UBC Theses and Dissertations

UBC Theses Logo

UBC Theses and Dissertations

The great northern wilderness : political exiles in the People’s Republic of China Wang, Ning 2005

Your browser doesn't seem to have a PDF viewer, please download the PDF to view this item.

Item Metadata


831-ubc_2005-105844.pdf [ 13.06MB ]
JSON: 831-1.0099851.json
JSON-LD: 831-1.0099851-ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 831-1.0099851-rdf.xml
RDF/JSON: 831-1.0099851-rdf.json
Turtle: 831-1.0099851-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 831-1.0099851-rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 831-1.0099851-source.json
Full Text

Full Text

THE GREAT NORTHERN WILDERNESS: POLITICAL EXILES IN THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA by NING WANG BA., Peking University, 1986 M.A., Peking University, 1989  A THESIS SUBMITED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in THE FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES (History)  THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA October 2005  © Ning Wang, 2005  Abstract In the spring of 1957, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) encouraged intellectuals and students to speak out against the abuses of Party and government officials, with the avowed intention of improving governance. But when criticisms were directed at a wide range of Party policies, the CCP launched the Anti-Rightist Campaign. Those who had called for intellectual and political freedoms, and for curbing corruption, were accused of political subversion. In a nation-wide crackdown, more than half a million Chinese, including intellectuals, Party cadres and government employees, were punished with labels of "rightists" or "counterrevolutionaries." The CCP sent these people to the countryside or to distant frontier regions to engage in "ideological remolding" through manual labor. This thesis focuses on the life, behavior and psychological experiences of those banished from central organizations to Beidahuang in northeastern Manchuria. Three types of political exiles are examined—the rightists in army farms, the ultra-rightists in labor reeducation camps, and the counterrevolutionaries in labor reform camps. In Beidahuang, the political exiles were deployed as forced labor in agriculture, forestry, construction, and other sectors. Treated as political outcasts, they suffered physical and psychological abuse at the hands of Communist officials. Internecine strife exacerbated their misery. Their banishment coincided with the most serious famine (1959-1962) in modern Chinese history. Food shortages, hard labor, and a lack of sufficient medical care resulted in high death rates. Under political pressure, many exiles acknowledged that they had commited errors or "crimes" and made considerable efforts to show signs of repentance, in order to redeem themselves. The end of their banishment to Beidahuang in the early 1960s did not end their torment, which was followed by long-lasting political discrimination. This study reveals the suffering of a specific population of political exiles, but also engages larger issues such as political persecution, forced migration, and the nature of CCP rule.  ii  Table of Contents Abstract  1 1  Table o f Contents  iii  Acknowledgements  iv  Introduction  1  Chapter One: The Anti-Rightist Campaign and Political Labeling  22  Chapter Two: The Beijing Rightists i n the A r m y Farms o f Beidahuang  61  Chapter Three: Political Offenders i n the Labor Camps o f Xingkaihu  87  Chapter Four: Life and Death in Beidahuang  112  Chapter Five: Looking for a Way Out: the Inner World o f the Political E x i l e s . . . . 141 Chapter Six: The E n d Without E n d  165  Conclusion  192  Bibliography  202  Appendix  211  Appendix A : Interview List  211  Appendix B : Glossary  213  Appendix C : M a p o f Beidahuang  215  iii  Acknowledgements I wish to express my appreciation for the support provided by a two-year University Graduate Fellowship from the University of British Columbia, and another two-year doctoral grant from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. These grants proved to be invaluable for my studies in UBC. I am also grateful for Professor Diana Lary, my research supervisor, for her seasoned guidance during the course of this long project. Her insightful ideas, practical advice, and her continuous push have finally helped bring this project to completion. Professor Timothy Cheek provided me with countless hours of advice and academic training. His inputs function not only for improvement of the dissertation but also for my expertise as a historian. My thanks also go to Professor Alexander Woodside, Professor Glen Peterson, Professor Leo Shin, Professor Gu Xiong, Professor Wu Guoguang, and Professor Norman Smith. During my years in UBC, Norman's consistent help and encouragements are unforgettable. The significant portion of source materials for this project come form personal interviews. I am deeply indebted to my interviewees in China, the majority of whom were victims of political persecution. Their experience obligate me to help tell their stories to readers who care about human suffering. Finally, my special thanks go to my daughter Ivy, and her pet "bear," a dwarf rabbit. During the past two years, talking to them constituted a bright spot in my life.  iv  Introduction Wangshi bingbu ruyan D o not let bygones be bygones. — Zhang Yihe  The purposes o f this thesis are multiple: to discuss how a particular form o f forced migration—political banishment—operated in the early P R C period; to show how political exiles—victims o f a mass persecution—fared i n the border regions o f northeastern China (Manchuria); and to investigate the patterns o f behavior and the mentality o f Chinese intellectuals i n exile.  Theme and Scope During the years 1957 and 1958, hundreds o f thousands o f Chinese, mostly intellectuals, were rendered victims o f a political campaign—the  Anti-Rightist  Campaign and were labeled "rightists" or "counterrevolutionaries" by the Chinese Communist Party ( C C P ) . A s part o f the persecution, the majority o f them were banished to distant frontier regions, or to the countryside or were simply put i n j a i l , and ended up in various forms o f forced labor. They had to perform heavy manual work and suffered maltreatment at the hands o f Communist officials. For those attacked in Beijing, the national capital, the attack was especially violent and the punishment severe. M a n y o f them were sent to labor camps i n the northeastern border region known as Beidahuang, the Great Northern Wilderness. M a n y stayed there for more than twenty years; still many others died o f starvation, disease and over-work, leaving broken families behind. The Anti-Rightist Campaign has long been discussed by academics, but the individual experiences o f the persecuted during and after the campaign have been largely ignored; a significant part o f the human suffering has been left out o f  1  systematic treatment by both Chinese and Western historians. This thesis examines the general pattern o f banishment to the northeastern border region, the life experiences, the patterns o f behavior and the mentalities o f the political exiles banished from Beijing, evaluates the success o f the social and ideological control o f the ruling party through intimidation, coercion and manipulation, and looks at the social consequence o f the frontier banishment. Why focus on those banished from Beijing and why on Beidahuang? There are four  reasons.  First, the  northeastern  border  region, with  its harsh  natural  environment and isolated geographical location, was long regarded by imperial rulers as the ideal place for physical punishment o f various offenders. The C C P government continued this practice. Second, the mass persecution coincided with an ambitious state program o f land reclamation in Northeastern China; the banishment o f political offenders there provided abundant forced labor, and thus suited the need o f a government economic adventure. Third, i n a general way, the political exiles from Beijing were among China's best educated elite members, therefore an exploration as to how they fared i n one o f China's harshest regions will be illuminating.  1  Fourth, the political exiles from Beijing, many o f whom were  journalists and writers, have left numerous valuable resources, which make research on their collective experience possible. W i t h regard to the political purge o f 1957, China specialists have been confronted with at least three fundamental questions. The first one involves the identification o f the persecuted. A r e they political dissidents opposed to the governing party, who thus "logically" invited harsh treatment? I f the answer is negative, or the number o f the dissidents was limited, a second question arises: how to explain the persecution? What was the logic behind political operations in the Communist world? Thirdly, whether or not, or to what extent did the persecution o f the intellectuals truly serve the purpose o f the ruling party? This thesis attempts to provide some preliminary explanations over these topics. Note that not all the persecuted in Beijing were subject to labor banishment, neither were all the banished sent to the northeastern borderlands. The treatment of the rightists singled out in Beijing will be formally discussed in detail in Chapter Two. 1  2  Punitive Exile in Comparative Perspective Internal exile o f various types o f offender to frontiers regions or rural rustication o f undesirable elements is certainly not an original idea o f the Chinese communists. Rather, it has been used for centuries by various states as a significant form o f penalty, with well-known cases including sending convicts to Austrilia by the British, and to D e v i l ' s Island by the French; the Russian banishment o f revolutionaries to Siberia; the labor camps (such as the Gulag) i n the Stalinist Soviet Union; the Taiwan government's confinement o f political convicts on Green Island; and the practice o f the Qing government o f sending exiles to Xinjiang, etc. The motives for these practices ranged from the removal o f disruptive elements to the rehabilitation o f offenders, from the colonization o f frontiers to the assimilation o f ethnic minorities. Discussion o f these practices goes beyond the scope o f this thesis. The comparative focus w i l l be on the internal and external influences on the C C P practice o f banishment, among which the liufang practice o f late imperial China and the Soviet labor camps are o f special relevance. In China, the banishment o f political or criminal offenders to distant regions has ancient origins. Since the Q i n dynasty ( 3 century B . C . E ) , imperial rulers have rd  been deporting convicts, disgraced officials and other people i n political disfavor to remote border locations, such as Yunnan, Guangxi, Guangdong and Hainan. During the Song, there came to be a common practice that convicts were branded on their faces before they were sent to frontier or insalubrious mountain regions for military services or as manual labor in state programs such as land reclamation, road construction and river projects. Under the M i n g , Liaodong (Northeastern China) received considerable number o f military exiles (junfan)  2  In the 18 century, the imperial practice o f banishment reached a new height. th  Manchuria (Northeast) and Xinjiang (Northwest) were successively used by the Qing government as the destinations o f banishment. In the early years, the offenders 2  For more about the general situation in imperial China, see Joanna Waley-Cohen, Exile in Mid Qing China: Banishment to Xinjiang, J 758-1820 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1991), Chapter Three, "Exile and Expansion prior to the Qing."  3  banished  to Manchuria were  mostly  "common criminals such  as  robbers,  counterfeiters, and smugglers. Traditionally such crimes ranked among the most serious." " M a n y o f these exiles had originally been sentenced to death but had had their sentences commuted." The exiles to Manchuria also included lesser figures 3  who had participated in rebellions and other illegal activities that posed serious threats to the existing order o f the Qing. Disgraced scholars and officials as well as their families were also banished, with the former group being treated rather well by local officials. After Qing conquered what is now Xinjiang in 1759, tens o f thousands o f people were sent there as laborers as well as officials. The extent to which the imperial practice links to the P R C banishment warrants interrogation. I f we consider that the C C P leadership, especially the Party Chairman M a o Zedong, was extremely familiar with imperial history and ruling tactics, we might perceive a possible connection between the imperial style o f banishment and the Communist practice. Both o f them made use o f exiles as a source o f labor, and drove them away from the main centers o f China. The C C P assertion o f benevolent treatment o f "class enemies" and the stress on "ideological remolding" also seems to be consistent with the late imperial focus on benevolent rule. However, there is no visible evidence to show that C C P drew directly for their 4  modern practice from the imperial legacy. M a o frequently flaunted his historical knowledge on almost a l l important occasions, talking about making the past serve the present (gu wei jin yong). However, from his speeches discovered so far, M a o never mentioned borrowing ideas o f imperial practice when he talked about the treatment o f the 1957 rightists. In actual practice, the C C P displayed little influence o f its imperial ancestor. Q i n g exiles in Xinjiang, for instance, were provided with enough food or allocated land to support themselves, whereas exiles in the P R C were constantly under the threat o f hunger, with their agricultural produce all going Ibid, 57. Sun Xiaoli, Zhongguo laodong gaizao zhidu de lilun yu shijian (Theories and Practices. Reform through Labor in China) (Beijing: Zhongguo zhengfa daxue chubanshe, 1994), 41. Waley-Cohen believes that the widespread use of frontier banishment reflected the Qing's reluctance to execute any but the most serious offenders, a concern for the benevolent rule, and its "pragmatic recognition that China's people were a highly valuable resource." Waley-Cohen, Exile in Mid-Qing China, 51. 3  4  4  to the state granaries. In the Qing's Manchurian frontiers, literati exiles enjoyed various job options, working as teachers, river patrollers and even doing business. Confucian scholars were used as assistants to local officials, with their learning highly appreciated. In the P R C frontiers, political exiles, many o f whom were well 5  educated, were almost exclusively used as manual laborers, and the C C P local officials on the whole treated the banished intellectuals with little respect. Compared to their counterparts  in the imperial period, the  communist exiles  suffered  tremendously in the Manchurian wilderness. It also should be noted that those who were sent to the frontiers by the C C P government included large numbers o f the politically disfavored (including those who had served the previous G M D government and those who had raised different opinions and asked for change), and even innocent people. While the political suspects were deemed dangerous, those who committed criminal offences were considered less threatening to the powers that be. In this aspect, the C C P regime bore more similarity with the Soviet Union than with the imperial court. The Soviet model o f sending offenders to exile settlements and labor camps has been widely discussed by many scholars. It is held that this practice found its origin i n Tsarist banishment o f offenders to Siberia and the deserted island o f Sakhalin. In October 1922 a permanent Exile Commission was set up by the Soviet government to deal with "socially dangerous persons and active members o f antiSoviet parties." The Gulag was developed as a formidable exile and labor reform 6  regime that held various people from rich peasants and common criminals to "counterrevolutionary offenders." According to a "socialist principle" propounded by Lenin, that "he who does not work shall not eat," the Soviet government in 1929 established an elaborate system o f exile and imprisonment i n conjunction with forced labor, by which the exiles had to earn their life necessities to feed and cloth themselves and to increase national production. Upon the foundation o f the P R C , 7  See Waley-Cohen, Exile in Mid-Qing China, 58-59, 178, 224. Alexander Solzhenitsyn, The Gulag Archipelago 1918-1956: An Experiment in Literary Investigation (London: Collins & Harvill Press, 1974-1978), V. 6, 340. Ibid, 343. 5  6  7  5  the  Chinese  government  enthusiastically followed  the  Soviet model  of a  combination o f exile and forced labor. M a o Zedong and Z h u D e both advocated learning from the Soviet Union i n terms o f using convict laborers in state projects. Soviet advisers were invited to advise on matters such as labor camp structure and inmate administration, etc.  8  Distinctions between the Soviet system and that o f the P R C can be identified. For instance, Gulag practice rarely forced inmates into political study sessions as the C C P did. In the Gulag, political offenders were by and large confined separately from criminal offenders. "Camps were for more 'socially dangerous elements' such as political offenders, while colonies had more common criminals." But the C C P 9  practice usually put political offenders among criminals and made use o f criminals to monitor and discipline the political. (Chapter Three w i l l discuss this practice i n detail) When the Gulag regime built railways, canals and roads with forced laborers, discipline was poor and the number o f escapes was large. B y contrast, in the early P R C period as w i l l be shown in the case o f Beidahuang, forced laborers were primarily used i n agriculture and lumbering in isolated and remote regions and the chance o f escape was l i m i t e d . M o s t importantly, as Hongda Harry W u noted, "the 10  purpose o f the Soviet labor camps is suppression and punishment—not  the  systematic, complete 'thought reform' emphasized by the P R C camps. Furthermore, the economic value o f the products from the Soviet camps was only a small percentage o f total national production, and available sources suggest that the treatment prisoners receive in the Soviet labor camps is better than that i n the C C P labor reform camps."  11  Listing the number o f differences between the two countries  aims to show that although Soviet influence upon China existed, and although the banishment and labor reform practice in both countries were repressive and entailed See Sun Xiaoli, Zhongguo laodong gaizao zhidu de lilun yu shijian,\S-\l. Mao instructed in a report of April 1951 "to punish considerable number of offenders with life sentences, and to remove them from their native places for state projects such as road building, river conservation, and land reclamation The Soviet Union used to treat serious offenders in this way." See Ibid. 15. J. Otto Pohl, The Stalinist Penal System: A Statistical History of Soviet Repression and Terror, 1930-1953 (Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland & Company, Inc., 1997), 10. Ibid, 13-15; Sun Xiaoli, Zhongguo laodong gaizao zhidu de lilun yu shijian, 182-183. Hongda Harry Wu, Laogai—the Chinese Gulag (Boulder: Westview Press, 1992), 3-4. 8  9  10  11  6  high humanitarian costs, both had its own characteristics that were engrained in their own culture and embodied different governing styles.  Literature Review China scholars i n the West have paid considerable attention to Communist politics, political campaigns  i n Maoist period, and the  intellectuals and the state. The Hundred Intellectuals  Flowers  correlation  Campaign  between  and the  Chinese  by Roderick Macfarquhar, Politics and Purges in China by Frederick  Teiwes, Literary  Dissent in Communist  China by Merle Goldman, The Gate of  Heavenly Peace by Jonathan Spence and the monumental works The  Cambridge  History of China (Vol.14) all contribute substantial chapters discussing the causes, the implementation o f the 1957 persecution and its impact on China and Chinese intellectuals. The studies o f intellectuals under Communism, it seems, have been integrated into the grand political history—how intellectuals were involved i n and responed to China's political changes and how their fortunes were affected by these changes i n general. Individual lives o f the persecuted, especially those sent to labor camps o f border regions after 1957 have largely been left untouched. Despite the extensive body o f literature about the persecuted rightists that has been published since the mid-1980s, the life experiences of these people remain little studied subject o f research in the Western world, and are more documented than academically treated in China. Within the existing Western scholarship, the limelight often focuses on the limited number o f famous writers, scholars, and scientists. D i n g L i n g , Zhang Xianliang, Fei Xiaotong and Fang L i z h i , for instance, are given special attention due to their scholarly achievements and familiarity to western audience and / or their image as political dissidents. However, what still needs further attention 12  12  Tani Barlow and Gary Bjorge, eds., I Myself Am a Woman: Selected Writings of Ding Ling (Boston: Beacon Press, 1989), Yi-tsi Mei-Feuerwerker, Ding Ling's Fiction: Ideology and Narrative in Modern Chinese Literature (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1982), James McGough, Fei Hsiao-lung: the Dilemma of a Chinese Intellectual (White Plains, NY: M.E Sharpe, 1979), and R. David Arlcush, Fei Xiaotong and Sociology in Revolutionary China (Cambridge: Council on East Asian Studies, Harvard University, 1981) are among the important research on these two leading intellectuals. For information about Fang Lizhi, see James H. Williams, "Fang Lizhi's Expanding 7  is the post 1957 experience o f many ordinary professionals, school teachers, university students, government employees, who constituted the vast majority o f the persecuted, regarding how they were purged, how they suffered and survived, or how they died in labor camps or exile settlements across the country. A l s o important is the question o f P R C labor camps. This issue has been much discussed i n recent years. The Great Wall of Confinement: the Chinese Prison Camp through Contemporary  Fiction and Reportage by Philip Williams and Yenna W u  makes use o f fiction and non-fiction sources to approach P R C prisons and labor camps from the 1950s to the 1990s. New Ghosts, Old Ghosts: Prison and Labor Reform  Camps  in China by James Seymour and Richard Anderson primarily  describes the prisons o f northwestern China as they existed between the 1980s and the mid-1990s. Hongda Harry W u ' s Laogai—the Chinese Gulag is among the few western-language studies that systematically investigate the P R C ' s system o f labor camps, yet does not deal with the individual experience o f the persecuted Chinese. The accuracy o f some o f his accounts is open to question. Virtually all o f these researches left those banished and enslaved i n the northeastern China out, and none o f them investigates an alternative labor reform regime—the army farms established by the state i n the 1950s, which were also exile settlements for political offenders. In Mainland China, while the persecuted rightists (including the ultra-rightists) have published their memoirs and recollections i n increasing numbers, scholarly treatments o f the life experience o f political outcasts remain almost nonexistent because o f the unfavorable political climate. Probably the only notable exception so far is a semi-academic work Chanji: kunan de jitan, 1957 (Allegorical Words: Bitter Sacrificial Altar, 1957) by H u Ping, which, based on recollection o f some rightists, contributes several chapters to discuss the experiences and behavior o f the rightists in labor camps in north and northwest China.  Source Materials and Methodology  Universe," in China Quarterly, Vol. 123 (September 1990), 459-484.  8  The thesis is based on both primary sources such as personal interviews, memoirs, autobiographical works, short recollections, unpublished manuscripts by people who had direct experience of border banishment, and official documents on the one hand, and secondary sources such as biographies and research works on the other. Provincial gazetteers and local gazetteers, as reworked sources produced in official initiative, are hard to categorize but are also made use of with a degree of caution. ( 1 ) Biographies  Since the mid-1980s biographies or biographical works about the persecuted rightists in Beidahuang have appeared in increasing number, due to the public concern for the victims of Maoist persecution and relaxation of government ideological control. Rightists Ding Ling, Ai Qing, Ding Cong, Huang Miaozi, Nie Gannu and others have seen their biographies compiled by young writers and journalists.  13  These sources are of great value in that they provide overall  descriptions of these intellectuals under Communist rule as well as brief sketches of their lives in exile, and thus are indispensable to my reconstruction of their experiences. The weakness of some biographies, it seems, is the lack of narrative that could clearly reveal personal characteristics of the protagonists during the years of persecution (as in cases of Ding Cong and Nie Gannu); in addition, little attention is paid to how these people associated with their fellow exiles and labor farm/camp officials. On top of this, some protagonists themselves are unsatisfied with regard to the accuracy of their stories told in these writings.  14  ( 2) Memoirs  Publications of memoirs by the banished intellectuals themselves have in some degree corrected this situation. Literati rightists such as Ding Ling, Liu Binyan, Zhang Xianliang, Cong Weixi, Dai Huang, Yin Yi and Wu Yongliang have Whenever relevant in the following chapters, I will identify and characterize these individual rightists. Ding Cong, for instance, pointed out numbers of mistakes in his biography Ding Cong zhuan, and made careful corrections during my personal interview in August 2003. Xin Suwei, Ding Cong zhuan (Biography of Ding Cong) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 1993). 13  14  9  published memoirs since the mid-1980s. Short recollections o f certain events during their exile also appeared i n magazines and newspapers. W e can find from these writings not only what their routine lives in exile were like, but also their inner world—their sad feeling, their attitude toward the thought reform, their sense o f guilt for some parts o f their behavior, and their reflection upon their painful past after rehabilitation. Since the authors were situated i n humble position in those years, however, their memoirs mostly focus on things on themselves; description o f how the policy o f frontier banishment were implemented i n their work units, and what happened in the labor farms/camps they stayed were their secondary focus. These memoirs vary considerably in terms o f the extent to which they disclose what happened to the authors themselves and what happened in the P R C labor camps o f the 1950s and 1960s. In general, memoirs published i n the 1980s were cautious i n describing the darkness o f labor camps.  15  Sensitive topics such as the  maltreatment o f inmates/exiles by camp officials that were seen as harmful to the socialist state were either avoided by the authors or removed from the memoirs when they were published because o f the state censorship i n place. Some authors, when interviewed, expressed their regrets at the forced omission o f some crucial parts o f their experiences. Comparatively, those published i n the 1990s and afterwards were more open and sharp, works such as Musi yisheng ( A Narrow Escape from Death) by D a i Huang and Ywcue feifei (Floating R a i n and Snow) by W u Yongliang. E v e n i n the 1990s and afterwards, however, memoirs or short recollections that display sharp condemnation o f the governing party were not easy to publish so some circulated underground among close friends; a typical case is Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi (The True Stories o f my Twenty two Years o f Laogai Experience) by Chen Fengxiao. B y contrast, those published abroad such as Mirror by L i u Naiyuan (Peter Liu), and A Single Tear by W u Ningkun enjoy much more freedom to display bold criticism toward the P R C ' s labor reform establishment.  Ding Ling's narrative of her experience in Beidahuang army farms, for instance, is mild as she intentionally avoids mentioning her physical suffering in her memoir Fengxue renjicm (The Blizzard World) (Xiamen: Xiamen daxue chubanshe, 1987). 1 5  10  (3 ) Personal interviews Personal interviews greatly enrich source materials for this research. With thirtysix personal remembrances  collected through oral interviews i n Beijing  and  Northeastern China and one i n Vancouver, I have been able to find new things that did not appear i n published sources. Stories o f those who have not written recollections and those who died in the frontier banishment are discovered as well. The method I took for interviews followed these stages: making arrangements through personal contacts; giving interviewees a rough ideas o f what I was interested in; meeting them one on one (because o f some sensitive questions involved and for the protection o f interviewees); and starting a semi-structured conversation with simple questions at the beginning. The interviewees were encouraged to talk freely, to give more details on concrete aspects, and to recall their actual mentalities at that time. If clarifications were needed, the interviewees were contacted more than once. For those who were from the same work unit or were once in the same labor camp, questions were repeated  and the  testimonies  crosschecked. Through extensive interviews, I was able to discover new sources that the persecuted were reluctant to put on paper, and to correct errors existed in the current memoirs and biographies.  16  ( 4 ) Other Oral Testimonies Another type o f interviewees—colleagues and/or friends o f the persecuted people,  whom  I  met  by  chance  during the  interview process—provided  supplementary sources. Some o f them provided different stories than those told by the persecuted, or, with unique angle, descriptions o f the personal characteristic o f those people i n exile. Some o f them told me sad stories o f their friends who had died in Beidahuang or elsewhere before they were rehabilitated. In this sense they served  Ding Ling in her Fengxue renjian does not criticize her rival Zhou Yang by name. However, her husband Chen Ming during an interview on August 19, 2003 clearly pointed out that Zhou was the crucial person for Ding's persecution in 1957. Liu Meng during a personal interview on October 4, 2003 mentioned the prevalence of stealing in Beidahuang army farms, which he did not in his memoir Chuntian deyuqiutian qing (The Whisking of Rain in Spring, the Clearing Skies in Autumn) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 2003). 16  11  as spokespersons o f the dead. The narratives o f these "accidental interviewees" broadened my knowledge o f the Anti-Rightist Campaign and the border banishment afterwards, and at the same time enable me to treat with caution some information from those with direct experience. A l l o f these source materials—biographies, memoirs, interviews, and oral testimonies o f others—are used for cross-checking, confirmation and mutual reinforcement, thus enabling me to piece together the significant life experience o f the political exiles i n the northeastern borderlands. Not only d i d these narratives provide more detailed insight into political campaigns in the Maoist P R C and the collective experience o f the victims, but they also permitted reexamination o f the differences that separate the victims apart in term o f the reasons for which they were persecuted, the pattern o f their behaviors, their physical and psychological sufferings, their self-perception i n exile, and the ways they treated their fellow exiles, etc. When I try to formulate generalization, these materials remind me that individual experiences o f the exiles are always unique, and thus cannot easily be generalised. ( 5 ) Official Sources Lack o f official documents is a limitation that confronts this research. Unlike the Cultural Revolution, the Chinese government still speaks o f the necessity o f the Anti-Rightist  Campaign,  Consequently, the  thus  majority  refused  to  condemn  portion o f official  its  archives  oppressive  nature.  on this event  and  maltreatment o f the rightists still remains closed to the public, to minimize public discussion and scholarly discourse in C h i n a .  17  Only establishment historians o f  certain rank can have access to crucial parts o f the Anti-rightist archives. What are made known to the public include the criteria against which the rightists were classified, the general guideline for treatment o f the rightists, basic labor reform  Note that some valuable documents such as the central directives of the CCP are already disclosed and appended into research works on the Anti-Rightist topic published overseas. See, for instance, Hua Min, Zhongguo da nizhuan: fanyou yundong shi (China's Great Reversal: A History of the AntiRightist Campaign) (New York: Ming-ching chubanshe, 1996). Scholars such as Frederick Teiwes and Roderick MacFarquhar have used numerous official documents for their research on purges in the PRC. However, official records about political outcasts in the frontier regions are still inaccessible for general researchers. 17  12  policies and regulations on labor reeducation o f the ultra-rightists, etc., all o f which are insufficient to understand how decisions regarding the treatment o f various types o f rightists were made, how the massive banishment was initiated and managed, and how the banished were treated at the grassroots. Exploration o f official attitudes toward and evaluation o f the banished rightists is also limited by lack o f relevant sources. The still-living officials who managed the banishment i n those years refuse to be interviewed, for various considerations. This situation is somewhat remedied by the publication o f collections o f some important Party documents such as Jianguo  yilai  zhongyao  wenxian  xuanbian  ^Selected Collections o f Important  Documents since the Establishment o f the P R C ) . Farm gazetteers produced by relevant labor farm authorities are o f great value, but there are some obvious errors and they are selective i n disclosing crucial statistics and events.  18  Lack o f official documents is compounded by a distinctive technique o f the C C P : some central decrees and directives were delivered by telephone message or i n person from higher levels to lower levels, rather than in written documents. This practice enhances the difficulty o f tracing the C C P ' s operation o f its policies in general, and the policy around the 1957 campaign and the treatment o f the persecuted i n particular. Although this situation was i n some degree remedied by 19  memoirs and recollections o f individuals who underwent the specific events, this insurmountable barrier presents a limitation to the degree o f conviction o f the thesis. Paul Cohen, with his research on the Boxer uprising o f 1900, raises valuable points on historical research and historical writing. For Cohen, reconstruction o f history is not a true recovery o f the past; the history a historian creates is fundamentally different from history people make; all historical writing entails radical simplification and compression o f the past. Cohen believes that individual participants i n "historical events" do not have the entire event inscribed i n their  1 will discuss the errors in the Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm and Gazetteer of Farm 850 in Chapter Four regarding the death record of the inmates. For instance, the evacuation ofrightistsfromBeidahuang at the end of 1960 is not documented in any written official sources. According to journalist Zheng Xiaofeng, the instruction for the evacuation was delivered to the chief of the Beidahuang army farms directly by Premier of the State Council. Zheng Xiaofeng, interview. 18  19  13  mind, and that the past reconstructed by direct participants has some emotional attachment so that it is hard to say it is totally r e l i a b l e Cohen's thesis is valuable 20  in that it sheds light on the tension between the history that people make and the history that people write. H i s warning about the limitation o f both the narratives o f those with direct experience and the writings o f historians is also useful for historical research. Although not aiming to fit this research squarely into Cohen's framework, I feel it beneficial to take Cohen's view i n approaching source materials collected. So far all the biographies, memoirs or short recollections used for this research with regards to the 1957 victims were produced after the early 1980s—more than twenty years after their banishment. Almost all o f these works build upon their personal memory, since few diaries, notes or other written records o f banishment have survived, especially through the turbulent years o f the Cultural Revolution. When 21  survivors o f the frontier banishment reconstructed their past, what they tell almost solely relies on their memory, which is not free from "emotional attachment" and significant omission. Furthermore, I find i n both memoirs and interview records that the narratives provided by individuals from a same work unit or a same labor camp could differ considerably. It is obvious that certain parts o f their memory are not reliable. The most striking distinction manifests itself in another dimension. Political exiles i n the P R C period are sharply different from the Boxers that Paul Cohen addresses in terms o f their educational background and their social status. They have not only direct experience o f the past but they are also writers o f history. Almost a l l literate, these political exiles when rehabilitated were capable o f understanding the 20  Paul A. Cohen, History in Three Keys: The Boxers as Event, Experience, and Myth (New York: Columbia University Press, 1997), 4, 59,61, 64. Rightist Wu Yongliang admits that since his notes about Beidahuang composed right after the banishment were all burned during the Cultural Revolution, his memoirs (published in 2002) are entirely based on his recent recollection. See Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei: Beidahuang shenghuo jishi (Floating Rain and Snow: True Stories of Life in the Great Northern Wilderness) ( Beijing: Zhongguo xiju chubanshe, 2002), 11-12. Among the biographies used for this thesis, only the self-criticism of Nie Gannu and the correspondence of Huang Miaozi were taken as references when their biographies were composed. 21  14  history o f the campaign, and they had basic information on frontier banishment and its consequences. In the 1980s and 1990s when they told their individual stories, their narratives may not have been free from the influence o f post-Mao social climates and current literatures. Fully aware o f social expectation o f them, it seems to me, some o f them subconsciously insinuate into their narratives something that might help cultivate ideal images o f themselves.  22  Even i f rational calculation on the one hand and emotional attachment on the other might not override their honesty, questions must still be raised with regards to the ambiguity and inconsistency o f the source materials they offered. Some like to tell how they were maltreated by labor camp/ farm cadres, but avoid mentioning their collaboration with these cadres; some like to describe routine life rather than their real mentality in that time. It seems to me that there are some parts o f their experience that they like to talk about, some parts they want to conceal, and some parts they want to exaggerate. Some portray themselves as courageous fighters for justice for which they were persecuted without mentioning other contributing reasons for their troubles; some want to show how they took against inhuman behavior i n the labor camps while omitting their indifference to their fellows; some want to express their consistent commitment to socialism and the governing party even i f they were persecuted for about twenty years. In not a few cases, what they portrayed about themselves is different from the impressions they gave to their fellow exiles. A s well, when they do recall their feelings and psychology in the past years, it seems, some ideas o f later years intrude into their descriptions, as seen in the use o f standard language and framework o f the 1980s to present their past mentalities. Being alert to the possibility o f simplified areas i n their narratives, I pay special attention to crosschecking their narratives with other sources, i n order to identify the extent to which their recollections might deviate from the past reality, and to filter out what is inconsistent i n their narratives. Mutually conflicting narratives are carefully identified or simply left out; only narratives that meet these standards have 2 2  The memoirs of Ding Ling and Liu Meng, for instance, are subject to this questioning.  15  been adopted to substantiate arguments. Since personal interviews were mostly conducted after reviewing the memoirs or biographies, questions raised from these published resources were relatively easy to clarify. I am fully aware that among the thousands o f persecuted people who were forced to undergo varying degree o f labor reform i n Beidahuang, only a small portion o f them have published their recollections or disclosed their past i n various forms. What 1 have access to is merely a small portion o f the experience o f a large population. Validity and effectiveness o f the thesis are subject to further test, and deeper treatment o f Beidahuang exiles awaits further scholarship.  Political exiles in Beidahuang: a general picture During the late 1950s and early 1960s, the political offenders  sent to  Beidahuang could be roughly broken down into the following categories: ( 1 ) The Beijing rightists i n the army farms W i t h the conclusion o f the Anti-Rightist Campaign i n 1958, thousand o f rightists from various agencies o f the central government and military units i n Beijing, i f merely labeled "rightists", were sent to the army farms in Beidahuang under the name o f "labor under supervision" (jiandu laodong). Although free from criminal charges, they were still deemed political antagonists. In Beidahuang, they worked in the same farms with demobilized soldiers and convicted criminals under the surveillance o f demobilized military officers. The majority o f them labored there for close to three years. The high death rate from starvation i n 1960 propelled the central government to call them back to better areas o f China. ( 2 ) Counterrevolutionaries i n the labor reform (laogai) camps o f X i n g k a i h u  23  "Counterrevolutionary" in the Maoist period was an ill-defined but all-embracing term. Defined entirely by the Party, this term was used to include various types of what were regarded by the government as politically subversive elements. In many cases, however, the difference between a criminal offense and a counterrevolutionary offense was not clear-cut. Criminal offenders whose offenses were deemed serious could also be classified as counterrevolutionaries with the "hats" like "counterrevolutionary murders" or "counterrevolutionary arsonists." During most of the PRC period, "counterrevolutionaries" were broken down into "active counterrevolutionaries" and "historical counterrevolutionaries." In order not to expand further the already unwieldy subject, I mainly consider "active counterrevolutionaries" that are more related to the Anti-Rightist politics but exclude "historical counterrevolutionaries."  2 3  16  M a n y o f those accused as "counterrevolutionaries" during the Anti-Rightist Campaign, i f sentenced, were sent to Xingkaihu labor reform camps. These people were mainly young dissidents (university students, young teachers or government employees). The difference between them and most other rightists was that they had voiced sharp criticism against the abuses o f the C C P and were advocates for intellectual independence and political renovation. A s well, some o f those who were at first labeled "rightists" and appealed for redress instead invited even more severe penalties and thus were elevated to the "counterrevolutionaries" status. M a n y o f those rounded up in Beijing were sent to Xingkaihu, which is the focus o f Chapter Three, but also to the Changshuihe, Yinhe and Wulan Farms in Heilongjiang and the Qinghe Farm in Tianjin as well. ( 3 ) Ultra-rightists i n the labor reeducation (laojiao) camps o f Xingkaihu The ultra-rightists were those at the top o f the scale o f rightists. They were considered to have committed serious offenses, and the punishment they received was harsher than that given to those who were sent to army farms, though less severe than those who were sent to labor reform camps. Although they were not formally tried and thus were not subject to a term-sentence because o f the Party's "leniency," they were still seen to be i n need o f discipline by the police authorities. Labor reeducation camps were thus the perfect places for them to go. These three types o f political outcasts made up most o f the Anti-Rightist victims banished from Beijing to Beidahuang. In Beidahuang, they were used as agricultural laborers, lumber workers, construction workers, and so on; essentially they were slave laborers. Their banishment and enslavement coincided with the most serious famine (1959-1962) in modern China. Their food supplies were low, and their labor heavy; these were compounded with a lack o f proper medical care. The death rate was high, in some camps up to 20-30 percent. Some o f them suffered physical abuse and psychological abuse at the hands o f the camp and army farm cadres. Discussions o f hardship, hunger, death, physical abuse, escape, punishment and psychological suffering constitute a major part o f the thesis. 2 4  2 4  Although I  This research primarily focuses on the frontier regions of Heilongjiang. To contextualize this  17  mainly focus on the Beidahuang border region, some o f the findings may reflect the fate o f the persecuted i n the Mao-era P R C as a whole. I w i l l also discuss how the ways o f thinking and behavior o f the persecuted intellectuals were affected by C C P indoctrination. Under political pressure and propaganda, many persecuted people i n various degree acknowledged that they d i d commit errors or crimes, that their criticisms o f government officials were anti-Party in nature, and that they needed to take labor reform to wash out their evil thinking, to achieve political and ideological perfection, and to reach spiritual growth through the trials and tribulations. Therefore many made considerable efforts at the labor camps and army farms to show signs o f repentance i n order to redeem themselves. Phony activism existed among banished intellectuals. In both army farms and Xingkaihu labor camp, some o f the persecuted attacked others to build themselves up. They reported and denounced others politically and used trivial issues to make scathing attacks. Those who succeeded in building up good images were often appointed as group leaders, and were offered better foods, lighter jobs, entrusted to monitor others, and, i n the case o f labor reform camps, could enforce physical penalties upon others. Those regarded as being politically backward or with poor work performances not only suffered at the hands o f camp cadres but also from these activists—their fellow inmates. In this sense, the victims o f political persecution were also perpetrators. A s a group, Chinese intellectuals were unable to develop collective consciousness i n face o f a repressive regime. Different strategies o f survival and different experiences also separated the political exiles. B y and large, those with official or semi-official positions before banishment showed more enthusiasm than others i n "labor reform," thus were more likely to be released earlier than others; those unable to secure favorable treatment had to try every means to survive in the harsh environment while still cherishing hope for release sometime; young students who were apathetic about Communist  research, however, some illuminating experiences of the persecuted individuals in other parts of Northeastern China are also put into analysis. I also occasionally discuss some labor camps in North China such as the Qinghe Farm, to which the inmates from the northeastern frontiers were transferred in the early 1960s.  18  policies or those who were sentenced for a relatively long term were more likely than others to write themselves off—resisting the labor reform  arrangements,  refusing to be submissive to camp cadres and thus inviting even worse treatment.  Thesis Structure The thesis is structured as following: Chapter One discusses the background o f the banishment—the Anti-Rightist Campaign and various reasons for the mass labeling o f rightists. I argue that although  some  intellectuals were  labeled because o f their criticism o f the  bureaucracy, hierarchy, and autocracy o f the C C P government, or their advocacy for the redress o f wrongs, the majority were persecuted actually because o f factionalism, personal animosity, grudges, trivial issues, or even by mistake. Labeling quotas set by higher authorities also forced local Party branches to frame innocent people. I also suggest that although the campaign was launched by the C C P to deal with its real or imagined threats, it was also taken advantage o f by intellectuals to attack their competitors. The main focus o f Chapter Two is the general experience o f the Beijing rightists (those from central government and military organizations in Beijing) in Beidahuang army farms. Despite the title o f "thought remolding through labor," they were actually sheer forced laborers, and were not given much ideological indoctrination at farms. A s well, despite  hardship as general  pattern,  experiences and suffering varied depending on their location. In some  their cases,  personal connections with influential officials were important, and their former influence and professional expertise also made their lives easier. Chapter Three presents an examination o f the life experiences o f two types o f political offenders—the "counterrevolutionaries" and the "ultra-rightists"—in the Xingkaihu labor camps. I argue that the political offenders were the worst treated o f all the inmates o f the camps, and that young student prisoners were more courageous than others in showing disobedience to the camp authorities. I also examine the C C P practice o f putting political offenders together with criminal offenders i n labor  19  camps and mobilizing the criminals to help monitor and deal with the political offenders. Descriptions o f the physical suffering o f the banished, such as hardship, starvation, death, physical abuse, and suicide constitute the major parts o f Chapter Four. I also argue that dignity and integrity o f the intellectuals was heavily damaged by the insurmountable difficulties. When intellectuals were driven by hunger and hardship, demoralized behavior such as lying, fighting and stealing inevitably became normal happenings i n their daily lives, and greatly damaged their image as a lofty social elite. Chapter Five tries to tap the inner world o f the political exiles by tracing their psychological journey. It shows how the political exiles, especially the rightists in the army farms, identified with the Party's ideology and were supportive o f labor reform arrangement even though their were purged and banished. This chapter w i l l also examine the internecine strife among Chinese intellectuals. In order to survive, to show their commitment to labor reform, and to be released earlier, some reported and denounced their fellow exiles, betrayed their friends, and tried hard to get rid o f their rivals under the auspices o f the authorities. Loss o f conscience was tremendous and the trauma remained deep in later years. Chapter Six discusses the completion o f the political banishment to Beidahuang. In the early 1960s, the majority o f Beijing rightists were allowed to leave the border areas. M a n y ultra-rightists in the labor reeducation camps o f Xingkaihu were also transferred to central parts o f China because o f government concern over border security. Even though they were released from labor reform establishment, many labeled rightists were i n later years still unable to resume their normal life, and they still suffered profound discrimination i n society. The main themes discussed in the Conclusion show how the Chinese Communist Party cruelly consumed its genuine followers, how the syndrome o f "dog eats dog" unfolded i n the P R C , and asks whether the Party achieved its goal by wielding their tool o f banishment. It shows that many brilliant youths who ardently joined the Communist revolution or willingly followed the preaching o f the Party  20  were successively purged by the Party. Through brief discussion o f the "loyal dissidents" i n the 1940s, the victims and perpetrators i n 1957, and the R e d Guards in the Cultural Revolution, this chapter shows that these people were part o f "a chain o f prey." A hypothesis is made that those who were deeply involved in the development o f Communism i n China were eventually rendered its victims, and those who actively attacked others were eventually attacked.  21  Chapter One The Anti-Rightist Campaign and Political Labeling The frontier banishment o f the politically suspect i n the late 1950s was the direct result o f a political campaign—the Anti-Rightist Campaign. During that campaign, sizable numbers o f Chinese intellectuals, including writers, teachers, university students, as well as Communist Party officials and government employees were labeled "rightists," or "counterrevolutionaries," lost their jobs or were suspended from them, and were sent to labor camps. The campaign negatively impacted the fates o f millions o f Chinese, as the governing party seemingly achieved its agenda o f state consolidation, the crushing o f real or imagined forces o f opposition,  and the  imposition o f ideological conformity.  2 5  Therefore,  this  examination o f political banishment cannot start without making reference to the Anti-Rightist Campaign o f 1957-8, the political background and the source o f labeling and persecution. Although a full treatment o f the campaign is beyond the scope o f this project, I focus on three issues: W h y the campaign? W h o were the rightists? W h y were they labeled? Received perceptions o f the rightists (those singled out for persecution by the C C P during the campaign), stress that they were labeled and then banished because they pursued intellectual independence and protested C C P control over intellectuals, that they criticized the government's bureaucratic practices and abuse o f power, that they demanded political and cultural reform and institutional changes, that they questioned the relevance o f M a o Zedong thought to academia, and that they 25  Julia Strauss in her work "Paternalist Terror" explores the process and features of the Campaign to Suppress Counterrevolutionaries in the early PRC. She argues that by unleashing terror upon political competitors and with the paternalist care for their followers, the CCP successfully met the challenges of the revolutionary regime consolidation. See Julia Strauss, "Paternalist Terror: the campaign to suppress counterrevolutionaries arid regime consolidation in the People's Republic of China, 19501953," in Comparative Studies in Society and History, Vol. 44, No.l (January 2002), 80-105. The frontier banishment featured in this thesis has numerous differences with the campaign of 1950-1953. However, it bears striking similarities in terms of the state agenda achieved, such as eliminating political opponents, controlling social groups, and, ironically, consuming much of the revolutionary elite itself '  22  challenged the domination o f C C P in literary and art spheres. Although recognizing that the chief motivation o f the critics was to improve rather than to oppose the Party, Western scholars prefer to emphasize the political, ideological and literary stance o f intellectuals as the main reasons for their persecution.  26  These explanations are only applicable to a small portion o f the persecuted, such as well-known student rightist L i n X i l i n g .  For the vast majority, as this  chapter reveals, political labeling was an unpredictable and random blow that hit them arbitrarily, a strike that was not caused by their political actions. Frederick Teiwes, in his monumental work Politics and Purges in China, argues that during the political campaigns o f the early P R C period, sanctions meted out to individuals were based on the seriousness o f their offenses.  28  The findings o f this research on  the Anti-Rightist Campaign, however, are unable to verify his thesis. Teiwes also discusses the concepts o f the rectification and campaign in Maoist China. H i s model was mainly based on his observation o f the C C P high level elite purges during the 1950-1965 period. This research, by analyzing the experience o f victims during the 29  Anti-Rightist Campaign, indicates that the political campaign, when extended to lower levels, was implemented in ways that were much different from that at higher levels. The main argument o f this chapter is that the majority o f those labeled and banished were not political dissidents; many o f the "critics" (such as L i u Binyan and Yue Daiyun) were loyal C C P members, and many others had no intention to be  Jonathan Spence, The Search for Modern China (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1990), 570-571; Merle Goldman, "The Party and the Intellectuals," in Denis Twitchett and John Fairbank, eds., The Cambridge History of China (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), Vol. 14, 251253; R. David Arkush, "Introduction" and Hualing Nieh, "Preface" for Hualirig Nieh, ed., Literature of the Hundred Flowers (New York: Columbia University Press, 1981). Vol. 1. Lin Xinling's criticism against the Party was much harsher than that of many other critics of the time. See Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao.jiyi zhong de fan youpaiyundong (Grass on the Plains: the Anti-Rightist Campaign in Memory) (Beijing: Jingji ribao chubanshe, 1998), 151158; Merle Goodman, Literary Dissent in Communist China (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1967), 197, 201. Frederick Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China: Rectification and the Decline of Party Norms, 1950-1965 (Armonk: M. E. Sharpe, 1993), 26. l b  2 7  2 8  29  Ibid, Part II.  23  critics o f the Party or to be involved in politics. While recognizing the fact that, on 30  the one hand, some radical activists especially university students boldly condemned Party abuses and demanded political and intellectual independence, and that on the other hand, many adopted a stance o f "loyal opponents" —criticizing the Party's errors in order to prolong its rule— I argue that the majority o f intellectuals were persecuted not for political reasons but because o f factionalism, personal animosity, grudges, jealousy, arid a variety o f trivial issues, or even by mistake. Labeling quotas set by higher authorities also forced local Party committees to frame innocent people. Consequently, the real practices o f the campaign were to a great extent contradictory to the initial motives o f high leaders. I also maintain that although the campaign was launched by the C C P to deal with real or imagined threats, it was also taken advantage o f by intellectuals and officials to attack their rivals. These people helped to precipitate the massive persecution and banishment.  The Anti-Rightist Campaign This campaign has been well examined by Western scholars such as Merle Goldman, Roderick MacFarquhar and Frederick Teiwes. Teiwes treats the carnpaign as a "defensive" measure to restore Party control, Goldman characterizes the campaign as a manifestation  o f the Party's "anti-intellectual stance," while  MacFarquhar cites the campaign as an important Revolution.  step toward the  Cultural  This chapter provides a short overview o f the campaign merely to  See Yue Daiyun and Carolyn Wakeman, To the Storm: The Odyssey of a Revolutionary Chinese Woman (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1985), Chapter 1; Liu Binyan, Liu Binyan zizhuan (Autobiography of Liu Binyan) (Taibei: Shibao wenhua chuban qiye youxian gongsi, 1989). Movies produced in the post-Mao era confirm the images of innocent people who were destroyed by political blows. For example, the literary characters Lin Shaolong in movie Blue Kite and "my father— Teacher Luo" in My Father and Mother were all ordinary men who were unpredictably involved in and victimized by the Anti-Rightist Campaign. Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China, 217. Goldman's argument can be found in Denis Twitchett and John Fairbank, eds., The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 14, 256; MacFarquhar's thesis is embodied in his The Origins of the Cultural Revolution: Contradictions among the People, 19561957 (London: Oxford University Press, 1974). JU  3 1  24  establish the basic context in which the political initiatives o f the Party evolved into a disaster for the general public. In early 1956, the C C P tried to w i n the cooperation o f intellectuals to facilitate economic and social development. B y raising the slogan "let a hundred flowers bloom and a hundred schools o f thought contend," the C C P leadership, and especially Chairman M a o Zedong, promised to grant intellectuals degree o f freedom to criticize, and to express their own opinions on questions in the arts, literature and science.  This was the origin o f the Hundred Flowers Movement. During the next  spring, M a o went further to enlist intellectuals' supports for a rectification o f the C C P . Non-Party intellectuals were encouraged to criticize the bureaucracy and present differing views. With the encouragement o f M a o , other leaders such as Zhou E n l a i also expressed unprecedented trust from the C C P for intellectuals.  33  In the beginning, most intellectuals did not respond positively to M a o ' s call for open criticism. Instead, they held back, out o f caution; they were instinctively reluctant to involve themselves i n politics and potential policy changes.  34  Another  reason that accounted for their silence was the conflicting signals that emerged from Beijing i n the spring o f 1957. A s some scholars have noted, while M a o Zedong and Zhou E n l a i advocated rectification o f the Party and an enlistment o f different opinions, many other top leaders such as L i u Shaoqi and Peng Zhen were rather  See The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 14, 243. For the general context of the CCP initiatives, see Ibid, 242-250. For other leaders' positive echo of Mao, see Zhou Enlai, "The Report on Issues of Intellectuals", January 14, 1956. Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguo yilai zhongyao wenxian xuanbian (Selected Collections of Important Documents since the Establishment of the PRC) (Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, 1994), Vol. 8, 11-45. Mao's real motives, although hard to fathom, have been interpreted by scholars and personnel close to him as having a wide range of considerations, from improving the bureaucracy to avoiding loss of revolutionary spirit, from preempting anti-Communist insurrection as had happened in Poland and Hungary to checking the rapid growth of power of his colleagues such as Liu Shaoqi arid Deng Xiaoping. 3 2  3 3  Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Jirigji lu: jiyi zhong de fan youpai yundong (The Thorny Road: the Anti-Rightist Campaign in Memory) (Beijing: Jingji ribao chubanshe, 1998), 9; Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China, 202-203; Roderick MacFarquhar, ed., The Hundred Flowers Campaign and the Chinese Intellectuals (New York: Octagon Books, 1974), 24-25. 3 4  25  negative toward these initiatives. In these circumstances, many people preferred to 35  remain aloof from Communist politics. Unhappy with the slow response o f intellectuals, M a o intensified his summons for critiques. In speeches delivered on M a r c h 12 and M a r c h 20, 1957, for instance, M a o made extraordinary efforts to call on "all people to express their opinions freely, so that they dare to speak, dare to criticize, and dare to debate"; "as long as they are not counterrevolutionaries, people should have the freedom to speak not only on pure scientific and artistic problems, but also on matters o f a political nature in terms of right and w r o n g . " M o v e d by M a o ' s seeming sincerity and benevolent attitude, 36  reassured by his promise to protect freedom Of expression, and pressured by repeated  encouragement  from  various  Party  organizations,  intellectuals,  professionals, students as well as some government employees finally began to speak out. Leaders o f the democratic parties (such as Zhang Bojun and C h u Anping) criticized the C C P " s monopoly o f power, and demanded political independence and real participation in policy making. Writers (such as A i Q i n g and L i u Shaotang) complained about the Party's restraints on literary creativity, and questioned the relevance o f M a o ' s Talks at the Yan 'an Forum on Literature and Arts. Scientists and university teachers (such as Qian Weichang and Fei Xiaotong) lodged criticism against the bureaucratic practices o f Party cadres, the Party's interference i n academic and intellectual life, the imposition o f ideological straight-jackets and the slavish following o f the Soviet model. M a n y students condemned the privileges, hierarchy, abuse o f power, alienation from masses, and economic corruption on the part o f Party and government officials. Those who had wrongly suffered persecution in previous political campaigns demanded rehabilitation. Pushed by M a o and 37  Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China, 166. See Roderick MacFarquhar, Timothy Cheek and Eugene Wu, eds., The Secret Speeches of Chairman Mao (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1989), 358; Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji (Selected Works of Mao Zedong) (Beijing: Remin chubanshe, 1977), Vol.5, 414-415. See Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Liuyue xue; jiyi zhong de fan youpai yundong (Snow in June: the Anti-Rightist Campaign in Memory) (Beijing: Jingji ribao chubanshe, 1998), 331-343; Niu and Deng, eds., Jingji lu, 154-158; The Cambridge History of China, Vol.14, 251-253. MacFarquhar in 35  3 6  3 7  26  believing his promises a sign o f political thaw, the educated elite aired their grievances against the governing party. Unprepared for the torrent o f criticism, the C C P leadership found that the Hundred Flowers had gotten out o f hand. Party leaders were shocked that criticism o f the abuse o f government officials and specific Party policies was leading to criticism not only o f individual Party members but also o f the Party itself. Even M a o became the target o f sharp c r i t i c i s m .  38  Strikes o f industrial workers and student  protests were also instigated in an increasingly politicized climate. The Party line shifted with the political winds and M a o , the chief architect o f the "blooming and contending," swung to the side o f the hard liners after mid M a y .  People's  Daily  3 9  O n June 8, the  announced a counterattack, and the formal reversal o f policy started.  The Anti-Rightist Campaign was set in motion.  40  The major phase o f the campaign lasted from June 1957 to the end o f the year, although an additional round o f "supplementary labeling" was added i n 1958. This resulted in the purging and labeling o f more than a half million Chinese intellectuals, government employees and other urban residents. Some had their "rightist" labels upgraded to "counterrevolutionary" due to their refusal to admit their "crimes" or  his Hundred Flowers Campaign and the Chinese Intellectuals also documents these various criticisms. Chu Anping, the newly appointed editor of Guangming Daily, made a criticism of Mao and Zhou with regard to the CCP's monopoly of state leadership. See Dai Qing, Liang Suming, Wang Shiwei, Chu Anping (Nanjing: Jiangsu wenyi chubanshe, 1989), 236-238. MacFarquhar believes that the Anti-Rightist Campaign reflected Mao's personal anger and embarrassment over his major defeat in the Hundred Flowers. Facing sharp external criticism, MacFarquhar argues, Mao was compelled to agree with other leading figures Liu Shaoqi and Peng Zhen, who advocated severe sanction of critics, and was compelled to defend himself by articulating a plan of "letting the demons and hobgoblins come out of their lairs then we will be able to wipe them out better." Mao had to justify his original "blooming and contending" plan in order to fix his credibility gaps. See MacFarquhar, The Origins of the Cultural Revolution, Chapter 18; also see MacFarquhar, "The Secret Speeches of Chairman Mao," in The Secret Speeches of Chairman Mao: from the Hundred Flowers to the Great Leap Forward^ The People's Daily editorial of June 8, "What is this for?" suddenly called for an attack on those who "wanted to employ the rectification campaign for waging class struggle." This editorial, together with an inner-Party instruction by Mao, "Organizing Forces to Counterattack Rightists," dramatically reversed the favorable political atmosphere built up by Mao's former speeches, and indicated the Party's decision for a formal counteract against its critics. See MacFarquhar, The Origins of the Cultural Revolution, 262; Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji, Vol. 5, 431-433. 3 8  3 9  4 0  27  "wrong-doings."  41  The C C P called the targets o f attack "bourgeois rightists" (zichan jieji  youpai)  or "rightists" (youpai); the terminology fluctuated. In English these labels might refer to a person who is a member o f right wing political party or who has conservative ideas, thus being resistant to change or liberal reform. In the context 42  o f modern China, although the C C P frequently denounced the antagonistic forces against the Party as a "nationalist right wing"(guomindang rightist  force" (zichanjieji  youyi shili)  yoityi), or a "bourgeois  at different stages o f the Communist  revolution, the term "right wing" has been mainly applied to those associated with "imperialist forces," and those with background as urban capitalists and rural landlords, or those with strong anti-Communist stances.  43  During the campaign o f 1957-1958, the term "bourgeois rightist" was used first in M a o ' s article (restricted to inner-Party circulation) "Things are Going to Change" o f M a y 15, 1957, in which he stated that 1 to 10 percent o f non-Party intellectuals wereVightists whose agenda was to get rid o f the Party's leadership. Afterwards, 44  especially after June 8, in various anti-rightist onslaughts, whoever was believed to have questioned the correctness o f the Party and socialism was branded a "rightist." For example, Zhang Bojun was assigned a rightist "hat" for his criticism o f the C C P ' s monopoly o f power, and young clerks who talked about deteriorating rural  Official sources released by the Central Organization Department of the CCP indicate that the total number of labeled "rightists" is 552,877. See Hao Mengbi and Duan Haoran, Zhongguo gongchandang liushinian (Sixty Years of the CCP) (Beijing: Jiefangjun chubanshe, 1982), 491. Considering the fact, however, that official figures are strikingly inconsistent from 1958 to 1979, that the official calculation does not include rightists in high school students and former capitalists, and that significant numbers of people who were at first labeled rightists and later charged as "counterrevolutionaries" or criminal offenders were not counted into the rank of rightists, some Chinese scholars estimate that the number of the direct victims of the Anti-Rightist Campaign was over 650, 000. See Hua Min, Zhongguo da nizhuan: fanyou yundongshi (China's Great Reversal: A History of the Anti-Rightist Campaign) (New York: Ming-ching chubanshe, 1996), 148-149. http:// www. hyperdictionary. com /dictionary /rightist. See Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji, Vol.1, 3-9; Vol. 2, 660-661; Vol. 4, 1182-1185. In the precommunist period, Mao indicated the existence of "rightists" among Chinese intellectuals. According to Mao, intellectuals who did not entirely trust the Communist Party but favored American imperialism were "rightists in People's China." However, Mao also stated that "they were not GMD reactionaries, although there were great deal of reactionary and anti-people thoughts in their mind." See Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji, Vol. 4, 1374. See Ibid, Vol. 5, 423-429. 4 1  4 2 4 3  4 4  28  condition were similarly labeled.  45  The mandate to define "rightist" was officially retained by the C C P central leadership. Despite various charges launched against "rightists" by M a o , L i u , and others, the most comprehensive definition was announced i n a speech o f Deng Xiaoping, then General Secretary o f the Party. In his "Report on the Rectification Movement" given at the third plenum o f the eighth congress o f the C C P , rightists were assessed the following features: —opposing socialist economic and political systems and socialist culture in favor o f bourgeois ones; —opposing the government's basic policies; —denying the achievements o f the people's democratic revolution, the socialist revolution and socialist construction, and --opposing the leadership o f the Communist Party i n government work, particularly i n cultural, educational, scientific and technological organization.  46  This definition was published on September 23, three and half months after the campaign was launched. It was not until October 15 that the C C P center  finally  provided the criteria for the labeling o f rightists. From early June to m i d October, it was the leaders o f local Party committees (or branches) or heads o f work units who administered the campaign and decided who needed to be singled out, based on. their understanding o f the Peoples Daily and the anti-rightist rhetoric o f the C C P leadership. In addition, although the Anti-Rightist campaign was seen as the most 47  significant event o f 1957, the sanctions against the rightists were never put into the legal code o f China, and there is no evidence that C C P leaders tried to legalize their Anti-Rightist move.  See Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Liuyue xue, 255-258; Liu Meng, Chimtian deyu qiutian qing (The Whisking of Rain in Spring, the Clearing Skies in Autumn) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 2003), 139. Deng Xiaoping, Quanyu zhengfeng yimdong de baogao (Report on the Rectification Movement) (Beijing: Quanguo zhengxie xuexi weiyuanhui yin, 1957), 16. The citation here summarizes Deng's arguments rather than provides the full text. On October 15, 1957, the Party Central Committee itself noted that since the start of the campaign, it was local Party committees that had made the criteria for the labeling of rightists. See Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed. Jianguo yilai zhongyaq wenxian xuanbian (Selected Collections of Important Documents since the Establishment of the PRC) (Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, 1994), Vol. 10, 613-614. 4 3  4 6  4 7  29  The Party center frequently referred the rightists as the proxies of Western imperialism and of the GMD (the Nationalist Party) reactionaries in Taiwan. Some 48  Hundred Flowers critics (such as Long Yun and Chen Mingshu) were ex-GMD high officials or had been employed by the GMD government or foreign agencies. Work unit leaders, when labeling, always searched for possible links between their targets and these reactionary forces. Actually during the earlier elimination campaigns most GMD supporters had 49  already been sentenced to labor camps or executed. According to Mao Zedong, some 770,000 "counterrevolutionaries" were executed in campaigns before 1957. Those who actively spoke out were precisely those who had collaborated with the CCP in 1949 and had won its trust. Long Yun, for instance, was appointed by the PRC vice-chairman of the National Defense Council because of his cooperation with the Party in "liberating" Yunnan. Accusations against these collaborators with the 50  Party for their lack of allegiance were often groundless. The language used in the campaign was often caustic, rude and vile. The Party's call for condemning "anti-Party anti-socialism" elements was taken by activists as empowering them to ruthlessly attack anyone they disliked. If a target tried to make a self-defense when facing arbitrary denunciations he/she would be accused of having a "poor attitude"(/aft/«  buhao),  and scorching condemnation  would pour out to overwhelm the target. According to published sources, the language used in scolding rightists in the central bureaucracy, democratic parties, and institutions of higher learning included "careerist" (yexinjia), "double dealer" For instance, Liu Shaoqi in his "Speech on the Second Session of the Eighth Congress of the CCP" accused the rightists of being the "running dogs" of the imperialists, feudal comprador class and Jiang Jieshi's GMD government. See Fang Jungui, ed., Liu Shaoqi wenti ziliao zhuanji (A Special Collection of Materials on Liu Shaoqi) (Taibei: Zhonggong yanjiu zazhishe, 1970), 296. Liu Naiyuan, a victim of the campaign, was labeled because he had once worked for an American news agency as a journalist before the Communist takeover, and thus was suspected of being an "American spy." See Liu Naiyuan, Mirror: A Loss of Innocence in Mao's China (Philadelphia: Xlibris Corporation, 2001), 178-179. Mao Zedong, "On the Correct Handling of Contradictions among the People," in MacFarquhar, Cheek and Wu, eds., The Secret Speech of Chairman Mao, 142. For information about Long Yun and Chen Mingshu, see MacFarquhar, Hundred Flowers Campaign and the Chinese Intellectuals, 311; Shang Hai and Kong Fanjun, eds, Minguoshi dacidian (Comprehensive Dictionary of ROC History) (Beijing: Zhongguo guangbo dianshi chubanshe, 1991), 904.  4 8  4 9  5 0  30  (liangmianpai),  "academic swindler" (xueshu pianzi), "cultural spy" (yvenhua  "rascal" (wulai), "venomous snake" (dushe), and "miser" (linsegui)  51  tewu),  Cartoons were  also used for personal attacks. Because of her obstinate resistance to the criticisms against her, Zhang Hu, a journalist at the Beijing Daily, was portrayed in a cartoon as a wolf with a long tail.  52  Charged with "crimes" or "wrongdoings", more than half a million intellectuals and other elite members were condemned harshly; the majority were removed from their jobs, driven out of the urban areas and herded into various labor camps. Human suffering was the direct result of the Anti-Rightist Campaign. Images of the " R i g h t i s t "  Since the late 1950s two contrasting images of the rightists have emerged. The first one, which prevailed during the Maoist period, was mainly produced by official propaganda during the campaign and by officially sponsored literature afterwards. In these publications,rightistswere portrayed as an evil force: they attacked the beloved CCP and socialism; they agitated to turn the masses against the Party leadership and sabotaged collectivization; they associated with the GMD in Taiwan and with American imperialists, and tried to drag China back in to darkness and backwardness. They deserved heavy punishment. Starting from 1958, rightists 53  began to be categorized as one of the "five black elements" (hei wu lei), right behind landlords, rich peasants, counterrevolutionaries, and bad elements, and thus were officially demonized. This image had a persuasive appeal among the general public, who for a long time were led to discriminate against the rightists, shunning them as a form of disease.  54  Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 515-518. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun (Going towards Chaos) (Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chu banshe, 1998), 15. See, for instance, Hu Ke, Huishu zhuang (Scholar Tree Village) (Shanghai: Shanghai wenyi chubanshe, 1963), 7-10, 54, 66. See Liu Shaoqi's speech on May 5, 1958, in Fang Jungui, ed., Liu Shaoqi wenti ziliao zhuanji, 297. Insulting and discriminating experiences of the rightists are disclosed in numerous resources. Chen Dengke recalls that arightistnormally couldn't help but lower his/her head with deep embarrassment whenever coming across a friend or a neighbor after the campaign. See Zheng Xiaofeng, Ding Ling 51  52  53  5 4  31  After Mao died in 1976, another image surfaced, as a result of post-Mao political change and the subsequent rehabilitation of the rightists. The rightists have come to be regarded as figures who courageously condemned the abuses of the ruling party, who pursued political democracy, and sacrificed themselves for the good of the masses. While they experienced untold suffering in their motherland, they still loved the nation as its sons and daughters. In post-Mao literature and movies, such as  Tianyunshan chuanqi  (The Legend of Tianyun Mountain) directed  by Lu Yanzhou, Mumaren (The Cowboy) directed by Zhang Xianliang and (Unrequited Love) written by Bai Hua, as well as in the reportage Liang Wang Shiwei, Chu Anping  Kulian  Shaming,  by Dai Qing, rightists were portrayed as courageous,  patriotic and having strong political and ideological commitment. They were the backbone of the nation, the true patriots.  55  Upon close examination of the category rightists, it can be seen, firstly, that it is an extremely diverse group and thus defies treatment as a unitary group. Among the more than half a million who were labeled, leaders of democratic parties, scientists, writers, university professors and student activists accounted for between a fifth and a quarter of the total, while the majority were elementary and secondary school teachers, government employees, Party cadres, clerks, police officers and military personnel. They represented a cross-section of Chinese society. Although 56  all of them were subjected to persecution during the campaign, not all were attacked for political reasons. Great variation distinguish this group in terms of their political allegiance, reasons for being labeled, and personal experience afterwards.  zai Beidahuang (Ding Ling in the Great Northern Wilderness) (Wuhan: Hubei renmin chubanshe, 1989), 78. When rightist Li Guowen was sent to a construction site in Shanxi, he was isolated from other workers except at work, and he had to have lunch by himself at a designated table where a placard was set up indicating "Reserved for the Rightist Li Guowen." See Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 598. Yin Yi recalls that even though he completed his term at Beidahuang his colleagues and neighbors still avoided saying hello when meeting him. See Yin Yi, Huishou canyang yi hanshan (The Setting of the Sun over the Maintain) (Beijing: Shiyue wenyi chubanshe, 2003), 104-105. While movies The Legend of Tianyun Mountain and Cowboy were celebrated at the end of 1970s because of their motif as "patriotism," Unrequited Love was officially criticized and banned in China due to its "anti-Party" undertones. For a positive portrait of Chinese rightists in 1957, see Dai Qing, "Chu Anping and the Party's Rule," in her Liang Shunting, Wang Shiwei, Chu Anping, 113-231. Hua Min, Zhongguo da nizuan, 148-153. 55  5 6  32  Secondly, although sharp criticism o f the C C P did emerge, and turned out to be the cause o f the Party's counterattack and national wide persecution, i n truth the vast majority o f the persecuted fell far short o f being strong critics o f the Party. They were either genuine followers o f the Party or had little political interest or consciousness. During the Hundred Flowers, the sharp dissenting voices o f the few over-shadowed the others, which gives the impression that the majority o f those who did speak were political dissidents. A s the following w i l l show, most "rightists" were actually "accidental dissidents." M a n y rightists were revolutionary cadres, devoted followers o f the Communist regime, who firmly identified with the Party. L u Gang, a former college head i n Harbin, said: "I never meant to take a stand against the Communist Party. I joined the revolution when I was 16 years old even before the victory in the Anti-Japanese War, and I followed the Party step by step. H o w could I take a stand against our Party? I was just very outspoken, raising criticisms against some Party leaders."  57  M a n y intellectuals, even though educated in the pre-communist period, were enthusiastic i n their service o f the nation under the leadership o f the C C P . A s described by Y u e Daiyun o f Peking University, young students i n the early P R C period were very supportive o f the Party. Their sincere trust in the Party led them 58  to have little hesitation to speak out about whatever they believed was good for the Party. W i t h regard to their criticism, their real motive was to help Party's rectification. W i t h regard to their attitude toward socialism in 1950s China, many firmly supported public ownership rather than private ownership; what they opposed was the sham o f the contemporary distribution system and the striking income differentiation between Communist cadres and the working class.  59  ' Lu Gang, interview. Yue Daiyun, a female student and young teacher in Peking University in the early years of the PRC, recounts in her book why she, as well as many youths, became sincere supporters of the CCP. Dissatisfied with the GMD's corruption and malfunctioning, Yue enthusiastically joined communistled student movements and entered the Party at the age of eighteen. She optimistically envisioned "a new society based on complete equality, free of corruption" under the Party leadership, the conviction that set the basis for her political activism and full identification with the Party during the early period of the PRC. See Yue Daiyun and Carolyn Wakeman, To the Storm, 16-22. Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 167, 244. 3  5 8  5 9  33  D a i Huang's letter to M a o during the Hundred Flowers bears testimony to this point. A s a senior correspondent in the N e w China News Agency, D a i condemned the emergence o f a "privileged class", criticized Party corruption and the Party's alienation from the masses, and reported the dissatisfaction o f ordinary people. He even blamed the C C P ' s Central Committee for widespread bureaucratic malpractice and corruption o f the Party. In the same letter, he also swore his unswerving allegiance to the Party and repeated that "our Party is correct and our cause great." His aim was to make the Party draw close to the masses, who had supported the Party during its quest for the national power.  60  This duality o f criticism and allegiance is also the theme o f a well-celebrated novel Young Newcomer in the Organization Department, in which novelist Wang M e n g depicted an idealistic young cadre, named L i n Chen, who was committed to the Party's policy but ran up against bureaucratic  rigidity.  While Wang M e n g  disclosed that the Party bureaucracy had become increasingly arrogant and lazy so that any form o f reform seemed impossible, his main thesis was to exemplify the Party's demand to improve revolutionary spirit.  61  There is no denying that some critics were bold enough to condemn the dictatorship o f the Party and to call for a degree o f democratic reform. Zhang Bojun loudly suggested  that the National People's Congress, the People's  Political  Consultative Conference and the democratic parties should become the designers o f China's governing framework in the form o f a political design institute, to share power with the C C P . (Mao later argued that Zhang was trying to "wipe out the Communist Party.")  62  Some professors i n Beijing suggested that Party committees withdraw from universities and warned the Party not to be too harsh towards intellectuals  63  With  their unofficial journal Guangchang (Square) as a mouthpiece, Peking University Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng: wo de youpai licheng (A Narrow Escape from Death: My Experience as a Rightist) (Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, 1998), 45-52. See Wang Meng, "Young Newcomer in the Organization Department," in Nieh Hualing, ed., Literature of the Hundred Flowers, Vol. 2, 473-511; also see Merle Goldman, Literary Dissent in Communist China, 179-180. Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Liuyue xue, 257. Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shangcao, 108. 6 0  6 1  6 2  6 3  34  students spearheaded  their sharp  attack  against  the government,  and  loudly  condemned the existing political system, especially the concentration o f power in the Party. Some o f them claimed that "Marxism has turned into its antithesis since 1895," that "the bureaucratism, subjectivism and sectarianism have roots firmly placed i n the existing social system," and that "real democracy does not exist i n current China... because o f high political pressure and absolute subservience to leaders."  64  L i n X i l i n g , a law student at the People's University, claimed that China's  socialism was not real socialism, and that all Chinese were entitled to show their dissatisfaction with i t . During the spring o f 1957, some students even tried to form 65  a new party as an opposition party to the C C P . Student L i Jiangxin at the Northeastern People's University criticized the C C P for ruthlessly exploiting the working class and proclaimed his intention to establish the Socialist Labor Party o f China, a proposal for which he was arrested.  66  It is obvious from such statements  that these students had started to question Party doctrine, and to use their own judgment to assess the Party and Chinese social system. They advocated radical reform o f the existing political system. In this sense they did challenge the legitimacy, credibility and orthodoxy o f the C C P . Sharp critics as they were, the majority o f activists continued to endorse the Communist Party. In order to clarify his stance, Tan Tianrong, the "Number One Rightist" i n Peking University, declared that "I don't doubt Chairman M a o w i l l back us up forever; I don't doubt that the Communist Party w i l l rid itself o f black sheep for its own good, and I don't doubt that M a r x i s m w i l l r i d itself o f dogmatism i n the course o f its development.'  L i n X i l i n g also claimed that "What we need is a real  socialism; ... the Communists should be those who sincerely serve the people and strive for the Communist cause."  68  Their advocacy o f political reform was not aimed  at pushing the Party off the scene, but for strengthening the position o f the Party.  lbid„ 4-5, 9, 28. Ibid„ 153, 156. Dongbei renda (The Northeastern People's University Newsletter), October 21, 1957; Wang Shushes interview. Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 57. Ibid, 164.  M  65  66  67  6H  35  In addition to student activists, many democratic party leaders who were some of the chief targets in 1957 were actually loyal dissidents. Some, such as Zhang Bojun, were early Communist members i n the 1920s or, such as L u o Longji, were long-term collaborators o f the C C P i n fighting against the G M D government. C h u A n p i n g was also a sincere believer i n M a o and the C C P when the N e w China was established.  69  W h i l e advocating the independence o f the democratic parties, they  sincerely strove to rectify the CCP. They treated bureaucratic malfunctioning and the abuse o f government officials as cancers i n the body o f N e w China. A s long as the tumors were removed, they believed, the Party and socialism would be restored to 70  their glory. Their criticism aimed to make the communist political system perfect. Given their basic political stance, the C C P greatly exaggerated the threat these "critics" posed. Although the ferment they instigated i n China's political arena and its impact on high politics was tremendous, the number o f democratic party leaders and student activists was tiny i n relation to the whole population. From A p r i l to June 1957, the number o f people who were reported by the media i n Beijing as having aired their criticism was less than three hundred. In the provinces, figures were even lower. O n June 29, 1957, M a o estimated that there were probably 4,000 rightists 71  across the country that had to be condemned publicly.  What was threatening to the  governing party was the compounding effect that they planted in the minds o f high leaders rather than their real numbers. W i t h the Anti-Rightist Campaign gathering strength and the C C P leadership overestimating the threat the rightists posed, the number o f people to be singled out escalated. B y early October 1957, around 62,000 had been labeled, and the C C P center estimated that 150,000 rightists would be finally found through the course o f the campaign. O n A p r i l 6, 1958, M a o updated his estimate o f rightist numbers to 300,000. In September 1959, the Central Committee o f the C C P disclosed that  Dai Qing, Liang Shunting, WangShiwei, Chu Anping, 179-180. Ibid, 179-180; Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Liuyue xue, 255-257, 281-283. Bo Yibo, Ruogan zongda juece yu shijian de huigu (Recollections on Several Important Policies and Events) (Beijing: Zhonggong zhongyang dangxiao chubanshe, 1991), Vol. 2, 149. 70  36  450,000 had ultimately been s e i z e d .  12  The dramatic increase i n rightists being  labeled suggests that a sizable number o f people who might not necessarily have been critics were netted, given the rapid development o f the campaign, many for reasons that were quite different from the apparent ones. Due to the  heated  atmosphere generated by the campaign, political persecution spilled over beyond the initially designed targets to the broader population. A s mentioned above, at the beginning o f the campaign in June 1957, the C C P central leadership had yet to envisage a unitary criterion with which to brand rightists. It was not until October 15 that the Anti-Rightist drive in national and provincial organizations, and institutions o f higher learning was so close to completion that the center issued its Criteria for Labelling Rightists. According to this document, those who "oppose the socialist system and basic socio-economic policies o f the Party and government," who "oppose proletarian dictatorship, attack the foreign policies o f the government, and attack the movement o f liquidation o f the counterrevolutionaries," who "take a stand against the Party leadership i n nation's political life, viciously attack organizations and personnel o f the Party and government, defame worker and peasant cadres and revolutionary activists," who "instigate the masses to take a stand against the Party and the government," and who "participate i n anti-Party, anti-socialist clique"—all had to be labeled rightists.  73  A s extensive as these criteria are, the guidelines to judge one's political stance were actually blurred, and thus subject to manipulation. While the Center might seriously target those who were potentially threatening, the labelers at lower levels could fabricate political pretexts for their own reasons. A s w i l l be shown in this chapter,  political  principles were manipulated as a means to meet various  instrumental purposes. Under the guise o f political necessity, as claimed by labelers, the real reasons for one's persecution could in fact be multiple. A s well, in the  Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 446; Mao Zedong, "Speech on Wuhan Conference", April 6, 1958; The Central Committee of the CCP, "Instruction Regarding Removal of the 'Hats' of the Rightists Who Have Shown Real Repentance," September 17, 1959, in Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguo yilai zhongyao wenxian xuanbian, Vol. 12, 572. The Central Committee of the CCP, "Criteria for Labeling Rightists," October 15, 1957, in Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed, Jianguo yilai zhongyao wenxian xuanbian, Vol, 10, 613-617. 7 2  73  37  process o f labeling, practical reasons were often more fundamental than political ones, as noted by Keith Foster i n his work on Zhejiang. Factionalism and group 74  conflicts  stretching back  decades,  personal  dislikes and grudges  from past  campaigns, o l d love affairs, professional jealousy, labeling quota, all played a role i n the persecution o f people, all had a part in the growing viciousness o f Anti-Rightist Campaign.  Reasons for Labeling Frederick Teiwes argues the existence o f a mechanical struggle in post-1949 China that raises minor questions o f a practical nature to the level o f principle. "In this form o f struggle the goal o f ideological reform is cast aside; rectifying mistakes degenerates into attacks  on  individuals. Personal  grievances  and  factional  differences come to the fore and instead o f strengthening the party unity such struggles deepen already existing rifts." This research tests Teiwes's thesis i n the 75  context o f the Anti-Rightist Campaign. A s well, it w i l l consider why so many Chinese were labeled and victimized.  ( 1 ) Factionalism and Personal  Discord  Factionalism was one o f the most common reasons for which a considerable number o f Party cadres, "red" writers, and even senior revolutionaries fell into disgrace. In the Maoist period, factional struggles were widespread both at high leadership and at local l e v e l . During the Anti-Rightist Campaign, factional feuds 76  Keith Foster in his Rebellion and Factionalism in a Chinese Province provides an excellent study of exactly this abuse in Zhejiang local politics, although in a different time period. Forster suggests that for competing political forces in Zhejiang during the Cultural Revolution, pragmatic considerations to a great extent overran the political line. "The claim that callow youth and hardboiled workers beat, tortured and killed each other over an issue as seemingly remote from their daily terms of reference as the loyalty of political leaders to an ill-defined "revolutionary line" of Chairman Mao may detach political action from its social basis." See Keith Foster, Rebellion and Factionalism in a Chinese Province: Zhejiang, 1966-1976 (Armonk: M.E. Sharpe, 1990), 6-7. Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China, 22. See Ibid, Chapter 5. Forster in Rebellion and Factionalism in a Chinese Province, too, has discussed how the pervasive factional divisions within both Party bureaucracy and Red Guard organizations featured the provincial politics of Zhejiang and gave rise to ceaseless chaos during the Cultural Revolution. 7 4  7 5  7 6  38  made political struggles extremely intense. For example, the cultural director o f the P L A ' s (The People's Liberation A r m y ) General Political Department C h e n Y i was charged as a rightist because o f his long-term feuds with his colleagues, and then was sent to Heilongjiang for labor r e f o r m .  77  Factional struggles were well known i n the left-wing literary circles under the Communist influence. Since the 1930s, Chinese left-wing writers had split into two groups based on their alignment with L u X u n or Zhou Yang (literary watchdog o f the C C P ) . In the early 1950s, while discord continued, the purging o f significant number o f writers and artists were more or less related to such factional divisions and conflicts i n the upper echelon o f the cultural bureaucracy, particularly i n the cases o f H u Feng and D i n g Ling. The experience o f D i n g L i n g , a prestigious left-wing writer since the 1930s, illustrates how a "red" writer could be violently victimized by factional struggle within the cultural bureaucracy. It was not her criticisms in the Hundred Flowers period, but rather her long-standing discord with Zhou Yang that sealed her fate. A s early as 1955, she was internally condemned for an alleged " D i n g L i n g - C h e n Q i x i a Anti-Party Group." When the Central Propaganda Department o f the C C P was about to redress her case i n 1957, the anti-rightist struggle began, i n which Zhou Yang persistently questioned her party loyalty. Without a single word o f criticism over current political issues, D i n g L i n g was labeled a rightist and was deprived o f her Party membership o f twenty-five years standing.  For D i n g L i n g and Zhou Yang, as  " Hu Ping, Chanji: kunart de jitan, 425; Ou Jiajin, Chen Yi pingzhuan (Critical Biography of Chen Yi) (Beijing: Zhongguo wenlian chubanshe, 2000), 196-197. Hu Feng was persecuted in 1955. Although it is said his argument against the CCP's literary policy, which forced writers to immerse themselves solely in the life of workers, peasants and soldiers and to study Marxism-Leninism before they could write, infuriated Mao and thus caused his arrest, his poor relations with major literary officials (especially Zhou Yang) to a large extent contributed to his downfall. See Denis Twitchett and John Fairbank, eds., The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 14, 240-241; Dai Guangzhong, Hu Feng zhuan (Biography of Hu Feng) (Yinchuan: Ningxia renmin chubanshe, 1994), 94-107; Li Hui, Lishi beige: Hu Feng Jituan yuan 'an shimo (Elegies in History: the Wrong Case of the "Hu Feng Clique") (Hong Kong: Xiangjiang chuban youxian gongsi, 1989), 15-19. 7 8  Although Ding Ling and her husband Chen Ming insisted that divergence in literary lines remained the main cause of conflict between Ding on the one side and Zhou Yang and his henchmen on the other, many believe that personal animosity between Ding and Zhou remained the root cause. The 7 9  39  many other rivals, historically rooted tensions provided the grist for renewed trouble, to the benefit o f those who enjoyed more power. The victims i n D i n g L i n g ' s case were far more numerous than D i n g herself. During the campaign, most o f those formerly associated with D i n g L i n g — A i Qing, L o Feng, and B a i Lang were also subjected to attack. Feng Xuefeng, another o f Zhou Yang's rivals who had said little during the Hundred Flowers episode, was also given a rightist label on the grounds that he was trying to establish an anti-Party magazine. Almost all o f the purges o f senior left-wing writers in 1957 were related to factional struggle.  80  A prominent feature o f factionalism, not limited to literary circles, was that antagonists made use o f every means to attack their rivals under the guise o f "divergence in principles." "Historical problems" such as family background or association with the former G M D government also provided perfect  excuses.  Charges against D i n g L i n g were partially based on her arrest by the G M D government i n 1933 and her inability to provide solid evidence for her allegiance to the Party during that period. Charges against Zhejiang provincial governor Sha Wenhan and his three associates were based on the fact that they all came from non-  animosity dated back to the period of Yanan rectification in the 1940s and the Yanan Literary AntiJapanese Association. In the early 1950s, Ding Ling showed increasing disapproval of Zhou Yang as the boss of China's literary world (Zhou was then the president of Writer's Union of China and the deputy director of Central Propaganda Department of CCP), to the extent that she even did not try to conceal her personal distaste toward him in public. Ding's criticism against the "paternalist authority" of Party cadres over writers was believed to allude to Zhou Yang, while Zhou Yang accused the Literary Gazette Ding was in charge of being an "independent kingdom," where Party leadership was unable to exert influence. Ding's increasing hostility toward Zhou and her unwillingness to come to terms with him prompted Zhou's decision to bring Ding down. Efforts were made in 1955 to collect proof of Ding's history. Ding's relationship with a deserterfromthe CCP and her early imprisonment by the GMD were made use of to accuse Ding of being a turncoat. Although the effort failed because of disapproval of the Central Propaganda Department and Zhou was forced to apologize during the Hundred Flowers period, the Anti-Rightist Campaign provided another opportunity for him. In July 1957, when the CCP waged its open counterattack against those who criticized it, Zhou Yang and his associate Lin Mohan renewed their attack on Ding, accusing her of being a member of an "anti-party group." In January 1958, Ding Ling was eventually labeled an anti-Party element and rightist. See Zhou Liangpei, Ding Ling Zhuan (Biography of Ding Ling) (Beijing: Shiyue wenyi chubanshe, 1993), 72-78; Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian (The Blizzard World) (Xiamen: Xiamen daxue chubanshe, 1987), 121. Chen Ming, interview (August 19, 2003). Denis Twitchett and John Fairbank, eds., The Cambridge History of China, Vol. 14, 255-256; L i Xin, interview. 8 0  40  proletarian families and were thus believed to have been significantly influenced by bourgeois ideology.  81  From the cases cited above, it is obvious that the C C P ' s drive to silence different voices during the Anti-Rightist Campaign was reinforced by intense factional struggles within the targeted group. A s well, even when facing persecution, some targets, such as the democratic parties leaders, proved unwilling to stop internal feuds, which exacerbated their misery. When Zhang Bojun and L u o Longji, two chief leaders o f the China Democratic League, were accused by M a o o f heading the "Zhang L u o anti-Party coalition", they still continued fighting each other and discrediting each other, as other leaders o f the League joined the chorus o f accusations.  ( 2 ) Fabrication and Framing Teiwes notes that in the C C P ' s political campaigns, the basic approach to deal with individuals at the elite level "has been selective and surgical rather than arbitrary," that the "rectification movements prior to the Cultural Revolution were generally under strict Party control with targets carefully chosen, models o f deviant behavior widely propagated, and sanctions meted out according to the seriousness o f offenses."  83  Stressing the rationality o f the Communist campaign, Teiwes' thesis  might be valid at the highest levels o f the Party. A t local levels and for ordinary individuals, however, measures and approaches used in the campaigns, at least during the Anti-Rightist Campaign, were rather arbitrary, unreasonable, and far more complex than Teiwes suggests. Cases repeatedly demonstrate that people were charged for wrongdoings that they never committed or for criticisms that they never made so that labelers were able to meet designated political needs. Ge Peiqi, widely known for his threat to " k i l l the Communists," was a university teacher in Beijing. During the Hundred Flowers, he was repeatedly urged Zhou Liangpei, Ding Ling zhuan, 46; for information about Sha Wenhan, see Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, All. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 369-383; MacFarquhar, Hundred Flowers Campaign and the Chinese Intellectuals, 263-264. Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China, 26. 81  82  8 3  41  to speak up to contribute to the rectification o f the Party. According to his memoir, what he argued at a meeting was that non-professional cadres were incapable o f managing universities, that the Party should not look down upon intellectuals, and that Party members and cadres should not disassociate themselves from the masses, or seek personal privileges. When printed i n an internal circulation memo at the university, parts o f his speech were misquoted, having him argue: "do not distrust our intellectuals; i f the C C P runs China well, that is ok; i f not, the masses are entitled to get rid o f the Party; they have right to k i l l Communists, which does not mean they are not patriotic, because the C C P does not serve the people w e l l . "  84  When Ge found that his words had been tampered with, he immediately requested the authorities o f the university to correct the mistakes. Nothing was done, however, until June 8 when his distorted speech was published in the People's Daily, together with an editorial comment "Ge Peiqi airing his anti-Communist declaration." The revised version o f G e ' s statement went further to suggest that "the masses have always wished to overthrew the C C P and to k i l l Communist Party members; i f you communists refuse to correct your wrongdoings or continue your corruption, you w i l l meet your d o o m . "  85  Even though Ge realized the enormity o f the issue and  wrote to the newspaper asking for clarification, no correction was made. Instead, a torrent o f denunciations appeared  in the newspaper.  Based on the  fabricated  evidence, Ge was labeled an ultra-rightist and, soon after that, was delivered a life sentence for "counterrevolutionary crimes". Consequently, G e spent 19 years in the prisons o f Beij ing and S h a n x i .  86  Another case o f frame-up is that o f the playwright W u Zuguang. W u and several friends, on the basis o f common interest, formed a literary and artistic club, which met regularly for the enjoyment o f poetry, drama, calligraphy, and painting. When the Anti-Rightist Campaign began, this group was attacked as a "small counterrevolutionary clique." W u and most members o f the club were labeled as  Ge Peiqi, Ge Peiqi huiyilu (The Memoirs of Ge Peiqi) (Beijing: Zhongguo renmin daxue chubanshe, 1994), 138-139. Ibid, 139; Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Liuyue xue, 305. Ge Peiqi, Ge Peiqi huiyilu, 151-162; Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Liuyue xue, 314-319.  85  86  42  o*7  rightists. None o f them was given a chance to explain what the club really was. Ge Peiqi and W u Zuguang were undoubtedly not the only victims o f fabrication. Due to the need to foster an anti-rightist climate, individuals had to be sacrificed, even though the authorities were aware o f the mistakes. In Ge's case, although the process o f manipulation had thus far not been disclosed, it is not presumptuous to say that with politics in command, Ge's employer, the People's University, and the People's Daily closely collaborated to fabricate Ge's case to enliven the campaign, even though they were aware that G e was misrepresented. Occasionally, the C C P center publicly announced that it did not want to see the campaign misdirected. O n October 15, 1957, it instructed provincial authorities to avoid producing wrong cases during labeling. In the meantime, however, it also stated that  In the units where labeling was overdone and correction is needed, the enthusiasm and commitment o f the masses and activists must be protected. There is no need to publicly announce the mistakes. A v o i d the wrong impression that Anti-Rightist struggle is excessive.  88  The undertone o f this instruction was probably perceived by leaders o f various Party organizations. L u Gang, a victim o f the Anti-Rightist Campaign, confirms that in 1957-8 there seemed to be a consensus among Party organizations and perhaps all political activists: that the campaign was initiated by Chairman M a o and the Party Central Committee; and that it was a significant event. Even though individuals might be treated unfairly, there was no need to make major rectification for the sake o f protecting revolutionary zeal o f the activists.  89  When discussing the coercive disciplinary measures used in the political campaigns o f pre-Cultural Revolution China, Teiwes argues that "In cases where cadres persist in deviant behavior despite repeated educational efforts, the most  Li Hui, Ren zai xuanwo: Huang Miaozi yu Yu Feng (People in the Eddy: Huang Miaozi and Yu Feng) (Jinan: Shandong huabao chubanshe, 1998), 270. The Central Committee of the CCP, "Criteria for Labeling Rightists," October 15, 1957, in Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguoyilai zhongyao wenxian xaanbian, Vol. 10, 613-614. Lu Gang, interview. 87  88  8 9  43  severe disciplinary measure o f expulsion is invoked. Thus the purge is regarded as an extreme action taken only when rectification fails."  90  Findings from the A n t i -  Rightist Campaign show a sharp contrast with the Teiwes thesis, at least at local and work-unit levels. A lack o f educational efforts and the intent to verify basic facts meant that the purges were meted out with extreme arbitrariness in order to satisfy a political agenda.  ( 3 ) Attacks for questioning previous political campaigns and asking for redress A l l too often, people were persecuted because o f their request for the redress o f past wrongs. Those who demanded redress for H u Feng's case were particularly prone to attack. After delivering to M a o a letter that attacked the contemporary cultural authorities and criticized the C C P literary guidelines, H u Feng was subjected to a nation-wide criticism campaign and was arrested in 1955. In the spring o f 1957, numbers o f young students advocated for the redress o f his case and for his rehabilitation. The prominent student L i n X i l i n g argued that " H u Feng's opinion about  literature  is correct,"  counterrevolutionary are  and  that  "the  ridiculous." L i n ' s  connected with her defense o f H u .  9 1  grounds persecution  to  accuse  afterward  h i m as  an  was tightly  L i u Q i d i , a physics student i n Peking University,  put up a wall poster i n the university square. That poster argued that H u was a progressive writer rather than a counterrevolutionary, and that the charges and the arrest o f H u were illegal. He loudly called for the immediate release o f Hu.  Liu's  call w o n a warm response among university students across the country. W h i l e H u Feng's case was never redressed, L i u himself was charged as a counterrevolutionary, was sent to prison camps, and died before completing his fifteen-year sentence. L i n and L i u were not alone i n their suffering.  93  Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China, 9-10. See Lin Xiling, "The First Speech in Peking University," May 23, 1957, in Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds, Yuan shang cao, 151-152; also see Goldman, Literary Dissident in Communist China, 197. Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 113-114. Zhang Xiaofeng, "Hu Feng anjian yu youpai xuesheng" (Hu Feng's Case and Student Rightists). Unpublished paper. Sources regarding the persecution of Liu Qidi come from Chen Fengxiao interview. 9 0  91  92  93  44  Closely related to H u Feng's case was the demand for rectification o f the Elimination o f Counterrevolutionaries Campaign. In the summer o f 1955, the C C P central committee estimated that approximately 5% o f personnel i n existing organs o f the Party, state, military, enterprises and schools were "hidden  counter-  revolutionaries who were trying to sabotage socialism from within." Thus, the center demanded a nation-wide Elimination o f Counterrevolutionaries Campaign. When the campaign was concluded in July 1957, 1.4 million Chinese had gone through interrogation, 81,000 were labeled counterrevolutionaries and 3,800 were labeled active counterrevolutionaries and put into prison. Countless numbers o f innocent people suffered under false accusations and physical abuse; some were mistakenly executed.  94  In 1957, aware o f the devastating consequences o f the campaign, many  intellectuals and leaders o f the democratic parties asked for rectification o f the abuses o f 1955, which resulted in their own labeling when the anti-rightist drive got started. Luo Longji, a vice Chairman o f China's Democratic League, was designated a top rightist for his ardent calls for the establishment o f a rehabilitation committee to redress the 1955 v i c t i m s .  95  Party cadres also suffered from their demands for the redress o f wrongful cases. L i X i n , an associate Party secretary o f the Central Propaganda Department o f the C C P , recounted the reasons for his labeling:  I complained about the serious consequences o f the elimination o f the counterrevolutionaries campaign in 1955, and I did not agree with the practice o f labeling H u Feng and his friends Su Qun and L u o Feng as antiParty elements, all o f which irritated my direct boss. Consequently, I was See Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguoyilai zhongyao wenxian xuanbian, Vol. 7, 134-148; People's Daily, July 18, 1957. Wrongful cases were so rampant that even Luo Ruiqing, then Minister of Public Security in charge of the campaign, openly acknowledged that during the campaign "mistakes and maltreatment occurred... when some innocent people were arrested; in some organs and work units, some of those who should not be put under attack were attacked." See Zhu Zheng, 1957 nian de xiaji: cong baijia zhengming dao liangjia zhengming (The Summer of 1957: from Hundred Schools of Thought Contending to Two Schools of Thought Contending) (Zhengzhou: Henan renmin chubanshe, 1998), 258. 5,4  Luo Longji, "The Speech Regarding Establishment of 'Rehabilitation Committee'," in Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Liuyue xue, 276-278, MacFarquhar, The Origins of the Cultural Revolution, 271-273. 9 5  45  degraded to a minor post i n Hubei Province during the campaign. The next year, I was deprived o f Party membership and labeled a rightist. The irony was that when the campaign got started, I was a member o f a special A n t i Rightist committee i n my unit, while at the end I myself became a rightist. 96  A t the grassroots levels, many suffered from their demands for redress o f wrongful cases involving their families, their friends and even themselves. Hongda Harry W u complained about his elder brother's treatment during the campaign, and L i u M e n g for his own experience in 1955, which became important reasons for their labeling in 1957.  97  ( 4 ) Attacks for criticizing individual Party members In many cases, denunciation and labeling occurred when individuals were accused o f "disregarding the Party organization," "defying the Party leadership," or "oral abuse o f Party members and activists." Careful analysis o f these accusations reveals that almost all those charged were actually those who disregarded, defied, or attacked the Party secretaries or Party members o f their work units. For critics i n the Hundred Flowers, accusations against individual Communists were very likely to be seen as anti-Party actions, which caused the Party to launch a counterattack. It was assumed that taking a stand against any individual Party member or Party leader was equivalent to taking a stand against the Party organization, and thus opposing the Party as whole.  The story o f journalist Y i n Jiliang exemplifies this excess.  In 1955, I criticized one o f my colleagues (a Party member) for his philistine taste, for which I was investigated quite a bit. The result showed that I was innocent, therefore my life turned back to normal. In the Hundred Flowers period, I was trying to be an activist to show my political commitment. So I sharply criticized the abuse o f power by the Party secretary o f my work unit, which greatly irritated him. When the Anti-Rightist Campaign began, I was immediately labeled by him. While Li Xin, interview. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds: A Memoir of My Years in China's Gulag (New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc., 1994), 22; Liu Meng, Chuntiandeyu qiutian qing, 58. Zhang Xikun, "Outline of the Apologists' Logic," in Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 125; Liu Meng, Chuntian de yu qiutian qing, 59-60. 9 7  46  I complained that this was his revenge against me, he said that this was defense o f the Party branch. M y repeated petitions brought no favorable results. The more I appealed, the worse things became. Eventually I was labeled an active-counterrevolutionary i n November 1957. That secretary hated me to the bones." The experience o f Yan X u e l i , a middle school teacher i n Liaoning, also confirms this observation: Two issues that I addressed sent me to labor reform. One was my discussion o f the Hungarian Incident. 1 said in a school political study session that it was the wrongdoings o f Hungarian Communists that caused the riots i n the country rather than the influence o f foreign imperialism. But the main reason was that, I believe, I had a terrible experience with a member o f the Party branch i n my school, the person who was in a strong position to label [rightists]. Taking a stand against him was synonymous to opposing the Party branch. Furthermore, due to my consistent refusal to acknowledge this charge, I was labeled ultrarightist i n the e n d . 100  101  Discord between political leaders and professional leaders i n a work unit often took on a political hue. When a non-Party leader defied the intervention o f a Party leader over work plans or the appointment o f employees, for instance, an accusation of "taking a stand against the Party's leadership" would likely be made. He Shanzhou, the head o f the Chinese Literature Department o f Northeastern Normal University, was branded a rightist mainly because he disagreed with the Party secretary over hiring teachers; his action was seen by Party officials as a political offence.  102  Yin Jiliang, interview. As a result of Khrushchev's de-Stalinism, anti-Soviet riots broke out in Boznan and Hungary in 1956. In Hungary, students and intellectuals expressed deep dissatisfaction with the ruling Hungarian Stalinists, and, on October 23, staged a massive demonstration in Budapest demanding the removal of Soviet forces and asking for democratic reform. These efforts were eventually crushed by the Soviet Union and understood by the CCP as counterrevolutionary rebellions mobilized by imperialist and anti-Communist forces. See MacFarquhar, Cheek and Yu, eds., Secret Speeches of Chairman Mao, 89; Liu Shaoqi, "The Report on the Second Plenum of the Eighth Congress of the CCP," in Fang Jungui, ed., Liu Shaoqi wenti ziliao zhuanji, 295. Yan Xueli, interview. He Shanzhou, interview. w  100  101  102  47  ( 5 ) Jealousy, petty resentment and poor inter-personal relationships as reasons for political  labeling  Tani Barlow, i n discussing D i n g L i n g ' s involvement i n Communist politics, reflects that antagonisms between people were often "not really ideologically motivated, that had i n many cases developed on the basis o f jealousy or personal dislike."  103  This issue is too extensive to discuss i n detail, but a couple o f examples  show the pattern by which the personal became political in Maoist China. H e Y i n g was condemned for rising too quickly and eclipsing co-workers: When I became a rightist, I was only nineteen years old. Before that, I was the youngest editor i n a literary journal i n Changchun, Jilin Province. I was very famous i n the literary sphere o f the city, I got higher pay than many o f my contemporaries, and I became the focus o f public attention. So sometimes I was overconfident and arrogant. M a n y o f my colleagues were jealous o f me and liked to see me brought down. I said nothing about politics during the Hundred Flowers, but they put the Party secretary up to label me, and they finally succeeded. 104  The story told by student rightist Y i n Jie in Liaoning is strikingly similar to H e Ying's:  When I was studying at college, I got a higher allowance than many o f my fellow students because I was a cadre student (i.e., who joined i n the revolution before going to school). I got paid R M B 62 yuan monthly and led a better life than many. In addition, I was not studying hard but always got good marks. Therefore I became a target o f jealousy. When the campaign came up, some urged the head o f my department to label m e . 105  These examples might emphasize the role o f jealousy and personal grudges i n political labeling while intentionally downplaying other factors. The interviewees might also be unable or unwilling to recollect a l l the factors for their labeling. However, since the late 1970s, the political and social climate has been conducive  Tani Barlow and Gary Bjorge, eds., I Myself Am a Woman: Selected Writings of Ding Ling (Boston: Beacon Press, 1989), 43. He Ying, interview. Yin Jie, interview. 104 105  48  for them to discuss any elements, including political ones, that affected their fortune. M a n y interviewees are outspoken in detailing those painful years, and they readily admit that both political and other elements contributed to their purge. It is unlikely, therefore, that interviewees only provided inter-person elements at the exclusion o f all others. Personal grudges d i d play a part i n political persecution, and at times an important one. During the Anti-Rightist Campaign, there was a sharp divergence between the rhetoric and claimed aims o f the high leadership on the one side and the personal impulses behind them on the other, both at the top and at local levels. While high leaders tried to liquidate anti-Party anti-socialist forces, those singled out for purge could also be the victims o f street level fighting.  (6) Labeling as a means to meet assigned quotas The movie My Father and Mother (Wode fuqin muqin) by Zhang Y i m o u tells a sad story. In an elementary school set i n a mountain region, a young teacher is asked by the principal to fulfill the one space on the labeling quota set for the school, and thus suffers for life. A similar experience is also dramatized i n The Blue Kite (Lan fengzheng) by Tian Zhuangzhuang.  106  These stories typify the experience o f the  political campaigns in the P R C , and are invaluable art that reflects the life o f the Chinese masses. During the Anti-Rightist Campaign, as i n other political campaigns, the C C P arbitrarily established labeling quotas.  In September  1957, as the campaign  continued, M a o estimated that "those who uphold socialism approximately account for 9 0 % o f the whole population while those who take a stand against socialism account for 10%, among which the die-hard elements account for 2 % . "  107  This talk  My Father and Mother was produced by the Guangxi Movie Studio, 1999 and The Blue Kite by the Beijing Movie Studio, 1992. In The Blue Kite, the boss of Lin Shaolong tried to search for more rightists in his work unit, thus held a political meeting in which participants were reluctant to openly point the finger at their colleagues. When Lin Shaolong came back to the meeting from the bathroom, he found out that he had been labeled rightist. Mao Zedong, "Speech at the Supreme State Conference," October 13, 1957, in Red Guard Materials, Mao Zedong sixiang wansui (Long Live Mao Zedong Thought) (Np.: No pub., 1967), Vol.12, 69. 106  1 0 7  49  was i n accordance with the C C P ' s long-established norm that among the whole population less 10% were enemies. Although this talk o f M a o ' s might not be treated as a compulsory guideline, its idea was reflected i n M a o ' s other speeches and Party's directives. For instance, i n M a y 15, M a o formally announced that the proportion o f rightists might vary, ranging from one, three, five to ten percent i n different work units, and on June 10 the Party Central Committee provided a working example, stating that " i n the Democratic League, the proportion o f rightists and reactionaries is relatively larger, accounting for around 10% o f the w h o l e . "  108  These documents, although not restricting the labeling quota to 10%, virtually functioned as a requirement during the campaign, as many local Party leaders bore this 10% number in mind. Labeling quotas set by the various Party organizations normally ranged from 5 to 10% while their implementation depended on the activism o f Party secretaries or heads o f work units. university, middle school, professional  109  Each work unit, including  association, academic  institution and  government agency had to single out a certain number o f their employees as rightists, as dramatized in the two movies mentioned above, whether the suspects spoke out during the Hundred Flowers episode or not. Where local enthusiasm and official commitment was high, more than 10% were often labeled. While i n Shanghai, 8.5% o f university teachers were labeled rightists, in Beijing the numbers were more than 13 % .  1 1 0  Since quotas needed to be filled in each relevant unit, mislabeling frequently occurred as Party secretaries and/or heads o f work units had to find scapegoats. Otherwise they themselves were at risk o f being labeled with rightist tendencies.  111  Consequently, a large number o f innocent people who had little involvement i n political discussion but merely made casual remarks became victims o f this malpractice.  Mao Zedong, "Things are going to change", May 15, 1957, in Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji, Vol.5, 424; the CCP Central Committee, "Instructions on Careful Analysis of Certain Important Figures during the Anti-Rightist Campaign," June 10, 1957, in Hua Min, Zhongguo da nizhuan, 332. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 450-451. Hua Min, Zhongguo da nizhuan, 149-150. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 112. 10  1 1 0 111  50  Y e Songtao, a doctor who died in the late 1970s i n Dandong, Liaoning, was one o f many victims. H i s story was told by his colleague Wang Zhiliang.  Y e was a medical graduate, who was assigned from Shanghai to our hospital When he came back from his vacation i n the late summer o f 1957, the anti-rightist campaign was almost over. The leaders o f our hospital had already decided who were to be rightists except for one rightist space that was still to be filled ... Y e as well as everyone else was asked to say something i n a political session to condemn rightist Zhang. "Comrade Zhang," Y e said, "I thought you were a good guy before. H o w could you come to take a stand against the Party?" Right at this moment, the chairperson o f the session, the Party branch secretary, declared the conclusion o f the meeting. A n announcement was made very quickly: Y e was designated a rightist because first he called Zhang "comrade', and second, he said Zhang was a good person before. B y doing so, that rightist space was filled. Y e was instantly deprived o f his doctor's position, and down graded to be a sanitation worker. 1 2  In some cases, heads o f work units preferred to over-fill the quota to show their dedication to the campaign, a phenomenon described by Teiwes as "excesses" i n rectification campaign.  113  Several example o f this are: while in the Harbin Foreign  Language Institute, 11% o f teachers and students were labeled, the heads o f the Ministry o f Judiciary singled out 16% o f their employees, and rightists i n N e w China News Agency accounted for around 18% o f its journalists and news editors.  114  When the C C P center suggested that ultra-rightists should comprise 20-  2 5 % o f all rightists, the leaders o f universities i n Beijing seized 4874 ultra-rightists, accounting for 2 3 % o f all the rightists there.  115  For M r . L u Gang, a senior Party official i n a college i n Harbin, one o f plausible reasons for his designation as a rightist was his criticism o f his boss. "However," recalled L u Gang, raising criticism was not the only reason for my labeling. The root cause was that I was a high-ranking cadre i n my college although I was only 29 Wang Zhiliang, interview. Teiwes, Politics and Purges in China, 43. Lu Gang, interview; Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 453. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 450.  51  years o f age. I belonged to the "senior cadres o f young age," the group from which a representative needed to be singled out to attack. Thus I was designated as the representative o f this type o f people. 1 1 6  When it was difficult to find scapegoats to meet a quota, some work units had to assign rightist labels to individuals by drawing lots. These were known as "lotsdrawing rightists" (zhuajiu youpai).  A movie theater was given a rightist quota,  which the head found no way to fulfill, either by political accusation or by "election." What he finally did was requiring employees to draw lots, so this way a box cashier was selected eventually.  117  The absurdity o f rightist labeling was fully  manifested.  ( 7 ) Remaining silent during the campaign and various  implications  In his discussion o f political labeling, C a i Wenhui agrees that "people could also be labeled deviants simply because they said nothing at the meeting. The term you du hu fang or having poison but not released it  applies to this situation".  118  Charges against those who remained silent are particularly salient to two situations in 1957. The first, those who kept silent when the Party strongly encouraged criticism during the Hundred Flowers might be accused as you du bu fang when the political wind reversed. The second, accusations could also be leveled against those who refused to show support for the Party's Anti-Rightist initiative. In both situations, non-activists became targets. During the Hundred Flowers, some adopted a strategy to avoid trouble-"acting wisely by playing it safe" (ming zhe bao sheri) due to the uncertainty o f the Party's intention; they tenaciously kept silent on political issues. Others simply had nothing to say due to a lack o f political interest or consciousness. This strategy was not always effective, however. Remaining silent could be perceived as a sign o f holding a grudge against the Party—"to nurse a grievance in the heart" or "to bury hatred  Lu Gang, interview. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 112. Cai Wenhui, Class Struggle and Deviant Labeling in Mao's China: Becoming Enemies of the People (Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press, 2001), 155. 1 1 7 118  52  inside against the Party" ihuai hen zai xin). "The rationale was that no speech disclosed your refusal to show your support to the Party, an indication that you had anti-Party intention."  119  People in this situation, therefore, were still not entirely  immune from attack i f the Party Secretary needed someone to fill the labeling quota. L u Wencai, a literature professor i n Liaoning, recalls,  I have a friend named Wang Deyu, who was a genius in foreign languages. He said nothing in the rectification period, but merely put his opinions i n his diary. After the diary was taken out i n a sudden housesearch, he was labeled a rightist, even though he continuously refused to admit his "crime." H e was eventually shot in 1968 for "counterrevolutionary comments." 120  The case o f Wang D e y u shows that once an individual was locked onto as a suspect, he/she would eventually be found guilty by some means or other. The likelihood o f being labeled for remaining silent, however, was lower than for other reasons. In the second case, people were labeled for remaining silent during the Party's counterattack, and for having failed to expose their friends or colleagues, even though they did not say anything against the Party. After Chen Y i was labeled, three o f his assistants were labeled too because they all refused to denounce Chen even after being repeatedly "persuaded."  121  During the labeling process, individuals could be implicated by association with suspected rightists. In Beijing, more than 170 people were implicated in L i n X i l i n g ' s case.  122  A person might also be labeled simply for having family members  or relatives who were rightists. Chen M i n g was labeled primarily because his wife D i n g L i n g was the number one rightist i n literary circles; opera star X i n Fengxia was labeled because o f her obstinate refusal to divorce her husband W u Z u g u a n g .  123  Friends or work relations might also be roots o f trouble. Qian X i n b o , a journalist in  Lu Gang, interview. Mr. Hu, a campmate of Liu Meng, was labeled merely because he remained silent during the Hundred Flower period. Liu Meng, Chuntiandeyu qiutian qing, 136. Lu Wencai, interview. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 473. Ibid, 474. Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Jingji lu, 86-87. 120  121 122  123  53  the Central People's Broadcast Station, was asked by his boss: " Y o u worked i n a bourgeois newspaper before and you also have so many friends who have become rightists now; do you mind i f we name you as a rightist?" Qian's answer was: " It's up to the Party." Qian X i n b o was then branded a rightist.  124  Wang L i said that "a  main fault o f mine was that some people I helped recruit into a democratic party— the Nine Three Society had become rightists, so I had to take the blame and j o i n  Political labeling in 1957-1958 China became a bizarre and grotesque process, with multifarious motives. What was common to most cases include the following: 1) Prosecutors often raised mundane issues to the level o f a political principle; 2) campaigns interwove high politics with street politics; and 3) local and work unit leaders, especially Party branch secretaries, used the campaign to facilitate their own ends. In this sense, " a l l politics were local." A s a result, cases o f labeling greatly challenged people's perception and in many cases defied standardized categorization.  - A school principle wanted to have an affair with the beautiful wife o f a teacher. During the Anti-Rightist Campaign, the principal finally found an excuse to label the husband, sent him to a labor camp, and married his wife.  126  -Dai Juying, the youngest rightist in China, was a 17 year o l d clerk in the Ministry o f Culture when she was labeled. She was deemed guilty for her casual remark that "shoe polish made i n the U . S . is really good." Because o f her refusal to accept the criticism against her, she was accused o f "worshiping and having a blind faith in foreign imperialist things," and was sent to the Manchuria border region for labor r e f o r m .  Ibid, 402-404. Wang Li, interview. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 254. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 103.  54  127  -During the Hundred Flowers, the Party journal Red Flag invited artist L i Binsheng to draw a cartoon to satirize those cadres who were too timid to air their own voices. When the political climate reversed, L i was accused o f 128  "using cartoons to release anti-Party poison." - A returned overseas student, X i e Hegeng (who was also an underground Communist Party member), was labeled for demanding the C C P center to vacate its residence in Zhongnanhai to make way for a public resort. A middle school teacher, Chen Dongbai, was also accused o f being a counterrevolutionary because he opposed the  program  of  simplifying  Chinese characters and complained about a P L A unit for its failure to protect historical sites.  129  It must be noted that one was rarely labeled for a single reason. In most cases, the issues through which people were brought down were multiple and interwoven. For the artist D i n g Cong, three issues revolved around his disgrace. Firstly, D i n g , as the executive editor o f People's  Pictorial,  which was published chiefly for the  outside world, argued for a less political hue and a greater emphasis on real life; he was thus accused o f "holding bourgeois tastes in running the Pictorial." Secondly, D i n g frequently took issue with a Soviet advisor regarding management o f the Pictorial, thus he was accused o f being Anti-Soviet. Thirdly, he and several friends often  met  together,  forming a  salon, which  was  accused  counterrevolutionary clique with the nature o f Petofi C i r c l e . "  o f "forming a  130  One o f the reasons for which Wang Hongren, a junior police officer i n Changchun, was labeled was that he tried several times to apply for university for continuing studies, rather than showing more enthusiasm for his work, which was seen by his supervisor as a sign o f being uneasy with the job designated by the Party. Another contributing factor was a poem he wrote, which was regarded as containing  Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 28-29. Zhang Zhicai, Yongyuan zai chulian (In Love Forever) (Beijing: Jiefangjun wenyi chubanshe, 1992), 313; Chen Dongbai, interview. Ding Cong, interview.  1 2 9  130  55  anti-Party undertones; the poem was entitled The Tree and Grass. Wang was told this by his supervisor before he was labeled,  You described how grass has difficulty surviving under the tree. That obviously implies that you are the grass, and the Party is the tree. H o w could our beloved Party cause you difficulty in survival? That's obviously an anti-Party p o e m . 131  The irony is that the people who took a leftist stance in the high tide o f the campaign o f 1957 were not entirely immune from being seized i n the supplementary labeling o f 1958. In not a few cases, when some leftists made efforts to show their absolute loyalty to the Party, they ran to the extreme o f attacking heads o f their work units for administrative failures, for lack o f revolutionary initiative, or for lack o f enthusiasm for the campaign. When supplementary labeling was initiated in 1958 to net "escaped rightists" (louwang youpai), many o f them were then rounded up. A typical case was H o u Fang, a young Marxist-Leninist philosophy teacher i n the Northeastern People's University. M a n y teachers in the university suffered from his aggression during the campaign. When the campaign was concluded with great success, it seemed to H o u that he had secured his place in the Party. Too confident and aggressive to know where to stop, however, i n December 1957 H o u waged a sudden attack on the university president Kuang Yarning for his alleged bureaucracy. The result was that H o u was labeled soon afterwards and sent to the Changbai Mountain for highway construction. Being labeled for leftist or egalitarian stance not only was tragic for the victims but also made them less popular. A story told by Wang M e n g is illustrating. It was already close to the end o f the campaign, when he came out and raised a loud cry for preservation o f the Y a n ' a n spirit, especially sexual puritanism. He condemned the misconduct o f several cadres i n his unit who divorced their rural wives when they were appointed to important posts after 1949. H e also advocated extreme frugality i n contrast to Wang Hongren, interview. Wang Shushen, interview; Dongbei renda (The Northeastern People's University Newsletter), December 6, 1957, April 3, 1958. 131  1 3 2  56  extravagance of the cadres. Not only were those in power sickened by him, but also ordinary cadres did not like what he said. When he was labeled in the wake of the campaign, nobody felt sympathetic towards him. 133  Similarly, there were also people who tried to show their utter devotion to the Party, by making a clean breast of their "unhealthy thoughts." When their thoughts were disclosed, they were labeled rightists. Their activism and loyalty turned out to be their undoing. A woman cadre in Beijing tried to show her allegiance by handing in her diary that exposed depression over her private life. The result was that her diary was condemned as "anti-Party, anti-socialist poisonous weeds" and she was banished to the Manchurian borderlands.  134  From the sources analyzed above, it can be argued that although the CCP claimed that the rightists were anti-Communist, anti-socialist bourgeois reactionaries, and through this process produced more than a half million victims for persecution, the majority of the rightists were labeled for reasons other than those stated. While some did heap criticism on Communist officials and on the social system under the Party, and an even smaller portion challenged the legitimacy, credibility and orthodoxy of the Party, the majority of those labeled neither involved themselves in politics nor had any political interest. At the national level, they were victimized by the CCP's sweeping attack, whose aim was the preempting of potential threats, and by its strategic design for political control and socialist transformation. At the local and work unit levels, they were victimized for political expediency and to serve the personal purposes of individual Party leaders. In terms of the real process of labeling, there was little relevance to the ideological goals proclaimed by the CCP center. Envisioning Punishment  By early 1958, the Communist Party had achieved seeming success on the political front. Critics were silenced, the press that had been used to spread poison was under strict control, the vast majority of those charged confessed their crimes, 133 1 3 4  Wang Meng, interview. Liu Meng, Chuntian de yu qiutian qing, 137.  57  and the working class was mobilized to express its support for the Party. The nation under the Party had apparently achieved an unprecedented conformity. In line with political labeling, the CCP envisaged a set of policies for the treatment of the labeled. Although insisting that the enmity between the Party and the rightists was similar in nature to "contradictions between ourselves and the enemy," the Party advocated a solution along the line of "contradictions among the people," as a sign of the Party's leniency and willingness to "save" those who had gone astray but wished to repent. With the triumph over the intellectual deviants at hand, Mao began to emphasis leniency. At important conferences in October and December of 1957, Mao stated that "we need to take disciplinary action against those rightists, but not too harsh," and that we need to "criticize them seriously but deal with them leniently." The lenient treatment was "to give a way out" to the 133  rightists, to send them to factories, the countryside, or frontier areas to engage in labor reform instead of merely putting them into jail; this would be instrumental in transforming their evil thinking and making them into socialist supporters. It seems that the CCP center did not enact a special decree regarding the banishment of the labeled. It treated the banishment of therightiststo rural areas 136  merely as a part of the overall pattern of sending cadres for manual labor. On February 28, 1958, the Party issued an instruction "on sending down cadres to manual labor," which emphasized the necessity of manual labor as a crucial measure for Communist cadres to cultivate a "proletarian outlook" and to "draw close to the masses."  One portion that dealt with the disposal ofrightistsread:  See Mao's speeches, respectively, on October 9, October 13 and December 8, 1957, in Red Guard Materials, Mao Zedong sixiang wanshui, Vol.13, 55-75. So far no official document specifying the sending down ofrightistshas been found, either at the central or local levels. When they were sent down, the rightists were normally not provided official documents as justification of their banishment. Rightists Lu Gang, Wang Hongren and Dai Huang, when interviewed, recalled that heads of their work units all said that the arrangement of "labor reform" was being carried out according to "instructions from above (shangji zhishi)", yet no specific document was shown to them. See the Central Committee of the CCP, "Instructions on sending down cadres to manual labor," in Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguoydai zhongyao wenxian xuanbian. Vol. 11, 196. 1 J 5  136  137  58  All those who are punished to "labor under supervision" due to their serious offences are to be sent to agricultural cooperatives for manual labor overseen by cooperative members and cadres; others who have committed minor offence, show acceptable repentance and are punished by "being kept on the job but on probation" can be sent down after their problems are solved, providing that their physical condition allows for it. This instruction, together with Mao's favorable attitude toward "reform through labor," constituted a formal basis and general guideline for the post 1957 banishment. In 1957, however, rightists were not banished outright to remote areas. First, they were ejected from the Communist Party or the Communist Youth League if they had been members, some were stripped of their posts, dismissed from their offices, and then waited for further disposal. The waiting period could be a couple of months or could last up to half a year, during which time they were asked to study anti-rightist documents and to write self-criticisms for their alleged crimes. In the meantime, except for a limited number of disgraced revolutionary seniors and leaders of democratic parties, the majority of rightists were required to do manual labor within their work units or at local construction projects nearby.  138  For rightists in Beijing, various industrial and agricultural units in or close to Beijing provided places for their labor reform. The majority of studentrightistswere removed from campus. Peking University student Yan Tunfu, for instance, was sent to a textile mill in Beijing although she retained her student status; Lin Xiling had to perform physical labor under supervision at a university farm.  139  As for the thousands of rightists from various central organizations, who are the focus of this dissertation, labor close to Beijing was the first phase of their forced The memoirs of Dai Huang, Cong Weixi, Liu Naiyuan and many others all mention this process. James H. Williams also mentions that Fang Lizhi, due to his involvement in the Hundred Flower movement in Peking University, was expelledfromthe CCP (to which he had been admitted in 1955) and subsequently sent to Hebei countryside for manual labor. See James H. Williams, "Fang Lizhi's Expanding Universe", in The China Quarterly, No. 123 (September 1990). Yan Tunfu believes that although Mao suggested in his Hangzhou Conference Speech, January 1958, that 80% of university students be allowed to continue their schooling, Beijing municipal authorities forestalled Mao by quickly sending the students down before Mao's speech was officially announced. Yan Tunfu, interview. Regarding how Lin Xiling fared after she was labeled, see Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 452-453. 138  139  59  labor experiences. M a n y were sent to the h i l l region west o f Beijing or to the construction site o f the M i n g Tomb Reservoir north o f Beijing, a well-publicized state project. Normally, they were allowed to return home at weekends, to receive a limited stipend (around R M B 28 yuan a month), and some were still considered members o f their work units.  140  Waiting in the hope o f redeeming themselves, they  passed the gloomy winter o f 1957 i n apprehension o f the next spring when large scale banishment began, when they were sent to the countryside i n their home regions, to mountain regions and most significantly, to the Manchurian borderlands. The following chapters discuss the experiences o f those sent-down, especially, the experience o f the banished rightists and counterrevolutionaries from Beijing who were sent to army farms and labor camps i n the Manchurian frontier regions.  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 76-77; Cong Weixi, Zouxicmg hundun, 28-36.  60  Chapter Two The Beijing Rightists in the Army Farms of Beidahuang When I arrived at Qianmen Railway Station in Beijing, I found that many people were lined up along the sidewalk close to the old dilapidated city wall. Most of them were wearing heavy cotton-padded clothes and cumbersome winter shoes, some with coarse sheepskin overcoats under their arms. They seldom talked to each other, their faces were serious and sadness filled their eyes. I gathered that this was probably the waiting line for rightists coming from various ministries and commissions of the central government. So I joined the end of the line.... When I got on board, I came to realize that this train was a "rightist express" laid on to deliver more than one thousand people. Its destination was Mishan, in eastern Heilongjiang. Yin Yi, Banished Rightist in Yunshan  Farm  141  It was a soft rainy day in early April... The rightists of various central organs in Beijing were congregating at Qianmen Railway Station. They were to take trains to the army farms in Mishan and Hulin, to start their unpredictable life of exile in Beidahuang... .Many of them had family members and close relatives to see them off. ...People had little to talk about. What could those suffering injustice say to their loved Ones? Staring eyes and silent weeping turned to murmured words, disclosing complex feelings to the world. It must be that The Good Lord had found out the misfortune of these people, and thus precipitated a special rain, to pour Out his tears for them. Liu Meng, Banished Rightist in Farm 850  1 4 2  The spring of 1958 saw a heavy human flow through the Qianmen station, which had been used for about half century before the new Beijing railway station was completed in 1959 as a present for the tenth anniversary of the People's Republic. Priority was given to the transportation to the Northeast of a wide variety of migrants, including demobilized PLA soldiers, land reclamation youths, etc., Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi hanshan (The Setting of the Sun over the Mountain) (Beijing: Shiyue wenyi chubanshe, 2003), 25. Liu Meng, "Yutian" (The Rainy Day), in Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Jingji lu.jiyi zhong de fan youpai yundong (The Thorny Road: the Anti-Rightist Campaign in Memory) (Beijing: Jingji ribao chubanshe, 1998), 365-366. 141  1 4 2  61  among whom the most conspicuous were thousands of political exiles—people labeled as rightists who were to spend years in the remote frontier regions. Yin Yi and Liu Meng were among the witnesses and participants of this huge movement. The banishment of rightists to the frontier regions or inland rural areas was a remarkable undertaking of the Chinese Communist government. This chapter looks at the basic patterns of banishment of Beijing rightists to the army farms of Beidahuang, the Great Northern Wilderness (in eastern Heilongjiang), the decision making for the banishment, the perceptions of the rightists about Beidahuang, their daily work and lives, and their relationship with their supervision officers. Disposition of the Rightists  By the end of 1957 and early 1958, while the Anti-Rightist Campaign was still going on, the disposition of hundreds of thousands of those singled out was put on the agenda of the CCP central authorities. According to a decision the Party issued in January 1958, the punishment meted out to the rightists was to be broken down into six levels: the first category—ultra rightists—were to be removed from thenjobs and sent to labor reeducation camps; the second category were to be removed from their jobs and sent to the labor under supervision; the third category were to be removed from their jobs and sent to do physical labour nearby with reduced salaries; the fourth category were to be allowed to keep their jobs yet remained on probation; the fifth category were to be given lower rank and salaries at their posts; and the sixth category were to be merely given rightist "hats"(or "caps") but would be free from other punishment. Among those who were sentenced to do manual labor, the 143  first category—the ultra rightists—had to be rounded up by police and sent to work together with criminal convicts in labor reform complexes. Those in the second category also had to go to remote region but were allowed a degree of personal freedom. These devices for punishment constituted the formal institutional basis on The Central Committee of the CCP and State Council, "Stipulations on the Disposal of Rightists among State Employees and University Students," January 29, 1958, see Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Zhou Enlai nianpu 1949-1976 (The Chronicle of Zhou Enlai. 1949-1976) ( Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, 1997), Vol.2, 122. 143  62  which thousand of rightists from Beijing (hereafter Beijing rightists) were sent to Beidahuang, a formidable place. Harsh as the sanctions were for the most serious offenders, even with general guideline in place, it seems that the CCP's supreme leadership had not made clear plans regarding how to systematically dispose of the thousands ofrightistsfrom the central organizations. For about five months, these rightists were assigned to do temporary work around Beijing. It was not until February 1958 when Wang Zhen, 144  the Minister of Land Reclamation, proposed his enlarged plan of land reclamation in Heilongjiang that the central government decided to sent the Beijingrightiststo Beidahuang.  145  The decision to send the rightists from the central organizations corresponded with an unprecedented development program in northeast China, land reclamation in eastern Heilongjiang. In the spring of 1958, the land reclamation program was in full force, under the rubric of the GLF. Tens of thousands of demobilized soldiers were ordered to relocate to Beidahuang as major reclamation forces, followed by young peasants recruited from Shangdong and Hebei (known as frontier youth), and criminals rounded up from northern and eastern China. In the early stages of the reclamation, however, agricultural, construction and forestry labor was still in great demand. In this context, Wang Zhen, eager to recruit as many reclamation laborers as possible, demanded the sending of the rightists from the central organizations to Beidahuang, and his request was approved by the State Council.  146  The great  Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun (Going towards Chaos) (Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe, 1998), 28-51; Xu Ying, interview. In 1954, Wang Zhen sent a report to the State Council advocating reclamation of vast tracts of virgin land of eastern Heilongjiang, and, with his report approved, sent around seventeen thousands demobilized soldiers as pioneers into the regions of Mishan, Hulin, Baoqing Raohe, where they established dozens of army farms. Wang was a crucial proponent for the reclamation project in Beidahuang. See Wang Zhen zhuan bianxiezu, Wang Zhen zhuan (The Biography of Wang Zhen) (Beijing: Dangdai zhongguo chubanshe, 2001), Vol. 2, 68-70; Heilongjiang sheng difangzhi bianweihui. Heilongjiang shengzhi guoying nongchang zhi (Gazetteer of Heilongjiang: the State Farms Volume) (Harbin: Heilongjiang renmin chubanshe, 1992), 6. In addition to the army farms, there were eight collective farms established in the nearby counties by frontier youth recruited from interior provinces. See Heilongjiang shengzhi guoying nongchang zhi, 85. Wang Zhen zhuan bianxiezu, Wang Zhen zhuan, 70, 74-78; Heilongjiang shengzhi guoying nongchang zhi, 92-94; L i Hui, Ren zai xuanwo: Huang Miaozi yu Yu Feng (People in the Eddy: 144  145  1 4 6  63  demand for labor in Beidahuang coincided with the emergence of the rightists, and the intention of the authorities to dispose of them. Little is known about how the CCP leadership made the decision to send down the Beijing rightists; it is also unclear how the various central ministries carried out the coordinated plan for mass relocation. The recollections of the political exiles, however, provide valuable sources on the process. Ding Ling recalled the experience of her husband Chen Ming: A couple of days after the New Year, the Beijing Movie Studio under the Ministry of Culture informed Chen Ming of his verdict: while he was to keep his post, he was to be deprived of his rank and to be sent to 'labor under supervision' in Mishan, Heilongjiang. He was given three days before reporting to a meeting place in an eastern suburb. 1  Other recollections (Liu Meng,Yin Yi) point to similar situations: the rightists, after being stripped of their posts, were ordered to designated meeting places (Qianmen Station, for instance) to board trains for Beidahuang; cadresfromtheir work units supervised their departure. Some trains were "rightist expresses" (youpai 14.8  zhuanlie)  reserved by the Ministry of Land Reclamation, but most were not.  Therightistsbanished to Beidahuang camefromvarious agencies of the State Council, professional associations and institutions of higher learning, ranging from senior revolutionaries to members of the non-party elite,fromcollege graduates to office clerks. Many were prestigious figures who had once held important posts in managerial, economic, cultural, literary, or otherfields.Figures such as Ding Ling, Ai Qing, Wu Zuguang, and Ding Cong were famous for their achievements in literature and art; Wei Zetong ( senior director of the Internal Affairs Ministry) and Xie Hegeng (senior CCP intellectual, graduate of Cornell University) attracted Huang Miaozi and Yu Feng) (Jinan: Shandong huabao chubanshe, 1998), 297. Ding Ling, Fengxue renjicm (The Blizzard World) (Xiamen: Xiamen daxue chubanshe, 1987), 3. Yin Y i , for instance, recalls that he took a "rightist express" to Beidahuang, see his Huishou canyang yihan shan, 26; however, Dai Huang indicates that he and his five fellows went to Beidahuang in small groups without any supervision. Dai Huang, Musi yisheng: wo de youpai licheng (A Narrow Escape from Death: My Experience as a Rightist) (Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, 1998), 95. 1 4 7  1 4 8  64  peoples' attention as revolutionary veterans.  149  Military personnel were not immune  from being labeled and banished. A m o n g around seven thousand P L A officers, cadets and technicians who were labeled, more than one hundred were sent to Beidahuang.  150  Not all the Beijing rightists were banished to Beidahuang, o f course. The rightists from the Beijing Forestry Institute, for instance, were sent to the Great Xingan Mountain as forestry workers, and those from the Beijing Daily went to road construction sites i n the western suburbs o f B e i j i n g .  151  Journalist L i u Binyan (a  political dissident i n the post-Mao period) was banished to Shanxi, and young writer L i u Shaotang was sent back to his home village i n Hebei. Some were given the option to choose their destination o f the banishment, but most were n o t .  152  The severity o f the punishment did not necessarily match the severity o f the denunciations the rightists received during the Anti-Rightist period. Those who had higher political rank before being labeled normally received moderate punishment. For example, top rightists Zhang Bojun and L o Longji, who suffered  harsh  condemnation by M a o , were not sent to labor camps, but remained i n Beijing retaining their standing membership o f the Chinese People Political Consultant Conference, and living a relatively easy life. Zhang Bojun still enjoyed subsidized housing and car.  1 5 3  Beidahuang: an Imagined World  Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei: Beidahuang shenghuo jishi (Floating Rain and Snow: True Stories of Life in the Great Northern Wilderness) (Beijing: Zhongguo xiju chubanshe, 2002), 30-31, 43; Liu Meng, Chuntian de yu qiutian qing (The Whisking of Rain in Spring, the Clearing Skies in Autumn) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 2003), 138. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan (Allegorical Words: the Bitter Sacrificial Altar) (Guangzhou: Guangdong luyou chubanshe, 1998), 454. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 48-49. Although sending rightists down for manual labor was a government decision and great pressure to go was felt, flexibility still existed regarding the destinations they were sent to. Liu Meng, originally to be relocated to Qinghai in the Northwest, was sent to Beidahuang instead because of his strong resistance to going to the Northwest. See Liu Meng, Chuntian deyu qiutian qing, 63-64. See Zhang Yihe, Wangshi bingbu ruyan (Do not let bygones be bygones) (Beijing. Renmin wenxue chubanshe, 2004), 87, 294. 1 5 0  151  152  153  65  The term Beidahuang, the Great Northern Wilderness, was at first used by H a n Chinese during the Q i n g dynasty (1644-1912). Considering Manchuria as their homeland, Q i n g rulers i n the late 17 century implemented an exclusion policy in th  Manchuria. They planted two lines o f willows, the w i l l o w palisades, i n southern Manchuria, to prohibit Chinese migration and thus preserve the M a n c h u way o f life and retain control over the valuable products o f the r e g i o n .  154  The H a n who lived  south o f the w i l l o w palisades called the boundless northern land including all o f eastern Siberia Beidahuang.  155  W i t h the Qing's lifting o f the ban on migration to  Manchuria i n the second half o f the 19  th  century, and the massive influx o f H a n  migrants, the imagined world o f Beidahuang was reduced in scope. B y the time o f the Communist takeover, the term Beidahuang referred to the vast plains north o f Harbin and the Yilerhuli Mountains, the Three River Plain (Sanjiang  pingyuan)  bounded by the A m u r , Ussuri and Sungari Rivers and the M u d a n River Plain (Mudanjiang pingyuan).  In these areas the ecology was still one o f hunting roe deer  with clubs, netting fish with ladles made from gourds, and watching pheasants fly into the k i t c h e n . "  156  In the massive land reclamation o f the mid-1950s, four counties, Mishan, H u l i n , Baoqing and Raohe i n the eastern frontier region o f Heilongjiang, were the location 1  o f large numbers o f army farms, the farms that the Beijing rightists were sent to. In later years, especially during the Cultural Revolution, Beidahuang, as the destination o f hundreds o f thousands o f sent-down youths, was the generic name o f the whole Heilongjiang wilderness. Beidahuang has long been considered an undesirable place to live. Although  Yang &'m,Liubian jilue (Notesfromthe Willow Palisades) (Taibei. Guangwen shuju, 1968), 4, 12; Thomas Gottschang and Diana Lary, Swallows and Settlers: the Great MigrationfromNorth China to Manchuria (Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press, 2000), 46. See Mei Jimin, Beidahuang (The Great Northern Wilderness) (Taibei: Shuifurong chubanshe, 1975) 5-6. Mei believes that due to the fact that the vast territory in eastern Siberia was legally under Qing jurisdiction because of the Treaty of Nerchinsk signed by China and Russia in 1689, the term of Beidahuang bore a broader implication. Ibid,6. Zhang Linchi, et al, eds., Dangdai Zhongguo de nongken shiye (Land Reclamation in Contemporary China) (Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe, 1986), 24-26. 1 5 4  1 5 5  lS6  1 5 7  66  arable land was abundant and soil fertile, its cold climate (minus 30 degree Celsius on average during winter), its isolation from China proper and the difficulty o f communication made people shrink back at the sound o f the name. Isolation, a diet based on coarse grains (corn, sorghum) and the lack o f vegetables during the winter were also deterrents. Even after the Qing lifted their exclusion policy, H a n Chinese, except for some Shandong and Hebei migrants, normally avoided this desolate marsh-land.  158  In the1930s Japanese colonizers attempted to open this area but  ended in failure.  159  While Beidahuang historically provided a perfect site for the rulers o f China to banish  undesirable  elements,  its  harsh  physical environment  and  isolated  geographical location generated immense fear in offenders, including the political offenders o f 1957. Being aware that they would be sent to Beidahuang, a sense o f sadness and despair overwhelmed many Beijing rightists. They did not know i f they would come back alive or whether they would ever see their families again. Some tried to appeal to be sent to other locations, but were usually refused.  160  Considerable numbers o f Beijing rightists, however, were not afraid o f being banished to Beidahuang, and some i n literary and cultural circles volunteered to go there even though they were offered other options. According to a directive o f the central authorities, only  rightists  assigned to the first and second levels o f  punishment had to be sent to difficult regions for labor reeducation or labor under supervision; while those with lower levels o f penalty did not have to be sent there. Some rightists such as writers D i n g L i n g and N i e Gannu requested to go to  For a general account of Shandong migration to Manchuria, see Gottschang and Lary, Swallows and Setders. Jiang Dongping, "Weiman riben kaituotuan de zuie lishi" (The Evil History of the Japanese Land Reclamation Group), in Zongheng, No.4, 1999, 47-49; Heilongjiang sheng difangzhi bianweihui, Hedongjiang shengzhi guoying nongchang zhi, 4. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 8. According to Wu, a journalist You Zai of the Dagong Daily tried to remain in Beijing on the grounds of his health problems, only to be refused immediately by his work unit and scolded by anti-rightist activists. 159  160  67  Beidahuang.  The reasons for these requests were complicated.  Some political exiles were impressed by the natural landscape o f the northeast. With the tidal wave o f land reclamation, media coverage o f the landscape and the social transformation  o f Manchuria increased dramatically; this contributed to  people's knowledge o f Manchuria and gave an idealized image o f Beidahuang. D i n g L i n g was among many who were impressed by the forests o f Heilongjiang pictured in books she collected.  162  Journalist Cong Weixi was also strongly impressed by the  boundlessness, the natural beauty and the fertile land o f Beidahuang. C o n g believed that, for people without families to worry about, Beidahuang was an oasis far away from mundane life. He wrote: "I was infatuated with the northeast, especially i n winter when it was decorated by the white snow, so I went to this silvery white world twice in the fall 1956 and spring 1957."  163  To young idealists, life in this great  wilderness could help people with their spiritual growth. The second reason to want to go there was, for some revolutionary writers, the search for sources and inspiration for literary creations about and for ordinary people. Taking to heart M a o ' s injunction i n the Yan'an Talks, some writers sincerely believed i n the necessity o f going to the grassroots and writing about the masses.  164  D i n g L i n g , for instance, insisted that a revolutionary writer should enthusiastically go down to the rural world, observe and learn from the real life o f the masses (tiyan shenghuo) even through adversity. She presumed that living close to the soil would provide nourishment for her literary creativity i n writings that would present the epic  Ding Ling, Fengxue renjicm (The Blizzard World) (Xiamen: Xiamen daxue chubanshe, 1987), 1618; Zhou Jianqiang, Nie Gannu Zhuan (Biography of Nie Gannu) (Chengdu: Sicuan renmin chubanshe, 1987), 219-220. Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian, 16-17. One of Ding's pastimes was to go through copies of People's Pictorial looking at scenes of the Xing'an Mountains in Manchuria. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 7, 121. In May 1942, Mao made his famous "Talks at the Yan'an Forum of Literature and Art," in which he required adherence to the Party line by writers and artists —to go down to the grassroots and write about the grassroots, in order to serve the masses well and to qualify as progressive writers. The Yan'an Talks served as a guideline for production of literature and art in Maoist China. See Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji (Selected Works of Mao Zedong) (Beijing: Renmin chubanshe), Vol. 3, 807-808. 1 6 2  163  1 6 4  68  transformation of heaven and earth by the northeasterners.  103  Another example was essayist Nie Gannu. With his prestige as a revolutionary veteran, Nie was offered the option of retirement after being labeled a rightist, or continuing his work at a lower rank at the People's Literature Press, but he declined the "kindness." "Life is the source of writing," he said. "As a writer I should experience all kinds of life. Now that I have become a rightist, I would like to lead the real life of this kind." In a sense, what these intellectuals sought was self166  banishment. The third reason some rightists opted for Beidahung was to show their commitment to ideological remolding and to redeeming themselves. Many artists, such as Ding Cong and Huang Miaozi, were told by the Party apparatus that they had committed serious crimes against the Party and the nation, and thus needed to redeem themselves through hard labor in the most difficult areas. Beidahuang with its dual features - physical hardship and its unprecedented revolutionary changes since 1949 - was the ideal place to go. Driven by this propaganda, they were willing to go to Beidahuang to prove their commitment to self-reform.  167  For most of .the rightists, however, revolutionary hyperbole could not make Beidahuang more attractive. But being demonized and having experienced periods of harsh attacks and insults, therightistswere notorious with both their colleagues arid their neighbors. A rightist would always have to lower his head in deep embarrassment when coming across a friend, and even their families were persuaded to condemn them and to announce the breakdown of the family relationship. The 168  Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian, 17. Zhou Jianqiang, Nie Gannu zhuan, 220. Xin Suwei, Ding Cong zhuan (Biography of Ding Cong) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 1993),182-184. See Zheng Xiaofeng, Ding Ling zai Beidahuang (Ding Ling in the Great Northern Wilderness) (Wuhan: Hubei renmin chubanshe, 1989), 78. Many other rightists indicate similar experiences they went through after the campaign. Wu Yongliang recalls that with the instructions from above to isolate the rightists, "there was no nodding, no hello, no smilefromfriends,who began to treat us as strangers and shunned us as contagious disease." Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 14. Ding Ling as well as leading rightists Zhang Bojun and Chu Anping all had experiences of being renounced by their children or cut off family relationship. See Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian, 64; Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 508-510. Opera actress Xin Fengxia was persuaded by her boss to divorce her husband Wu Zuguang but she refused. See Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Jingji lu, 87. 1 6 5  1 6 6  1 6 7  1 6 8  69  social isolation the rightists felt was unbearable. In this situation, going to Beidahuang seemed to be a relief to some extent. Many rightists assumed that in an exile community established in a remote location, everybody would be equal, and that the smell of the black earth meant hope.  169  When their fates were sealed and  discrimination by their colleagues and neighbors escalated, many wanted to seek refuge in the wilderness, to free themselves from political pressure.  Arrival in Beidahuang When they first arrived in the place of banishment, the chief concern of the Beijing rightists was how long they would have to stay in Beidahuang. Things did not seem so grim at this point. Before leaving Beijing, many rightists were given hints by heads of their work units that as long as they did well, they might be recalled within one or two years.  170  There were other signs that reform through  manual labor was likely a temporary period: bosses of many work units advised the rightists not to let their professional expertise get rusty. The rightists from the Central Orchestra in Beijing, for instance, were allowed to take their musical instruments with them to Beidahuang. Journalists from the Xinhua News Agency were  encouraged  to  take  with them  English books  and English-Chinese  171  dictionaries.  Many exiles, therefore, expected that their frontier banishment would  not be that harsh and would not last long. As long as they sincerely engaged in reform through labor, they assumed, the Party would give them a chance go back to normal life, and continue their work in their fields of expertise. Journalist Dai Huang recalls that when taking the journey "with a box of books, I was full of confidence in pursuing a bright future in the wilderness."  172  Even though it is hard to gauge if  Dai's feelings were typical, it seems that at least some political exiles were not Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian, 17-18; Xu Chengbei, "Nie Gannu zai Beidahuang," in Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao: jiyi zhong de fan youpai yundongiGtass on the Plains: the AntiRightist Campaign in Memory) (Beijing: Jingji ribao chubanshe, 1998), 308. When Ding Cong was about to leave for Beidahuang, the director of his work unit encouraged him to show his best performance in labor reform, and promised to get him back in one year. See Xin Suwei, Ding Cong zhuan, 186. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 97. Ibid, 97. 169  170  171 172  70  feeling entirely hopeless. From early M a r c h 1958, thousands o f Beijing rightists arrived at various locations i n Beidahuang. D i n g L i n g was assigned to Tangyuan and A i Qing, the famous poet, and his family to Farm 852; the vast majority o f the Beijing rightists were sent to Farms 850 and 853.  Revolutionary veterans N i e Gannu and X i e  Hegeng, artists D i n g Cong and Huang M i a o z i , as well as journalists D a i Huang, W u Yongliang and L i u M e n g were sent to Farm 850, the first army farm set up in Beidahuang. Foreign literature specialist Huang W u , playwrights W u Zuguang and Wang Zheng, and journalists Zheng Xiaofeng and Sun Zhanke were sent to Farm 853. Chen M i n g , before being allowed to join D i n g L i n g in Tangyuan, was also sent to Farm 8 5 3 .  174  In these farms the Beijing rightists worked with demobilized soldiers,  convicts and j o b placement people (those who had completed their terms but were forcibly retained within labor camps). The gazetteers o f Farms 850 and 853, as well as the memoirs o f D a i Huang, W u Yongliang, Y i n Y i , and the recollections o f Zheng Xiaofeng a l l mention that these three kinds o f people constituted the major labor force i n the army farms. For most political exiles i n Farm 850, their experience in the first months was not bad. In sharp contrast to their debased status in Beijing, their formal status i n the farm was agricultural worker (nonggong) rather than rightist, t h e farm authorities designated 120 demobilized officers to supervise their daily life and to organize their  According to the farm gazetteers, 925 rightists were sent from Beijing to different branches of Farm 850 and 486 rightists to Farm 853, totaling 1411. See Bawuling nongchangshi bianxie bangongshi, Bawuling nongchangshi (Gazetteer of the Farm 850) (Hulin, Heilongjiang: No pub, 1986), 30; and Bawusan nongchangzhi bianshen weiyuanhui, Bawusan nongchangzhi (Gazetteer of the Farm 853) (Beijing: No pub,1986), 2. The figures of the Beijing rightists provided by the two Gazetteers are not consistent with other sources, however. For instance, Wang Zhen zhuan indicates 1039, and Zhongguo dongbeijiao indicates 1327. See Wang Zhen zhuan bianxiezu, Wang Zhen zhuan, 78; Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao, 66. A possible reason is that the gazetteers include the rightists sent from various military units of Beijing while others do not. Another possible reason is that the spouses of the Beijing rightists who came along might be incorporated into the rightist list in some sources while omittedfromothers. See Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 103. Significant information about these political exiles is drawn from their memoirs and biographies. Zheng Jiazhen in his lengthy reportage Zhongguo dongbeijiao also describes the lives of Ding Ling, Ai Qing, Nie Gannu and Wu Zuguang in Beidahuang. 173  1 7 4  71  Forced labor allocation to the army farms (1958)  Forced Laborers of Demobilized Criminals  Name Farm  Soldiers  Farm 850  12,800  Farm 852  10,600  5,074  Rightists Beijing  Local  Military  828  61  97  Ai Qing & 261 (including His Family  other  "bad  elements") Farm 853  484  4,668  Tarig Yuan  14,000  60  19  Ding Ling & husband  Sources: Bawiding nongchcmgshi, 30; Bawuscm nongchcmgzhi, 2; Zhongguo dongbei jiao, 66; Wa Zhen zhuan, 68, 81; HeUongjiang shengzhi guoying nongchang zhi, 76.  work. It seems, however, that the farm authorities did not develop clear measures 175  as to how to remold these rightists ideologically as instructed by the Party. The managerial and ideological control over the rightists was relatively loose in the first months, which enabled them to enjoy considerable freedom to learn, to talk, and to entertain themselves after work. They sang Peking opera, practiced painting, played bridge, conducted research, and read foreign language texts." While living 176  conditions were hard - they lived in shabby earthen sheds - and the physical work heavy, the rightists led passable lives until the summer of 1959 when food shortages started to be felt. The situation was similar at Farm 853 where, as journalist Zheng Xiaofeng recalls, the political exiles did not feel much pressure. The demobilized PLA officers in Zheng's work team treated the rightists rather politely, addressing them as "sent175 176  Bawuling nongchangshi, 30. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 117-118.  72  down cadres" (xiafang  ganbu)  rather than using insulting terms. Except for daily  work, the lives of political exiles were not badly disturbed, and discrimination 177  against the rightists was kept at a minimum. Some Party officials in charge of the land reclamation took a moderate attitude toward the rightists. Wang Zhen, the minister of Land Reclamation, seemed rather helpful to the rightists that he had recruited from Beijing. He visited the rightists in Farms 850 and 853 shortly after they arrived, and tried to cheer them up by suggesting that they had a bright future if they took a positive attitude towards labor reform. What made the rightists extraordinarily happy was that Wang addressed them as "comrades," which seemed to remove the stigma and humiliation of the 17R  Anti-Rightist Campaign. Under Wang's instructions, the farm authorities took certain measures to improve the living conditions of the exiles (generating electricity for daily use of the rightists, for instance) and reassigned some rightists to work on local literature magazines, in art troupes, movie theaters, schools, etc. Many rightists in Farm 850 were moved to the point that they even called their experience so far as "civilized banishment."  179  The rightists were normally allowed to bring family members with them. Although few of them had the heart to make their families experience unforeseeable hardship, there were cases in Farm 850. Han Yuan, an ordinary employee in the Ministry of Culture, went with her husband, trying to follow the example of the heroic wives of Russian Decembrists with whom she was familiar from Soviet movies. When Nie Gannu worked in Farm 850, he met several women who had 180  Zheng Xiaofeng, interview. Huang Wu also recalls that the Farm 853 "was a new world, where we felt liberated psychologically, and there was no discrimination from outside anymore." Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji (Additional Collection of Mahua Hall) (Guangzhou: Guangdong wenhua chubanshe, 1989), 189. Bawuling nongchangshi, 31; Wang Zhen zhuan, 78-79; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 113-115; Liu Meng, Cuntian de yu qiutian qing, 94-96; Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian, 14-15; all acknowledge Wang Zhen's visits and his paternalist care for the rightists. Wang Zhen's warm gesture to the rightists was seen as a sign of Party's concern of the banished intellectuals. Bawuling nongchangshi, 31; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 115. Regarding rightist comments on "civilized banishment," see Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 119-120. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 103. 177  178  179  180  73  accompanied their husbands to the desolate region. For a period they had to live with other male laborers in a newly-built shed that housed about ninety people. At night, the wives slept at both ends of the wide kang (northern style bed), with their husbands close to them, and the rest of men jammed together on the other side of the husbands. With women about, the men tried to show better behavior; and the dirty jokes that used to circulate among men totally disappeared. 181  Couples in such surroundings certainly were unable to enjoy conjugal life, but the warmth and kindness of the exile community was appreciated. Rightists with accompanying spouses were rare. Most of them left their wives or husbands behind. In cases where both members of a couple were labeled and banished, their child(ren) were left in Beijing, often without proper care. Even though divorce because of political disgrace was not as common as in the period of the Cultural Revolution, there were cases where one of a couple attempted to avoid being implicated or to draw a political line between themselves and the one who had once been beloved but was now the enemy of the people. While there are many stories about unwavering commitment to marriage, such as the cases of artists Wu Zuguang, Huang Miaozi and Ding Cong, there were also a few cases where spouses of rightists asked for divorces to show their commitment to the Party, such as the cases of journalists Xu Zimei and Dai Huang.  182  Somerightists,however,  voluntarily asked their spouses for divorces once they were labeled, or publicly announced a break with their families in order not to bring trouble to them; those who were engaged broke their engagements. Forced Labor  Xu Chengbei, "Nie Gannu zai Beidahuang," in Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 309. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 86-87. Liu Meng, Cuntian de yu qiutian qing (108-110), Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei (87-89), Yin Yi, Huishou canyang yi nan shan (41), also documented various family crises, most of which ended in divorces. Huang Wu, Mahuatangwaiji, 5, 16, 26. 181  182  183  74  The early, relaxed stage o f life i n Beidahuang turned out to be transitory, however. It was not long before most o f the rightists realized that things would not work out as they expected, and came to see how harsh the conditions they had to confront were. During the years 1958-59, the nation-wide economic adventure, the G L F , featured huge and wasteful inputs o f labor. In desolate Beidahuang, the state's agenda to establish a national grain base spelt daunting manual work i n agriculture and forestry, work that became the daily job o f the rightists. Eastern Heilongjiang, and Beidahuang i n particular, was i n a physical sense the toughest region o f all Manchuria. When the various forced migrants (demobilized soldiers, convict criminals and rightists) gathered i n the area in early 1958, it was just a vast stretch o f swamp and boggy grassland as far as the eye could see.  184  Since  the level o f mechanization was extremely l o w i n the early stages, a l l the tilling, sowing and reaping had to be done manually. Put into special rightist teams the political exiles had to do all kinds o f work: cultivating the land, harvesting crops, building reservoirs, cutting wood, excavating earth, making bricks, erecting barracks, building roads and raising livestock, etc. The work was backbreaking for the frail intellectuals who had only done academic work and managerial work before. D a i Huang provided an example o f the variety o f work done by the political exiles in the Yunshan Branch:  Right after the soybean harvest i n the early winter o f 1958, dozens o f us went into the Wanda Mountains to cut hard oak trees...Less than one month afterward (December 1 , 1958), we were ordered to leave the mountains, to go to the grasslands for an irrigation project...The people i n our platoon had to strive to finish their work quotas. We used pickaxes to break up the frozen topsoil, sometimes close to one meter thick, then dug out the unfrozen soil...It was still dark when the reveille sounded i n the morning. We had to leave our barracks and rush dozens o f //' to work, and have breakfast i n the fields. During that winter, we usually slept for no more than four hours a day. st  185  Zhang Linchi, et al., eds., Dangdai Zhongguo de nongken shiyie (Land Reclamation in Contemporary China) (Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe, 1986), 18-19. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 125-126. 1 8 4  185  75  For the rightists, work hours ranged from twelve to sixteen hours a day. In the summer, they had to get up at three or four o'clock in the morning, and to work until dark. In some branch farms, weekends were cancelled during the summer of 1958, during the GLF. The rightist laborers were driven to ceaseless physical exertion. 186  Forestry work in winter was another ordeal for the banished intellectuals. As poet Huang Wu recalls: In the winters of 1958 and 1959, we rightists were twice ordered to go into the Wanda Mountains to cut wood. We went into the mountain in September and left in March the next year, which was the coldest season in this remote frontier area... The mountain valleys were deep and the forest dense without a trace of human habitation. We had to share the forests with wolves, bears and wild boars day and night. The tree felling was not without danger; it was easy for us to get hurt or even killed by the falling .  trees.  187  Casualties happened during forestry will be discussed in Chapter Four. Like winter forestry, charcoal making was also an ordeal for many rightists. In order to produce charcoal of good quality, the rightists often had to go into kilns to bring out the charcoal while the kilns were still filled with hot smoke and ash. The stronger people could manage to do this quickly, but those in poor physical shape often fainted inside. Some were rescued by their fellows, and some died with charcoal ash on their faces.  188  The rightists, like the demobilized soldiers and convicts, were put into a quasimilitary system and organized along military lines: regiment, company, platoon, squadron and so on, with demobilized officers (now cadres) as their commanders above the company level. Some officers, as Nie Gannu saw in Branch 4, showed a Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 120; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 7, 64. Dai Huang recalls that he and his fellow exiles were once forced to work for 56 hours almost without sleep when constructing an irrigation canal. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 127. Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 189. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 601; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 175. Dai Huang was himself a survivor of charcoal making; he once fainted in a charcoal kiln and was rescued by his friends through artificial respiration. 186  1 8 7  188  76  degree of concern for the physical fitness of the rightists, and assigned the elderly and the weak lighter work. Other officers such as those in the Yunshan Branch, 189  driven by quotas setfromabove and enmeshed in the fanatical fervor of the GLF, treated the political exiles as slaves and even required them to engage in competitions with demobilized soldiers and convicts. In the busiest seasons (such as harvest), as unreasonable work quotas were set, the work drove the rightists crazy, or in the words of Dai Huang, the cadres "wanted to wring every ounce of sweat and blood out of us." When designated work quotas were not filled, the rightists were often denied rest and food.  190  Despite their seemingly equal status as nonggong, the rightists during most of the period of their banishment were treated worse than demobilized soldiers in terms of their living and working conditions. In the Farm 850, when the rightists had to sleep in the open air during work rushes, the demobilized soldier workers were provided with barracks. In the Farm 853, while the soldiers could refuse to work due to food shortages in the famine years, the rightists still had to come out to work in the fields with empty stomachs. The low political status of the rightist was 191  underlined in the farms. The harsh climate posed untold difficulties for the rightists. The first was the extreme cold. As early as mid October, the cold wind began to slice through the mountains and wilderness of eastern Heilongjiang. Between January and March when the land isfrozensolid, and any agricultural activity is impossible, traditional northeasterners (dongbeiren) stayed indoors doing nothing except for drinking and gambling, with perhaps the one exception being hunting deer. After the Communist takeover, however, the winter season was used for hydraulic projects, road construction and forest work, which was exactly what was experienced by the rightists in Beidahuang. During the day they were exposed to temperatures of minus 30° C, and at night they lived in makeshift cabins made of thick birch logs with Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 309-310. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 158-159. Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 49. Zheng Xiaofeng interview.  77  thatched roofs. The temperature outside could go down to minus 40° C, while inside it was not much warmer because wind and snow could blow in through the cracks.  Many rightists drank alcohol to warm up before sleep and wore the cotton-  padded hats to keep warm at night. Eating after work was not easy. When the food (usually corn or sorghum bread) was sent to the work sites, it was often frozen solid; people had to cut it into pieces with axes in order to eat. The bitter cold meant that one had to work without stopping.  193  In summer, a major harassment came from insects, especially mosquitoes. Nourished by the grassy marshland, their size was much larger than normal mosquitoes. They tortured everyone in Beidahuang. Writer Wang Zheng recalls: Once wakened, these extremely vicious creatures would swarm those of us who worked on the marshland, and would try to get into our noses, eyes, ears, and mouths as well as under our collars. People would go mad in this situation.  194  Exposure to mosquitoes would lead to instant bites. Short of wearing cumbersome insect-proof suits, the exiles had to keep their whole body in ceaseless motion. For many political exiles, mosquitoes were a nightmare during their banishment in Beidahuang.  195  Ideological Remolding  Recent Western scholarship emphasizes the Mao era efforts in the political indoctrination of inmates in labor camps, a practice which is considered to be in sharp contrast to the Soviet model. Some academics assume that political study was * Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 79-80. Wu recalls that during the period when his team was working in the mountains, it was so cold inside their makeshift straw shuts that "neither pen nor ball-pen could be used since ink would simply freeze." Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 127-128; Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 64; Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan, 618-619. Wang Zheng, "Menghui huangyuan" (Dreaming back to the Wilderness), in Liu Meng, ed., Lishi zai shenpan (Retrial by History) (Chengdu: Sichuan renmin chubanshe, 1996), 338. Many survivors of Beidahuang banishment see mosquitoes as one of their worst experiences there. See Yin Yi, Huishou canyang yi han shan, 33; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 60; Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao, 67. l  z  1 9 3  1 9 4  195  78  a distinguishing feature of the labor camps of Maoist China. This argument is true 196  of the general practice in Maoist labor camps and concurs with the CCP's claims about the significance of thought reform. This research shows, however, that during the period of the GLF and its aftermath and in particular location such as Beidahuang, little effort was made by the army authorities to systematically enforce the thought reform policy, although higher authorities might have seriously believed in using manual labor to remold the minds of those who had committed political errors, and although therightiststhere did not refuse political indoctrination.  197  Generally speaking, the Beijing rightists displayed a certain degree of commitment to thought reform through labor when they first arrived in Beidahuang. While many felt wronged and sad about being labeled, they recognized the necessity of physical labor in terms of the role it played in ideological remolding, and in washing away their "bourgeois ideologies." As mentioned earlier, Ding Ling and Nie Gannu took laboring in Beidahuang as an opportunity to have access to the working class and rural world, to cast off their old selves, and to achieve spiritual regeneration. Nie Gannu, for instance, wrote in his thought report (sixiang  huibao):  I was born into a non-working class family, and thus had neither experience of physical labor nor access to working people. Therefore, I am glad to join in working people, going into the countryside or mountainous area, to participate in physical labor or work at grass level in order to change my ideology....I am now prepared for a long-term self-remolding anywhere. 198  Such self-reflection should not be simply treated as affectation because it was Philip Williams and Yenna Wu note that Russia's Gulag almost never compelled its inmates to listen to propaganda, or write self-criticisms and confessions. As a comparison, they believe, in Maoist China, indoctrination sessions were pervasive and usually taken extremely seriously in labor camp. See Philip Williams and Yenna Wu, The Great Wall of Confinement: the Chinese Prison Camp through Contemporary Fiction and Reportage (Berkeley: The University of California Press, 2004), 112-113. Given their nature of forced labor, the restriction of individual freedom and the practice of physical and psychological abuse, the army farms in Beidahuang could certainly be considered a special form of labor camps — camps without walls. Nie Gannu, Nie Gannu zixu (Nie Gannu's Own Account) (Beijing: Tuanjie chubanshe, 1998), 450, 452. 1 9 6  1 9 7  1 9 8  79  consistent with his earnest requests to go to Beidahuang and his serious engagement in physical labor there. Many others, such as artist Huang Miaozi and journalist Dai Huang, also took a positive attitude towards labor reform. In the early period, they wrote poems and essays to praise the life in army farms and express their willingness to make a new start. As well, many brought political books with them, 199  trying to improve their minds through political studies after work  200  Nevertheless, the rightists found out before long that the army farm authorities essentially saw them as mere slave laborers rather than paying attention to their thought reform; that it was unrealistic to think that they would achieve any ideological remolding. During the years of the GLF, any form of study session was virtually impossible after fourteen hours of backbreaking labor. Yin Yi recalls that during the years of the GLF "daily life was reduced to an endless circle of working, eating and sleeping, plus the morning call of a cadre, Lu. There was nothing more than that." As long as work quotas were filled, farm cadres did not bother with 201  study sessions. At times, the rightists were asked to submit their thought summaries, but the summaries that the rightists took pains to compose were used by the cadres as toilet paper.  202  A notable exception in political indoctrination was at Farm 850, as described by Wu Yongliang. Wu recalls that at times his cadre, Zhu, did arrange newspaper reading at breakfast, trying to update the rightists about national politics, especially about the allegedly high crop yields and other myths. Some demobilized soldiers were also brought in to give political talks to these well-educated yet bourgeois rightists.  203  The most common political instruction given by cadres was rebuking or  A much sung song "Let's build our beautiful Beidahuang" was composed by an enthusiastic rightist after exhausting work. See Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 119. Huang Miaozi recalls that in the early months of his stay in Beidahuang he seriously read through Red Flag (a leading Party journal^ and the works of Karl Marx and Fredericks Engels. L i Hui, Renzai xuamvo, 307. Nie Gannu also brought many of Mao's works with him. See Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 309. Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 63. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 97-98. Ibid, 70. 201  2 0 2  203  80  dressing down (xunhua). Xuhua normally occurred in two types of situation. The first case was whenever cadres found that therightistshad failed to or would not fulfill designated work quotas, or they perceived a less than positive work attitude amongst the rightists; these situations meant a xunhua and the denial of food or the imposition of extra hours of work. The language used was insulting, including phrases such as  yiqun cunzhu  (a host of pigs),  laomianyang  (old sheep),  fulu  (captives), or tufei (bandits). In other situations, officers used xunhua as a regular 204  means to keep pressure on the rightists. Topics would be the rightists' bourgeois tastes, lack of knowledge of agriculture, and lack of physical strength for work. The rightists were reminded of their inferior status compared to working people, and the need for long-term reform.  Aiming to make rightists work harder, the xunhua for  the first situations were often given before breakfast and at evening roll call. For the second type of situation, they could be given at any time and happened without any notice. In both types of situation, political indoctrination was simply reduced to reprimand, and reform through labor to forced labor. This form of political lecture brought a negative reaction rather than a positive one, and undermined the confidence of the political exiles in thought reform. Being deprived of dignity, and merely treated as forced laborers, the rightists came to realize that Beidahuang was far from a refuge, and that land reclamation or any kind of manual labor was for them no more than physical and psychological punishment. As Yin Yi puts it, the maltreatment meted out in his branch made his fellow exiles realize that "thought reform through labor" was merely a camouflage, and the punishment through labor was the whole point of what they were going through.  206  When the food shortages started to loom large from mid 1959, the question of how to survive in Beidahuang rather than how to achieve ideological renewal or how to redeem oneself became the overwhelming concern of the rightists. After going through years of forced labor few people held a positive attitude In the case of the Yunshan Branch, directors Lu and Zhu frequently scolded the rightist workers in coarse language during xunhua for their failure to fulfill work quotas See Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 131; Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 51. Li Hui, Renzai xuanwo, 305; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 66-67. Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 63.  2 0 4  2 0 5 2 0 6  81  toward their experience with banishment. The result o f the ideological remolding or thought reform turned out to be contrary to the stated expectations o f the C C P leadership. In  assessing the experience o f the political exiles i n Beidahuang, the  relationship o f the rightists with their officers (the cadres) needs to receive special attention. Although the political exiles were generally maltreated i n Beidahuang, their lot to a great extent was i n the hands o f individual cadres, i.e., branch leaders (fenchangzhang),  brigade leaders (duizhang), and political instructors  (zhidaoyuan),  whose attitudes and managerial styles toward the rightists were by no means uniform or consistent, but quite individual, varying by location and time period. Under a considerate and sympathetic officer, the rightists would fare well even i f their workload remained heavy and the cold w i n d chilled them to the bone. Generally speaking, those in Farm 853 fared better than those i n Farm 850, within which those i n Branches 1, 2, 4, 5 fared better than those i n Yunshan Branch (there were no rightists assigned to Branch 3), and D i n g L i n g i n Tangyuan and A i Q i n g i n Farm 852 fared best o f all those i n the Beidahuang army farms.  207  Most officers, with the responsibility o f organizing rightists to work and, i n theory, o f helping them with thought reform, had to obey rules set by the higher authorities. Nonetheless, they could certainly manipulate and make arrangements i n favor o f the rightists in terms o f foods and living conditions. In Branch 4 (Farm 850), when fifty-six year o l d N i e Gannu felt pressured with his soy bean sowing quota, his two officers came to help him, something that deeply impressed N i e and other exiles.  208  In Farm 853, a brigade leader L i Fuchun worked together with the rightists,  treated them as friends and tried to help them with food supplies.  209  Under the  Analysis of the memoirs of the political exiles (Liu Meng, Nie Gannu, Huang Wu, Dai Huang, Wang Zheng, Yin Y i and Wu Yongliang) shows that the rightists in Yunshan Branch suffered the worst among all the rightists banished to Beidahuang. They endured longer work hours, poorer accommodations, more stringent food supplies and higher death rates in the years of the great famine. Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 311-312. Even in Yunshan Branch there were still helpful cadres who, like political instructor Liu Wen, were cherished by Dai Huang, Yin Y i and Wu Yongliang. Liu cared about the well-being of the rightists, and showed great respect for them. See Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 34-36; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 128-129; Wu Yongliang, Yuxuefeifei, 37-38. Wang Zheng, "Menghui huangyuan," in Liu Meng, ed., Lishi zai shenpan, 347-348. 2 0 7  2 0 8  2 0 9  82  supervision of these compassionate officers, the exiles felt respected and thus were highly motivated in their work. These officers stood between the demanding regime and the politically disfavored group. The same group of rightists might fare badly under different cadres. According to Dai Huang, after his helpful political instructor Liu Wen was replaced, the situation of the rightists in Yunshan rapidly deteriorated as the newly appointed officers Zhu and Yin treated them harshly and reprimanded themfrequently. This 210  was the crucial reason that accounted for the lots of the rightists in Yunshan much worse than those in other branch farms. Fortunate Exiles: Ding Ling, A i Qing and Others  By and large, the Beijing rightists in the army farms of Beidahuang experienced tremendous suffering, physical and psychological, which, as the fundamental characteristics of the border banishment, will be examined in Chapter Four and Chapter Five. A close look into some individual cases reveals that a small portion of rightists led relatively easier lives, for differing reasons. Compared to those who labored in Farms 850 and 853, Ding Ling seems to have fared much better due to the patronage of Wang Zhen, her friend from the pre-1949 period. Jonathan Spence describes the experience of Ding Ling in the post-1957 Beidahuang: During this period Ding Ling was assigned to duty in the chicken coops of Tangyuan. She has recorded that she grew absorbed in the task of raising the fowl and expert at looking after the ailing chickens, some of which she nursed back to health on the heated kang in her own hut...She began to take a genuine interest in the problems of developing the best methods for raising a healthy flock, and during her spare time even built models of an ideal chicken complex, using the cardboard from old toothpaste containers or any other materials she could find. 211  Spence provides a close-up of Ding's life at the grassroots and her seeming Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 131-133; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 54-55. Jonathan Spence, The Gate of Heavenly Peace: The Chinese and Their Revolution, 1895-1980 (New York: The Viking Press, 1981), 339. 11  83  adaptation to her surroundings. Other sources, including her memoir of 1986, piece together a more comprehensive picture of her life. When assigned to Tangyuan, Ding lived in a chicken shed with her husband. On the grounds of her illness (osteomyelitis), she was assigned light work - selecting eggs for hatching, and feeding chickens that were raised around her dormitory. At times when her husband was sent to road construction during the winter, she was asked to engage in literacy projects for the local community. She enthusiastically participated in local affairs such as mediating neighbor feuds and fixing local roads. Under the patronage of Wang Zhen, she did not lack supplies of paper, special food and medicine in the famine years. The good relationships she enjoyed in the village even made her hesitant to return to her professional job in Beijing when the opportunity appeared.  212  It seems that living in Beidahuang did not bother her at all, since she  was satisfied with being a chicken run manager and doing manageable physical labor. "Why should not a writer raise chicken while Chinese commoners can do that?" she said. experience government.  in  213  For this reason, Ding did not consider her more than ten years'  Beidahuang as  banishment  meted  out  by  the Communist  214  Like Ding Ling, poet A i Qing was also lucky among the political exiles. Due to his personal connection with Wang Zhen, A i Qing received favorable treatment in Farm 852. For him physical labor was symbolic, as his major work was to write poetry in praise of labor heroes/heroines and the great cause of land reclamation. He was appointed as deputy director of a forestry center and offered single housing,  D i n g Ling, Fengxue renjian, 48-56; Tani Barlow and Gary Bjorge, eds., I Myself Am a Woman: Selected Writings of Ding Ling (Boston: Beacon Press, 1989), 44; Zheng Xiaofeng, Ding Ling zai Beidahuang, 19-23. Zheng Xiaofeng, Ding Ling zai Beidahuang, 73. After being released and getting her case reversed in the late 1970s, Ding Ling expressed an even more positive attitude towards the Party. She seldom talked about her personal afflictions in Beidahuang but considered all her suffering in the Maoist period as a special trial the Party afforded to her, as well as a good opportunity to steel her revolutionary spirit. Zheng Xiaofeng, Ding Ling zai Beidahuang, 2, 84. 21i  2 1 3  2 1 4  84  which was extremely rare i n that political context.  215  The experience o f D i n g and A i  show the importance o f personal network, even for ones who were politically disgraced. For artists, playwrights and engineers who did not have personal connections with important figures, their professional expertise made their life easier. After engaging i n several months o f reservoir construction, artist D i n g Cong was transferred to a part-time job editing a magazine Beidahuang  wenyi (Literature and  Art i n Beidahuang) due to his talent in cartoon drawing. Playwright W u Zuguang had a similar experience. H e was asked to serve i n a farm art troupe writing plays to sing the praises o f land pioneers. Although they still needed to do some physical labor, their new posts provided obvious benefits other political exiles could hardly dream of—better living conditions, freedom to go to county towns, the chance to practice their expertise and, most importantly, better f o o d .  216  In the difficult years,  less manual labor and better food supplies meant more chance o f survival.  The political exiles granted favorable treatment were limited in number. O f the thousands o f Beijing rightists i n Beidahuang, no more than twenty were transferred to less strenuous work before October 1959.  217  For the vast majority, the only way to  leave the lives mired i n starvation and hardship rested with periodical "removal o f hats (or caps)" (zaimdo), which started in the fall o f 1959. In August o f 1959, the C C P Chairman M a o Zedong proposed to remove rightist labels from a proportion o f rightists who were deemed to behave well i n labor r e f o r m .  218  . The proportion o f  those to be removed o f their labels was to be under 10%. When the first round o f this removal project was finished i n the Beidahuang army farms i n winter o f 1959,  Zhou Hongxing, Ai Qing zhuan (Biography of Ai Qing) (Beijing: Zuojia chubanshe, 1993), 441444; Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao, 76-77. Xin Suwei, Ding Cong zhuan, 188-189, 192; Zhang Jie, Wu Zuguang beihuan qu (Wu Zuguang: Vicissitudes of Life) (Chengdu: Sichuan wenyi chubanshe, 1986), 343-344. Ding Cong, interview; Yang Congdao, interview. Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguo yilai zhongyao wenxian xuanbian, Vol. 12, 528-529. 2 1 6  2 1 8  85  only limited numbers of rightists had their labels removed and were given 9 1Q  permission to leave the farms. A deep sense of disappointment was generated. Ultimately, it was the massive starvation and deaths caused by serious food shortages in Beidahuang (see Chapter Four) that helped put an end to this phase of border banishment. Although initially planning to release the rightists group by group in different time periods, the central authorities were struck by the flood of deaths in 1960. It was obvious that the longer the rightists stayed in Beidahuang, the 99fi  more of them would die of starvation.  Therefore, from the end of 1960 to early  1961, Beijing rightists were allowed to successively leave this great wilderness in which many of their fellow exiles lay forever.  Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi ban shan, 70-71; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 108-109; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 168-169. The "label removal" project in the army farms would be examined in detail in Chapter Six. See Zhou Jianqiang, Nie Gannu zhuang, 229. 2 2 0  86  Chapter Three Political Offenders in the Labor Camps of Xingkaihu Starting in late 1957, prisons and pre-trial detention centers i n metropolitan Beijing saw an increasing intake o f prisoners and suspects o f various kinds. In the general context o f the Anti-Rightist Campaign, the C C P government waged a battle against counterrevolutionaries i n December 1957, arresting across the country hundreds o f thousands o f what were termed "historical counterrevolutionaries" and "active counterrevolutionaries". O n August 3, 1957, the State Council issued the "Resolution  on Reeducation  through Labor"  under which various elements that  allegedly fostered political instability were to be sent to labor reeducation camps. In Beijing,  the  Public  Security Bureau elevated  its persecution  o f "social  undesirables." Street hooligans, pickpockets, and tramps who were usually left alone were rounded up as criminals; villagers i n the suburbs o f Beijing were also picked up for petty theft or vagrancy.  222  Prior to further dispersal, a l l o f these detainees  were put into various detention centers, such as Caolanzi, Banbuqiao and Beiyuan. Those who received fixed term sentences were sent to prisons or nearby labor camps, such as the X i n d u Machinery Factory, the Qinghe Farm and Tongzhou P r i s o n .  223  These large scale arrests tested the holding capacity o f Beijing labor reform regimes. The Caolanzi Detention Center, which had been notorious for the confinement o f political convicts in the G M D period, received approximately 2400  See Guowuyuan fazhiju, ed., Zhonghua renmin gongheguo xianxingfalu xingzhengfagui huibian (The Comprehensive Collection of Current Laws and Administrative Regulations of the PRC) (Beijing: Zhongguo falu chubanshe, 1995), Vol. 1, 104. See Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi (The True Stories of My Twenty-Two Years of Laogai Experience) (Unpublished work), 31-32; Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds: A Memoir ofMy Years in China's Gulag (New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc., 1994), 53. General information regarding how various offenders were put into detention centers and prisons is drawn from Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear: A Family's Persecution, Love and Endurance in Communist China (New York: The Atlantic Monthly Press, 1993), 73-75, Liu Naiyuan, Mirror: A Loss of Innocence in Mao's China (Philadelphia: Xlibris Corporation, 2001), 189-192, as well as Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 47-50, and Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 31-32. Interviews with Yin Jiliang, Han Dajun and Wu Yue also confirm this massive intake of various offenders. 2 2 1  2 2 2  2 2 3  87  new inmates. B y late December 1957, each cell i n the prison held around 40 inmates, and the space for each to sleep was less than 10 inches; inmates had to sleep on their sides at night instead o f on their b a c k s .  224  According to Hongda Harry W u , who was  put into the Beiyuan Detention Center, the problem o f over-crowding remained unresolved even in 1960. "The kangs (traditional brick sleeping platforms used i n north and northeast China) were clogged with bodies. N o longer did we have two feet o f space, but we lay on our sides, pressed tightly together. Twice each night the duty prisoner gave orders for everyone to turn over, and we shifted to the other side in a collective movement because the kang was too crowded for us to move individually."  225  Facing the annoying dilemma that existing prison facilities were unable to accommodate so many targets o f the proletarian dictatorship, the Public Security Bureau o f Beijing i n early 1958 decided to transfer some inmates (both political and criminal) to the Northeast frontier regions, i n particular Heilongjiang's Xingkaihu Labor Farm, i n order to make room for the recent arrivals.  226  The importance o f the Xingkaihu Labor Farm for this study is that it was the most notorious labor reform complex established by the Beijing police authorities i n the Northeast frontier region. The results o f the 1957 purge for Xingkaihu have hardly been paralleled i n P R C history, i n terms o f the physical conditions, the suffering inmates endured there, and the number o f political prisoners it received 777  from Beijing.  While those sent to Xingkaihu consisted o f various types o f  offenders, this chapter focuses on the experiences o f the prisoners banished for political reasons (hereafter referred to as political prisoners, or political offenders), Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 31. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 65-66. Xingkaihu changshiban, Xingkaihu nongchang shi (Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm) (Mishan: No pub., 1988), 399. Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm acknowledges that this labor farm was the biggest labor reform farm that the Beijing Public Security Bureau established in the frontier regions. For various offenders and even the general public in North China and Manchuria, Xingkaihu has been synonymous with severe punishment and death. Literature and movies in the post-Mao period frequently dramatize the harshness of Xingkaihu. In the movie Blue Kite, for example, one of the main characters Lin Shulong was among many who were banished to and died in Xingkaihu, after being labeled a rightist. 2 2 4 2 2 5  2 2 6  88  typically ultra-rightists (jiyou) in labor reeducation camps, and people sentenced as counterrevolutionaries (fan geming) in labor reform camps. Other inmates are also discussed where relevant. To contextualize this research, the experiences o f political prisoners i n other labor camps i n Manchuria and Northern China are occasionally incorporated. Since no official documents or police records have been published about political prisoners in Xingkaihu in terms o f their work, lives and deaths, it is difficult to obtain the official version o f the experiences o f these political prisoners. L o c a l gazetteers (such as Heilongjiang  Provincial Gazetteer, Gazetteer of Xingkaihu  Farm  and Gazetteers of Mishan County, where Xingkaihu farm is located) are useful for providing basic accounts o f Xingkaihu's agricultural activities, population statistics and the farm structure, yet sources regarding how the inmates were managed, and accounts o f their lives i n Xingkaihu are still lacking. This research has greatly benefited from individual recollections o f former inmates — publications by L i u Naiyuan and W u Ningkun, as well as unpublished manuscripts and interview materials from Chen Fengxiao, Tan Tianrong, H a n Dajun, Y i n Jiliang, B a Hong, H u i Peilin, and H u Xianzhong. In addition, some fragmentary recollections incorporated in Chanji: kunan de jitan by H u Ping, and Hongda Harry Wu's Bitter Winds have also proved valuable.  Xingkaihu Labor Farm Xingkaihu Labor Farm, with its name drawn from the nearby X i n g k a i Lakes (Little X i n g k a i Lake i n the north and Great X i n g k a i Lake in the south), is located in the southeastern corner o f Heilongjiang. In the mid-1950s, it was a vast stretch o f desolate marshland with no trace o f human habitation. During the rainy season from A p r i l to August when the Little X i n g k a i Lake frequently overflowed, this region was terribly waterlogged, with thousands o f square kilometers o f inundated areas. When the massive military colonization o f Heilongjiang began i n the m i d -  Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 4, 387/ Mishan xianzi bianweihui, Mishan xianzhi (Gazetteer of Mishan County) (Beijing: Zhongguo biaozun chubanshe, 1993), 188-189.  89  1950s, the Ministry o f Public Security ordered the Beijing Public Security Bureau to establish a substantial base i n the Heilongjiang frontier area to perform the combined functions o f grain production and convict rehabilitation. Considering the remote geographical location and the special requirements for confining inmates, preference was given to the Xingkaihu area. In August 1955, with an official document signed by Zhou Enlai, the premier o f the People's Republic, the Xingkaihu Labor Reform Farm was formally acclaimed the Xingkaihu State Farm (Heilongjiang).  229  Compared to other labor farms that emerged i n Heilongjiang from the 1950s to the  1960s, the administrative features o f Xingkaihu were unique. From  its  establishment to January 1967, when it ceased to be a labor reform farm, Xingkaihu turned out to be an enclave o f the Beijing Public Security Bureau. The prisoners, the forced laborers, were customarily transported there from Beijing. A l l the personnel o f Xingkaihu, from camp police and managerial staff to prisoners, had Beijing hukou, used Beijing food coupons and had their farm products shipped to Beijing. The heads o f the farm were police officers appointed by the Beijing Public Security Bureau.  230  The early development o f Xingkaihu involved an intensive use o f forced labor. Construction i n this area started i n winter 1955, when more than ten thousand convicts (former G M D soldiers, subsequently labeled counterrevolutionaries, and various kinds o f criminal offenders) were delivered by train and truck. U p o n arrival, these convicts were assigned to numerous projects, designed to change the physical landscape o f this inundated area. The construction they undertook included: 1) one hundred  o f main dykes to separate the Little Xingkai Lake from the surrounding  marshland; 2) a flood relief channel, which was used to discharge flood water from the Little X i n g k a i Lake to the Great X i n g k a i Lake; 3) a set o f drainage works leading to the nearby Songacha River to secure land reclamation; and 4) a fifty-  Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 387-388; Heilongjiang sheng difangzhi bianweihui, Heilongjiang shengzhi guoying nongchang zhi (Gazetteer of Heilongjiang: the State Farms Volume) (Harbin: Heilongjiang renmin chubanshe, 1992), 77. Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 3, 9; Chen Fengxiao, interview; Yin Jiliang, interview. 229  230  90  kilometer long trunk canal, which was used to irrigate rice fields.  These massive  undertakings were accomplished by the convicts using manual labor only—with spades and picks. A local newspaper disclosed that i f the excavated earth were piled up i n a cubic meter wall, it would circle the equator three and half times. While this achievement in pioneering the formidable wilderness was warmly acclaimed i n the official media, only limited credit was accorded to the forced laborers, even thirty years later.  232  B y early 1958, when hordes o f political prisoners—the victims o f the  Anti-Rightist Campaign—arrived, the majority o f the irrigation projects had been completed. The work left for these newcomers was mainly rice and  wheat  cultivation. The years 1958 and 1959 saw a massive deportation to Xingkaihu o f various offenders and an influx o f police officers who came to supervise them. B y the end o f 1959, the total population (inmates, police officers, supporting workers, etc.) in X i n k a i h u numbered 20,435; by the following year it had reached 25, 6 9 4 .  233  By  1960, when its holding capacity approached its peak, Xingkaihu was composed o f ten branch farms that used convicted labor forces: Branches 1 to 4 were labor reform camps that confined convicts; Branch 5 confined both convicts and resettlement workers—those who had completed their terms but were forcibly retained i n the labor reform system; Branches 6 to 9 were  labor reeducation  camps that  accommodated those who had not received a formal sentence but had to be punished in a similar way to labor reform. The livestock farm accommodated  female  offenders. There was also an affiliated prison for those who repeated their offences during the course o f their terms.  234  With these elaborate arrangements and several  Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 36, 394; Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 69. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 69. Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm acknowledges that the establishment of the Xingkaihu farm entailed a degree of contribution of convict laborers, and that some of whom lost their lives. See the Prelude for Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm. Gazetteer ofXinkaihu Farm, 10. The Gazetteer does not specify the influx of inmates during these two years. However, statistics are available for a longer period. During the 1955-67, the numbers of police officers and camp cadres totaled 1783, convicted criminals, laojiao inmates, and other urban undesirable elements totaled 21364, and supporting workers from Beijing were around 2200. We can estimate that over 84% of the Xinkaihu population consisted of various offenders. Gazetteer of Xinkaihu Farm, 9. Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 35, 44; Yin Jiliang, interview. 2 3 2  233  234  91  industrial enterprises (such as a coal mine and a paper mill) that involved the use o f forced labor as well, Xingkaihu turned into a huge labor reform complex.  Labor Reform System and Categories of Political Offenders Beginning i n August 1957, when the labor reeducation system was instituted, the P R C ' s labor reform regime consisted o f three distinct parts: camps for reform through labor, or labor reform (laogai),  that held those who had been sentenced  under law; camps for reeducation through labor, or labor reeducation  (laojiao),  that  held those who were not formally sentenced but were subjected to administrative discipline by police authorities; and camps o f forced j o b placement  (jiuye),  that held  those who had completed their sentence but were not allowed to leave the labor camp system. A l l the camps that imprisoned offenders and featured intensive use o f their labor for production are generally referred to as labor reform camps. the  fact  that  those  incarcerated  overwhelmingly transferred to  laogai  in  detention  and  laojiao  centers  and  prisons  Given were  camps and, i f they were lucky to  survive, eventually ended up in j i u y e camps, l a o g a i , l a o j i a o and j i u y e constituted the major part o f China's forced labor reform system. Xingkaihu, with its wellestablished facilities, accommodated all o f these three kinds o f forced laborers. Its structure, as shown i n the section above, precisely embodied the characteristics o f the P R C ' s labor reform framework. During the founding period o f Xingkaihu, a significant percentage o f the inmates were political offenders. Despite a lack o f accuracy, the Gazetteer o f Xingkaihu provides valuable clues about the number o f political offenders by disclosing that "during the early period o f the farm, one third o f the convicts were counterrevolutionaries, among more than two thousands o f the w h o l e . "  236  During the  massive influx i n 1959 and 1960, it seems that the proportion o f political offenders  Hongda Harry Wu, Laogai-the Chinese Gulag (Boulder: Westview Press, 1992), 1, 6; Sun Xiaoli, Zhongguo laodong gaizao zhidu de lilun yu shijian (Theories and Practices: Reform through Labor in China) (Beijing. Zhongguo zhengfa daxue chubanshe, 1994), 119. Detention centers, prisons and juvenile reeducation camps, and other integrated parts of the PRC's prison camp system are not the focus of this research. Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 396. 235  236  92  did not increase substantially. According to Yin Jiliang, who was labeled a counterrevolutionary and placed into Branch One, there were around three or four people sentenced for political reasons in his twelve-person squad during his five years of imprisonment. Tan Tianrong, an ultra-rightist, also estimates that political 237  offenders roughly accounted for 30% of all the people in his team.  If this  proportion represents the average percentage, at its high point of 1959-60 Xingkaihu might have incarcerated at least 5,000 political prisoners. Political inmates in Xingkaihu could be roughly broken down into three categories: the ultra-rightists, the historical counterrevolutionaries, and the active counterrevolutionaries. 1.  The ultra-rightists. Ultra-rightists, such as Tan Tianrong from Peking University and Han Dajun from the Chinese Academy of Sciences, were sent to labor reeducation camps (Tan was in Branch 8 and Han in Branch 7). They were considered to have committed serious offenses, and the punishment they received was harsher than the rightists sent to army farms though less severe than those who were sent to labor reform branches. Although they were not formally tried and were not subject to a term-sentence because of the Party's "leniency," they were still seen to be in need of discipline by the police authorities. Labor reeducation camps were thus perfect places for them to go. According to the "Resolution on Reeducation through Labor" promulgated by the State Council on August 3, 1957, "Reeducation through labor" was an administrative, rather than a judicial, penalty used to deal with "anti-socialist reactionaries" and those who were discharged by their work units, both of which were perfectly applied to "ultra-rightists."  239  Yin Jiliang, interview. Tan Tianrong, interview. The PRC State Council, "The Resolution on Reeducation through Labor"(August 3, 1957), in Guowuyuan fazhiju, ed., Zhonghua renmin gongheguo xianxingfalu xingzhengfagui huibian, Vol. 1, 104. This resolution also applied to other social groups, such as those who refused to accept designated jobs, or those who allegedly committed "sexual misconduct."  2 3 8 2 3 9  93  The historical counterrevolutionaries. This group of offenders mainly included personnel who had been employed in the former G M D government, which was overthrown by the communists in 1949, collaborators with the Japanese and colonial governments during the Japanese occupation, and those who gave military service to these regimes. Leaders of secret societies before the Commumst takeover were also categorized into this group. Relatively older than other inmates, they normally had less political commitment, admitted their "crimes," behaved themselves and showed obedience to the camp authorities. Although they were deemed to be class enemies and some received term-sentences, cadres in prison camps normally treated them with a degree of leniency.  240  The active counterrevolutionaries. This group received the worst treatment amongst the political prisoners, and prisoners as a whole. Considered to have committed the most serious crimes, they went through formal trials and many were sentenced for relatively long terms.  241  The charges against them were weighty, such as "trying to  overthrow the  people's government" and/or "the  sabotage of  socialism." Many of them were young and energetic, independent in political opinion, less submissive to ideological and administrative control, and thus were deemed by camp authorities as the most dangerous elements. In prisons or in labor camps, they were prime targets for various kinds of persecution and discrimination.  It is often assumed that people who were put into labor reform camps were those who had committed more serious crimes than those put into reeducation camps.  Liu Junying, a camp cadre in Branch Five of Xingkaihu, recalls that the historical counterrevolutionaries under him were generally docile and worked dedicatedly, so he did not give them a hard time. Liu Junying, interview. Chen Fengxiao and Liu Qidi (student dissidents of Peking University), for instance, were both sentenced for 15 years for their sharp criticisms during the Hundred Flower Movement. 4 1  94  Actually some of those sent to Xingkaihu labor reform branch for serious political crime had by no means committed anything that could be referred to "political" or "criminal." Han Chuntai, an ordinary construction worker in Beijing, was regarded by his colleagues as an upright, dedicated person who never made any dissent against the government. It was his oral abuse of a Soviet engineer that sent him to Xingkaihu. When one day he found the Soviet engineer and the Chinese woman driver who served him hugging each other in public, he was very upset and scolded them "Shameful (buyaolian)\"  After he was handcuffed and sent to a detention  center, the judges found it difficult to declare him a counterrevolutionary or a rightist. Eventually he was sentenced to fifteen-years imprisonment on the grounds of "insulting a Soviet expert, and sabotaging Sino-Soviet friendship" and was sent to Xingkaihu labor reform camp.  242  By contrast, Tai Tianrong, the spiritual leader of student dissidents in Peking University, received no formal sentence, but was sent to a labor reeducation camp even though he stubbornly refused to acknowledge his "error." It is unreliable to 243  judge a person's political crimes simply based on the classification of laogai or laojiao. It is also misleading to assume that people in laojiao camps necessarily fared better than those in laogai camps, since laogai inmates were sentenced as criminals while laojiao inmates were merely subjected to "administrative discipline." For a penal offender whose crime was seen as less threatening to the regime,  laojiao  treatment certainly lent more hope. But for political offenders, especially for the ultra-rightists, their situation did not see much improvement because of thenpolitical status as class enemies. A penal criminal in laogai camps, whose offense was defined as criminal rather than political in nature, likely fared better than ultrarightists in laojiao camps. Laojiao  inmates in theory enjoyed partial personal freedom and nominal  Tan Tianrong, unpublished essay "Meiyou qingjie de gushi " (Stories without Plot), 2; Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 13. Tan received lighter sanction probably because he never tried tofleeor resist, but stayed in his dormitory doing research while waiting for the police.  95  suffrage, and received limited wages, while laogai inmates were deprived o f almost everything except for basic subsistence needs.  244  These advantages, however, could  be trumped by the indefinite duration o f their confinement i n labor reeducation camps. Because no clear, fixed term was declared for laojiao inmates, they could be detained for periods as lengthy as, or even longer than, laogai convicts. Although counterrevolutionary Y i n Jiliang was sentenced to a five year term to a laogai branch in Xingkaihu, Tan Tianrong and L i u Naiyuan, as ultra rightists, were incarcerated i n laojiao camps for eleven years. According to M e n g B o , some laojiao inmates even served fourteen years.  245  In terms o f hardship, inmates i n the laogai  branches o f Xingkaihu sometimes worked for 8 hours or 8.5 hours since the P L A soldiers who escorted them (when needed) during their work had fixed working hours; but laojiao inmates who theoretically had more freedom normally worked for more than ten hours a day.  246  This is an important reason why many laojiao inmates  saw their sufferings i n laojiao camps as being worse than the convicts i n laogai camps.  Young Intellectuals O f the various political exiles in the Xingkaihu labor reform complex, young intellectuals,  especially ex-university students and  conspicuous group.  247  young teachers,  were  a  M a n y o f them had received or were pursuing post-secondary  education, which had encouraged their independent  thinking before arrest or  detention. They did not merely assume the position o f loyal opponents as many other rightists did, but rather they waged sharp attacks on the existing political  According to Han Dajun, a laojiao inmate in Xingkaihu received a monthly stipend of 17 yuan Chinese RMB. Han Dajun, interview. Tan Tianrong, "Meiyou qingjie de gushi," 2; Liu Nianyuan, Mirror, 314. Both of them were detained from 1958-1969. Also see, Meng Bo, "Laogai jishi" (Stories in Laogai), in Xiao Ke, et al., Wo qili guo de zhengzhi yundong (The Political Campaigns That I Have Experienced) (Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, 1998), 73-74. Wu Yue and Tan Tianrong, interviews. Tan said that the best period he spent in Xingkaihu was the several months when he was ordered to temporarily work in laogai branches. From the source materials of more than 40 political exiles that I have reviewed, it can be surmised that the student prisoners, both in Xingkaihu and in other labor camps, were the most defiant group among the political prisoners. 2 4 4  2 4 5  2 4 6  2 4 7  96  system. Their statements such as "the origin of bureaucratism and hierarchy lies exactly in the current political system" and "get the Communist Party committee out of universities" were among the harshest condemnations that appeared during the Hundred Flowers Movement.  248  Compared to the rightists in army farms discussed  in Chapter Two, these young intellectuals displayed enormous courage in pursuing political and intellectual independence. Many of them were initially labeled ordinary rightists and yet received additional punishment for their firm defense of their opinions and their resolute refusal to admit their "guilt." In labor camps, some of them displayed strong resistance and disobedience towards camp authorities. Although not refusing to do physical labor, their attitudes toward thought reform through labor were largely negative, as will be shown below.  Chen Fengxiao (1936--) Chen Fengxiao was born into an urban family in Weifang, Shandong. Before his arrest in September 1957, Chen was a math student in Peking University and the chief leader of Hundred Flowers Society, a well-known student dissident society in Beijing. Because of their vigorous condemnation of the darkness under the Communist rule, of the Liquidation of Counterrevolutionaries Campaign of 1955, and of Stalinist totalitarianism, Chen and his fellow students were accused of forming a "counterrevolutionary group" and of engaging in "subversion of the people's democratic dictatorship." Having found punishment unavoidable, Chen 249  made constant efforts to flee China. He tried to break into the Indian Embassy, the British Office of the Charge d'Affaires, and the Yugoslav Embassy for refuge, and when all of these efforts failed, he attempted to sneak on to a foreign cargo ship anchored at the port of Tianjin. He was arrested immediately, and in April 1958 was sentenced to 15 years of imprisonment for his counterrevolutionary treason. After months of imprisonment and forced labor in Beijing, Chen was sent to the Branch 4 Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 42, 108. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 38. For general statements of Chen and his friends in the "Hundred Flower Society," see Roderick MacFarquhar, ed., The Hundred Flowers Campaign and the Chinese Intellectuals (New York. Octagon Books, 1974), 135-138; Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 215-223. 2 4 8  2 4 9  97  Farm in Xingkaihu in A p r i l 1 9 5 9 /  50  In the labor camp, Chen's work assignment was similar to others—digging trenches, building roads, planting rice, hoeing weeds, etc. During the years o f severe food shortages, this work demanded more energy and endurance than a hungry laborer could exert. Chen was so worn out that sometimes he even doubted i f he could survive his 15 year sentence with the crushing workload. The  frequent  witnessing o f the deaths o f his fellow exiles added to his desperation grievance.  and  251  Luckily, Chen survived the starvation and the daunting labor. It was the physical abuse that made him most miserable i n the camp. Because o f his untamable temperament, he spoke defiantly and openly expressed his contempt for the camp cadres; he talked with other political prisoners at w i l l , without fear o f punishment.  252  H e firmly believed in his innocence, and refused to show appreciation for the Party's labor reform policy; he even used a secret code to write down his reflections on current political issues, such as the forbidden for prisoners to discuss.  Sino-Soviet split, which was absolutely  A s the result o f such obstinate and unyielding  behavior, he was often beaten and hung up, sometime with fifty pounds o f shackles on his feet, and sometimes he was badly burned with cigarettes. Several times when he was handcuffed and put into solitary confinement in a small concrete cell, he could only crawl towards food and grab it with his mouth. When the camp police executed convicts, he was hauled out to the execution ground to witness the horrible scene.  254  U p o n completion o f his term in 1972, he was transferred to a camp for  forced job placement as a resettlement worker until 1979, when he was fully rehabilitated.  Tan Tianrong (1935—)  Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 14-15, 41-42. Ibid, 85. Ibid, 74-75. From Caolanzi Detention Center to Tongzhou Prison and to Xingkaihu, Chen rarely kept silent when police scolded him, but spoke back at every opportunity. Ibid, 108-110. Ibid, 128-131. 251  252  253 254  98  Tan Tianrong is marked i n Chinese history for his talents as an outstanding physics student and as an ardent critic o f Stalinism, o f the inherent contradictions in the worldwide communist movement, and o f the bureaucratization o f the Chinese Communist Party.  255  Satirically labeled by M a o "the leader o f rightist students," Tan  was demonized during and after the Anti-Rightist Campaign. He was formally arrested i n November 1958, and was sent to Xingkaihu i n spring 1959.  256  Tan treated the labor assigned to him with scholarly seriousness but he was still so closely watched by camp cadres that his campmates preferred not to work close to h i m and be under constant surveillance. What distinguished Tan from other political prisoners i n the labor reeducation camp was his unremitting pursuit o f academic interests after work—to read whatever he could find, whether Marxist classics or science texts, from which he drew great inspiration to resist thought remolding. He was passive in formal political study sessions, but quietly conducted research  on quantum  mechanics  and mathematical  logic when blizzards i n  Xingkaihu made field work impossible; his behavior was seen by camp cadres as an indication o f "resisting thought reform."  257  Tan's creative perceptions o f Marxist texts, which were officially permitted reading i n labor camps, provided him with a useful tool to refute current political indoctrination, rather than follow revolutionary rhetoric. In early 1963, official media claimed that the l o w price o f vegetables i n Chinese markets indicated the good living standard o f ordinary people under socialism. Yet Tan argued in a political study session that this was exactly the cause o f poverty among the Chinese peasantry under the state planned economy; Tan was ruthlessly attacked by camp  For the political statements of Tan Tianrong, see MacFarquhar, ed., The Hundred Flowers Campaign and the Chinese Intellectuals, 135-137; Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Yuan shang cao, 28-67. Tan Tianrong, interview. Mao's criticism of Tan can be found in his "Speech at the Shanghai Conference" in July 8, 1957. See Red Guard Materials, Mao Zedong sixiang wansui (Long Live Mao Zedong Thought) (Np.: No pub.,1967), Vol. 10, 163. Tan Tianrong, "Meiyou qingjie de gushi," 3-4. This same "science and resistance" pattern was repeated by Fang Lizhi. See James Williams, "Fang Lizhi's Expanding Universe", in The China Quarterly, Vol. 123 (September, 1990), 459-484. 2 i S  2 5 6  2 5 7  99  cadres and even by his fellow i n m a t e s .  258  H i s independent thinking and his  passionate defense o f himself were deeply abhorred by camp cadres, thus he was classified several times as an "anti-reform element"(/anga/zao fenzi), and was repeatedly punished with extended session o f confinement i n labor canips. In 1969, when Tan finally completed his years o f labor reeducation, he was sent back to his home village i n Xiangxiang, Hunan, as a commune member under mass surveillance, and spent relatively peaceful years with his mother and his friendly fellow villagers.  259  H u Xianzhong (1932--) Hu's experience as a political prisoner deserves special attention, even though he was mostly confined in Jilin labor camps rather than Xingkaihu. A s a student at Northeastern People's University, H u had a similar educational background to Tan Tianrong and Chen Fengxiao, except he had experience as a veteran Communist before the Communist takeover.  260  In 1957 H u Xianzhong was severely condemned  for his ardent defense o f the literary critic H u Feng. H u Xianzhong refuted a l l the accusations against him, and even composed a couplet satirizing his ignorant attackers.  261  L i k e Chen Fengxiao, i n 1957 H u Xianzhong wanted to leave the country that he and his fellow communists had fought so hard for. H e attempted to secure protection from foreign representatives i n Beijing, as evidenced by his unsuccessful contact with the British Office o f the Charge d ' Affaires. When he returned to his university i n September 1957, he was labeled an ultra-rightist, and shortly afterward * Meng Bo, "Laogai jishi," in Xiao Ke, et al., Wuo qinli guode zhengzhiyundong, 80-82. Ibid, 82-83; Tan Tianrong, interview. Tan claims that his stay in his home village of Xiangxiang was his best period since he was labeled an ultra-rightist. Although drawing a political line against him, his fellow villagers rarely disrupted his research, such as that on quantum mechanics. After he joined the CCP at the age of 16 as a secondary school student, Hu Xianzhong was enthusiastically involved in underground activities to sabotage GMD rule in his home province, Jiangxi. Having escaped an inner-Party purge before the Communist takeover, Hu lost contact with his Party branch as well as his Party membership, and was thus subjected to constant suspicion in the early 1950s. See Wang Shilan, "Yuanyu ershinian" (The Unjust Sentence of Twenty Years), in Jishi wenxue, No. 2, 1989, 73. Ibid, 78; Hu Xianzhong, interview; Zhang Xiaofeng, unpublished essay "Hu Feng anjian yu youpai xuesheng" (Hu Feng's Case and Rightist Students)," 4-6. a  259  2 6 0  261  100  was arrested and sentenced to life imprisonment with a charge o f "treason."  262  During his years o f imprisonment, H u was transferred between various prison camps i n Jilin Province—Tiebei Prison, Jinqianpu Labor Camp, and Zhennai Labor Farm, etc. H u obstinately showed defiance to the Party's labor reform policy and resisted all remolding efforts o f the camps. When ordered to talk about what he had learnt from labor reform, his reply was "nothing to learn." When asked i f he realized the Party's benevolence in providing a chance to reform in prison, his answer stunned all the camp cadres: "Even when the Communist Party supported me for school and allowed me to freely air my opinion, I still criticized it for its errors. H o w can I shift my stance and sing its praises when it shuts me up and puts me into prison?"  263  Because o f statements such as these, which were rarely heard in the  prison camps, he suffered severe maltreatment. H i s four attempts to break out o f prison a l l ended i n failure, which i n turn invited even more physical abuse, including hunger punishment and tight handcuffs biting into his flesh. H i s survival o f labor camp was thanks to a compassionate prison doctor who saved his life from the brink o f death several t i m e s .  264  The young inmates who behaved fearlessly towards the camp authorities are also known to include X u a n Shouzhi, G u Xiangqian and L i u Q i d i . X u a n , a graduate o f Qinghua University, kept refusing to work no matter which branch farm he was sent to i n Xingkaihu, and was put into the solitary confinement where he was eventually crippled. G u , a lecturer i n the Beijing F i l m Institute, refused to admit the error o f his ways when he was sent to Xingkaihu, and thus suffered repeated insults. H e maintained a hunger strike for one week, and finally died i n a camp c e l l .  2 6 5  B y and large, however, political inmates who behaved defiantly i n labor camps  Hu Xianzhong, interview. Due to his appeal, Hu was re-sentenced for ten years imprisonment, which was a real exception in the post-1957 period. Hu Xianzhong, interview. Hu Xianzhong, " Sanshiqi nian youzilei" (Tears of a Wandering Son: Thirty Seven Years), in Zhonggong Nanchang shi chenggongbu jinian wenji (The Memorial Collection of the CCP's Nanchang Urban Work Department) (Nanchang: No pub., 1999), 284-310. In response to repeated abuse, Hu once rose up and punched a duty prisoner (a trustee of the camp cadres), for which he was beaten into unconscious; the constant use of handcuffs also lead to his left arm being semi-crippled. Hah Dajun, interview. Regarding Liu Qidi, see Chen Fengxiao's narrative quoted in Chapter Four. 2 6 2  2 6 3  2 6 4  2 6 5  101  were rare. Having survived relentless attacks during the Anti-Rightist Campaign, most political inmates collapsed mentally and thus gave up. The charges they faced were intimidating, camp cadres were powerful and labor work was daunting. A l l o f these factors forced them to realize that direct confrontation with camp authorities could only bring physical abuse, hunger and extra workloads. The majority o f political inmates tried to avoid direct confrontation with camp authorities and behaved submissively instead, even though they held deep-rooted anger and grievances. Inmates such as L i u Naiyuan, W u Ningkun and Y i n Jiliang all adopted a strategy o f silence and endurance to avoid unnecessary trouble. Even though they argued for their basic human rights, such as equal shares o f food and shorter work hours, they tried not to excessively irritate camp cadres.  266  Life in Xingkaihu Compared to the rightists in the army farms (see Chapter Two), physical conditions the Xingkaihu inmates confronted were worse, and their treatment harsher. U p o n arrival, they cut grass and wood to build their shacks, and they collected ice and snow for cooking and d r i n k i n g .  267  They had to stand i n icy mud  digging trenches or leveling the ground without any labor protection equipment. Work targets had to be fulfilled. Those who showed poor work performance not only suffered at the hands o f camp cadres but also from duty prisoners and other inmates.  268  In Xingkaihu, work was assigned collectively according to the number o f  Liu Naiyuan at times went to camp cadre Zhang to ask for an equal share of his cereal ration, which was kept lower than other inmates because of his poor performance at work. His manner was polite; although he was firmly refused, he tried not to irritate cadre Zhang. Liu Nayuan, Mirror, 229230. Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 391, 397. In Xingkaihu as well as in the PRC's prison camp system as a whole, the personnel who were in charge of inmates were generally referred to camp cadres or guanjiao ganbu, ranging from political instructors to team leaders and managerial secretaries. Appointed by the Beijing Public Security Bureau, the camp cadres in Xingkaihu were responsible for disciplining inmates, administering their life, supervising their work and giving political tutelage. See Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 72-74; Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 396-397. Duty prisoners or laotou were designated prisoners, who were normally physically strong and politically close to the camp authorities, and thus were entrusted to assist camp cadres in handling inmates at the lowest level. In addition to wielding considerable power over their fellow inmates, they were also responsible for the completion of labor work assigned to their squads or teams. 267  2 6 8  102  inmate teams. If individuals did not fulfill their targets, the whole team would lag behind. Camp cadres would then blame duty prisoners, who, in turn, would personally or via other prisoners visit misfortune on that individual. During the three lean years of 1959-62, these forced laborers survived on the meagerest grain rations, with their food subjected to frequent appropriation by camp cadres. Strenuous labor, lack of nutrition and medical care, and physical abuse were among the main causes of their untimely deaths.  269  The physical abuse, mental suffering and death the  political prisoners experienced will be discussed in detail in Chapter Four. Below, I outline a number of distinctive features of their daily camp routine. Treated as class enemies or criminals, the inmates in Xingkaihu were closely watched and subjected to armed escort even during work. Laojiao  inmates were  guarded by camp cadres who brought pistols with them while laogai convicts were guarded by P L A soldiers. Fields they worked were marked by red flags. Anyone who went beyond the marked lines could be shot on the spot by the authority of the law.  270  The living areas of laojiao inmates were marked by a large ring of wooden  sticks sparsely planted without cords or ropes encircling their living quarters. In the first week after his arrival, a fellow inmate of Liu Naiyuan in Branch 8 was shot dead for crossing the unclear cordon in the night.  271  In the Xingkaihu labor camps, official newspapers (especially the  Heilongjiang  Daily) were available, or to be more accurate, were compulsory reading for the political prisoners. After a day of strenuous labor, they had to attend political study sessions of one or two hours before sleep. The main routine of such sessions was the reading out of newspapers by camp cadres, or alternatively, by a literate prisoner. During study sessions, everybody was required to speak, to repeat or to rephrase materials from newspapers, to praise the Party's policies, or to eulogize economic  The death toll varied in the different branch camps of Xingkaihu. According to Chen Fengxiao, among the 75 convicts who were sent to Team One of Branch Four in April 1959, only 29 remained alive on January 1967, when Xingkaihu labor farm was disbanded. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 90. Xiu Min, a campmate of Chen Fengxiao, was shot in the arm because of slightly crossing the marked line. Ibid, 169. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 211-212.  2 6 9  2 7 0  2 7 1  103  achievements.  272  Free expression o f individual opinion was not allowed. Prisoners  were also asked to examine their daily thoughts and work, and to find fault with others.  273  Study sessions were essentially the focus o f thought reform i n labor camps.  Free reading was officially restricted, except for the works o f M a r x , Engels, Lenin and M a o . Chen Fengxiao was originally allowed to bring with h i m a box o f books, which included Russian versions o f math texts, an English Bible, and foreign literary masterpieces. When he arrived at Xingkaihu, all o f these books were seized by camp authorities and burned during the Cultural Revolution. In some branch camps, works on science and technology that were regarded as politically irrelevant were a l l o w e d .  274  Occasionally, severe weather in the borderland allowed relaxation for the Xingkaihu inmates. When blizzards raged, any outdoor work was impossible, and inmates were kept i n their barracks. Additionally, right after busy farm seasons, such as spring sowing, inmates were also given a short break. During these breaks, inmates often played chess or chatted among themselves. However, i f political offenders met too frequently, camp cadres would intervene. A s a sign o f the Party's benevolence, prisoners i n Xingkaihu were allowed to write to their families once a month, although letters were censored by camp authorities. L i u Naiyuan recounts,  A l l our correspondence was under strict censorship. A l l incoming mails for us from our families were opened before they were distributed to the recipients, and all letters we wrote to our dear ones were submitted, stamped but unsealed, to the police officers who sent them out after examining their contents. 276  Descriptions o f hardship, hunger, and requests for food were forbidden in Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 97, 103. Ibid, 89; Yin Jiliang, interview. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 96. As a laojiao inmate, Han Dajun was allowed to read books of agricultural technology; some camp cadres also borrowed these books from him. Han Dajun, interview. Tan Tianrong, interview; Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 74. Chen was once put into solitary confinement for hisfrequentchats with other "counterrevolutionaries." Liu Naiyun, Mirror, 241.  2 7 2 273  2 7 4  2 7 5  7 6  104  letters during the earlier famine years. When Yin Jiliang hinted to his mother in Beijing that he wanted some biscuits, he wrote "Do you often visit Yili (the name of a food product factory)?" in order to get his request past the censors.  277  Escape In the Maoist period, due to its harsh environment, Xingkaihu was considered a formidable place by offenders, criminal and political alike. The remoteness, the marshlands, the cold and the mosquitoes have been infamous for many Chinese especially prisoners. Being banished to Xingkaihu was almost synonymous to a death sentence, so convicts tried hard not to be sent there. In the Beiyuan Detention Center, Cong Weixi recounted how, a rumor of possible banishment to Xingkaihu 978  caused grave fear among the inmates.  When their fates were sealed and prisoners  were destined for Xingkaihu, some tried to escape during the journey. In April 1959, when around 5,000 convicts were on the way to Xingkaihu, seven plotted to escape. The scheme failed and four of the chief organizers were executed. Upon arrival at Xingkaihu, exiles found it difficult to flee since the grim geographical and ecological environment made escape unfeasible. The Xingkaihu complex was surrounded by rivers, lakes, and thousands of square kilometers of marshland, which could devour anyone who got lost in it during the wet season. Still, some tried though none succeeded.  280  Inmates fleeing to the wilderness during the  winter headed for certain death during the unpredictable blizzards. The only potential way out was a man-made embankment guarded by P L A soldiers. Some Yin Jiliang, interview. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun (Going towards Chaos) (Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chu banshe, 1998), 118-121. The exception existed, however. In the Banbuqiao Detention Center in which Wu Ningkun was put, many detainees did not fear to be sent to any labor camp including Xingkaihu, as long as they could get enough food to eat and leave the crowded prison cells. "After two months of incarceration on a starvation diet, we all jumped at the prospect of working in the sun on a full stomach." See Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear, 77. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 71-72. Liu Naiyuan recalls that an inmate in Branch Eight got away from the encampment after careful preparation. Armed with a map, a compass, and food he stole from the kitchen, he marched into the depth of ripened wula grass one autumn dawn, and gradually walked into ankle-deep water in what he thought was the right direction. He walked for the whole day but ended up in neck-deep water and silt. In a desperate panic he shouted for help. A peasant collecting wild-duck eggs in a rowboat saved him and returned him to the camp. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 240.  2 7 7  2 7 8  2 7 9  2 8 0  105  would-be escapees put their hope on crossing into the Soviet Union, which faces the Xingkaihu marshland across a shallow river—the Songacha River. During the SinoSoviet honeymoon, all escapees fleeing to the Soviet Union were sent back, and some were executed.  281  The Sino-Soviet breakdown bred a degree of hope for  prisoners who desperately wanted to leave. One laogai inmate, Wang Xingbai, of Branch 1, successfully escaped. As a former Russian language instructor in a Chinese university, Wang was at first treated well by Russian frontier guards and sent to Moscow, but he was eventually extradited to China. He paid for his adventure with the sentence "stay of execution". According to Chen Fengxiao, the majority of returned escapees were sentenced to execution or received a stay of 787  execution for their "counterrevolutionary treason" of attempted escape. For those confined in other labor camps in Manchuria, attempted escapes would normally lead to maltreatment by camp police rather than the death penalty. Hu Xianzhong's frequent escapes rose from the maltreatment he suffered in prison camps, but each attempt resulted in even more abuse. The punishments he received included starvation, beating and hanging up, as well as the noted "Su Qin carries a sword on his back"—being handcuffed with one arm turned over the shoulder and the other twisted up from below.  783  Political Offenders among Criminal Offenders One of the striking characteristics of the Xingkaihu labor farms, as that of the whole prison camp systems in Maoist China, was the practice of placing political offenders among criminal offenders, in order to use criminals to monitor and discipline the political offenders. Unlike in G M D prisons, where prisoners were locked up separately according to the nature of their crimes, political prisoners of the CCP were distributed to various units of labor camps to prevent their collective gathering. In Xingkaihu, political prisoners amounted to no more than one-third; a majority of the inmates were non-political offenders. Liu Naiyuan recalls that in his 2 8 1  2 8 2 2 8 3  Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 69, 102; Yin Jiliang, interview. Chen Fengxiao, Ibid, 114. Hu Xianzhong, interview.  106  labor team non-political criminals included those who committed "larceny, hooliganism, corruption, murder and the like, the majority being thieves or pickpockets who had been enjailed before, and some were experienced jailbirds." In addition, Yin Jiliang's team also accommodated those who were convicted of 98S  sexual misconducts, such sexual assault, rape, homosexuality and adultery. Although these offenses were abhorred by the general public, they were seen by CCP authorities to be less threatening to the existing political order.  286  With clear political lines drawn by the central authorities, political offenders in China's prison camps were nicknamed "external contradictions," or "extercons," while criminal offenders were "internal contradictions," or "innercons." The latter received more favorable treatment from camp cadres. Political inmates in Xingkaihu, such as Liu Naiyuan, got a strong feeling that camp cadres had intrinsic hatred towards bourgeois rightists while they were more friendly to "intercons." Thus they were more willing to use the "intercons" as leaders of inmate teams. Chen Fengxiao also recalls that camp cadres explicitly cited the superiority of criminal offenders 'yon  over political ones and encouraged them to help watch the latter.  Cell bosses,  overwhelmingly criminals, were particularly responsible for watching and reporting political inmates. In the beginning, many political prisoners felt insulted to be placed alongside common criminals, or even under them. As Yin Jiliang puts it, "we felt irritated being put among these criminals. As intellectuals, scientists and writers, we felt deeply humiliated."  Although some political offenders such as Tan Tianrong did  Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 230. Yin Jiliang, interview. In February 1957, Mao in his "On correctly handling contradictions among the people" defined two contradictions within Chinese society the one between the CCP government (as the spokesman of the people) and anti-socialist reactionary forces, and the one within the ranks of the people. The former spelt fundamental political divergence, and thus needed to be solved by dictatorship and oppression; the latter referred to non-political problems, which could be solved through the approach of "democratic centralism." Mao also stated that offenders such as those who committed larceny, fraud, murder, and hooliganism were also in need of punishment, but their penalty should differ in nature from the suppression of reactionaries. See Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji (Selected Works of Mao Zedong) (Beijing: Remin chubanshe, 1977), Vol. 5, 364-366. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 231; Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 56-57. Yin Jiliang, interview.  2 8 4 2 8 5  2 8 6  2 8 7 2 8 8  107  not mind being placed among criminal offenders (as Tan was absorbed in his academic interests), many treated criminal offenders as human trash. Living in the same cell, hearing the coarse language and street lingo of criminals, and watching their undesirable behavior and unsanitary habits was unbearable for intellectuals who had been well-educated and saw themselves as the social elite. On the other hand, criminal offenders were neither respectful nor sympathetic to the persecuted intellectuals because of their aloofness, their inferior political status, and their inability to carve out a better life in camps.  289  This poor relationship not only prevented these two groups from forming any alliances, but also provided camp authorities with the opportunity to strengthen their administrative control. In Xingkaihu, camp cadres commonly incited physical abuse of political prisoners by criminal prisoners. "If cadres believed a political prisoner to be difficult to tame, he would tell the duty prisoner to 'give this guy a lesson,' then the ruffian would jump up arid began to slap and kick the victim," said Yin Jiliang.  290  This practice extended beyond Xingkaihu. Hu Xianzhong, who was  detained in several labor camps in Jilin, recalls that when criminal offenders were violent towards their political counterparts, camp police intervened only when the targets were seriously injured.  291  By inciting one group of prisoners against the other,  labor camp authorities were able to further their end—of driving fear into the hearts of political prisoners who showed disobedience, and retaining efficient control over various groups of prisoners. However, not all the political prisoners withstood the insults and bullying imposed on them. Some fought back, such as the Shandong native Chen Fengxiao. One day when a ruffian repeatedly made trouble for him at the worksite, Chen responded with unbelievable ferocity, chopping him to the ground with a spade. This violence sent Chen into a solitary confinement cell for three months. As a university Yin Jiliang recalls that only when intellectual prisoners were begged by criminal convicts to help write confessions or letters home could they receive a degree of respect. Tan Tianrong recalls that a young hooligan was once trying to find fault with him and shouted "You are arightist;it will serve you right if you are beaten to death." Yin Jiliang, Tan Tianrong, interviews. Harry Wu's campmates, such as Xing, saw Wu's school education as useless. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 66. Yin Jiliang, interview. Hu Xianzhong, interview.  289  2 9 0  2 9 1  108  student who was believed to be inferior in physical and spiritual strength, his counterattack to some extent readjusted the relationship between the political prisoners and criminals in his squad.  292  By and large, however, the inferior position of the persecuted intellectuals in Xingkaihu could not be easily reversed. In addition to their low political status, which could be taken advantage of by the criminal offenders, hooliganism flourished in the camps, targeting the weak physical condition of the intellectuals. As in other labor camps in China, hooliganism developed in Xingkaihu, and those intellectuals who were physically weak became easy targets. Being robbed of food and being bullied were common places. Mr. L i , a former leading horticulturist, was frequently robbed of his food by the criminal prisoners in his squad. Indignant, he rose to defend his food and to steal that of others, but he always lost out. The relationship between political and criminal offenders was complex, however. At times the former felt that some benefit could be gained from the life experience and philosophy of the latter: they increasingly discovered that penal criminals—those who were sentenced for theft, robbery, rape, murder, etc—were clever in dealing with hardship in the difficult years. Thus, when their interests were not in direct conflict, intellectuals could learn something and get help from them. Both Chen Fengxiao and Yin Jiliang recall that some warm-hearted penal prisoners advised them on how to deal with camp cadres and how to survive the camp.  294  To some extent, criminal offenders exerted an influence upon political prisoners in terms of their moral principles and philosophy. This is especially apparent in Hongda Harry Wu's case. During his twenty years of banishment, Harry Wu saw Mr. Xing as the first mentor in his life. A poverty-stricken peasant, Xing had roamed around and did whatever he could to support himself before he was sent to a labor reeducation camp, where he made friends with Wu. Talking from his heart, Xing advised Wu to take care of himself alone, rather than to be concerned about others. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 86-87. Yin Jiliang, interview. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 94; Yin Jiliang, interview. Hongda Harry Wu also recalls that Lang, a penal criminal, "taught me a lot about how to labor, how to save energy, and how to survive in the camp." Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 105. 2 9 2  2 9 3  2 9 4  109  "In this place the strongest one is the best one." Xing also suggested that in order to survive, people were justified in doing whatever they could and that stealing "is a small thing, not important, not a big deal at all."  295  In the beginning, Wu could not  accept Xing's indifference to moral standards. Gradually, however, Wu's disapproval gave way to respect. "I grew to admire him as the most capable and influential teacher of my life." He realized that Xing was actually far more intelligent than himself. "To survive in the camps, I needed new skills and different attitudes." Under the influence of a criminal, Wu employed and justified whatever means necessary for his survival during the difficult years. Ironically, he believed that this was the most important result of his "labor reeducation": "I realized that my 'reeducation' had reached another stage."  297  The above constitutes a grim and ironic picture: in the labor camps of Maoist China, inmates of different kinds were put together, where they often shared their philosophy of life. Besides serving as one source of their physical abuse, criminal offenders also taught political offenders unique lessons on how to survive the harsh reality of camp life, and imbued them with street ethics. With these influences and pressure for survival, some political offenders began to disregard their former ideas and scruples, and their sense of dignity gave way to the exigency of subsistence.  Conclusion Although not significantly different from other labor camps in Maoist China, Xingkaihu stands out as a labor reform regime used to confine and punish various social undesirables from Beijing, most notably the victims of political persecution. The most ardent critics of the government and some of China's best educated people spent years in this desolate region as their lives were squandered and consumed. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 63, 66-67. Ibid, 64, 80. Under the influence of Xing, Hongda Harry Wu "had learned how to steal, how to protect myself, and finally how to fight...I had a new ethic of survival." Wu confesses how he grabbed food from one of his fellow prisoners and beat him down. When a camp cadre asked him to serve as group record keeper, Wu jumped at the chance to write down everything the prisoners said. The reward for this new assignment was an extra half of cornbread at every meal. See, Ibid, 68, 81,107. 2 9 5  296  2 9 7  110  Placed under close surveillance by camp cadres and discriminated against by penal criminals, the experiences of political exiles mirror that of many of the country's political underclass. While their general life pattern and ordinary experiences, as well as the characteristics of the Xingkaihu complex, are treated as the focus of this chapter, the human suffering they endured (heavy workload, physical abuse, starvation, death and suicide) will be detailed in the next chapter, to show how the exiles survived a hellish existence in the frontier region. As well, since the army farms in Beidahuang functioned as another type of labor camp, the suffering of the Beijing rightists, which to some extent paralleled that of the Xingkaihu inmates, will also be explored in the next chapter.  Ill  Chapter Four Life and Death in Beidahuang "Hey, look over there," Liu shouted as he was pointing to the east, "the shining Ussuri River, a vast expanse of whiteness. And further east, that would probably be the habitat of the Russians. Have you ever imagined that you, a revolutionary writer, nowadays would come here, to such a primeval forest like Wanda Mountain as a lumber worker?" "Yes, I have." I said. "I dreamed of going to the forest when I was very little. I was born on the Yangzi- Huaihe Plain, where there are no mountains or forests at all. So I liked to read about the Xing'an Mountains on the northeastern border. ...People portray the forests here like heaven—peaceful, quiet, with birds singing and flowers blossoming. You could lie down on the soft grass anywhere you like and enjoy the sunlight, with nuts and mushrooms within arm's reach. Actually, that is not the real world for us who have to labor here. Just look at that hanging tree there— with just a gust of wind blowing past, it might fall down and crush us to death. ... In wood-cutting here, the very moment of felling a tree is exactly when one's fate hangs in the balance." 298  Huang Wu, a writer and foreign literature specialist who went through three years of forced labor, reveals a sharp duality in Beidahuang—a lovely world that nonetheless threatens death. While the natural beauty and the vitality of the wild world embraced everybody including the banished, many may not have enjoyed these surroundings because of the very nature of the forced labor they had to perform and the difficult living conditions they had to endure. For the banished, the various challenges to their physical existence were real, and death, gloomy and unpredictable, might descend on them at any time. Life and death in prisons and in the laogai system of China have been reconstructed and examined by many, including Bao Ruo Wang, Hongda Harry Wu, James Seymour, Kate Saunders, and Philip Williams. The narratives they provide range from the daily routine in labor camps to the human suffering, from "brainwashing" to physical abuse, from individual stories to the  collective  Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji (Additional Collection of Mahua Hall) (Guangzhou: Guangdong wenhua chubanshe, 1989), 34.  112  experience/  99  The life experience o f political exiles i n Manchuria's border region  during the 1950s and 1960s, however, has yet to be analyzed by scholars in the English-speaking  world,  although  since  the  early  1990s,  publications  and  underground manuscripts by the banished have significantly contributed to our understanding o f their w o r l d .  300  This chapter examines the most common experiences o f political exiles both in the army farms and i n the Xingkaihu labor reform complex, with a focus on the heavy workload, hunger, death, physical abuse, and suicide, which constitute the main themes o f political banishment and o f the tremendous human tragedy i n the period o f 1959-62. While recognizing that some positive experiences did occur, the bulk o f the chapter serves to delineate what was painfully carved into the exile's memory  about  Beidahuang—suffering  and  dehumanization,  and  subsequent  distortion o f human behavior. This chapter suggests that the policies and actions o f the camp and farm authorities were the direct causes o f suffering that made human life there extremely fragile.  Life During the early period o f their stay i n Beidahuang (approximately from the spring o f 1958 to the middle o f 1959), hunger was not strongly felt, and the life o f the exiles d i d not seem so bad. Since they were offered relatively sufficient food, their basic needs for survival  were  ensured.  While  the  ultra-rightists  and  See Kate Saunders, Eighteen Layers of Hell: Storiesfromthe Chinese Gulag (London: Cassell Wellington House, 1996); Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds: A Memoir ofMy Years in China's Gulag (New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc., 1994); James Seymour and Richard Anderson, New Ghosts, Old Ghosts: Prisons and Labor Reform Camps in China (Armonk: M E . Sharpe, 1998); Philip F. Williams and Yenna Wu, The Great Wall of Confinement: the Chinese Prison Camp through Contemporary Fiction and Reportage (Berkeley: The University of California Press, 2004); Bao Ruo wang and Rudolph Chelminski, Prisoner ofMao (New York: Penguin Books, 1973). The rightists sent to army farms in Beidahuang, such as Dai Huang, Wu Yongliang and YinYi have been able to get their memoirs published in China. By an interesting contrast, those imprisoned in the labor reform complex of Xingkaihu could only publish their recollections overseas, as in the case of Wu Ningkun and Liu Naiyuan; their memoirs (forbidden to be published in the Mainland) were circulated among friends, as in the case of Chen Fengxiao, although the extent to which they disclose the darkness of banishment life is not much different. 3 0 0  113  counterrevolutionaries sentenced to the Xingkaihu labor reform complex were subjected to tight physical control (see Chapter Three above), those sent to the army farms enjoyed a degree o f freedom after their daily work was completed. Therefore, they could feel that they belonged to a lovely and dynamic world, and the life during this early stage was often portrayed by them i n a relatively positive manner. L i u M e n g recalls that "when I first arrived at Farm 850,1 did not feel very bad, probably because I was young and energetic. I was surprised that the northeast plain was so vast, and it took an hour or so to reach the edge o f the field where we worked; I worked on the sowing machine. That was really fantastic. I had a feeling that I was embraced by the vast sky and the earth."  301  Even though he sharply condemned the  C C P policy o f frontier banishment i n his recollections, L i u does not conceal his good feeling about the landscape o f Beidahuang. A n even more positive description is made by D a i Huang, although he was also a harsh critic o f the inhumanity o f camp life i n Beidahuang. What made us most excited was the spring here. There was no pollution, no destruction o f the natural wilderness. The blue sky, white clouds and w i l d flowers on the fertile plain set each other off beautifully. The plain was then really an impressive sight. In particular, almost every sunny morning, there would be a mirage i n the eastern sky lasting for about a half hour—forest, land, houses, lakes, wagons... everything inside....In M a y after a rainy morning, when we were allowed to take a day off, many o f us walked along a trail all the way down to the edge o f the forest. Listening to the twittering o f birds, we collected various kinds o f flowers and took them b a c k . " 302  This positive description mirrors their passable life i n the early stage o f banishment. During work breaks, rightists i n the army farms were allowed to pursue many pastimes. Painting, singing, playing musical instruments, practicing Peking opera, or playing bridge became regular pleasures. The rightists i n Farm 850 even had free Liu Meng, interview. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng: wo deyoupai licheng (A Narrow Escape from Death: My Experience as a Rightist) (Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, 1998), 117. Some rightists who had had experience of living abroad claimed that Beidahuang rivaled Geneva in terms of its natural beauty. See Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei: Beidahuang shenghuo jishi (Floating Rain and Snow: True Stories of Life in the Great Northern Wilderness) (Beijing: Zhongguo xiju chubanshe, 2002), 43. 3 0 1  3 0 2  114  time to maintain a flower nursery close to where they lived.  303  853 at times even enjoyed his favorite poetry by Walt Whitman.  Huang Wu of Farm 304  Living in such an environment, the rightists felt rather contented, and this could contribute to their commitment to manual labor. They built up shacks to live in, produced the food they needed, and cut wood for socialist construction, all of which, seen by at least some of them, were the meaningful life and part of a grand plan for the transformation of the virgin land on the one hand and their inner world on the other. The early life of the rightists in Farm 853 and their positive attitude toward manual labor are reflected in Chen Ming's letter to Ding Ling. As Ding Ling recalled, Chen Ming: described floating snow in April as a picturesque scene, and he presented their work—lumbering in the snow, drilling wells, melting cooking water from ice, and building barracks as being full of meaning. The vast wilderness and the undulating mountain ranges of Beidahuang were captivating. Chen Ming and his friends are actually waging a war against heaven and earth." Chen Ming even suggested that Ding Ling Come and join him.  305  Dai Huang also  describes how the banished rightists gained a feeling of happiness through their work, and tried to make significance out of their backbreaking labor. The positive 306  and even aesthetic perspectives on their labor reflect satisfaction with their life and a seeming adaptation to their banishment. They temporarily forgot their sadness, and the nature of their forced labor faded.  Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 36-37; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 117. Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 36. Huang Wu particularly enjoyed Whitman's "Song of the Broad-Axe," which sang of the life of American lumbermen in the nineteenth Century. Huang Wu even tried to imagine some link between his life as a lumber worker in Beidahuang and the imagery reflected in Whitman's poems. See Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian (The Blizzard World) (Xiamen: Xiamen daxue chubanshe, 1987), 17. Chen Ming was sent to Beidahuang at first in March of 1958 and sent back a letter that pushed Ding to make up her mind to go and join him. Dai Huang writes: "In the field people worked cheerfully while in the sky cuckoo, larks, turtledoves, and quails sang in flight, all of which constituted a wonderful scene of changing heaven and earth." Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 122. J U J  3 0 4  3 0 5  0 6  115  Another face o f banishment rapidly unfolded, however, as their workload became heavier, and especially with the devastating impact o f nation-wide famine beginning in 1959. Work satisfaction and an appreciation o f natural beauty gave way to untold suffering.  Death by L a b o r A s discussed in Chapter Two, the intensive use o f forced labor i n Beidahuang caused unimaginable hardship for the exiles as their banishment was prolonged, and their suffering was compounded by food shortages. The consequence o f this process was untimely death for many laboring exiles. The banishment o f political offenders coincided with the economic adventure o f the P R C government in 1958-59—the Great Leap Forward ( G L F ) , which featured intensive labor and material inputs i n exchange for rapid economic g r o w t h .  307  In  Beidahuang, as elsewhere in China, high production targets spelled heavy workloads for the exiles, which in turn led to mass death from exhaustion i n both the army farms and the Xingkaihu labor camps. According to L i u Naiyuan, i n an irrigation project all o f the inmates were driven to ceaseless labor by the camp cadres and pressured by blackboard assessments that indicated one's work achievements. Gan, a lean, pale inmate was so pressed and mocked because o f his slowness that he could barely take a breath in his efforts not to be left far behind. Eventually after days o f desperate physical exertion, Gan was found dead one night.  308  Chen Fengxiao's account supplies more details o f death through hard labor in Branch 4 at Xingkaihu.  During forty or more days o f spring sowing i n 1960, the rain went on and on. In order not to miss the sowing season, all the convicts were ordered to go out to the fields with only a plastic sheet shielding their bodies, raking and sowing i n the rain. We got up at three o'clock in the morning and went 307  For a comprehensive narrative of the GLF, see Jonathan Spence, The Search for Modern China (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1990), 574-583. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror: A Loss of Innocence in Mao's China (Philadelphia: Xlibris Corporation, 2001), 224-225. 3 0 8  116  home after eight at evening, terribly overwhelmed by hunger and cold. O n one horrible day, several weaker convicts fell to the ground on the road back from work. They were taken back to the barrack, and died soon after. Rather than dying o f fatal disease, they were actually worked to death." 309  Mass death by excessive forced labor happened i n the army farms, as well. According to D a i Huang, on Oct 13, 1960, around one hundred rightists i n the Yunshan Branch o f Farm 850 were herded into intensive harvesting o f soy beans. Seven o f them died on the road back home after a whole day o f ceaseless work on a snowy day. Lack o f food supplies and timely relief also contributed to these deaths.  310  Forced labor led to frequent accidental deaths when exiles were ordered to engage i n activities with which they were not familiar. In the winter o f 1958, hundreds o f rightists from both Farms 850 and 853 were organized into lumbering teams, to go to the Wanda Mountain and cut trees. In the context o f the G L F , they were asked to cut as much wood as possible to contribute to socialist construction. They had to work i n pairs, and complete work targets (in some cases, at least eight cubic meters per day) with hand saws. Unable to properly handle manual lumbering and forced to work extra hours at night, they frequently suffered sudden injury and death—for example, being crushed by falling trees, as cited by Huang W u at the beginning o f this chapter. In his lumber team o f fifty-six people, two were killed by falling trees and one was badly injured during the winter o f 1958-59.  311  D a i Huang  also recalled that four o f around one hundred o f his campmates died i n lumbering  Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi (The True Stories of My Twenty-Two Years of Laogai Experience) (Unpublished work), 85. What Chen describes here happened in the aftermath of the GLF; the intensive use of weak laborers was definitely the key reason for their deaths. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 225-232. This mass death in Yunshan is also documented by Yin Yi, Huishou canyang yi han shan (The Setting of the Sun over the Mountain) (Beijing: Shiyue wenyi chubanshe, 2003), 87-89, and Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 133-134. Dai Huang believes that more than one year of prolonged hunger maderightistsin his branch farm extremely weak and pale, which, compounded with intensive labor in vile weather, caused this mass death. Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 37, 59. Deaths also occurred in daily farm work. Chen Fengxiao recalls that in the laogai branch farm where he stayed, accidental casualties occurred every year when convicts were unable to properly handle electric threshing machines or other farm machines. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 80-81. 3 1 0  3 1 1  117  accidents that winter.  312  While the unfamiliarity o f the exiles with their newly assigned manual work led to casualties, the root cause rested with the Party's policy o f herding urban people and intellectuals into the rural world, and the indifference o f camps authorities towards human life. Tragic deaths o f the exiles was inevitable when camp authorities made unrealistic and unproductive work plans and forced the exiles to complete them regardless o f bad weather and their poor physical condition, as indicated by D a i Huang, Huang W u and others. Furthermore, the camp authorities often failed to provide timely relief even when people were i n danger and death was imminent. The tragic death o f seven rightists in the Yunshan Branch on October 13, 1960 was to a great extent due to the farm cadres' refusal to send out a rescue team at night on the grounds that "tomorrow's work is not to be affected"; they did not even bother to call a doctor. Thus, the rightists were indignant to learn that their lives were less important than those o f the local draft horses.  313  In both Xingkaihu and the army farms, cases o f death and injury were handled perfunctorily. The dead normally did not receive proper mourning nor did their families get any compensation. Often, the bodies o f the dead would be buried right away, and their families would then be notified, without any offer o f compensation. If maimed, inmates i n Xingkaihu were still not released from labor, but had to continue working i n their barracks after treatment, performing lighter work such as weaving baskets or straw ropes.  314  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 141-143. Some of exiles died tragically in efforts to save tools, handsaws or spades for instance, when danger was perceived. Since the camp leaders promoted the notion that "one must give higher priority to public properties than one's own life," inmates would be severely condemned for the loss of tools. In this circumstance, some died from falling trees or landslides when trying to show their commitment to "saving public property." See Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 90; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 141; Xingkaihu changshiban, Xingkaihu nongchang shi (Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm) (Mishan: No pub., 1988), 359. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 231, 233. According to Dai, when the "Oct 13 tragedy" happened, the heads of the Yunshan branch did not even bother to send for doctors to rescue those in danger at night, so that the rightists had to perform first aid for their fellow inmates. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 80-81. There is no indication that mourning ceremonies were provided in army farms. Wu Yongliang recalls that when one of his friends died in lumbering, his team leader refuted requests for a ceremony on the grounds that "Chairman Mao told on us that the death for the revolution is perfectly normal, so there is no need to make a fuss." See, 3 1 2  3 1 3  3 1 4  118  Death by overwork and the authorities' indifference towards human life, although astonishing, were less threatening than other conditions. Starvation, disease, and the lack of medical care were more critical and fundamental to the loss of human life in Beidahuang. A l l too often, death was a manifestation of these combined forces. The old and the weak who were unable to stand up to a torrent of adversities were especially prone to death in the years 1959-61.  Hunger For  the majority of the offenders (both political and criminal) sent to  Beidahuang, hunger was the most unforgettable aspect of their experience. Since their banishment coincided with the three successive years of famine caused by the GLF, their lot, as outcasts of society, was particularly miserable. During most of the 1950s, hunger was not a major threat for political offenders, as long as they remained in prison and obeyed prison rules. Wu Yue and Chen Fengxiao indicate that political prisoners received adequate food in the Caolanzi Detention Center in Beijing before they were sent to laogai camps; before October 1957, no food limits were set for them.  315  Certain influential prisoners or former  high ranking officials were even served lavish food (by contemporary standards)— four dishes and one soup (sicai yitang). Pan Hannian, the former-deputy mayor of Shanghai, for instance, even enjoyed milk, eggs, tea, and high-grade cigarettes while 11/-  he served his fifteen-year sentence in the Tuanhe Laogai Farm. During the early part of their stay at Beidahuang, neither the rightists in army Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 91. An exception occurred in Xingkaihu, however, when three convicts died for saving tools in a construction accident; they were honored in a public gathering for their courageous actions to save public property, and limited compensation was offered to their families. See Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 397. Wu Yue, interview; Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 30-31. Yan Peng, "Pan Hannian zai Tuanhe nongchang" (Pan Hannian in Tuanhe Farm), in Zongheng, No. 10, 1998, 24-30. Those put in detention centers or prisons that accommodated ordinary offenders, however, complained about their experience of hunger. Liu Naiyuan, who was put in the Banbuqiao Detention Center in Beijing, recalls that during his first couple of months, he was in a "desperate fight with a gnawing hunger." "For all the consummate skill of the cooks, the food was far from enough, so that at the end of each meal I felt barely half full. My guts used to rumble at bedtime; so did those of my cellmates." See Liu Nanyuan, Mirror, 192-193. 3 1 5  3 1 6  119  farms nor the inmates in the Xingkaihu labor camps felt much threat of hunger, mainly because the authorities had to ensure that they were physically capable of heavy work. "Upon arrival at the army farms," recalls Liu Meng, "rightist laborers were allowed to eat as much as they could due to the heavy workloads," although 317  some complained about coarse food such as com gruel.  The situation was the  same for inmates in Xingkaihu. From the summer of 1959, however, hunger crept in quietly. In Farm 850, "grain rations were set and dropped rapidly, from 72 jin to 63 jin, and later went down to 54 jin, 48 jin, 40 jin a month (1 jin is equal to 1.1023 lbs). Our stomachs became increasingly empty," Dai Huang recalls. During the worst period of 1960, in Farm 853, a rightist worker had only an 8 jin monthly ration of grain.  318  Wu  Yongliang recalls that the feeling of hunger became increasingly acute after the second half of 1959, but grain rations were replenished by vegetables. As time 319  passed, however, without a trace of meat or oil, the exiles had to depend solely on grains for nutrition, and their stringent daily rations, in the forms of corn buns and watery vegetable soup, hardly alleviated the hunger pangs of those who were forced to perform heavy manual labor. Their diet was thus far from sufficient for subsistence.  320  While Philip Williams and Yenna Wu are convinced that the PRC's rationing of food to laogai inmates exerted a thoroughgoing control over prisoners and won ' L i u Meng, interview. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 33. Sources from other rightists also indicate there was enough food for them during the early part of their stay in the army farms. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 157; Bawusan nongchangzhi bianshen weiyuanhui, Bawusan nongchangzhi (Gazetteer of the Farm 853) (Beijing: No pub, 1986), 132. Whether the exiles received their designated rations is doubtful. Some exiles complained that their limited rations were subject to frequent appropriation by farm leaders and managerial personnel. Yang Congdao and Wang Keqin recalls that while ordinary workers including rightists were fed with food substitutes and thin porridge in dining halls, the farm leaders ate in a "small kitchen" (xiaozao) enjoying special food. Yang Congdao and Wang Keqin, interviews. Dai Huang recalls that when grain rations per person dropped to 30 jin per month from December 1959, a rightist in Yunshan only received two small wotous (Wotou is a bread-like bun, mainly made of corn flour, corn chaff, or in some rural areas of Manchuria, rough sorghum). It is eaten for breakfast and lunch, and very little porridge for dinner, which was far less than what they should have been allocated. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 174. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 114. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 84. 3 1  3 1 8  3 1 9 3 2 0  120  their submission to its authority more efficiently than other forms o f torture, they also note that "the problem o f hunger among laogai inmates varied greatly in intensity according to the historical period, the region, and the rationing policies o f the local camp cadres."  321  In the case o f Xingkaihu, inmates found that food rations  differed considerably between different branches. According to H a n Dajun, who was transferred between three branches during August and September 1960, grain rations were 60 jin o f corn flour per person per month i n Branch 2, 45 jin i n Branch 8, but only 30 jin i n Branch 7 .  322  The implication o f these differences is that the heads o f  branches had considerable autonomy i n deciding levels o f rationing for their inmates, and thus the degree o f hunger the inmates suffered. Closely related to variations in food rationing was the extent o f grain shortages in Beidahuang at this time. Although rationing at low levels might not be seen as a conscious design o f the C C P authorities to inflict suffering upon the "class enemies," decreasing food supplies did not necessarily stem from a lack o f grain in this farming region. Barns were often full o f grain, according to H a n Dajun, Y i n Jiliang and D a i Huang, but farm authorities intentionally cut food rations o f inmates as well as other farm workers (demobilized soldiers and newly recruited farmers from the interior, for instance), trying to show their commitment to the state and to build up their good image. L i u , the head o f Branch 7 o f Xingkaihu, was particularly honored by his superiors for his success i n "economizing" (jieyue) on g r a i n .  323  Recollections o f individual inmates are echoed by official sources. When ordinary workers, including rightists, were rationed a starvation diet o f 8 jin per month, the Farm 853 leaders voluntarily turned over significant amounts o f grain to the higher authorities, twice in 1960—the first time five m i l l i o n jin and the second time 630 Williams and Wu, The Great Wall of Confinement, 87, 89. Han Dajun, interview. In the worse period of 1960, food supplies in the Xingkaihu labor reform complex generally seemed better than in army farms, and grain rations for inmates were more than that for camp cadres. Liu Junying, a former camp cadre in Branch 5, says: "When the convicts in our farm were rationed more than 30 jin, I was just given 28 jin" So Liu argues that the complaints of inmates about their hunger were no more than a "psychological effect." Liu Junying, interview. But the recollections of Chen Fengxiao, Yin Jiliang and Liu Naiyuan all indicate more severe hunger among the inmates than the camp cadres in Xingkaihu, simply because inmates had to perform heavy labor. Han Dajun and Yin Jiliang, interviews. 3 2 1  3 2 2  3 2 3  121  thousand jin,  thus the farm leadership was praised by the Ministry of Land  Reclamation for their "Farm 853 revolutionary spirit." The political activism of 324  farm leaders exacerbated grain shortages in their own units. With work strenuous and food rationed, the life of the exiles became increasingly difficult. As Huang Miaozi wrote in a letter home in June 1959, rightists in his team normally had three meals a day, "two porridge and one solid, or alternatively, two solid and one porridge when work is heavy; the meals are mostly corn gruel, corn breads and cabbage leaves with no or little dietary oil."  325  Like  many other rightists, who tried not to inform their families of suffering in Beidahuang unless it was too unbearable, in the summer of 1959 Huang did not explicitly tell of his hunger. Three months later, he began to suffer serious dropsy as the result of malnutrition.  326  Overwhelmed by hunger, inmates in both the army farms and in Xingkaihu had to make whatever effort they could to search for food to fill their stomachs. The vast fields of Beidahuang were a ready source of wild food. After work, famished exiles flocked out of their barracks searching the fields for edible weeds, wild herbs and grasses, collecting bird eggs, digging up plant roots, and even searching rat holes for caches of grain stored underground by rats.  377  When nothing was left, people  Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao (The Northeast Corner of China) (Harbin: Heilongjiang renmin chubanshe, 1998), 163. Li Hui, Ren zai xuanwo: Huang Miaozi yu Yu Feng (People in the Eddy: Huang Miaozi and Yu Feng) (Jinan. Shandong huabao chubanshe, 1998), 322. Ibid, 324-326; Xin Suwei, Ding Cong zhuan (Biography of Ding Cong) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 1993), 186, 191. In the general context of hunger, exceptions existed in Beidahuang. It seems that those who were not involved in strenuous manual labor suffered less hunger. Ding Cong and Wu Zuguang, who were asked to work on a local magazine Literature and Art in Beidahuang, did not suffer as Dai Huang did, and some laojiao inmates in Xingkaihu did not indicate hunger either. For example, being assigned to work in a cultural and educational team (wenjiao dui) and free from manual labor, ex-movie director Ba Hong admits that he was very lucky. "I did not suffer edema, nor did my friends in wenjiao dm". Ba Hong, interview. Hui Peilin, a female laojiao inmate in a wild life raising team in Xingkaihu recalls that no food ration was set for female inmate workers in her unit of estimated hundred of people, and that they could even eat fish, chicken andfreshvegetable, since her team director treated the female inmates nicely. Hui Peilin, interview. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 213; Liang Nan, "Chaosheng zhe" (Pilgrims), in Liu Meng, ed., Huishou rensheng (Reflections on Our Life) (Beijing: Shidai wenyi chubanshe, 1992), 9. Wu Yongliang also recalls that once upon a time he and three of his fellows were sent to dig rat holes for soy beans stored by field rats, and their six days' work brought back more than ten bags of soy beans as important additions to food. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 112-113. 3 2 4  3 2 5  326  3 2 7  122  foraged in the trees. In the winter o f 1960, i n the Yunshan Branch, all the bark o f elm trees was peeled off and eaten.  328  Tree leaves were ground into flour, which was  mixed with plant stalks and stem, chaff, nut kernels and seed as food substitutes. W i l d animals also became targets. Some exiles dug the ground to catch field rats to eat. There are many recollections by Y i n Jiliang, D a i Huang, L i u M e n g and Y i n Y i about their experiences i n devouring field rats, which for many became a normal dietary fixture and an important source o f nutrition.  329  Intellectuals' picky eating  habits and humanitarian concerns in normal time entirely disappeared. In hunger and malnutrition, people also tried to entice snakes out o f their lairs. Tang Zunwen, a former opera actor, was famous for his skill i n capturing snakes with simple tools. " A t times in that summer he went out to the river side and came back with couple o f snakes. H e took out their poison gland (in the case o f venomous snakes), washed them, cut them into pieces, and cooked them in an iron barrel with a bit o f salt to make a tasty snake soup.... Even those who hated snake could not help coming to try it."  During the years o f famine, rightists were among the first i n  Beidahuang who tried snakes. Famished exiles who gorged on various w i l d species risked getting poisoned. In the Qinghe camp in north China, laojiao inmate L u Fengnian felt happy when he caught a snake, a frog, a toad and a rat in a field. He cooked them all together i n a  Liang Nan, "Chaoshengzhe", in Liu Meng, ed., Huishou rensheng, 16. Liu Meng, Cunticm de yu qiutian qing, 141; Yin Y i , Huishou canyangyi han shan, 75-76; Yin Jiliang, interview; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 242. Dai Huang describes how they devoured voles: "After work that day, we began to prepare these voles—skinning them, cutting open their bellies, and putting them in an iron washbasin. We got 81 in total. ... We put in water, mixed these voles with salt and chili powder, and boiled them. When they were cooked, we all devoured them very fast. ... When we could not find voles, we started to pick up raw corn to eat." However, searching for rats to eat sometimes was disapproved of by camp cadres. Yin Y i recalls that one of his fellow exiles caught rats to cook but was condemned by farm cadres for "trying to discredit socialism." Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 76. Huang Wu in his Mahuangtang waiji (25) and Wang Zheng in his "Menghui huangyuan" both recall Tang's excellent performance in catching snakes to make soup for his fellows. Hongda Harry Wu, an inmate in Qinghe camp, also describes how he caught hibernating snakes in the winter of 1961 and enjoyed theni himself. See Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 134-135. Philip Williams and Yenna Wu have noticed that Mao era prisoners often ate field mice, crickets, locusts, toads, grasshoppers, insect larvae and so on. See Williams and Wu, The Great Wall of Confinement, 90. In Beidahuang, however, the exiles mainly focused on field rats and snakes, which were bumper sources in the wilderness. 3 2 8  3 2 9  3 3 0  123  pot and ate them all with the soup. In the middle o f the night, however, he suffered terrible diarrhea and fever. The prompt arrival o f a camp doctor saved h i m from death.  331  Regarding Xingkaihu, an official  source admits that accidental death  frequently happened when inmates tried poisonous w i l d herbs. In the spring o f 1960, 13 convicts in Branch 4 died o f poisonous w i l d herbs.  332  When starvation and physical suffering was prolonged, exiles looked scarcely human even though they were still alive. D a i Huang recalls that due to a lack o f nutrition, "people i n my team became either badly emaciated or suffered terrible edema; night blindness, obtuseness, and suddenly falling down on the frozen ground became common occurrences."  333  When L i u Nanyuan chanced to look at himself i n  his campmate's mirror he was startled to confront a literal skeleton which he simply could not identity with himself. " B y early 1962, I was reduced to 90 pounds, about half o f my former body weight, literally a bag o f bones."  334  When Hongda Harry W u ,  himself a laojiao inmate, first met the inmates transferred from Xingkaihu to Qinghe labor camp in 1962, he was astonished:  The brow bones above their eyes protruded under tightly stretched skin. Their mouths hung slightly open below hollowed cheeks. Their gaunt necks seemed unnaturally long. Their blank faces gave no sign that they had noticed our arrival. 33  Driven by an empty stomach and obsessed with food, the exiles scarcely behaved as humans. In Beidahuang, they stole, robbed, and fought for food, which in turn not only escalated abuse by camp cadres, but also exacerbated their relationships with each other. A l l too often, they stole raw grains—rice, wheat and soybeans—from the fields. Chen Fengxiao recalls: Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun (Going towards Chaos) (Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chu banshe, 1998), 161. Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 404; Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 84. Some rightists in the Farm 850 found that garbage dumps close to farm cadres' living compounds might have chicken and fish bones or rotten vegetable. Dai Huang and some of his friends at times visited these garbage dumps. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 248, 259. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 173. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 261-262. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 114-115. 331  332  3 3 3  3 3 4 3 3 5  124  During the fall harvest o f this year (1960), it was very common that convicts i n Xingkaihu stole raw rice. ... W e pulled out grains off rice ears, scrubbed them i n our hands, blew away the shell, and chewed them carefully before swallowing, so we might avoid appendicitis. I was stealing rice too. M a n y o f us also snuck raw rice back to dormitories and ate it at night. 336  Sometimes they snuck into public kitchens to steal wotou, vegetables, or soup. In Y i n Y i ' s branch farm, when food i n the public kitchens was stolen, there was no way for farm cadres to determine guilt i f nobody was caught, since the rightists who thought o f nothing but their stomachs desperately defended their hard-come-by food. Some i n extreme hunger even stole food from their campmates. Y i n Y i himself had the experience o f having biscuits sent from his family in Beijing stolen.  337  " O f ten  rightists, nine were thieves," said L i u Meng. " I f you refused to lift something to eat in that circumstance, there would be only one way awaiting you—death." L i u M e n g confesses that he once stole ajar o f honey that his friends entrusted h i m to purchase from a nearby t o w n .  338  When their stomachs ruled their minds, their sense o f shame  was put aside. In army farms even though some were caught thieving, there was normally no punishment other than a harsh scolding; but in Xingkaihu, stealing from public kitchen could lead to severe punishment such as solitary confinement, as in the case o f Ren H o n g s u o .  339  L i Chao, a former university teacher, snuck out at night  to take swill to eat, for which he was publicly rebuked by a camp cadre as "less than a pig."  3 4 0  It was difficult for the political exiles to retain their integrity and self-  Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 88-89. Hongda Harry Wu also describes his personal experience in northern China. When he was confined in a labor camp, he was assigned to work delivering chemical powder within the camp area, which provided him an opportunity to pass a vegetable garden run by the camp police. He recounts: "Several times a day I would stare at the cabbages and cucumbers, warning myself not to take risk, but one night when I was hungerier than I had ever felt, the smell of cucumbers overwhelmed my caution. For the first time in my life, I stole... Four or five more times in the next two weeks I visited the police garden." Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 58-59. Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 66-67. Liu Meng, interview, and his Cuntian de yu qiutian qing, 134. Yin Y i , Huishou canyang yi han shan, 76. Han Dajun recalls, when interviewed, that his campmate Ren Hongshuo crept into a team kitchen at night trying to lift wotou but got caught in the act and was sent to solitary confinement. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 88. i i b  3 3 7  3 3 8  3 3 9  3 4 0  125  esteem when driven by the instinct for survival. Their experiences, like those in the Holocaust, reconfirm that human beings subject to horrible maltreatment w i l l do things they would not normally do. Philips Williams and Yenna W u note that "even well-educated P R C inmates would often jostle and fight with other prisoners over the little bit o f gruel left at the bottom o f the vat, and rummage through rubbish heaps i n search o f something edible."  341  This image, a reflection o f the C C P ' s long-term malnourishment and  mistreatment  o f this group o f educated people, is confirmed by events in  Beidahuang. Y i n Jiliang recalls,  M y friend M r . L i was one o f the most prestigious horticultural experts in China, but i n Xingkaihu he did not display any self-esteem at all. He often fought for food with others, just for a little bit gruel or a corn bun, for instance. H e was always the loser in the end as he was very thin. One day when he was i n charge o f distributing vegetable soup, he reserved for himself a bit more. A s the result, he was beaten black and b l u e " . 342  Obsessed with food, some rightists i n army farms even fought for a space watching over the dead i n the night i n order to earn one extra wotou.  343  Under the immense  pressure, Chinese intellectuals displayed a nature that is no different from that o f commoners or even abject people. Going through years o f hellish banishment, they increasingly lost status as role model for ordinary Chinese. While limiting the food supply, the authorities o f both the army farms and Xingkaihu made efforts to keep hunger and starvation at a minimum. In some camps, workdays were reduced to six hours, and no compulsory work quota was required.  344  The authorities also promoted various food substitutes (daishipiri) to counteract food shortages. In September 1960, the Mudanjiang Reclamation Bureau, the top army Williams and Wu, The Great Wall of Confinement, 91. Yin Jiliang, interview. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 260. Wu Yongliang remembers that in the fall of 1960 when he was transferred to the Branch One of Farm 850, he and his fellow exiles were allowed to workfromeight a.m. and to knock off at two p.m. to save energy. After a meal of thin gruel at five p.m. they all went to bed to sleep. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 139-140. 3 4 1 3 4 2 3 4 3  3 4 4  126  farm authority in Beidahuang, issued an instruction requiring the use o f corn stalks, wheat straw, sorghum stalks, oat straw, bean stalks, corncobs, acorns, grass seed, and tree leaves as food substitutes. Such substitutes, with very l o w starch, provide little nutrition and could obstruct the digestive s y s t e m .  345  In Xingkaihu, the camp  authorities ordered food substitutes o f raw rice or raw corn mixed with chaff for the convicts. They also promoted the method o f "double steam baking", to steam buns o f wheat, c o m , or sorghum twice i n order to add more bulk and to give the stomach a fuller f e e l i n g .  346  Finding that the rightists could hardly subsist on these food  substitutes and that there was no way to increase their grain rations, some sympathetic cadres i n army farms managed to purchase better food for the rightists through personal connections outside the farms.  347  In the worst period o f 1961, the  Qinghe labor camp announced a new initiative—allowing family members or relatives to deliver food parcels to the inmates—to show the Party's "revolutionary humanitarianism."  348  A l l o f these measures, however, turned out to be merely temporary relief in the context o f the massive man-made food shortage. With stringent food rations and a forced labor system in place, hunger continued in Beidahuang. Death—as the ultimate  consequence  o f starvation and  its  related malnutrition—eventually  descended upon these exiles.  Death and Death Watch Malnutrition, as the root cause o f the mass death o f exiles, manifested itself first i n forms o f related diseases, edema for instance. In Beidahuang, countless exiles (political and criminal) died o f edema, as well as from tuberculosis and fever,  Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao, 159. Wang Keqin's friend Mr. Du died of intestinal obstruction because of the coarseness of the food substitutes. Wang Keqin, interview. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 84-85. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 181. Dai recalls that one of his political instructors collected money from the rightists and managed to purchase biscuits and bean powder for them from elsewhere. However, that was an exception rather than a rule in the army farms. Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear: A Family's Persecution, Love and Endurance in Communist China (New York: The Atlantic Monthly Press, 1993), 131. 3 4 5  3 4 6  3 4 7  3 4 8  127  which were also the side effects of prolonged malnutrition. The primary symptom 349  of hunger was edema, as described by Hongda Harry Wu. For the first time I saw a person with one leg swollen and the other as thin as a stick. I began to recognize the symptoms of edema. First someone's foot would swell so that he could not wear his shoe. Slowly, the swelling would move up through the ankle, the calf, the knee, the thigh. When it reached the stomach and made breathing difficult, a person died quickly. 350  This terrible sight approximated the situation prevailing among the political exiles in Beidahuang. The first rightist documented as dying of starvation-induced edema was Tang Wehyi, who in June 1960 perished on the road after searching for food in a nearby farm with seriously swollen legs.  351  In his work Jiusi yisheng, Dai Huang  describes how six of his fellow exiles died of edema within a month in the fall of 1960. Some died on the road while searching for food, and some died at night after work.  352  It was very common for an edema-stricken inmate who had worked in the  fields in the daytime to be found dead in bed the next morning. In Xingkaihu, people also died of fever, diarrhea or dysentery caused by contaminated food and a lack of medical care. Mo Guixin, a famous singer who came back from the U.S. in 1951 to serve the New China, died of dysentery.  353  With  malnourishment and a lack of adequate medical care, diseases like dysentery were almost incurable. Yin Jiliang provides a gloomy scene of his own experience in Xingkaihu:  Seriously weakened by long-term hunger, according to the experiences of many inmates, their bodies were particularly susceptible to various diseases. The smallest cut brought tetanus, and a minor cold turned to tuberculosis, which could be fatal for the exiles in the wilderness. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 102. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 123. Dai Huang Jiusi yisheng, 244-247. Dai recounts that some rightists died in carrying chicken foods, millet for instance, while they themselves were denied these foods. Liu Naiyuan recalls that "Soon after the new prisoners settled down, No. 7 Branch Farm became epidemic of acute enterities, also said to be dysentery... practically all of the 200 plus inmates were affected and some died. Mo Guixin's case was not so bad at the beginning. He was one of the few who were hospitalized as a special favor. Before long he complained of belly ache which quickly worsened into acute agony. The doctor diagnosed gastric perforation and could do nothing." Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 226. 3 4 9  3 5 0 3 5 1  3 5 2  3 5 3  128  In the winter of 1961, agricultural work was rather light because of food shortages. During that period we got up at nine a.m. and went to bed at three p.m. to save energy. Two meals a day...That winter I fainted several times. One was on December 12th when I fell down on the way back from the fields. When I woke up I found myself in the mortuary. On that day, twelve of us fell unconscious, and only I came around. I remember clearly that day. At that time people died everyday like flies. For the people sent into the mortuary, few of them left alive. 354  Watching their campmates perish and be buried was a heartbreaking experience for many exiles. In October 1960, Luo Xiangcheng, a thin, sick rightist who was denied food by his team leader for his inability to work, died in Farm 850. His friend Dai Huang, who was with him at the end, recounts the emotional strain with great sadness. I fed Luo half of my lunch and carried him home on my back in the blizzard. But soon I found that I was so weak that my leg could not stop trembling. ... It was impossible for the two of us to return to our barracks. Luo said to me: 'Leave me behind, Dai, just go and save yourself." Nobody was around, so I put Luo by a heap of soybeans, covered him with pods and stumbled to a team barrack nearby for help....When we came back with lunch and a cart, Luo had lost consciousness, with his eyes closed and his lips blue. ... Three days afterwards Luo died. 355  Dai Huang was deeply traumatized by Luo's death, and by seeing many lives so needlessly snuffed out one after another. For political exiles, being asked to bury their campmates was also a heartbreaking experience, a form of torture through body disposal:  The bodies of the seven dead were put onto a cart, bound together with a single thick rope and then were sent to the Yunshan foothills. No body bag was provided for them, let alone coffins.... It was freezing cold and the blizzard was heavy. Those sent to bury the dead had no energy to dig graves at all.... Finally they found a natural depression, put in the bodies all 354 355  Yin Jiliang, interview.  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 239-240. A similar experience tortured Ba Hong when he saw his friend Mo Guixin for the last time at the medical center of Xingkaihu. "I called him again and again but he still could not recognize me even though his eyes were open... I had to leave for work. I knew that was probably the last time I could see him." Ba Hong, interview. 129  together, and piled on them a mound o f snow. That way a grave mound was made for the seven dead. N o mourning ceremony, no wreaths. When they left with great sadness, they only heard the swirling snow and howling wind that swept the white h i l l . 3  During the famine years, the dead were unlikely to get buried in a timely fashion either, especially during the winter season. I f convicts died in winter, authorities o f some branches o f Xingkaihu d i d not bother to make arrangements for a prompt burial, partly because it was too difficult to dig graves even though forced laborers could be used, and partly because the coldness o f the Manchurian borderland serves as an open freezer, so that the camp directors normally let corpses pile up outside for natural freezing.  If the stick-like frozen corpses accumulated to thirty or forty, they were to be sent by carts to the wilderness somewhere for disposal. The soil in winter was frozen so hard that it could not be dug up with spades or picks. In this situation, explosives were put into use. After a big pit was blasted, the cart drew close, and the bars were pulled out. When the carts were titled, all o f the bodies were dumped into the p i t . " 357  Some camp directors foresaw deaths i n the coming winter, and arranged preparation o f as many grave pits as possible in the warmer season. Former-movie director B a Hong and his fellow campmates spent several months digging graves on the Sun Mount (taiyang gang)  358  A daily quota o f three graves was set for each  worker i n his team. M o G u i x i n was among many who died in the freezing winter o f  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 233-234. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan (Allegorical Words: The Bitter Sacrificial Altar) (Guangzhou: Guangdong luyou chubanshe, 1998), 665. The Sun Mount, notorious for being the main graveyard for countless dead in Xingkaihu but ironically given an impressive name, is a water-made ridge at the north end of the Xingkai Lake. Ever since the establishment of the Xingkaihu labor complex, and especially during the three bad years of 1959-1962, numerous inmates died and were buried there. The side of the mount that faces the Xingkai Lake was thickly dotted with numerous graves, some of which were placed a small stone or wooden tablet with the words "the grave of X X X " . When deaths increased rapidly, the camp authorities did not bother to make tablets; instead, they simply used red bricks with the names of the dead written in chalk stick. After a rain shower, the words in chalk were washed away, and the dead became unknown. The Sun Mount was synonymous with death in Xingkaihu labor reform complex since the early 1960s. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 157-158; Liu Junying, interview. 3 5 6  3 5 7  3 5 8  130  1959 and was buried in a grave that Ba Hong's team had prepared in advance. The lack of medical care was another contributing factor to death. In Xingkaihu, one or two camp doctors, normally inmates too, were responsible for medical services for one branch, or approximately 2,000 to 3,000 inmates. Although they were helpful and saved lives, as indicated by Liu Naiyuan, in many cases they could hardly provide timely medical care. Han Dajun recalls that "in the summer of 1958, our whole living quarters were infested with flies and serious gastroenteritis spread. The only doctor in our branch did nothing to help us since there was simply no proper medicine at all. People died one after another like flies."  360  In army farms,  while doctors were dedicated and helpful to the rightists, as experienced by Dai Huang, some farm cadres did not take human life seriously and were slow to provide the necessary rescue, as evidenced in the Yunshan death of October 13, I960.  361  In  Qinghe farm of North China, according to Hongda Harry Wu, inmates who had reached an advanced stage of starvation would be sent to a different compound, which was named the "Prison Patient Recovery Center." Four medical workers were employed there. However, "their primary job was not to treat our illness, as they had no medicine to dispense, but to report which prisoners drew close to death and then to record the cause of death in the person's file."  362  Death records of the political exiles in Xingkaihu are lacking. The main reason is that neither Chinese police organs in Beijing nor the Xingkaihu authorities are willing to disclose Xingkaihu  detailed information about prisoners' death.  In the Gazetteer of  Farm compiled in 1988, details of natural calamities and difficulties  Xingkaihu confronted are provided, in terms of the amount of crops destroyed, financial deficits the camp suffered, and even the death toll of pigs and chickens; but there are no definitive death figures for the inmates who died during the famine Ba Hong, interview. Han Dajun, interview. Whereas Han Dajun complained about the poor performance of his camp doctor in Branch 7, Liu Naiyuan was grateful to his camp doctor Li in Branch 8 as he saved Liu's life when Liu contemplated suicide through an intentional effort to contract pneumonia by catching cold. See Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 246^247. See Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 210-211, 231. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 116. 3 5 9 3 6 0  3 6 1  3 6 2  131  While official records are lacking, individual accounts—narratives by political prisoners about the death around them—give insight to the severity o f death i n various labor camps. Chen Fengxiao recalls that among the 75 convicts who were sent to Team One o f Branch Four in Xingkaihu i n A p r i l 1959, only 29 were still alive i n January 1967 when Xingkaihu was disbanded; the majority o f the others died i n the years o f 1960 and 1 9 6 1 .  364  Regarding the death toll o f rightists in the army farms, official statistics are highly dubious and inconsistent. While the gazetteer o f Farm 850 states that "during the serious famine period o f 1959-60, 8 rightists i n all the farms died o f edema," the gazetteer o f its Yunshan Branch indicates 10 deaths i n this b r a n c h .  365  A l l these  figures are contested by rightist inmates. According to Yang Congdao, from M a y to November o f 1960 alone, 29 Beijing rightists, whose names are recorded by Yang, died o f starvation and related illness i n Yunshan.  366  The official figures o f death on  the farm seem to be dramatically underestimated. The deaths o f rightists can be compared with the mass deaths i n the Beidahuang army farms in general. Its severity was disclosed i n a self-criticism In Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, the most comprehensive description regarding the impact of the famine upon human beings reads as following: "With the decrease of grain and bean output brought about by natural calamities, hunger severely threatened people's heath. Edema, night blindness and malnutrition happened successively. Grain rations had to be reduced and non-staple foods decreased. People tried all means to fill their stomach ...Ten people died of poisonous wild herbs. In particular, the death rate of the elderly and weak convicts increased." Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 403-404. The perceptible ambiguity and omission of important statistics make this narrative less than reliable. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 90. In his unpublished recollection "Xingkaihu jishi" (Stories of Xingkaihu), Chen estimates that of the 200—250 convicts in the same team, no less than 50 died in the three famine years. Bawuling nongchangshi bianxie bangongshi, Bawuling nongchangshi (Gazetteer of the Farm 850) (Hulin, Heilongjiang: No pub, 1986), 31; Yunshan nongchang shizhi bangongshi, Yunshan nongchangshi (Gazetteer of the Yunshan Farm) (Jiamusi: No pub.,1995), 5. Yang Congdao, "Bawuling Yunshan xumuchang liuren feizhengchang siwang mingdan" (The List of the Abnormal Deaths in Yunshan Branch of the Farm 850—unpublished note). Besides an apparent underestimation of the death toll, the method the farm authorities used to interpret death is also highly problematic. According to Yang Congdao, who in 1960 was in paid secretarial service for the farm and part of whose work was to write reports of deaths in Farm 850, the farm leaders ordered the use of terms "edema," "tuberculosis," "intestinal obstruction" and "diarrhea" to explain the cause of deaths. So the impression was created that the deaths were caused by various diseases rather than starvation. Yang Congdao, interview. 3 6 3  3 6 4  3 6 5  3 6 6  132  report by the Mudanjiang Reclamation Bureau, as submitted to the Ministry of Land Reclamation in 1961. While the reliability of the statistics the report provides is hard to identify, it reveal something about death in the whole land reclamation region of eastern Heilongjiang. The report reads: "from October of last year (1960) to February of this year (1961), 491 staff, workers and their families in our reclamation region died for abnormal reasons... 68 died of edema, 190 of edema combined with other chronic diseases, 133 of coldness, hunger, food poisoning and intestinal obstruction, 70 of reasons unknown."  This report did not specify the death rate of  the Beijing rightists. It should be noted that despite invaluable accounts, most of those with direct experience of banishment find it difficult to pinpoint the precise death toll of those around them, let alone in the broader sphere, which makes accurate calculation of death during banishment almost impossible. When interviewed, Tan Tianrong, Yin Jiliang, Liu Meng, Zheng Xiaofeng and others expressed their inability to accurately assess death rates in their team, although they did provide a vivid account of everyday happenings in their farm/camp. Living in a specific location and overwhelmed by human woes, they were hardly cognizant of anything beyond their direct world, or as Paul Cohen puts it, individual participants in historical events "do not have the entire event" in their minds. In both Xingkaihu and the army farms, 368  when death became perfectly normal, an inmate did not even know whether his cellmates were alive or dead, or he himself might live in a state of paralysis. When Shen Mojun was sent to the medical center of Farm 850 for edema, he could not remember how many dead were removed or how many new patients were brought in; his wardmates experienced the same numbness. Just as Harry Wu described his 369  labor camp experience in Qinghe, Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao, 161. It is reasonable to speculate that the deaths of political offenders in Beidahuang labor reform regime were not the most serious among the labor reform camps in Manchuria. According to journalist Dai Huang, by the end of 1960, 1001 of more than 1200 inmate laborers died of starvation in Jinxi laogai coal mine in Liaoning, and the survivors ate frogs, grasshoppers and butterflies. See Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 266. Paul Cohen, History in Three Keys: The Boxers as Event, Experience, and Myth (New York: Columbia University Press, 1997), 61. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 250. 3 6 7  3 6 S  3 6 9  133  Inside the 585 barracks it became more difficult to distinguish the dead from the living. At a glance there seemed no difference. Much of the day and night we lay in a state of near stupor. No longer did we pay attention when someone reached the end and went into last gasps or tremors... The only sign that a prisoner had died was that he failed to sit up at mealtime... I don't know how many sick prisoners died that October. I don't even know how many died in my squad. The number in my room fluctuated too much to keep track. Dead bodies went out and live bodies came in almost daily. I 370  paid no attention. I never even learned their names. In the circumstance where death became daily routine, the death rate seemed meaningless to the exiles, and awareness of death likely gave away to the concern for self—those who were still alive. Physical Abuse  The most serious physical abuse suffered by political exiles in Beidahuang occurred in the Xingkaihu labor complex. As for the rightists in the army farms, so far there have been no recollections indicating physical torture, although many remember that those who could not finish their work targets were at times denied food or rest by some farm cadres. In Xingkaihu, there was a differentiation in terms of the severity of physical abuse between those in labor reeducation branches  (laojiao)  and those in labor  reform branches (laogai). For labor reeducation inmates, physical abuse seemed less pervasive because their civil rights had not been taken away and they were still under admimstrative discipline rather than criminal sanction. Tan Tianrong recalls that in the labor reeducation branch where he stayed those who suffered physical beatings were mainly those who stubbornly refused to "draw close to the government" (kaolong zhengfu) and those who did not get along well with their Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 122-123. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 197-198. Wu Yongliang recalls that in Yunshan, certain heavy but meaningless work, such as transporting wood planks on one's back for long distances, was particularly designed as punishment for the rightists who were believed to be less dedicated to remolding themselves through labor, as enforced by his farm cadre Zhu. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 56-57. 3 7 0 3 7 1  134  campmates. "I did not show much activism i n drawing close to the government but I got along well with others i n my team. So I never suffered a physical beating."  372  Since camp cadres could not always dominate the lives o f inmates, getting along well with other inmates, especially the duty inmate, might free a political offender from physical abuse. The recollections o f other labor reeducation inmates such as L i u Naiyuan, W u Ningkun and H a n Dajun do not indicate physical abuse either. Corporal punishment i n labor reform branches (laogai), however, was much more common, as experienced by Chen Fengxiao and L i u Qidi. It was mainly imposed upon those who showed disobedience towards the camp cadres, to inflict physical pain through which to break one's spirit.  373  According to Chen Fengxiao,  physical punishment was imposed when camp cadres wanted to resolve discipline problems, to crush the w i l l o f inmates or to extort confessions. When a convict behaved or spoke defiantly against an individual cadre, physical abuse was also very likely to happen. Corporal punishment included the use o f handcuffs, leg irons, tiger benches, cigarette burning and placing victims in solitary confinement cells. The suffering o f Chen Fengxiao, featured i n Chapter Three, reveals how brutal physical abuse could b e .  374  Another case is L i u Q i d i , who was sentenced to 15 years for defending the literary dissident H u Feng. When L i u was sent to Branch 5, Xingkaihu, in 1961, according to his campmate M e n g Fuwu, he was very i l l and often coughed up blood. Tan Tianrong, interview. Physical punishment has been officially forbidden in China. See "Zhonghua fenmin gongheguo laodong gaizao tiaoli" (Regulations of the PRC on Reform through Labor), in Guowuyuan fazhiju, ed., Zhonghua renmin gongheguo xianxing falu xingzheng fagui huibian (The Comprehensive Collection of Current Laws and Administrative Regulations of the PRC) (Beijing: Zhongguo falu chubanshe, 1995), 66, However, the same document stipulates that in some situations the jieju (disciplinary equipment) could be used when it is necessary to preempt insurrections of convicts. See Ibid, 68. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 52, 86, 109; 129-130. Certain disciplinary measures, including use of handcuffs and leg irons, were permitted by the Ministry of Public Security. According to its "Guanyu dui fanren shiyong jieju de tongzhi" (Instructions on the use of disciplinary equipment on convicts) enacted on January 29, 1957, however, the use of handcuffs and leg irons was not allowed to exceed one week. See Wang Mingdi, et al., Zhongguo yuzheng falu wenti yanjiu (Studies on Legal Problems in Prison Administration of China) (Beijing: Zhongguo zhengfa daxue chubanshe, 1995), 51. Chen Fengxiao's experience indicates, however, that in Xingkaihu laogai branches the use of such equipment could exceed one month. See Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 86. 3 7 3  3 7 4  135  Because of his obstinate attitude toward admitting his "crime," Liu was hung up and beaten many times by camp police. After numerous bouts of torture, Liu had a mental breakdown and was put in solitary confinement where he died.  Solitary  confinement, in a small concrete cell, was used to punish intractable prisoners. The cell in Xingkaihu, according to Chen Fengxiao, was about one meter tall and wide, and 1.5 meters long. According to Hongda Harry Wu, the one he saw was about six feet long, three feet wide, and three feet high, slightly larger than a coffin. Locked in this tiny cell, one was unable to sit or stand or lay down in a comfortable position; one had to take food with the mouth, and lie trapped in one's own excrement.  376  The exposure of inmates to mosquitoes was another source of physical abuse. In the marshland of Xingkaihu, the mosquitoes were allegedly more poisonous than those in other parts of Beidahuang. Flying swiftly in swarms, they became a major source of distress for those who worked in the fields, since "any area of exposed skin would be soon blackened with a layer of mosquitoes."  377  Wang Jinquan, a  historical counterrevolutionary in Branch 4, was victimized by this inhuman treatment. Because he spoke back to the camp police, he was tied up and thrown into a ditch that was full of grass. When he was released at evening after work, Wang was found bitten almost to death by mosquitoes, his white prisoner clothes bloodstained and his whole face swollen. Three days afterwards, Wang died.  378  Since inmate beating was (and is) officially forbidden in China, camp cadres in Xingkaihu tried to deal with the inmates they disliked in more insidious ways, for instance, instigating a group of prisoners to beat up the targets. When a convict was believed to be insufficiently deferential, a cadre might order other prisoners to "give Chen Fengxiao, unpublished essay "Nanwang de jiyi" (Unforgettable Memories), 3. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 86; Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 180-182. Kate Saunders in her Eighteen Layers of Hell describes the experience of a juvenile offender who was put into a cage. This kind of cage, which measured 2.5 meters by 1 meter and held twenty people, was certainly more horrible than solitary confinement used in Xingkaihu and northern China in terms of its crowdedness. See Saunders, Eighteen Layers of Hell: Stories from the Chinese Gulag, 20. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 238. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 70. At times, inmates abused each other by the means of exposure to mosquitoes. Liu Naiyuan tells a story about how an unpopular labor reeducation inmate was stripped, tied up and left outdoors by his campmates for the night. "The next morning they went out to release him, when he was already breathless, swollen all over beyond recognition." Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 239. 3 7 5  3 7 6  3 7 7  3 7 8  136  him a lesson," or "give him a help'Xbangzhu ta). Then his minions would j u m p at the v i c t i m .  379  Y i n Jiliang said that i n his branch camp, the camp cadres never beat  inmates themselves but always instigated others to do it. After having instigated the abuse, the cadre would normally leave i n order not to take responsibility i f the target was badly injured or beaten to death.  380  Suicide Even before they were banished, intellectuals in Beijing used suicide as a means to protest their persecution or to avoid further persecution. In June 1957, when the Anti-Rightist Campaign had just started, Q i X u e y i , a journalist o f the Beijing Daily, killed himself i n public by suddenly jumping from the fourth floor o f the assembly hall where a meeting to condemn L i u Binyan was being conducted. H i s suicide was explained by the anti-rightist activists as "sacrificing himself for the rightists" and "choosing to alienate himself from the people."  381  Q i is among the  first ones known to die symbolically as a protest against the Anti-Rightist Campaign. When labeled a bourgeois rightist and thus treated as a class enemy, individuals were torn by a question—to live or to die, since one could not predict the political pressure and hostile environment generated afterwards. Those who were relatively optimistic chose to live and went to labor camps to redeem themselves; those who were pessimistic chose to die or contemplated death in order to avoid further torment. A t Peking University, a history professor D i n g Zeliang drowned himself in  Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 28. Yin Jiliang, interview. Liu Binyan, Liu Binyan zizhuan (Autobiography of Liu Binyan) (Taibei: Shibao wenhua chuban qiye youxian gongsi, 1989), 110. Cong Weixi recalls that "when the high pitch of condemnation echoed around the hall, a man a couple of rows in front of me suddenly stood up. Before I realized what would happen, he quickly dashed onto the balcony of the fourth floor and jumped down like a diver...Blood! I saw red blood when I looked out. I covered my eyes and had no guts to see anymore... Then I heard someone shout downstairs: "This guy sacrificed himself for rightist Liu Binyan." Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 5-6. 3 7 9  3 8 0 3 8 1  137  W e i m i n g Lake near the university campus when he heard his designation as a rightist.  382  For many labeled as rightists who had the courage to continue their lives, life was sheer torture, and some attempted committing suicide then. "It is better to die than live," an ex-doctor Ye Songtao told his friend Wang Zhiliang, who saved h i m from suicide. After Ye had been labeled and forced to do cleaning work, almost anyone i n his work unit could punch him, scold him and spit on him at w i l l . H e was asked to live i n a cell right next to an X-ray room, from which he contracted blood cancer. He did not know how to survive the ordeal.  383  B i Fangfang, an former junior  researcher at the Chinese Academy o f Science, also tried to die by swallowing sleeping pills before she was sent to Beidahuang.  384  For the exiles i n Beidahuang, when the sense o f isolation and humiliation was hard to overcome, when bad news arrived from their families, or when they found incessant political pressure or physical hardship i n labor camps  insurmountable,  many chose suicide. The death o f Tong Aicheng, D a i Huang's campmate, had its roots i n his deep desperation and sadness. After he was sent to Farm 850, his wife divorced him and left their two children without proper care i n Beijing. Tong did not have sufficient money to support them from his 32 yuan R M B allowance, and there was no way he could return to take care o f them. A n unbearable workload also daunted him. In the end, Tong hung himself on a tree after w o r k .  385  Another rightist who committed suicide i n Farm 850 was an overseas Chinese who returned to serve the motherland when the " N e w C h i n a " was established. Driven by hunger in Beidahuang, he wrote to his father i n Britain to ask for milk powder, for which he was repeatedly condemned by farm cadres as "having disgraced the socialist motherland." In the conviction that "a gentlemen prefers Zhang Jiqian, interview. According to Zhang (Ding Zeliang's colleague), Ding, as a former CCP member, had quit the Party before its victory in 1949, and thus was severely condemned in various political campaigns in the early 1950s. Grave fear of being "struggled" again seems to be the root cause of his suicide. Wang Zhiliang, interview. Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 5. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 192-193. 3 8 2  3 8 3  3 8 4  3 8 5  138  death to humiliation," he drowned himself at n i g h t /  80  Some exiles committed suicide after being badly humiliated and physically abused i n labor camps. Y i n Jiliang recalls, In a job placement camp at Suiling, I had a campmate, M r . Q i , who was a very knowledgeable person. There was once a famous saying "The East W i n d Prevails over the West W i n d , " which was considered as coming from Chairman M a o and having strong anti-imperialist undertones. One day Q i pointed out i n casual talk that this saying originally came from a classic novel the Dream of Red Chamber, for which he was accused for viciously attacking the great leader. He was forced to make endless selfcondemnations i n struggle sessions for more than twenty days. One day, when he was ordered to stand on a discipline bench facing the audience and to condemn himself, one activist dashed into him, slapped him on his face and kicked over the bench. He fell down heavily and his glasses were cast off. W i t h a bleeding mouth, he crawled on the ground fumbling for his glasses. He could not see anything, and nobody went up to help him. Several days later, he committed suicide by cutting his stomach Open with a sickle, probably in the hope to die as quickly as possible.... H i s body was thrown into the swamp without b u r i a l . 38  One case o f suicide was distinguished from many others. L i n Cheng, a laojiao inmate as well as a medical graduate, chose to die i n defense o f his self-esteem that he highly valued. A s a labor camp doctor, L i n was often asked to provide medical services for camp cadres, for which he was offered benefits other inmates could hardly dream of—a single room, special meals and an exemption from manual labor. The hunger and abuse experienced by others did not bother h i m either. Although his expertise made his life easier, L i n Cheng was deeply sickened by the humiliation o f intellectuals i n Xingkaihu. One day on his medicare tour to the fields, he ended his anguish by cutting open an artery with a scalpel.  Suicide turned out to be the last  means for L i n to show his resentment and protest against an inhuman world.  Three points can serve as a conclusion for this chapter. The first is that the political offenders in Beijing were banished to Beidahuang during the Great Leap Ibid, 247. Yin Jiliang, interview. Cong Weixi, Zuoxiang hundun, 164; Ba Hong, interview.  139  Forward period o f 1958-59, and stayed there through the worst time o f the great famine i n the early  1960s. The intensive forced labor and starvation that  characterized these two stages o f the P R C history also inevitably constituted dual threats for these hapless exiles, making their lives extremely miserable. The second is that, authorities o f the labor reform regime (in Xingkaihu as well as the army farms) tended to show their commitment to the Party's Great Leap policies and strove to fulfill or surpass designated production targets i n particular, which made manual labor i n Beidahuang sheer physical tortures. Their devotion to the state i n terms o f "saving grains and supporting the country" spelt a dramatic reduction o f the food supply for their own workers, including the political exiles. The local activism o f the labor reform regime exacerbated human suffering and entailed a heavy loss o f life there. The third is that the political exiles i n Beidahuang, as i n other parts o f China, were deemed antagonists  o f the Party and socialism, and were thus deeply  demonized. A n y maltreatment, including physical abuse, depersonalization and undernourishment o f this underclass was generally not seen as excessive. It was unlikely that any lenient treatment that was conferred on other farm workers was extended to them. In times o f economic hardship, they were the last group to receive humane care.  140  Chapter Five Looking for a Way Out: the Inner World of the Political Exiles Xixin gemian, tuotai huangu To change one's heart and face, and thoroughly remold oneself (traditional Chinese proverb)  Political exiles i n Beidahuang were tortured by harsh physical conditions, heavy workloads and prolonged hunger, and maltreated by labor reform authorities. Sources show, however, that at the same time they were also victimized and traumatized by their sincere efforts to pursue self-redemption and ideological advancement. This chapter shows how the political exiles, especially the rightists in the army farms, adopted the Party's ideology and were submissive to the labor reform arrangements. While feeling wronged and sad, the majority o f the rightists still expressed loyalty to the governing party, and showed endorsement for the Party's policy o f reform through labor i n particular. This chapter w i l l also examine internecine strife among the persecuted and banished. In order to survive, to show their commitment to reform through labor, and to be released early, some political exiles reported and denounced their fellow exiles, betrayed their friends, and tried hard to eliminate their rivals at the instigation of  the  authorities.  The political  exiles were  unable  to  develop collective  consciousness i n face o f a repressive regime. Loss o f conscience was tremendous and trauma deep i n later years.  Commitment to Labor Reform When the Anti-Rightist Campaign came to an end and the fate o f the rightists was sealed, the feelings o f those labeled were complex. W h i l e many were feeling sad, disgruntled and depressed for being wronged, many sincerely acknowledged their "sin." The long-lasting indoctrination they had received convinced them that it must be individuals rather than the Party that committed faults or made mistakes,  141  and individuals had to search their souls for what was wrong with them. Many of the persecuted, therefore, admitted the charges against them at least in public. Lu Gang, who was once sent to the Hulan farm of Heilongjiang, recalls, I was trying to positively understand the significance of the campaign even if I was given a hard time. An editorial of the People's Daily stated that the rightists were the running-dogs of the western imperialists. Through a hard ideological struggle in my mind, I eventually realized that during the Hundred Flower period I did speak for the interest of the imperialists. Like me, the majority of my fellow rightists admitted that we were wrong and the Anti-Rightist Campaign was right... With this belief in mind, all of us worked very hard in the farm." 389  Some rightists who had had experience in dealing with the C C P quickly admitted their "crimes" in order to avoid more trouble, such as the case of Zhang Bqjun; but many others were sincere.  390  The post campaign propaganda and mass  criticism were so powerful that they created a climate that made those labeled dig into their very souls to such an extent that they finally realized they were truly wrong—they had been poisoned by bourgeois ideas and degenerated in to anti-Party elements, and their criticisms during the Hundred Flower period were reactionary in nature. With this self-abasing mentality, many admitted that they deserved the punishment imposed on them.  391  Lu Gang, interview. Mr. Gu recalls that "at that time I was really convinced that I fell short of the expectations of the Party and committed faults; it was right for the Party to brand me as a rightist because I wrote down something harmful to the Party. Stripping me of my Party membership meant the purification of the Party. I was willing to accept it. So I did not hold a grudge against either the Party or the people who designated me asrightist."Mr. Gu, interview. Wang Zheng also says that he and his fellow exiles in the Farm 853 tried hard to cultivate the "correct understanding" of the AntiRightist Campaign all the time. See Liu Meng, ed., Lishi zai shenpan (Retrial by History) (Chengdu: Sichuan renmin chubanshe, 1996), 342. As a toprightist,Zhang Bojun later explained his submission to the false accusation against him as trying to make a quick end to the campaign and to save others from being implicated. See Zhang Yihe, Wangshi bingbu ruyan (Do not Let Bygones be Bygones) (Beijing: Renmin wenxue chubanshe, 2004), 291. It is difficult to pinpoint how many Beidahuang exiles had this mentality, but some such as Wang Zheng and Huang Miaozi clearly revealed this point in their memoirs. Some felt a degree of grievance for being labeled though, but still recognized the necessity of changing their world outlook (shijieguan). See Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan (The Setting of the Sun over the Mountain) (Beijing: Shiyue wenyi chubanshe, 2003), 27. 3 8 9  3 9 0  3 9 1  142  Many rightists continued stating their commitment to the Communist Party, and the revolutionary cause. Lu Gang says: "Although I was labeled a rightist, I was absolutely loyal and submissive to the Communist Party and Chairman Mao." Dai Huang, too, had similar faith. He convinced himself that "even being insulted and humiliated, we should still pump up our revolutionary spirit, to enrich and improve ourselves with this brand new life, and to seek for light in darkness." In the labor team where Dai lived, "even though many of us had been expelled from the Party, we still saw the Party as our mother." Ding Ling recalls in her memoir that when they first arrived in Beidahuang, "my husband Chen Ming and I agreed that we should stick to our belief and ethics as communists, to ignore what we had suffered, to share weal and woe, and to break a new path in the cold northern frontier of our motherland."  This statement perhaps should be treated as real feelings rather  than affectation. The acknowledgement of their faults and their continuing endorsement to the Party led to their positive attitudes toward labor reform. The rightists sent to Beidahuang were led to believe that they needed to take labor reform as an opportunity to wash away their evil thinking, to achieve political and ideological perfection, and to reach spiritual growth; sending them to physical labor in a difficult location was a necessary measure the Party designed to save them through trials and tribulations. Thus some such as Huang Miaozi and Ding Cong "happily" accepted the imposed labor reform when asked to go.  393  This attitude is perhaps related to Mao's promise of benevolent treatment of the rightists. In a speech made on October 13, 1957, for instance, Mao asserted that the rightists "are a antagonist force. But we do not treat them as landlords or counterrevolutionaries; let them remold themselves through labor... once they have rectified themselves, they would be allowed to return to the rank of the people."  394  Lu Gang, interview; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng: wo de youpai licheng (A Narrow Escape from Death: My Experience as a Rightist) (Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, 1998), 96, 122; Ding Ling, Fengxue renjian (The Blizzard World) (Xiamen: Xiamen daxue chubanshe, 1987), 4. Huang Miaozi, Huang Miaozi sanwen (The Prose of Huang Miaozi) (Guangzhou: Huacheng chubanshe, 1998), 200. Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji (Selected Works of Mao Zedong) (Beijing: Remin chubanshe, 3 9 2  3 9 3  3 9 4  143  An announcement of this sort was instrumental in calming down the frustrated rightists and letting them readily accept labor reform. Therefore, some rightists sang the Hymn of Communist Youth League on the journey to Beidahuang.  395  Even  realizing that laboring in the wilderness was a punishment, many treated it positively. Arriving in Beidahuang, accordingly, considerable numbers of the Beijing rightists showed high enthusiasm and activism in the manual work assigned to them. Sources available so far overwhelmingly point to this, even though some counter proofs exist. Huang Miaozi recalls that in order to construct a reservoir that was designed to be dedicated to the 3 7  th  anniversary of the Party, he and his fellow  rightists tirelessly worked for a week almost without rest.  3 9 6  For the banished  intellectuals in Dai Huang's team, work in a hydraulic project and grass-cutting was daunting, and living conditions were appalling, "but none of us complained; we all labored hard cheerfully;" some even demanded more work that was not assigned to them, with their laboring process accompanied with joyful work songs.  397  From the recollections of these rightists, it seems that labor in army farms and labor camps was not only enforced by the powers that be but was also self-imposed. Some extolled their lives in the army farms and the labor that they engaged in. For instance, Huang Miaozi in his letters home positively described the sent-down life and job satisfaction that the physical labor brought to him.  It is reasonable to  assume that in the case of Beidahuang, forced labor imposed by the authorities on one side and the rightists' commitment to labor reform (at least during the early period) on the other were two props to the forced labor arrangements. The high morale of the rightists collapsed later mainly because they were worn down by the 1977), Vol. 5, 491. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 95. L i Hui, Ren zai xuanwo: Huang Miaozi yu Yu Feng (People in the Eddy: Huang Miaozi and Yu Feng) (Jinan: Shandong huabao chubanshe, 1998), 298-299. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 121; Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 36; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei: Beidahuang shenghuo jishi (Floating Rain and Snow: True Stories of Life in the Great Northern Wilderness) (Beijing: Zhongguo xiju chubanshe, 2002), 40. This work enthusiasm was also manifested in labor reeducation camps. In Cong Weixi's labor team, some rightists even refused to take a rest when they were injured or fell ill. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 139. L i Hui, Renzai xuanwo, 310-311. Huang also stated that through physical labor and the major changes it brought about, he realized that "labor create the world; only under the leadership of the Party could the wilderness turn to metropolis and poverty to richness." 3 9 5  3 9 6  3 9 7  3 9 8  144  prolonged daunting work and food shortages during the famine years. The degree to which the rightists were committed to serious ideological remolding varied during their banishment. Memoirs of Yin Y i , Wu Yongliang and Liu Meng mention little about their consciousness or effort in self-remolding. However, letters of Huang Miaozi reveal his piousness in "digging deep to very soul." In a political session of "opening one's heart to the Party," Huang made a confession about his "dirty and evil mind" such as hoping to return to Beijing soon, a lack of interest in agricultural technique, holding grudges against certain farm cadres, etc. Huang stated in a letter that "I have always achieved ideological growth through such sessions. It is worthwhile to do the self-exploration although I feel bitter going through it." This mindset was by no mean cooked up due to the fact that after being restored Huang frankly admitted that "these thoughts came from my heart indeed."  399  Cong Weixi believes, however, that this soul-searching was actually an adaptation to the surroundings in which the rightists was situated.  In study sessions, all of the rightists expressed with earnest faces that they would sincerely correct their rightist thinking and standpoints. This piousness did not necessarily involve any affectation. Once situated in that environment, it seemed we truly sensed our guilt and crimes. With everybody trying to get a word in, our self-examinations and selfcriticisms were profound and deep. 400  Sincere as these expressions sounded, there were something fishy behind them. Behind their efforts were the rightists' attempts to impress the farm authorities with their dedication to labor reform and, consequently, their hope to redeem themselves. With the physical environment so harsh, the work so daunting and their families left far behind, the rightists by no mean intended to remain in Beidahuang any longer than they had to, despite their heated rhetoric. As indicated in Chapter Two, when  Li Hui, Renzai xuartwo, 312, 324. In 1997, Huang told the writer of his biography Li Hui that "in retrospect this self-cheating expression was only cure for the wound when human nature and feelings were deformed." Li Hui, Renzai xuanwo, 324. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 42.  4 0 0  145  the rightists left Beijing, many were told or given hints by the bosses of their work units that their stay in the wilderness would be likely a short period if they showed a good performance in labor reform. In Beidahuang, speeches of farm cadres also followed the line of "removal of your 'hats' and return to Beijing depends on your performance in work."  401  Trying to redeem themselves by good work in Beidahuang, the rightists hoped their efforts,  as a sign of repentance,  self-renewal,  devotion and political  progressiveness, would be appreciated, and consequently their banishment would be shortened  4 0 2  Liang Nan recalls, "the vast majority of the labeled labored with all  their might, even ventured their lives, in order to get their 'hats' removed and to improved their situation...I was not an exception either." Some, such as Ding Cong, expected that they would probably be called back in a year or two.  403  Their  dedication to physical labor, blending with their practical calculations, precisely reflected their desire to terminate the labor reform. The mentality of the laojiao inmates in Xingkaihu seemed similar to that of rightists in the army farms, but was not exactly the same. When they were rounded up by police and sent to labor reeducation, no fixed period of internment was announced. Although their penalty spelled forced labor, the camp authorities also stated that their detention period depended on their individual performances, and that whoever labored hard and behaved well could be released earlier than others. Therefore inmates such as Han Dajun and Wu Ningkun spared none of their strength, "hoping like everybody else that my exertion at physical labor would put me in the  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 158; Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 53. Exceptions existed, however, in the case of Ding Ling, for instance. She did not make much effort to leave Beidahuang even though an opportunity appeared later; rather she and her husband Chen Ming seemed to be satisfied with life there, and, in her words, "tried to make a new start in the wilderness." As will be indicated in Chapter Six, She and Chen Ming went on living in Beidahuang army farms until 1966 when the Red Guards put them into incarceration. See Liu Meng, ed., Huishou rensheng (Reflections on Our Life) (Beijing. Shidai wenyi chubanshe, 1992), 2; Xin Suwei, Ding Cong zhuan (Biography of Ding Cong) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 1993), 187. Liu Meng recalls: "No sooner had we arrived than we started to hope to return to our original work units." See Liu Meng, Chuntian deyu qiutian qing (The Whisking of Rain in Spring, the Clearing Skies in Autumn) (Beijing: Zhongguo gongren chubanshe, 2003), 96. 4 0 1  4 0 2  4 0 3  146  good graces of the officers and bring closer the day of release." " 4  4  The key issue here is admitting crimes (renzui). In the Chinese tradition, Confucian  doctrine  emphasized  self-examination  or  introspection  (zixing).  Willingness to examine self thrice a day (san xing wu sheri) was in theory a criterion to show oneself a gentleman (junzi). In Communist's labor camps, "crimeconsciousness" was a major criterion of virtue by which to judge the inmates' behavior. Oral recognition of crime was necessary but far from enough. One had to convince the camp authorities of one's "crime-consciousness"  with a good  performance in work, since, as Liu Naiyuan recalls, camp cadres always linked physical labor with sincerity in admitting one's faults and even "identified desperate physical exertion with a proof of such sincerity"; those with poor work records were singled out for condemnation  4 0 5  Under tremendous pressure, political inmates in  laojiao camps tried to show camp authorities their good performance.  406  The problem arose that the work the political exiles engaged in was exactly what they were not good at. Many branded as rightists and counterrevolutionaries had for long before their banishment been engaged in academic or managerial work as writers, teachers, journalists, scientists, engineers, officials, clerks, etc. Tilling land, cutting trees or digging earth was not their expertise, even though they tried Han Dajun, interview; Wu Ningkuri, A Single Tear: A Family's Persecution, Love and Endurance in Communist China (New York: The Atlantic Monthly Press, 1993), 89. Han and Wu's narratives were confirmed by an official document, the Resolution on Reeducation through Labor promulgated in August 1957. According to the resolution, "The labor reeducation personnel could be reassigned to other jobs with the approval of labor reeducation organizations, provided that they behave well during the period of labor reeducation." See, Guowuyuan fazhiju, ed., Zhonghua renmin gongheguo xianxing falu xingzheng fagui huibian (The Comprehensive Collection of Current Laws and Administrative Regulations of the PRC) (Beijing: Zhongguo falu chubanshe, 1995), 104. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror: A Loss of Innocence in Mao s China (Philadelphia: Xlibris Corporation, 2001), 223-224. The situation of political convicts in laogai branches was different from those in laojiao branches, however. As sentenced criminals, their term was fixed, from varying terms to life sentence. The adequate performances merely secured their punctual release and freed them from additional penalty. Only those with "eminent contribution" could have their term reduced. See Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 104; Xingkaihu changshiban, Xingkaihu nongchang shi (Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm) (Mishan: No pub., 1988), 397. Recollections of both Chen Fengxiao and Yin Jiliang (both were counterrevolutionaries) did not provide any record of motivation or dedication of the laogai inmates to manual work. Exceptions did exist, however. As showed in Chapter Three, a laojiao inmate Xuan Shouzhi stubbornly refused to work and was thus interned in a solitary confinement cell and crippled. 4 0 4  4 0 3  4 0 6  147  their best. Great inputs of effort and physical exertion might temporarily satisfy farm or camp cadres but they could not sustain the level for long, and thus could not meet mounting requirements. Memoirs of Liu Naiyuan, Dai Huang, Yin Y i and Wu Yongliang all indicate cases where the exiles could not finish assigned work thus were insulted by camp cadres, and felt untold bitterness.  407  Furthermore, the overall  evaluation of the rightists in the army farms was not good despite their efforts. A n official report regarding rightists' performance in the army farms criticizes that the rightists "were afraid of cold, of hardship, and of fatigue." Their effort in physical labor was poorly appreciated.  408  Put in surroundings where almost everyone tried to show his or her best, political exiles also found it not easy to make themselves stand out. For some, good work achievement, despite an indication of repentance, was insufficient to show their political commitment or progressiveness. Instead, more active gestures such as "drawing close to the government" (kaolong zhengfu), or "drawing close to the organization"(£tf0/o«g zuzhi) were shortcuts, which meant active responses to the authorities' calls for "thought report" (sixiang huibao) and, for some political exiles, running down others as an important step to build themselves up and thus to assure various benefits. Accordingly, internal strife, betrayal, reporting and denouncing other inmates constituted conspicuous parts of the Beidahuang banishment.  Internecine Strife in the Pre-Banishment Context Anne Thurston, presenting the Cultural Revolution as a failure of morality, provides an insightful interrogation of the Chinese human conscience in the postrevolutionary period. Under the Communist, she believes, many Confucian norms have been destroyed. People forget loyalty, honesty and respect for others people. They attack others in order to get ahead, to climb higher on the ladder of political  See, for instance, Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 132; Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 53; Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 219, 224. Liu and his campmate Gan were frequently humiliated for their slowness in work. The camp cadre in charge of Liu's team even used worksite struggle meetings to exert pressure on inmates. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 243-244. Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao (The Northeast Corner of China) (Harbin: Heilongjiang renmin chubanshe, 1998), 95. 4 0 7  4 0 8  148  success, and to avoid being attacked by others. People act out of expediency rather than morality.  409  The experiences of the persecuted intellectuals in 1950s verify Thurston's arguments. A n overview of their psychology and their internal strife before their bamshment helps understand the psychology and behavior of the exiles during their banishment. Internal strife among the political exiles could be seen as the result of manipulation by the governing party. The CCP publicly encouraged mutual surveillance, secret reporting and mutual denunciation, and suggested redemption as a reward for this behavior.  410  This strategy worked even before 1957. When Ding  Ling and her former Literary  Gazette colleague Chen Qixia were attacked as an  Anti-Party Clique, Chen Qixia broke first under political pressure. On August 3, 1955, when he confessed to various anti-Party crimes, he handed over all the correspondence he and Ding Ling had exchanged over the previous years, and accused Ding  of attempting  "to  seize the  leadership of literary circles."  Denunciations of Ding Ling also came from many of her colleagues. Lao She and Mao Dun, for instance, actively joined in attacks on her.  411  In the early summer of 1957 when the political wind shifted to the AntiRightist Campaign and the massive persecutions loomed large, many intellectuals chose to expose and attack their colleagues and friends politically in order to assert their loyalty or to save themselves. False accusations, denunciations and betrayal were widespread, based on the survival instinct, and under the encouragement of the  See Anne Thurston, Enemies of the People (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1987), "Conclusion", for more discussion. See "Zhonghua renmin gongheguo laodong gaizao tiaoli" (Regulations of the PRC on Reform through Labor), in Guowuyuan fazhiju, ed., Zhonghua renmin gongheguo xianxing falu xingzheng fagui huibian (The Comprehensive Collection of Current Laws and Administrative Regulations of the PRC) (Beijing: Zhongguo falu chubanshe, 1995), 70, In June of 1957 Mao Zedong in an internal instruction admitted that "We skillfully push those in the left wing and the middle elements to attack the rightists, which turns out to be very effective." Mao Zedong, Mao Zedong xuanji, Vol. 5, 432. Chen Fengxiao recalls that one of his Hundred Flower Society friends wasfreefrombeing sentenced because of his exposure of "crimes" of Chen and other members of the society. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengyajishi, 40, 43. Jonathan Spence, The Gate of Heavenly Peace: The Chinese and Their Revolution, J895-J980 (New York: The Viking Press, 1981), 336. 4UV  4 1 0  4 1 1  149  Party authorities. Almost a l l the rightists featured i n this thesis had once suffered denunciation and betrayal from their colleagues and friends  4 1 2  W h i l e some scathing  attacks came from people who lacked clear political judgment but merely followed political trends, and from those who naively put faith on the Party and thus responded to the Party's call to attack whoever was accused, the vast majority denounced their colleagues and friends out o f a desire to show their political correctness or need for self-protection. The behavior o f many o f the most revered intellectuals was less than exemplary. The well-known playwright Tian H a n managed to label his colleague W u Zuguang to save himself. The famous writer L a o She also joined i n the attack against W u .  4 1 3  W u Han, historian and a leader o f  Beijing branch o f Chinese Democratic League, was a leading activist during the campaign and labeled sixty-seven o f his league members as rightists.  414  During the  campaign, intellectuals were led to incriminate their friends. The reason for actively denigrating others, even betraying friends, was mainly self-defense or self-redemption. When the campaign started, the Party called on people to show their political correctness by pointing out the problematic or reactionary ideas o f others, or they themselves would risk being criticized or labeled. For the purpose o f self-protection, silence was less useful than finding a scapegoat. Artist Sun Chengwu (also a Party member) kindly reminded a colleague to be cautious since he (that person) was on the verge o f being labeled. To his surprise, Sun's colleague sold out Sun to the Party branch. W h e n Sun was adversely labeled for "disclosing Party secrets" and sent to Beidahuang, his colleague became an A n t i -  For instance, many of those who joined in framing Dai Huang were his comrades in arms —who had once fought with him on battlefields, worked closely and held dinner parties together. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 77. Li Wenhui, Ship laoren de hua Wu Zuguangjuan (Words of Seniors of the Century: Wu Zuguang) (Shenyang: Liaoning jiaoyu chubanshe, 2000), 130; Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Jingji lu: jiyi zhongde fan youpai yundong (The Thorny Road: the Anti-Rightist Campaign in Memory) (Beijing: Jingji ribao chubanshe, 1998), 90-91. Ye Yonglie, Fan youpai shimo (The Whole Story of the AntiRightist Movement) (Xining: Qinghai renmin chubanshe, 1995), 513. Lao She denounced Wu's spiritual world as that of "manure pit, maggot, monsters and demons." As well, his denunciation of young writer Cong Weixi was astonishing. Since Cong in a novel "A Unpleasant Story" revealed a dark side of rural China in the early 1950s, Lao She accused him of "trying to instigate peasant rebellion against the Communist Party." Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 25. Ye Yonglie, Fan youpai shimo, 326; Li Xin, interview. 4 1 2  4 1 3  4 1 4  150  rightist activist. The goal to "atone for one's crime by doing good things" was achieved.  415  For those who tried to find scapegoats, close friends, colleagues and comrades turned out to be more suitable targets than others, since the accusers had had more access to their lives and minds, and they were fully aware o f the weak points o f these targets. When political pressure remained high and labeling quotas were set, many were badly scared, and thus the survival instinct outran friendship and ethical principles. Targeting their closest colleagues and friends, exposing the  most  confidential information about the victims and raising trivial issues to political levels were best ways to assert the political loyalty o f accusers, and thus provide them a better chance to survive the campaign. For a well-known rightist L u o Longji, the most vicious attack came from his girlfriend o f seventeen years, who made use o f L u o ' s personal life to frame and slander, and accused L u o as a " w o l f covered with a sheepskin."  416  The story o f writer L i u Shaotang is also illuminating. According to L i u , the most vicious attacks on h i m came from a female colleague, a sister-like person, whom L i u had treated with extreme confidence and she had treated L i u well. "We almost had nothing secret between each other," L i u said. When L i u was designated a rightist, she was also on the verge o f being labeled. In her desperate effort for selfredemption, L i u became her easy target. She accused L i u for trivial issue—allegedly, failing to pay as much in Party dues as he should, which offered additional materials for other attackers. Probably, L i u would still have been labeled without her attack, since the main charge against L i u was "taking a stance against Chairman M a o ' s literary thoughts." However, her betrayal was a fatal blow to L i u . "It made me heart broken." L i u recalls.  417  In a perilous situation, or at a point o f life or death, kind  people became more vicious than could be expected by others, or even by  Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 40. Zhang Yihe, Wangshi bingbu ruyan, 282-283. Even more heart broken was the betrayal of families. When Dai Huang underwent denunciation from his colleagues and comrades, his wife joined in and put up a wall poster, accusing Dai for plotting to organize an anti-Party clique within the CCP. Dai Huang, Jiushi yisheng, 61. See Niu Han and Deng Jiuping, eds., Jingji lu, 334. 4 1 5  4 1 6  4 1 7  151  themselves. Nevertheless, the goal o f self-protection was not always successfully achieved by unscrupulous attacks on others. Once somebody was internally selected as the target, his/her fate was, i n most cases, sealed, and he/she stood little chance to be set free to clear themselves. The labeling quotas were set and thus needed work to get people to fit them. Thus the Party organizations seldom freed the targets. The revolutionary lady who denounced L i u Shaotang, for instance, was not exempt from being labeled, and she died miserably several years later.  418  Deng Youmei, a writer  i n Beijing, is another example. O n October 11, 1957, when the Writer's U n i o n o f Beijing convened a mass condemnation meeting against L i u Shaotang, Deng had not been labeled yet. Thus he lodged a sharp denunciation against L i u . Ironically, right after Deng concluded his speech and enjoyed the warm applause o f the audience, the Chairman denounced Deng a rightist on the spot.  419  The discussion by L i u Naiyuan  about this situation is illuminating.  It happened that people who had criticized the Party more sharply (during the Hundred Flower period), or those whose history was "complicated", were eager to vindicate themselves by coming out with vigorous attacks on Rightists, and ironically these were apt to become Rightists themselves. A s a result, there were cases i n which a very eloquent defender o f the Party and the cause o f socialism stood crestfallen a few day later on the stage a few meters aside o f the rostrum he had just taken. Ironically, again, critics o f these ill-fates warriors could find themselves in their shoes i n no t i m e . 420  False accusations and betrayals o f friends left many anti-rightist activists mentally tortured. Some felt guilty and displayed a degree o f repentance later on. Novelist B a Jin painfully admits i n his memoir that when he harshly condemned D i n g L i n g and A i Qing, he actually "threw stones toward those i n dire strait."  421  In  1961 when W u Zuguang returned from Beidahuang, Cao Y u , his friend and fierce  * See Ibid, 334. Cong Weixi, Zouxicmg hundun, 32. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 173-174. Ba Jin, Sui xiang lu (Random Thoughts) (Hong Kong: Sanlian shudian, 1979), Vol. 1, 161.  9  0  1  152  attacker in the campaign, came to see him and asked for his  forgiveness. ^ 4  Nevertheless, it seems that few people openly repented their behaviors in the immediate post-campaign period. Furthermore, since considerable numbers of victims of 1957 were also the perpetrators of denunciations against others at the same time, this behavior was brought to locations of their banishment including Beidahuang.  False Accusations and Internecine Strife in Beidahuang Several Beidahuang rightists still remember that warmness existed among their exile communities. Friends within same team helped each other with work, collected donations for needy families of fellow exiles, and in some cases shared hard-tocome-by food.  423  When the farm authorities were slow to provide rescue of those in  emergency in the Yunshan incident, some rightists volunteered to search for their lost fellows even though they were physically very weak.  424  However, many found  that in their communities there were no lack of informants, who tried to show their political activism by watching and exposing others for their "inappropriate" deeds. As Hongda Harry Wu puts it, "Those who reported to the police in exchange for special benefits hoped that by demonstrating the progress of their reform, they could secure an early release."  425  Some activists fingered issues that seemed rather political. In Farm 853, Huang Wu and couple of friends in a casual talk joked out an idea of gathering all the rightists of the country in Beidahuang, which was reported by a certain Pan with the  Li Wenhui, Shiji laoren de hua Wu Zuguang juan, 101. In some cases repentance was expressed even during the heated labeling period. Yin Jie recalls that "Yu Engui, my roommate and my good friend, was forced to expose me. One night when she finally returned from a political session, she cried and cried on my shoulder, and begged my pardon. She said that she would not be allowed to go home for food or sleep unless she came up with something against me." Yin Jie, interview. According to the available sources, however, such apologies during the period of campaign were rare. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 151; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 61; Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 19, 58; Zhang Jie, Wu Zuguang beihuan qu (Wu Zuguang: Vicissitudes of Life) (Chengdu: Sichuan wenyi chubanshe, 1986), 341. All these sources document numerous moving stories among the exile communities. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 228-231. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds: A Memoir ofMy Years in China's Gulag (New York: John Wiley & Sons Inc., 1994), 160.  4 2 2  4 2 3  4 2 4  4 2 5  153  distortion that the rightists were trying to establish a "rightist kingdom" to confront the Communist government.  426  Another case happened i n D a i Huang's team: a  Chinese poetry specialist H o u D e l i n gave a negative rating o f a verse o f M a o ' s poem, which was instantly reported by a rightist squad leader. The result was that H o u was publicly scolded as a "stubborn reactionary", repeatedly denounced afterwards and forced to do extra w o r k .  427  Other issues picked up were trivial. Practicing drawing (in the case o f D i n g Cong), reading history chronologies, singing English songs were all subjected to being reported although these activities were never explicitly banned by the farm authorities.  428  In some branch farms, as indicated i n the previous chapter, even  catching field mice to eat during famine years was fussed over as "disgracing socialism." When D i n g Cong, Huang M i a o z i and Gao Fen, long-time friends, happened to be assigned to the same labor team i n Farm 850, some o f their fellow rightists informed the farm leader that they had once formed an "anti-Party cliques" in Beijing, and suggested a split o f them apart.  429  In the army farms, as discussed in Chapter T w o , thousands o f rightists were organized along military line, headed by demobilized P L A officers (the farm cadres). Direct contact between these officers and the rightists was mainly limited to work time, and the officers did not have much interest i n the personal issues o f the rightists, or what they said or what they thought. It was the informants among the banished that made things fester, especially those appointed by farm authorities as squad leaders or platoon leaders (ban pai zhang). M a n y o f these rightist headmen were those who seemingly wished to "draw close to the organization" and were enthusiastic in public affairs.  430  In daily life, they showed little difference from other  rightists except for assisting farm cadres with the arrangement o f agricultural work.  Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao, 95; Liu Meng, ed., Lishi zai shenpan, 345; Huang Wu, Mahuatangwaiji, 47-48. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 172. Ding Cong, interview; Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 37; Liu Meng, Cuntian de yu qiutian qing, 124-125; Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 75. Li Hui, Renzai xuanwo, 299. Huang VJu, Mahuatangwaiji, 47; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 124-125. 4 2 6  4 2 7 4 2 8  4 2 9  4 3 0  154  During work routines, meal and rest periods, they were all together and chatted and joked with others as normal. Some o f them, however, i n attempts to take chances to build themselves up, would memorize what their fellow rightists said and did, and quietly reported what they believed as problematic. Platoon leaders Zhang and Jiao in Yunshan, for example, were said to be such persons. Repeated condemnations D a i Huang suffered from camp cadres were due to their reports.  431  Based on the secret reports, many o f which were farfetched, scary charges would be lodged on the target(s), and other rightists would be mobilized against their fellow campmates. The repertoire went like this: after farm cadres had made major condemnations, all the other rightists i n the team concerned were asked to participate i n mass denunciations against the one(s) regarded as having committed faults. Rightists i n this situation were hardly able to keep silent. Some jumped forward with great activism, and some followed the trend. In the political sessions over "the incident o f rightist kingdom" o f Farm 853, some rightists analyzed the reactionary nature o f the incident, charging these people (the targets) with trying to establish a rightist kingdom o f millions o f people against the Party and the People's Republic; some disclosed the daily behavior o f these people, raising every small issue to match the political line; and some even strongly demanded severe punishment for these people. The condemnation sessions lasted for several evenings, the atmosphere was tense, and everybody was scared. 432  L i v i n g in such a milieu, those who were reluctant to j o i n i n attacks were also obligated to say something against the selected targets. D a i Huang and W u Yongliang acknowledged that many o f these people joined i n condemnations merely to get by under false pretenses, to muddle through, or just for the sake o f appearances. Their criticism, therefore, would likely be less harsh; it normally took  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 172-173. In his memoirs, Dai Huang boldly exposes names of the informants in his teams, whereas Wu Yongliang, Y i Yi, and Liu Meng merely narrate the cases without reference to any names, and Huang Wu uses nickname to the informants. It also needs to be noted that not all the rightist headmen were informants; some were nice and popular among the ordinary rightists. For Wu Yongliang, his platoon leader Hao Qixin and squat leader Xiao Wang turned out to be conscientious and protective rightist headmen by shunning off heavy work demands from above at times and helping others with work. See Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 58, 119. Liu Meng, ed., Lishi zai shenpan, 345. 4 3 1  4 3 2  155  the form o f persuasion and suggestions, and was combined with self-criticism, in the hope o f satisfying the camp authorities and at the same time minimizing the hurt to their fellows. In very unusual cases, some refused to make accusations and kept silent.  433  The farm cadres were fully aware o f the internal strife amongst the banished intellectuals. A team cadre L i Fuchun (Farm 853) recalls that "There were so many conflicts among those intellectuals. Everybody wanted to get above the others. Some liked to drop small reports (secret reports) i n order to show their activism, and drew everything to political line." A t times, even farm cadres did not bother to make fuss o f the small reports. Bored with heated political rhetoric caused by "the incident o f the rightist kingdom" i n the Farm 853, the chief farm leader finally stopped the escalating condemnation sessions, just treated this issue as a joke, and did not make severe punishment o f those involved in i t .  434  Nevertheless, it was sad for the rightist targets to hear ferocious denunciations coming from their campmates, some o f who might have chatted i n a friendly way the day before their criticism. D a i Huang recalls that several campmates were quite sympathetic to him and supportive o f his opinions such as on the Great Leap myth, which turned out to annoy a camp cadre Z h u . However, when Z h u decided to condemn D a i and ordered these rightists to j o i n i n , most o f them changed their tone and began to condemn D a i or stated to draw a line between themselves and D a i .  4 3 5  Betrayal by close friends caused D a i and other victims enormous spiritual trauma. Y a n g Taiquan, D a i Huang's campmate, even refused to talk i n the army farm. "During labor, meal and rest, he always expressed himself with eye contacts, gestures, nods, and shakes o f the head, rather than saying anything. When someone  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 146-147; 166; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 100-101. In Ding Cong's narrative, the less harsh criticism made by his fellow rightists were statements to that they would draw a political line between themselves and Ding and be free from his negative influences. Ding Cong, interview. Zheng Jiazhen, Zhongguo dongbeijiao, 87; Liu Meng, ed., Lishi zai shenpan, 345-346. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 146. 4 3 3  4 3 4 4 3 5  156  chatted and joked, he sometimes could not help but smile; but he smiled very transiently, and swiftly turned his back to conceal his feelings."  4 3 6  Phony activism also existed in Xingkaihu and other labor camps. Compared to the army farms, Xingkaihu was a more formal labor reform regime, in which political study sessions were structured in a more formal way. In Chen Fengxiao's laogai team, political instructors openly encouraged "small reports" and mutual denunciation in the name of "mutual surveillance and mutual help." In the evening after dinner inmates "had to sit down and join in life examination meeting (shenghuo jiantaohui), dogs."  437  in which inmates were encouraged to bite each other like  In the laojiao camp where Wu Ningkun lived, "every three months there  was a two-day political campaign supposedly designed to speed up the reform of the inmates. We would be enjoined to inform against each other and confess old crimes we had concealed or new crimes we'd recently committed." This kind of political 438  arrangement was often a good chance for activism. Chen Fengxiao recalls that every part of his daily life, including chatting with other political convicts, or keeping silent during political study sessions, was subject to being reported and denounced by his campmates.  439  internecine strife among the persecuted intellectuals would at times lead to physical abuse, which partly reflected grudges or retaliation against others. In the labor camp Harry Wu stayed, fights often occurred over trivial issues. Those who were too weak and cowardly to engage in fights would act out their rivalries and resentments in political setting. These people would be active in offering false accusations and joining in the prearranged struggle against the inmates they hated. A  Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 255. In Beidahuang, as happened during the Anti-Rightist Campaign, some who denounced their friends or campmates felt guilty and came up to apologize afterwards. Xin Ruoping was designated by camp cadres to condemn Dai Huang's "anti-Great Leap" poison in a political struggle session, and later on came to Dai to express his apology. Ibid, 147. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 89. Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear, 97. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 74, 81. False accusations were also widespread in other labor camps in Manchuria. In Zhenlai Labor Farm where Hu Xianzhong were incarcerated, when arightistprisoner Liu used a piece of newspaper that happened to have Mao's portrait on it to wrap shoes, his campmate Bi reported it to the camp cadre, with the implication that Liu had "inveterate hatred" for Chairman Mao. Hu Xianzhong, interview. 4 J 0  3 7  4 3 8  4 3 9  157  story told by Harry Wu was daunting. In Qinghe Farm, when two rightists Guo and Wang were denounced as active-counterrevolutionaries, the attacks from four activists were horrible. To my horror, the four activists, themselves fellow rightists, began viciously to strike and kick their captives, shouting for them to confess...Then before our eyes two activists stripped off the helpless men's clothing. One of the men being struggled against slumped to the floor...Soon the two victims were strung by their wrists from the crossbeam in the roof. I saw someone come in with a belt dipped in water and began beating one of the men, against whom I knew he held a grudge." 440  Political exiles acknowledge the human weakness shown in relentless attacks upon rightists by other rightists, and some also admit their inability to avoid such weakness. From a struggle session Cong Weixi personally experienced, he realizes that "the Anti-Rightist Campaign suggests to me that attacks on intellectuals by intellectuals are extremely ferocious; this struggle session reveals again that when rightists lacking in conscience attack their like, it is ten-time cruder than other ordinary intellectuals."  441  The story Cong told was about his friend, artist L i  Binsheng, who was condemned for using cartoons and traditional Chinese painting to defame socialism. During the condemnation session, almost all the rightists in Li's labor group, including his former colleagues and friends, tried to bring all their skills into play to condemn him in order to show their own piousness. Even Li's fainting did not stop them from yelling at him. Interestingly, Cong confides that he  Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 203-204. This story is also told by Meng Bo. See Xiao Ke, et al., Wo qili guo de zhengzhi yundong (The Political Campaigns That I Have Experienced) (Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, 1998), 116-123. According to Meng, some of those who were actively joining in the beating had actually suffered before at the hands of Guo and Wang. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 57. In contrast to the uneasy relationship among intellectuals, the banished found that kindness and consolation came from rural folks rather than from their colleagues. During his years of "labor under supervision," Cong found peasants with whom he performed labor very friendly —they never took advantage of their superior political status in dealing with the hapless intellectuals. Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 40. Tan Tianrong recalls that when he was sent back to his home, a mountain village in Hunan, after completing his term of labor reeducation, local people did not show any discrimination against him. Tan Tianrong, unpublished essay "Meiyou qingjie de gushi"(Stories without Plot), 3. Many of my interviewees claim that living among the peasantry was better than among intellectuals. 4 4 0  4 4 1  158  did not say anything against poor L i not because he was reluctant to do so, but simply because he did not get a chance when so many attackers spat out speeches one after another.  442  The reward for these attackers for their activism was their promotion as rightist group leaders in the case of the army farms, or cell bosses in the case of labor camps in Xingkaihu. Sometime they were provided with a little more food and a lighter workload than others, and could, in both army farms and Xingkaihu, wield considerable power over their fellow inmates, and even enforce physical penalties. In Xingkaihu, many cases of physical abuses were perpetrated by cell bosses; in Yunshan, Dai Huang witnessed some rightist platoon leaders orally and physically abuse other rightists or deny them food.  443  Phony activism also played a role in early  release from the army farms. By reporting on their fellows and seeing them disgraced, opportunities for the activists to acquire early release seemed to increase. According to Dai Huang, those appointed as platoon and squad leaders found it relatively easy to get their rightist "hats" removed earlier than others. "Some got their rightist hats removed in the first wave of 'label-removal' precisely because they were active in reporting others."  4 4 4  These informants were much more  abhorred by the rightist communities than the camp cadres they dealt with. Nevertheless* putting others down hardly played a role in early release for laogai or laojiao  inmates in Xingkaihu. Firstly, for the laogai  inmates, then-  sentence was fixed and the decision to reduce a sentence was based on their work record rather than on political denunciations against others. In November 1959, 14 convicts got their sentences reduced. A l l of them were due to their good performance in agricultural production or for saving public property. As Liu Naiyuan puts it, in the struggle sessions in China's prison system "no political shows would bring any benefit or reward."  445  Secondly, for the laojiao  inmates, poor  political performance would likely get their internment extended, but good deeds did Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 54-57. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 73; Han Dajun interview; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 188, 238. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 172. Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 44; Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 197. 4 4 2  4 4 3  4 4 4  445  159  not guarantee early release. Neither Tan Tianrong, H a n Dajun, L i u Naiyuan or W u Ningkun (all were laojiao inmates) provide any cases o f early release for whatever reason during their internment i n Xingkaihu. Furthermore, for laojiao  inmates,  whether to be granted release on time was more decided by national politics than by their political performance in the labor camps. When the Xingkaihu laojiao inmates were transferred to Qinghe, many were told that they would serve a maximum threeyear term starting from M a y 24, 1961. Yet when the date o f expiry o f the laojiao term came i n 1964, many inmates were kept on i n internment because o f the tightening  o f political  Movement."  446  control  i n the  context  o f the  Socialist Education  Political activism could not improve the fortunes o f those i n labor  camps. Nevertheless, phony activism was still persistent. Even those who had little hope o f redeeming themselves tried to show their political loyalty. D i n g Tong, who was banished to Xingkaihu under charge as a historical counterrevolutionary and an active counterrevolutionary, actively exposed and condemned Chen Fengxiao for lack o f enthusiasm in studying M a o ' s Little R e d Book i n 1965, and joined i n the physical abuse o f Chen, even though he was aware that it was impossible to get his own sentence mitigated.  447  It seems that attacking others did not always serve a  practical propose.  Psychological Suffering and Low Morale Despite their efforts to extricate themselves from the abyss o f their miseries, many political exiles came to realize that, with the political label (rightist or counterrevolutionary) hung over their heads like a sword o f Damocles, when they would be able to leave Beidahuang was beyond their control, and whether they could see their families alive was uncertain. When their early enthusiasm for work faded and their internment was prolonged, frustration, loneliness, and the fear o f dying i n the great wilderness overwhelmed many exiles. When Huang W u and his Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 275-276. For information on "Socialist Education Movement," see Jonathan Spence, The Search for Modem China (New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 1990), 590-596. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 104.  4 4 6  160  fellow rightists talked about their future, they sadly agreed that they would likely end up as forced land pioneers, stay on forever and have their "bones buried in the black soil." In early 1960, rightist Zhu Qiping, realizing that he would probably not be able to return home, sent his only precious belonging, a watch, back to his wife in Beijing, as a sign of farewell.  448  Psychological suffering was profound. In Xingkaihu and some army branch farms (such as Yunshan), when the political exiles were deprived of dignity and human treatment, and merely driven like draft ariimals or slave laborers, the sadness generated was untold. Some even envied livestock and field animals that had enough forage and were free from exposure to the cold.  449  They used a term "boundless sea  of bitterness"(£«/*aj wubiari) to describe their misery, a feeling that eventually turned to numbness—the absence of any feeling of sorrow. When Wu Yongliang was asked to keep a night watch for four of his fellow rightists who had died of hard labor and hunger, he found that he was in a state without sadness or any other feeling:  I felt my mind empty—no fear, no sorrow, ho even resentment. During the past three years, what could be called freedom, dignity, personality, or feelings—what a human being owned or should own—seemed to be entirely gone. This probably was the ideal state of "thorough remolding of oneself (tuotai huangu)?^  With this profound sense of sadness and frustration, some political exiles became increasingly depressed and withdrawn. Huang Wu's story about his friend Wang Dahua is striking. It can be summarized as following: Wang's banishment to Beidahuang and the death of his wife left his little daughter without proper care and eventually she was killed by a run-away truck. The reticent Wang became even more silent; his fellow exiles could only hear his soft calls for his daughter at night. One day Wang found a monkey in the forest. He brought the monkey back and treated it like his daughter and talked to it gently. Before long, however, the monkey was 448 j  ^ Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 56; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 1. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 233; Yin Yi, Huishou canyangyi han shan, 44, 47. Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 135  4 5 0  161  secretly hung by an unpopular fellow rightist. Wang buried the monkey and resumed his silence again.  451  Tortured by psychological stress, prolonged hunger, and uncertainty about the future, some political exiles grew increasingly eccentric, intolerant, and selfish. In Yunshan, "it seemed that people only cared about their own personal gain or loss; mutual understanding, friendship, consideration and help began to wane." Quarrels and physical feuds blew up out of trivial issues. When someone failed or was believed to be failing to do an equal amount of work with others, or if someone lifted food from others, he would be hurled out, beaten, and even tied to a tree and for expose to the cold of winter.  452  In Xingkaihu, the exiles communities were full of  tension. Chen Fengxiao's violent eruption against his campmate Hao Zhixiang reflects his anger at his humbled situation.  453  The fact that internal feuding was the direct result of prolonged internment and frustration was also manifested in the period after the Beidahuang. When many laojiao  inmates were transferred to Tuanhe Farm in June 1962, the personal  relations among them were good for the first several weeks. "The atmosphere remained harmonious," recalled Harry Wu, since the inmates were given hints by the camp cadres that their fate would be improved due to the relaxation of the political climate, and thus they held deep hopes for release soon after. However, This good will faded as the weeks of summer passed and we received no word about release. The personal tensions, the continuing fights over food, and the disputes over labor assignments reflected our mounting frustrations and our dwindling hopes.' 5 4  In some cases, feuds and the use of force and violence in labor camps could be seen as the result of selfishness and moral degeneration, which makes the whole issue complicated. Harry Wu provides a story about how he dealt with his  Huang Wu, Mahuatang waiji, 11-15. Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 174. Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 86. See Chapter Three for Chen's violence gainst his campmate Hao. Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 158. 52 53  ,4  162  campmates: Wu, as a squad leader in Qinghe Labor Farm, was once responsible for making the fire to warm the squad dormitory on winter nights. One day when he was busy with other work, he asked his fellow inmate Lu to help make the fire. But L u refused on the grounds that this was not supposed to be his job. Feeling his authority challenged, Wu decided to implement his order by force: "Follow my order," I shouted, "or you'll regret it." Lu shook his head. I stood up and grabbed his foot. " Do it!" I said, and twisted his foot hard. "Let go of me, I'll go," Lu cried, and the tension passed. He went outside to fetch the cornstalks from the ox cart and load them into the stove. 455  According to Wu, Lu also refused to provide necessary aid to a fellow prisoner, who was suffering from painful hemorrhoids, with his work assignment. "Sorry," L u said, "but... we all eat the same food. I won't do someone else's job."  456  It is hard to assume that Lu's selfishness and submissiveness to force and Wu's tendency to use force on his fellow prisoners as being typical of the banished intellectuals. From the sources we have consulted, however, it can be discerned that moral degradation existed widely in the post-1957 labor camps.  Conclusion The period of the Anti-Rightist Campaign and the border banishment afterwards was a significant phase of the psychological journey of Chinese intellectuals. Bound by the Party ideology and hoping to serve the country under the Party leadership, many of China's educated elites willingly adhered to the Party line that led to their persecution, and sincerely repented their "faults" when purged. Their self-abasing mentality led to slavish obedience to the regime, and their sense of identity and dignity was shattered. During the banishment, many made strenuous efforts to offer good service in exchange of redemption.  Ibid, 140. Ibid, 143.  163  Considerable numbers of political inmates were involved in or were victimized by internecine strife even while being persecuted and banished. False accusations  continued,  betrayal of  friend reappeared,  secret reporting and  incrimination of their fellow exiles widely existed—all of which indicate that political exiles, especially intellectuals, were mentally damaged and deformed not only by the Communist regime but also by themselves. Those who made efforts to redeem themselves—to please labor reform authorities in order to crawl their way out of labor camps—paid a heavy price for that. Their dignity, personality and moral value were severely eroded. Thus the experience of the banishment not only left millions of Chinese physically damaged, but also with crushed human values and defiled the sanctity of the human spirit.  164  Chapter Six The End Without End We were living in two different worlds, divided by an unbridgeable gap. Staying behind in America, he was able to reap success and honor and live a happy life in security and affluence. Returning to China, I struggled through trials and tribulation and barely made it to this day of rehabilitation. Wu Ningkun reflects upon his life and that of his friend Lee Tsung-Dao (Li Zhengdao), a Nobel Prize winner.  457  The years of 1960-1961 brought a number of significant changes to the political exiles in Beidahuang. Due to the CCP authorities' intention to show their benevolence, and their apprehension of mass deaths, many rightists got their labels removed and were brought back from the border regions to the interiors. Some were allowed to return to their original work units. The ultra-rightists were transferred from Xingkaihu laojio camps to Qinghe and then Tuanhe Farms in north China to continue their labor reeducation. The number of political exiles in Beidahuang drastically declined. While the rightists from the central civilian organizations and the majority of ultra-rightists in Xingkaihu (the laojiao  inmates) benefited from the temporary  political relaxation in the early 1960s by being evacuated, the laogai inmates whose status was sentenced convicts and the rightists from military organizations were left behind in the Heilongjiang frontier regions. For many, the conclusion of their banishment to Beidahung did not spell the end of their status as political outcasts, or to their suffering. They had to intermittently participate in agricultural labor in local farms, were forced to go through various ideological remolding sessions and subjected to continuous harassments in ensuing political campaigns. This chapter will look at the process of "label removal" (otherwise known as 457  Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear: A Family's Persecution, Love and Endurance in Communist China (New York: The Atlantic Monthly Press, 1993), 341.  165  hat removal or zaimao) for the rightists, the withdrawal o f the political exiles from Beidahuang. It also looks at how they fared i n later years.  Mao's proposal and hat removal (zaimao) of the rightists The redemption o f the rightists came from a proposal o f M a o Zedong, the very person who had insisted on sending them down for ideological remolding. O n August 24, 1959, M a o wrote a letter to his deputy L i u Shaoqi on the adjustment o f policy regarding the rightists: I believe that we can convert at least 70% o f those labeled rightists within a certain period o f time. Within the next seven years or more, for instance, it is possible to convert 10% o f them and remove their "hats" per year. Please initiate a discussion among the standing members o f the Political Bureau as well as the central secretariat, and enact an instruction: at the tenth anniversary o f the country, to remove "hats" o f 10% rightists, i.e., 45 thousands based on the situation as to how they have remolded themselves. This would be instrumental to teach lessons to rightists, general bourgeoisies, intellectuals, and members of'democratic parties'." 4 5 8  In the same letter, M a o also instructed that the "hat removed" rightists continue to be watched: " i f they have a relapse, just put the rightist hats on them again." The reason for this initiative, although hard to pinpoint accurately, may be established from an analysis o f national politics. Due to the seeming failure o f the G L F and dissatisfaction among the general public as well as the Party members, it was necessary to rebuild confidence and display a degree o f relaxation. With the coming tenth anniversary o f the People's Republic (October 1 1959), the release o f st  a certain number o f inmates was helpful to show the benevolence o f the Party and to build up a warm political environment.  459  The "hat" removal (zaimao) o f the  See Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguo yilai zongyao wenxian xuanbian (Selected Collections of Important Documents since the Establishment of the PRC) (Beijing: Zhongyang wenxian chubanshe, 1996), V. 12, 528. See Xiao Donglian, Qiusuo Zhongguo: wenge qian shinian shi (The Search for China, the Ten Years' History prior to the Cultural Revolution) fBeijing: Hongqi chubanshe, 1999), Vol. 1, 237; Ye Yonglie, Fanyoupai shimo (The Whole Story of the Anti-Rightist Movement) (Xining: Qinghai renmin chubanshe, 1995), 568. Both of these two sources point to the CCP's attempt to relax internal 4 5 8  4 3 9  166  rightists reflected strategic considerations o f the C C P leadership. A bitter irony was that this program was bound up with another plan as a integrated  package—the amnesty o f sentenced criminals (POWs  from  pre-  Communist regimes and penal criminals) currently detained by the C C P public security authorities. In the same letter M a o suggested the remission o f the sentences o f a certain number o f " P O W s and ordinary convicted criminals who have truly turned over a new l e a f , for the tenth anniversary o f P R C .  4 6 0  This suggestion  revealed that M a o had a dual consideration i n dealing with criminal offenders and those who aired different opinions, and that i n the issue o f state consolidation, intellectual critics i n M a o ' s eyes might be little different from those who fought the Communists during the c i v i l war and the criminals who caused social disturbance. M a o ' s letter set i n motion the hat removal o f rightists as well as their withdrawal from rural areas and the border regions. O n September 17, 1959, the Central Committee o f the C C P issued an "instruction on hat removal o f rightists who show real repentance", which ordered the hat removal o f a number o f rightists "during the celebration o f the National D a y " .  4 6 1  Despite the seeming urgency to  create the desired atmosphere, it was too close to the National Day to make realistic plans or to perform careful scrutiny o f individual rightists i n order to identify who could get their "hats" removed and who had to keep their "hats" on. It was not until early December that the names o f the first group o f rightists to have their hats removed i n Beijing (142 people, all from central government organs and democratic parties) were publicly announced.  462  In terms o f the whole country, the process o f  tension and to build up a good atmosphere for the National Day. As well, Ye mentions that amnesty was regularly used by various China's rulers as a tactics at times of major celebrations. See Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguo yilai zongyao wenxian xuanbian, V. 12, 529. Implementing Mao's instruction, by December 1959, the PRC central government released 33 highrank POWs (Aisin Gioro Puyi included), and provincial authorities remitted the sentences of 12,082 counterrevolutionary offenders (fangeming fan) and criminal offenders (xingshi fan). See Ma Qibin, et al., eds., Zhongguo gongchanaang zhizheng sishi nian (The CCP: Forty Years' in Power) (Beijing: Zhonggong dangshi ziliao chubanshe, 1989), 174. See Zhongyang wenxian yanjiushi, ed., Jianguo yilai zongyao wenxian xuanbian, V. 12, 572-574. Xiao Donglian, Qiusuo zhongguo, Vol. 1, 237. Zhu Zheng, 1957 nian de xiaji: cong baijia zhengming dao liangjia zhengming (The Summer of 1957: from Hundred Schools of Thought Contending to Two Schools of Thought Contending) (Zhengzhou: Henan renmin chubanshe, 1998), 519. The names of these people were published in the People's Daily, December 5, 1959. The 4 6 0  4 6 1  4 6 2  167  hat removal was cautious. When the first round o f the program was completed in early 1960, 37,506 people i n total got their rightist hats removed, which accounted for 8.5% o f all the rightists.  463  The work o f hat removal o f Beijing rightists in Beidahuang was set in motion in October 1959. Several central observation teams (zhongyang kaochatuari)  were  sent to the army farms to evaluate the success o f rightists' ideological remolding. They checked files o f the Beijing rightists, consulted farm leaders and determined the number o f those who needed to have their hats removed.  464  The result, to the  dismay o f the rightists, was that only a small portion o f the rightists were told to get their political labels removed. A m o n g 925 rightists sent from central civilian organizations and military units to Farm 850, for instance, only 46 got their rightist hats removed. They were allowed to leave the farm for their new posts in Beijing, Shanxi, Inner Mongolia and other better locations i n Heilongjiang. Those left behind were advised to continue their efforts in reform through l a b o r .  465  Reports o f death from starvation turned out to be a decisive element for the C C P government to withdraw the rightists. During their stay i n the army farms i n 1959, the observation teams had heard o f food shortages and dropsy (a sign o f  majority of these people, including Fei Xiaotong, Pan Guangdan, Xu Zhucheng and Pu Xixiu, were influential intellectuals in thefieldsof science, arts and the mass media. Hu Ping, Chanji: kunan de jitan (Allegorical Words: The Bitter Sacrificial Altar) (Guangzhou: Guangdong luyou chubanshe, 1998), 660. An official document issued by the Party central authorities on Sept 17, 1960 indicates that around 40,000 people got their "hats" removed, or 9% of all the rightists. See The CCP Central Organization Department and the United Front Department, "Guanyu youpai fenzi gongzuo de baogao" (The Report on the Work over the Rightists), in Hua Min, Zhongguo da nizhuan: fanyou yundong shi (China's Great Reversal: A History of the Anti-Rightist Campaign) (New York: Ming-ching chubanshe, 1996), 397-398. 4 6 3  Bawuling nongchangshi bianxie bangongshi, Bawuling nongchangshi (Gazetteer of the Farm 850) (Hulin, Heilongjiang: No pub, 1986), 31; Yunshan nongchang shizhi bangongshi, Yunshan nongchangshi (Gazetteer of the Yunshan Farm)(Jiamusi: No pub.,1995), 5; Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei: Beidahuang shenghuo jishi (Floating Rain and Snow: True Stories of Life in the Great Northern Wilderness) (Beijing: Zhongguo xiju chubanshe, 2002), 108-109. According to Wu, during the stay of the central observation teams, many Beijing rightists tried hard to show good performances in their daily work, in order to impress the teams and get an early release. Yu Shanpu and Yang Chongdao, "Beidahuang liuren mingdan" (The Name List of Beidahuang Exiles); Yang Congdao, interview. According to Yu and Yang, among more than 200 rightists sent from central civilian organs to the Yunshan Branch, only three had their hats removed in 1959. 4 6 4  4 6 5  168  malnutrition), but they did not take it seriously at the time. In 1960, however, frequent reports of the deaths of Beidahuang rightists reached Beijing, and gradually caused concern in the central government and, to a great extent, prompted its acceleration of the hat removal process and the evacuation of more rightists (including those still wearing hats) back to the interior. Regarding how the central authorities made the decision on the evacuation of rightists, no official sources have been disclosed on this topic. Rather, individual recollections and biographies provide various versions, although they are yet to be verified. Some sources show that, certain well-connected rightists and their families wrote to the State Council reporting their predicament, which served as one element prompting the State Council to evacuate the rightists.  466  Another source is the journalists Zheng Xiaofeng and Dai Huang. They claim that when Zhou Enlai in the fall of 1960 discovered the discrepancy between the numbers of Beijing rightists who had been sent to Beidahuang and those who were still alive, he demanded from Wang Jingkun, the director of Mudanjiang Land Reclamation Bureau, an explanation for the mass deaths. When he found out from the ambivalent report Wang provided that the majority of deaths were from edema, malnutrition and diseases, Zhou finally realized the jeopardy of the rightists, and demanded their withdrawal.  467  (These banished intellectuals convinced themselves  that it was Premier Zhou saved them from jeopardy at last. Although it is implacable for people that Zhou actively saved those whom he had participated in to send away, in the post Mao context people needed to believe that Zhou was a good leader when image of Mao collapsed.) On September 17, 1960, the CCP central authorities issued another document, which showed a degree of seriousness for the solution of the rightist problem. The For instance, a well-known figure Xie Hegeng and his wife Wang Ying wrote to premier Zhou Enlai and vice Chairman of the State Dong Biwu, reporting his hardship in Beidahuang, Zhou and Dong made a quick response and arranged for Xie's return. See Zhang Zhicai, Yongyuan zaichulian (In Love Forever) (Beijing: Jiefangjun wenyi chubanshe, 1992), 332-333; Yao Lan and Deng Qun, Bai Congxi shenbicm de zhonggong mimi dangyuan (The Underground CCP Member Working with Bai Chongxi) (Beijing: Zhonggong dangshi chubanshe, 1998), 258-259. Zheng Xiaofeng, interview; Dai Huang, Jiusi Yisheng: wo de youpai licheng (A Narrow Escape from Death: My Experience as a Rightist) (Beijing: Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, 1998), 267-268. 4 6 6  4 6 7  169  document demanded continuous effort to remove the hats o f rightists i n the coming years, and suggested that the hat removal quota for 1960 be around 15-20% o f the total. It also read, "those who do not meet the standard for hat removal, but have labored for more than two years and behaved properly could also be recalled and assign suitable j o b s "  468  W i t h this instruction in operation, the central observation  teams were sent to Beidahuang again i n November 1960 to implement the second round o f hat removal, which was much larger i n scale than that o f a year before. O f around nine hundred rightists i n Farm 850, 127 were able to get their hats removed.  469  While the observation teams were doing their paper work and going through formulaic procedures, however, the death rate accelerated i n Beidahuang. Within less than a month, according to D a i Huang, six o f his fellow rightists died o f starvation and related illnesses.  470  The hat removal also gave rise to unexpected  result— the sudden death o f rightists due to the combined effects o f surprise and extreme physical weakness. After the central observation team announced his hat removal and gave h i m permission to return to Beijing, Guo Guanjun, a young linguist and translator, gave out his valuables as farewell presents to those still wearing hats. That night, however, he died o f heart failure. D a i Huang also revealed other deaths during and right after hat removal d a y s .  471  The successive deaths o f  rightists at the juncture o f hat removal disclosed a grim picture: rightists i n Beidahuang were being swallowed by hunger, malnutrition and lack o f medical care at alarming rate when hat removal (zaimao) was going on. The fact that many were too i l l to attend zaimao meetings and that some died right after the good news was announced indicated the prospect that the natural consumption o f a life might  See Hua Min, Zhongguo danizhuan, 397. Yu Shanpu and Yang Congdao, "Beidahuang liuren mingdan." Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 244-247. Yu Shanpu and Yang Congdao, "Beidahuang liuren mingdan"; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 253-256, 265-266. A story told by Dai reads that a rightist in Yunshan was too sick to attend the hat removal meeting. When his campmates told him that his hat had just been announced removed, he burst out laughing and crying in delight and then fell into sudden death. Records of Yu and Yang repeatedly show that rightists died one after another after they had their hats removed, some on the train for Beijing. 4 6 9 4 7 0 4 7 1  170  overtake that o f political redemption. Concerned about the increase i n deaths, the central authorities made a quick decision. In December 1960, the observation team in Farm 850 announced that except for those who had previously worked for the military, a l l the rightists coming from Beijing were to leave the army farms. "Those who have got their hats removed are to be reassigned jobs; those still wearing hats but who have behaved well are also to be given new jobs," a chief o f the observation team announced. Political appraisals were made and suggestions for job assignment were provided. December  1960 to January  472  From  1961, Beijing rightists, after having experienced  disproportionate afflictions, successively left the Beidahuang army farms.  473  Evacuation of the Laojiao Inmates While the rightists were evacuated mostly because o f starvation and death i n the army farms, the laojiao inmates left Xingkaihu mainly because o f government concern over border stability. A s discussed i n Chapters Three, the Xingkaihu labor reform complex was located right next to the Soviet borer i n the east. "Backed up by Soviet elder brother" had been one o f important reasons for choosing Xingkaihu as the camp location, as the Chinese government anticipated efficient prevention o f escape and, as alternative, successful extradition o f escapees from the Soviet Union. This advantage was quickly reversed into a disadvantage i n the early 1960s with the emergence o f the Sino-Soviet rift and tension on the northeastern border.  474  The Xingkaihu camp authorities also faced difficulties i n efficiently handling inmates. In 1960, for instance, the convicts it accommodated were 13,318, while the camp cadres and staff were less than 400 i n total. In Branch Five, there were about Yang Congdao, interview; Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 252. Yu and Yang "Beidahuang liuren mingdan" documents valuable information about the jobassignments of many rightists. Some who were at first recalled to their original work units in Beijing were relocated to other provinces later on, such as the case of Wu Yongliang. See Wu Yongliang, Yuxue feifei, 10-11. So far no official document has been released regarding the central authorities' concern over border security in relation to laogai and laojiao inmates in the borderlands. However, Wu Yue recalls that there was a document issued by the public security authorities in the late 1960 that all the laojiao elements needed to be removed from coastal regions, frontier regions, principal railhead and major urban areas, and the laogai elements needed to be put under stricter confinement. Wu Yue, interview. 4 7 3  4 7 4  171  450 inmates with less than 20 camp cadres  overseeing their work.  The  apprehension o f the camp authorities was reflected i n their action i n October 1960: a new picket line (a earth dyke fence) was constructed to prevent inmates from fleeing.  476  Although the shortage o f management personnel i n Xingkaihu was not  the major reason for the mass transfer o f laojiao inmates, the camp authorities found that i n times o f trouble, so many inmates were hard to handle. In December 1960, the majority o f ultra-rightists i n laojiao  camps were  evacuated to Qinghe Farm i n north China, and in the following year, around 600 laogai convicts were also sent back to the interior.  477  The camp authorities explained  the motive o f the transfer as kindness and leniency to these detainees. Zhang, a director o f Branch Eight, told L i u Naiyuan and his campmates that this "was the result o f a lenient policy towards us criminals which was meant to better help us i n our reform," recalls L i u Naiyuan. The Gazetteer o f Xingkaihu Farm, too, stresses care o f the "weak and sick", and their need to receive better food and medical care i n better locations.  478  However, those transferred insist that this evacuation merely  reflected the government concern for border security. L i u Naiyuan recalls that "we later learned that the purpose o f the relocation was to prevent secret collaboration between bourgeois rightists and the Soviet revisionists across the border. Zhang's version o f leniency was therefore irrelevant." Camp cadre L i u Junying also admits that those who were sent back to the interior "were actually 'dangerous elements'," and that "our chiefs were trying to keep the inmates here at a minimal l e v e l . "  479  Although i n 1960 the inmates half-dead from starvation showed no sign o f Mishan xianzhi bianweihui, Mishan xianzhi (Gazetteer of Mishan County) (Beijing: Zhongguo biaozun chubanshe, 1993), 146; Liu Junying, interview. Chen Fengxiao also recalls that in Branch 4, around 30 camp cadres oversaw 250-300 convicts. Chen Fengxiao, interview. Xingkaihu changshiban, Xingkaihu nongchangshi (Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm) (Mishan: No pub., 1988), 45. Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear: A Family's Persecution, Love and Endurance in Communist China (New York: The Atlantic Monthly Press, 1993), 109; Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 248; Ba Hong, interview. For the transfer of laogai convicts, see Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 404. As well, some female inmates from Xingkaihu were transferred to the women team of Beiyuan farm in northern Beijing. See Niu Weina, unpublished work "Cuowei: wo he wojia jidai zhishi fenzi de gushi" (Disjunction: the Stories of Intellectuals in My Clan), 148. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 248; Gazetteer ofXingkaihu Farm, 404. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 249; Liu Junying, interview. 4 7 6  4 7 7  4 7 8 4 7 9  172  disobedience, the government was still wary and tried to preempt them from making trouble in case of a possible frontier conflict.  Those left behind—the military rightists and Laogai convicts When a host of rightists from the central civilian organizations were withdrawn from Beidahuang, almost all of those from military units (such as the General Political Department of the PLA, the National Defense Industry Commission, or Navy Headquarter) were left behind, unable to return to their original work. According to a central directive of November 2, 1959, the former rightists were not allowed to resume their posts in key departments; all those who had served in the military were kicked out.  480  In Beidahuang, the military rightists were mostly  relocated to the nearby farms or to local enterprises, getting their position changed from agricultural laborer to industrial worker, office employee or school staff. Their wages was raised. Many worked there for more than ten years. After getting his label removed in 1961, ex-lieutenant Wang Keqin found his lot improved but not significantly. He continued to work in Farm 850 as a lumber worker and then a coal miner with his salary going up to 62 yuan R M B , still much lower than his original pay. In 1965, he managed to find a better job in a nearby lumber team as a truck dispatcher. It was not until 1976 that he was allowed to return to Beijing, only because his wife was employed there.  481  The most common work for the military rightists left behind in Beidahuang was in local schools, which was in accordance with the principle established by the center—"providing them appropriate job but not important posts.'  Chen Erzhen, a  former engineer at the Bayi Movie Studio of the PLA, was reallocated to a middle  See "Zhonggong zhongyang guanyu zhaidiao youpai maozi de renyuan de gongzuo fenpei he shenghuo daiyu de guiding" (Stipulations of the CCP Central Committee on Job Replacement and Remuneration of the ex-Rightists), in Hua Min, Zhongguo da nizhuan, 395-396. According to Wang Keqin, a navy lieutenant, his relocation was decided based on a document issued by the Central Military Commission in the end of 1959, which stipulated that all the ex-military rightists were to be assigned to jobs in regions close to where they were performing thought reform. Wang Keqin, interview. Wang Keqin, interview. See Hua Min, Zhongguo danizhuan, 395. 4 8 0  4 8 1 4 8 2  173  school in a nearby county seat, where he at first worked as an odd-jobman, cleaning things, boiling water, and ringing the school bell. When the school head happened to find with surprise that Chen was actually an American trained student who had graduated from the University of California, and that he had traveled and worked in ten or more countries around the world, Chen began to be given teaching workmath, physics, history, drawing, English and Japanese, etc., whenever regular teachers were on leave. While he was still treated as a politically unreliable person, he gradually came to be seen as a good teacher.  483  Like military rightists, the laogai convicts, including the sentenced political prisoners, were retained in Beidahuang when the majority of laojiao inmates left, although their treatment was different from the remaining military rightists. Confined separately in Xingkaihu, it seemed that the laogai inmates were not aware of the mass evacuation of the laojiao in 1960; the fact that 600 of their fellow convicts were transferred to the interior in 1961 did not catch much of their attention either.  484  Life kept going on, bitter and hopeless. The only good thing they  remembered was that their situation got better when the summer of 1962 came. Improved harvests brought an end to the three successive years of nation-wide famine. While grain continued to go to the national granary from Xingkaihu, some branches acquired a degree of freedom in planting more vegetable, and thus vegetable supplies for the inmates were increased.  485  Hunger was mitigated and  gradually came to an end. The most difficult years had passed. Many laogai convicts felt the pressure that resulted from the intensification of China's external relations. In the spring of 1962, Taiwan G M D leader Jiang Jieshi Chen Erzhen, interview. Like Chen, some remaining rightists managed to work in their areas of expertise to limited degree. During his service as a language arts teacher in an elementary school, playwright Shen Mojun went to local people to collect war hero stories. The result of his efforts was a well-know revolutionary play Red Lantern (Hongdengji), which, as a model play, was a huge success for all the years of the Cultural Revolution. See Dai Huang, Jiusi yisheng, 249-250. 4 8 3  When interviewed, neither Chen Fengxiao nor Yin Jiliang were able to recall the out-transfer of these people. However, Hui Peilin noticed that in the livestock farm where she worked, three Christian believers among around one hundred female laojiao inmates were sent to the interior. Hui Peilin, interview. Chen Fengxiao, unpublished work Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi (The True Stories of My Twenty-Two Years of Laogai Experience), 101. 4 8 4  4 8 5  174  actively made plans for a military attack o n the Mainland's southeast coast, which gave rise to the Taiwan Straits Crisis. W h i l e its ramification varied by locality, the political convicts in Xingkaihu labor reform complex were adversely affected: all the historical counterrevolutionaries were concentrated i n Branch 2, and a l l the active counterrevolutionaries were put into a special brigade, supervised and escorted to their work sites by armed P L A soldiers, a situation which was different from normal times. Working hours were reduced and the convicts were herded back before dark to their closely watched quarters to prevent possible riots.  A s well,  because o f the deterioration o f the Sino-Soviet relationship, Xingkaihu as a labor reform complex began to contract. Branch 1, located very close to the border river, was evacuated and its convicts were sent to other branches. N o new inmates were sent to Xingkaihu after 1963 because o f the precarious situation o f the Sino-Russian border.  487  Nevertheless, it was developments in national politics rather than external factors that terminated the Xingkaihu labor camp regime and changed the fortune o f the remaining political convicts. W i t h the outbreak o f the Cultural Revolution, the C C P ' s Beijing Municipal Committee and other municipal authorities were heavily pounded by the R e d Guard movement, thus the Beijing Public Security Bureau found it difficult to manage the Xingkaihu labor camps anymore at long distance. In September 1966 Xingkaihu was transferred to the Heilongjiang Provincial Public Security Bureau; i n February 1967 it was put under military control. B y September 1967 all the existing inmates, both the laogai convicts and jiuye  (forced job  placement) elements had been transferred to other labor camps managed by the Heilongjiang provincial police authorities.  488  Chen Fengxiao was at first transferred  Han Dajun, interview; Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 91-92. In normal time, the inmates were supervised by camp cadres in plainclothes when they went to work, and their working hours normally extended well late after dark. Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 409; Liu Junying, interview. Gazetteer of Xingkaihu Farm, 46-47. Heilongjiang, with its widely scattered labor reform facilities and its remote geographical location, has still been functioning as an important region for forced laborers. Hongda Harry Wu estimates 52 labor farms in present day Helongjiang. See Hongda Harry Wu, Laogai— the Chinese Gulag (Boulder: Westview Press, 1992), 150. According to the transferred inmates, the most notorious ones among Heilongjiang provincial labor farms were Changshuihe Farm 4 8 0  487  488  175  to Changshuihe Farm, in B e i ' a n County, and then to Wulan Farm, i n Zhalaite County until he completed his term i n 1972. Y i n Jiliang, as a forced job placement element, was transferred to the Suiling Farm. H u i Peilin, also a forced j o b placement element, was sent to a weaving m i l l i n Yinhe Farm and then to a nearby commune.  489  Xingkaihu had completed its role as a labor reform regime.  With most political exiles being relocated to Beijing or other provinces i n the early 1960s, the post-1957 frontier banishment to Beidahuang came to an end. For the victims o f the 1957 persecution, however, their withdrawal from the great wilderness did not necessarily spell the end o f their internal exile. Rightists all too often had to perform their ideological remolding through labor in local farms; as well, those inmates transferred away from Xingkaihu had to continue their forced labor i n dozens o f other labor camps i n Heilongjiang or in north China until they were rehabilitated at the end o f 1970s.  Qinghe and Tuanhe: Laojiao Inmates in North China In the winter o f 1960, political offenders among the laojiao elements in Xingkaihu were transferred to Qinghe Farm, in eastern Tianjin. Tan Tianrong, L i u Naiyuan, W u Ningkun and H a n Dujun were among them. Qinghe farm, located i n Ninghe County (Tianjin), was another labor reform complex established by the Beijing Public Security Bureau outside the Beijing Municipality. Starting from the early 1950s, various political outcasts including landlord  elements,  officials  of  the  former  G M D government  and  other  counterrevolutionaries were sent to perform forced labor i n this marshland o f around 300 square kilometers. W i t h the Anti-Rightist Campaign o f 1957, several thousand rightists from Beijing were punished to reeducation through labor and sent to Qinghe, followed by various pretty criminals arrested i n B e i j i n g  4 9 0  From late 1960  to m i d 1961, laojiao inmates from various locations o f north and northeast China (Bei'an), Hada Farm (Mudanjiang), Yanjiagang Farm (Harbin), Wulan Farm (Zhalaite), Suiling Farm (Suiling), and Yinhe Farm (Gannan). Chen Fengxiao, Ershier nian laogai shengya jishi, 111, 146; Yin Jiliang, Hui Peilin, interviews. For detail information about Qinghe Farm, see Hongda Harry Wu, Laogai—the Chinese Gulag, Appendix 3, 218-223. 4 8 9  4 9 0  176  began to congregate in Qinghe, i n which the lives o f Xingkaihu inmates and o f others from north China such as Hongda Harry W u and C o n g W e i x i crossed.  491  U p o n arrival, the Xingkaihu transferees found themselves entrenched i n a more scary world that featured "high walls that were topped by electrified wire." A s W u Ningkun notes, " W e were taken into the monstrosity by sour-faced officers, through an entrance guarded by several soldiers holding rifles with fixed bayonets. Above them i n the turrets were other soldiers holding submachine guns."  492  The  grim scene as well as the treatment they received afterwards shattered the hope o f the laojiao rightists who expected better food and better treatment in the interior.  493  The first thing they encountered in Qinghe was continuing deterioration o f food supplies. A s discussed i n Chapter Four, inmates in Xingkaihu were  officially  rationed 45 jin or at least 30 jin grain when they performed heavy labor. Soon after they arrived at Qinghe, their grain rationed dropped to 18 jin o f sweet potato flour, which was at times replaced by "food substitutes" made o f powdered corncobs, bean stalks, elm bark, rice grass, and so o n .  4 9 4  The inmates were driven by hunger to  search everywhere they could for anything edible. Qinghe was haunted with hungry ghosts during late 1961 and early 1962. The death rate, according to the personal experience o f W u Ningkun, was probably higher than i n Xingkaihu. The grave pit o f an inmate he buried bore the number 6 1 3 0 1 .  495  For those coming from Xingkaihu,  Shortly after the Xingkaihu inmates, Hongda Harry Wu was transferred to Qinghe from a labor mine in Yanqing, and Cong Weixi from Tucheng detention center, both north of Beijing See Hongda Harry Wu, Bitter Winds, 98-99; Cong Weixi, Zouxiang hundun, 153. Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear, 127. Han Dajun, who was put in the same branch farm with Liu Naiyuan, recalls that "We were taken by truck to Branch 3, which was encircled by a high square wall, and reinforced by electrified barbed-wire entanglement and four watch towers at the corners. A row of one-storey cells had been built close to the wall, which accommodated the laogai teams, laojiao teams and juvenile teams. We entered the worst famine period that was marked by 16-18 jin of sweet potatoflouras monthly ration, without food oil and vegetable." Han Dajun, interview. As Wu Ningkun recalls, the laojiao inmates originally "hoped that Qinghe state farm's close proximity to the national capital would bring more humane treatment and better food", as well as "better hopes of release." Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear, 109, 127. Some, such as Han Dajun, hoped that it would be easier for their families to visit them. Han Dajun interview. Liu Naiyuan, Mirror, 252-253. Wu Ningkun, A Single Tear, 136. 4 9 1  4 9 2  4 9 3  4 9 4 4 9 5  177  the years i n Qinghe was another horrible period o f their tribulations. Those still alive felt their lives withering away i n a hapless numbness.  496  During their confinement i n Qinghe, a major issue that made laojiao rightists indignant was the official explanation o f the period o f reeducation through labor. According to the laojiao regulations promulgated on August 3, 1957, as discussed i n Chapter Five, the laojiao inmates who displayed real repentance and behaved well i n the labor camps could be released. Although many ultra-rightists fell into police custody and began their internment shortly after the Anti-Rightist Campaign, in early or m i d 1958, and many tried their best for release as early as possible, none o f them were released until M a y 24, 1961 when the camp authorities suddenly announced that this day was the beginning o f their labor reeducation.  497  Resentment  among the laojiao rightist was tremendous since their three years o f internment and suffering had gone in vain. F e w dared to question the logic behind the decision, however, instead they " a l l appreciated the favor o f the socialist legal system, were grateful for the leniency shown by Chairman M a o and the P a r t y . "  498  The camp authorities did not provide an explanation for the decision, and no official record has been found regarding whether the decision was merely applicable to the inmates in camps close to Beijing or applied to those i n the whole country. Nevertheless, a C C P document enacted afterwards in June 1962 might help reveal the intention o f the Party and state to prevent laojiao inmates from returning to urban areas. The document reads: " W i t h regard to the rightists and the hat removed elements who have completed their labor reeducation and need to be sent back to urban areas, it is necessary to hold them for a period, and to make effort to support  Liu Naiyuan describes how the surviving inmates in the 1962 winter killed their time in a cold, dead silent cell after a meager dinner. "Each climbed up to his part of the long wooden