
JSON-LD: 1.0108209+ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 1.0108209.xml
RDF/JSON: 1.0108209+rdf.json
Turtle: 1.0108209+rdf-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 1.0108209+rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 1.0108209 +original-record.json
Full Text
1.0108209.txt
Citation
1.0108209.ris

Full Text

         SEEDS Student Reports    1  UBC Social, Ecological Economic Development Studies (SEEDS) Student Reports          An Investigation into Polystyrene Recycling at UBC  Ricky Gu Oscar Lee Yusef Salehzadah University of British Columbia APSC 262 April 2010             Disclaimer: “UBC SEEDS provides students with the opportunity to share the findings of their studies, as well as their opinions, conclusions and recommendations with the UBC community. The reader should bear in mind that this is a student project/report and is not an official document of UBC. Furthermore readers should bear in mind that these reports may not reflect the current status of activities at UBC. We urge you to contact the research persons mentioned in a report or the SEEDS Coordinator about the current status of the subject matter of a project/report.”      An Investigation into Polystyrene Recycling at UBC By Ricky Gu, Oscar Lee, and Yusef Salehzadah       Dawn Mills APSC 262  The University of British Columbia April 2, 2010    2 ABSTRACT Polystyrene waste is a large portion of UBC’s daily overall waste. UBC has 350 active hazardous waste generating laboratories that dispose of polystyrene. This practice is not sustainable in the long term due to the fact that polystyrene is not biodegradable and continues to occupy space in landfills. An estimated $25,000 is needed per year to carry out a campus wide recycling program for polystyrene with a local company, Pacific Mobile Depots. After investigating the pilot program that UBC is currently implementing at the Brain Research Centre, it is apparent that carrying polystyrene recycling program with Pacific Mobile Depots is not sustainable. This is because the program is not cost efficient or beneficial for the environment due to the high costs of transportation. A sustainable alternative to the current pilot program is to invest in a polystyrene compactor on campus that can process polystyrene waste into a valuable commodity. At a price of only $35,000 for the compactor, UBC’s return on investment (ROI) is less than 2 years in comparison to paying Pacific Mobile Depots $25,000 per their services.            3 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT 2 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 4 GLOSSARY 5 1.0 INTRODUCTION 6 2.0 ABOUT POLYSTYRENE 7 3.0 ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES 9 4.0 AQUA-PAK 10 5.0 UBC PILOT PROGRAM 12 6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS 13 CONCLUSION 16 REFERENCES 17           4 LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS FIGURES Figure 1 Chemical composition of polystyrene 7  Figure 2 The extrusion process 8  TABLES  Table 1 Comparison of polystyrene compactors  13               5 GLOSSARY Biodegradable Capable of decomposing.  Extrusion When material is pushed through a die to create a shape.  Monomer A simple chemical molecular entity that can combine with other monomers to form more complex structures.  Molding Creating something by casting it in a mold.  Polymer A chemical compound of molecules consisting of repeating simple monomers.  Polystyrene A lightweight plastic often used for insulation and as a food container.  Sustainability  Using resources in a manner that meets current needs without negatively affecting future generations.          6 1.0 INTRODUCTION Styrofoam is a name trademarked by Dow Chemical Company for extruded polystyrene foam (Dow Chemical Company, 2010). Styrofoam is often used as a generic term for all products produced from polystyrene. Polystyrene products are common throughout the world. Retail boxes, food containers, and building insulation are just some of the many types of products that are produced from polystyrene.  Due to the inexpensive manufacturing cost of polystyrene, the demand for its insulating and protective properties is very high. The product is not biodegradable and is currently being recycled poorly throughout the world (American Chemistry Council, 2010). Therefore, there is great interest in recycling technologies to reduce the amount of polystyrene waste in landfills. Most of the world’s polystyrene products are not recycled. Recycling programs for polystyrene are not currently in place on a large scale (Styro-Tech, 2009). However, there are methods available to recycle and reuse polystyrene that are not yet getting major attention from large companies and institutions. UBC is currently testing a limited polystyrene recycling program that is not sustainable on a campus-wide scale (UBC Sustainability, 2010). This report will provide background information on polystyrene, methods of recycling, information on the limited UBC recycling program and why it is not sustainable, and recommendations that UBC should put in place in order to effectively manage polystyrene waste.       7 2.0 ABOUT POLYSTYRENE Polystyrene has a chemical composition of carbon and hydrogen (C8H8)n . Styrene is the naturally occurring monomer that makes up the polymer, polystyrene (American Chemistry Council, 2010).  A chemical composition of polystyrene is illustrated in Figure 1.   Figure 1: Chemical composition of polystyrene Source: Padleckas, H. 2005.   Polystyrene is an inert chemical. This means that it is very stable and will not start react with other chemicals (American Chemistry Council, 2010). This chemical property makes polystyrene a very desirable material to be used as food containers and other storage containers . There is no fear that the polystyrene container and food items will mix to create a harmful resultant chemical. There are several ways to manufacture polystyrene products. The most common methods are injection molding, extrusion, and expanding (Styro-Tech, 2009). A chemical property of polystyrene is that it becomes soft when heated. This property makes injection molding very easy. Polystyrene is heated until it is soft and then placed into a mold cavity. The polystyrene cools and hardens into the shape of the mold cavity (Harden Machinery, 2010). Extrusion is a production method that results in a rigid final product. Rigidity is desirable for products such as toys, cutlery, CD cases, and license plate frames. In extrusion, polystyrene is pushed through a pre-cut shape. The resulting polystyrene that is pushed out conforms to the shape that it was pushed through (Harden Machinery, 2010). The extrusion process is illustrated in Figure 2.  8  Figure 2: The extrusion process Source: Brown, Tyler. 2008.  Expanding polystyrene is another method in which polystyrene products are produced. Small, dense polystyrene beads are placed into a mold cavity. The mold is then placed into an expander where it is heated with steam. The steam causes the polystyrene beads to expand and stick to each other until the mold cavity is entirely filled. The resulting polystyrene product is then cooled and made ready for distribution (American Chemistry Council, 2010).       9 3.0 ENVIRONMENTAL CONSEQUENCES Polystyrene has a low scrap value and is difficult to transport. Because of this, most polystyrene is thrown into landfills instead of being recycled. Because polystyrene is not biodegradable, it remains in landfills with no value. This practice is not sustainable as there is limited land available for waste storage Landfills are designed to take products that do not biodegrade because the process of biodegradation can emit harmful liquid and gaseous by-products. These harmful by- products contaminate soil, ground water, and air (Styro-Tech, 2009). Since polystyrene does not biodegrade, it is not immediately harmful to place it in landfills. The inert characteristics of polystyrene make sure that it does not cause any contamination. However, this method of polystyrene disposal is not sustainable for the following reasons: 1. Polystyrene does not decompose. It will reside in landfills and will continue taking up space. As more polystyrene is created, it will take up even more space. 2. Polystyrene products are very low in density. Polystyrene products are composed mostly of air. This means trucking these materials to landfills is very inefficient because a truck load of polystyrene products may only be 5% in actual polystyrene. This causes pollution and a large carbon foot print from the fuel used in transportation (Wastefree UBC, 2009).  3. Polystyrene is fully recyclable.  Due to these reasons, polystyrene recycling is a more sustainable approach in dealing with polystyrene waste.      10 4.0 AQUA-PAK Aqua-Pak is a company that produces expanded polystyrene packaging for protection, insulation, and aesthetics (Aqua-Pak, 2009). Operations at the Surrey, B.C. plant began in 1987 in response to a demand for insulated packaging by the salmon farming industry. Since then, Aqua-Pak has expanded its products into other industries in which expanded polystyrene packaging is needed.  Aqua-Pak’s main business is supplying polystyrene packaging for perishable food items such as fish, insulated concrete forms for insulation inside buildings, trays for potted plants, and custom packaging (Aqua-Pak, 2009). Aqua-Pak also plays a part in the recycling process of polystyrene. Aqua-Pak purchases used expanded polystyrene and processes it through a compactor. Aqua-Pak then sells the resulting compressed polystyrene to Timbron and Netco, companies based in California, USA, that use the recycled polystyrene to produce goods (Timbron International, 2010). Timbron produces decorative non-structural household products while Netco produces picture frames. This process in particular is one that draws interest. Aqua-Pak buys used expanded polystyrene from companies and institutions that have no use for the polystyrene (Aqua-Pak, 2009).  The used expanded polystyrene is brought in to the shipping and receiving area in Surrey, B.C. via trucks. This method of transportation is unfavourable as trucks leave a large carbon footprint. However, there is no viable alternative method of transportation for the polystyrene.  Aqua-Pak then feeds the used polystyrene into a polystyrene compactor (Aqua-Pak, 2009). The compactor reduces the polystyrene by a factor of 50. The compactor has two components that work in tandem to produce compacted polystyrene logs (Harden Machinery, 2010). The pre-breaker first breaks the polystyrene into small flakes.  The auger compactor then presses the polystyrene flakes into dense logs. These polystyrene logs are then packaged, placed on pallets, and loaded into trucks where they are driven to California. Timbron and Netco purchase the polystyrene logs to produce recycled goods.   11 Timbron and Netco melt the polystyrene and blend it with other materials (Timbron International, 2010). This mixture is then put through a molding machine to get the desired outcome. The resulting product is painted and packaged for distribution. The process is fairly standard among product manufacturers. The only unique part of the process is that the materials used are a blend of recycled polystyrene and other additives.                  12 5.0 UBC PILOT PROGRAM UBC generates over 12 tonnes of garbage daily (Wastefree UBC, 2000). Much of that waste is from UBC Food Services. 40% of the waste generated at Food Services consists of disposable containers, such as coffee cups, plates, and boxes. At present, used polystyrene of any kind is thrown in trash along with other waste items. Much wasted polystyrene is being sent to dumps when the potential to recycle is so great. However, initiatives are being taken by UBC Health, Safety and Environment (HSE) to encourage polystyrene recycling (UBC Health, Safety, and Environment, 2009). The Brain Research Centre, which consists of nine labs at the UBC Hospital, is currently piloting a four-month polystyrene recycling project (UBC Sustainability, 2010). Clean polystyrene boxes and chips/peanuts are placed into separate bags. Trucks from Pacific Mobile Depots then collect these bags from the UBC Hospital loading dock at a charge of $5 per bag. The bags of polystyrene are sent to Aqua-Pak where they compaction process begins. The polystyrene recycling initiative by the HSE is not feasible on a campus-wide basis. While data has yet to be released, it is apparent that this pilot cannot be scaled and adapted to fit the entire UBC campus. The charge $5 per bag is too costly for the amount of polystyrene that UBC produces. In order to justify the cost, UBC’s polystyrene waste needs to be drastically reduced.        13 6.0 RECOMMENDATIONS  UBC has the resources needed to implement a polystyrene recycling system on campus. The main component consists of a polystyrene compactor. The cost of owning a polystyrene compactor is approximately 35 thousand dollars (Harden Machinery, 2010). A polystyrene compactor can be purchased from manufacturers in countries around the world, including the US and China.   The machine is simple to control and can be operated by a UBC custodian staff. As illustrated in Table 1, a large polystyrene compactor is 124" x 29.5" x 78.7" in size (Harden Machinery, 2010). This indicates that the polystyrene can be stationed within a small sized room or facility on campus. Furthermore, UBC has plenty of unused land available in which the compactor can reside.   Model CP100 CP180 CP250 CP370 Total motor power HP 2.2 3.2 7.6 14.8 Styrofoam Volume reduction 40:1 50:1 50:1 50:1 Throughput lb/h 35-55 65-130 175-330 390-700 Feeding capacity f3/h 70-200  175-530 530-880 880-1200 Feed inlet size inch 16"*10.5" 18.3"*13.2" 26.2"*16.9" 37.8"*23" Log dimension inch 4.9"*4.9" 7.1"*7.1" 9.8"*9.8" 14.6"*14.6" Machine weight lb 660 925 1460 3150 Dimensions  inch 78.7"*19.7"*66.9" 85.6"*21.7"*70.1" 98.4"*23.6"*72.8" 124"*29.5"*78.7" Images      Table 1: Comparison of polystyrene compactors  Source: Harden Machinery, 2010.   14 Compared to other initiatives UBC is currently pursuing, the cost of owning a polystyrene compactor is insignificant. By comparison, the construction of the future CIRS Building will cost at least $55 million dollars (Energy Evolution, 2007), not including the inherent maintenance costs of the final product. Similarly, UBC spends a significant amount of money on waste management and reduction each year. With a cost of less than one percent of the CIRS Building, a single staff member can operate the polystyrene compactor year round. Therefore, the machine is worth the purchase at least on an experimental basis.  A polystyrene recycling system can be implemented campus wide. The polystyrene waste would first be collected from buildings and facilities around trucked to the compactor. The polystyrene would then be compacted to approximately 2% of its originally size and extruded from the compactor to form dense polystyrene blocks (Harden Machinery, 2010). Afterwards, UBC would then sell the blocks to companies in North America who would utilize the substance to fabricate new products. There are many companies that buy dense polystyrene blocks. UBC could partner with companies that use recycled polystyrene for home insulation, manufacturing of products, fuel, and more.  Operating a polystyrene compactor on campus is more sustainable than having Pacific Mobile Depots collect polystyrene waste from UBC. The pickup process is largely inefficient, costly, and consumes a lot of energy. Transporting a large amount of polystyrene in its expanded form is difficult due to its high volume. If the polystyrene were compressed into 2% of its original volume, Pacific Mobile Depots would be able to transport fifty times more polystyrene per truck than it does currently. UBC estimates that it would spend 25 thousand dollar annually if it were to expand its current pilot polystyrene program to serve the entire campus. At a cost of only 35 thousand dollars, a compactor is the obvious solution to UBC’s polystyrene recycling needs.  If UBC were able to conduct the compacting process on campus, the university would be able to effectively promote polystyrene recycling elsewhere in the Lower Mainland. Nearby companies and institutions may implement similar compacting processes. Large  15 department stores and electronics stores, which have a lot of polystyrene as a result of their packaging, could recycle the material using the same method. Furthermore, the city of Vancouver may also take notice of the potential of polystyrene recycling and support a more widespread implementation. Even if the city does not intend to send the resulting compressed material to a company which would reuse it, the reduction in volume would put less pressure on British Columbia’s landfills.                           16 6.0 CONCLUSION  Polystyrene continues to be a major problem for the world. Cost effectiveness is the key factor to the excessive use of the product. For this reason it is unlikely to see a reduction in the amount of polystyrene that will be produced in the future. Since the product is not biodegradable, disposing polystyrene waste in landfills is not a sustainable practice, and hence, recycling polystyrene become a needed alternative. There are currently no wide scale polystyrene recycling programs anywhere in the world. By implementing a campus- wide polystyrene recycling program, UBC can promote this practice and show its commitment towards sustainability. Purchasing a polystyrene compactor is the next step in implementing a successful recycling system due to its potential to cut economic and environmental costs while raising UBC’s status socially.                     17 REFERENCES  American Chemistry Council (2010). Polystyrene Facts. Retrieved March 21, 2010 from http://www.americanchemistry.com/s_plastics/sec_pfpg.asp?CID=1421&DID=5213  American Chemistry Council (2010). Polystyrene Frequently Asked Questions. Retrieved March 21, 2010 from http://www.americanchemistry.com/s_plastics/doc_pfpg.asp?CID=1417&DID=5332#19  Aqua-Pak (2009). EPS Packaging Solutions. Retrieved March 17, 2010 from http://aquapak.com/  Brown, Tyler (2008). Photograph retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Polystyrene_formation.PNG  Dow Chemical Company (2010). About Styrofoam Brand Products. Retrieved March 15, 2010 from http://craft.dow.com/about/environ.htm  Energy Evolution (2007). UBC’s Structure Aims to be Greenest Structure on Earth. Retrieved March 23, 2010 form www.cirs.ubc.ca/assets/pdf/media/Energy%20Evolution.pdf  Harden Machinery (2010). Styrofoam Densifier for Volume Reduction of Waste EPS Foam. Retrieved March 17, 2010 from http://www.styrofoam-compactor.com/styrofoam- compactors.html  Padleckas, H. (2005). Photograph retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Extrusion.JPG  Styro-Tech (2009). Expanded Polystyrene Engineering. Retrieved March 21, 2010 from http://www.polystyreneps.com/  Timbron International (2010). Premium Interior Mouldings from Recycled Plastic. Retrieved March 17, 2010 from http://www.timbron.com/  UBC Health, Safety, and Environment (2009). Green Research. Retrieved March 17, 2010 from http://www.hse.ubc.ca/environment/greenresearch/greenresearchnov09.html   18 UBC Sustainability (2010). Green Research Program. Retrieved March 15, 2010 from http://www.sustain.ubc.ca/campus-sustainability/greening-the-campus/green-research- program Wastefree UBC (2009). Wastefree UBC Home. Retrieved March 15, 2010 from http://www.recycle.ubc.ca/wastefree/Wastefreemain.htm 

Cite

Citation Scheme:

    

Usage Statistics

Country Views Downloads
United States 27 2
France 23 0
China 19 0
Iran 17 56
Canada 12 0
Germany 6 0
Hong Kong 4 4
New Zealand 4 0
Japan 3 0
Malaysia 1 0
Argentina 1 0
Belgium 1 0
Brazil 1 0
City Views Downloads
Unknown 55 56
Shenzhen 15 0
Vancouver 10 0
Ashburn 5 0
Central District 4 4
Seattle 4 0
College Park 3 0
Tokyo 3 0
Beijing 3 0
New London 2 0
Surrey 2 0
Grandville 2 0
Kansas City 2 0

{[{ mDataHeader[type] }]} {[{ month[type] }]} {[{ tData[type] }]}
Download Stats

Share

Embed

Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML of your page to embed this item in your website.
                        
                            <div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
                            <script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
                            src="{[{embed.src}]}"
                            data-item="{[{embed.item}]}"
                            data-collection="{[{embed.collection}]}"
                            data-metadata="{[{embed.showMetadata}]}"
                            data-width="{[{embed.width}]}"
                            async >
                            </script>
                            </div>
                        
                    
IIIF logo Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard. To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:
http://iiif.library.ubc.ca/presentation/dsp.18861.1-0108209/manifest

Comment

Related Items