Open Collections

UBC Theses and Dissertations

UBC Theses Logo

UBC Theses and Dissertations

Development of a murine model of actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans-induced pathogenesis Colfer, Ellen Lee 2000

Your browser doesn't seem to have a PDF viewer, please download the PDF to view this item.

Item Metadata

Download

Media
831-ubc_2000-0041.pdf [ 5.42MB ]
Metadata
JSON: 831-1.0089376.json
JSON-LD: 831-1.0089376-ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 831-1.0089376-rdf.xml
RDF/JSON: 831-1.0089376-rdf.json
Turtle: 831-1.0089376-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 831-1.0089376-rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 831-1.0089376-source.json
Full Text
831-1.0089376-fulltext.txt
Citation
831-1.0089376.ris

Full Text

DEVELOPMENT OF A MURINE MODEL OF ACTINOBACILLUS ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS-INDUCED PATHOGENESIS By E L L E N LEE COLFER D D S , University of Toronto, 1996  A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL F U L F I L L M E N T O F T H E REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF SCIENCE in T H E F A C U L T Y OF G R A D U A T E STUDIES (Department o f Oral Biological and Medical Sciences)  We accept this thesis as conforming to the required standard  T H E UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH C O L U M B I A December 10, 1999 © E L L E N L E E COLFER  In  presenting  degree freely  at  this  the  thesis  in  partial  University  of  British  available for  copying  of  department publication  this or of  reference  thesis by  this  for  his thesis  fulfilment  scholarly  for  her  the  requirements  Columbia, I - agree  and study.  or  of  I further  purposes  financial  agree that  may  representatives.  that the  It  gain shall not  be is  Library  permission  granted  by  understood be  for  an  advanced  shall make for  the that  allowed without  extensive  head  of  my  copying  or  my  written  permission.  D e p a r t ™ , o, The University of British C o l u m b i a Vancouver, Canada  DE-6 (2/88)  /  it  g / ^ ^ j ^ o ^  ABSTRACT  Animals have been used in health sciences for over 100 years to study the mechanism and virulence of bacterial pathogens. M a n y variations o f the abscess model o f inflammation have been developed but they do not provide the ability to easily quantify the resulting pathology. The aims o f this study were to 1) develop a quantitative method of grading an inflammatory response to Actinobacillus (A. actinomycetemcomitans)  actinomycetemcomitans-mduc&d  inflammation using non-viable bacteria, 2) determine the  reproducibility o f the inflammatory and immunohistologic response and 3) determine the virulence o f three strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans  using the proposed grading  system developed in the model.  During the study, C D - I mice were injected s.e. in the ear and/or abdomen with two serotypes strains (three strains) of A. actinomycetemcomitans  bacteria, JP2 (serotype b),  A T C C 43718-Y4 (serotype b) and I D H 1705 (serotype e). Two grading systems were proposed for histological and immunohistological evaluation o f the tissues. The histological evaluation was based on the area o f the inflammatory spread within the tissues and number o f inflammatory cells counted using an optic grid. The immunohistologic response was determined for the three antibodies; F4/80 antimonocyte/macrophage antibody, anti-neutrophil antibody and anti-CD3 T cell antibody, by the number of cells found in the tissues. The reproducibility o f the kinetic study was  ii  deterirrined by nonparametric analysis o f variance using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic.  The results of the study did revealed that non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans could elicit both an inflammatory and an immunohistologic response. The quantitative analysis for both the Histologic Score and the Immunohistologic Score suggested that there was a difference in virulence between the strains that was also dependent on dose (dilution) and time. The results demonstrated a strong trend towards a graded virulence and immunological responses of JP2 >_Y4 >_IDH 1705.  iii  T A B L E OF CONTENTS  ABSTRACT  ii  T A B L E OF CONTENTS  iv  LIST O F T A B L E S  vii  LIST O F F I G U R E S  viii  ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS  x  DEDICATION  xi  CHAPTER ONE - LITERATURE REVIEW  .1.1 PERIODONTAL DISEASE 1 1.1.1 Definition of Periodontal Disease 1 1.1.2 Classification of Periodontal Disease 1 1.1.2.1 Gingivitis 2 1.1.2.2 Periodontitis 5 1.1.3 Categories of Periodontal Disease 6 1.1.3.1 Adult Periodontitis 8 1.1.3.2 Early Onset Periodontitis 8 1.1.3.2.1 Prepubertal Periodontitis 9 1.1.3.2.2 Juvenile Periodontitis 9 1.1.3.2.3 Rapidly Progressive Periodontitis 11 1.1.3.3 Periodontitis Associated with Systemic Disease 11 1.1.3.4 Necrotizing Ulcerative Periodontitis 15 1.1.3.5 Refractory Periodontitis 16 1.1.4 Pathogenesis of Periodontal Disease 17 1.1.4.1 Microbial Challenge 18 1.1.4.2 Microbial Virulence 19 1.1.4.3 Protective Host and Immune Response 20 1.1.4.4 Destructive Immune Response 22 1.1.4.4.1 Tissue and Extracellular Matrix Destruction ....23 1.1.4.4.2 Destruction of Bone 25 1.2 ACTINOBACILLUS  ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS  PERIODONTITIS 1.2.1 Biotypes, Serology and Strains 1.2.2 Virulence Characteristics 1.2.3 Host Susceptibility 1.3 ANIMAL MODELS IN PERIODONTAL DISEASE  iv  IN  27 28 32 36  1.4 O B J E C T I V E S O F T H E S T U D Y  40  CHAPTER TWO - MATERIAL AND METHODS 2.1 A N I M A L S  42  2.2 B A C T E R I A  42  2.3 I N J E C T I O N S  43  2.4 T I M E I N T E R V A L S  46  2.5 M U R I N E V I R U L E N C E M O D E L S  46  2.6 H I S T O L O G I C A L P R E P A R A T I O N A N D P R O T O C O L  47  2.7 I M M U N O L O G I C A L M E T H O D S A N D P R E P A R A T I O N 2.7.1 Antibodies 2.7.2 Staining Method  51 51 52  2.8  53  STATISTICAL ANALYSIS  CHAPTER THREE - RESULTS 3.1  M E T H O D O L O G Y FOR THE E V A L U A T I O N OF HISTOLOGICAL A N D IMMUNOHISTOLOGICAL SCORE 54 3.1.1 Histologic Score 54 3.1.2 Immunohistologic Score 61  3.2  C O M P A R I S O N OF S U B C U T A N E O U S INJECTIONS OF E A R A N D A B D O M E N FOR ELICITATION OF I N F L A M M A T O R Y RESPONSE  67  3.3  D O S E D E P E N D E N C Y OF I N F L A M M A T O R Y R E S P O N S E IN E A R A N D A B D O M E N (JP2) A T D A Y 15 72  3.4  KINETIC ANALYSIS OF I N F L A M M A T O R Y RESPONSE OF THREE S T R A I N S O F A. ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS 81  3.5 DOSE DEPENDENCY OF INFLAMMATORY RESPONSE OF THREE STRAINS OF A. ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS 87 3.6 REPRODUCIBILITY OF THE KINETIC RESPONSE  90  3.7 IMMUNOHISTOLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF THE CELLULAR INFILTRATE MEDIATED BY THREE STRAINS OF A. ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS  93  CHAPTER FOUR - DISCUSSION  4.1 INFLAMMATORY RESPONSE OF VIABLE BACTERIA COMPARE TO NON-VIABLE BACTERIA IN MICE 99 4.2 NON-VIABLE BACTERIAL MURINE MODEL COMPARED TO THE MURINE ABSCESS MODEL 101 4.2.1 Histologic Response in the M A M and Non-viable Bacterial Model 102 4.2.1.1 Time/Dose Effects on the Histologic Response 103 4.2.2 Immunohistological Response in the M A M and Non-viable Bacterial Model 4.2.2.1 Time Effects on the Immunohistologic Response 4.3 STRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES OF THE A. ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS-INDVCED MODEL OF INFLAMMATION  105 105  106  CHAPTER FIVE - CONCLUSIONS  109  REFERENCES  110  vi  LIST O F T A B L E S  TABLE  1 - Immunohistologic Score of F4/80, Neutrophil and CD3 Antibodies at day 5 and 15 for undilute JP2  95  vii  LIST OF FIGURES  Figure 1(a) Injection of Mouse Ear 1(b) Injection of Mouse Abdomen  45 45  Figure 2 Histologic Score (magnification X l O and X40) 2(a) Grade 1 - IDH 1705 - day 5 2(b) Grade 2 - A T C C 43718 - day 15 2(c) Grade 3 - A T C C 43718 - day 5 2(d) Grade 4 - JP2 - day 5  57 58 59 60  Figure 3 Immunohistologic Score (magnification X l O and X40) 3(a) Grade 1 - IDH 1705 - CD3 - day 15 3(b) Grade 2 - A T C C 43718 - Neutrophil - day 5 3(c) Grade 3 - JP2 - Neutrophil - day 15 3(d) Grade 4 - A T C C 43718 - F4/80  63 64 65 66  Figure 4(a) Inflammatory Response in Ear - PBS Control and JP2 - day 5 4(b) Inflammatory Response in Abdomen - PBS Control and JP2 - day 5  70 71  Figure 5 Inflammatory Response of Varying Dilutions of JP2 - (Graph) - Ear and Abdomen - day 15  74  Figure 6 Inflammatory Response of Varying Dilutions of JP2 -Ear - day 15 (XlO) 6(a) 0.05 X10 bacterial equivalents/ml 6(b) 0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml 6(c) 1.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml 6(d) 5.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml 9  9  9  9  .76 76 77 78  Figure 7 Inflammatory Response of Varying Dilutions of JP2 - Abdomen - day 15 (XlO) 7(a) 0.05 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml 79 7(b) 0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml 79 7(c) 1.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml 80 7(d) 5.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml 80 9  9  9  9  Figure 8(a) 8(b) 8(c) 8(d)  Kinetic Response of 3 Undilute Strains - day 5, 15, 25 - Ear 84 Kinetic Response of 3 Undilute Strains - day 5, 15, 25 - Abdomen 84 Inflammatory Response of 3 Undilute strains - day 5, 15, 25 - Ear (X40)..85 Inflammatory response of 3 Undilute strains - day 5, 15, 25 - Abdomen (X40) 86  Figure 9 Inflammatory Response of Varying Dilutions of 3 Strains - day 15 Abdomen  viii  89  Figure 10 Mean Histologic Scores o f 3 Strains - (0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml)- day 15 9  92  Figure 11 Immunohistologic Response o f 3 Antibodies - d a y 5 and 15 ( X l O ) 11(a) Immunologic Response o f Antibody F4/80 for JP2 at day5 and 15 96 11(b) Immunologic Response o f Neutrophil Antibody for JP2 at day5 and 15...97 11 (c) Immunologic Response o f Antibody C D 3 for JP2 at day 5 and 15 98  ix  ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS  To Dr. Doug Waterfield, my thesis supervisor, thank you for your guidance, support, kindness and most of all your patience during the development o f my thesis.  To the members of my thesis committee, Dr. E . Putnins, Dr. H . Larjava and D r . J. Uitto, thank you for your insight and constructive participation throughout this project.  To Dr. Rendy Yan, thank you for your laboratory expertise and help with the histology and immunology in this study.  DEDICATION  This paper is dedicated to the late Dr. John Charles Leishman, D D S (1947-1993), who's professionalism, ethics, and kindness to others has influenced me forever. John, you were my employer, my mentor, and most o f all, my friend. Thank you for believing in me.  xi  CHAPTER ONE - LITERATURE REVIEW  1.1 PERIODONTAL DISEASE  1.1.1 Definition of Periodontal Disease  Periodontal diseases have afflicted mankind around the world for centuries. Skulls from ancient civilizations indicate that alveolar bone loss and destructive periodontal disease were a common dental finding. Early writings are replete with descriptions o f the disease o f the gums as well as primitive remedies and methods o f prevention of this disease (Shklar & Carranza, 1996).  Periodontitis is an inflammatory condition o f the periodontal tissues, involving the periodontal ligament and loss o f the bony support around the tooth (Burt & Eklund, 1992; Susuki, 1988; Page & Schroeder, 1976). Genco (1988,1996) refers to periodontal diseases as infections, resulting in periodontal pocket formation, loss of gingival and periodontal connective tissue attachments and loss o f tooth-supporting alveolar bone. The term periodontal  disease actually  describes a group o f soft tissue diseases that involve complex bacterial-host cell interactions, with particular forms o f the disease becoming more understood (Burt & Eklund, 1992; Meyer & Fives-Taylor, 1997).  1.1.2 Classification of Periodontal Diseases  Gingivitis is an inflammatory condition restricted to the gingiva itself (Listgarten, Schifter & Laster, 1985; Suzuki, 1988; Ranney, 1993) whereas the inflammations extending to involve the periodontal ligament, cementum, or alveolar bone are considered Periodontitis (Listgarten, 1986; Suzuki, 1988; Ranney, 1993; Kornman, Page & Tonetti, 1997).  1  1.1.2.1  Gingivitis  Gingivitis is caused initially by bacteria that colonize the gingival sulcus and adjacent tooth surfaces (Loe, Theilade, & Jensen, 1965; Theilade, Wright Jensen & Loe, 1966; Lindhe, Hamp & Loe, 1973, 1975). As the disease becomes more severe, there is a more apical extension of the inflammation over time. Although this plaque-associated gingivitis has been shown to be related to bacterial accumulations, the composition o f the flora is not very specific (Moore et al, 1987).  The severity o f plaque- related gingivitis could be aggravated by coexisting systemic conditions resulting in clinical manifestations from the gingival margin to the mucogingival junction. In this case, gingivitis can be attributed to drugs such as calcium channel blockers (nifedipine and oxodipine), anticonvulsants (phenytoin or diphenylhydantoin), or immunosuppressants (cyclosporin). In these cases the clinical findings include diffuse swellings of interdental papillae, or a marginal collar or festooning o f the tissue around the clinical crowns o f the teeth (Suzuki, 1988). The connective tissue fibroblasts respond with abnormal rates o f mitosis when these medications are taken. The amount of associated inflammation is a function of the bacterial plaque accumulations.  Gingivitis can also be seen in patients taking oral contraceptives (Pearlman, 1974) or associated with pregnancy (Loe, 1986) and altered hormonal balances, due in part to the effects of progesterone on the micro vasculature of inflamed connective tissue (Hugoson, 1970). Estrogens also play a role in amplifying the clinical inflammatory changes of gingivitis. Steroid hormone therapy use may result in enhanced gingival tissue responses similar to the overall systemic response seen in the reproductive organs and mammary glands (Suzuki, 1988). These clinical signs and symptoms include acute mflammation around one or more plaque retentive areas, with spontaneous bleeding being a common finding. Pyogenic granulomas may be the outcome o f more severe gingival lesions.  2  When severe gingivitis is seen without severe plaque accumulations, especially in children, other systemic factors are suspected such as blood dyscrasias, vitamin deficiencies, leukemia, and granulomatosis.  There is also a necrotizing form of gingivitis that presents as ulcerated margins or punched-out papillae, often accompanied by pain, lymphadenopathy, elevated temperature, malaise, malodor and a sloughing grayish white psuedomembrane over the affected gingiva. The extent of these ANUG (acute necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis) lesions may include isolated interproximal areas or may be generalized throughout the entire dentition (Suzuki, 1988). This necrotizing gingivitis has been associated with bacterial invasions of spirochetes, Bacteroides (Porphyromonas Prevotella), Fusobacterium  or  sp. and other bacteria (Loesche et al, 1982) as well as possible  mental or physical stress (Goldhaber, 1964; Stevens et al, 1984), and human immunodeficiency virus ( H I V ) (Rowlands etal,  1991). Rowlands et al, 1991 suggest that H I V infection should be  suspected when the signs o f necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis are present.  Gingivitis is also associated with dermatological diseases including lichen planus, mucous membrane pemphigoid, pemphigus and other vesiculobullous disorders, including oral manifestations of epidermolysis bullosa and ectodermal dysplasia. Desquamative  Gingivitis was  once thought to be a nonspecific oral manifestation o f a variety o f metabolic disturbances (McCarthy, McCarthy & Shklar, 1960; Scopp, 1964; Glickman & Smulow, 1965) based on clinical and histologic findings. The use of electron microscopy and immunofluorescent techniques led to a better understanding o f the diseases involved, allowing more accurate diagnosis and treatment (Rogers, Sheridian, & Jordan, 1976; Markopoulos et al, 1996).  In an early paper by Weinmann (1941), several theories of progression from gingivitis to periodontitis are discussed. One such theory suggested that inflammation from gingivitis spread into the periodontal membrane (Black G V , 1936; Talbot E S , 1899; Fish E W , 1939) as 3  "the lymphatics within the periodontal membrane form the natural route for the movement of infection.. .from the gingiva through the periodontal ligament to the apex of the tooth."  1  Another theory suggested that the inflammation extended into the external surface of the alveolar process and into the bone marrow spaces (Noyes FB, 1927; Coolidge ED, 1931). A third theory proposed that " the path of invasion passes through the gum-corium to the alveolar bone.. .and later, the periodontal membrane." Weinmann (1941) showed that inflammation actually 2  followed the blood vessels but there was still great controversy of how gingivitis progressed to periodontitis. Progression was commonly associated with destruction of the connective tissue attachment to the tooth and apical migration of the junctional epithelium beyond the cementoenamel junction (Hull, Soames & Davies, 1974). Further disease involved bone loss and progressive gingival involvement (Listgarten, 1986). Early studies indicated that human periodontal disease started in childhood and progressed steadily with increasing age (Gad, 1968). In a study of untreated periodontal disease, Becker, Berg and Becker (1979) report that although annual deterioration scores were related to patient age, there was an inverse relationship between pocket depth increase and patient age; as age increased, mean annual deterioration scores decreased. Hirschfield and Wasserman (1978) demonstrated in their study of 420 treated patients, followed from 15-50 years, that bone loss did occur among all patients but to varying degrees and patients were classified as "Well-maintained", "Downhill" or "Extreme Downhill" depending on tooth loss over the period of the study.  Animal studies using squirrel monkeys, or beagle dogs, demonstrated that it could take years for progressive soft tissue destruction and eventual bone loss to be apparent (Gad, 1968; Hull,  Black GV. Operative Dentistry Vol. 4: 165. Chicago, Medico-Dental Publishing Co., 1936. In Weinmann JP Progression of gingival inflammation into the supporting structures of the teeth. J Periodont. 12(2): 71-81, 1941. 1  James WW and Counsell A. Brit Dent J. 48: 1237, 1927. In Weinmann JP. Progression of gingival inflammation into the supporting structures of the teeth. J Periodont. 12(2): 71-81, 1941.  2  4  Soames, Davies 1974; Soames, Entwisle & Davies, 1976; Heijk, Rifkin, Zander, Schei, 1976), confirming human findings. Lindhe, Hamp and Loe (1975) demonstrated in their beagle dog study o f plaque-induced periodontal disease that as was found in humans, not all gingivitis progressed to periodontal disease (Anerud A , L o e H , Boysen H & Smith M , 1979; Listgarten, Schifter & Laster, 1985). T w o out of 20 dogs in the study had no roentgenographical signs o f alveolar bone loss.  1.1.2.2 Periodontitis: Progression  The clinical progression from gingivitis to periodontitis reflects a histopathologic progression from an established lesion to a more advanced stage of the disease. Three plausible hypotheses for this occurrence have been advanced: 1. Bacterial tissue destruction (plaque); 2.Hyperresponsiveness o f the immune system resulting in immune complexes, lymphocyte blastogenesis and/or activation o f the complement pathways; 3. Ffyporesponsiveness or immune deficiencies involving neutrophil functions (such as chemotaxis, phagocytosis), neutropenia, or autologous mixed lymphocyte response (Suzuki, 1988).  Page and Schroeder (1976) considered four stages of inflammatory periodontitis: the Initial, Early, Established and Advanced stage(s) based on the histologic presentation of the lesions. The first three categories are descriptions of gingivitis, and the fourth stage describes the more advanced periodontal lesion.  The Initial lesion, which appears clinically normal, occurs within 2-4 days, and is characterized by vascular dilation and increased permeability to fluid and lymphocytic cells. There is  5  increased P M N extravasation and migration, alterations o f the junctional epithelium and loss of perivascular collagen.  The Early lesion, occurring approximately 4-7 days later and up to 21 days, is identified by a lymphocyte-rich infiltrate adjacent to the junctional epithelium, with increased collagen loss. At this stage there are cytotoxic effects on the fibroblasts and the lesion may be subclinical or show clinical signs o f gingivitis.  The Established lesion is a further extension of the early lesion with plasma cells rjecoming the dominant cell o f the inflammatory infiltrate. There is further collagen loss, junctional epithelial cell proliferation and pocket formation. Lymphocytes can be seen in the connective tissues particularly B cells. This stage is protective and reversible and/or pockets may persist for years with no further destruction.  The Advanced lesion has all the signs and symptoms o f chronic gingivitis plus attachment loss, bone destruction, pocket formation and apical migration of the junctional epithelium. There may be fibrosis of bone marrow and further collagen loss. P M N s and B-cells continue to infiltrate the lesion that is characterized by periods of quiescence, but with the signs and symptoms o f chronic inflammation and bursts of activity resulting in further attachment loss.  1.1.3 Categories of Periodontal Disease  Various forms o f periodontitis have been described based primarily on clinical observations and basic scientific research over the years. The term "pyorrhea alveolaris" was used by F . H . 3  Rehwinkl (1823) who was associated with the Baltimore College of Dental Surgery and brought  6  the term from Germany when he emigrated to the United States. Later that century, John W . Riggs also of Baltimore College o f Dental Surgery, became the leading authority on periodontal disease and alveolar pyorrhea became later known as "Riggs Disease". Merritt (1931), Black 4  (1936), and Fish (1939) described periodontitis as "chronic suppurative pericementitis" . 5  Other synonyms not in current use included "schmutz pyorrhea"(Gottlieb), "paradentitis" (Weski, Beck), "paradentosis", "periodontoclasia", "pericementitis", "parodontitis", and "alveoclasia"  6  The clinical diagnosis of progressing periodontitis was described in early works of Schei (1949), Belting, Massler and Schour (1953), and Marshall-Day and Shourie (1949). The loss o f bone was considered a "cardinal symptom" o f periodontal disease, as was the resorption o f the alveolar crest evaluated roentgenologically. Marshall-Day and Shourie (1949) provided an early system of measuring bone loss radiographically, using percentages of maximum bone height measured with the aid of a specially developed translucent ruler.  There are several accepted classifications o f periodontal disease. A l l include the recognition of several types o f periodontal disease "that have differences among them in etiology, natural history, progression and response to therapy".  7  The following descriptions are based on the  disease categories established by the World Workshop in Clinical Periodontics, 1989.  CarranzaF.A. and Newman M.G. Clinical Periodontology, 8 edition: 6. W.B. Saunders Company, 1996. Carranza F.A. and Newman M.G. Clinical Periodontology, 8 edition: 6. W.B. Saunders Company, 1996. Black G.V. Operative Dentistry 4, Chicago, Medico-Dental Publishing Co., 1936. In Weinmann JP. Progression of Gingival Inflammation into the supporting structures of the teeth. J. Periodont. 12(2): 71, 1941. Carranza F.A and Newman M.G. Clinical Periodontology, 8 edition: 59. W.B. Saunders Company, 1996. 3  th  4  th  5  6  th  7  1.1.3.1 Adult Periodontitis  Adult periodontitis is the most prevalent form o f periodontitis clinically recognized after the age of 35. Adult periodontitis has a slow rate o f progression (Listgarten M A , 1986), either occurring over time in random bursts o f disease activity (Goodson et al, 1982) or, as proposed by Jeffcoat & Reddy (1991), in a continuous, slow progression. The bacteria associated with adult periodontitis include P. gingivalis, P. intermedia, P. micros, Fusobacterium forsythus, C. rectus, T. denticola, A. actinomycetemcomitans, Bacteroides, spirochetes, and Staphyloccoccus  species, B.  Capnocytophaga,  black-pigmented  species. There is however, no consistent  significant associations o f given species with episodes o f progression (Zambon JJ, 1996).  1.1.3.2 Early-Onset Periodontitis  When severe periodontal disease occurs in very young patients (preteens), teenagers and young adults to age 35, it is considered to be early-onset periodontitis. The American Academy o f Periodontology (1989) divides early-onset periodontitis into Prepubertal Periodontitis, Juvenile Periodontitis, and Rapidly Progressive Periodontitis. Prepubertal and Juvenile Periodontitis are further subdivided into localized (LJP) and generalized (GJP) forms o f the disease based on intraoral distribution o f affected sites and severity.  7  Ranney RR. Classification of periodontal diseases. Periodontology 2000. 2: 16, 1993.  8  1.1.3.2.1  Prepubertal Periodontitis  The age o f onset o f prepubertal periodontitis is 4 years or earlier although it may not be detected until age 7 to 9.  It can also be divided into a localized and generalized form. In the localized  form, many or only a few primary teeth are affected. The gingival tissues are only slightly inflamed and microbial plaque, i f present, is minimal. Deep pocket formation with destruction of alveolar bone is more rapid than that found in adult periodontitis, but slower than the generalized form o f prepubertal periodontitis. The generalized form o f the disease demonstrates fiery red inflammation of the marginal and attached gingiva combined with gingival proliferation, cleft formation and recession. Alveolar bone as well as tooth roots may resorb, at an extremely rapid rate. The disease can begin with tooth eruption and all primary teeth may be lost by age 2 or 3 years old. In both the localized and the generalized form o f prepubertal periodontitis, otitis media and upper respiratory tract infections may be present. Another trait in common for both forms o f the disease is that these children appear to have defective peripheral blood leukocyte function, either neutrophil or monocyte chemotaxis and adherence (Genco et al., 1986; V a n Dyke & Hoop, 1990), phagocytosis or both (Altman et al, 1980; Bowen et al., 1982).  Prepubertal periodontitis may be followed by a normal permanent dentition or by severe  periodontitis in the permanent teeth (Page etal., 1983).  1.1.3.2.2 Juvenile Periodontitis  This disease affects teenagers and young adults who are otherwise healthy (Schenkein & V a n Dyke, 1994), and is also divided into a localized and generalized form.  9  Localized Juvenile Periodontitis is typically limited to severe loss o f alveolar bone around the first molars and incisors, although involvement of 1-2 teeth other than first molars or incisors is allowed within the disease definition (Burmeister et al, 1984; V a n Dyke et al, 1980). This pattern of disease can persist into the mid-to late twenties or later in many o f the cases (Ranny, 1991). These patients rarely demonstrate accumulations of plaque or calculus despite the severity of the disease (Baer, 1971; Waerhaug, 1977). The microbial flora associated with localized juvenile periodontitis (LJP) lesions are predominantly anaerobic and capnophilic rods (Slots, 1976). A. actinomycetemcomitans  is the bacteria most strongly associated with L J P  (Socransky 1977; Slots 1979; Slots & Dahlen 1979, 1984; Christersson etal Zambon 1985), along with some Capnocytophaga  1983, 1985;  strains (Gjermo, 1986). A high percentage of  J P patients (77%) demonstrate decreased neutrophil chemotactic response and depressed phagocytosis (Astemborski et al, 1989).  Generalized Juvenile Periodontitis (GJP) is found in older juveniles and young adults (Page, 1983), with the disease often involving the entire dentition. These patients differ from L J P patients in that they usually display generalized severe inflammation and heavy accumulations o f plaque and calculus (Page, 1983). Astemborski et al (1989) described F o r m A type G J P , characterized by minimal plaque and an age range from 14 to 26 years old, involving females more than males, and having a decreased neutrophil chemotactic defect. F o r m B type G J P was characterized as having significant plaque accumulations and an age range from ages 26-35, o f undetermined sex distribution with normal or decreased neutrophil chemotactic response (Astemborski et al, 1989). The microbiota associated with G J P includes high percentages of nonmotile, facultative anaerobic, Gram-negative rods such as Porphyromonas 1982; Wilson, Zambon Suzuki & Genco, 1985), along with Prevotella Capnocytophaga,  gingivalis (Slots,  intermedia,  Eikonella corrodens and Neisseria are common isolates in G J P . A.  10  actinomycetemcomitans is present but in low numbers (Newman & Nisengard, 1988).  1.1.3.2.3 Rapidly Progressive Periodontitis  Rapidly progressive periodontitis is a disease form characterized by relatively rapid loss o f clinical attachment and alveolar bone in young adults. The early stages o f R P P may involve localized moderate to deep periodontal pockets and early bone loss. However, the later stages o f RPP, which can take only a few months to develop, demonstrate generalized moderate to deep pocket formation, and severe loss o f attachment and bone (Suzuki, 1988). Page (1983) described the disease as rapid, with periods o f acute, often painful tissue inflammation displaying hemorrhage and exudate. Mobility and tooth loss were seen in the later stages. Suzuki (1988) described another type of R P P (Type B ) occurring in older patients, 26-35 years of age, with moderate to heavy plaque deposits. There is, however, little clinical significance of Type B as it may be confused with early adult periodontitis or GJP. Neutrophil chemotaxis is depressed in approximately 66% of patients (Levine, 1997; V a n Dyke, 1982), as is the autogenous mixed lymphocyte reaction ( A M L R ) . This may account for the increased rate o f pathogenesis with R P P (Suzuki, 1988).  1.1.3.3 Periodontitis associated with systemic disease  Periodontitis and tooth loss has been associated with several systemic diseases (Suzuki, 1988; Watanabe, 1989; Ranny, 1993). These include Leukocyte Adhesion Deficiency ( L A D ) , Hypophosphatasia, Papillon-Lefevere Syndrome, Neutropenia, Leukemias, Chediak-Higashi 11  Syndrome, A I D S , Insulin-dependent Diabetes Mellitus, Down's Syndrome, and Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome ( T y p e V l 11). Pre-pubertal periodontitis has been associated with most of these systemic disorders.  Leukocyte Adhesion Deficiency is characterized by severe acute inflammation, rapid bone destruction and proliferation o f the gingival tissues (Waldrop et al., 1987; Ranney, 1993). These patients can display other disorders such as respiratory tract infections or otitis media, septicemia, and impaired pus formation (Meyle, 1994; Carranza & Newman, 1996). Page et al. (1983, 1987), noted that patients with L A D had abnormalities o f leukocyte chemotaxis, or function. They also contributed to the severity and rapidity o f the periodontal progression in children with prepubertal periodontitis to the abnormally low levels o f adherence glycoproteins on leukocyte cells, not seen in JP, R P P or A P (Page et al, 1987). Waldrop et al. in that same year published data that demonstrated, using monoclonal antibodies against Mac-1, L F A - 1 (leukocyte function antigen-1), and p l 5 0 , 95 adhesion molecules, that generalized prepubertal periodontitis was an oral manifestation of L A D .  Hypophosphatasia  is a rare skeletal disease seen in patients with a quantitative deficiency o f  alkaline phosphatase, resulting in a failure to develop a periodontal ligament due to a disturbance in cementogenesis. Other clinical manifestations include rickets, poor cranial bone formation, craneostenosis and premature loss of teeth (Carranza & Newman, 1996).  Leukemia can result in severe periodontal changes such as the infiltration of the gingiva and alveolar bone with leukemia cells, resulting in leukemic gingival enlargements. The gingiva appears red or bluish, cyanotic, rounded, and swollen, and bleeding can be spontaneous.  12  Neutropenia, characterized by a reduction in the number o f circulating granulocytes, results in severe inflammations such as necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis, gingival hemorrhage, and periodontal destruction.  , Chediak-Higashi  Syndrome is a rare disease that effects the production o f organelles in almost  every cell, producing mild bleeding disorders and recurrent bacterial infections (Carranza & Newman, 1996). Functional neutrophil defects include decreased chemotaxis, degranulation, and microbicidal activity. Oral manifestations include severe periodontitis and ulcerations.  Papillon-Lefevre  Syndrome is characterized by rapid alveolar bone loss of both the primary and  permanent dentitions. Neutrophils have decreased chemotaxis and there is a possible increase in circulating natural killer cells (Carranza & Newman, 1996). The syndrome includes hyperkeratosis of the palms and soles of the feet, possible calcification o f the cerebrum tentorium and choroid plexus, increased susceptibility to infections, hyperkeratotic plaques on cheeks, eyelids, labial commissures, legs, thighs, knees and elbows, as well as severe periodontal disease (Hart & Shapira, 1994).  Ehlers-Danlos  syndrome is an uncommon disorder, clinically characterized by joint  hypermobility and skin hyperextensibility due to a decreased amount o f collagen hydroxylysine, and/or a failure of procollagen conversion to collagen. There are eight variants o f this syndrome; the periodontal form ( E D S type VIII) is characterized by rapidly progressing periodontal disease resulting in complete tooth loss by early adulthood (Regezi & Sciubba, 1993). Dental findings can include deep anatomical grooves and excessive cuspal height of the molars and premolars, stunted or dilacerated roots, irregular dentine and enamel hypoplasia. Severe prepubertal and juvenile periodontitis seen in these patients usually leads to tooth loss. 13  Diabetes Mellitis patients have been shown to have a significantly higher incidence of gingivitis and a greater loss of attachment than non-diabetics (Belting et al., 1964; Cohen et al., 1970; Cianciola et al., 1982; Rylander et al., 1987; Hugoson et al., 1989). Neutrophils from diabetic patients with severe periodontal disease have a lower chemotactic response than neutrophils from diabetic individuals with mild periodontal disease or healthy patients with mild or severe disease. Insulin used to treat diabetes has a marked effect on both glucose and lipid metabolism, which can impair phagocytosis and killing by P M N s . Impaired wound healing appears to be the result o f abnormalities o f collagen cross-linking and reduced collagen synthesis (Salvi et al., 1997).  Down's Syndrome (Trisomy 21) patients have an increased prevalence of infections and periodontal disease compared with normal age-matched individuals or other mentally handicapped patients. The oral manifestations o f Down's syndrome (DS) patients are consistent with those o f juvenile periodontitis, characterized by onset at a young age, a rapid rate o f disease progression and destruction of periodontal tissues (Cichon, Crawford & G r i m m , 1997). P M N s and monocytes have demonstrated reduced chemotaxis, diminished phagocytosis, and abnormal bactericidal activity (Barkin et al, 1980; Izumi et al, 1989).  Immunological defects such as deficient T-cell function may contribute to the severe disease progression. It is suggested that the T-cells have a diminished ability to recognize and respond to specific antigens, and do not express cell-surface T-cell receptor (Mehta et al, 1993). A n increased frequency o f A. actinomycetemcomitans, intermedium, B.forsythus  P. gingivalis, Fusobacterium species, P.  and P. micros has been associated with periodontitis in Down's  syndrome patients (Meskin, Farsht & Anderson, 1968; Barr-Agholme et al., 1992; Cichon, Crawford & G r i m m , 1997). The outcome of the pathogenic microflora, immune deficiencies and 14  poor oral hygiene result in the severe periodontal destruction seen in D o w n ' s syndrome patients. AIDS - related periodontal findings range from an intensely erythematous marginal gingivitis, a severe form o f acute necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis, a severe localized periodontitis, to a destructive necrotizing infection of the gingiva, spreading to the surrounding tissues and alveolar bone (Murray, 1994). C D 4 : C D 8 ratios for HIV-associated gingivitis are in the range of 0.9-1.7, whereas HIV-associated periodontitis is in the range o f 0.1-0.9. The absolute C D 4 + T-cell counts in H I V periodontitis is also lower than healthy patients or HIV-associated gingivitis patients. A complex host-parasite relationship as well as a compromised immune response accounts for the increase risk o f severe and aggressive periodontal disease in infected patients (Murray, 1994).  1.1.3.4 Necrotizing Ulcerative Periodontitis  HIV-associated peridontitis (HIV-P) comprises a wide range of conditions including conventional adult periodontitis (Friedman, et al., 1991), rapidly progressive periodontitis (Reichart et al, 1987), and periodontitis with soft tissue loss and irregular bone destruction in an otherwise healthy mouth (EEC-Clearinghouse & W H O , 1993). H I V - P also includes H I V associated gingivitis with necrosis of gingival/periodontal attachment apparatus and rare spontaneous resolution (Winkler & Robertson, 1992). In the initial stage of acute necrotizing ulcerative periodontitis ( A N U P ) , the clinical manifestations are changes in gingival contour, such as interproximal necrosis, ulceration and cratering. A fetid odor is present in most cases. Severe deep pain, localized in the jawbone, is considered an important feature of HIV-associated A N U P . Another prominent feature of the disease is bleeding on probing and spontaneous bleeding of the involved sites. One of the most distinguishing features is soft tissue necrosis and 15  rapid destruction of periodontal attachment and alveolar bone (Winkler JR et ai, 1990). The disease usually affects several localized areas independently, but severe cases can affect all teeth. Dire to the extensive gingival necrosis that often coincides with loss of crestal alveolar bone, deep periodontal pocketing is not usual, but exposed bone may become sequestrated, creating craters (Holmstrup & Westergaard, 1994). Immunological studies have shown complete absence of T-cells in the gingival tissues of HIV-infected individuals with periodontitis, suggesting that the impairment of local immune defenses could explain the rapidly progressive nature of periodontitis in these patients (Steidley et ai).  1.1.3.5 Refractory Periodontitis  Patients referred to as having refractory periodontitis are those patients who seemingly fail to respond predictably to conventional therapy of scaling and root planing, flap surgery and/or antibiotics (Caton, 1989). Treated sites continue to lose attachment in a rapid manner despite the type orfrequencyof treatment applied (Hirschfeld & Wasserman, 1978; McFall, 1982; Haffajee, 1985). Hernichel-Gorbach et al. (1994) conceded that there was no real clear biological profile of these patients and no consistent microbial or host response patterns could be detected. The term "refractory" then is only defined in terms of therapy employed and the rate of progression of the disease over time (Haffajee et al, 1988).  There does not appear to be a significant difference in the microbiology in patients with refractory periodontitis, but higher levels of B. forsythus, F. nucleatum, S. intermedius, E. corrodens and B. gingivalis were found in those subjects who responded poorly to therapy (Haffejee et al., 1988). Magnusson et al. (1991) found a higherfrequencyof large and small 16  motile rods in active sites, but no significant differences in the level o f any other species. They in fact found very little plaque in these patients and no difference in the amount o f plaque in sites gaining or losing attachment. The losing sites demonstrated a higher frequency o f bleeding and suppuration than those gaining periodontal attachment.  Current studies in periodontal disease have suggested that the disease process may reflect the immunoregulation that dictates the balance between protective and destructive aspects of the host response to bacteria (Seymour, 1991, 1993, Ranny, 1991; Gemmell & Seymour, 1994, Hernichel-Gorbach, 1994). In their 1994 study of patients with refractory periodontitis, Hernichel- Gorbach et al. found that there was a greater release of I L - i p and P G E 2 & o m monocytes in patients with gingivitis. They also note a decreased C D 4 / C D 8 T-cell ratio.  This recent evidence suggests that refractory patients demonstrate differences in their host immune response that could influence treatment outcomes, although more research is necessary.  1.1.4 PATHOGENESIS OF PERIODONTAL DISEASE  The study of the pathogenesis o f periodontal disease is one o f immense diversity, involving the role of microorganisms, host responses, immunology, environmental risk factors, and genetics. Extensive work has been done in these areas and this paper w i l l briefly outline areas o f research, rather than attempt to discuss any particular aspect or contributing factor to pathogenesis in detail. For comprehensive information, refer to the works of Page & Schroeder, 1976; Page, 1991; Genco, 1992; Tonetti, 1993; Offenbacher, 1996; Page & Kornman, 1997; Fives-Taylor et  ai, 1999. 17  1.1.4.1 M i c r o b i a l Challenge  Bacteria can attach to an acquired pellicle formed from proteins and glycoproteins in the saliva and crevicular fluid. Coaggregation (attachment o f one bacteria to another based on metabolic needs) facilitates the specific interactions that increase the number and species of bacteria found in the maturing dental plaque (Whittaker et ai, 1996). Streptococcus  and Fusobacterium  are two  early colonizers and play a major role in plaque biofilm formation. This microbial biofilm provides an ecological habitat, with a primitive circulation system for the provision of nutrients, oxygen and the passage of metabolic wastes needed for the survival of the varied species of bacteria found in dental plaque (Costerton et al, 1994, 1995).  In gingival health, the bacterial load is quite low (10 -10 isolates), being predominantly gram2  positive Streptococci  and Actinomyces  3  (Syed & Loesche, 1978; Tanner et al, 1997).  Experimental gingivitis studies have documented the role of increased bacterial load (10 — 10 4  6  isolates) and decreased oral hygiene in the development of gingivitis (Theilade, et al, 1966; Syed & Loesche, 1978; V a n Dyke et al, 1999). A s well as an increased bacterial load (>10  8  isolates), multiple bacterial complexes (species) are implicated in the development of periodontitis (Socransky, Haffajee & Dzink, 1988; Haffajee & Socransky, 1994).  In health, the dental plaque is characterized by predominantly gram-positive coccoid microbiota. The gingivitis-associated microbiota is characterized by a relative increase in the numbers and proportion of gram-negative bacteria, usually motile rods and filaments. In adult periodontitis, the microbiota consists o f predominantly gram-negative microorganisms coaggregating in "testtube brush" formations (Listgarten, 1994). Although the plaque of juvenile periodontitis is less abundant, there is an increase in the numbers of A. actinomycetemcomitans, 18  and gram-negative  fusiform bacteria resembling Capnocytophaga (Berthold & Listgarten, 1986). In deep subgingival sites, anaerobic, gram-negative bacteria ultimately dominate the plaque microbiota.  The 1996 World Workshop on Clinical Periodontics has determined that "most human periodontitis is caused by "Porphyromonas gingivalis, Bacteroides forsythus and A. actinomycetemcomitans" . Epidemiological studies have shown, however, that the presence of 8  these specific microbes is not necessarily predictive of disease (Beck et ai, 1990, 1992; Christersson et al, 1992; Wheeler et al, 1994). Although periodontitis, like any infectious disease, requires the presence of an etiological agent (bacteria), the bacteria act in concert with many other host and environmental factors, such as smoking and immune deficiencies which can alter the disease prevalence and predictability.  1.1.4.2 M i c r o b i a l Virulence  Microbial virulence properties enable organisms to successfully colonize and compete with other bacteria for nutrients, and confer the ability to evade the host defenses. In general, virulence traits include the expression offimbriae(Holt etal, 1980; Fives-Taylor, Meyer, Mintz, 1995), proteases, leukotoxin capable of killing the host leukocytes (Baehmi et al, 1979; Ohta et al, 1996), endotoxins such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS) (Fives-Taylor, Meyer, & Mintz, 1996), hemolysins (Kimizuka, 1996), H2S, (Holt, etal, 1999), and the production of short-chain fatty acids toxic to neutrophils (Tsai et al, 1984; Taichman et al, 1987).  Page RC & Kornman KS. The pathogenesis of human periodontitis: an introduction. Periodont. 2000. 14: 9, 1997.  8  19  If the organism does not possess all of the necessary genetic elements to evade the host defenses, a periodontally healthy site may be colonized with a pathogen that is unable to induce tissue destruction. As mentioned earlier, a minimum threshold number of a particular microorganism is likely needed to initiate disease.  There have been major advances in the development and use of various procedures such as polymerase chain reaction and other DNA-based technologies to demonstrate that most species of peridontopathic bacteria such as P. gingivalis and A. actinomycetemcomitans involve a large number of genetically distinct clonal types (Zambon et al, 1996; Darveau et al, 1997). Recent research has shown that virulence is not equal in all clonal types of a pathogenic species (Van Steenbergen, 1987; Grenier & Mayrand, 1987; Reddy et al, 1995; Spitznagel et al, 1995) allowing some clonotypes or altered pathogens to be avirulent.  1.1.4.3 Protective Host and Immune Responses  Gram-negative bacteria release outer membrane vesicles containing lipopolysaccharide (LPS), lipid and protein, which can have direct effects on host cells to produce inflammatory mediators such as cytokines, chemokines or cellular adhesion molecules (Reddi et al, 1995). Indirect effects include the activation of neutrophils or monocytes by bacteria to produce cytokines such as IL-1 p, which activate fibroblasts, endothelial or epithelial cells to elicit inflammatory mediators such as matrix metalloproteinase (MMP), prostaglandin E2, and tissue necrosis factor (Page, 1991; Darveau, Tanner & Page, 1997). This bacterial shedding is important for the host to respond to the bacterial challenge, allowing the host to resist colonization of the bacteria.  20  The bacterial challenge induces early changes in the junctional epithelium to facilitate vascular permeability and an influx o f neutrophils. I L - 8 , a chemotactic cytokine, is found to be present in gingival tissue (junctional epithelium) and may play a role in directing neutrophils to the gingival sulcus area (Kornman, Page & Tonetti, 1997).  The cell turnover rate of the sulcular epithelium  increases, with the greatest number of infiltrating cells found in the coronal junctional epithelium. There is an increase in vascular permeability, leukocyte cell adhesion molecules and a release o f specific leukocyte- activating agents in early inflammation. The connective tissue is infiltrated when there is increased leakage o f plasma components, including acute-phase proteins (a2-macroglobulin) and leukocyte extravasation into the crevicular fluid. Neutrophils exit the inflamed venules, and migrate along the gradient of chemoattractants (intracellular attachment molecule 1 and chemokines) to the junctional epithelium to form the first line o f defense. With a change from health to infection there is an alteration in host inflammatory mediators (arachidonic acid metabolites), neutrophil enzymatic activities, and tissue degradation products. The bacterial products and epithelial derived cytokines also activate the local tissue mononuclear cells that influence the local immune response.  In diseased sites, mononuclear cells dominate the vascular exudate. Small lymphocytes consisting o f T and B cells predonunate in the tissue infiltrate, which continue to enlarge and replicate in the presence o f antigen and various cytokines. Macrophages are also activated by the bacterial challenge to secrete cytokines and express cell surface receptors that influence the antigen-specific immune response to the bacteria. These cytokines include interferon y, tumor necrosis factora transforming growth factor p\ I L - l a a n d p\ IL-6, IL-10, IL-12, IL-15. Chemoattractant cytokines (chemokines) such as M C P (monocyte chemoattractant protein), M I P (macrophage inflammation protein) and R A N T E S (regulated on activation, normal T-cell expressed and secreted) are also secreted as are the matrix metalloproteinases and prostaglandin 21  E (Kornman et al, 1997). Thus, these activated macrophages can act as chemoattractants to 2  bring additional monocytes and lymphocytes to the area. Inflammatory mediators are found in severe periodontitis at elevated concentrations, causing complement activation (the products of which are chemotactic for neutrophils), production o f matrix metalloproteinases, increased prostaglandin production, upregulation o f F c receptors on neutrophils and monocytes, upregulation o f the major histocompatability complex expressed by B and T cells to increase clonal expansion and immunoglobulin production (Kornman et al, 1997). Prostaglandins and leukotrienes are also potent chemoattractants for neutrophils, causing vasodilation. It is by these host-parasite interactions that the host tissues are protected by the neutrophil activity in the sulcus, and antibodies that are produced both locally and systemically.  1.1.4.4 Destructive Immune Responses  Macrophages and neutrophils are important for the defense o f the host against bacterial invasion. Neutrophils respond to chemoattractants to form a " w a l l " separating the advancing plaque front from the sulcular epithelium and are critical in minimizing the destructive effects of the bacteria. With increased accumulations o f bacteria and inflammation, a high concentration of chemotactic factors and cytokines occurs in the connective tissue. The connective tissue then becomes exposed to neutrophil degranulation and the releasing of neutrophilic enzymes, including collagenase, potent proteases, prostaglandins (bone resorption) and other proinflammatory agents, causing tissue destruction and furthers inflammation. Abnormalities o f neutrophil function or numbers can alter host defenses and are seen in such disorders as agranulocytopenia, cyclic neutropenia, leukocyte adhesion deficiency syndrome, chronic granulomatous disease,  22  Chediak-Higashi syndrome, and early onset periodontitis, all of which involve severe periodontitis (Dennison & V a n Dyke, 1997).  Activated macrophages also create an environment that favors collagen degradation, and can cause C D 4 T-lymphocytes to differentiate to cytokine producing T-cells that are capable of +  initiating B-cell differentiation and antibody production (Ebersole et al., 1993). However, not all antibodies are protective. B cells have been shown to produce IL-1, which has a potent effect on tissue destruction and bone loss (Birkedal-Hansen, 1993) and which can stimulate fibroblasts to produce collagenases (Richards & Rutherford, 1988 in Gemmell et al, 1997).  Destructive periodontitis then is likely due in part to the manifestation of a hypersensitivity-type reaction with the elicitation o f tissue-destructive mediators from the host cells (Ebersole & Taubman, 1994). Under continued bacterial challenge, cytokines may not be degraded, resulting in diminished clearance and causing host tissue destruction. With a continued bacterial challenge, some pathogens can produce molecules which mimic host cytokines and can trigger an abnormal inflammatory or immunolmodulatory response (Offenbacher, 1996). Thus, the length of time the immune response continues to be activated may contribute to its destructive effects.  1.1.4.4.1 Tissue and Extracellular Matrix Destruction  Connective tissue remodeling is a normal event in growth and development and is tightly regulated by a complex interplay o f cell-cell and cell-matrix interactions, involving the  23  production of enzymes, activators, inhibitors, and regulatory molecules such as cytokines and growth factors (Meikle, Heath & Reynolds, 1986).  In disease, bacteria, polymorphonuclear leukocytes, macrophages and host cells, release proteinases. Everts et al. (1996) have suggested that when there is a high turnover o f matrix in inflammation, the metalloproteinases are important in extracellular degradation. They have also suggested that an intracellular pathway for resorption, particularly for collagenases, exists when turnover is low.  Matrix metalloproteinases ( M M P s ) , synthesized by macrophages and many cells o f the periodontal tissues, are induced by cytokines and prostaglandins to initiate degradation of periodontal ligament and bone resorption. M M P s such as stomelysin and collagenase, and serine proteases such as urokinase-type plasminogen activator, when induced by IL-1, can digest all the macromolecules of tissue matrices (Leizer et al., 1987). Collagenases ( M M P - 1 , -8, -13) degrade interstitial collagens type / , / / , / / / . Proteoglycanase (stromelysins, M M P - 3 , -10, -11 and the membrane-bound group, M M P - 1 4 , -15, -16, -17) degrade Type I V collagen and a number of matrix glycoproteins such as fibronectin, osteonectin and laminin (Murphy et al, 1981; Birkedal-Hansen, 1993; Galloway et al, 1983). Gelatinases ( M M P - 2 , -9), can degrade Types I V and V collagens as well as denature interstitial collagens (Murphy et al, 1981). Recent studies have demonstrated the importance o f these metalloproteinases and other inflammatory mediators (IL-1,11-1(3 and tumor necrosis factor a) in tissue destruction (Page, 1991; Alexander & Damoulis, 1994).  In inflammation, arachidonic acid products (thromboxane A 2 , prostaglandins, prostacyclins), complement and other plasma proteases can perpetuate and amplify the process. IL-1 can be 24  synthesized by macrophages, blood platelets, fibroblasts, keratinocytes and endothelial cells. Besides its chemoattractant and stimulating effects on neutrophils and monocytes, IL-1 can induce the PGE2 response by macrophages and gingival fibroblasts, with resulting effects on increased bone resorption.  Together, these mediators of inflammation can synergistically digest all of the major structural elements of the connective tissue in states of inflammation or disease (Meikle, et al, 1986).  1.1.4.4.2 Destruction of Bone  Two major cell types exist in bone; the osteoblast (osteocyte when mineralized) is responsible for synthesizing the organic matrix components and directing mineralization and the osteoclast, which is responsible for demineralization and resorption of the organic matrix of bone. These cells act together in a process known as "coupling" to remodel and maintain bone through life. Remodeling, the process of bone resorption and formation is homeostatically balanced in normal healthy adults (Schwartz et al, 1997).  During resorption, osteoclasts release local factors (osteotropic cytokines) from the bone that stimulate further osteoclast formation (resorption) and cause inhibition of osteoblasts (bone formation).  In inflammation leukocytes, mesenchymal cells, osteoclasts and gingival fibroblasts release P G E (El Attar & Lin, 1981; Offenbacher, Heasman, Collins, 1993). In low doses, PGE can 2  2  25  stimulate bone formation, but in the high doses found in inflammation, bone resporption is enhanced (Dewhirst et al., 1983). Osteotropic cytokines such as EL-1, IL-6, tumor necrosis factor (TNF), lymphotoxin and hormones (parathyroid hormone, l,25-(OH)2D3, calcitonin, estrogens and androgens) can have an additive effect on bone resorption (Dewhirst et ai, 1987).  IL-1 a, I L - i p are potent stimulators of bone resorption, by stimulating PGE2 release and acting directly on osteoclasts. IL-6 production is increased in response to hormones and cytokines by osteoblasts (Bellido et al., 1995) and is responsible for the formation of an osteoclastic phenotype (Bertolini et al, 1994). Tumor necrosis factor acts by inhibiting osteoblast phenotypes, differentiation and function and stimulates osteoblastic bone resorption. Sex hormones have also been reported to have effects on osteoclastic bone resorption (Bellido et al, 1995).  26  1.2  A. ACTINOMYCETEMCOMITANS  AND ITS ASSOCIATION TO PERIODONTAL  DISEASE  1.2.1  Biotypes, Serology and Strains  A. actinomycetemcomitans  bacteria are anaerobic, non-motile coccobacilli (round ended rods)  measuring approximately 0.7 ±0.1 by 1.0 ±_0A um. They are found singly, in pairs or in clumps. When grown on selective media they form smooth, circular, convex and translucent colonies with a star-shaped internal morphology. A. actinomycetemcomitans  has been  subgrouped into 3-10 biochemical groupings known as biotypes based on the variable fermentation of such sugars as dextran, galactose, maltose, mannitol, and xylose (Slots et ai, 1980; Pulverer & K o , 1970).  Specific serotypes and bacterial antigens have been identified using agglutination assays. Pulverer & K o (1972) identified 1-6 agglutinating antigens on each strain. These antigens are large molecular weight, heat-stable carbohydrates, which are easily detected by immunofluorescent techniques (Zambon et ai, 1983). Initially three serotypes o f oral A.a (serotype a, b, c) were reported by Zambon et al. (1983), while serotypes d and e were described later (Asikainen et al., 1991; Saarela et al., 1992; Gmur et al., 1993). Approximately 3-8% of clinical isolates are non-serotypeable.  Serotype c is reported in healthy individuals but serotype  b is predominantly associated with localized juvenile periodontitis (Zambon et al., 1983; Asikainen et al, 1991).  Within the five serotypes there are major genetic differences, resulting in strains o f varying virulence capabilities, particularly as it relates to the leukotoxins that are produced (DiRienzo & 27  M c K a y , 1994; Poulsen et al, 1994, Haubek et al, 1995). Serotype b strains were detected more frequently in U S and Finnish L J P patients than serotype a and c strains (Zambon et al, 1983; Asikainen et al, 1991). Serotype b strain JP2 is thought to be particularly virulent, and found in younger, more disease active L J P patients (Tsai & Tachman, 1986). Leukotoxins are one of the major virulence factors contributing to the pathogenic potential o f A,  1.2.2  actinomycetemcomitans.  V i r u l e n c e Factors of A . actinomycetemcomitans  The virulence factors o f bacteria enable them to colonize and overcome the host defenses and initiate disease. For a comprehensive review, refer to Fives-Taylor et al, Periodont. 2000 20: 136-167, 1999.  Fimbriae of A. actinomycetemcomitans  (cell surface appendages) have been considered  important for colonization and adhesion to epithelial cells, fibroblasts and salivary hydroxyapatite (Rosan et al, 1988). Evidence has shown however that non-fimbriated strain of Aa. also exhibits the ability to colonize and adhere, indicating other nonfibrillar elements function in adherence (Meyer & Fives-Taylor, 1994).  Vesicles or "blebs" originating from the outer membrane consist of highly toxic lipopolysaccharides. A . actinomycetemcomitans  have an outer membrane covered by a  carbohydrate microcapsule (Zambon et al, 1983) as well as membrane vesicles, similar to lipopolysaccharide vesicles (Holt et al, 1980). They also contain bone resorption activity, bactericidins and adhesins. Highly leukotoxic strains exhibit more vesicles than minimally leukotoxic strains. 28  Extracellular  Amorphous Material is a cell surface component that mediates adherence to other  cells as well as exhibiting bone resporption properties (Wilson, Karnin, & Harvey, 1988). It has both protein (glycoprotein) and carbohydrate, its expression being determined by culture conditions.  Bone Resorption Factors include lipopolysaccharide, proteolysis-sensitive factors in microvesicles, and surface associated materials. Lipopolysaccharide has been shown to effect osteoclasts and cause the release of calcium from bone (Kiley & Holt, 1980).  Bactericides  are lethal proteins produced against other bacteria, to facilitate colonization. One  such protein, actinobacillin, is especially active against S. sanguis, S. uberis and A. viscosus (Hammond, Lillard & Stevens, 1987) causing increased permeability to the cell membrane resulting in leakage o f D N A , R N A and macro molecules essential for growth (Fives-Taylor et al., 1999).  Collagenase is an important virulence factor in the enzymatic degradation of collagen in periodontal disease. Collagenolytic activity is associated with P. gingivalis and A. actinomycetemcomitans Fusobacterium,  (Robertson et al., 1982), but not with other indigenous oral flora such as  Actinomyces,  Lipopolysaccharide(LPS)  Capnocytophaga  and Selenomonas.  or endotoxin of A . actinomycetemcomitans has been widely studied  due to its tissue destructive effects. It can directly cause Schwartzmann reaction skin necrosis, bone resporption, platelet aggregation as well as activate macrophages to produce IL-1 a and I L 1(3, T N F and other proteins (cytokines) involved in tissue inflammation and bone resorption 29  (Saglie era/., 1990).  Chemotactic Inhibitors are advantageous for the infecting organism as they w i l l disrupt neutrophil recruitment to the site of bacterial challenge. A. actinomycetemcomitans  has been  shown to be able to inhibit chemotaxis (Van Dyke et al, 1982).  Cytotoxic Factors produced by A. actinomycetemcomitans  can inhibit human fibroblast  proliferation. This inhibition of fibroblast D N A and R N A is recognized by the decrease in collagen synthesis seen in periodontal disease (Shenker, Kushner, Tsai, 1982; Gibbons R J , 1989).  Immunosuppressive  Factors of A. actinomycetemcomitans  include a protein capable of  suppressing R N A , D N A and protein synthesis of antigen activated T-cells (Shenker, McArthur & Tsai, 1982). This immunosuppressive protein is capable o f inhibiting IgG and I g M production in B-cells by interfering with the early stage o f cell activation. Kurita-Ochiai, Ochiai and Ikeda (1992) demonstrated the immuno inhibitory effects of A. actinomycetemcomitans  via depressed  C D 4 / C D 8 ratios in Aa sensitized mice.  Fc Binding Components (outer membrane proteins) are produced and released by A. actinomycetemcomitans  (Tolo & Helgeland, 1991). These components can bind to the Fc part  of IgG molecules, reducing phagocytosis by 90%. Bacterial clearance depends on Fc-receptors and C 3 b receptors on phagocytic cells. In periodontal lesions, the Fc binding components of A. actinomycetemcomitans  interfere with phagocytic activity, complement function and  downregulation of the B-cell response.  30  Epithelial  Cell Penetration as well as bacterial penetration into gingival connective tissue and  bone has been reported. Christersson et al: (1987) have demonstrated bacterial infdtration of 80% o f tissue biopsies studied from periodontal lesions. Epithelial invasion by A. actinomycetemcomitans  is a multistep process that involves entry into the cell, escape from the  vacuole, rapid multiplication, exit from the host cell (intracellular spread) and cell-to-cell spread via host microvilli (Sreenivasan, Meyer & Fives-Taylor, 1993; Fives-Taylor, Meyer & Mintz, 1995; Meyer et al, 1996, 1997). It is this dynamic process o f invasion o f epithelial cells that enables the spread of Aa to the gingival and connective tissues and initiates the destruction associated with periodontal disease.  Antibiotic Resistance o f A. actinomycetemcomitans  to tetracyclines used to treat the infections of  localized juvenile periodontitis and the ability to transfer resistance to other A. actinomycetemcomitans  strains and Haemophilus species suggests that current antibiotics may  not be effective (Roe et al, 1995).  Leukotoxin produced by A. actinomycetemcomitans  is a member of the R T X (repeats- in -toxin)  family o f toxins and has been widely studied. A s a virulence factor, it is able to bind to neutrophils, monocytes and some lymphocytes forming pores in their membranes, resulting in cell death (Tsai et al, 1984; Taichman et al, 1991).  A. actinomycetemcomitans production (Lally etal,  strains are not equivalent in terms o f leukotoxin  1996). Non-leukotoxic strains have comparatively few extracellular  vesicles (which contain endotoxin, bone resorption activity, bacteriocins and adhesins) compared to more toxic strains. Brogan et al. (1994) have shown a difference in the genetic structure of the highly toxic strains such as JP2 and the minimally toxic strains such as 652. The leukotoxin 31  gene (ItxA) along with three other genes (ItxB, C, and D) which encode for activation and transport of the toxin, make up the ltx operon. The promotor region of the highly toxic JP2 strain has a 530-bp deletion that may be important in repressing leukotoxin expression. Zambon et al. (1996) were able to demonstrate that highly toxic JPs-type strains were found only in localized juvenile periodontitis patients and not in healthy individuals or those patients with adult periodontitis.  1.2.3  Host Susceptibility to A. actinomycetemcomitans  The etiology o f periodontal disease has been associated with several specific bacteria, including P. gingivalis, A. actinomycetemcomitans,  P. intermedia, B. forsythus, W. recta, F. nucleatum  and spirochetes. The number and type o f bacteria required to exceed an individual's disease threshold defines host susceptibility. A s well as bacterial colonization, some of the pathology of periodontitis results from host-mediated responses triggered by bacterial infection. Susceptibility may be influenced by a number of genetic and non-genetic determinants as well as various risk factors, environmental and systemic factors, which affect the protective and destructive host responses and the pathogenic flora. Host response and virulence factors have been discussed earlier. At this time, the discussion w i l l focus on the humoral immune responses that enhances host susceptibility, particularly as it relates to infection with A. actinomycetemcomitans juvenile periodontitis.  32  and localized  There are two immune responses: cell-mediated and the humoral immune response. Both components react cooperatively to protect the host.  Cell-Mediated  Immune Response - Innate immunity, a component o f the cell-mediated immune  response, refers to the first line of defense against pathogens. The innate immune system includes complement, monocytes/macrophages and neutrophils that can engulf and destroy bacteria. They do not, however, always eliminate the pathogenic bacteria, depending on the virulence characteristics o f the organism. The adaptive immune response mediated by lymphocytes with specific receptors of the immunoglobulin superfamily can be activated to improve the efficiency o f eUminating the invading microorganisms. Innate and specific immunity work "hand in hand". Phagocytosis (innate immunity) usually requires opsonization (coating of the bacteria for recognition) with antibody (specific immunity) and/or complement (innate immunity). Moreover, phagocytic cells produce cytokines that are involved in activation of specific T and B-cells (Zadeh, Nichols & Miyasaki, 1999).  Many functional and biochemical polymorphonuclear leukocyte defects have been associated with periodontal disease, such as decreased integrin expression affecting transendothelial migration and decreased receptor expression for complement seen in Leukocyte Adhesion Deficiency, type 1 ( L A D ) . Other P M N defects related to decreased number, decreased chemotaxis, decreased oxidative killing mechanisms, and pleomorphism o f the Fc receptor responsible for binding of I g G l , 2 and 3 by P M N s , are manifested in periodontal problems seen in agranulocytosis, neutropenia, Down's Syndrome, specific granule deficiency, ChediakHigashi syndromes, L A D , and chronic granulomatous disease. A. actinomycetemcomitans  is able to evade the early host defenses by its virulence capabilities  already discussed. Polymorphonuclear leukocytes need antibodies to ingest and kill A. 33  actinomycetemcomitans.  Antibodies and complement are absolutely required for the  opsonization o f A actinomycetemcomitans  to overcome the dense cell-surface outer membrane  carbohydrates (Baker & Wilson, 1989).  Humoral Immune Response - Early-onset periodontitis ( E O P ) can cluster in families, suggesting a genetic predisposition to develop periodontal disease early in life. There can be marked differences in the clinical expression related to several factors, but differences in microbial flora and in the ability to respond immunologically are among the important variables (Tew et al, 1996). A. actinomycetemcomitans  is strongly associated with E O P which can be supported by  the high antibody titer reactive with serotype-specific antigens (especially to serotype b) in most E O P patients (Ebersole et al., 1982; Genco Zambon & Murray, 1985). Approximately 40-90% of L J P patients are seropositive for A actinomycetemcomitans antigen for A. actinomycetemcomitans  serotype b. The immunodominant  Y 4 (serotype b) is a serospecific carbohydrate. The  immunodominant antigen o f serotypes a and c is polysaccharide. During periodontal infections, some patients respond by producing serum antibodies against the pathogenic bacteria, whereas other patients do not. Patients resistant to periodontitis likely produce sufficient levels of high affinity antibodies (IgG) to clear the infection, where susceptible patients mount no humoral immune response or produce antibodies of low affmity/avidity that allow the disease to appear and progress (Ishikawa et al, 1997.)  IgG demonstrates four subclass isotypes produced during  the antibody response, depending on the nature of the antigen. The four subclass isotopes have various defense mechanisms including opsonic activity, complement activation and toxin inactivation (Tsai et al, 1981; Baker & Wilson, 1989). The IgG2 subclass predominates in response to L P S (carbohydrate) derived from A . actinomycetemcomitans  34  serotype b.  Seymour, Powell and Davies, 1979 have suggested that progressive lesions demonstrate predominantly B-cells, whereas T-cells are found in advanced resting lesions. Conversion from a T-cell lesion to a B-cell lesion then is destructive to the host. In B-cell lesions there is evidence for polyclonal activation o f B-cells while superantigens have been shown to activate T-cells in Tcell lesions. Polyclonal B - c e l l activators can stimulate B-cells in a T-cell independent manner (Sveen & Skaug, 1992). It has also been shown that T-cells and macrophages must be present for bacterial extracts to activate B-cells in a T-cell dependent manner (Tumang et al, 1990). B cells can be activated by both mechanisms.  The humoral antibody response can be detrimental to the host as well as protective. Polyclonally activated B-cells can make large quantities o f IL-1, which can in turn, activate osteoclasts and initiate bone resorption. T-cells activated by superantigens can also lead to the release o f a number o f cytokines. T-cells express either C D 4 or C D 8 molecules on their surface and are referred to as helper and suppressor/cytotoxic T-cells respectively. C D 4 T-cells demonstrate 3 subsets, depending on cytokine production ( T h l , Th2, ThO). T h l cells produce IL-2, IFN-y and function in delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions. Th2 cells secrete IL-4, IL-5, IL-6 and IL-10 and provide help for IgG, IgA and IgE responses (Mosmann et al, 1986). ThO produces IFN-y, IL-2, I L - 4 and IL-5 (Firestein, 1989). It is hypothesized by Zadeh et al, 1999 that T-cell subsets take part in the regulation of the immune response and have protective or destructive consequences. Several models of T-cell involvement in periodontal disease have been constructed. For further explanation and in depth coverage of these models, see Ebersole & Taubman (1994), Yamamoto et al, (1997) and Seymour et al. (1979).  35  1.3 ANIMAL MODELS IN PERIODONTAL RESEARCH  Animals, notably the primates, beagle dog and rat have been widely used in periodontal research. Beagle dogs (Rosenberg, Rehfeld & Emmering, 1966; Saxe et al, 1967; H u l l & Davies, 1974; Lindhe, Hamp & L o e , 1975), were often used to study the prevalence, etiology and pathogenesis of periodontal disease as they resemble humans in periodontal anatomy, microbiology and pathophysiology (Madden & Caton, 1994). When plaque is allowed to accumulate, naturally occurring periodontitis usually develops by 4-7 years of age (Lindhe, Hamp & Loe, 1975).  Clinical measurements of periodontal disease in dogs may include plaque scoring, calculus, gingivitis scoring, attachment loss, pocket depth and width o f gingiva (Sorensen, Loe & Ramfjord, 1980). These parameters are also used in scoring clinical periodontitis in humans.  Periodontal virulence studies usually require histological gingival biopsies to examine the inflammatory /bacterial cells in the connective tissues. A measure of disease activity can also be determined by analyzing the cells or biochemical markers found in the gingival crevicular fluid (Attstrom & Engelberg, 1970; Kryshtalskyj, Sodek & Ferrier, 1986). Host immune responses, cytokine activity and altered bone metabolism has been studied in the dog model to determine virulence of periodontal disease. A n important feature of any animal model used to study human infections is that it should simulate an infectious process in humans while mimicking the natural pathogenesis to the greatest extent possible (Holt et al, 1999).  Primates used in periodontal research are the cynomolgus monkey (Macacafasicularis),  squirrel  monkey (Saimiri sciureus), rhesus monkey (Macaca mulatta), baboon (Papio anubis) and the 36  marmoset. Adult monkeys are susceptible to naturally occurring periodontal disease or disease induced by any number o f ligature devices designed to accumulate plaque. Caton and Zander (1975), using a primate model, studied bone and attachment loss clinically and histologically. Heijl, Rifkin and Zander (1976) used squirrel monkeys to determine histologic changes following the conversion o f gingivitis to peridontitis when silk ligatures were used for plaque accumulation. Holt et al. (1988) modified this model by injecting P. gingivalis into monkeys after ligature-induced plaque accumulation, to demonstrate its pathogenicity. Although primates most closely resemble humans, the expense of maintenance and safety issues limits the number of monkeys used in any study.  The mouse, for over 100 years, has been and continues to be used as a research tool in the study of infections and diseases. Research in bacterial diseases as early as the 1880s used mice routinely for isolation of bacteria, as well as determination of pathogenesis of disease and immunization studies (Madden & Fujiwara, 1982). Mice were chosen for the experiments in these studies because o f their availability, ease o f handling and low maintenance costs. Genetically inbred mice assure the homogeneity o f the test subjects to facilitate the study of inflammation. Murine models have been used repeatedly to demonstrate virulence capabilities of such periodontal pathogens as P. gingivalis, P. intermedia, W. recta and A. actinomycetemcomitans  (Kastelein et al, 1982; V a n Steenbergen et al, 1982; Grenier &  Mayrand, 1987; Neiders etal,  1989; Ebersole etal,  1989; Kesavalu etal,  1990).  Evaluation of the virulence o f a bacterial strain is based on the gross pathology induced following inoculation of the animals. The mice are typically inoculated with a graded dose o f different strains of live bacteria, using either implanted subcutaneous chamber models (Genco & Arko, 1977) or subcutaneous site injection, and the pathology compared. The use o f chamber 37  models ensures a ready obtainable sample of the transudate which contains bacterial cells, host cells and inflammatory products and allows the researcher to examine the interactions during the progression o f infection (Genco et al, 1997).  Injections o f bacteria at specific sites establish an abscess model that is used to grade soft tissue destruction (Van Steenbergen etal,  1982, 1987; Ebersole et al, 1995; Joiner et al, 1997). The  abscess model can also be used to determine the phenotype o f lymphocytes and macrophages recruited to the site (Kesavula et al, 1991; Gremmel E , Bird PS, Bowman JJD, et al, 1997) and to study the effects, i f any, of immunization (Chen et al, 1987; Kesavalu et al, 1991; Gemmell etal,  1997).  In many papers, the grading o f the soft tissue pathology is a subjective, quasi-quantitative evaluation of the extent of the abscess formation. V a n Steenbergen et al. (1982) described histological sections by: 1) diameter o f a localized abscess formation, < 1 mm > 4 mm, 2) spreading o f the inflammatory cells between subcutaneous muscle and the injection site, 3) mean diameter of the abscess progressing 1-2 mm in lateroventral direction 4) area o f phlegmonous abscess at the ventral side o f the mouse, including skin necrosis.  Other evaluations included semi-quantitative estimates o f inflammatory cells and bacteria in the tissues (Kesaluva et al, 1991), as well as descriptions of the size and consistency of the lesions at the injection site with presence, location and appearance o f a secondary lesion (Chen et al, 1987). Further detail o f the appearance of the mice, such as cachexia, ruffling, general erythema and phlegmonous, ulcerated, necrotic lesions and death (Genco et al, 1991) were used as pathologic criteria. These and other papers evaluated histopathology according to clinical signs, 38  localization or spreading of lesions, and/or ultimate death of the animal. There did not appear to be a consistent, reproducible grading system to evaluate the extent of the inflammatory response induced by bacterial invasion. In these abscess models, only live bacteria were used. Studies evaluating the inflammatory response using dead bacteria or bacterial products were not readily found.  39  1.4  OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY  The research objectives of the Early-Onset Periodontitis Workshop includes defining the current status of periodontal diseases and making recommendations for future directions, goals and approaches. One of their future research goals is to find a good animal model for periodontal disease (Van Dyke & Schenkein, 1996). It is hoped that this study may in some way advance those goals.  1. To develop a quantitative method of grading an inflammatory response in a murine model of inflammation using non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans.  Current models of inflammation using live bacteria have assessed virulence capabilities both clinically (by the size and severity of abscess, malaise and eventual death of the animal) and histologically. A few models of inflammation have tried to quantitate the observed pathology, but no standardized method has routinely been used in the literature. In this study we report a new system of quantifying the inflammatory responses in a murine model of inflammation using 3 strains of non-viable Aa  2. To evaluate the reproducibility of an inflammatory reaction in a murine model using non-viable bacterial components of A. actinomycetemcomitans.  Periodontitis is an infectious disease. Although hundreds of bacterial species, serotypes and strains are found in dental plaque, there are clearly differences between the healthy and diseased sites. A. actinomycetemcomitans, P. gingivalis and B. forsythus have been found associated with diseased sites and have been implicated as causative pathogens in 40  periodontitis.  This study investigates if there is a predictable inflammatory reaction produced with non- viable bacterial components of the bacterium A. actinomycetemcomitans.  3. To evaluate the inflammatory reaction (virulence) of 3 different strains (2 serotypes) of non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans.  Studies have demonstrated that the levels of virulence capabilities of specific bacteria can explain approximately 9 to 16% of the variability in disease expression. This has led to the concept that with live bacteria, different serotypes of the same bacteria display different pathogenic properties. We hypothesized that an inflammatory model using non-viable bacteria of different serotypes of A. actinomycetemcomitans will demonstrate the same varied virulence capabilities as live bacteria.  41  CHAPTER TWO- MATERIAL AND METHODS  2.1 A n i m a l s  Healthy male C D - I mice (Animal Care Facility, University o f British Columbia), weighing approximately 35 gm, age 4-6 weeks, were used in all o f the experiments. The mice were caged in groups o f four and were maintained on standard lab chow (Purina) and water ad libitum. Approval for the study was granted by the A n i m a l Care Committee o f the University o f British Columbia.  2.2 B a c t e r i a  Three strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans were used in the various experiments: JP2 (serotype b), Y 4 ( A T C C - American Type Culture Collection 43718) (serotype b) and I D H (Institute o f Dentistry, Helsinki) 1705 (serotype e). The three A. actinomycetemcomitans strain were grown on Trypticase soy-serum-bacitracin-vancomycin ( T S B V ) agar plates (Slots 1982), incubated in 5% C 0 2 in air at 37° C for 2-3 days. The bacteria showed typical colony morphology, positive catalase reaction, and negative lactose fermentation (Asikainen et al. 1986). The bacteria were collected into P B S and stored at -20° C until used. The initial optical density (OD oo) o f JP2 was 6  0.2; Y 4 was 1.2, and I D H 1705 was 0.73.  C e l l concentrations were established using the spectrophotometer (Varian) so that each undiluted strain had the same optical density (ODeoo)Of 0.2 with equivalent cell counts of approximately 5 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml. The calibrations were done using sterile phosphate buffered 9  42  saline (PBS). Each undiluted sample of bacteria was kept frozen until use. After thawing, the aliquots were sonicated at output position 2 (Branson Sonifier 250) for 30-sec and dilutions of 0.2, 0.1, or 0.01 were made using sterile P B S (concentration 0.1M), as needed per experiment.  The types and concentration of inoculae were as follows: 1.  Sterile phosphate buffered saline 0 . 1 M as vehicle control  2.  Immunopathological testing JP2- strain b, IDH-1705- strain e, A T C C 43718- strain b, at concentrations of 5.0 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml (undilute), 1.0 X 10 bacterial 9  9  0.05 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml (0.01 dilution). 9  The various dilutions were made using the OD<5oo equivalent for each stock strain and mixing sterile phosphate buffered saline (0.1M) to the appropriate dilution/concentration.  2.3  Injections  The inoculae to be used were prepared in sterile tubes, and mixed thoroughly. 0.05 cc of solution was drawn into 1.0 cc tuberculin syringes. The syringes were capped with 26 gauge needles. Recipient animals were placed into the anesthesia chamber and administered equal amounts o f halothane and oxygen until unconscious. Hair was removed from either the right or left ear and/or abdomen (depending on the experimental design) and the site swabbed with 70% alcohol. Figure 1 demonstrates the subcutaneous injections of the mice in the ear and abdomen with 0.05 cc of the appropriate A. actinomycetemcomitans  strain. The mice were then placed in  their cages. They appeared well immediately after the injections and throughout the experimental period. 43  Figure 1(a) Ear Injection. Mice were injected subcutaneously (s.e.) at base of Ear Figure 1(b) Abdomen Injection. Mice were injected s.e. in ventral side of Abdomen  44  F i g u r e 1(a) Injection of JP2 - E a r 1(b) Injection of JP2 - A b d o m e n  2.4 T i m e Intervals  The time intervals for each experiment were 5 days, 15 days and 25 days, chosen to correspond to histological phases of inflammation. The 5-day period represented an early acute cellular response, populated by polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs) such as neutrophils. The 15-day time interval represented a late acute-early chronic response with the presence of increased PMNs, phagocytic cells and macrophages and 25 days was chosen to represent the late chronic response based on an infiltration of lymphocytes and cells of the monocyte-macrophage lineage (Newman & Nisengard, 1988).  2.5 M u r i n e Virulence Model/Studies  Experimental Groups- the animals were randomly separated into 6 experiments for the virulence studies: 1. To establish Control vs JP2 Reaction- mice were injected s.e. ear and abdomen with phosphate buffered saline as control compared to a 5.0 X 10 , 0.5 X 10 and 0.05 X 9  9  10 bacterial equivalents/ml inoculae of JP2 (serotype b) and sacrificed after 15 days 9  to determine if there was an inflammatory reaction compared to the saline control. 2. To determine the Time-Course of Reaction- mice were injected s.e. ear and abdomen with JP2 (serotype b) undiluted 5.0 X l O and 1.0 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml and 9  9  evaluated after 5, 15 and 25 days to determine the comparable extent of the inflammatory reaction. 3. To compare the Time-Kinetics of the 3 different strains of Aa- mice were injected s.e. ear and abdomen with undilute 5 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ ml ATCC JP2, Y4 9  46  ( A T C C 43718), I D H 1705 strains o f A. actinomycetemcomitans  and evaluated after 5,  15, 25 days to compare inflammatory reactions of the three strains over time. 4.  T o determine the Titratability of the 3 strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans were injected s.e. abdomen only with 4 dilutions of each A.  - mice  actinomycetemcomitans  strain and sacrificed after 15 days to determine and compare the inflammatory reactions caused by the different concentrations of each strain. 5.  T o study the Immunohistologic actinomycetemcomitans,  Cell Response of the 3 strains o f A.  tissue samples from mice in group 3 were processed for  immunohistologic staining. Days 5 and 15 after injection were chosen to ensure a reaction that was more acute and detectable.  2.6 Histological Preparation and Protocol  At the appropriate time intervals, the selected mice were euthanized using CO2 asphyxiation; hair was removed from the injection site and the area swabbed with alcohol. The injected tissue sites were removed with a scalpel and/or scissors. The specific tissues were put into labeled Histoprep tissue capsules (Fisher Scientific, B . C . ) and placed in a glyoxol, ethanol and buffer solution (Prefer, Anatek Ltd, M I ) for up to 24 hours i f being prepared for Hematoloxylin and Eosin staining. The samples to be studied immunohistologically were placed into Tris Z n Buffer ( Q L T Pharmaceuticals, B.C.).  The samples were immediately washed or placed in P B S  overnight and washed thoroughly with tap water the next day, then placed into the Autotechnicron (Technicon C o . N . Y . ) for dehydration.  47  Dehydration of Samples The tissue samples were placed into the tissue receptacles o f the Autotechnicon and the baskets rotated from one reagent beaker to another through the various processing stages. During emersion into the beakers, the samples are gently oscillated vertically to ensure free flow of the beaker reagent. The sequence and duration o f immersion are timed automatically by a timing disc, which permits a definite sequence o f varying time intervals to be preset. The first five reagent beakers are intended to dehydrate the tissues with varying concentrations o f alcohol, while the last three beakers contain a clearing agent (Hemo D , Fisher Scientific, B ; C ) . The timing sequence was as follows:  Dehydrating - 70% ethanol -1 hr - 95% ethanol - 2 hr -100%ethanol-2hr (X3) Clearing - H e m o - D - 1 hr (X3)  At the completion of the cycle, the tissue samples were tapped gently to remove as much HemoD as possible and then put into ceramic pots for waxing.  Waxing Embedding Paraffin waxing pellets (Paraplast X-tra, Fisher Scientific, B . C . ) were placed into the waxing oven overnight at 56° C (2-4 degrees above the melting point of the wax).  When the samples were removed from the Autotechnicron, they were placed into ceramic pots and covered with the melted paraffin, then placed into the vacuum chamber with a heat setting of 56° C for Vacuum Impregnation. The samples were subjected to 15 pounds of pressure for 1 48  hour, then removed to add fresh melted paraffin to the pot. The samples were placed in the vacuum chamber for 30 minutes at 15 pounds pressure two more times, and new melted wax added each time.  When each wax impregnated sample was removed from the vacuum for the  last time, it was quickly put into a prepared histological block for Embedding.  Embedding After thorough impregnation, each tissue sample was placed in an appropriately sized mold. The bottom o f the mold was covered with paraffin and the tissue oriented. W i t h the proper sized embedding ring in place, paraffin was poured in to make a block about 1 cm. thicker than the piece o f tissue. The molds were cooled to solidify the wax. When the blocks were solid, the waxed molds were removed and kept at 4 ° C until ready to section.  Trimming and cutting of Tissue Samples After embedding, surplus wax was removed to prepare for sectioning with a Spencer Microtome 820. Sections 6u thick were cut into ribbons and separated for mounting on slides.  Mounting Sections on Slides The ribbons were divided into sections and placed onto frosted slides (Fisher, B . C . ) which were flooded with water to initially stretch the sections. They were then poured off the slide into water in a thermostatically controlled water bath (46° C ) and floated for a few minutes to get rid of creases. A clean slide was lowered into the water and withdrawn at an angle, bringing the section with it. The section was then oriented on the slide and placed into the drying oven set at 37° C overnight to dry completely.  Prior to staining, the slides were placed into the waxing oven  for 15-30 minutes. 49  Staining and Mounting for Histological Study Haematoxylin (Harris's Modified Haematoxylin, Fisher, B . C . ) and Eosin (Fisher, B . C ) , ( H & E ) staining was done by hand in small batches. Both H and E were filtered prior to use. Running tap water was used for washing. The staining procedures, completed under the fume hood, consisted of placing the slides into beakers of the following reagents: Dewaxing - 5 minutes each: - Xylene ( X 2) - Absolute ethanol - 95% ethanol, - 70% ethanol Wash in tap water -3-4 dips  Staining - Haematoxylin 4-5 minutes- wash in running water 20 minutes - 1.5% N a H C 0  3  or saturated L I C 0 , wash 30 sec. 2  3  - Eosin 1-3 minutes - Ethanol 100% ( X 3) for 1 minute each - Xylene ( X 2) for 5 minutes. Coverslip - Coverslips were placed on the slides using Entallan (Merck, Ont) and then left to dry.  50  2.7 Immunological Methods and Preparation  2.7.1  Antibodies  The immunological staining performed in this study was done using the MicroProbe Staining System, a component of the FisherBiotech MicroProbe System, Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh, P A . (capillary gap technology). Three antibodies were used; purified anti-mouse macrophage (F4/80) monoclonal antibody (Cedarlane), rat anti-mouse neutrophil monoclonal antibody (Serotec) and D A K O rabbit anti-human T cell C D 3 .  The F4/80 antigen is found on most macrophages and on macrophage precursors. It is found in low levels on activated macrophages and eosinophils. Anti-mouse macrophage (F4/80) monoclonal antibody reacts with the mouse macrophage F4/80 antigen. The rat anti-mouse neutrophil monoclonal antibody is specific for mouse neutrophils. The C D 3 antigen is a highly specific marker for T cells, and the D A K O Rabbit anti-human T cell, C D 3 antibody reacts with the intracytoplasmic portion o f the C D 3 antigen expressed by human and mouse T cells.  The tissue samples slides were placed in a 37° C oven overnight, then deparaffinized and rehydrated in the following sequence: Xylene 5 minutes (X3) -  100% Alcohol 2 minutes (X2)  -  95% A l c o h o l 2 minutes ( X I )  -  70% A l c o h o l 2 minutes ( X I )  The slides were then placed in fresh Automation buffer for 5 minutes. 51  The Reagents used in the immunological staining were as follows: 1.  I X Automation buffer - Dilute 10 ml. of 10X Automation buffer to a final volume of 100 ml. with distilled water.  2.  I X Phosphate Enhancer - Dilute 10 ml. of 10X Phosphate Enhancer to a final volume o f 100 ml. with distilled water.  3. Primary antibody - Rabbit Anti-human T cell,CD3 (1:100); Anti-mouse macrophage F4/80 (1:50); rat Anti-mouse neutrophil (1:100). 4. Reagent 1A - Biotinylated second antibody mix (supplied) 5. Reagent 2 - Avidine-alkaline phosphatase complex (supplied). 6. Reagent 3 - Working chromogen reagent: A ) Transfer 5 ml. o f distilled water to bottle labeled 3. B) A d d 2 drops of concentrated buffer p H 8.2. Mix. C) A d d one tablet of fast red T R tablets. Wait one minute. D) A d d one drop of Naphthol A S - M X phosphate. Mix. Control slides were processed (subjected to immunological staining) without the addition o f the primary antibodies.  2.7.2  Staining Method  The Staining method for the Immunohistologic study involved the addition o f the primary antibodies, (F4/80, C D 3 , or neutrophil) to the slides and incubating at 37°C for 60 minutes. After rinsing with I X Automation buffer (6 times), the biotinylated second antibody mixture (Reagent 1A) was added to the slides. The slides were then incubated at 37°C for 15 minutes, after which they were rinsed with I X Automation buffer (6 times). Reagent 2, the avidin-alkaline phosphatase complex was then added, and the slides incubated at 37°C for a further 20 minutes.  52  They were then dipped into Phosphate Enhancer for 1 minute, after which time the working chromogen reagent, Reagent 3 was applied. After incubating at room temperature for 10 minutes, the slides were rinsed twice with distilled water. Counterstaining was done with 1:5 dilution of Hematoxylin, then the slides were rinsed three times with distilled water. After being dipped into I X Automation buffer for 2 minutes, the slides were dipped twice into distilled water. They were then removed from their holders and Crystal mount applied.  2.8  Statistical Analysis  The statistics used were the nonparametric Kolmogorov-Schmirnov test o f Significance. Standard Error was calculated for the reproducibility data, presented in Figure 10.  53  CHAPTER THREE - RESULTS  3.1 Methodology for the Evaluation of Histological and Immunohistological Score  The histological and immunohistologic evaluation o f inflammatory responses in the literature is very subjective and relies on observational criteria only. The main objective o f this part of the study was to try to standardize the methodology for grading the histopathological responses caused by non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans.  3.1.1  Histological Score  In this inflammatory model, two parameters were selected for grading of the histological slides. The first parameter of the grading system used here was the percentage of the microscopic field that demonstrated an inflammatory infiltrate. This was determined by examining the slide at X l O power and grading the area of cellular infiltrate on a 0-4 scale (0 = 0-9% of field, 1 = 1014% of field, 2 = 15-19% of field, 3 = 20-24% of field and 4 = >25% o f field).  The second parameter was the cellular density o f the infiltrate. This was determined by counting the number o f inflammatory cells per optical grid square (each 0.49 sq. mm) at X 4 0 power and grading the density on a 0-4 scale: 0 = 0 cells/grid square, 1 = 1-4 cells/grid square, 2 = 5-9 cells/grid square, 3 = 10-14 cells/grid square, and 4 = >15 cells/grid square. The overall histological score was determined by the addition of the two above parameters and assigning a score as follows:  54  Percent of Field + Density  Histological Score (Grade)  0  0  1-2 (1+0 or 1+1)  1  3-4 (2+1 or 2+2)  2  5-6 (3+2 or 3+3)  3  7-8 (4+3 or 4+4)  4  Figure 2 represents examples of the percentage of field demonstrating an inflammatory infiltrate and cellular density of infiltration calculated to determine the Histological Score.  55  Figures 2(a), (b), (c) (d) Histologic Score (Grade) as calculated by addition of area and density.  2(a) Grade 1 - I D H 1705 at day 5 - abdomen at magnification X 10 and X 40. A ) fat B) blood vessel C) muscle layer D) P M N infiltrate 2(b) Grade 2 - Y 4 at day 15 - abdomen at magnification X 10 and X 40. 2(c) Grade 3 - Y 4 at day 5 - abdomen at magnification X l O and X 40. A ) fat B ) muscle layer C) P M N infiltrate 2(d) Grade 4 - JP2 at day 5 - abdomen at magnification X l O and X 40.  The photo shown at 10X magnification demonstrates an example of the area of the slide that contains inflammatory cells. The photo taken at 4 0 X magnification represents the most densely populated area for cell counting.  56  Figure 2(a) Histological Score - G r a d e 1 - magnification X l O and X 4 0 .  F i g u r e 2(b) Histological Score - G r a d e 2 - magnification X l O and X 4 0  F i g u r e 2(d) Histological Score - G r a d e 4 - magnification X l O and X 4 0 .  3.1.2  Immunohistological Score  The parameters used for grading o f the immunohistological slides were more difficult due to the non-specific binding seen on many o f the slides and the more diffuse nature of the cellular response. The 0-4 scale was based predominantly on the number o f cells (density) counted at X 4 0 power using the optical grid. Score 0 = 0 cells/grid square, 1=1-5 cells/grid square, 2 = 610 cells/grid square, 3 = 11-15 cells/grid square and 4 = > 15 cells/grid square. The immunological reaction for the three antibodies were graded the same.  Figure 3 represents examples o f the density of field with inflammatory infiltrate used to determine the Immunologic Score.  61  Figures 3(a), 3(b), 3(c) and 3(d) Immunohistological Score as determined by density of the field with an inflammatory infiltrate.  3(a) Grade 1 - I D H 1705 - C D 3 at day 15 - Abdomen at magnification X l O and X 4 0 A ) +ve staining - T-cells B ) - v e nonspecific binding 3(b) Grade 2 - Y 4 -Neutrophil at day 5 - Abdomen at magnification X l O and X 4 0 A ) +ve staining - neutrophils B ) - v e nonspecific staining 3(c) Grade 3 - JP2 - Neutrophil at day 15 - Abdomen at magnification X l O and X 4 0 A ) +ve staining - neutrophils B) - v e nonspecific staining 3(d) Grade 4 - Y 4 - F4/80 at day 5 - Abdomen at magnification X l O and X 4 0 A ) +ve staining - monocyte/macrophages B ) - v e nonspecific staining  62  F i g u r e 3(a) Immunohistological Score - G r a d e 1 - magnification X l O and X 4 0  Figure 3(b) Immunohistological Score - G r a d e 2 - magnification X l O and X40  Figure 3(c) Immunohistological Score - G r a d e 3 - magnification X l O and X 4 0  Figure 3(d) Immunohistological Score - G r a d e 4 - magnification X l O and X 4 0 .  3.2  Comparison of Subcutaneous Injections of Ear and Abdomen for Elicitation of the Inflammatory Response.  In this study two sites were chosen for investigation; the ear and abdomen of C D 1 mice. The ear (at the base o f the skull) was chosen as it had a unique anatomical feature, the internal cartilage core, which could be used as a histological marker from which the degrees of inflammation could be measured. Moreover, as the ear is heavily vasculated, erythema could be easily assessed and the contralateral ear could be used as a control. Finally the degree o f swelling after injection could be measured by micrometer. A negative feature o f this site was the difficulty in performing a subcutaneous injection, due to the risk o f perforation of the epithelium on the opposite side o f the ear. As well, when harvesting the ear, some of the inflamed tissue may have been destroyed or severed on removal.  The abdomen was chosen as the second site for investigation as it had an external marker, the hair follicles from which the degrees o f inflammation could be measured. Moreover, it was a relatively easy site to perform subcutaneous injections. The injection site could be easily localized and the degree of induration could be measured.  In the first experiment, A. actinomycetemcomitans  (Aa) bacteria, JP2 (strain b) was chosen for  testing as this strain has been shown to be highly associated with L J P (Zambon, Slots & Genco, 1983). Three mice were prepared as described for injection with 0.05 ml JP2 at concentrations of 5 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml (undilute), 0.5 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml (0.1) and 0.05 9  9  X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml (0.01) and a P B S control (0. I M ) . In the right ear and abdomen, 9  each mouse received one of the concentrations of inoculate of bacteria, while on the contralateral side, the animal received 0.05 ml of phosphate buffered saline (0.1 M ) as a control.  67  The animals were sacrificed at 15 days and the tissues processed as indicated in the protocols. The entire wax blocks were cut, sections mounted, stained and microscopically evaluated to find the sections with the strongest inflammatory reaction present within the entire tissue sample. The most severe reaction was graded and recorded according to the proposed inflammatory grading model.  The tissues injected with the saline control demonstrated a normal histological appearance with no inflammatory infiltrate as a result of the saline or the needle itself. This was true for both the ear and the abdomen samples. In the ear samples injected with varying dilutions o f strain b JP2 and harvested on day 15, an inflammatory reaction was evident by the staining of the P M N infiltration, which was scored according to the Histologic Score criteria.  The inflammatory reaction demonstrated in the abdomen samples injected with varying dilutions of strain b JP2 and harvested on day 15, demonstrated more intense staining and a heavier infiltration of P M N leukocytes than the ear tissues. This appeared true for all dilutions.  68  F i g u r e 4(a) The top photograph ( X l O ) demonstrates the mouse ear injected with the saline control, devoid o f P M N s , macrophages or inflammatory cells. In the bottom photograph ( X l O ) on day 15, after injection with undilute JP2, the inflammatory reaction is quite localized and intensely populated with P M N s . Many inflammatory cells are also evident in the muscle and fat layers. A ) epithelium B) fat C) muscle D) P M N infiltrate 4(b) The top photograph ( X l O ) demonstrates the abdomen injected with the saline control. The bottom photograph ( X l O ) demonstrates the P M N reaction in the abdomen injected with undilute JP2, and harvested on day 15. There is a large area o f inflammatory cells, densely populated with P M N s visible in both muscle and fat layers. A ) epithelium B) C) D) E)  fat muscle P M N infiltrate hair follicle  69  F i g u r e 4(a) Inflammatory Response in E a r - P B S control and J P 2 at day 15 ( X l O )  F i g u r e 4(b) Inflammatory Response in Abdomen - P B S control and J P 2 at day 15 ( X l O )  3.3 Dose Dependency of Inflammatory Response in Ear and Abdomen (JP2) at Day 15.  A s can be seen in figures 5 to 7, the mflammatory response to the varying dilutions o f JP2 injected into both Ear and Abdomen sites demonstrate a higher response with the more concentrated A. actinomycetemcomitans. A s the samples were graded for Histologic Score involving area and density o f inflammatory cells, the abdomen site demonstrated a greater inflammatory response than the ear for all dilutions. However, the 1 X l O bacterial 9  equivalents/ml dilution - Ear, demonstrated a higher histologic score at 15 days than the undilute sample (5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml). In the Abdomen samples, these two dilutions 9  produced equally high scores (Grade 4).  72  Figure 5 Graph of the inflammatory Dose Responses in the Ear and Abdomen using 5.0 XlO ,1.0 XlO , 0.5 XlO and 0.05 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml of JP2 at day 15. 9  9  9  9  73  Figure 5 Inflammatory Response of varying dilutions of JP2atdayl5 - Ear and Abdomen  74  Figure 6 Inflammatory Response of the varying dilutions of JP2 at day 15 - Ear (XlO)  6(a) 0.05 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml. 9  6(b) 0.5 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml. 9  6(c) 1.0 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml. 9  6(d) 5.0 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml. 9  75  igure 6(a) Inflammatory Response of 0.05 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml of J P 2 - Day 15 9  Ear  (XlO)  6(b) Inflammatory Response of 0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml of J P 2 - Day 15 9  Ear  (XlO)  76  Figure 6(c) Inflammatory Responses of 1.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml of J P 2 - Day 15 E a r (XlO) 6(d) Inflammatory Response of 5.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml of J P 2 - Day 15 E a r (XlO) 9  9  Figure 7 Inflammatory Response of the (XlO)  ing Dilutions of JP2 at day 15 - Abdomen  7(a) 0.05 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml. 9  7(b) 0.5 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml. 9  7(c) 1.0 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml 9  7(d) 5.0 XlO bacterial equivalents/ml. 9  78  Figure 7(a) Inflammatory Response of 0.05 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml - Day 15 Abdomen (XlO) 7(b) Inflammatory Response of 0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml - Day 1 5 Abdomen (XlO) 9  9  79  F i g u r e 7(c) Inflammatory Response of 1.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml - Day 15 Abdomen (XlO) 7(d) Inflammatory Response of 5.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml - Day 1 5 Abdomen (XlO) 9  9  3.3 Kinetic Analysis of Inflammatory Response of Three Strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans.  We next determined whether there was a difference in the inflammatory response between the three different strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans  at time periods: 5, 15, and 25 days. It has  been demonstrated that Serotype b, found in increased proportions in L J P (Zambon, Slots & Genco, 1983; Asikainen et al, 1991), produced more leukotoxin (up tolO-20 times more) than serotypes a or c and may be particularly virulent in destroying periodontal tissues. Saarela et al. (1992) determined that serotype e was much less pathogenic, as it was found less frequently in periodontitis than serotypes a, b, c or d. Even within serotypes, leukotoxin production and virulence are not equivalent (Poulsen et al, 1994; Brogan et al, 1994). This study looks at the kinetic analysis o f the three different strains to determine i f the inflammatory reaction seen in the mice would be consistent with reported findings.  Three groups of mice were randomly caged in groups of four. In each group, 0.05 ml o f 5 X l O  9  bacterial equivalents/ml (undiluted) o f strains JP2, Y 4 , and I D H 1705 were injected s.e ear and abdomen. The animals were sacrificed on day 5 (early acute response), day 15 (acute), and day 25 (chronic response). Tissues were fixed in Zn-Tris buffer and sectioned for H and E and Immunohistological staining. The histologic specimens were evaluated to find the most pronounced inflammatory reaction in the tissues, which were then graded as described.  As can be seen in Figure 8, the Ear samples of the undilute JP2 injections demonstrate a very acute, heavily infiltrated, localized P M N response on Day 5. The P M N inflammatory reaction of the Y 4 and I D H 1705 undilute strains indicate a reduced (less virulent) response which remains consistent over day 5 and 15. Histological examination revealed a chronic, diffuse inflammatory response for all strains at day 25, in which P M N s and macrophages could be seen. 81  In the Abdomen samples, JP2 demonstrates a strong P M N response both day 5 and day 15, becoming less intense, more diffuse (chronic) by day 25. Strain Y 4 produced a less intense inflammatory response day 5 and 15 than JP2, decreasing by day 25. The inflammatory response on day 5 o f I D H 1705 produced a minimal staining of P M N s , macrophages or monocytes. The most acute reaction for I D H 1705 can be seen at day 15. The response at day 25 appears more intense than the initial response at day 5. The responses were quite equal for all strains by day 25.  82  Figure 8(a) Graph of the Kinetic Response of undilute strains - JP2, Y4, IDH 1705 (Ear) Day 5,15 and 25 8(b) Graph of the Kinetic Response of undilute strains - JP2, Y4, IDH 1705 (Abdomen) - Day 5,15, and 25 8(c) Inflammatory Response of strains JP2, Y4 and IDH 1705 - Day 5,15,25 - Ear (X40) 8(d) Inflammatory Response of strains JP2, Y4 and IDH 1705 - Day 5,15, 25 Abdomen (X40)  83  Figure 8(a) K i n e t i c Response of J P 2 , Y 4 a n d I D H 1705 - E a r  .  5  O 4  • JP2  o qo  W  mi  "5)  o 2 o  % 1 if 0  15  0  • Y4  • 1705  25  Day  F i g u r e 8(b) K i n e t i c Response of J P 2 , Y 4 a n d I D H 1705 - A b d o m e n  co 5 -  8  4  • JP2  CO o 3  • Y4  Ui _  • 1705  o 2 o  % 1 £  0  i  r  0  15  5 Day  84  25  Figure 8(c) Inflammatory Response of J P 2 , Y 4 , I D H 1705 - Day 5, 15, 25 - E a r (X40)  85  F i g u r e 8(d) Inflammatory Response of J P 2 , Y 4 , I D H 1705 - Day 5,15, 25 - A b d o m e n  86  3.5  Dose Dependency of Inflammatory Response of Three Strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans  In order to determine whether there was a difference in the inflammatory response mediated by the 3 strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans,  mice were injected s.e. abdomen with 0.05 cc of four  dilutions of the 3 strains of Aa. A l l o f the mice were sacrificed at 15 days as described and the tissues were prepared for H and E staining. The samples with the most mflammatory response were graded and compared. Figure 9 illustrates a graph of the Dose Response at day 15 of the three different strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans  at dilutions 0.05 X l O bacterial 9  equivalents/ml, 0.5 X 1 0 bacterial equivalents/ml, 1.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml and 5.0 9  9  X l O b a c t e r i a l equivalents/ml. 9  In this experiment, strain JP2 demonstrated the strongest inflammatory response at 1.0 X l O and 9  5.0 X 1 0 bacterial equivalents/ml as determined by the Histologic Scores. Y 4 demonstrated a 9  greater response than the other two strains at 0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml at day 15. A t the 9  lowest dilution of 0.05 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml, a l l three strains produced an equal 9  response. Strain I D H 1705 demonstrates the least variable and the lowest inflammatory response of the three strains.  87  Figure 9 Inflammatory Response of Varying Dilutions of strains JP2, Y4 and IDH 1705 - Day 15 - Abdomen (XlO)  88  i  1i i 1-  i  i  i  i  • JP2 • Y4 • 1705  i  Histologic Score  F i g u r e 9 G r a p h of Inflammatory Response of v a r y i n g dilutions of strains J P 2 , Y 4 a n d I D H 1705 - D a y 15 - A b d o m e n  0  0.05  0.5  Cell Eqn ivalents  89  1  X10(9)  5  3.6 R e p r o d u c i b i l i t y of the K i n e t i c Response.  In order to detenriine the reproducibility o f the kinetic response, a final experiment was done using 1:10 dilution (0.5X10 bacterial equivalents/ml) of the three strains of Aa for day 5, 15, 25. 9  Four mice were used in each grouping for a total of 36. The Histologic Scores from a l l animals that were tested at 0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents in all experiments were used to calculate the 9  mean of the histologic Scores. Figure 10 demonstrates the mean of the histological scores of the 3 strains at 0.5 X 10 bacterial components/ml at day 5, 15, 25. 9  A s can be seen from the graph, the mean Histologic Score for JP2 was highest o f the three species day 5 and 15, representing the acute phase of the inflammatory response. B y day 25, the chronic inflammatory phase, the JP2 response was consistently reduced, as revealed by the lower Histologic Score. Strain Y 4 demonstrated a mean Histologic Score that increased with time (not statistically significant), but overall, the inflammatory response was lower than the JP2 P M N response. As seen in the former experiments, strain I D H 1705 demonstrates low Histologic Scores, (particularly by day 25), which are not significantly different from strain Y 4 . There were extreme inconsistencies with one animal in both of the strain groups ( Y 4 and I D H 1705) that may have affected the mean values.  90  Figure 10 Graph of Mean Histologic Scores and Standard Errors of JP2, Y4 and IDH 1705 (dilution 0.5 X 10 bacterial equivalents/ml) - Day 15. 9  91  Figure 10 M e a n Histologic Scores and S t a n d a r d E r r o r s o f J P 2 , Y 4 , a n d I D H 1705 (0.5 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml) - D a y 15. 9  92  3.7  Immunohistological Analysis of the Cellular infiltrate Mediated by Three Strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans.  Day 5 and 15, representing the early and acute inflammatory phases, were chosen to investigate the immunohistologic response in this murine model. Using the antibody F4/80, neutrophil and C D 3 T-cell, the Immunohistologic Score for undilute strains JP2, Y 4 and I D H 1705 was determined as described earlier. The Immunohistological Score for the three antibodies is displayed in Table 1.  A s can be seen in Table land Figure 11, tissue sections from JP2- and Y4-injected animals demonstrate a very strong and equal response to F4/80, for both 5 and 15 days. I D H 1705 induced a strong F4/80 monocyte/macrophage response day 15, equal to the other two antibodies.  The neutrophil response is the highest for JP2 at 5 days and less at 15 days. Y 4  shows a moderate neutrophil response day 5, but I D H 1705 demonstrates an equal neutrophil infiltration at day 15. The T-cell response induced by a l l strains is similar for both days, with a very strong response detected day 15 for JP2. The weakest is demonstrated on day 15 by I D H 1705.  93  Table 1 Immunohistologic Score of F4/80, neutrophil and CD3 for 3 undilute strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans at day 5 and day 15.  Figure 11 The Immunohistologic Response of 3 antibodies at day 5 and 15 for undilute JP2. 11(a) F4/80 - day 5, day 15 11(b) Neutrophil - day 5, day 15 11(c) CD3 - day 5, day 15  94  Table 1 Immunohistologic Score of the 3 Antibodies for undilute JP2, Y4 and IDH 1705 Day 5 and 15  JP2  Y4  1705  CD3 T-cell  Neutrophil  F4/80  Time (days)  Aa  5  4  4  2  15  4  3  4  5  4  3  2  15  4  2  2  5  3  2  2  15  4  3  1  95  Figure 11(a) Immunohistologic Response of Antibody F4/80 for JP2 at day 5 and 15 (XlO)  F i g u r e 11(b)  Immunohistologic Response of Neutrophil A n t i b o d y for J P 2 at day 5 and  Figure 11(c) Immunohistologic Response of Antibody CD3 for JP2 at day 5 and 15 (XlO)  CHAPTER FOUR - DISCUSSION  4.1 Inflammatory Response of Viable Bacteria Compared to Non-viable Bacteria in Mice  Robert K o c h , in 1800, first demonstrated the technique o f creating abscesses subcutaneously in mice. Since that time, hundreds of investigators have used and modified this technique. In models involving mice, researchers have been able to study in vivo, the etiology, control, treatment and ultimately prevention of disease in man and animals (Madden and Fujiwara, 1982). In abscess models the pathogenic activities o f periodontal pathogens injected s.e. into tissues other than the periodontium have attempted to provide controlled and interpretable results for assessing selected host-parasite interactions and examining pathology and virulence potential associated with soft tissue destruction.  One of the first reported techniques for producing subcutaneous encapsulated abscesses was first developed by introducing cultures of B. frigalis or S. aureus homogenized with autoclaved cecal contents by subcutaneous inoculation in mice (Wilkins et al, 1977; Dickerman et al, 1980 and Joiner et al, 1980). Since then, various suspending media and bacteria or combinations of bacteria have been used in the study o f pathogenesis and virulence. These studies utilize such bacteria as A. actinomycetemcomitans (Taubman et al, 1984; Chen et al, 1991; Kurita-Ochiai et al, 1992; Ebersole etal, 1995), C. rectus (Ebersole etal, 1995), and F. nucleatum (Baumgartner et al., 1992; Ebersole et al, 1995; Feuille et al, 1996). Other species used for abscess models include P. anaerobius and V. parvula (Baumgartner et al, 1992), T. denticola (Ebersole et al, 1995), P. gingivalis (Van Steenbergen et al, 1982, 1986; Chen et al, 1987; Genco C A et al, 1991; Baumgartner et al, 1992; Kesavalu et al, 1992, 1995; Schifferle et al, 1993; Ebersole et al, 1995; E k e et al, 1996; Feuille et al, 1996; Gemmell et al, 1997), P. intermedia (Chen et al, 99  1987; Baumgartner et al., 1992), P. melaninogenica  (Van Steenbergen et al, 1981; Baumgartner  et al, 1992) and W. rectus (Kesavalu et al, 1991; Chen et al, 1991; Ebersole et al, 1995).  The subcutaneous infection in the M A M is characterized by localized abscess formation (with gangrenous necrosis o f skin and subcutaneous layers and/or dry gravity abscesses with no pus) at the injection site within 3 days. This may occur with or with out a secondary spreading, phlegmonous abscess containing pus, blood and exudate. These secondary spreading abscesses often involve subcutaneous tissues and muscle layers in the dorsal, flank and ventral side of the abdomen, base o f the tail or thoracic region. Live bacteria can be cultivated from the secondary abscesses, depending on the species or combinations of species. Lesion size remains stable through 7-9 days, with resolution occurring 12-15 days. W i t h virulent organisms, the mice display severe cachexia, ruffled hair, hunched bodies, weight loss and ultimately death (Kesavalu etal,  1991; Chenet al, 1991; Genco etal,  1991; Schifferle et al, 1993; Ebersole et al, 1995;  Eke etal, 1996).  Subcutaneously injected heat-killed F. nucleatum caused the formation of local lesions only, with no spreading abscess formation at distant sites (Feuille et al, 1996). Investigations o f heatkilled P. gingivalis demonstrated no lesions or abscess development when injected subcutaneously (Genco C A et al, 1991; Kesavalu et al, 1992, 1995; Eke et al, 1996; Feuille et al, 1996;). Genco, on examination o f lesions caused by non-viable P. gingivalis, reported seeing a few P M N s on histologic examination on day 1, but no P M N s after day 3. Joiner et al. (1980) reported no lesion development with heat-killed B. fragilis or S. aureus. Non-viable C. rectus did not elicit a localized abscess when injected s.e. (Ebersole etal, 100  1995).  No dilutions o f the three strains o f non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans  used in these  experiments led to observable abscess formation and none of the animals appeared cachectic or died as a result of injection of the bacteria. This is in agreement with other investigators using non-viable bacteria as reported.  4.2 Non-viable Bacterial Murine Model compared to Murine Abscess Model  The murine abscess models use subcutaneously injected live bacteria, at concentrations of 1 X l O to 5 X l O 7  1 1  bacterial ml, depending on the bacterial strain used. The non-viable bacterial  model involves injections of sonicated killed bacteria (three strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans),  at concentrations of 0.05 X l O to 5.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml to 9  9  study the virulence ability o f each of the strains by a quantitative analysis o f the histologic and immunohistologic response. The virulence of A. actinomycetemcomitans  is largely dependent on  its surface ultrastructure that includes fimbriae, vesicles o f lipopolysaccharide, and extracellular amorphous material (important for adhesion).  Although the A. actinomycetemcomitans  were non-viable, their outer membrane virulence factors were still able to cause a tissue inflammatory response, without causing death to the mice.  101  strains  4.2.1  Histologic Response in the M A M and Non-viable Bacterial Model.  Most of the abscess models provided descriptions of the mice or the encapsulated abscesses produced by injection of live bacteria. Virulence was determined by lesion size and shape (Chen et al, 1991; Kesavalu et al, 1990; Ebersole et al, 1995; Feuille et al, 1996) or lesion area and volume (Joiner et al, 1979; Kesavalu et al, 1992, 1995; Schifferle et al, 1993) produced by the various strains and dilutions o f the bacteria. Other indicators of virulence were the spreading capability o f the abscesses to distant sites (Van Steenbergen et al, 1986; Chen et al, 1987; Eke et al, 1996) or death o f the animal (Wilkins et al, 1977; Chen et al, 1987; Baumgartner et al., 1992; Ebersole et al, 1995). Histology was not reported in most of the studies. In the murine abscess models that did look at the histological response, either descriptively or quantitatively, a P M N infiltrate and inflammatory exudate were apparent in the early abscess lesions 1-5 days postinoculation (Joiner et al, 1979; Kesavalu et al, 1990; Genco et al, 1991; Ebersole et al, 1995). In a virulence study by Kesavalu et al (1990), tissue sections o f the skin lesions produced by Wolinella recta revealed coagulation necrosis o f the epidermis, as well as underlying cutaneous muscle. Marked exudation of serum proteins and neutrophils were seen beneath the necrotic area. Joiner et al. (1980) described the abscess produced by the injection of B. fragilis or S. aureus as having a distinct band o f white blood cells, 95% o f which were P M N s around the periphery o f the abscess by 24 hours. Garant (1976) demonstrated primary inflammatory cells consisting o f P M N s , macrophages, lymphocytes and monocytes in the gingival tissues of germ-free rats 65 days after infection with A. naeslundii.  As is characteristic  of the P M N host defense mechanism to periodontopathogens in the gingival sulcus of humans (Schroeder & Graf-deBeer, 1976; V a n Dyke & Hoop, 1990), P M N s also responded to the nonviable bacterial components injected into the tissues o f the mice in these experiments.  102  The current model o f A. actinomycetemcomitans  -induced inflammation demonstrates a  nonencapsulated inflammatory response to all A a strains and dilutions used in the study. JP2 demonstrates the most intense P M N reaction day 5 and 15 (Figure 2(d), 8(a), 8(b), 10). A T C C 43718 produces a strong acute P M N reaction similar to JP2 (Figure 3(d), 9) and the mean Histologic Score demonstrates the most intense P M N reaction at day 25 compared to the other two strains (Table 1). The inflammatory infiltration is much less intense with strain I D H 1705 (Figure 10), which is considered as a non-periodontopathogen (Saarela et al., 1992). These findings are in agreement with Ebersole et al. (1995) who showed a comparison o f the virulence capacity o f various A. actinomycetemcomitans  strains and serotypes in a M A M , indicating a  progression o f virulence (lesion size), with JP2 >_Y4 >_serotype c. Virulence differences within bacterial strains (other than A.a) were also demonstrated by V a n Steenbergen et al, 1982; Kesavalu etal,  1990; Genco etal,  1991 and Ebersole etal,  1995).  4.2.1.1 Time/Dose Effects on the Histological Response.  The Histological Scores of the varying doses of A. actinomycetemcomitans  demonstrate a weaker  cellular response with higher dilution o f the bacteria. Figure 5 demonstrates the dose responses (abdomen) of varying dilutions o f JP2 on day 15. The ear sample however, produced a more severe reaction with the 1.0 X 1 0 bacterial equivalents/ml on d a y l 5 than the undilute JP2. The 9  ear site provided a less predictable and less severe inflammatory reaction and eventually the abdomen site alone was used in future experiments. Figure 9 illustrates the histologic response to the three strains of varying doses on day 15. JP2 demonstrates the highest histologic scores for dilutions 5.0 X l O and 1.0 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml, with strain Y 4 showing an equally 9  9  intense inflammatory reaction at 0.5 X 1 0 bacterial equivalents/ml. I D H 1705 demonstrated the 9  103  weakest reaction at higher concentrations but was equal to the other strains at the lowest concentrations. A l l o f the strains demonstrated a minimal P M N , macrophage response at the lowest dilution, 0.05 X l O bacterial equivalents/ml. The inflammatory response to A. 9  actinomycetemcomitans  at this low dose does not appear to be related to the virulence o f the  strain.  In many M A M virulence studies, lesion size and death of the mice were shown to be dose dependent. Genco etal. (1991) demonstrated the pathological course of P. gingivalis using many strains and dilutions, and found that at higher doses severe abscesses or death resulted, where lower doses demonstrated smaller localized lesions or no pathology at all.  These results  are in agreement with Ebersole et al. (1995) who demonstrated dose dependency for P. gingivalis,  W. recta, and F. nucleatum.  Although the mice in the non-viable bacterial model did  not die, virulence variation was shown to be dose dependent for A. actinomycetemcomitans  as  indicated by the Histologic Score.  In the M A M studies, most of the animals developed severe abscesses by 24-48 hour, with septicemia or death by day 4-5. If the mice did not die, the lesion size remained stable until day 7- 9. Resolution would occur by approximately 12-15 days. The acute responses for the live bacterial model occurred within hours. Day 5 represents the acute time period in the non-viable bacteria study for strain JP2 (Figure 2(d), 8(a) and (b)); day 15 demonstrates a similar or less severe reaction for JP2, the P M N response being less localized and more diffuse. Y 4 is also time dependent, but with less variation in inflammatory response between day 5 and day 15. B y day 25, the inflammatory response was similar for all three strains. 104  Non-viable P. gingivalis elicited only a slight P M N response on day 1. N o P M N s were seen after day 3 (Van Steenbergen et al, 1982; Genco et al, 1991). This is markedly different from the inflammatory response detected using non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans  in this study.  Further investigation is needed to draw conclusions about the comparative virulence of nonviable P. gingivalis and non-viable A.  4.2.2  actinomycetemcomitans.  Immunohistological Response in the M A M and Non-Viable Bacterial Model  In this study, antibodies F4/80, anti-neutrophil and anti-CD3, were used to study specific cells recruited into the lesions during the inflammatory response. The Immunohistologic Scores are presented in Table 1 for the three antibodies after injection with undilute JP2, Y 4 and I D H 1705 strains on A. actinomycetemcomitans.  A l l three antibodies identified specific leukocyte  subpopulations at day 5 and day 15.  4.2.2.1 Time Effects on the Immunohistologic Response  JP2 and Y 4 (both strain b), demonstrate a very strong F4/80 response (monocyte and macrophage) at day 5 and 15. I D H 1705 did not demonstrate quite as strong a response on day 5, but was equal to the other two strains by day 15. This was closely matched by the neutrophil antibody response, with JP2 showing the highest Immunohistologic Scores and I D H 1705 again  105  showing a stronger reaction at day 15 than day 5. A s expected, the F4/80 and neutrophil responses were high at days 5 and 15, representing the early acute and late acute phases o f inflammation in this study. P M N s and macrophages are the most important phagocytic cells in the defense of the host against acute bacterial infections (Van Dyke & Hoop, 1990) and this was demonstrated in this study for both P M N s and macrophages.  In a similar quantitative study o f P. gingivalis performed by Gemmell (1997), H and E staining demonstrated a P M N , macrophage inflammatory response from day 1 in their murine abscess model study. They also detected and counted C D 4 and C D 8 T cells, noting their presence in the lesions from day 1, with increasing numbers during the time course o f the experiment. This is in agreement with the results of this study for JP2, where the C D 3 response is greater at day 15 than day 5. For Y 4 , both days 5 and 15 demonstrate an equal response while I D H 1705 produced a low Immunohistologic Score, especially at day 15. While the Immunohistologic Scores are relatively low, these results suggest that in this A. actinomycetemcomitans-induced inflammatory mouse model, there is a protective immune response to non-viable bacteria, depending on the virulence characteristic o f the strain of A. actinomycetemcomitans. JP2 (serotype b), mounts a greater T cell response than Y 4 (serotype b), which in turn, demonstrates a greater response than I D H 1705 (serotype e). The late or chronic response at 25 days was not looked at in this study, so no conclusions can be made for the later immunologic response of the antibodies at that time.  4.3 Strengths and Weaknesses of the A. actinomycetemcomitans-induced Model of Inflammation  The previously discussed abscess models of inflammation have many limitations, the first o f which is its imprecise quantitation. Lesion size is variable, making assessment difficult, and 106  animal death often results. Histologic analysis is not always available. Quantitative assessment of the dynamics of the infection and resulting pathology is an important component in elucidating the pathogenesis of bacterial infections. The MAM is not capable of assessing these dynamics quantitatively.  The application of this A. actinomycetemconitans-induced model of inflammation allows the use of the virulence components of A.a, which results in localized pathology, but does not kill the mice. Acute lesions, chronic infection, and resolution can be studied in this animal model. This model can localize or concentrate the bacteria, to study the PMN migration and phagocytosis during the critical stages of inflammation. The quantitative measurements take into consideration the number of cells seen in the inflammatory response, as well as the percentage of spread of the inflammation. The relationship between these cells relating to time and dose of bacteria can also be determined. Further studies could be designed to determine what effect particular drugs would have on cellular and immunological responses, or determine what mechanisms could enhance/inhibit the destructive host responses to periodontopathogens. This animal model could be used to grade virulence factors such as fimbriae or membrane proteins if assessed individually.  The results of this study however must not be used to directly compare the mouse inflammatory and immunohistological mechanisms to the human subject, nor can we concluded that all bacteria will produce the same degree of inflammatory response as various strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans.  The vast majority of the virulence studies to date have been done with  Porphyromonas gingivalis  strains and this study took the liberty to compare results as much as  possible to the mechanisms of the response, rather than to the actual bacterial responses of P. gingivalis.  107  The reproducibility o f the inflammatory response to various strains and serotypes of A. actinomycetemcomitans  demonstrated a strong trend, rather than a statistically significant  quantitative difference in virulence between strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans  in the non-  viable mouse model. Further studies with a greater number of mice would be needed to statistically prove the trends shown in this work. A s only one observer did the entire experiment, intraobserver variation may have been inevitable. A repeat o f the study with several observers and lab technicians could determine the validity o f these results. However, this study did demonstrate a higher Histologic and Immunologic Score with strain JP2 than either Y 4 or I D H 1705 throughout the experiments. Strain IDH1705, considered the least virulent strain (Saarela et al, 1992), demonstrated the lowest Histologic Scores and the least Immunohistologic response overall.  108  CONCLUSIONS  The objectives o f this study were to develop a quantifiable, reproducible model o f A. actinomycetemcomitans-mduced  inflammation, that would demonstrate virulence differences  between strains. This mouse model o f inflammation, using non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans  bacteria, was able to identify and grade the virulence differences  between several strains by the intensity o f the induced inflammatory response. Inflammatory responses for various dilutions o f bacteria were also determined and graded at selected time intervals, and found to be time dependent. It was demonstrated that non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans  induced both a histologic and immunohistologic response in a mouse  model. The results suggest that the non-viable A. actinomycetemcomitans-induced  lesions in  C D - I mice are consistent with a strong innate immune response involving the recruitment of neutrophils. This is followed by the infiltration o f phagocytic macrophages and T-cells.  There are currently available no other animal models that study inflammation in a quantifiable, reproducible fashion. There are implications for future uses of this model to determine the quantitative bacteriology involved in virulence and immunological responses, treatment trials (antibiotics, anti-inflammatory agents, steroids), and ultimate healing of induced lesions in animal models.  109  REFERENCES  Alexander M B , Damoulis P D . The role of cytokines in the pathogenesis o f periodontal disease. Curr. Opin. Periodontal. : 39-53, 1994. Altman L C , Page R C , Bowen T, Ochs H . and Osterberg S. Neutrophil and monocyte chemotaxis in patients with various forms o f periodontal disease. Program and Abstracts, Abs. # 252: 1980. Anerud A , L o e H , Boysen H , Smith M . The natural history o f periodontal disease in man. Changes in gingival health and oral hygiene before 40 years of age. / . Periodont Res. 14: 526540, 1979. Asikainen S, L a i C H , Alaluusua S, Slots J. Distribution of A. actinomycetemcomitans serotypes in periodontal health and disease. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 6: 115-118,1991. Astemborski J A , Boughman J A , M y r i c k P O , Goodman S B , Wooten R K , Agarwal S, Vincent J W and Suzuki JB. Clinical and laboratory characterization o f Early Onset Periodontitis. J. Periodont. 60: 557-563, 1989. Attstrom R and Engelberg J. Presence o f leukocytes in crevices o f healthy and chronically inflamed gingiva. J. Periodont. Res. 5(1): 42-47, 1970. Baer P. The case for periodontosis as a clinical entity. / . Periodont. 42(8): 516-529, 1971. Baker P J and Wilson M E . Opsonic IgG antibody against A. actinomycetemcomitans in localized juvenile periodontitis. Oral Microbiol Immunol. 4:98-105,1989. Barkin R M , Weston W L , Humbert JR, and Maire F. Phagocytic function in D o w n ' s syndrome. 11. Bactericidal activity and phagocytosis. J. Ment. Defic. Res. 24: 251-256, 1980. Barr-Agholme M , Dahllof G , Linder L , Modeer T. A. actinomycetemcomitans, Captnocytophaga and Porphyromonas gingivalis in subgingival plaque o f adolescents with Down's syndrome. Oral Microbiol Immunol. 7:244-248,1992. Baumgartner J C , Falkler W A Jr, Beckerman T. Experimentally induced infection by oral anaerobic microorganisms in a mouse model. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 7: 253-256, 1992. Beck J D , K o c h G G , Rozier R G , et al. Prevalence and risk indicators for periodontal attachment loss in a population of older community-dwelling blacks and whites. J. Periodont. 61: 521-528, 1990. Beck JD, K o c h G G , Zambon JJ et al. Evaluation of oral bacteria as risk indicators for periodontitis in older adults. J. Periodont. 63: 93-99, 1992. Becker William, Berg Lawrence, Becker Burton E . Untreated periodontal disease: A longitudinal study. J. Periodont. 50(5): 243-244, 1979.  110  Bellido T, Jilka RI, Boyce B F , Girasole G et al. Regulation of interleukin-6, osteoclastogenseis and bone mass by androgens. The role o f androgen receptors. J. Clin. Invest. 95: 2886-2895, 1995. In: Schwartz Z , Goultschin J, Dean D and B o w e n B . Mechanisms o f alveolar bone destruction in periodontitis. Periodont. 2000. 14:161,1997. Belting C M , Hiniker JJ, Dummett C O . Influence o f diabetes mellitis on the severity o f periodontal disease. J. Periodont. 35: 476-480, 1964. Belting C M , Massler M . and Schour I. Prevalence and incidence of alveolar bone loss. 47: 190-197, 1953.  J.A.D.A.  Berthold P, Listgarten M A . Distribution of A. actinomycetemcomitans in localized juvenile periodontitis plaque: an electron immunochemical study. J. Periodont. Res. 21: 473-785, 1986. Bertollini D R , Votta B , Hoffman S, Strassmann G . Interleukin 6 production in fetal rat long bone cultures is correlated with PGE2 release and does not correlate with bone resorption. Cytokine 6: 368-375,1994. In: Schwartz Z , Goultschin J, Dean D , Boyan B . Mechanisms o f alveolar bone destruction in periodontitis. Periodont. 2000. 14: 161, 1997. Birkedal-Hansen H . Roles o f cytokines and inflammatory mediators in tissue destruction. J. Periodont. Res. 28: 500-510, 1993. Black G V . Operative Dentistry. 4: 165, Chicago, Medico-Dental Publishing C o . , 1936. In Weinmann JP. Progress of gingival inflammation into the supporting structures o f the teeth. J. Periodont. 12(2): 71-81, 1941. Bowen T J , Ochs H D , Altman L C , Price T H , V a n Epps D E , Brautigna D L , Rosin R E , Perkins W D , Babior B M , Klebanoff SJ, and Wedgewood R J . Severe recurrent bacterial infections associated with defective adherence and chemotaxis in two patients with neutrophil deficiency in a cell-associated glycoprotein. J. Pediatr. 101: 932, 1982. Brogan J M , Lally E T , Poulsen K , K i l i a n M , Demuth D R . Regulation of A. actinomycetemcomitans leukotoxin expression: Analysis of the promotor regions of leukotoxic and minimally leukotoxic strains. Infect Immun. 62:501-508,1994. Burmeister J A , Best A M , Palcanis K G , Caine F A , Ranney R R . Localized juvenile periodontitis and generalized severe periodontitis: clinical findings. J. Clin. Periodontol. 11: 181-192, 1984. Carranza F A , Newman Michael G . Clinical Periodontology. Eighth Edition. Philadelphia. W . B . Saunders Company, 1996. Caton J. Periodontal diagnosis and diagnostic aids. In: Proceedings of the World Workshop in Clinical Periodontics. Chicago: The American Academy of Periodontology. July 23-27:1-1 to 132, 1989. Caton J. Establishing and maintaining clinically healthy gingiva in the Rhesus monkey. J. Clin Periodont. 6(4): 260-263, 1979.  Ill  Caton J and Crigger M . A primate model for the treatment o f periodontal lesions. J. Periodont. Res. 20: 14-15, 1972. Caton J G , Zander H A . Primate model for testing periodontal treatment procedures. 1. Histological investigation o f localized periodontal pockets produced by orthodontic elastics. J. Periodont. 46(2): 71-77, 1975. Cianciola L J , Park B H , Bruck E , Mosovich L , Genco R J . Prevalence o f periodontal disease in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (juvenile diabetes). J. Am. Dent. Assoc. 104: 653-660, 1982. Chen P B , Davern L B , Neiders M E , Reynolds H S , Zambon JJ. Analysis of in vitro lymphoproliferative responses and antibody formation following subcutaneous injection of A . actinomycetemcomitans and Wolinella recta in a murine model. Oral Microbiol. 6: 12-16, 1991. Chen P B , Neiders M E , Millar S L , Reynolds H S , and Zambon JJ. Effect o f immunization on experimental Bacteroides gingivalis infection in a murine model. Infect. Immun. 55(10): 25342537, 1987. Christersson L A , A l b i b i B , Zambon JJ, Slots J and Genco R J . Demonstration of A. actinomycetemcomitans in gingiva of localized juvenile periodontitis lesions. J. Dent Res. 62: 198, abstract no. 255, 1983. Christersson L A , A l b i n i B , Zambon J, Wikesjo M E and Genco R J . Tissue location of A. actinomycetemcomitans in human periodontitis. 1. Light, Immunofluorescence and electron microscopic studies. J. Periodont. 58(8): 529-539, 1987. Christersson L A , Grossi S G , Dunford R G et al. Dental plaque and calculus: risk indicators for their formation. / . Dent. Res. 71: 1425-1430, 1992. Christersson L A , Slots J, Rosling B and Genco RJ. Microbial and clinical effects of surgical treatment of localized juvenile periodontitis. J. Clin. Periodontol. 12: 465-476. Chung Hyun-Ju, Chung Chong-Pyoug, Son Seong-Heui and Nisengard R J. A. actinomycetemcomitans serotypes and leukotoxicity in Korean localized juvenile periodontitis. J. Periodont. 60: 506-511, 1989. Cichon P, Crawford L , and G r i m m W D . Early-onset periodontitis associated with Down's Syndrome - A clinical interventional study. Annals of Periodont. 3(1): 370-380, 1997. Cohen D W , Friedman L A , Shapiro J, Kyle G C , Franklin S. Diabetes Mellitis and periodontal disease: two-year longitudinal observations. Part 1. J. Periodont. 41: 709-712, 1970. Coolidge E D . JADA 18: 2255, 1939. In Weinmann JP. Progress of gingival inflammation into the supporting structures of the teeth. J. Periodont. 12(2): 71-81, 1941. Costerton JW, Landowski Z , Caldwell D E , Korber D R , Lappin-Scott H M . Microbiofilm. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 49: 711-745, 1995. 112  Costerton J W , Landowski Z , DeBeer D , Caldwell D , et al. Biofilms, the customized microniche. J. Bacteriol. 176: 2137-2142, 1994. Dahlen G , Renvert S, Wikstrom M and Egelbert J. Reproducibility of microbiological samples from periodontal pockets. J. Clin. Periodontal. 17: 73-77, 1990. Darveau R P , Tanner A and Page R C . The microbial challenge in periodontitis. Periodont. 2000. 14: 12-32, 1997. Dennison D K and V a n Dyke T E . The acute inflammatory response and the role of phagocytic cells in periodontal health and disease. Periodont 2000. 14: 54-78, 1997. Dewhirst Fe, A g o J M , Peros W J , Stashenko P. Synergism between parathyroid hormone and interleuki-1 in stimulating bone resorption in organ culture. J. Bone Miner. Res. 2: 127-134, 1987. Dewhirst F E , Moss D E , Offenbacher S, Goodson J M . Levels o f P G E 2 , thromboxane, and prostacyclin in periodontal tissues. J. Periodont. Res. 18: 156-163,1983. DiRenzo J M and Slots J. Genetic approach to the study o f epidemiology and pathogenesis o f A. actinomycetemcomitans in localized juvenile periodontitis. Arch. Oral Biol. 35: 79S-84S, 1990. DiRenzo J M , M c K a y T L . Identification and characterization of genetic cluster groups of A. actinomycetemcomitans isolated from the human oral cavity. / . Clin. Microbiol. 32: 75-81, 1994. Ebersole J L , Kesavalu L , Schneider S L , Machen R L , and Holt S C . Comparative virulence of periodontopathogens in a mouse abscess model. Oral Diseases 1: 115-128,1995. Ebersole J L , Schneider S L , Szekeresova M , Crawley R R and Holt S C . Murine models for virulence characteristics. / . Dent. Res. 68: 268, 1989. Ebersole J L , Singer R E , Steffanson B , Filloon T, Kornman K S . Inflammatory mediators in G C F from healthy, gingivitis, and periodontitis sites. J. Periodont. Res. 28: 543-546, 1993. Ebersole J L and Taubman M A . The protective nature o f host responses in periodontal diseases. Periodont. 2000. 5: 112-141, 1994. Ebersole J L , Taubman M A and Smith D J . Gingival crevicular fluid antibody to oral microorganism. 11. Distribution and specificity to local antibody responses. J. Periodont. Res. 20: 349-356, 1985. Ebersole R J , Taubman M A , Smith D J , Genco R J , Frey D E . Human immune responses to oralmicroorganisms. 1. Association of localized juvenile periodontitis with serum antibody response to A. actinomycetemcomitans. Clin. Exp. Immunol. 47: 43-52, 1982.  113  EEC-Clearinghouse on Oral Problems Related to HIV-Infection and W H O Collaborating Center on Oral Manifestation for the Human Immunodeficiency virus. Classification and diagnostic criteria for oral lesions in H I V infection. J. Oral Path. Med. 22: 289-291, 1993. Eke PI, Rotimi V O , Laughin B E . Experimental model for Porphyromonas in animals. Afr. J. Med. Med. Sci. 25: 31-39, 1996.  gingivalis infection  E l Attar T M A , L i n H S . Prostaglandins in gingiva of patients with periodontal disease. J. Periodont. 52: 16-19, 1981. Everts V , V a n der Zee E , Creemers L , Beertsen W . Phagocytosis and intracellular digestion of collagen, its role in turnover and remodelling. Histochem. J. 28: 229-245, 1996. Feuille F, Ebersole J L , Kesavalu L , Steffen M J , and Holt S C . Mixed infection with Porphyromonas gingivalis and Fusobacterium nucleatum in a murine lesion model: Potential synergistic effects on virulence. Infect Immun. 64(6): 2095-2100, 1996. Firestein G , Roeder W , Laxer J et al. A new murine C D 4 + T cell subset with an unrestricted cytokine profile. / . Immunol. 143: 518-525, 1989. Fish E W . J.A.D.A. 20: 691, 1939. In Weinmann JP. Progress o f gingival inflammation into the supporting structures of the teeth. J. Periodont. 12(2): 71-81, 1941. Fisher L D and V a n Belle G . Biostatistics. A methodology for the Health Sciences. N e w York. John Wiley & Sons, Inc, 1993. Fives-Taylor P, Meyer D and Mintz K . Characteristics of A. actinomycetemcomitans. of and adhesion to cultures epithelial cells. Adv. Dent. Res. 9(1): 55-62, 1995.  Invasion  Fives-Taylor P, Meyer D and Mintz K . Virulence factors of the periodontopathogen A. actinomycetemcomitans. J. Periodont. 67: 291-297, 1996. Friedman, R B et al. Periodontal status of HIV-seropositive and A I D S patients. J. Periodont. 2: 623-627, 1991. Gad T. Periodontal disease in dogs. J. Periodont. Res. 3: 268-273, 1968. Galloway W A , Murphy G , Sandy J D et al. Purification and characterization o f rabbit bone metalloproteinases that degrade proteoglycan and other connective tissue components. Biochem. J. 209: 741-752, 1983. Garant PR. Microscopic study of the periodontal tissues of germ-free rats and rats monoinfected with Actinomyces naeslundii. J. Periodont. Res. ll(suppl. 15): 9-79, 1976 Gemmell E , Bird PS, Bowman JJD, X u L , Polak B , Walsh L J and Seymore G J . Immunohistological study of lesions induced by Porphyromonas gingivalis in a murine model. Oral Microbiol Immunol. 12: 288-297, 1997.  114  Gemmell E, Marshall RI and Seymore G. Cytokines and prostaglandins in immune homeostasis and tissue destruction in periodontal disease. Periodont. 2000. 14: 112-143, 1997. Gemmell E and Seymour G. Modulation of immune responses to periodontal bacteria. Curr. Opin. Periodont. : 28-38, 1994.  Genco CA and Arko RL. Animal chamber models for the study of host-parasite interactions. Methods in Enzymology. 235: 120-140, 1994.  Genco CA, Cutler CW, Kapczynski D, Maloney K and Arnold RR. A novel mouse model to study the virulence of and host response to Porphyromonas (Bacteroides) gingivalis. Infect. Immun. 59(4): 1255-1263, 1991. Genco RJ. Current View of Risk Factors for Periodontal Diseases. J. Periodont. 67(10): 10411049, 1996. Genco RJ. Host responses in periodontal diseases: current concepts. J. Periodont. 53:338-355, 1992. Genco RJ, Van Dyke TE, Levine MJ, Nelson RD, Wilson ME. Molecular factors influencing neutrophil defects in periodontal disease. J. Dent.Res. 65: 1379-1391, 1986. Genco RJ, Zambon JJ and Murray PA. Serum and gingival fluid antibodies as adjuncts in the diagnosis of A. actinomycetemcomitans-assoc'uted periodontal disease. J. Periodont. 56:41-50, 1985. Gibbons RJ. Bacterial adhesion to oral tissues: a model for infectious disease. J. Dent. Res. 68: 750-760, 1989. Gjermo P. Chemotherapy in juvenile periodontitis. J. Clin. Periodontol. 13:982-986. Glickman I, and Smulow J. Chronic desquamative gingivitis: Its nature and treatment. J. Periodont. 35: 397-405, 1965. Gmur R, McNabb H, Van Steenbergen TJMB, Baehni P, MombeUi A, Van Winkelhoff AJ, Guggenheim B. Seroclassification of hitherto nontypeable A. actinomycetemcomitans strains: evidence for a new serotype e. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 8: 116-120, 1993. Goldhaber P, Giddon DB. Present concepts concerning the etiology and treatment of ANUG. Int. Dent. J. 14: 468-496, 1964. Goodson JM, Tanner ACR, Haffejee AD, Sornberger GC, Socransky SS. Patterns of progression and regression of advanced periodontal disease. J. Clin. Periodontol. 9: 472-481, 1982. Grant DA, Stern IB and Listgarten MA. Periodontics. Sixth Edition. St. Louis. The C.V. Mosby Company, 1988. Grenier D and Mayrand D. Selected characteristics of pathogenic and nonpathogenic strains of Bacteroides gingivalis. J. Clin. Microbiol. 25: 738-740, 1987.  115  Haffajee A D and Socransky SS. Microbiological agents o f destructive periodontal disease. Periodont. 2000. 5: 78-111, 1994. Haffejee A D , Socransky SS, Dzink J L , Taubman M A and Ebersole J L . Clinical, microbiological and immunological features of subjects with refractory periodontal diseases. J. Clin. Periodontol. 15: 390-398, 1988. Hammond B F , Lillard S E and Stevens R H . A bacteriocin o f A. actinomycetemcomitans. Immun. 55(3): 686-691, 1987.  Infect.  Hart T C , and Shapira L . Papillon-Lefevre syndrome. Periodont. 2000 6:88-100. Haubek, D , Poulsen K , Westergaard J, Dahlen G , K i l i a n M . Highly toxic clone o f A. actinomycetemcomitans in geographically widespread cases of juvenile periodontitis in adolescents of African origin. J. Clin. Microbiol. 34: 1576-1578,1996. Heijl L , Rifkin B R, Zander H A . Conversion of chronic gingivitis to periodontitis in squirrel monkeys. J. Periodont. 47(12): 710-716, 1976. Hernichel-Gorbach E , Kornman K S , Holt S C , Nichols F, Meador H , Kung JT and Thomas C . Host response in patients with generalized refractory periodontitis. J. Periodont. 65: 8-16, 1994. Hirschfeld L and Wasserman B . A long-term study o f tooth loss in 600 treated periodontal patients. J. Periodont. 49: 225-237. Holmstrup P, and Westergaard J. Periodontal diseases in HIV-infected patients. J. Clin. Periodontol. 21: 270-280, 1994. Holt S C , Ebersole J L , Felton J, Brunsvold M , Kornman K S . Implantation of Bacteroides gingivalis in non-human primates initiates progression of periodontitis. Science. 239: 55-57, 1988. Holt S C , Kesavalu L , Walker S and Genco C . Virulence factors of Porphyromonas Periodont. 2000. 20: 168-238, 1999.  gingivalis.  Holt S C , Tanner A C R and Socransky SS. Morphology and ultrastructure of oral strains o f A. actinomycetemcomitans and Haemophilus aphrophilus. Infect. Immun. 30: 588-600, 1980. Hugoson A . Gingival inflammation and female sex hormones. A clinical investigation o f pregnant women and experimental studies in dogs. J. Periodont. Res. Suppl. 5: 1-18, 1970. Hugoson A , Thorstensson H , Falk H , Kuylenstierna J. Periodontal conditions in insulindependent diabetics. J. Clin. Periodontol. 16: 215-223, 1989. H u l l PS, Soames J V and Davies R M . Periodontal disease in the beagle dog colony. J. Comp. Path. 84: 143-150, 1974.  116  Ishikawa I, Nakasima K , Koseki T et al. Induction o f the immune response to periodontopathy bacteria and its role in the pathogenesis o f periodontitis. Periodont. 2000. 14: 79-111, 1997. Izumi Y , Sugiyama S, Shinozuka O, et al. Defective neutrophil chemotaxis in D o w n ' s syndrome patients and its relationship to periodontal destruction. J. Periodont. 60: 238-242, 1989. James W W and Counsell A . Br. Dent. J. 48: 1237, 1927. In Weinmann JP. Progression of gingival inflammation into supporting structures of teeth. J. Periodont. 12(2): 71-81, 1941. Jeffcoat M K , Reddy M S . Progression o f probing attachment loss in adult periodontitis. J. Periodont. 62: 185-189, 1991. Joiner K A , Onderdonk A B , Gelfand J A , Bartlett J G , Gorbach S L . A quantitative model for the subcutaneous abscess formation in mice. Br. J. Exp. Pathol. 61: 97-107, 1980. Kastelein P, V a n Steenbergen T J M , Bras J M and DeGraaff J. A n experimentally induced phlegmonous abscess by a strain o f Bacteroides gingivalis in guinea pigs and mice. In: Kesavalu L et al. Virulence o f Wolinella recta in a murine abscess model. Infection and Immunity 59(8): 2806-2817, 1991. Kesavalu L , Ebersole J L , Machen R L and Holt S C . Porphyromonas gingivalis virulence in mice: Induction o f immunity to bacterial components. Infect. Immun. 60(4): 1455-1464, 1992. Kesavalu L , Holt S C , Crawley R R , Borinski R and Ebersole J L . Virulence o f Wolinella recta in a murine abscess model. Infect. Immun. 59(8): 2806-2817, 1991. Kesavalu L , Holt S C and Ebersole J L . Trypsin-like proteases activity o f Porphyromonas gingivalis as a potential virulence factor in a murine lesion model. Microb. Path. 20: 1-10, 1996. K i l e y P, Holt S C . Characterization o f the lipopolysaccharide from A. actinomycetemcomitans Y 4 and N27. Infect. Immun. 30: 862-873, 1980. K i m i z u k a R, Miura T and Okuda K . Characteristics of A. actinomycetemcomitans hemolysin. Microbiol. Immunol. 40(10): 717-723, 1996. Kornman K S , Page R C and Tonetti M S . The host response to the microbial challenge in periodontitis: assembling the players. Periodont. 2000 14: 33-53, 1997. Kryshtalskj E , Sodek J, and Frerrier. Correlation of collagenolytic enzymes and inhibitors in G C F with clinical and microscopic changes in experimental periodontitis in the dog. Arch. Oral Biol. 31(1): 21-31, 1986. Kurita-Ochiai T, Ochiai K , Ikeda T. Immunosuppressive effect induced by A. actinomycetemcomitans: effect on immunoglobulin production and lymphokine synthesis. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 7: 338-343, 1992. Laine M L , V a n Winklehoff A J . Virulence of six capsular serotypes o f Porphyromonas gingivalis in a mouse model. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 13: 322-325, 1998. 117  Lally ET, Kieba IR, Golub EE, Lear JD and Tanaka J. Structure/function aspects of A. actinomycetemcomitans leukotoxin. J. Periodont. 67(3): 298-308, 1996. Lavine WS, Maderazo EG, Stolman J, et al. Impaired neutrophil chemotaxis in patients with juvenile and rapidly progressive periodontitis. J Periodont. Res. 14: 10-19, 1979. Leizer T, Clarris BJ, Ash PE. Van Damme J, Saklatvala J. Interleukin-1 (3 and interleukin-la stimulate the plasminogen activator activity and PGE2 levels of human synovial cells. Arthr. Rheum. 30: 562-566, 1987. In: Page R. The role of inflammatory mediators in the pathogenesis of periodontal disease. J. Periodont. Res. 26: 233,1991. Liakoni H, Barber P and Newman HN. Bacterial penetration of pocket soft tissue in chronic adult and juvenile periodontitis cases. J. Clin. Periodontol. 14: 22-28, 1987. Lindhe J, Hamp SE, and Loe H. Experimental periodontitis in the Beagle dog. J Periodont. Res. 8: 1-10, 1973. Lindhe J, Hamp SE, and Loe H. Plaque induced periodontal disease in beagle dogs. A 4-year clinical, roentgenographical and histometrical study. J. Periodont. Res. 10: 243-255, 1975. Listgarten MA. Pathogenesis of periodontitis. J. Clin. Periodontol.  13:418-425,1986.  Listgarten MA. The structure of dental plaque. Periodont. 2000 5: 52-65, 1994. Listgarten MA, Schifter CC, Laster L. 3-year longitudinal study of the periodontal status of an adult population with gingivitis. J. Clin. Periodontol. 12: 225-238, 1985. Lloyd A and Oppenheim JJ. Poly's Lament: the neglected role of the polymorphonuclear neutrophil in the afferent limb of the immune response. Immunol. Today 13: 169-172, 1992. Loe H, Anerud A, Boysen H and Morrison E. Natural history of periodontal disease in man. Rapid, moderate and no loss of attachment in Sri Lankan laborers 14 to 46 years of age. J. Clin. Periodontol.  13:431-440,1986.  Loe H, Anerud A, Boysen H and Smith M. The natural history of periodontal disease in man. The rate of periodontal destruction before 40 years of age. J Periodont. 40: 607-620, 1978. Loe H, Theilade E, and Jensen SB. Experimental gingivitis in man. J Periodont. 36: 177-187, 1965. Loesche WJ, Syed SA, Laughon BE, Stoll J. The bacteriology of acute necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis. J. Peridont. 53: 223-230, 1982. Madden TE and Caton JG. Animal models for periodontal research. Methods in Enzymology 235: 106-119, 1994. Madden DL and Fujiwara K. Selected bacterial diseases, Chapter 15. The Mouse in Biomedical Research. 4: 257-270, 1982. 118  Magnusson I, Marks R G , Clark W B , Walker C B , L o w S B and McArthur W P . Clinical, microbiological and immunological characteristic o f subjects with "refractory" periodontal disease. J. Clin. Periodontol. 18: 291-299, 1991. Markopoulos A K , Antoniades D , Papanayotou P and Trigonidis G . Desquamative gingivitis: A clinical, histopathological and immunological study. Quintessence International 27(11): 763767, 1996. Marshall-Day C D , and Schourie K L . Roentgenographic survey o f periodontal disease in India. J.A.D.A. 39: 572- 599, 1949. McCarthy F P , McCarthy P L , and Shklar G . Chronic desquamative gingivitis. Oral Surg., Oral Med, and Oral Pathol. 13(11): 1300-1313, 1960. M c F a l l W T Jr. Tooth loss in 100 treated patients with periodontal disease. A long-term study. J. Periodont. 53: 539-549, 1982. Mehta P D , Dalton A l , Mehta SP, et al. Immunoglobulin G subclasses in older persons with Down's syndrome. J. Neurolog. Sci. 117: 286-291, 1993. Meikle M C , Heath J K , Reynolds JJ. Advances in understanding cell interactions in tissue resorption. Relevance to the pathogenesis of periodontal disease and a new hypothesis. J. Oral Pathol. 15: 239-250, 1986. Meskin L H , Farsht E M , Amderson D L . Prevalence of Bacteroides melaninogenicus in the gingival crevice area o f institutionalized trisomy 2 l a n d cerebral palsy patients and normal children. J. Periodont. 39: 326-328, 1968. Meyer D H and Fives-Taylor P M . Characteristics o f adherence of A. actinomycetemcomitans epithelial cells. Infect. Immun. 62: 928-935, 1994. Meyer D H and Fives-Taylor P M . The role of A. actinomycetemcomitans periodontal disease. Trends in Microbiology 5(6): 224-228,1997.  to  in the pathogenesis of  Meyer D H , Lippman JE, and Fives-Taylor P M . Invasion o f epithelial cells by A. actinomycetemcomitans: adynamic, multistep process. Infect. Immun. 64(8): 2988-2997, 1996. Meyer D H , Sreenivasan P K and Fives-Taylor P M . Evidence for Invasion of a human oral cell line by A. actinomycetemcomitans. Infect. Immun. 59(8): 2719-2726, 1991. Meyle J. Leukocyte adhesion deficiency and prepubertal periodontitis. Periodont. 2000 6: 2636, 1994. Mintz K P and Fives-Taylor P M . Adhesion of A. actinomycetemcomitans line. Infect. Immun. 62(9): 3672-3678, 1994.  to a human oral cell  Moore L V H , Moore W E C , Caton E P , et al. Bacteriology of gingivitis. J. Dent. Res. 66: 989995, 1987. 119  Moore W E C and Moore L V H . Bacteria of periodontal disease. Periodont. 2000. 3: 66-77, 1994. Mosmann T R , Cherwinski H , Bond M W , Giedlin M A , Coffman R L . Two types of murine helper T cell clone. 1. Definition according to profiles of lymphokine activities and secreted proteins. / Immunol. 136: 2348-2357, 1986. Murphy G , Cawston T E , Galloway W A et al. Metalloproteinases from rabbit bone culture medium degrades Type I V and V collagens, laminin and fibronectin. Biochem. J. 199(3): 807811, 1981. Murray, P. Periodontal disease in patients infected by human immunodeficiency virus. Periodont. 2000 6: 50-67, 1994. Neiders M E , Chen P B , Reynolds H , Zambon JJ and Genco R J . Heterogeneity of virulence among strains of Bacteroides gingivalis. J. Periodont. 24: 192-198, 1989. Newman M G and Nisengard R. Oral Microbiology and Immunology. First edition. Philadelphia. W . B . Saunders Company, 1988. Offenbacher S. Periodontal diseases: pathogenesis. Ann. Periodontol.  1:821-878,1996.  Offenbacher S, Heasman P A , Collins J G . Modulation o f host PGE2 secretions as a detemiinant of periodontal disease expression. J. Periodont. 64: 432-444,1993. Ohta H , Miyagi A , Kato K and Fukui K . The relationship between leukotoxin production, growth rate and the bicarbonate concentration in a toxin-production-variable strain of A. actinomycetemcomitans. Microbiology 142: 963-970, 1996. Page R. The role o f inflammatory mediators in the pathogenesis o f periodontal disease. J. Periodont. Res. 26: 230-242, 1991. Page R C , Altman L C , Ebersole J L , et al. Rapidly progressive periodontitis: A distinct clinical condition. J. Periodont. 54: 197-209, 1983. Page R C , Beatty P, and Waldrop T C . Molecular Basis for the functional abnormality in neutrophils from the patients with generalized prepubertal periodontitis. J. Periodont. Res. 22: 182-183, 1987. Page R C , Bowen T, Altman L , Vandesteen E , Ochs H , Mackenzie P, Osterberg S, Engel D and Williams L . Prepubertal Periodontitis. 1. Definition of a clinical disease entity. J. Periodont. 54(5): 257-271, 1983. Page R C , Schroeder H E . Current status of the host response in chronic marginal periodontitis. J. Periodont. 52(9): 477-491, 1981. Page R C , Schroeder H E . Pathogenesis of inflammatory periodontal disease: A summary o f current work. Lab Invest. 34: 235- 249, 1976. 120  Pearlman B A . A n oral contraceptive drug and gingival enlargement: The relationship between local and systemic factors. / . Clin. Periodontol. 1: 47-51, 1974. Pontalone R and Page R C . Enzyme production and secretion by lymphokine-activated macrophages. J. Reticuloendothel. Soc. 21: 343-357, 1977. Poulsen K , Theilade E , Lally E T , Demuth D R , K i l i a n M . Population structure of A. actinomycetemcomitans: a framework for studies o f disease-associated properties. Microbiology 140: 2049-2060,1994. Pulverer G and K o H L . A. actinomycetemcomitans: Appl. Microbiol. 20: 693-695, 1970.  fermentable capabilities of 140 strains.  Pulverer G and K o H L . Serological studies on A. actinomycetemcomitans. 207-210, 1972. Ranney R R . Classification of periodontal diseases. Periodontology R a n n y R R . Diagnosis o f Periodontal diseases. Adv. Dent. Res.  Appl. Microbiol.  23:  2000 2:13-25, 1993.  5:21-36,1991.  Ranny R R . Immunological mechanisms of pathogenesis in periodontal diseases: A n assessment. J. Periodont. Res. 26: 243- 254, 1991. Reddi K , Wilson M , Poole S, Meghji S and Henderson B . Relative cytokine-stimulating activities o f surface components of the oral periodontopathogenic bacterium A. actinomycetemcomitans. Cytokine. 7(6): 534-541, 1995. Regezi J A and Sciubba J. Oral Pathology. Clinical-Pathological Correlations. Second edition. Philadelphia. W . B . Saunders Company, 1993. Reichart, P A et al. Aids and the oral cavity. The HIV-infection: virology, etiology, origin, immunology, precautions and clinical observations in 110 patients. Int. J. Oral Maxillofacial Surg. 16: 129-1533, 1987. Reife R A , Shapiro R A , Bamber B A et al. Porphyromonas gingivalis Lipopolysaccharide is poorly recognized by molecular components of innate host defense in a mouse model o f early inflammation. Infect. Immun. 63(12): 4686-4694, 1995. Richards D and Rutherford R B . The effects of interleukin-1 on collagenolytic activity and prostaglandin-E secretion by human periodontal-ligament and gingival fibroblasts. Arch. Oral Biol. 33: 237-243, 1988. Robertson P B , Lantz M , Marucha P T , Kornman K S , Trurnmel C L and Holt S C . Collagenolytic activity associated with Bacteroides species and A. actinomycetemcomitans. J. Periodontol. Res. 17: 275-283, 1982. Roe D E , Braham P H , Weinberg A , Roberts M C . Characterization of tetracycline resistance in A. actinomycetemcomitans. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 10:227-232, 1995. 121  Rogers R S , Sheridian P J and Jordan R E . Desquamative gingivitis: Clinical, histologic and immunopathologic investigations. Oral Surg. Oral Med. and Oral Pathol. 42(3): 316-327, 1976. Rosan B , Slots J , Lamont R J , Listgarten M A , Nelson G M . A. actinomycetemcomitans Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 3(2) 58-63, 1988.  fimbriae.  Rosenberg H , Rehfeld JF and Emmering T E . A method for epidemiologic assessment o f periodontal health - disease state in a beagle dog colony. J. Periodont. 37(3): 208-213, 1966. Rowland R W , Friedman R B , Escobar M R . Relationship between H I V infection, lymphocyte function and necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis. J. Dent. Res. 7 0 : 437 abstr. 1368, 1991. Rylander H , Ramberg P, Blohme G , Lindhe J. Prevalence of periodontal disease in young diabetics. J. Clin. Periodontol. 14: 38-43, 1987. Saarela M , Asikainen S, Alaluusua S, Pyhala L , et al. Frequency and stability of mono- or polyinfection by A. actinomycetemcomitans serotypes a, b, c, d or e. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 7: 277-279, 1992. Saglie F R , Simon K , Merrill J, Koeffler H P . Lipopolysaccharide from A. actinomycetemcomitans stimulates the macrophages to produce interleukin-1 and tumor necrosis factor m R N A and protein. Oral Microbiol. Immun. 5: 256-262,1009. Salvi G E , Herenia P L , Offenbacher S, Beck J D . Influence of risk factors on the pathogenesis o f periodontitis. Periodont. 200014: 173-201, 1997. Saxe SR, Greene J C , Bohannan H M . and Vermillion JR. Oral debris, calculus, and periodontal disease in the beagle dog. Periodontics 5: 217-225, 1967. Schei O, Waerhaug J, Lovdal A and Arno A . Alveolar bone loss as related to oral hygiene and age. J. Periodont. January: 7-17, 1959. Schifferle R E , Chen P B , Davern L B et al. Modification of experimental Porphyromonas gingivalis murine infection by immunization with a polysaccharide-protein conjugate. Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 8:266-271, 1993. Schou S, Holmstrup P, and Kornman K S . Non-human primates used in studies of periodontal disease pathogenesis: A review of the literature. J. Periodont. 64(4): 497-508, 1993. Schwartz Z , Goultschin J, Dean D D and Boyan B D . Mechanisms o f alveolar bone destruction in periodontitis. Periodont. 2000. 14: 158-172, 1997. Scopp IW. Desquamative Gingivitis. J. Periodont.  35: 149-154,1964.  Seymour G J . Importance of the host response in the periodontium. J. Clin. Periodontol. 421-426, 1991.  122  18:  Seymour G J , Gemmell E , Reinhardt R A , Eastcott J and Taubman M A . Immunopathogenesis o f chronic inflammatory periodontal disease: cellular molecular mechanisms. J. Peridont. Res. 28: 478-486, 1993. Seymour G J , Powell R N , Davies W I R . Conversion o f a stable T-cell lesion to a progressive B cell lesion in the pathogenesis o f chronic inflammatory periodontal disease: an hypothesis. J. Clin. Periodontol. 6: 267-277, 1979. Shenker B J , Kushner M E , Tsai C C . Inhibition of fibroblast proliferation by A. actinomycetemcomitans. Infect. Immun. 38: 986-992, 1982. Slots J. Importance o f black-pigmented Bacteroides in human periodontal disease. In Periodontal diseases o f children and adolescents: Position paper. J. Periodont. 67:57-62, 1996. Slots J. The predominant cultivable organisms in juvenile periodontitis. J. Dent. Res. 84: 1-10, 1976. Slots J. Subgingival microflora and periodontal disease. J. Clin. Periodontol.  6:351-382,1979.  Slots J. and Dahlen G . Subgingival microorganisms and bacterial virulence factors in periodontitis. Scan. J. Dent. Res. 93:119-127. Slots J, Reynolds H S , Genco R J . A. actinomycetemcomitans in human periodontal disease: a cross-sectional microbiological investigation. Infect. Immun. 29: 1013-1020, 1980. Smith K A , Holt S C and Ebersole J L . Fimbriae o f Porphyromonas/Prevotella/Bacteroides species from human and nonhuman primates. J. Dent. Res. 1\:(AADR Abstracts #932), 1992. Soames J V , Entwisle D N , Davies R M . The Progression of gingivitis to periodontitis in the beagle dog: a histological and morphometric investigation. J. Periodont. 47(8): 435-439, 1976. Socransky SS, Haffajee A D , Dzink J L . Relationship o f subgingival microbial complexes to clinical features at the sampled sites. J. Clin. Periodontol. 15: 440-444, 1988. Sorensen W P , Loe H and Ramfjord. 15(4): 380-389,1980.  Periodontal disease in the beagle dog. J. Periodont. Res.  Spitsnagel J, Kraig E , Kolodrubetz D . The regulation of leukotoxin production in A. actinomycetemcomitans strain JP2. Adv. Dent. Res. 9(1): 48-54, 1995. Sreenivasan P K , Meyer D H and Fives-Taylor P M . Requirement for invasion of epithelial cells by A. actinomycetemcomitans. Infect. Immun. 61(4): 1239-1245. Steidley K E , Thompson S H , McQuade M J , et al. A comparison of T4:T8 lymphocyte ratio in the periodontal lesion of healthy and HIV-positive patients. J. Periodont. 63: 753-756,1992. Stevens A W Jr, Cogen R B , Cohen-Cole S, Freeman A . Demographic and clinical data associated with acute necrotizing ulcerative gingivitis in a dental school population. / . Clin. Periodontol. 11: 487-493, 1984. 123  Suzuki Jon B . Diagnosis and Classification of the Periodontal Diseases. Dent. Clin. N. Am. 32(2): 195-216, 1988. Sveen K , Skaug N . Comparative mitogenicity and polyclonal B-cell activation capacity o f eight oral or nonoral bacterial lipopolysaccharides in cultures of spleen cells from athymic (nu/nuBALB/c) and thymic ( B A L B / c ) . Oral Microbiol Immunol. 7:71-77, 1992. Syed S A , Loesche W J . Bacteriology o f human experimental gingivitis: effect of plaque age. Infect. Immun. 21: 821-829, 1978. Taubman M A , Yoshie H , Ebersole J L , Smith D J and Olson C L . Host response in experimental periodontal disease. J.Dent. Res. 63(3): 455-460, 1984. Tew J G , Zhang J, Quinn S, Tangada S et al. Antibody of the IgG2 subclass, A. actinomycetemcomitans, and early-onset periodontitis. J. Periodont. 67: 317-322, 1996. Theilade E , Wright W H , Jensen S B and L o e H . Experimental gingivitis in man. 11. A longitudinal clinical and bacteriological investigation. / Periodont. Res. 1: 1-13, 1966. Tolo K and Helgeland K . Fc-binding components: a virulence factor in A. actinomycetemcomitans? Oral Microbiol. Immunol. 6:373-377, 1991. Tonetti M S . Etiology and pathogenesis. In Lang N P , Karring T (ed.). Proceedings o f the 1st European Workshop on Periodontology. Berlin: Quintessence Verlag, 4-89, 1993. Tsai C C , McArthur W P , Baehni P C , Evian C , Genco R J , Taichman N S . Serum neutralizing activity against A. actinomycetemcomitans leukotoxin in juvenile periodontitis. J. Clin Periodontol. 8: 338-348. Tsai C C and Taichman N S . Dynamics of infection by leukotoxic strains of A. actinomycetemcomitans in juvenile periodontitis. J. Clin. Periodont. 13: 330-351, 1986. Tumang JR, Posnett D N , Cole B C , C r o w M K , Friedman S M . Helper T-cell dependent human B-cell differentiation mediated by a mycoplasmal superantigen bridge. J. Exp. Med. 171: 21532158,1990 V a n Dyke T E , Bartholomew E , Genco R J , Slots J, Lavine M J . Inhibition of neutrophil chemotaxis by soluble bacterial products. J Periodont. 53: 502-508, 1982. V a n Dyke T E , Hoop G A . Neutrophil function and oral disease. Crit. Rev. Oral Biol. Med. 1(2): 117-133, 1990. V a n Dyke T E , Horoszewicz H V , Cianciola L J , Genco R J . Neutrophil chemotaxis dysfunction in human periodontitis. Infect. Immun. 27:124-132, 1980. V a n Dyke T E , Offenbacher S, Pihlstrom B , Putt M , and Trummel C . What is gingivitis? Current understanding o f prevention, treatment, measurement, pathogenesis and relation to periodontitis. Int. J. Academy Periodont. 1(1): 3-15, 1999. 124  V a n D y k e T E and Schenkein H A . Research objectives for the study of early-onset periodontitis. A summary o f the working groups for the Early-Onset Periodontitis Workshop. / Periodont. 67(3): 279-281, 1996. V a n Steenbergen T J M , Kastelein P, Touw JJA, and de Graaff J. Virulence o f black-pigmented Bacteroides strains from periodontal pockets and other sites in experimentally induced skin lesions in mice. J. Periodont. Res. 17: 41-49, 1982. V a n Steenbergen T J M , Delemarre F G A , Namavar F , DeGraaff J. Differences in virulence within the species Bacteroides gingivalis. Antonie Van Leewenhoek 53: 233-244, 1987. Waerhaug J. Plaque control in the treatment of juvenile periodontitis. J. Clin. Periodontol. 4: 29-40, 1977. Waldrop T C , Anderson D C , Hallmon W W , et al. Periodontal manifestations o f the heritable Mac-1, Lfa-1 deficiency syndrome. Clinical, histopathologic and molecular characteristics. J. Periodont. 58: 400-416, 1987. Watanabe K . Prepubertal periodontits: a review of diagnostic criteria, pathogenesis, and differential diagnosis. / . Periodont Res. 25: 31-48, 1990. Weinmann Joseph P. Progression of gingival inflammation into the supporting structures of the teeth. / Periodont. J u l y : 71-82, 1941. Wheeler T T , McArthur W P , Magnusson I et al. Modeling the relationship between clinical, microbial, and immunologic parameters and alveolar bone levels in an elderly population. / Periodont. 65: 68-78, 1994. Whittaker C J , Klier C M , Kolenbrander P E . Mechanisms of adhesion by oral bacteria. Rev. Microbiol. 50: 513-552, 1996.  Anna.  Wilkins T D , Walker C B , Nitzan D and Salyers A A . Experimental infections with anaerobic bacteria in mice. J. Infect. Dis. 135(suppl): S13-S17, 1977. Wilson M , Kamin S, Harvey W . Bone resorbing activity of purified capsular material from A. actinomycetemcomitans. J. Periodont. Res. 20: 484-491, 1985. Wilson M E , Zambon JJ, Suzuki J B , Genco R J . Generalized juvenile periodontitis, defective neutrophil chemotaxis and Bacteroides gingivalis in a 13-year-old female. / Periodont. 56: 457-463, 1985. Winkler, JR, Grassi M , Murray P. Clinical description and etiology of HIV-associated periodontal disease. In: Robertson, P B and Greenspan JS, eds. Perspectives on oral manifestations of A I D S . Littleton M A : P S G Publishing C o . , 49-70, 1988. Winkler JR and Robertson P B . Periodontal disease associated with HIV-infection. Oral Surg., Oral Med., Oral Path. 73: 145-150, 1992.  125  Yamamoto M , Fujihashi K , Hiroi T, et al. Molecular and cellular mechanisms for periodontal diseases: role of T h l and Th2 type cytokines in induction o f mucosal inflammation. J. Periodont. Res. 32: 115-119, 1997. Yamashita K , Eastcott J W , Taubman M A , Smith D J and C o x D S . Effect of adoptive transfer o f cloned A. actinomycetemcomitans-specific T helper cells on periodontal disease. Infect Immun. 59(4): 1529-1534, 1991. Zadeh H H , Nichols F C & Miyasaki K T . The roll o f the cell-mediated immune response to A. actinomycetemcomitans and Porphyromonas gingivalis in periodontitis. Periodont. 2000. 20: 239-288, 1999. Zambon JJ. A. actinomycetemcomitans 1-20, 1985.  in human periodontal disease. J. Clin. Periodontol.  Zambon JJ. Periodontal Diseases: Microbial Factors. Annuls of Periodontology. Workshop in Periodontics. 1(1): 879-925, 1996.  12:  The World  Zambon JJ. Christersson L A and Slots J. A. actinomycetemcomitans in human periodontal disease. Prevalence in patient groups and distribution of biotypes and serotypes within families. J. Periodont. 54(12): 707-711, 1983. Zambon JJ, Haaraszthy V I , Hariharan G , Lally E and Demuth D . The microbiology of EarlyOnset Periodontitis: Association o f highly toxic A. actinomycetemcomitans strains with localized juvenile periodontitis. J. Periodont. 67(3): 282-290, 1996. Zambon JJ, Slots J, Genco R J . Serology of oral A. actinomycetemcomitans and serotype distribution in human periodontal disease. Infect. Immun. 41(1): 19-27, 1983. Zar J H . Biostatistical analysis. Second edition. Englewood Cliffs, N . J . Prentice-Hall, Inc, 1984. Zhang J H , Ferrante A , Arrigo A P and Dayer J M . Neutrophil stimulation and priming by direct contact with activated human T lymphocytes. / Immunol. 148(1): 177-181, 1992.  126  

Cite

Citation Scheme:

        

Citations by CSL (citeproc-js)

Usage Statistics

Share

Embed

Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML of your page to embed this item in your website.
                        
                            <div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
                            <script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
                            src="{[{embed.src}]}"
                            data-item="{[{embed.item}]}"
                            data-collection="{[{embed.collection}]}"
                            data-metadata="{[{embed.showMetadata}]}"
                            data-width="{[{embed.width}]}"
                            async >
                            </script>
                            </div>
                        
                    
IIIF logo Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard. To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:
http://iiif.library.ubc.ca/presentation/dsp.831.1-0089376/manifest

Comment

Related Items