Dynamic Average-Value Model of High Power AC-DC Converters and HVDC Systems by Hamid Atighechi B.Sc. the Isfahan University of Technology, 2006 M.Sc. the Iran University of Science and Technology, 2009 A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in The Faculty of Graduate Studies (Electrical and Computer Engineering) THE UNIVERSITY OF BRITISH COLUMBIA (Vancouver) June 2013 © Hamid Atighechi, 2013 Abstract High power switching converters such as line-commutated converters (LCC) and high voltage direct current (HVDC) systems are widely used in modern energy grids for interconnection of industrial loads, large motor drives, as well as electronically-interfaced renewable/alternative/distributed energy resources (DER) and storage systems. For design and analysis of systems with power-electronic-based DERs and loads, accurate and efficient computer models are essential. This thesis is focused on dynamic average-value models (AVM) that neglect switching of converter circuits and are established by averaging the variables (currents and voltages) over a prototypical switching interval. The AVMs are continuous (free of switching), allow using larger integration time steps, and typically run much faster than the conventional detailed switching models, which makes them particularly useful for the system-level studies. This thesis considers the parametric AVM framework, and extends this approach to the thyristor-controlled LCCs operating in inverter mode with current source or voltage source control. The proposed modeling methodology is demonstrated on various topologies including the HVDC CIGRE benchmark system. The research is further extended to incorporate the ac side harmonics into the AVM using the multiple reference frame theory. Traditionally, the AVMs are developed using state-variable-based approach. This thesis also presents a new parametric AVM for direct interfacing in nodal-analysis-based electromagnetic transient programs (EMTP), e.g., PSCAD/EMTDC, EMTP-RV, and MicroTran. It is expected that the proposed models and ii interfacing approaches will find their application in widely used transient simulation tools and will be appreciated by many researchers and practicing engineers worldwide. iii Preface Based on the research contributed in this thesis, several papers have been published, accepted for publication or ready for submission as journal articles and conference publications. My research work and all my publications have been done by me under the supervision of Dr. Juri Jatskevich. The co-authors of publications have provided me with their constructive feedback and comments, and helped with the subsequent iterations and revisions of manuscripts as was necessary in each case. On the basis of chapter 2: H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, K. Tabarraee, J. Jatskevich, “Dynamic Average-Value Model of Thyristor-Controlled-Rectifier Synchronous Machine Systems,” Submitted. H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, J. Jatskevich, “Approximate Dynamic Average-Value Model for Controlled Line-Commutated Converters,” in Proc. IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering (CCECE) , Niagara Falls, 2011, pp. 966–970. H. Atighechi, S. Amini Akbarabadi, F. Therrien, and J. Jatskevich, “Dynamic Average-Value Modeling of Synchronous Machine Line-Commutated Converter Using a Constant Parameter Voltage-Behind Reactance Interfacing Circuit,” iv accepted for presentation in International Conference on Power Systems Transients (IPST), Vancouver, 2013. On the basis of chapter 3: H. Atighechi, J. M. Cano, and J. Jatskevich, “Average-Value Modeling of Thyristor Controlled Line-Commutated Converter Using Voltage and Current Source Formulation,” accepted for Presentation in IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting (PES), Vancouver, 2013. H. Atighechi, F. Therrien, and J. Jatskevich, “Using Current Source Formulation for Dynamic Average-Value Modeling of Inverter Side HVDC System,” in Proc. IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering (CCECE), Regina, 2013. On the basis of chapter 4: H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, J. Jatskevich, A. Davoodi, J. A. Martinez, M. O. Faruque, V. Sood, M. Saeedifard, J. M. Cano, J. Mahseredjian, D. C. Aliprantis, and K. Strunz, “Dynamic Average-Value Modeling of CIGRE HVDC Benchmark System,” Accepted in IEEE Trans. Power Del. 2013. v H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, J. Jatskevich, “Large-Signal Average Modeling of HVDC System Transients using Parametric and Analytical Approaches,” submitted. On the basis of chapter 5: H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, and J. Jatskevich, “Using Multiple Reference Frame Theory for Considering Harmonics in Dynamic Average-Value Modeling of LineCommutated Converter,” to be submitted. On the basis of chapter 6: H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, J. Jatskevich, “Directly-Interfaced Parametric Average-Value Models for Line-commutated Rectifier Circuits in EMTP-Type Solution,” to be submitted. H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, J. Jatskevich, “Discretized Parametric AverageValue Model of Line-commutated Rectifier based on the trapezoidal integration with localized damping,” under the preparation. vi Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................................. ii Preface ................................................................................................................................................................. iv Table of Contents................................................................................................................................................. vii List of Tables ......................................................................................................................................................... xi List of Figures ....................................................................................................................................................... xii List of Abreviations ............................................................................................................................................ xvii Acknowledgments .............................................................................................................................................xviii Dedication ........................................................................................................................................................... xx Chapter 1: Introduction ......................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 Motivation ..........................................................................................................................................................1 1.2 Literature Review ................................................................................................................................................3 1.2.1 Line-Commutated Converter Models .........................................................................................................7 1.2.2 HVDC System Models ..................................................................................................................................8 1.2.3 Multiple Reference Frames Average-Value Models of Line-Commutated Converters ...............................9 1.2.4 Discretized Average-Value Model of Line-Commutated Converter in EMTP-Type Solution ....................11 1.3 Research Objectives and Anticipated Impact ....................................................................................................12 Chapter 2: Dynamic Average-Value Model of Thyristor Controlled Rectifier ........................................................ 16 vii 2.1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................................16 2.2 Detailed Model System .....................................................................................................................................18 2.3 Extended Parametric Approach ........................................................................................................................20 2.4 Implementation of Parametric Average-Value Model ......................................................................................26 2.5 Extended Analytical Average-Value Model .......................................................................................................28 2.6 Model Verification.............................................................................................................................................30 2.6.1 Time- Domain Studies ...............................................................................................................................31 2.6.2 Time-Domain Transient Study with a Controller.......................................................................................36 2.6.3 Frequency-Domain Studies .......................................................................................................................38 2.1 Summary of Contributions ................................................................................................................................41 Chapter 3: Modeling Bidirectional Line-Commutated Converter Systems ............................................................ 43 3.1 Average-Value Model Formulations .................................................................................................................43 3.2 Well-Posedness of Voltage Source AVM (VS-AVM) ...........................................................................................45 3.2.1 Current Source AVM (CS-AVM) .................................................................................................................55 3.2.2 Case Studies ..............................................................................................................................................57 3.3 Summary of Contributions ................................................................................................................................62 Chapter 4: Average Modelling of HVDC System Using Voltage and Current Source Formulations ........................ 63 4.1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................................63 4.2 HVDC System Detailed Model ...........................................................................................................................64 4.3 HVDC System Dynamic Average-Value Model ..................................................................................................68 viii 4.3.1 Rectifier Dynamic Average-Value Model ..................................................................................................70 4.3.2 Inverter Dynamic Average-Value Model ...................................................................................................74 4.3.3 AC Subsystems ..........................................................................................................................................77 4.3.4 DC Subsystem ............................................................................................................................................80 4.3.5 Control Subsystem ....................................................................................................................................80 4.4 Computer Studies ..............................................................................................................................................81 4.4.1 Change in DC Reference Current...............................................................................................................81 4.4.2 Short Circuit in DC Side .............................................................................................................................82 4.5 Summary of Contributions ................................................................................................................................87 Chapter 5: Considering AC Side Harmonics in Dynamic Averaging of Line-Commutated Converters .................... 88 5.1 Multiple-Reference Parametric Average-Value Model .....................................................................................90 5.2 MRF-PAVM Implementation .............................................................................................................................97 5.3 Computer Studies ..............................................................................................................................................98 5.3.1 Model Verification in Steady-State Study Over Wide Range ....................................................................99 5.3.2 Transient Study .......................................................................................................................................109 5.4 Summary of Contributions ..............................................................................................................................112 Chapter 6: Direct Interfacing of Parametric Average-Value Models in EMTP Type Solution ............................... 113 6.1 Discretized Parametric Average-Value Model ................................................................................................114 6.2 Directly-Interfaced PAVM with Collapsed DC Side ..........................................................................................116 6.3 Directly-Interfaced PAVM with Snubber in DC Side ........................................................................................122 6.4 Computer Studies ............................................................................................................................................125 ix 6.5 Damping Technique for Directly-Interfaced Parametric Average-Value Models ............................................133 6.5.1 Trapezoidal Integration with Damping ...................................................................................................134 6.5.2 Localized Damping for Interfacing DI-PAVM ...........................................................................................136 6.5.3 Case Study ...............................................................................................................................................138 6.6 Summary of Contributions ..............................................................................................................................141 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Future Work ........................................................................................................... 143 1.7 Conclusions and Contributions .......................................................................................................................143 7.2 Future Work ....................................................................................................................................................146 References ......................................................................................................................................................... 148 Appendices ........................................................................................................................................................ 162 Appendix A: Synchronous Machine/Rectifier System ............................................................................................162 Appendix B: Well-Posedness Study .......................................................................................................................164 Appendix C: CS-Formulation Verification ..............................................................................................................165 Appendix D: CIGRE HVDC System ..........................................................................................................................166 Appendix E: Harmonic Analysis .............................................................................................................................167 Appendix F: Discretized PAVM ..............................................................................................................................168 x List of Tables Table 3-1: Simulation speed for AVM and detailed simulation to t 2.25s ........................................................ 62 Table 4-1: Comparison of simulation speed for different models for time interval from t 0.9 s to t 2 s ....... 85 Table 5-1: Comparison of simulation speed for different models for time interval from t 0 to t 2 s .......... 112 xi List of Figures Figure 1-1: Example three-phase ac-dc converter system: (a) line-commutated converter (LCC); and (b) pulsewidth-modulated (PWM). ............................................................................................................................. 4 Figure 1-2: Example HVDC system depicting three-phase line-commutated inverter and rectifier. ........................ 5 Figure 1-3: Various average-value modeling methodologies of high-power converters. ...................................... 15 Figure 2-1: Synchronous machine/thyristor-controlled-rectifier system. ............................................................ 17 Figure 2-2: Typical phase terminal voltage and current of controlled-rectifier with firing angle of 30 electrical degrees. ...................................................................................................................................................... 19 Figure 2-3: Generator and converter ac side voltages and currents expressed in rotor and converter reference frames. ....................................................................................................................................................... 21 Figure 2-4: Numerically calculated parametric functions wv z, , wi z , , z, , z, and z, . ................................................................................................................................................................... 25 Figure 2-5: Implementation of parametric average-value models: (a) using rotor position as a reference for generating firing pulses; and (b) using converter terminal voltages for generating firing pulses. ................ 27 Figure 2-6: Analytical average-value model for machine/thyristor rectifier system: (a) equivalent circuit diagram of interfacing voltage-behind-reactance machine model and thyristor rectifier system; and (b) block diagram depicting implementation with algebraic loop. The equation numbering in part (b) refers to the original sources [72] and [15]. .................................................................................................................... 29 Figure 2-7: Steady state output dc voltage: (a) using converter terminal voltages for generating firing pulses; and (b) using rotor position as a reference for generating firing pulses. ............................................................ 32 Figure 2-8: System response to a change in load in mode 1 as predicted by the detailed model, analytical and parametric AVMs. ....................................................................................................................................... 34 xii Figure 2-9: System response to a change in firing angle in mode 2 as predicted by the detailed model, analytical and parametric AVMs. ................................................................................................................................ 35 Figure 2-10: Controller used to control load voltage. ........................................................................................... 37 Figure 2-11: Closed-loop system response to a step change in load; detailed and parametric AVM models. ....... 37 Figure 2-12: Output impedance as predicted by various models. ......................................................................... 39 Figure 2-13: Transfer function for the input firing angle to the output dc voltage as predicted by various models. ................................................................................................................................................................... 39 Figure 2-14: Output impedance for controlled system as predicted by various models. ...................................... 41 Figure 3-1: Block diagram depicting AVM implementation of the thyristor-controlled inverter: (a) voltage-source formulation; and (b) current-source formulation. ....................................................................................... 44 Figure 3-2: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled rectifier using method: (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. ..................................................................................................................... 50 Figure 3-3: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled inverter using method: (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. ..................................................................................................................... 52 Figure 3-4: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled inverter using method LC 0.1 mH : (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. ................................................................................ 53 Figure 3-5: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled inverter using method, LC 0.3 mH : (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. ................................................................................ 54 Figure 3-6: Stability region of CS-AVM for inverter. ............................................................................................. 57 Figure 3-7: Inverter side of the HVDC system with current control on rectifier side. ............................................ 58 Figure3-8: System response to a fast change in input current. ............................................................................. 60 Figure 3-9: System response to a step change in firing angle. .............................................................................. 61 xiii Figure 4-1: CIGRE HVDC benchmark system circuit diagram. ............................................................................... 65 Figure 4-2: CIGRE HVDC benchmark control subsystem: (a) rectifier control; and (b) inverter control. ............... 66 Figure 4-3: Typical voltages and currents of a 12-pulse rectifier transformer primary winding. .......................... 69 Figure 4-4: Block diagram depicting implementation of the AVM rectifier side: (a) original AVM with two rectifiers separately; and (b) collapsed AVM. ............................................................................................. 74 Figure 4-5: Block diagram depicting implementation of the AVM inverter side. ................................................. 76 Figure 4-6: Block diagram depicting implementation and interfacing of the inverter side ac subsystem: (a) using abc original circuit; (b) using transformed qd0 -circuit. ........................................................................... 78 Figure 4-7: Inverter side ac subsystem implementation using transformed qd0 -circuits. .................................. 79 Figure 4-8: Currents and voltages resulting from a change in dc reference current as predicted by various models. ....................................................................................................................................................... 84 Figure 4-9: Currents and voltages during a short circuit in dc side as predicted by various models. .................... 86 Figure 5-1. Typical phase terminal voltage and current of diode rectifier system and their harmonic content. .. 90 Figure 5-2: Rectifier ac side voltages and currents expressed in synchronous, converter [15], and nth harmonic reference frames. ....................................................................................................................................... 92 Figure 5-3: Block diagram depicting implementation of the MRF-PAVM for the diode rectifier system. ............. 98 Figure 5-4: Steady state regulation characteristic of the considered line-commutated converter as predicted by various models. ........................................................................................................................................ 100 Figure 5-5: System variables as predicted by various models in DCM; detailed, conventional PAVM, and MRFPAVM models, respectively. ..................................................................................................................... 102 Figure 5-6: Harmonic content of the phase current and voltage as predicted by various models in DCM. ........ 103 Figure 5-7: System variables as predicted by various models for operation in CCM-1. ...................................... 104 xiv Figure 5-8: Harmonic content of the phase current and voltage as predicted by various models for the rectifier operation CCM-1. ..................................................................................................................................... 105 Figure 5-9: System variables as predicted by various models in CCM-2; detailed, conventional PAVM, and proposed MRF-PAVM models, respectively. ............................................................................................. 106 Figure 5-10: Harmonic content of the phase current and voltage in rectifier in CCM-2 as predicted by the detailed model and the proposed MRF-PAVM. ......................................................................................... 107 Figure 5-11: Total harmonic distortion of the rectifier phase current and voltage as predicted by the detailed model and the proposed MRF-PAVMs over a wide range of operating conditions. .................................. 109 Figure 5-12: System response to a step change in load as predicted by various models; detailed, conventional PAVM and proposed MRF-PAVM. ............................................................................................................. 111 Figure 6-1: Thevenin equivalent-circuit diagram of directly-interfaced PAVM in abc variables with collapsed dc side. .......................................................................................................................................................... 115 Figure 6-2: Block diagram of descretized averaged-circuit model with collapsed dc side. .................................. 118 Figure 6-3: Norton equivalent-circuit diagram of directly-interfaced PAVM in abc phase variables with collapsed dc side....................................................................................................................................... 121 Figure 6-4: Block diagram of the descretized averaged-circuit model interfaced with resistive snubber in dc side. ................................................................................................................................................................. 124 Figure 6-5: Transient response of the system in dc and ac variables as predicted by the various models using 50 μs time-step. ..................................................................................................................................... 129 Figure 6-6: Transient response of the system in dc and ac variables as predicted by various models using 500 μs time-step: (a) dc and ac waveforms of the overall transient; and (b) magnified view of the start-up waveforms................................................................................................................................................ 131 xv Figure 6-7: Transient response of the system in dc and ac variables as predicted by various models using 2 ms time-step: (a) dc and ac waveforms of the overall transient; and (b) magnified view of the start-up waveforms................................................................................................................................................ 132 Figure 6-8: Discretized equivalent circuit of inductance: (a) Thevenin equivalent; and (b) Norton equivalent. .. 134 Figure 6-9: Discretized equivalent circuit of lumped inductance with damping history term: (a) Thevenin equivalent; and (b) Northon equivalent.................................................................................................... 137 Figure 6-10: Thevenin equivalent-circuit diagram of the locally damped DI-PAVM in abc variables. ............... 138 Figure 6-11: Dc and ac waveforms predicted by the models, with and without localized damping; t 2 ms . ................................................................................................................................................................. 140 Figure 6-12: Transient response of DI-PAVM with collapsed dc side as predicted by various models using time step t 2 ms , and conventional and localized damping. .................................................................... 141 xvi List of Abreviations Abbreviation Meaning AC Alternating Current DC Direct Current LCC HVDC Line-Commutated Converter High Voltage Direct Current IPP Independent Power Producer DER Distributed Energy Resource EMTP AVM PAVM PWM Electro Magnetic Transient Program Average-Value Model Parametric Average-Value Model Pulse-Width-Modulation IHA Iterative Harmonic Analysis VSC Voltage-Source Converter VS-AVM Voltage-Source-Average-Value Model CS-AVM Current-Source-Average-Value Model MRF MRF-PAVM DI-PAVM Multiple Reference Frames Multiple Reference Frame Parametric Average-Value Model Directly Interfaced Parametric Average-Value Model xvii Acknowledgments First and foremost I would like to thank my research supervisor, Dr. Juri Jatskevich, for his inspiration, vision, help, patience and support which made it possible for me to accomplish this research and produce the original contributions that comprise this dissertation. The financial support for this research was made possible through the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) Discovery Grant entitled “Modelling and Analysis of Power Electronic and Energy Conversion Systems” and the Discovery Accelerator Supplement Grant entitled “Enabling Next Generation of Transient Simulation Programs” lead by Dr. Juri Jatskevich as a sole principal investigator. I also I would like to express my gratitude to my research supervisory committee, Dr. Hermann Dommel, Dr. William Dunford, Dr. Jose Marti, and Dr. KD Srivastava, for the help and advice that I received from them during all these years of my research program at UBC. I would like to thank my colleagues and fellow researchers in the Electric Power and Energy Systems research group at UBC. Particularly, I would like to thank Dr. Sina Chiniforoosh for the countless hours and discussions of many details in my research topic. My research has extended his Ph.D. work, and I felt very privileged to have Dr. Sina Chiniforoosh so readily available and willing to see the continuation of research ideas of our group. Also, I owe many thanks to Francis Therrien, Amir Rasuli, Mehrdad Chapariha, Kamran Tabarraee, and Mehmet Sucu for their time and help in my research and life as a xviii member of the UBC’s Electric Power and Energy Systems research group. I thank all my dear friends who made my student life at UBC colorful and meaningful. I also would like to thank all the staff in Electrical and Computer Engineering Department and the Faculty of Graduate Studies for their kind smiles and help with any administrative and/or procedural questions whenever I had them, and I had a lot. I would like to express my sincere gratitude toward my mother who has been giving me courage during all the years of studying at UBC, her endless love and believe in me and my future success. I also thank all my family members who were always in my heart and provided a strong support for me. I also thank my dearest Hong Zhu who was beside me during all the hard times of writing this dissertation. xix Dedication This thesis is dedicated to my mother, Rababeh Mofazzali, who showed me the true love and passion in life; and to the memory of my father, Morteza Atighechi, who always showed me the way when I was lost; and to my brother, Saeed Atighechi, and my sister, Farahnaz Atighechi, who never stopped supporting me during all these years despite the distance. xx Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1 Motivation Power electronic converters are commonly used in modern power systems and wide variety of applications such as high voltage dc (HVDC) transmission systems, high-power dc supplies, excitation systems of large electric generators, etc. Moreover, the use and application of power electronic converters in power systems has been increasing faster than before due to development of Smart Energy Grid and interconnection of numerous distributed energy recourses (DERs) and independent power producers (IPPs). Modeling and simulation of these power-electronic-based systems are essential for design and analysis of modern electrical energy systems with switching components. Design and analyzes of such complex systems normally require many computer studies in the time and frequency domains. Thousands of engineers and researchers around the world are involved in conducting various studies and computer simulations of systems containing power electronic converters. There are many time-domain simulation packages, nodal-analysis-based electromagnetic transient programs (EMTP-based) [1]-[5], and state-variable-based, [6]-[12], that are extensively used to model the power-electronic-based systems including line-commutated 1 converters considering all the switching details. Although the modern transient simulation tools are constantly improving, their simulation speed and applicability to larger systems with switching converters remain to be among the limiting factors wherein the detailed models of switching converters are often the bottle-neck. In particular, due to inherent switching, the detailed models developed using the time-domain simulation packages are discontinuous, and impossible to linearize for small-signal frequency-domain characterization, which is an important tool for assessing the system’s stability and designing of the required controllers. Moreover, the detailed switching models are computationally expensive for system-level transient studies with many components and subsystems, which often leads to significant increase of the required computing time and in turn limits the size of the system that can be practically studied [13], [14]. In order to overcome these difficulties, the average-value models (AVMs), wherein the effect of fast switching is averaged or neglected with respect to a prototypical switching interval, have been developed. The AVMs are computationally efficient and can execute orders of magnitude faster than the corresponding detailed switching models. Moreover, AVMs are continuous and can be linearized about any operating point for the small-signal frequency-domain characterization. Since the need for system-level modeling and analysis tools is rapidly increasing, the average-value modeling approach has been recognized by many researchers as a powerful tool to study and analyze complicated power-electronicbased systems when the dynamics of interest is slower than the switching frequency. A comprehensive review of different averaging approaches and their application to the 2 modeling and analysis of power systems transients can be found in reports by the IEEE Task Force on Dynamic Average Modeling [13], [14]. 1.2 Literature Review Depending on the type of semiconductor switches, the high-power converters as it is shown in Figure 1-1, may be generally classified into pulse-width-modulated (PWM) (ones that use power transistors) or the line-commutated (ones that use diodes or thyristors) converters. While the dynamic average modeling of PWM-based converters can be readily established due to continuous nature of the phase currents using the conventional reference frame theory [15], this is generally not the case for the line-commutated converters due to discontinuous phase currents and complicated waveforms of the voltages and currents. The line-commutated converters such as the one depicted in Figure 1-1(a), are particularly common in high-power applications due to low cost and high efficiency of thyristor-based semiconductor switching devices. Figure 1-1 shows a generic three-phase topology which results in six pulses per electrical cycle. The line-commutated converter shown in Figure 1-1, based on the application, may be supplied by a distribution feeder and transformer or a rotating machine such as synchronous generator. 3 Figure 1-1: Example three-phase ac-dc converter system: (a) line-commutated converter (LCC); and (b) pulse-width-modulated (PWM). Dynamic average-value models for line-commutated converters can be classified in to two main categories: analytical [15]-[23] and parametric [24]-[34]. In the first approach, the average-value model is derived analytically, wherein the variables (currents and voltages) are analytically averaged over a prototypical switching interval [15]. One of the main applications of line-commutated converters is the HVDC systems. HVDC Classics systems are frequently employed for long distance transmission applications due to their low electrical losses. For shorter distances, the higher costs of the power electronic equipments may still be justified due to other benefits achieved by HVDC such as improved system stability and inter-connection between unsynchronized ac systems. A typical HVDC system is composed of two back-to-back thyristor-controlled line-commutated converters as shown in Figure 1-2. Presently, the HVDC Classics technology represents a major source 4 of projects and contracts for the leading manufactures such as ABB, Siemens, and Alstom Grid. Figure 1-2: Example HVDC system depicting three-phase line-commutated inverter and rectifier. In order to model HVDC systems, it is necessary to develop the desirable model for both the inverter and rectifier sides. The developed HVDC models so far can be classified into three main categories. First, the steady state models [35]-[41] which are very simple to implement but inadequate for predicting the system’s large-signal transients. Second, the dynamic models [42], [43] which can be used to predict the system dynamics with a limited accuracy. Finally, the small-signal models in the frequency-domain [44]-[47] which can be used to predict the system's stability. Such linear or linearized models are advantageous for design of controllers, analysis of converter-machine system interaction, studies involving the sub-synchronous torsional interaction phenomenon, etc. However, the small-signal models are valid only within a small range about an operating point for which they were 5 established (and need to be re-derived when a different operating point is considered) and are not valid for large-signal time-domain studies. Power-electronic devices such as line-commutated converters are sources of different harmonics injected to the energy grid. The injected harmonics (current and voltage) have a undesirable effect on the system generators, transformers, variable speed drives, etc [48]. The conventional AVMs preserve only the fundamental (60 or 50 Hz) component on the ac side, whereas including at least several of significant (5th, 7th, 11th, etc.) harmonics would be very much desirable for the systems studies involving ac filters and evaluation of losses. Therefore, it has always been desirable to extend the AVMs to the power quality analysis and harmonic power flow calculations. An analytical AVM of the line-commutated converter has been introduced in [19] and [49], where in the ac side waveforms are reconstructed. Another challenge comes from the fact that most of previously-proposed average-value models have been formulated in conventional state-variable form. Therefore, these models can be readily implemented in the state-variable-based transient simulators only (e.g. Matlab/Simulink, ACSL, Easy5 and Eurostag), whereas for modeling of large-scale electric power systems the nodal-analysis-based simulation packages (e.g. EMTP-RV, PSCAD, etc.) in which the discretization is performed at the branch/component level are often preferred due to their numerical efficiency. Reformulation of the established average-value models for the nodal-analysis-based solution is a significant area of research that requires further 6 consideration. Reformulated analytical and parametric AVMs of the line-commutated rectifier systems, on the basis of their interfacing method with the nodal-based simulators (PSCAD and EMTP-RV) may be classified as indirectly or directly interfaced approaches [50]. In the following Subsections, a brief literature review of the different approaches of the average-value modeling for the line-commutated converters and their application is provided. 1.2.1 Line-Commutated Converter Models The initial attempts to develop analytical AVM for a synchronous machine/converter system, such as the one shown in Figure 1-1, date back to 1960s [17]. For the purpose of steady state analysis, reduced order models [18] and [22] may be used. However, these reduced order models are inaccurate for small-signal analysis in high frequencies. An analytical AVM which is accurate in both the time- and frequency-domains has been studied in [19], and later extended in [20] for an inductorless machine/converter system. In general, the analytical derivation of AVM for a switching system is challenging because the analytical expressions should be extracted for each mode of operation separately. A dynamic analytical AVM has been developed in [23] quite recently in which the equations are derived for two modes of operation. The challenges in analytical derivations led to the development of parametric average-value models for machine/diode rectifiers in [24], [25], wherein the rectifier AVM parameters are obtained using a detailed simulation. However, 7 the AVM parameters of the proposed model [24] and [25] are independent of the loading condition which causes error in both the steady state and the dynamic responses of the model. Recently, the parametric approach with constant parameters [24] is extended to model thyristor-controlled rectifier system in [26]. A parametric AVM of a synchronous machine/diode rectifier system in which the AVM parameters are variable based on the loading condition has been introduced in [27]. This model is very accurate in both the time and frequency domains but valid only for diode rectifier. The approach proposed in [27] requires running a detailed simulation to extract the AVM parameters and save them as look-up tables. On the basis of [27], a fast and efficient procedure for extracting the AVM parameters has been introduced in [28]. The parametric approach introduced in [27], has been evolved and used by many researchers [29]-[34] due to its accuracy and being easy to implement. 1.2.2 HVDC System Models Developing steady-state and dynamic equivalent models for HVDC transmission systems has been of great interest in the power system research community. Steady-state models for HVDC systems were first proposed in [35], and further improved in [36] and [37]. The effects of harmonics and inter-harmonics in steady-state HVDC models have been discussed in the literature [38]. Impedance mapping and equivalent circuit of HVDC system have been considered in [39]. More recent improvements have been made in [40] by 8 considering the commutation subinterval. The conventional steady-state models discussed in [35]-[40], are straightforward to implement. A simplified model [41] considers the dc and ac side dynamics with some approximations. A dynamic model for the rectifier side of hybrid HVDC system can be found in [42], where the inverter side is modeled as a voltage or current source. In order to predict the HVDC system's stability, the small-signal model has been developed in [43]-[47], which are advantageous for controller design, analysis of interaction among the subsystems, sub-synchronous torsional interaction phenomenon, etc [46]. 1.2.3 Multiple Reference Frames Average-Value Models of LineCommutated Converters If the harmonics can be incorporated into the AVMs, then such models could also be used for faster and more efficient harmonic analysis instead of the traditional detailed models. For the purpose of modeling, instead of a detailed/switching model, it has been proposed to employ the equivalent harmonics current sources of the most significant harmonics [51]. In this approach, the magnitudes and phases of the current sources in the model are predicted based on the harmonic spectrum of the original switching components. These models are much simpler to implement but they may not provide the desired accuracy. For better accuracy in predicting the injected harmonics, voltage-dependent current-source models have been developed in [52]-[56]. Such models are solved iteratively, and the 9 method is hence known as the Iterative Harmonic Analysis (IHA). The complexity of the IHA method has led to the development of some analytically-derived models, wherein the relationship between the harmonic voltages and currents are established through a transformation matrix [57] or an admittance matrix [58], [59]. All the above-mentioned models can only be used for steady-state system-level studies. For the purpose of power system stability analysis, small-signal models have been developed in [60]-[62], wherein the small-signal input impedance of the LCC is analytically derived. However, the common drawback of these models is that they are valid only in a small range (e.g. 5%) about the considered operating point. In order to overcome the challenges imposed by the switching in power-electronic-based systems, the AVM have been developed in [15]-[32] that are capable of maintaining the system dynamics. The conventional AVMs for LCC preserve only the fundamental (50/60 Hz) component of the ac currents and voltages. Such simplification occurs directly as a result of averaging. In order to employ the AVMs in power quality analysis and harmonic power flow calculations, it is desirable to include at least several significant harmonics (5th, 7th, 11th, etc.). The analytical AVM of the machine/rectifier system introduced in [18] has been extended in [19] to reconstruct the original switching waveforms from the averagevalue model. More recently, based on the analytical approach introduced in [15], an AVM is formulated in [47] considering ac system harmonics and reconstructing the system variable waveforms. However, extracting the analytical expressions for such complex 10 switching system is challenging in general, and the equations should be derived for each LCC mode of operation [27], which makes this approach less practical. 1.2.4 Discretized Average-Value Model of Line-Commutated Converter in EMTP-Type Solution The first step to implement the AVMs in EMTP-type programs has been taken in [14] by using indirect interfacing approach [63]-[65], [13]. However, the indirect interfacing technique introduces one step delay in the simulation which causes loss of accuracy and numerical stability for large time-steps. Therefore, in [48], a direct interfacing methodology [65] has been implemented for interfacing of the analytical AVM introduced in [15] with the external EMTP networks. Direct interfacing technique removes the one-time-step delay and significantly improves the simulation accuracy at large time-steps in comparison to the indirect approach. Among the modeling approaches, the parametric average-value modeling methodology that was set forth by the UBC researchers appears very promising and extendable to more complex converter systems and topologies. However, at the present time, this approach has only been developed for machine/diode rectifier systems [27], [28]. Therefore, the parametric average-value modeling has been chosen as the framework for the research carried out in this thesis. 11 1.3 Research Objectives and Anticipated Impact For the purpose of this research, the methodologies for average-value modeling of high power ac-dc converters can be broadly depicted in a block diagram shown in Figure 1-3. The PWM converters use high-frequency switching and generally operate in continuous current mode, which significantly simplifies their average-value modeling [13], [15]. The research is therefore focused on the line-commutated thyristor-controlled converters (see green path in Figure 1-3). In particular, since most of the previous work has been done for the uncontrolled (diode) rectifiers, herein, this approach is extended to the thyristorcontrolled rectifiers as well as inverters. This extension allows combining the parametric AVMs of the controllable rectifier and inverter subsystems into an HVDC system. Another direction of research is the inclusion of major harmonics (e.g. 5th, 7th, and 11th) into the average-value modeling methodology. Such harmonics can be significant in systems with LCCs. The AVMs with such capabilities would then be very useful for studies involving harmonic filters, harmonic power flow, evaluation of losses and efficiency, etc., while the underlying models will be continuous (without switching) and linearizable. This feature is also useful for modeling the flexible ac transmission devices (FACTS) and other power-electronic-based devices in power systems. Moreover, the system analyst would be able to select the desired harmonic(s) that may be needed depending on the study objectives and the desired accuracy without having to default to the conventional switching (discontinuous) models. 12 Finally, it is also observed that average-value modeling of both the PWM and linecommutated converters can be formulated in a very similar and general (parametric) form that may be used to unify the interfacing of various AVMs with the external power network. However, since most transient simulation packages are based on the nodal (EMTP-type) solution, it is necessary to formulate the appropriate discretized models and their interface for the EMTP-type programs such as PSCAD/EMTDC, EMTP-RV, MicroTran, and etc. This research extends the previous work of the UBC’s power group on interfacing the AVMs with EMTP-based packages. To summarize, the research objectives of this thesis include the following major steps and directions: Objective #1: Extend the parametric average-value modeling to thyristor-controlled rectifier systems. Objective #2: Investigate the challenges in formulating the AVMs for the thyristorcontrolled inverters. Propose appropriate models for representing the voltage source and current source controlled inverter systems. Objective #3: Combine the results from the previous two objectives to enable the averagevalue modeling of the HVDC systems based on the parametric approach. Objective #4: Incorporate the ac side harmonics into the parametric average-value modeling approach. 13 Objective #5: Developing the discretized formulation of the parametric AVM for direct interfacing with the network solution in EMTP-type transient simulation programs. 14 Figure 1-3: Various average-value modeling methodologies of high-power converters. 15 Chapter 2: Dynamic Average-Value Model of Thyristor Controlled Rectifier 2.1 Introduction The parametric average-value models available in the literature have all been developed for machine/diode rectifier systems. In a wide range of applications, however, controlled line-commutated converters are utilized, which employ controllable switches, such as thyristors. It is therefore advantageous to extend the parametric average-value modeling methodology to thyristor-controlled line-commutated converter systems. In this chapter, the machine/thyristor controlled LCC shown in Figure 2-1 is considered. Such systems are also common in various industrial applications including synchronous machine exciters [65]-[69]. The shown in Figure 2-1 is modeled based on the parametric approach wherein the dc and ac side variables are related with some nonlinear algebraic functions dependent on the applied firing angle and loading condition. On the basis of [28], the AVM parameters are extracted using a fast and efficient procedure wherein the numerical functions are established by applying a slow transient in the load for different firing angles. 16 The advantages of the proposed parametric AVM over the analytically derived AVMs [17][21] of the machine/thyristor controlled LCC system can be summarized as follows: Relative ease of implementation. Validity and accuracy for all modes of operation. Ease of extension to more complex systems, e.g., HVDC Explicit formulation of the developed AVM, i.e., absence of algebraic loops in the model. As a result of this formulation, the solution of the model at each time step is obtained faster than the analytical AVMs [17]-[21] which require iterative solution at each time-step, due to the algebraic loops. Figure 2-1: Synchronous machine/thyristor-controlled-rectifier system. 17 2.2 Detailed Model System Without loss of generality, a synchronous machine/line-commutated converter benchmark system [69] is considered here with some modifications as depicted in Figure 2-1. A conventional three phase, six-pulse, thyristor-rectifier is used to supply the dc load and regulate the output voltage and current by changing the thyristor firing angle delay. The system includes a synchronous machine, a thyristor-rectifier, a firing pulse generator, a dc filter, and the ac system. The thyristor firing pulse generator provides the firing pulses based on the commanded firing angle. The methods to produce the firing pulses may be based on the filtered terminal voltages [70] or the sensed rotor position [18], [20]. In the first method, the thyristor firing pulses are generated based on the first harmonic (fundamental) of the line-to-line converter terminal voltages, wherein some filtering is typically required. The typical waveforms of the line and phase voltages and current are depicted in Figure 2-2. Here, it is assumed that switch S 2 (see Figure 2-1) is fired at point A. As can be seen (see Figure 2-2, bottom subplot), the actual phase voltage and phase current may be significantly distorted due to switching. The filtered line-to-line open circuit voltage (which is also the back EMF ebas ), and the terminal voltage (fundamental), vbas , are superimposed in Figure 2-2 (top plot). Using the first firing control method, the thyristor firing instant is delayed by angle from the reference instance defined by the zero-crossing of vbas (point B in Figure 2-2). 18 In the second method, the zero-crossing of the line-to-line open circuit back EMF voltage ebas is determined based on rotor position r . The back EMF ebas leads the terminal voltage vbas by the rotor angle . The reference for the firing angle is then point C, which is shifted by angle as shown in Figure 2-2. Therefore, for this method, the converter firing angle, , is defined as . (2-1) Figure 2-2: Typical phase terminal voltage and current of controlled-rectifier with firing angle of 30 electrical degrees. 19 For values of smaller than a certain value, the thyristor-rectifier is not controllable by thyristor firing angle delay. This firing angle is referred to as min , which denotes the minimum value of , for which the rectifier output voltage is still controllable. Provided that the applied is smaller than min , the anode to cathode voltages are negative when the thyristors are fired, and consequently the LCC works as a diode rectifier. The dc filter, composed of an inductor and a capacitor as shown in Figure 2-1, is used to reduce the magnitude of ripple in the rectifier output voltage and current. For the purpose of the studies in the following sections, the dc system (load) is represented by an equivalent resistive load that consumes the needed amount of real power (although it is understood that the dc subsystem may have a very complicated configuration in general). 2.3 Extended Parametric Approach The parametric average-value model presented in this chapter is an extension to the methodology set forth in [27]. Dynamic average-value modelling assumes that all ac and dc variables can be replaced by their fast averages over a prototypical switching interval, Tsw . This fast average value is defined as f 1 Tsw t f t dt , (2-2) t Tsw 20 where f (t ) may represent voltage or current. This definition directly applies to the dc side variables. However, in order to apply (2-2) to the ac variables, they must be first expressed in a qd synchronously rotating reference frame. Figure 2-3 depicts the ac side voltages and currents expressed in the rotor and converter reference frames, respectively. Herein, the angular position of the converter reference frame q -axis is chosen to be aligned with the phase a voltage [15]. Figure 2-3: Generator and converter ac side voltages and currents expressed in rotor and converter reference frames. 21 Assuming there is no energy storing element in the converter, for any operating point, the average of dc and ac side variables can be related with algebraic functions as conv v qds wv v dc , and conv idc wi i qds . (2-3) (2-4) Conditions (2-3) and (2-4) hold for any operating point, because there always exist some weighting coefficients wv and wi that will make those equalities true. The power factor conv angle between vectors v conv qds and i qds is defined in Figure 2-3, ir r r ds tan 1 ids tan 1 vds . ir ir vr qs qs qs tan 1 (2-5) The generator voltages in rotor reference frame can be calculated based on Figure 2-3 as v r cos qs wv v dc . v rds sin (2-6) It is important to note that the existence of wv and wi for any operating point further translates into existence of wv and wi as functions that cover entire range of operating conditions of the considered converter circuit. However, obtaining closed-form analytical expressions of these functions may not be possible (for the machine-converter systems [18]-[21]) or practical (for all operating modes). Therefore, the considered approach relies 22 on calculating the functions wv , wi and numerically using the detailed simulation [27]. Moreover, since the angles and are also related, one may calculate either or , which will be sufficient to completely define the ac-dc relationships (2-3)–(2-6). These formulations are referred to as and methods, respectively. The rectifier operating condition may be specified in terms of terminal currents and voltages. For compactness, the terminal voltages and currents are combined into a dynamic impedance z vdc rec i qds . (2-7) In addition, the thyristor firing angle should be specified, which may be either the angle or the delay angle (see Figure 2-2), depending on the thyristor firing control method. Thereafter, it is possible to express the parametric functions as either wv z , , wi z, and z, , or alternatively as wv z , , wi z , and z, . For implementing the proposed average-value model, wv , wi and or need to be extracted by running the detailed simulation for a range of operating points, changing the firing angle and the loading condition. The corresponding model parameters for some operating points are calculated using (2-3)-(2-6) and stored in look-up tables. The number of operating points for which the look-up tables are extracted is determined based on the 23 desired accuracy (e.g. 15 to 30 points may be sufficient for most studies). This method may become computationally intense, due to multiple runs of the detailed simulation. However, regarding this fact that the converter circuit is modeled as an algebraic block, the model parameters can be extracted using a single transient study, instead of multiple runs [28]. Herein, the look-up tables wv , wi and or are extracted by sweeping the load resistance from short circuit to open circuit corresponding to the firing angles of interest. By sweeping the loading condition from short circuit to open circuit, all the rectifier modes of operation are covered. Besides, the rectifier firing angle delay is changed from minimum to maximum value to cover the whole range of interest. For the considered benchmark system of Figure 2-1, these functions have been numerically calculated, and are shown in Figure 2-4. As seen in Figure 2-4, these functions are nonlinear and curve significantly in the regions of heavier loading conditions, and large values of the firing angle delay . To specify a diode-rectifier mode, when the switches start conducting as soon as the voltage becomes positive, the firing delay angle is set to 0 , which is shown in Figure 2-4 subplots with a highlighted (red) line. These parametric functions may also be equivalently established in terms of the control angle . Without loss of generality, the numericallycalculated function z, is also depicted in Figure 2-4 (e), which may be used to calculate the wv z , , wi z , and z, , instead of wv z , , wi z, and z, , respectively. 24 Figure 2-4: Numerically calculated parametric functions wv z, , wi z , , z, , z, and z, . 25 2.4 Implementation of Parametric Average-Value Model Assuming that required parametric functions have been calculated and available as look-up tables, the AVM can be implemented according to Figure 2-5(a) and (b), wherein the rectifier is represented as an algebraic block with respective inputs and outputs. This formulation assumes a voltage-source ac side and a current-source dc side, respectively. The implementation depicted in Figure 2-5(a) assumes that the firing pulses are generated based on the rotor position r , and therefore, the input firing angle is . Alternatively, when the firing pulses are generated based on the filtered ac voltages, one may consider the implementation depicted in Figure 2-5(b) which uses the firing delay angle . When this control method is used, the dynamic effect of filtering the rectifier terminal voltages has to be included. For example, during a voltage transient, the filter will have a delay effect in producing the zero-crossing reference signal for establishing the correct firing angle . In the AVM implementation of Figure 2-5(b), the effect of voltage filter is applied to the transformed voltages v rqds in order to reproduce the equivalent effect on the firing angle during transients. Therefore, based on the transformed voltages, is calculated as r 1 vds tan vr qs . (2-8) To add the effect of a filter, the applied firing angle to the converter is modified as follows: 26 ' f , (2-9) where f is extracted by passing through the same filter used to extract the fundamental component of the converter terminal voltages. In steady state conditions, ' becomes equal to . Figure 2-5: Implementation of parametric average-value models: (a) using rotor position as a reference for generating firing pulses; and (b) using converter terminal voltages for generating firing pulses. 27 2.5 Extended Analytical Average-Value Model The analytical approach assumes a certain operating mode, i.e., switching pattern of the phase currents. Subsequently, the average-value relationship between the dc link variables and the ac side variables transferred to qd reference frame are established analytically [15]. The analytical AVM introduced in [15] is developed using voltage sources and constant inductances in the ac side. In order to make it compatible to the machine/rectifier system studied in this chapter, a voltage-behind-reactance (VBR) machine model presented in [71], [72] with constant inductances and variable voltage sources based on the rotor dynamics is used in the analytical model. The analytical expressions for VBR model are achieved by mathematically manipulating the voltage equation of the classical qd 0 model, and making the interfacing branches constant. The circuit diagram of the VBR model connected to the rectifier system is shown in Figure 2-6(a). The implemented AVM block diagram of the same circuit is illustrated in Figure 2-6(b). Connection of the machine VBR model to the rectifier AVM, and also considering the steady-state voltage drops of the ac circuit in the model, introduces algebraic loops and makes overall formulation implicit. The algebraic loops shown in Figure 2-6(b) with dashed lines are produced due to two reasons. First, the machine VBR model variables are represented in rotor reference frame, as opposed to the rectifier AVM variables, which are in the converter reference frame. Therefore, as depicted in Figure 2-6(b), all the input variables to the rectifier model are transferred to the converter reference frame and all the 28 Figure 2-6: Analytical average-value model for machine/thyristor rectifier system: (a) equivalent circuit diagram of interfacing voltage-behind-reactance machine model and thyristor rectifier system; and (b) block diagram depicting implementation with algebraic loop. The equation numbering in part (b) refers to the original sources [72] and [15]. 29 outputs are transferred to the rotor reference frame on the basis of the rectifier power factor angle . The rectifier power factor angle , as shown in Figure 2-6(b), is algebraically calculated based on the input voltages. This relates the inputs and outputs of the rectifier AVM algebraically. The second reason for the existence of algebraic loop is that the commutation angle has to be calculated algebraically based on the input rectifier voltages, and it is used algebraically to calculate the rectifier output currents. As a result, such implicit model will require iteration at each time-step, and will be less efficient numerically. 2.6 Model Verification The detailed model of the system depicted in Figure 2-1 has been implemented in Matlab/Simulink as described in [27]. The proposed parametric AVM has been implemented in Simulink according to Figure 2-5 using method. The system parameters summarized in the Appendix A are chosen from the test configuration documented in [20]. In order to verify the accuracy of the model, the detailed model, the analytical AVM [15], and the parametric AVM are compared in time- and frequency-domains. The accuracy of the parametric AVM for a machine/diode rectifier has been shown in [27] for modes 1 and 2 operation. Also in [73], it has been shown that the proposed parametric AVM for a machine/diode rectifier is independent of the input frequency. Therefore, in the study presented here, r is considered constant and equal to 120 rad/s. Also, for all studies in 30 this chapter, the system mode 1 operation is assumed, wherein the commutation angle is less than 60 degrees. 2.6.1 Time- Domain Studies The new average-value model is first validated in steady state and then during transient, with and without controller on the applied thyristor firing angle delay. The accuracy of the proposed average-value model in steady-state is investigated by comparing the performance of the detailed simulation, analytical AVM, and the proposed parametric AVM of the machine/rectifier system presented in Figure 2-1 for different firing angles. In this study, the excitation voltage is equal to 19.5 V and the dc current is also kept constant at 2.46 A by using a PI controller. As it is described in the previous sections, the firing pulses could be generated either based on the rotor position , or the machine terminal voltages . The steady-state output voltage of the detailed model and the AVMs versus the firing angles, and , are plotted in Figure 2-7(a) and Figure 2-7(b) respectively. Both the parametric and analytical AVMs show an excellent agreement with the detailed simulation. Here, the AVM results are within less than 2% error with respect to the reference detailed simulation, which is considered sufficiently accurate for all practical purposes of such models. As it can be seen in Figure 2-7(a), the dc terminal voltage is decreasing monotonically by increasing for the entire range of operation. However, the output voltage is not controllable by for the values less than min , which is close to 30 31 degrees here. It should be noted that the input firing angle to the analytical AVM and accordingly, , is calculated using (2-1). Therefore, as it can be seen from Figure 2-7(b), the waveform related to the analytical AVM is plotted for the firing angles between min and max . Figure 2-7: Steady state output dc voltage: (a) using converter terminal voltages for generating firing pulses; and (b) using rotor position as a reference for generating firing pulses. 32 In the following time-domain transient study, the system initially operates in steady state with a constant excitation voltage equal to 19.5V and a resistive load of 21 . Since is dependent on the loading condition (see (2-1)), herein, is used as the thyristor firing delay angel to study the system response to a step change in the load and firing angle. The initial value for the firing angle is set as 30 . At t 0.02 s , the load resistance is changed to 3.64 by adding a 4.4 resistor in parallel to the load. The corresponding transient responses in the load voltage vc , dc current idc , and the generator field current i fd , are shown in Figure 2-8 for the parametric and analytical AVMs, respectively. As it can be seen in Figure 2-8, the new AVM with functions wv z , , wi z, and z, , and the analytical AVM predict the entire transient very close to the reference detailed model. Next, at t 2.5 s , the firing angle is changed to 10 degrees. The simulation results for this study are shown in Figure 2-9, wherein the AVMs follow the transient response of the detailed model very accurately. However, by reducing the applied firing angle to 10 degrees, the rectifier operating point is getting close to the mode 2 operation. Therefore, the analytical AVM fails to follow the transient response of the detailed simulation with acceptable accuracy since it is a reduced order model and valid only for the mode 1 operation. 33 Figure 2-8: System response to a change in load in mode 1 as predicted by the detailed model, analytical and parametric AVMs. 34 Figure 2-9: System response to a change in firing angle in mode 2 as predicted by the detailed model, analytical and parametric AVMs. 35 2.6.2 Time-Domain Transient Study with a Controller Controlled rectifier may be used as a voltage or current source depending on the control objectives. Based on the type of load connected to the dc side, the output voltage or current may need to be controlled by changing the applied firing delay angle to the rectifier switches. Regardless of the load type (with nonlinearity or dynamics) or controller added to the system, the developed average-value model should be accurate in predicting the transient response of the original switching system. Here, the machine/rectifier system depicted in Figure 2-1 is implemented using the PI controller shown in Figure 2-10. This controller simply regulates the load voltage using the firing angle. The controller parameters are summarized in Appendix A. Herein, the thyristor firing pulses are generated based on the rotor position, in order to demonstrate the accuracy of this approach as well. The system is assumed to operate initially in steady state defined by 21 resistive load and firing angle 64 . The capacitor voltage is assumed to be kept constant and equal to 40 V. At t 3 s , the resistive load is changed from 21 to 12 . Since the command voltage is set to 40 V, the firing angle changes in order to keep the capacitor voltage constant. The fast transient response for vc , idc , and i fd are plotted in Figure 2-11, wherein the AVM predicts the behavior of the detailed simulation with great accuracy. 36 Figure 2-10: Controller used to control load voltage. Figure 2-11: Closed-loop system response to a step change in load; detailed and parametric AVM models. 37 2.6.3 Frequency-Domain Studies Here, for consistency with the reference studies performed in [27], the system load is assumed resistive and equal to 10.74 . The firing angle is also considered as 30 degrees. The AVM has been implemented for both cases of with and without the effect of the filter used to extract the fundamental components of the converter terminal voltages for generating the thyristor firing pulses. The magnitude and phase of the rectifier output impedance as predicted by various models are shown in Figure 2-12 for the frequency range of 1 to 200 Hz. For the frequencies closer to the switching frequency, 360Hz, the results become distorted due to the interaction between the injected small-signal currents and the rectifier switching, and it is outside the validity range of the AVMs. Figure 2-12 shows that the output impedance changes very noticeably by changing the thyristor delay firing angle (here, from 0 to 30 ). This figure also reflects the importance of considering the filter used to extract the fundamental components of the converter voltages in the AVM. As seen in this figure, neglecting the filter introduces a noticeable error in the predicted magnitude and phase of the output impedance, especially in the lowfrequency range, 7 to 30 Hz. 38 Figure 2-12: Output impedance as predicted by various models. Figure 2-13: Transfer function for the input firing angle to the output dc voltage as predicted by various models. 39 Next, a transfer function from the input firing angle to the averaged output dc voltage may be particularly useful. Figure 2-13 depicts this transfer function, extracted at the same operating point considered in the previous study. As seen in Figure 2-13, the AVM captures the frequency-domain characteristics of the original switching system with superior accuracy. The magnitudes and phases of the rectifier output impedance of the closed loop system studied in section 2.6.2 are plotted in Figure 2-14, for both detailed and average models. The detailed and AVM results match almost perfectly as observed in Figure 2-14. Comparison between the output impedances of the open loop study, plotted in Figure 2-12, and closed loop study shows the superior performance of the PI controller for low frequencies. As it can be seen in Figure 2-14, the magnitude of the output impedance has reduced, which shows that low frequency components of the rectifier output voltage have been regulated. However, the PI controller does not have any effect in the high frequency range close to the switching frequency. This is due to the low-pass filter in the controller loop. In order to reduce the effect of this filter, a more advanced controller should be applied which is fast enough for high frequencies and stable for low load conditions. However, designing such a controller is outside of the scope of this work. 40 Figure 2-14: Output impedance for controlled system as predicted by various models. 2.1 Summary of Contributions In this chapter, the parametric AVM approach has been extended to model thyristor controlled LCC in the rectifier mode of operation. This has been achieved by constructing parametric functions that in addition to the converter switching cell dynamic impedance also include the thyristor firing angle. For implementation of the proposed extended parametric AVM, the required parametric functions are readily calculated using the detailed switching model and stored as 3-dimensional look-up tables. The number of points for which the parametric functions are extracted is determined based on the desired 41 accuracy, wherein even 15 to 30 points may be sufficient for most studies. The performance of the new AVM has been verified against the detailed simulation and the classical analytical AVM of a synchronous machine/thyristor-controlled-rectifier system. It has been shown that the new AVM is very accurate in predicting the transient responses in a wide range of operating conditions and thyristor firing angle [from very light load (close to open-circuit) to very heavy load (close to short-circuit)], which has not been achieved by the previously established models. 42 Chapter 3: Modeling Bidirectional LineCommutated Converter Systems In Chapter 2, the new parametric AVM of thyristor controlled LCC working in the rectifier mode was developed. In many industrial applications such as HVDC system, the line commutated converter is operating in inverter mode. Therefore, in the next step, it is necessary to develop the AVM that is capable to operate as an inverter. In this Chapter, the parametric AVM of the LCC working as an inverter is developed based on two formulations: (i) voltage source, and (ii) current source. Here, the application of these formulations is further classified on the basis of their well-posedness in different modes of operation. 3.1 Average-Value Model Formulations The converter of Figure 1-1(a) can also operate as an inverter when the firing angle 90 . The corresponding AVM may be formulated based on (2-3)–(2-7) using either voltage-source or current-source approach as depicted in Figure 3-1. Moreover, the functions wv z , , wi z , , z, and/or z, have to be re-calculated for inverter operation. In Figure 3-1 (a), the algebraic block representing converter AVM outputs the ac voltages and is therefore referred to as voltage-source AVM formulation (VS-AVM). In 43 Figure 3-1 (b), the algebraic block representing converter AVM outputs the ac currents and is therefore referred to as current-source AVM formulation (CS-AVM). Figure 3-1: Block diagram depicting AVM implementation of the thyristor-controlled inverter: (a) voltage-source formulation; and (b) current-source formulation. Depending on the control mode, one of these AVM formulations may be chosen. Using the voltage source formulation in one of the state-variable-based simulation programs (such as Matlab/Simulink), the ac system can be formulated as a proper state space model. 44 However, since the rectifier subsystem outputs the dc current, in order to add the dynamic effect of the dc inductance L f to the model, the numerical differentiation is required. At the same time, using the current source formulation, the dc-link filter is modeled using a proper state model without any difficulty, unless L f is equal to zero. However, numerical differentiation is still inevitable in the ac subsystem model since the converter cell outputs the converter currents. 3.2 Well-Posedness of Voltage Source AVM (VS-AVM) The parametric AVM of the LCC (rectifier and inverter) system shown in Figure 3-1 (a) is extracted based on (2-3)–(2-7), which should result in a proper state model that is built by the simulation program and can be symbolically expressed as a system of nonlinear differential equations dx f x, u , dt (3-1) where x is the vector of state variables, and u is the vector of inputs. The relationships (23)–(2-7) that are defined by parametric functions may be directly integrated into (3-1), or equivalently, expressed as companion algebraic equations. The Jacobian of (3-1) is A f x, u x (3-2) 45 In order for the AVM to be well-posed, the following conditions must be satisfied for any steady state operating point defined by x ss , u ss and achievable by the respective original switching model: dx f x ss , u ss 0 , and dt (3-3) Rei 0 , for all i eig A x ss (3-4) Conditions (3-3) and (3-4) ensure that the parametric AVM will achieve the same steady state as the original switching model. Moreover, the AVM should also track the transient response in order to properly capture the system’s dynamics close to the converter switching frequency. However, as it will be shown, despite (2-3)–(2-7) being always satisfied by the numerically-constructed parametric functions, this only ensures condition (3-3), but (3-4) may not always hold. To demonstrate the conditions (3-3) and (3-4), we first consider the converter circuit of Figure 1-1, where the dc system is replaced with a voltage source E dc . The state equations describing the ac side in the synchronous reference frame aligned with the phase a source voltage (hence “rotor” superscript is used herein) can be expresses in the following form r diqs dt rC r 1 r 1 r r iqs ids e eqs vqs , LC LC LC (3-5) 46 r dids r r 1 r 1 r r C ids iqs e eds vds dt LC LC LC (3-6) r r where e is the speed of synchronous reference frame, and eqs and eds are the equivalent r ac sources also expressed in the same reference frame. Note that eds 0 . Using (2-7) we have r diqs dt rC r 1 r 1 r iqs ids e eqs wv cos vdc LC LC LC r dids r r 1 r 1 r C ids iqs e eds wv sin vdc . dt LC LC LC (3-7) (3-8) where rotor angle can be calculated based on Figure 2-3 as ir ds . ir qs tan 1 (3-9) The converter dc voltage and currents can be written as vdc Edc R f idc 2 idsr 2 . r idc wi iqs (3-10) (3-11) Substituting (3-9) - (3-11) into (3-7) and (3-8), we obtain a system that uses angle , 47 ir rC r E 1 r r iqs ids e eqs dc wv z , cos tan 1 ds z , Edc ir LC LC LC qs , ir r 2 r 2 wv z , wi z , cos tan 1 ds z , iqs ids ir qs (3-12) r ir dids r r E 1 r r C ids iqs e eds dc wv z , sin tan 1 ds z , Edc ir dt LC LC LC qs . ir Rf 2 2 r r wv z , wi z , sin tan 1 ds z , iqs ids r LC iqs (3-13) r diqs dt Rf LC An equivalent system of equations can also be obtained if one uses as a lookup table instead of . Assuming that z, is available, we get r diqs dt Rf LC rC r E 1 r r iqs ids e eqs dc wv z, cos z, Edc LC LC LC wv z, wi z, cos z, r dids r r E 1 r r C ids iqs e eds dc wv z , sin z , Edc dt LC LC LC Rf LC wv z , wi z , sin z , (3-14) r 2 r 2 iqs ids . (3-15) r 2 r 2 iqs ids 48 The AVMs defined by (3-12)–(3-13) ( method), or (3-14)–(3-15) ( method), have the r general form of (3-1) where the state and input vectors are x iqs r u eqs r eqs Edc r ids T and . T To investigate the conditions (3-3)–(3-4), we first assume a thyristor-controlled rectifier that operates with firing angle 30 and dc voltage, Edc 2.46 kV. The system parameters are summarized in Appendix B. The VS-AVM is implemented using (3-12)–(313), method. The Jacobian matrix and its eigenvalues have been numerically calculated for a wide range of operating conditions of this rectifier circuit, and the results are shown in Figure 3-2. In particular, Figure 3-2(a) shows the state-space region in which all eigenvalues have negative real part – stable region (depicted in white inside the investigated region). The steady state operating point x ss is also shown as the stable equilibrium point. Moreover, the corresponding phase portrait depicted in Figure 3-2(b) also shows that for the given inputs, all state-space trajectories converge to this steady state equilibrium point x ss , which demonstrates that the considered VS-AVM of rectifier circuit is well-posed. 49 Figure 3-2: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled rectifier using method: (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. 50 The same investigation is performed for the thyristor-controlled converter operating as an inverter. The VS-AVM is implemented according to (3-12)–(3-13) using method. The new operating point is defined by the firing angle 140 and E dc 825 V. The Jacobian matrix and its eigenvalues have been numerically calculated for a wide range of operating conditions, and the results are shown in Figure 3-3. As it can be seen in Figure 3-3(a), the considered range of operating conditions is not entirely stable, and the assumed steady state equilibrium point x ss is now outside of the stable region. The phase portrait depicted in Figure 3-3(b) further reviles that the state trajectories around this point would move the state away. Next, the thyristor-controlled inverter system is implemented according to (314)–(3-15) using method. Figure 3-4 shows the corresponding region of stability and the phase portrait. As it can be seen in Figure 3-4(a) the considered steady state operating point is now inside stable region, and the region itself has different shape. Moreover, the phase portrait also shows that this is a stable equilibrium, and the entire state trajectory with different initial conditions will easily converge. 51 Figure 3-3: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled inverter using method: (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. 52 Figure 3-4: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled inverter using method LC 0.1mH : (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. 53 Figure 3-5: Stability of the VS-AVM for thyristor-controlled inverter using method, LC 0.3 mH : (a) stability region in state space; and (b) phase portrait. 54 As it can be seen by looking at Figure 3-3 and Figure 3-4, using method, the stable region is larger than the stable region resulted from method. Further investigation has shown that the region of stability is dependent on the systems parameters. For example, as it can be seen by looking at Figure 3-5, by increasing LC in the ac side and using method the equilibrium point is not stable anymore and the state trajectories do not converge to that. Based on these studies for the inverter, it can be concluded that the parametric VS-AVM formulation is not well-posed for some operating conditions and system parameters that are otherwise well predicted by the original switching model. The numerically-constructed parametric functions always satisfy (2-3)–(2-7) and condition (3-3), but (3-4) may not always hold. 3.2.1 Current Source AVM (CS-AVM) To extend the parametric AVMs, the current-source of Figure 3-1 (b) is considered here. In this formulation, instead of (2-7), the converter switching cell operating condition is determined in terms of equivalent dynamic admittance y i 1 dc , z v qds (3-16) 55 Moreover, according to Figure 3-1 (b), the ac side can now be interfaced with the currentsource inverter AVM block based on indirect approach, using snubber circuits (typically large resistors or small capacitors). Using the snubber approach, the state equations (3-5)–(3-6) for the ac side may be kept, wherein the input voltages will be calculated as the voltages across the snubbers. An equivalent interfacing may also be achieved if the ac side inductor branches are represented using transfer function with added very fast pole. As the dc inductance cannot be neglected in this case, the CS-AVM of the switching system shown in Figure 1-1(a) with the dc filter inductance L f 0.5968H is considered, and the CS-AVM will have three state variables. The final state model will have the same general form (3-1), but with the input r vector u eqs r eds idc _ sys T . The system parameters are summarized in Appendix B, and the firing angle 140 is assumed. In order to investigate the validity of (3-3) and (3-4), the same system as before is considered with the dc filter inductor ( L f 0.5968 H) added to the dc side, and the firing angle 140 is assumed. For the considered model, the stability region has been first investigated for the considered operating point, as well as for a large range of state space similar to the studies of Figure 3-5, all predicting stable operation. Next, the stability region is investigated with respect to the system parameters, specifically the ac line inductance LC , and the operating condition defined by dynamic admittance y . Figure 3-6 shows the 56 region reachable by the corresponding detailed model, which is also entirely stable for the proposed CS-AVM. Based on these investigations, the CS-AVM formulation for the inverter model is compliant with condition (3-4), and therefore should result in convergent parametric AVM. Figure 3-6: Stability region of CS-AVM for inverter. 3.2.2 Case Studies To validate the proposed CS-AVM formulation, the inverter subsystem of the HVDC system shown in Figure 3-7 is considered. The system parameters are summarized in Appendix C. 57 Since in HVDC systems it is assumed that the dc current is controlled by the rectifier side, the dc subsystem herein is represented by a dc current source, I dc _ rec . The detailed simulation is executed using the Automated State Model Generator (ASMG) toolbox [12], and the parametric AVM is simulated in Matlab/Simulink using standard library components. The accuracy of the developed AVM is verified by comparing it with the detailed model in time- and frequency- domain studies. Figure 3-7: Inverter side of the HVDC system with current control on rectifier side. Here, the system is assumed to initially operate in steady state. The peak value of the ac source voltage is 175.6 kV, the dc current I dc _ rec is equal to 3 kA, and the thyristor firing 58 angle is set to 135°. At t 1 s, the dc current is abruptly changed to 11 kA. The simulated responses of current idc and voltage vdc for this study are shown in Figure3-8. As it can be seen in Figure3-8, the AVM follows the transient response of the detailed simulation with an excellent accuracy. Next, at t 2 s, the firing angle is changed to 125 . The transient response predicted by the new AVM and detailed simulation are superimposed in Figure 3-9. As it can be seen in Figure 3-9, the results of the AVM are again in excellent agreement with the reference. A comparison of the CPU time and number of simulation steps for the AVM and detailed simulation is denoted in Table 1. By looking at Table 3-1, it can be concluded that the AVM is approximately 30 times faster than the detailed simulation. 59 Figure3-8: System response to a fast change in input current. 60 Figure 3-9: System response to a step change in firing angle. 61 Table 3-1: Simulation speed for AVM and detailed simulation to t 2.25s Model Detailed (Variable step solver) AVM (Variable step solver) Step size, t 2 ms (max) 2 ms (max) CPU time, s 5.061 Time steps 18935 0.154 1168 3.3 Summary of Contributions In this chapter, we have shown that although the parametric AVM methodology as it has been formulated prior to this thesis and applied to the rectifier circuits, the same formulation may not be result in a well-posed model when considering the inverter operation. This discovery has led to the new formulations proposed in this chapter for modeling the thyristor-controlled inverters using either voltage-source or current-source control modes. To demonstrate the new AVM formulations, the proposed methodology has been applied to the HVDC inverter side operating in current-source mode. For the considered example system, it has been shown that the proposed parametric AVM is very accurate in predicting the transient responses, and at the same time is computationally very efficient (32 times faster than the detailed simulation). These contributions set the stage for modeling the complete HVDC systems at the level of accuracy and computational efficiency that were not achieved by the previously established models. 62 Chapter 4: Average Modelling of HVDC System Using Voltage and Current Source Formulations 4.1 Introduction HVDC systems are frequently employed for long distance transmission due to their lower electrical losses. Since this research work is focused on the high power LCCs, in this thesis we consider only the HVDC Classic type thyristor-based converter technology. An HVDC system is composed of two back to back connected converters and a control system. Depending on the controlling mode, one of LCCs’ is operating as a rectifier and the other one as an inverter. The LCCs used in HVDC systems often utilize the 12-pulse converter topology (two 6-pulse LCCs connected in series). Therefore, for modeling the HVDC systems, the parametric approach should be extended to model the 12-pulse thyristor controlled LCCs. Herein, a benchmark system is considered to demonstrate the dynamic average modeling methodology developed in this thesis and its advantages over a conventional detailed switching model. The average-value models for the rectifier and inverter sides are set forth 63 and developed based on the parametric approach [27], [28] and the AVMs presented in Chapters 2 and 3. 4.2 HVDC System Detailed Model The CIGRE HVDC benchmark system, first proposed in [74], is a mono-polar 500 kV, 1000 MW dc link which employs 12-pulse converters on rectifier and inverter sides. The detailed modeling of this system in PSCAD/EMTDC and Matlab/Simulink has been presented in [75]. The circuit diagram of this system is illustrated in Figure 4-1, and the corresponding parameters are summarized in Appendix D. The system is composed of two ac sides, each represented by the equivalent supplying/receiving network. The rectifier and inverter ac networks are represented by R-L circuits to represent weak grids on each side. In order to absorb the harmonics generated by the converter as well as providing the converter with reactive power, multi-harmonic ac filters are placed on both ac sides. The dc subsystem is represented by the T-equivalent circuit of the transmission line combined with the smoothing reactors that are connected at both sides in order to reduce the ripple in dc current. The 12-pulse converters are constructed by a series connection of two 6-pulse converters. At each ac side, (rectifier and inverter), the 3-phase transformers with Y- and D-connected secondary windings are employed to produce the desired 30-degrees shifted voltages (equivalent to 6-phase) that feed the two 6-pulse converters, respectively, thus resulting in a 12-pulse operation. As depicted in Figure 4-1, each converter is controlled through the respective control module. 64 Figure 4-1: CIGRE HVDC benchmark system circuit diagram. 65 Figure 4-2: CIGRE HVDC benchmark control subsystem: (a) rectifier control; and (b) inverter control. 66 In the considered CIGRE HVDC benchmark system, the ac network is weak (short circuit ratio of 2.5 at rated frequency of 50 Hz) [75], which also presents some challenges for the controls. Here, in Figure 4-1 the power is assumed to flow from left to right, which determines the rectifier and inverter sides, respectively. But otherwise, the controllers can reverse the power flow by appropriately changing the firing angles on each side and changing the ac voltage magnitudes of the two sources. The details of the rectifier and inverter controllers are depicted in Figure 4-2, and the corresponding parameters are summarized in Appendix D. For the rectifier side, a proportional-plus-integral (PI) current control (PI-1) is realized with the reference denoted by idc _ ref _ lim . This reference current is provided by the inverter controller. At the inverter side, the controller is composed of a voltage dependent current controller (PI-2) and the extinction angle -control, respectively. The reference value for the rectifier controller, idc _ ref _ lim , is determined by the inverter controller in order to ensure limited current during under-voltage conditions. Under normal operation, the externally provided reference value idc _ ref is sent to the output. This value determines the power flow through the HVDC system. Under fault conditions, the reference value idc _ ref _ lim is limited based on the dc link voltage vdci and current idci at the inverter side, as shown in Figure 4-2. During normal operation, the inverter is controlled using the extinction angle which determines the difference between the turning off angle of the valves and the angle of 180 degrees. The lower limit for this angle is determined based on the protection constraints to 67 allow enough time for the valves to turn off before the end of a half-cycle. The -control (PI-3) adjusts the value of extinction angle. However, the inverter control may be switched from the -control strategy to the current-control mode that limits the current to some specified reference value. The firing angle for the inverter is then established based on the output of these control modules and the respective gate signals are constructed by the Pulse Generators depicted in Figure 4-1. 4.3 HVDC System Dynamic Average-Value Model Herein, the AVM is developed in both Matlab/Simulink and PSCAD/EMTDC. In order to model a complex system such as CIGRE HVDC benchmark, it is necessary to divide it up into smaller parts. Hence, the main circuit of HVDC system is divided into seven subsystems: two line-commutated converters (rectifier and inverter sides) which are modeled using the parametric average-value modeling approach; two ac subsystems; two controller subsystems; and the dc transmission line subsystem. For convenience, each subsystem is implemented as a separate module. These modules are then interconnected to form the overall HVDC system. The parametric AVM approach is generally independent of the simulator platform. For the purpose of dynamic average-value modeling, all the ac and dc variables are replaced by their fast averages over a prototypical switching interval Tsw as (2-2). Due to the 12-pulse 68 operation, Tsw 1 T , where Ts represents the period of the ac waveform as depicted in 12 s Figure 4-3. The switching interval Tsw and primary voltages and currents of the transformer in the rectifier side are illustrated in Figure 4-3. As seen in Figure 4-3, the transformed ac voltages v qdrp and currents i qdrp appear dc in the qd synchronous reference frame and have ripple with period of Tsw . Figure 4-3: Typical voltages and currents of a 12-pulse rectifier transformer primary winding. 69 4.3.1 Rectifier Dynamic Average-Value Model In this Section, the parametric average-value modeling methodology for 6-pulse diode rectifier is extended to the 12-pulse rectifier side of CIGRE HVDC benchmark system. Herein, the 12-pulse rectifier is composed of two 6-pulse line-commutated converters. In the AVM developed here, each converter may be modeled separately to represent the corresponding dc and ac side variables. The ac side converter voltages and currents for both 6-pulse rectifiers can be expressed in converter reference frame [15]. The parametric AVM assumes that the rectifier may be viewed as a multi-port switching cell, wherein the transformed ac side and dc side variables can be related through some algebraic functions. Herein, since there are two 6-pulse bridges, the two sets of parametric functions relating the ac and dc voltages are defined as: conv1 v qdrs ,1 w v dcr ,1 v,1 . conv 2 v qdrs ,2 wv,2 v dcr ,2 (4-1) Considering the series connection of the rectifier bridges, the ac and dc side currents are also related as conv1 conv 2 wi,1 i qdrs ,1 wi,2 i qdrs ,2 i dcr . (4-2) 70 where wv , wi and are algebraic functions of loading conditions and thyristor firing angle, and “conv1” and “conv2” refers to the converter reference frame for each converter, conv respectively. The power factor angles between vectors v conv qdrs and i qdrs for each converter are defined as se se se se 1 1 i drs ,1 i qrs ,1 1 v drs ,1 v qrs ,1 . tan tan se se se se i drs 2 i v v ,2 qrs ,2 drs ,2 qrs ,2 (4-3) Here, the superscript “se” refers to the sending-end equivalent voltage. Conditions (4-1) and (4-2) hold for any operating point, since functions wv , wi , and exist for the entire range of operation. The considered approach relies on calculating functions wv , wi , and numerically by running the detailed simulation similar to conventional 6-pulse converters [27]. The loading condition of each rectifier may be specified in terms of terminal currents and voltages. For compactness, the terminal voltages and currents are combined into dynamic impedances defined as se v i qdrs ,1 dcr , 1 z1 . se z 2 v dcr ,2 i qdrs ,2 (4-4) Assuming that AVM parameters for each rectifier are extracted and saved as lookup tables, the AVM of the rectifier side of CIGRE HVDC benchmark system can be implemented 71 according to the diagram depicted in Figure 4-4. For example, if the two AVMs are constructed (one for each bridge), then the system can be implemented according to Figure 4-4(a), where each bridge is modeled as an algebraic module that relates the corresponding dc and ac side variables transferred to a qd rotating reference frame. Alternatively, taking into account the symmetry between the bridges and their series connection, the two sub-models can be collapsed into one as depicted in Figure 4-4(b). In particular, assuming that the dc voltages for both rectifiers have the same average-value, we have v vdcr ,1 vdcr ,2 dcr 2 (4-5) Therefore, (4-1) and (4-2) can be simplified as conv1 v qdrs , eq wveq v dcr conv1 i dcr wieq i qdrs , eq where wveq (4-6) (4-7) 1 1 wv,1 wv,2 and wieq wi,1 wi,2 . Following the same approach, the 2 2 equivalent power factor angle eq may be defined as se se 1 i drs , eq 1 v drs , eq eq tan tan se se i qrs , eq v qrs , eq (4-8) 72 Using (4-6)-(4-8), the collapsed AVM of the rectifier side can be implemented as shown in Figure 4-4(b). The equivalent dynamic impedance is defined similarly, using appropriate equivalent dc voltage and ac currents in (4-4). The firing angle R is also provided by the respective controller (see Figure 4-2). It is worth mentioning that the collapsed AVM of Figure 4-4(b) provides more simplicity in comparison to the general formulation of (4-1)(4-3) when the rectifiers are symmetrical with respect to each other. The Pulse Generator module in Figure 4-1 produces the necessary thyristor firing pulses which are generally determined using the filtered converter ac voltages or their fundamental components. For example, the generation of firing pulses may be implemented based on the zero-crossing of the respective ac voltages (fundamental components). Any such filters will generally have some response delay which should be taken into account when constructing the AVM where all voltages and currents are continuous and appear as dc in appropriate synchronous reference frame. 73 Figure 4-4: Block diagram depicting implementation of the AVM rectifier side: (a) original AVM with two rectifiers separately; and (b) collapsed AVM. 4.3.2 Inverter Dynamic Average-Value Model The inverter side of CIGRE HVDC benchmark can be modeled using an approach similar to the rectifier side. As depicted in Figure 4-1, the 12-pulse inverter is composed of two 6pulse bridges connected in series. It is also important to keep in mind that the rectifier ac side (sending-end) and the inverter ac side (receiving-end) may have difference phase and even frequency. Therefore, to distinguish between the reference frame coordinates associated with the sending and receiving ac sides (represented by Thevenin equivalent 74 sources as depicted in Figure 4-1, the variables in the respective reference frames will be denoted by the superscript “se” and “re”, respectively. If the inverters’ AVMs are represented separately, one may consider two converter reference frames with the angular difference of 30 degrees. Assuming that there are no energy-storing-elements in the inverter circuit, the algebraic relationships relating the dc and ac variables similar to (4-1)-(4-3) can be readily established. The corresponding implementation will be similar to Figure 4-4(a), except reverse direction of the power and variables will be required. For the inverter side, the -control is also required to calculate the extinction angle. In the detailed simulation, the extinction angle is calculated based on voltages and currents on the valves of the bridges. However, in the AVM, the switching variables are replaced by their respective fast averages. Therefore, is extracted running a detailed simulation similar to wv , wi , and , and saved for the future use. Similar to the rectifier side, due to the symmetry in the system, the two AVMs of the inverters can be collapsed and represented using simplified equivalent relationships similar to (4-5)-(4-8). Implementation of the equivalent (collapsed) inverter AVM is shown in Figure 4-5. The firing angle I is also provided by the respective controller (see Figure 4-2). For the inverter AVM shown in Figure 4-5, as opposed to the rectifier AVM shown in Figure 4-4, the inverter ac currents i re qdis, eq and dc voltage vdci are assumed to be the outputs of the inverter average switching cell, whereas the ac voltages v re qdis, eq and dc 75 current idci are the inputs, respectively. Here, the inverter operating condition is determined in terms of an equivalent dynamic admittance defined as: yeq 1 i dci re z eq v qdis , eq (4-9) Interfacing the AVM depicted in Figure 4-5, as it is explain in Chapter 3, may require special consideration to achieve the input-output compatibility with other modules of the overall system. The desired interfacing for the AVM of Figure 4-5 can be achieved using snubber circuits (typically large resistors or small capacitors), or equivalently may also be achieved if the ac side inductor branches are represented using proper transfer function with a very fast pole [27]. Figure 4-5: Block diagram depicting implementation of the AVM inverter side. 76 4.3.3 AC Subsystems The ac subsystems at the rectifier and inverter sides are composed of an equivalent ac networks, the ac filters, and the phase-shifting transformers. For the purpose of dynamic average modeling, the ac subsystem can be modeled using approaches as depicted in Figure 4-6. In the first approach shown in Figure 4-6(a), the ac side is modeled as a network circuit in physical abc variables. In this case, interfacing the ac subsystem model with the AVM of the converter may require interfacing circuitry [14]. This approach is suitable for either PSCAD/EMTDC or SimPowerSystems in Matlab/Simulink. However, the ac subsystem can also be implemented in transformed synchronous qd coordinates/variables as a qd 0 -circuit shown in Figure 4-7. If this is possible, then the interface of the converter AVM with the ac network becomes simpler as depicted in Figure 4-6(b), since no abc to qd transformations of the interfacing variables would be required. Moreover, due to the symmetry of the transformer and the collapsed AVM representation of the converter, the transformer is represented here only in terms of its equivalent series impedance as shown in Figure 4-7. The ac subsystem of the rectifier side is very similar and can be modeled using any of the approaches depicted in Figure 4-6 and Figure 4-7, which is not shown due to similarity. 77 Figure 4-6: Block diagram depicting implementation and interfacing of the inverter side ac subsystem: (a) using abc original circuit; (b) using transformed qd 0 -circuit. 78 Figure 4-7: Inverter side ac subsystem implementation using transformed qd 0 -circuits. 79 4.3.4 DC Subsystem For the purpose of modeling in this study, the dc line is represented as an equivalent T circuit with two smoothing inductors (one on each side), and one equivalent capacitor, as depicted in Figure 4-1. If the dc subsystem is implemented as a circuit, it can be readily realized in most transient simulators such as PSCAD/EMTDC and SimPowerSystems in Matlab/Simulink, wherein appropriate interfacing with the rectifier and inverter AVMs will be required [65]. Additionally, the dc network could be modeled in state space form using proper transfer functions to represent the inductors and capacitor as explained in [27]. For example, for interfacing with the rectifier AVM which requires the input dc voltage v dcr as an input, the smoothing inductor in the rectifier dc side can be represented using a proper transfer function as in [27]. Alternatively, a snubber circuit (typically large resistor or small capacitor) can be added to the dc terminal of the rectifier [65]. 4.3.5 Control Subsystem Since the dynamic average modeling is only changing the implementation of the switching part of the system, the developed AVM of the entire CIGRE HVDC benchmark should be valid for a wide range of operating conditions as well as different controllers. Thus, the control system depicted in Figure 4-2 is considered here for the AVM as well for all subsequent studies for consistency with the original detailed model of the system. 80 4.4 Computer Studies Here, the detailed model of the CIGRE HVDC benchmark system is implemented using SimPowerSystem toolbox (using discrete blocks for faster simulation) in Matlab/Simulink. The AVM of the same system is also implemented in PSCAD/EMTDC and Matlab/Simulink using standard library blocks. In order to verify the accuracy of the proposed AVMs, the results of the detailed model are compared with the results of the developed AVMs in two transient studies. 4.4.1 Change in DC Reference Current In the first study, a fast change in the dc current reference is applied. First, it is assumed that the HVDC system is operating in a steady state and under nominal conditions with the dc current of 2000A. At t 1s , the command value of the dc current i dc _ ref is reduced to 1600A. After t 1.4s , the current reference is set back to 2000A. The transient responses produced by the detailed switching model and the AVMs implemented in Matlab/Simulink and PSCAD/EMTDC are shown in Figure 4-8. As it can be seen in Figure 4-8, the reduction in the reference current on the rectifier side causes the current drop on both the rectifier and inverter sides, which also results in respective increase in the dc voltage. The ac voltages on both sides are also depicted in Figure 4-8 (last two subplots), wherein the corresponding changes are also visible but less pronounced due to the scale. As expected, the results of AVMs in Matlab/Simulink and PSCAD/EMTDC follow the transient response of the detailed simulation with good accuracy but without the switching. As the switching is 81 averaged over a prototypical switching interval, the AVMs can be run with larger time-step without losing the accuracy of results and therefore execute faster than the corresponding detailed model. In order to demonstrate this point for the same study, both AVMs and detailed simulation are run with the maximum possible time-step to achieve acceptable accuracy. The detailed simulation is run using a fixed-step discrete solver as the model is developed using discrete blocks from the SimPowerSystem library. For this model, the time step of at least 10s was required to maintain the accuracy. The AVM implemented in PSCAD/EMTDC required a 110s time step. The AVM in Matlab/Simulink is run using a variable-step solver ODE23tb which dynamically adjusts the time-step size. For this model, the maximum time step was set to 2ms , and the average step size used by the solver was 1.6ms . The corresponding CPU time for different models is summarized in Table I. To remove the overhead due to initialization in each program, the CPU time is measured from t 0.9s to t 2s . As it can be seen in Table I, the AVMs run much faster than the detailed simulation. 4.4.2 Short Circuit in DC Side In the following study, a short circuit happens in the dc line. The HVDC system is again assumed to operate in a steady state and under the nominal conditions with the dc current of 2000A. Then, at t 2s , a resistive short circuit (0.4 pu) is applied in the middle of the dc line. The short circuit is then cleared at t 2.5s and the system recovers following a transient. The dc currents and voltages, and the phase voltage of the transformers primary 82 sides as predicted by various models are shown in Figure 4-9. As can be seen from Figure 4-9, during the short circuit, the dc currents of the rectifier and inverter drop significantly due to the controller action that limits the value of the fault currents by reducing the dc reference current and also increasing and decreasing the applied firing angles of the rectifier and inverter sides, respectively. During the short circuit, as the dc voltage drops, the output current of the rectifier is limited to the minimum value due to the voltagedependent current control on the rectifier side. However, on the inverter side, the firing angle is reduced to the minimum value and therefore inverter current is close to zero. The dc voltages at the inverter and rectifier ends of the transmission line are also undergoing significant drop. After the fault is cleared, the system recovers and following a transient response all voltages and currents return to their pre-fault values as can be seen in Figure 4-9. Throughout the whole transient study, which is determined by the HVDC system dynamics and the action of its both controllers, the results predicted by the AVM remain in very good agreement with respect to the reference solution provided by the detailed switching model. 83 Figure 4-8: Currents and voltages resulting from a change in dc reference current as predicted by various models. 84 Table 4-1: Comparison of simulation speed for different models for time interval from t 0.9 s to t 2 s Model Detailed –SimPowerSystems (Discrete Blocks) PAVM- Simulink (Variable step solver) PAVM- PSCAD/EMTDC Step size, 10 s t 2 ms (max) 1.6 ms (avg.) 110 s CPU time, s 13.911 0.5290 0.62 85 Figure 4-9: Currents and voltages during a short circuit in dc side as predicted by various models. 86 4.5 Summary of Contributions In this chapter, the parametric average-value modeling approach presented in Chapters 2 and 3 has been extended to model the 12-pulse line-commutated rectifier and inverter. Based on the new AVMs for 12-pulse rectifier and inverter subsystems, the AVM of the CIGRE HVDC Benchmark system has been developed for the first time in both statevariable-based simulation languages such as Matlab/Simulink as well as EMTP-type packages such as PSCAD/EMTDC. On the basis of the work accomplished in this chapter, a significant gain in simulation speed (26 times faster) and time-steps (up to 2ms for SV programs) are demonstrated for the CIGRE HVDC Benchmark system. 87 Chapter 5: Considering AC Side Harmonics in Dynamic Averaging of LineCommutated Converters Although line-commutated converters such as the one shown in Figure 1-1(a) provide numerous advantages [76], [77], they are also a significant source for current harmonic in the power systems. As an example, the phase current waveform of the line-commutated rectifier of Figure 1-1(a) together with its harmonic content is illustrated in Figure 5-1. As it can be seen from Figure 5-1, the current waveform is significantly distorted due to high content of harmonics produced by the switching in the system. The injected harmonic currents can result in harmonics in the common bus voltage. In general, the harmonics in current and voltage increase losses and have an adverse impact on the system generators, transformers, variable speed drives, etc [48]. To provide some guidelines for dealing with harmonics generated by static powerelectronic converters and preventing any damage to the power system equipments, a number of standards have been set, e.g. [80], which set the limitations on maximum current and voltage harmonics in a particular system. Therefore, engineers commonly conduct various feasibility studies to predict the amount and spectrum of injected harmonics from the equipment that is under consideration for installation in the power grid. Presently, such 88 studies may only be carried out using the conventional simulation techniques and detailed switching models (which are computationally expensive). The conventional dynamic AVMs, based on either the analytical and parametric approaches, are only capable of predicting the fundamental component of the ac voltages and currents. This is due to the fact that the ac variables are first transferred to a qd rotating reference frame with the rotational speed equal to the fundamental frequency. The transformed waveforms are then composed of a dc component (which has a constant average in steady-state) superimposed by some ripple due to harmonics. Subsequently, all the ripple in these transformed qd variables are filtered (averaged out). Hence, the averaged transformed qd variables become pure dc, and transferring them back to phase variables generates only the fundamental component of the ac waveforms (which is also illustrated in Figure 5-1). Extending the parametric AVMs for the transient studies with harmonics would potentially enable a new family of computational tools for the power quality and feasibility studies, where traditionally only the detailed switching models could be used. To the best of our knowledge, this has not been achieved or proposed prior to this thesis. 89 Figure 5-1. Typical phase terminal voltage and current of diode rectifier system and their harmonic content. 5.1 Multiple-Reference Parametric Average-Value Model The conventional parametric AVM (PAVM), introduced in [27], is a single-reference framebased model, and therefore incapable of including the effects of harmonics in the ac side. In this Chapter, the parametric methodology is extended to consider the ac system harmonics using the multiple reference frames theory. In general, the qd rotating reference frame is not limited to the system fundamental frequency, and its rotational speed could be chosen according to any system harmonic. The multiple reference frames theory, was introduced 90 in [78] to analyze symmetrical induction machines under presence of unbalanced stator voltages or harmonic content. The multiple reference frame PAVM (MRF-PAVM) developed in this section utilizes multiple rotating coordinate systems in order to extract the fast average of variables related to each harmonic in the ac side. These rotating reference frames are depicted with respect to each other in Figure 5-2. The synchronous reference frame, wherein the q -axis is aligned with phase a of the ac system Thevenin equivalent voltage source, is rotating according to the fundamental frequency in the modeling, and referred to by the superscript “s”. However, for simplicity, the converter reference frame, superscript “c”, is defined wherein the angular position of the rotating reference frame q -axis is considered to be aligned with the phase a voltage [15]. Herein, the nth harmonic of the synchronous reference frame is referred with superscript “n”. The harmonics such as 7th and 13th that rotate in the same direction as the fundamental component (see Figure 5-2) are known as the positive sequence harmonics. The harmonics such as the 5th and 11th rotate in the opposite direction as the fundamental, and are called negative sequence harmonics. The triple harmonics (all multiples of 3) such as 3rd and 9th do not rotate because their respective three-phase components are aligned with each other. These harmonics comprise the zero–sequence component, whose current is blocked by the bridge. A particular emphasis should be placed on the sequence for different harmonics. These positive- and negative-sequence harmonics play an essential role in the operation of ac 91 electric machinery. In synchronous machines, for example, the positive-sequence harmonics act to rotate field and rotor in the proper direction; whereas, the negativesequence harmonics act against the direction of the rotation. Figure 5-2: Rectifier ac side voltages and currents expressed in synchronous, converter [15], and nth harmonic reference frames. 92 Assuming that the ac side has only periodic integer harmonics (no sub harmonics, etc.), each ac variable can be represented based on its harmonic components as f abcs n , f abcs (5-1) nM where n represents the harmonic number of each component. The positive and negative superscript signs are used to differentiate between the positive- and negative-sequence harmonics. As a result, M 1, 5, 7, ..., 1k 1 2k 1 k 2, 3... . In order to calculate the fast average of the ac variables for each harmonic component over a switching interval, first, (5-1) should be transferred to the nth -harmonic synchronous reference frame as shown in Figure 5-2: n f qds K ns n . f abcs (5-2) nM As it is denoted in Figure 5-2, the positive- and negative-sequence-harmonic reference frames rotate in opposite directions. The transformation matrix for each harmonic reference frame is defined as 93 2 2 cosn s cos n s 3 cos n s 3 2 2 2 K ns sinn s sin n s sin n s , 3 3 3 12 12 12 (5-3) where s , as shown in Figure 5-2, is the angular position of the synchronous reference frame. The rotational speed of the nth -harmonic reference frame is n times faster than the conventional synchronously rotating reference frame (which corresponds to the fundamental component). Moreover, the direction of rotation alternates for different harmonics, starting with the positive direction for the fundamental component. For instance, 5th harmonic is negative sequence, and 7 th harmonic is positive-sequenceharmonics. If desired, (5-1) may be transformed to the nth -harmonic reference frame using the frame-to-frame transformation matrix according to: n s , f qds s K n f qds (5-4) wherein s K n cos n 1 s sin n 1 s sin n 1 s . cos n 1 s (5-5) Upon transferring (5-1) into the nth -harmonic rotating reference frame, the nth harmonic component will have a dc value in steady state, as opposed to all other harmonic 94 components which will be oscillatory with a zero average value. Adopting the above concepts of multiple reference frames established for various harmonics, the average-value of each variable in the nth -harmonic rotating reference frame may then be defined by the generalized fast-average expression as t 1 n n t dt , f qds f qds Tsw t Tsw (5-6) n (t ) represents the ac voltage or current transferred to the nth -harmonic where f qds rotating reference frame. The dynamic average model can now be formulated employing the parametric approach. For this purpose, the fast average of dc and ac side variables are related through algebraic functions. These relationships are established at each operating point for each harmonic, with the ac variables transferred to the respective reference frame. Specifically, wv , n v dc n v qds , nM , (5-7) , nM . (5-8) and n i qds wi , n i dc 95 The above algebraic functions are extracted and tabulated for all the system operating points and the desired harmonics (herein, 1st, 5th and 7th). This can be done by running a detailed simulation using a large signal transient, similar to the procedure introduced in [28]. In order to solve the ac network, it is required to calculate the rectifier voltages for each harmonic. According to the relationship between the vectors shown in Figure 5-2, the converter terminal voltages can be calculated as v n cos n qs wv, n v dc , nM , n v ds sin n (5-9) where, n is also extracted and tabulated directly from a detailed simulation. For the fundamental component, may also be calculated as is s ds tan 1 vds is vs qs qs tan 1 . (5-10) In general, the converter operating point is directly determined by the transferred power to the dc load. The consumed power in the dc load is calculated based on the converter dc terminal voltage and current. These dc variables are typically dependent on the ac fundamental components. Therefore, regardless of the harmonic content in the ac side, similar to the conventional PAVM [27], the rectifier operating condition is defined as 96 z vdc c i qds . (5-11) 5.2 MRF-PAVM Implementation After extracting the AVM parametric functions for all the desired ac harmonics, the MRFPAVM is implemented according to the block diagram shown in Figure 5-3. As it can be seen in Figure 5-3, the whole system is divided into three subsystems: the ac system, which could be in abc phase variables or in qd rotating reference frame; the dc system; and the rectifier subsystem. As it is illustrated in Figure 5-3, the rectifier subsystem is composed of different sub-modules for the fundamental and other-order harmonics of the ac variables. The blocks labeled as AVM _1 to AVM _ n algebraically relate the dc and ac variables of the corresponding harmonic. Figure 5-3 shows that in the proposed implementation the harmonics other than the fundamental component, do not have effect on the predicted dc waveforms. The dc current idc is the input for the dc subsystem model is calculated according to the fundamental ac current inside the subsystem AVM _1 . According to this implementation, both the proposed MRF-PAVM and conventional PAVM produce the same dc waveforms. 97 Figure 5-3: Block diagram depicting implementation of the MRF-PAVM for the diode rectifier system. 5.3 Computer Studies In this Chapter, the detailed model of the diode rectifier system shown in Figure 1-1(a) is simulated using the ASMG toolbox [12] in Matlab/Simulink [9]. The system parameters are summarized in Appendix E. The AVMs, PAVM and MRF-PAVM, of the same system are implemented in Matlab/Simulink using standard library blocks. In order to verify the accuracy of the proposed MRF-PAVM, the results of the detailed model as well as the conventional PAVM are compared with the results of the proposed MRF-PAVM in timedomain studies. 98 First, the MRF-PAVM is validated in steady-state operations for CCM and DCM from very light dc load (close to open circuit) to very heavy dc load (close to short circuit). The CCM results are shown for the first and second rectifier modes of operation. In the second step, it is shown that the new MRF-PAVM can accurately follow the transient response of the original switching system. 5.3.1 Model Verification in Steady-State Study Over Wide Range The LCC may work under a wide range of loads, from open to short circuit. On the basis of switching pattern and loading condition, different modes of operation may be defined. Just based on the load, the rectifier operation may be roughly classified as light and heavy. The LCC with typical system parameters normally operates with the light load, wherein the commutation angle is less than 60 degrees and 2 or 3 switches are conducting during each conduction and commutation subintervals, respectively [14]. However, in some cases with a very light load (and depending on the system parameters), the dc current may be discontinuous. Therefore, in general, the LCC modes of operation in the light load may be defined as discontinuous current mode (DCM) and continuous current (CCM). The conduction and commutation pattern defined by 2 or 3 switches is therefore referred to as the CCM-1. Under heavy loads, the commutation angle may become higher than 60 degrees, and three switches will be conducting at each time. This mode mostly is called CCM-2, and it may happen for systems with sufficiently large commutating inductance in dc filter inductance, or the conditions that are close to short circuit or fault. The corresponding 99 steady state regulation characteristic obtained from the detailed simulation and PAVM is plotted in Figure 5-4, wherein the different modes of operation are illustrated. In the following studies, the proposed MRF-PAVM is validated in steady-state for three modes of operation. The chosen operating points are marked on the regulation characteristic plotted in Figure 5-4. Figure 5-4: Steady state regulation characteristic of the considered line-commutated converter as predicted by various models. 100 First, it is assumed that the system is operating in DCM with a very light load defined by the dc load resistance of 905 . The resulting dc and ac currents and voltages are shown in Figure 5-5 for the detailed simulation and the AVMs. As it can be observed in Figure 5-5, in DCM, the phase voltage is very close to the sinusoidal waveform but the phase current has very pronounced distortions in the form of 5th and 7th harmonics. In the dc side, both the conventional PAVM and MRF-PAVM predict results and that perfectly match the detailed simulation (see Figure 5-5). For the ac side, as it is shown in Figure 5-5, the results of the proposed MRF-PAVM are visually close to the actual current and voltage waveforms. The MRF-PAVM results for the ac side could become even closer to the actual waveforms if more accuracy is required by including more of the higher order harmonics. Extending the MRF-PAVM to the higher order harmonics requires smaller simulation time step. However, as it is shown in Figure 5-5, for the ac side, the conventional PAVM can only predict the response in terms of the fundamental component. The extracted harmonic content of the rectifier phase current and voltage is shown in Figure 5-6 for the MRF-PAVM and detailed simulation. As it can be seen in Figure 5-6, for the considered 1st, 5th, and 7th harmonics in the AVM, the results of the MRF-PAVM match the detailed simulation very well. Next, the load is changed to 150 , and the converter operation changes to CCM-1, which is the most common operating mode for the LCCs. The current and voltage waveforms of the detailed and AVMs are shown in Figure 5-7. As the Figure 5-7 shows, both AVMs have the same results for the dc side that match the detailed simulation. For the ac side, the 101 proposed MRFPAVM predicts the actual ac waveforms much better while the conventional PAVM can predict only the first harmonic of the ac variables. Figure 5-5: System variables as predicted by various models in DCM; detailed, conventional PAVM, and MRF-PAVM models, respectively. 102 The harmonic content of the detailed simulation and the MRF-PAVM in CCM-1 is plotted in Figure 5-8, wherein the harmonics predicted by MRF-PAVM are in very good agreement with the results produced by the detailed simulation. Figure 5-6: Harmonic content of the phase current and voltage as predicted by various models in DCM. 103 Figure 5-7: System variables as predicted by various models for operation in CCM-1. 104 Figure 5-8: Harmonic content of the phase current and voltage as predicted by various models for the rectifier operation CCM-1. Finally, the rectifier operation is changed to the heavy mode CCM-2, which is achieved by the dc load resistance of 1 . The corresponding simulation results are shown in Figure 5-9, which demonstrates that the MRF-PAVM may be considered sufficiently accurate in reproducing ac waveforms as well as predicting the average of system variables even under heavy loads. The phase current and voltage harmonic content for the CCM-2 extracted from the MRF-PAVM and detailed simulation are shown in Figure 5-10. This figure shows that the MRF-PAVM is also capable of predicting the harmonic content of the detailed simulation very well. In CCM-2, the phase current is very close to the sinusoidal. This fact is verified in Figure 5-10, wherein the fundamental component is dominant. 105 Figure 5-9: System variables as predicted by various models in CCM-2; detailed, conventional PAVM, and proposed MRF-PAVM models, respectively. 106 Figure 5-10: Harmonic content of the phase current and voltage in rectifier in CCM-2 as predicted by the detailed model and the proposed MRF-PAVM. Considering studies presented in Figure 5-5 through Figure 5-10, it can be concluded that the proposed MRF-PAVM is sufficiently accurate in predicting the original switching system response in the range of operations from very light to heavy loads. For the purpose of power quality and feasibility analysis of the proposed connections to the energy grid, it is necessary to consider the total harmonic distortion (THD) level [79], which is defined as Fn2 THD nM n 1 F12 , (5-12) 107 where F is the RMS value of current or voltage. To assess how the proposed AVM can be used for the power-quality-focused studies, the THD of ac voltage and current is obtained for a wide range of load from open to short circuit using detailed simulation and proposed MRF-PAVM considering system harmonics. The results are plotted in Figure 5-11. As it can be seen in Figure 5-11, considering only the 5th and 7th harmonics, the MRF-PAVM can predict the system THD fairly accurate. However, as it is shown in Figure 5-11, although considering the 5th harmonic only increases the simulation speed, this also reduces the accuracy in predicting the THD of the terminal voltages and currents. For instance, according to [80], the maximum permissible voltage THD is 5 % for a typical industrial power system. However, based on Figure 5-11, it can be noticed that the level of THD in the LCC terminal voltage is far above the standards and therefore, injected harmonics are not negligible. The proposed MRF-PAVM will then be capable of predicting the effect of various harmonic filters and other measures applied in the system without the needed for the detailed switching model. 108 Figure 5-11: Total harmonic distortion of the rectifier phase current and voltage as predicted by the detailed model and the proposed MRF-PAVMs over a wide range of operating conditions. 5.3.2 Transient Study For the purpose of this study, it is assumed that the system is initially operating in steady state with resistive load of 20 . At t 1s , the load is changed to 5 . The corresponding simulation results are shown in Figure 5-12. The waveforms plotted in Figure 5-12 clearly demonstrate that the proposed MRF-PAVM can follow the transient response of the detailed simulation as accurate as the conventional PAVM for a large disturbance in the system beside the fact that it is advantageous in predicting the ac variables waveforms by 109 including the harmonics into the model. Before the step change in the load, the rectifier is operating in CCM-1. After the step change in the load, the operating mode changes to CCM2, close to the short circuit. The conducted transient study shows that the propose MRFPAVM can accurately follow the transient response of the switching mode in a wide range of operating conditions. Furthermore, since the AVMs are continuous, the simulation time-step could be chosen larger and therefore such models can run faster than the corresponding detailed model. To support this claim, the same transient study is run using the detailed simulation and PAVMs with the maximum possible time-step to achieve acceptable accuracy. For consistency, all simulations are using fixed-step solver ODE 3. The CPU time and time-steps for each simulation are summarized in Table 5-1. As it can be seen in Table 5-1, the PAVMs are running with larger time step and execute faster than the detailed simulation. However, considering system harmonics, the MRF-PAVM requires smaller time steps, and consequently slower than the conventional PAVM which has only the fundamental component of the ac variables. 110 Figure 5-12: System response to a step change in load as predicted by various models; detailed, conventional PAVM and proposed MRF-PAVM. 111 Table 5-1: Comparison of simulation speed for different models for time interval from t 0 to t 2 s Model Detailed Step size 100 s Simulation time (s) 1.0113 1.6 m s 0.377 0.191 PAVM (1st, 5th &7th Harmonics) PAVM (1st Harmonic) 5.4 500 s Summary of Contributions In this chapter, the ac side harmonics have been incorporated into the parametric AVM approach using multiple reference frame theory. This extension makes it possible to use the parametric AVMs for the power quality and feasibility analysis with transients; whereas in the past such studies would require the use of computationally expensive detailed switching models. To demonstrate the proposed concept, herein only the 5th and 7th harmonics have been included in the simulation studies as these are typically are the dominant harmonics contributing to the power quality issues with the LCCs. The accuracy of the developed PAVM in predicting the desired ac harmonics has been established by conducting steady-state and large-signal transient studies. It has also been demonstrated that that new MRF-PAVM significantly increases the simulation speed and efficiency in comparison to the detailed simulation, although it runs slower than the conventional PAM which includes only the fundamental 60/50 Hz component. This difference is due to the fact that predicting higher order harmonics also requires smaller integration time step. 112 Chapter 6: Direct Interfacing of Parametric Average-Value Models in EMTP Type Solution AVMs are typically formulated in state-space, which is suitable and straightforward to implement in state-variable-based programs. However, in EMTP-type programs [3], [4], [81], implementation of AVMs developed in state-space is challenging due to the discretization and interfacing. In addition, the AVMs are typically developed in qd synchronous reference frame, but the terminal variables of the switching system are in abc physical variable and coordinates. Hence, the interfacing of AVM with the external EMTP network requires additional attention. In general, the interfacing approaches may be categorized as indirect and direct [14]. The direct interfacing significantly improves the simulation accuracy at large time-steps in comparison to the indirect approach due to removing of the time-step delay. Therefore, in this Chapter, the parametric AVM introduced in [27], which appears very promising and extendable to more complex converter systems and topologies, is discretized using the trapezoidal rule and directly interfaced to the external EMTP networks using two different approaches. The developed methodologies are validated for all the ac-dc converters including the LCC and PWM converters. Developing 113 AVM of the LCC is much more complicated and challenging than for the PWM converters. Therefore, herein, the direct interfacing approach has been applied to the PAVM of the LCC. 6.1 Discretized Parametric Average-Value Model The established average-value models in state-space and qd coordinates are required to be reformulated for the nodal-analysis-based simulators (PSCAD and EMTP-RV), wherein each circuit component is presented based on the discretized formulation using a particular integration rule (such as trapezoidal or backward Euler). The trapezoidal and backward Euler integrations are formulated respectively as yn 1 yn t f n 1 f n 2 y n 1 y n t f n 1 (6-1) (6-2) In EMTP solution, the network is solved based on the nodal-analysis formulation as GVn I h , (6-3) where, G represents the system nodal conductance matrix, and I h is composed of history terms and independent current-sources in the network. Recently, analytical and parametric AVMs of the line-commutated rectifier systems have been reformulated and interfaced with the EMTP-type simulators using an indirect 114 interfacing approach (which involves a time-step relaxation) [14]. However, the indirect interfacing generally requires very small integration time-step in order to produce sufficiently accurate solution, and leads to poor accuracy and/or numerical instability when large time-steps are used. Here, a direct interfacing approach that achieves a simultaneous and numerically stable solution is developed. As it is shown in Figure 6-1, the directly interfaced parametric AVM (DI-PAVM) is interfaced into the discretized power network by adding 4 elements to the G matrix and history terms to I h using the Thevenin equivalent circuit depicted in Figure 6-1. Therefore, the DI-PAVM is solved together with the external EMTP network at each time-step using (6-3) without any delay. Figure 6-1: Thevenin equivalent-circuit diagram of directly-interfaced PAVM in abc variables with collapsed dc side. 115 6.2 Directly-Interfaced PAVM with Collapsed DC Side In order to interface the PAVM directly with the ac network model in abc phase variables, it is necessary to express the ac voltages based on the rectifier ac currents (or vice versa) using (2-3)-(2-7). Substituting (2-5) into (2-6), the qd components of the ac terminal voltages in the synchronous reference frame are i t cos tan 1 ( ds ) iqs t vqs t . w v v dc v t ds sin tan 1 ( ids t ) iqs t (6-4) In the PAVM as shown in Figure 6-2, the dc voltage which is the input of the converter AVM block is determined by the dc sub-system circuit. Here, the dc voltage is calculated based on the dc side Thevenin or Norton equivalent circuit. Figure 6-2 shows the PAVM described by (2-3)-(2-7), (6-4) wherein the dc sub-system Norton equivalent circuit is considered as part of the rectifier AVM subsystem. The dc voltage in the block diagram in Figure 6-2 is calculated as vdc t Req idc t ih,dc t . (6-5) Substituting (6-6) and (6-5) into (6-4), and using method, results in 116 i t vqs t wv t wi t Req iqs 2 t ids 2 t cos tan 1 ( ds t ) iqs t i t wv t Req ih, dc cos tan 1 ( ds t ) , iqs t i t vds t wv t wi t Req iqs 2 t ids 2 t sin tan 1 ( ds t ) iqs t (6-6) i t wv t Req ih, dc sin tan 1 ( ds t ) . iqs t After some extensive effort, (6-6) can be written as vqs t wv t wi t Req iqs 2 t ids 2 t iqs t ids t cos t sin t iqs 2 t ids 2 t iqs 2 t ids 2 t wv t Req ih,dc cos t , vds t wv t wi t Req iqs t ids t 2 (6-7) 2 iqs t ids t sin t cos t iqs 2 t ids 2 t iqs 2 t ids 2 t wv Req ih,dc sin . wherein ids t . iqs t tan 1 (6-8) 117 In (6-8), the ac side voltage-sources shown in Figure 6-2, are represented as nonlinear functions of ac currents. Hence, these functions are required so that the model can be linearized in a time-step t as Figure 6-2: Block diagram of descretized averaged-circuit model with collapsed dc side. vqs t wv t t wi t t Req cos t t iqs t wv wi Req sin t t ids t i t t wv Req ih, dc cos tan 1 ( ds t t ) , iqs t t vds t wv t t wi t t Req sin t t iqs t (6-9) wv t t wi t t Req cos t t ids t i t t wv t t Req ih, dc sin tan 1 ( ds t t ) . iqs t t Equation (6-9) describes the discretized AVM in qd which can be directly interfaced with the ac network. The final implemented model can be represented in the general matrix form as 118 Vn Z avm qd I br e h qd , (6-10) where Req cos t t Req sin t t Z avmqd wv t t wi t t , Req sin t t Req cos t t (6-11) i t t wv t t Req ih,dc cos tan 1 ( ds t t ) iqs t t , e hqd 1 ids t t w t t R i t t ) eq h,dc sin tan ( v i t t qs (6-12) (6-13) I br iqs ids T , and Vn vqs vds T . It is worth mentioning that using instead of method results in different equations. In this case, the discretized ac equations can be expressed as follows, vqs t wv t t wi t t Req cos t t ) iqs t t iqs 2 t t ids 2 t t ids t t iqs t t ids t t 2 2 iqs t wv t t wi t t Req cos t t ids t wv t t Req ih,dc cos t t , vd t wv wi Req sin t t ) iqs t t iqs 2 t t ids 2 t t ids t t iqs 2 t t ids 2 t t (6-14) iqs t wv t t wi t t Req sin t t ids t wv t t Req ih,dc sin t t . 119 Defining the following nonlinear functions as A B iqs t t iqs t t ids t t 2 2 ids t t iqs t t ids t t 2 2 , (6-15) , (6-16) the AVM Impedance and history terms matrixes are written as Req cos t t ) A Req cos t t B Z avm qd wv t t wi t t , Req sin t t ) A Req sin t t B (6-17) wv t t Req i h,dc cos t t e h qd . wv t t Req i h,dc sin t t (6-18) In a case that the ac system is developed in qd , the developed PAVM can be directly interfaced to the ac circuit. However, ac system model developed in qd is not a common practice in most of system studies wherein the network model is prepared in abc phase variables. Therefore, it is necessary to transform the discretized PAVM to the abc phase coordinates. Applying the inverse transformation [15] and after some effort, the Theveninequivalent of the AVM can be represented as Vn Z avmabc I br e habc , 33 , ehabc eh,a Zavmabc Zij (6-19) eh,b eh,c T , (6-20) 120 Vn vas vbs vcs T , and I br ias ibs ics T . (6-21) Then, in order to make the PAVM easy to interface in EMTP-type simulators such as PSCAD/EMTDC, the developed PAVM can be expressed based on the Norton-equivalent of the current source-conductance branches by multiplying both sides of (6-19) by Z1 as bellow. Z 1avm abc Vn I br I h abc , (6-22) I h , a 1 I h abc I h,b Z avm abc e h abc . I h, c (6-23) The interfacing of the Norton-equivalent PAVM with the ac system is shown in Figure 6-3. Figure 6-3: Norton equivalent-circuit diagram of directly-interfaced PAVM in abc phase variables with collapsed dc side. 121 6.3 Directly-Interfaced PAVM with Snubber in DC Side In the directly interfaced PAVM developed in the Subsection 6.2, the dc voltage in (6-4) is calculated based on the equivalent-circuit of the dc system. Therefore, the dc side is collapsed and its equivalent-circuit is mapped into the ac side equations. Although, this PAVM is very suitable for the applications when the dc system is isolated from the entire ac network such as machine drives or induction furnaces, etc., in some applications such as HVDC systems the dc side of the rectifier is interconnected to the other parts of the ac network and other converters. Therefore, the discretized PAVM should be capable of being interfaced with both the ac and dc networks. As it is shown in Figure 6-2, the rectifier is modeled in the dc side as a dependent current source and therefore the dc voltage cannot be calculated independent of the dc system equivalent-circuit. In order to overcome this challenge shown in Figure 6-4, a resistive snubber is added to the rectifier output. In order to reduce the interfacing error in the dc side, the snubber resistance should be chosen sufficiently large. Using this snubber, the rectifier dc voltage can be calculated independent of the dc network variables (see Figure 6-4) as vdc t Rsb wi iqs 2 t ids 2 t iLoad t . (6-24) Substituting (6-24) in (6-4) and linearizing the resulting equation, the discretized PAVM based on the method can be written as 122 vqs t wv t t wi t t Rsb cos t t iqs t t iqs t t ids t t 2 2 ids t t iqs 2 t t ids 2 t t iqs t wv t t wi t t Rsb cos t t ids t wv t t Rsb cos t t iLoad t , vd t wv t t wi t t Rsb sin t t iqs t t iqs 2 t t ids 2 t t ids t t iqs 2 t t ids 2 t t ids t wv t t Rsb sin t t iLoad t , iqs t t vdc t wi t t Rsb wi t t Rsb iqs t wv t t wi t t Rsb sin t t iqs t t ids t t 2 2 ids t t iqs 2 t t ids 2 t t iqs t ids t Rsb iLoad t . (6-25) As it can be seen in (6-25), the PAVM does not have any history terms and the impedance matrix is generated as wv t t wi t t R sb cos t t A Z avmqd wv t t wi t t R sb sin A wi t t R sb A wv t t wi t t R sb cos t t B .. wv t t wi t t R sb sin t t B ... wi t t R sb B ... (6-26) wv t t R sb cos t t ... wv t t R sb sin t t R sb 123 where the coefficients A and B are defined in (6-15) and (6-16). By transforming the discretized PAVM into abc phase variables, the Thevenin-equivalent of the model can be written as Vn Z avm abc I br , (6-27) , Z avmabc Zij 44 Vn vas vbs vcs (6-28) vdc T , and I br ias ibs ics iLoad T (6-29) The Norton-equivalent can then be represented as Z 1 avmabc Vn I br . (6-30) The Thevenin-equivalent of this DI-PAVM is the same as the diagram shown in Figure 6-1, wherein the converter is connected to the EMTP external network as a discretized component with multiple terminals. Figure 6-4: Block diagram of the descretized averaged-circuit model interfaced with resistive snubber in dc side. 124 Although using resistive snubber in the dc side solves the interfacing problem of the PAVM with the dc system as described, it also introduces interfacing losses to the model and causes some numerical oscillations for the large time-steps. To mitigate this problem, the interfacing is modified by adding a compensating current source in parallel to the snubber as shown in Figure 6-4. This current source is calculated in each step as V (t t ) . icomp (t ) dc Rsb (6-31) Using this modified circuit brings the ability to reduce the resistance of the snubber as the resistive loss introduced by the snubber is compensated, and smaller value for the resistive snubber prevents numerical oscillations in large time-steps. It should be mentioned that all discretized PAVMs are developed and formulated in synchronous reference frame, but the concepts of the parametric approach and discretization technique are general, and the PAVMs can be reformulated for any arbitrary rotating reference frame such as the converter reference frame. 6.4 Computer Studies Here, the LCC system shown in Figure 1-1 with parameters summarized in Appendix F is simulated using the directly interfaced PAVMs proposed and formulated in the previous 125 sections. In order to verify the accuracy and demonstrate the performance of the DIPAVMs, these models are compared with the detailed simulation and the analytical directly interfaced AVM introduced in [51] for different time-steps t . Here, the detailed simulation is implemented in PSCAD/EMTDC, and all the AVMs are implemented based on an EMTPtype algorithm written in MATLAB. In the first study, the integration time-step is considered to be small, 50 μs . The system is starting up from zero initial condition. At t 0.02s , the resistive load is changed from 2 to 1 . Then, at t 0.04s , the load is changed back to 2 . For this study, the waveforms resulted from the detailed simulation, directly interfaced PAVM with the collapsed dc side (DI-PAVM1), directly interfaced PAVM with the resistive snubber in the dc side (DIPAVM2), and the directly interfaced analytical AVM [50] are plotted in Figure 6-5. As it is shown in Figure 6-5, all the AVMs follow the transient response of the detailed switching simulation almost perfectly. Next, the performance of the proposed PAVMs is studied for larger time-steps. First, the same study as is carried out with the time-step of 500 μs . The simulation results of the different AVMs are compared with the detailed simulation in Figure 6-6(a), which demonstrates the accuracy of the AVMs in predicting the transient response of the detailed simulation. The compensation current connected in parallel with the resistive snubber is considered based on the dc voltage calculated in the previous time step. The effect of this may be presented in the startup for large time-steps and small value of the snubber 126 resistance. For instance, a magnified view of the startup trajectories of ias and vas is shown in Figure 6-6(b). As it is shown in Figure 6-6(b), there is a small error and oscillations in the startup predicted by the PAVM with the resistive snubber (DI-PAVM 2) in dc side for a large time-step. Finally, for the same case study, the simulation results are plotted in Figure 6-7(a) for a very large time-step of 2 ms . In Figure 6-7(a), the AVMs are compared with the reference results which are obtained using the time-step of 50 μs . As it is illustrated in Figure 6-7(a), the AVMs still predict the response of the detailed simulation with acceptable accuracy. For more clarification, the magnified view of v Load and ias during the transient is illustrated in Figure 6-7(b). Based on Figure 6-7(b), it can be verified that the accuracy of the proposed DI-PAVMs does not degrade by increasing the size of the time-step. However, due to the trapezoidal integration rule, for very large time-steps such as 2 ms , some numerical oscillations may be introduced to vdc using the analytical AVM and DIPAVM with the collapsed dc side (DI-PAVM1) during the initialization and fast transient which will be damped after a while. This can be seen in vdc curve plotted in Figure 6-7. Using the resistive snubber in the dc side, these numerical oscillations are damped as can be seen from vdc curve in Figure 6-7. 127 In order to suppress these steady numerical oscillations introduced to the simulation by the trapezoidal integration, a damping technique is developed on the basis of the methodology introduced in [82]. 128 Figure 6-5: Transient response of the system in dc and ac variables as predicted by the various models using 50 μs time-step. 129 130 Figure 6-6: Transient response of the system in dc and ac variables as predicted by various models using 500 μs time-step: (a) dc and ac waveforms of the overall transient; and (b) magnified view of the start-up waveforms. 131 Figure 6-7: Transient response of the system in dc and ac variables as predicted by various models using 2 ms time-step: (a) dc and ac waveforms of the overall transient; and (b) magnified view of the start-up waveforms. 132 6.5 Damping Technique for Directly-Interfaced Parametric Average-Value Models The trapezoidal integration used in the previous Section 6.3 is the dominant method for the EMTP-type solution as it is proven to be simple, numerical stable for stiff systems and also self-starting [81]-[86]. However, the trapezoidal integration also appears to be oscillatory. Therefore, during the past decades, many researches have been trying to solve this weak point of trapezoidal integration. One of the most significant techniques is the so called critical damping adjustment (CDA) introduced in [84], [85]. Another method is trapezoidal integration with damping introduced in [82], [83]. In this method, the G matrix is required to be changed or updated, which makes it challenging to be implemented in software packages. This issue is solved by the methodology introduced in [86], wherein the timestep size is flexible and changing during the simulation. Nevertheless, it is challenging to apply this methodology in simulators with fixed simulation time-step such as PSCAD/EMTDC and EMTP-RV. Herein, on the basis of the trapezoidal with damping technique [82], a methodology is developed which does not require any change or update in the G matrix. 133 6.5.1 Trapezoidal Integration with Damping Using the trapezoidal integration, all the system elements can be presented as pure resistive and history voltage source or nodal current injection as shown in Figure 6-8. In order to solve the steady numerical oscillations, (6-1) is replaced with the following equation as yn 1 yn t 1 f n 1 1 f n 2 (6-32) where is the damping ratio [82]. The discretized model extracted using (6-32) for system elements such as inductor is equivalent as an ideal inductor in parallel with a shunt resistor R 2L t . The trapezoidal rule with damping formulation adds some dissipation to the solution [82]. By varying from zero to one, the integration is changing from ordinary trapezoidal to Backward Euler. Figure 6-8: Discretized equivalent circuit of inductance: (a) Thevenin equivalent; and (b) Norton equivalent. 134 For instance, an equivalent discretized circuit of an inductor using trapezoidal integration as shown in Figure 6-9 is calculated as [81] R 2L t (6-33) eh t vt t 2L it t t (6-34) However, using the trapezoidal integration with damping for the same inductor results in [81] R 2L , t 1 eh t 1 2L vt t it t . 1 t 1 (6-35) (6-36) As it can be seen in (6-35) and (6-36), for the EMTP-type transient simulation programs wherein the discretization is implemented on the component level, each system component can be reformulated on the basis of the trapezoidal integration with damping. Although the trapezoidal integration with damping technique is very advantageous to solve steady numerical oscillation in the solution, most existing EMTP-type transient simulators are developed based on the ordinary trapezoidal integration. Therefore, it requires the network conductance matrix G to be updated in order to use the trapezoidal integration with damping for the solution. Hence, herein, a damping technique is used on the basis of 135 the trapezoidal integration with damping method in which the G matrix is not required to be changed or updated, and damping is implemented locally. 6.5.2 Localized Damping for Interfacing DI-PAVM In order to add dissipation to the solution, each component should be reformulated based on the trapezoidal integration with damping as it is presented in (6-35) and (6-36) for an inductor. However, using the reformulated components with damping in any of the existing EMTP-type transient simulation programs such as PSCAD/EMTDC, the network conductance matrix G is required to be changed. Hence, the reformulated components based on the trapezoidal integration with damping should be written in a suitable form. For simplicity, the procedure is explained on an inductor using (6-35) and (6-36). In order to avoid changes in the G matrix, (6-35) is approximated as (6-33), and the history term calculated in (6-35) can be written as eh t vt t 2L it t ehd t t (6-37) where ehd t 2 L vt t it t 1 t 1 (6-38) 136 Equation (6-38) is combined with the history term calculated in (6-34) using the ordinary trapezoidal integration plus one extra term, which is called as correction term. Therefore, as it is shown in Figure 6-9, in order to damp the oscillations, in each time-step of the solution, all the system elements are presented as a resistor and history voltage source, and the damping history term which is added as a voltage source ehd or current source ihd . Figure 6-9: Discretized equivalent circuit of lumped inductance with damping history term: (a) Thevenin equivalent; and (b) Northon equivalent. Using this damping technique in EMTP type programs, there will be a correction history matrix added to the nodal-analysis formulation as GVn I h I hd , (6-39) 137 where I hd is composed of damping history terms. Applying this damping technique to Thevenin equivalent-circuit diagram of DI-PAVM in abc variables shown in Figure 6-1, all the system element as shown in Figure 6-10 have one added voltage source for damping. These damping terms are calculated at each time-step in the converter AVM sub-system and added to the history terms in the simulation for damping of the oscillation. Figure 6-10: Thevenin equivalent-circuit diagram of the locally damped DI-PAVM in abc variables. 6.5.3 Case Study Here, the same study as in Section 6.2.1 is conducted on the system shown in Figure 1-1(a) using both the proposed parametric DI-PAVMs with the time-step t 2 ms , and damping 138 ratio 0.2 . As it is shown in Figure 6-11, the oscillation introduced in the dc voltage by the DI-PAVMs (especially with the collapsed dc side) is damped very well using the trapezoidal with localized damping. Moreover, as it is shown in Figure 6-6, the DI-PAVM with the snubber in the dc side may introduce an error or oscillation in the start-up for large time-steps and small value of the snubber resistance. However, by using the damping technique, it is possible to chose larger snubber resistance which reduces the error in the start-up. This reduction in the start-up error can be clearly seen in Figure 6-11. The trapezoidal rule with localized damping is advantageous over the conventional trapezoidal as it is not required to change or update the G matrix. In general, the simulation results using both damping techniques are the same in steady state. However, during the transient, due to difference in the G matrix, the predicted transient response of the system is slightly different using this two damping methods. This fact is depicted for the DI-PAVM with the collapsed dc side in Figure 6-12, wherein the simulation results are compared using these two damping methods. The study shown in Figure 6-11 demonstrates that the directly interfaced PAVMs, unlike the indirectly interfaced AVM [14] or the other AVMs developed in the state-space, can be used for system level studies with very large time-steps and with damped oscillations. 139 Figure 6-11: Dc and ac waveforms predicted by the models, with and without localized damping; t 2 ms . 140 Figure 6-12: Transient response of DI-PAVM with collapsed dc side as predicted by various models using time step t 2 ms , and conventional and localized damping. 6.6 Summary of Contributions In this chapter, we have investigated the problem of interfacing the AVMs with the external networks in the EMTP solution. As an outcome of this research, two discretized equivalent 141 circuits for direct interfacing of the parametric AVMs have been proposed for the first time. It has been demonstrated that the directly interfaced PAVMs can perform very well even at fairly large time-steps (~0.5 …1 ms). Moreover, for efficient interfacing in EMTP-type packages and removing the possible artificial numerical oscillations caused by the trapezoidal integration, the new DI-PAVM with local damping has been proposed. This new DI-PAVM model with damping is shown to be capable of producing fairly good/accurate results even at a much larger time-step (~2 …3 ms). This achievement also sets the stage for the future generation of the EMTP-type transient simulation programs, in which the user can potentially automatically replace the detailed switching models with their AVM equivalents, wherein it will be desirable for the system-level-studies. 142 Chapter 7: Conclusions and Future Work 7.1 Conclusions and Contributions This thesis is focused on dynamic average-value modeling of high power switching converters. Averaging of the switching details makes the AVMs computationally efficient and also continuous. Due to the importance of line-commutated converters in high power applications, the research conducted here is mainly focused on the development of a general parametric AVM of the line-commutated converters for various applications. The motivation behind this research has been described in Chapter 1. In Chapter 2, the parametric approach introduced in [27] for the state-variable-based simulation languages is extended to model the thyristor controlled line-commutated converters in the rectifier mode of operation. The contribution of this chapter addresses Objective 1 stated in Introduction of this thesis. The extended PAVM enables modeling of more complicated systems with closed-loop control such as rectifier side of HVDC system, wind turbines, and synchronous machine exciter. In this chapter, on the basis of the extended parametric approach, the new average-value model of machine/thyristorcontrolled-rectifier system is presented for two methods of generating thyristor firing pulses: (i) using converter terminal voltages, and (ii) using the machine rotor position. The resulting model is continuous and computationally efficient, and can be used for large143 signal time-domain studies as well as linearization for small-signal frequency-domain analyses. The proposed AVM is verified against the original switching model as well as analytical AVM in large-signal time-domain studies as well as small-signal frequencydomain transfer functions characteristics, and is shown to produce expected good results. In Chapter 3, based on the parametric approach and the PAVM introduced in Chapter 2, the thyristor controlled LCC model is reformulated for the inverter operation as was the focus of Objective 2. The voltage-source and current-source average-value modeling (VS-AVM and CS-AVM) formulations are proposed based on the well-posedness of the underlying state equations. It is shown that the proposed CS-AVM will have advantages for modeling the thyristor controlled LCC inverter, whereas a more conventional VS-AVM may not be convergent. The contributions of this chapter enable the average-value modeling of HVDC systems with bidirectional energy flow. Chapter 4 addresses Objective 3. Specifically, the PAVMs developed in Chapters 2 and 3 for rectifier and inverter modes, are extended to the 12-pulse converters. The dynamic AVM of the CIGRE HVDC benchmark system has been developed and demonstrated for the first time in state-variable-based simulation languages such as Matlab/Simulink as well as EMTP-type packages such as PSCAD/EMTDC. The accuracy of the developed AVMs is verified against the detailed simulation in large-signal time-domain transients including the dc reference current command change and a short circuit implemented on the dc 144 transmission line. It has been shown that by utilizing the developed PAVM, a significant gain can be archived in simulation time. All conventional AVMs only predict the fundamental component of the ac variables. In Chapter 5, a new parametric average-value model of diode rectifier system which includes the main harmonics (5th and 7th) in ac system has been proposed. The LCC is modeled on the basis of the parametric approach in which the nonlinear parametric functions relate the fundamental and harmonic components of the ac voltages and currents to the dc side variables. The introduced MRF-PAVM (aligned with Objective 4) enables to use the parametric AVM for the transients and power quality analysis, which has not been achieved. The developed MRF-PAVM can also be used by utility companies for feasibility studies to evaluate the impact of the LCC-equipment connections to the energy grid. In Chapter 6, two discretized parametric average-value models of the LCC are developed for the EMTP-type solution, as outlined in Objective 5. In the first one, the dc side is collapsed and the dc equivalent circuit is mapped into the ac equations. This approach is useful mostly in a case when the dc side is isolated from the EMTP external network. In the second approach, the AVM is interfaced with the dc system using a resistive snubber and injecting a compensation current connected in parallel with the snubber. The proposed models are interfaced directly with the external ac networks, which provide the simultaneous solution of the system variables. It is shown that the proposed models are numerically stable and accurate even for very large simulation time-steps such as 2 ms . 145 Moreover, a new methodology is developed to damp the artificial numerical oscillations caused by the trapezoidal integration without introducing changes or update in the overall network conductance G matrix. The modeling techniques and contributions in this thesis will be useful to many researchers and practicing engineers in the area of electric power and energy systems who are dealing with applications of power electronic components and modules as well as using modern digital simulation tools. The generalized parametric AVMs developed in this thesis can be easily added as modules to the libraries of different simulation packages such as state-variable-based and EMTP-type programs. 7.2 Future Work For more precise simulations and extending the AVMs to the power quality analysis and harmonic power flow calculations including at least several of significant (5th, 7th, 11th, etc.) harmonics has always been desirable. In this thesis, the contributions from a number of (significant) harmonics of interest are considered in the parametric AVM of the diode rectifier using multiple reference frame theory. However, in most LCC applications such as HVDC systems, the power is transferred bidirectional using thyristor switches. Therefore, one of the immediate directions for the future research would be to extend the multiple reference frame theory approach of Chapter 5 to the thyristor-controlled LCCs with bidirectional power flow and as HVDC systems. 146 The directly interfaced PAVMs proposed in this thesis for EMTP type solution have been developed and demonstrated for the diode rectifier systems. The extension of this approach to the thyristor-controlled LCCs operating in rectifier and inverter mode is therefore appears to be very feasible. The next logical direction would be to include the harmonics for the directly interfaced PAVMs of the LCCs with bi-directional power flow and as HVDC systems. Other HVDC technologies based on multi-level modular converters (MMC) are gaining wide acceptance and will be considered for developing the computationally efficient dynamic average models. Those and other research topics will be considered in the very near future by other graduate students in the Electric Power Energy Systems research group at UBC. 147 References [1] (1997). MicroTran Reference Manual (MicroTran Power System Analysis Corp.). [Online]. Available: http://www.microtran.com [2] (2007). Alternative Transients Programs (ATP-EMTP, ATP User Group). [Online]. Available: http://www.emtp.org [3] (2005). PSCAD/EMTDC (Ver. 4.0 On-Line Help Manitoba HVDC Research Centre and RTDS Technologies Inc. Winnipeg, MB, Canada). [4] (2011). Electromagnetic Transient Program (EMTP RV, Powersys Solutions, Inc.). [Online]. Available: http://www.emtp.com [5] (2003). Resistive Companion Modeling and Simulation for the Virtual Test Bed (VTB) Modeling Guide (Univ. South Carolina). [Online]. Available: http://vtb.ee.sc.edu [6] (2008). ACSLX, Advanced Continuous Simulation Language, User’s Guide (Ver. 2.4 The AEgis Technologies Group, Inc.). [Online]. Available: http://www.acslsim.com [7] (2008). EASY5 Engineering Software for the Design, Analysis and Simulation (MSC SimEnterprise, Inc.). [Online]. Available: http://www.mscsoftware.com 148 [8] (2008). EUROSTAG: Software for Simulation of Large Electric Power Systems (Tractebel Energy Engineering). [Online]. Available: http:// www.eurostag.be and www.tractebel-engineering.com [9] (2008). Simulink Dynamic System Simulation Software Users Manual (MathWorks Inc.). [Online]. Available: http://www.mathworks.com [10] (2006). SimPowerSystems: Model and Simulate Electrical Power Systems User’s Guide (The MathWorks Inc.). [Online]. Available: http://www.mathworks.com [11] (2008). Piecewise Linear Electrical Circuit Simulation (PLECS) User Manual (Version 1.4, Plexim GmbH). [Online]. Available: www.plexim.com [12] (2003). Automated State Model Generator (ASMG) Reference Manual, Version 2 (P C Krause & Associates Inc.). [Online]. Available: www.pcka.com [13] S. Chiniforoosh, J. Jatskevich, A. Yazdani, V. Sood, V. Dinavahi, J. A. Martinez, and A. Ramirez, “Definitions and applications of dynamic average models for analysis of power systems,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 2655-2669, October 2010. [14] S. Chiniforoosh, H. Atighechi, A. Davoodi, J. Jatskevich, A. Yazdani, S. Filizadeh, M. Saeedifard, J. A. Martinez, V. Sood, K. Strunz, J. Mahseredjian, V. Dinavahi, “Dynamic average modeling of front-end diode rectifier loads considering discontinuous 149 conduction mode and unbalanced operation,” IEEE Trans., Power Del., vol. 27, pp. 421429, Jan. 2012. [15] P. C. Krause, O. Wasynczuk, and S. D. Sudhoff, Analysis of electric machinery and drive systems, 2nd edition, IEEE Press, Piscataway, NJ, 2002. [16] H. A. Peterson and P. C. Krause, “A Direct- and quadrature-axis representation of a parallel ac and dc power system,” IEEE Trans. Power App. Syst., vol. PAS-85, no. 3, pp. 210-225, Mar. 1996. [17] P. C. Krause and T. A. Lipo, "Analysis and simplified representation of a rectifierinverter induction motor drive," IEEE Trans. Power App. Syst., vol. 88, no. 5, pp. 588596, May 1969 . [18] S. D. Sudhoff and O. Wasynczuk, "Analysis and average-value modeling of linecommutated converter-synchronous machine systems," IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 92-99, Mar. 1993. [19] S. D. Sudhoff, ”Waveform reconstruction from the average-value model of linecommutated converter-synchronous machine system," IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 408-410, Sep. 1993 . 150 [20] S. D. Sudhoff, K. A. Corzine, H. J. Hegner, and D. E. Delisle, "Transient and dynamic average-value modeling of synchronous machine fed load-commutated converters," IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 11, no. 3, pp. 508-514, Sep. 1996 . [21] J. T. Alt, S. D. Sudhoff, and B. E. Ladd, "Analysis and average-value modeling of an Inductorless synchronous machine load commutated converter system," IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 14, no. 1, pp. 37-43, Mar. 1999. [22] H. Zhu, “New multi-pulse diode rectifier average models for ac and dc power systems studies,” PhD Dissertation, ECE Dept., Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, 2005. [23] M. Shahnazari, A. Vahedi, "Improved dynamic average value modeling of brushless excitation system in all rectification modes," IET Electr. Power Appl., Vol. 4, Iss. 8, pp. 657–669, Sep. 2010. [24] I. Jadric, D. Borojevic, and M. Jadric, "A simplified model of a variable speed synchronous generator loaded with diode rectifier," in Proc. IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conf. (PESC) , 1997, pp. 497-502. [25] I. Jadric, D. Borojevic, and M. Jadric, "Modeling and control of a synchronous generator with an active dc load," IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 303311, Mar. 2000. 151 [26] H. Atighechi, S. Chiniforoosh, J. Jatskevich, “Approximate dynamic average-value model for controlled line-commutated converters,” in Proc. IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer Engineering (CCECE), 2011, pp. 966–970. [27] J. Jatskevich, S. D. Pekarek, and A. Davoudi, “Parametric average-value model of a synchronous machine-rectifier system,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 9-18, Mar. 2006. [28] J. Jatskevich, S. D. Pekarek, and A. Davoudi, “Fast procedure for constructing an accurate dynamic average-value model of synchronous machine-rectifier system,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 435-441, Jun. 2006. [29] S. Chiniforosh, A. Davoodi, and J. Jatskevich, “Averaged-circuit modeling of linecommutated rectifiers for transient simulation programs,” in Proc. IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems (ISCAS), 2010, pp. 2318-2321. [30] S. Chiniforosh, P. Alaeinovin, A. Davoodi, J. Jatskevich, P. Chapman, “Average-value modeling of automotive alternator-rectifier systems,” in Proc. IEEE Industrial Electronics Conference (IECON), 2008, pp. 2800-2805. [31] S. Chiniforosh, P. Alaeinovin, A. Davoodi, J. Jatskevich, P. Chapman, “Dynamic modeling of stand-alone micro-wind turbine generator systems for telecommunication power supply,” in Proc. IEEE International Telecommunications Energy Conference (INTELEC), 2008, pp. 1-6. 152 [32] S. Chiniforosh, J. Jatskevich, V. Dinavahi, R. Iravani, J. A. Martinez, A. Ramirez, “Dynamic average modeling of line-commutated converters for power systems applications,” in Proc. IEEE Power & Energy Society General Meeting (PES), 2009, pp. 18. [33] P. Norman, S. Galloway, G. Burt, and J. Timothy Alt, “Average-value diode rectifier modeling for aerospace applications,” in Proc. SAE Technical Paper, 2011. [34] P. Norman, J. Timothy Alt, and G. Burt, “Parametric Average-Value Converter Modeling for Aerospace Applications,” in Proc. SAE International, 2012, pp. 318-324. [35] C. E. Grund, T. H. Lee, S. R. Lightfoot, R. J. Piwko, R. V. Pohl, K. Mortensen, R. J. Newell, J. Reeve, and D. A. Woodford, “Functional model of two-terminal HVDC systems for transient and steady-state stability,” IEEE Trans. Power App. and Sys., vol. 103, pp. 1249–1255, Jun. 1984. [36] Y. X. Ni, “A simplified two-terminal HVDC model and its use in direct transient stability assessment,” IEEE Trans. Power Sys., vol. 2, pp. 1006–1012, Nov. 1987. [37] B. K. Johnson, “HVDC models used in stability studies”, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 4, pp. 1153–1163, Apr. 1989. 153 [38] L. Hu, and R. Yacamini, “Calculation of harmonics and interharmonics in HVDC schemes with low dc side impedance,” IEEE Trans. Generation, Transmission and Distribution, vol. 140, pp. 469–476, Nov. 1993. [39] L. Hu, “Sequence impedance and equivalent circuit of HVDC system,” IEEE Trans. Power Sys., vol. 13, pp. 354–360, May 1998. [40] R. Kumar, and T. Leibfried, “Analytical modeling of HVDC transmission system converter using Matlab/Simulink,” in Proc. IEEE Industrial and Commercial Power Systems Technical Conference (ICPST), 2005, pp. 140-146. [41] R. M. Brandt, U. D. Annakkage, D. P. Brandt, and N. Kshatriya, “Validation of a two-time step HVDC transient stability simulation model including detailed HVDC controls and dc line L/R dynamics,” in Proc. IEEE Power Engineering Society General Meeting, 2006, pp. 1-6. [42] H. Zhou, G. Yang, and J. Wang, “Modeling, analysis, and control for the rectifier of hybrid HVDC systems for DFIG-based wind farms,” IEEE Trans. Energy Conv., vol. 26, pp. 340–353, Mar. 2011. [43] D. Jovcic, N. Pahalawaththa, and M. Zavahir, “Analytical modeling of HVDC-HVAC systems,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 14, pp. 506–511, Apr. 1999. 154 [44] C. Osauskas, and A. Wood, “Small-signal dynamic modeling of HVDC systems,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 18, pp. 220–225, Jan. 2003. [45] R. K Pandey, “Stability analysis of ac/dc system with multiRate discrete-time HVDC converter model,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 23, pp. 311–318, Jan. 2008. [46] P. F. Toledo, L. Angquist, and H. P. Nee, “Frequency domain model of an HVDC link with a line-commutated current-source converter. Part I: Fixed overlap,” IET Trans. Generation, Transmission and Distribution, vol. 3, pp. 757–770, Aug. 2009. [47] X. Yang, and C. Chen, “HVDC dynamic modelling for small signal analysis,” IEE Trans. Generation, Transmission and Distribution, vol. 151, pp. 740–746, Nov. 2004. [48] “Guidance notes on control of harmonics in electrical power system,” in Proc. American Bureau of Shipping, May 2006. [49] J. T. Alt, “Average value modeling of distorted wave shape distribution,” Ph.D. dissertation, Dept. Elect. And Comp. Eng., Purdue University., West Lafayette, Indiana, 2001. [50] S. Chiniforoosh. H. Atighechi, J. Jatskevich, “Direct interfacing of dynamic average models of line-commutated rectifier circuits in nodal analysis EMTP-type solution”, Submitted to IEEE Trans on Circuits and Systems-I. 155 [51] Taskforce on Harmonics Modeling and Simulation, “Modeling and Simulation of the Propagation of Harmonics in Electric Power Networks Part I: Concept, Models and Simulation Techniques,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 452-465, Jan. 1996. [52] H. W. Dommel, A. Yan, and W. Shi, “Harmonics from transformer saturation,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 209-215, Jan. 1996. [53] W. Xu, J. E. Drakos, Y. Mansour, and A. Chang, “A three-phase converter model for harmonic analysis of HVDC systems,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 17241731, July 1994. [54] W. Xu, J. R. Marti, and H. W. Dommel, “A multiphase harmonic loadflow solution technique,” IEEE Trans. Power Sys., vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 174-182, Feb. 1991. [55] V. Sharma, R. J. Fleming, and L. Niekamp, “An iterative approach for analysis of harmonic penetration in power transmission network,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 6, no. 4, pp. 1698-1706, Oct. 1991. [56] K. L. Lian, B. K. Perkins, and P. W. Lehn, “ Harmonic analysis of a three-phase diode bridge rectifier based on sampled-data model,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 23, no. 2, pp. 1088-1096, Apr. 2008. [57] S. G. Jalali, R. H. Lasseter, “Harmonic interaction of power system with static switching systems,” in Proc. IEEE Power Electronics Specialist (PES), 1991, pp. 330–337. 156 [58] VJ. G. Mayordomo, L. F. Beites, R. Asensi, F. Orzaez, M. Izzeddine, and L. Zabala, “A contribution for modeling controlled and uncontrolled ac/dc converters in harmonic power flows,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 1501-1508, Oct. 1998. [59] Y. Sun, G. Zhang, W. Xu, and J. G. Mayordomo, “A harmonically coupled admittance matrix model for ac/dc converters,” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 22, no. 4, pp. 15741582, Nov. 2007. [60] J. Sun, and K. J. Karimi, “Small-signal input impedance modeling of line-frequency rectifiers,” IEEE Trans. Aeorospace and Electronic Sys., vol. 44, no. 4, pp. 1489-1497, Oct. 2008. [61] Z. Bing, K. J. Karimi, and J. Sun, “Input impedance modeling of line-commutated rectifiers,” IEEE Trans. Power Electronics, vol. 24, no. 10, pp. 2338-2346, Oct. 2009. [62] J. Sun, Z. Bing, and K. J. Karimi, “Input impedance modeling of multipulse rectifiers by harmonic linearization,” IEEE Trans. Power Electronics, vol. 24, no. 12, pp. 2812-2820, Dec. 2009. [63] D.A. Woodford, A.M. Gole, and R.W. Menzies, “Digital simulation of dc links and ac machines,” IEEE Trans. Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 102, no. 6, pp. 1616-1623, Jun. 1983. 157 [64] A.M. Gole, R.W. Menzies, H.M. Turanli, and D.A. Woodford, “Improved interfacing of electrical machine models to electromagnetic transients programs,” IEEE Trans. Power App. and Sys., vol. 103, no. 9, pp. 2446–2451, Sep. 1984. [65] L. Wang, J. Jatskevich, V. Dinavahi, H. W. Dommel, J. A. Martinez, K. Strunz, M. Rioual, G. W. Chang, R. Iravani, “Methods of interfacing rotating machine models in transient simulation programs,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 891-903, Apr. 2010. [66] R. C. Schaefer, “Application of static excitation systems for rotating exciter replacement,” in Proc. IEEE Pulp and Paper Industry Technical Conference (PPITC), 1991, pp. 330-337. [67] C. A. Platero, F. Blazquez, P. Frias, M. Pardo, “New on-line rotor ground fault location method for synchronous machines with static excitation,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 572-580, Jun. 2011. [68] C. K. Kim, B. M. Yang, B. E. Kho, G. J. Jeong, "Performance analysis for the modified excitation system of synchronous machine connected to HVDC system," in Proc. IEEE Industrial Electronics Society Conference (IECON), 2002, pp. 816-821. [69] S. D. Sudhoff, S. F. Glover, P. T. Lamm, D. H. Schmucker, D. E. Delisle, and S. P. Karatsinides, "Admittance space stability analysis of power electronic systems," IEEE Trans. Aerosp. Electron. Sys., vol. 36, no. 3, pp.965 -973, Jul. 2000. 158 [70] B. R. Pelly, Thyristor phase-controlled converters and cycloconverters; operation, control, and performance, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1971. [71] S. D. Pekarek, E. A. Walters, “An accurate method of neglecting dynamic saliency of synchronous machine in power electronic based systems,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 14, no. 4, pp. 1177-1183, Dec. 1999. [72] M. Chapariha, L. Wang, J. Jatskevich, H. W. Dommel, S. D. Pekarek, “Constantparameter R-L-branch equivalent circuit for interfacing ac machine models in statevariable-based simulation packages,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 27, no. 3, pp. 634-645, Sep. 2012. [73] J. Jatskevich, S. D. Pekarek, “Numerical validation of parametric average-value modeling of synchronous machine-rectifier systems for variable frequency operation,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 342-344, Mar. 2006. [74] J. D. Ainsworth, “Proposed benchmark model for study of HVDC controls by simulator or digital computer,” CIGRE SC-14 Colloq. HVDC with Weak AC Systems, Maidstone, U.K., Sep. 1985. [75] M. O. Faruque, Y. Zhang, and V. Dinavahi, “Detailed modeling of CIGRE HVDC benchmark system using PSCAD/EMTDC and PSB/SIMULINK”, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 21, pp. 378–387, Jan. 2006. 159 [76] G. Seguier, Power electronic converters, 2nd Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1986. [77] N. Mohan, T. M. Undeland, W. P. Robbins, Power electronics, 3rd Edition, Wiley and Sons, Inc, 2003. [78] P. C. Krause, “Method of multiple reference frames applied to the analysis of symmetrical induction machinery,” IEEE Trans. Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. 87, no. 1, pp. 218–227, Jan. 1968. [79] A. B. Nassif, W. Xu, and W. Freitas, “An investigation on the selection of filter topologies for passive filter applications”, IEEE Trans. Power del., vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 1710-1718, July 2009. [80] IEEE Recommended Practices and Requirements for Harmonic Control in Electrical Power Systems, IEEE Std. 519-1992, Apr. 1993. [81] H. W. Dommel, EMTP theory book, MicroTran Power System Analysis Corp., Vancouver, BC, Canada, 1992. [82] F. L. Alvarado, R. H. Lasseter, J. J. Sanchez, “Testing of trapezoidal integration with damping for the solution of power transient problems”, IEEE Trans. Power App. and Sys., vol. 102, no. 12, pp. 3783–3790, Dec. 1983. 160 [83] V. Brandwajn, “Damping of numerical noise in the EMTP solution,” EMTP Newsletter, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 10–19, Feb. 1982. [84] J. R. Marti, J. Lin, “Suppression of numerical oscillations in the EMTP,” IEEE Trans. Power Sys., vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 739–747, May. 1989. [85] J. Lin , J. R. Marti, “Implementation of the CDA procedure in the EMTP” , IEEE Trans. Power Sys., vol. 5, no. 2, pp. 394–402, May. 1990. [86] K. Strunz, “Flexible numerical integration for efficient representation of switching in real time electromagnetic transients simulation”, IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 1276–1283, July. 2004. 161 Appendices Appendix A: Synchronous Machine/Rectifier System Synchronous machine parameters: US Electrical Motors, 5 HP, 230Volt, 215T Frame, 1800 rpm, rated field current 1.05A, custom-made for university lab. b 2 60 rad/s rs 0.382 P 4 (four poles) xls 0.4222 xmq 9.3871 xmd 14.8158 1 5.07 rkq 2 1.3195 xlkq 2 1.06 rkq 2 1.3195 xlkq 3 0.447 rkq 3 9.8772 xlkq 1 140 rkd 2 1.19 rkd 1 3.7209 xlkd 2 1.8510 xlkd 3 1.58 rkd 3 1.7002 xlkd r fd 0.112 0.5768 xlfd stator-to-field turns ratio N s N fd 0.0269 Dc link filter parameters: L f 1.19 mH ; r f 0.32 ; C f 2.28F 162 PI controller parameters: 2 102 ; K p 10; Ki 100; max 90; min 0 The averaging window is 1 6 of the line frequency. 163 Appendix B: Well-Posedness Study System parameters: L f 0 ( mH ), R f 0.32 ( ), rC 0.1 . eas v m cos(t ) , e 2 60rad / s , vm 391.4 ( V ), 164 Appendix C: CS-Formulation Verification System parameters: e 2 60rad / s , vm 175.6 (kV), LC 24 (mH), rC 0.1 , LLine 0.5968 (H), R Line 0.32 ( ), C Line 26 (μF). 165 Appendix D: CIGRE HVDC System CIGRE HVDC Benchmark System Parameters: Table A. 1: CIGRE HVDC system parameters used for simulation studies System parameters Ac voltage base Transf. tap (HV side) Voltage source Nominal dc voltage Nominal dc current Transformer impedance System frequency Minimum angle Rectifier Inverter 345 kV 230 kV 1.01 pu 0.989 pu 1.08822.18 0.935 23.14 500 kV 500 kV 2 kA 2 kA 0.18 pu 0.18 pu 50 Hz 50 Hz 15 15 Controller Parameters: 1 2 3 0.0003 , k 0.01, a 106 , b 0.0101, k P1 1.0989 , k I1 100.63 , k P 2 0.63 , k I 2 65.61, k P 3 0.7506 , k I 3 20 , R max 80 , Imin 100 , Imax 150 . 166 Appendix E: Harmonic Analysis Testing system parameters: Vline 480 V , f e 60 Hz , rC 0.2 , LC 10 mH , rdc 0.5 , Ldc 1.33 mH , C f 500 F . 167 Appendix F: Discretized PAVM Parameters of the front-end rectifier example system: Vrms 208 V , f e 60 Hz , rth rac 0.05 , Lth 45 H , Lac 50 H , rdc 0.5 , Ldc 1.33 mH . 168
- Library Home /
- Search Collections /
- Open Collections /
- Browse Collections /
- UBC Theses and Dissertations /
- Dynamic average-value model of high power ac-dc converters...
Open Collections
UBC Theses and Dissertations
Featured Collection
UBC Theses and Dissertations
Dynamic average-value model of high power ac-dc converters and HVDC systems Atighechi, Hamid 2013
pdf
Page Metadata
Item Metadata
Title | Dynamic average-value model of high power ac-dc converters and HVDC systems |
Creator |
Atighechi, Hamid |
Publisher | University of British Columbia |
Date Issued | 2013 |
Description | High power switching converters such as line-commutated converters (LCC) and high voltage direct current (HVDC) systems are widely used in modern energy grids for interconnection of industrial loads, large motor drives, as well as electronically-interfaced renewable/alternative/distributed energy resources (DER) and storage systems. For design and analysis of systems with power-electronic-based DERs and loads, accurate and efficient computer models are essential. This thesis is focused on dynamic average-value models (AVM) that neglect switching of converter circuits and are established by averaging the variables (currents and voltages) over a prototypical switching interval. The AVMs are continuous (free of switching), allow using larger integration time steps, and typically run much faster than the conventional detailed switching models, which makes them particularly useful for the system-level studies. This thesis considers the parametric AVM framework, and extends this approach to the thyristor-controlled LCCs operating in inverter mode with current source or voltage source control. The proposed modeling methodology is demonstrated on various topologies including the HVDC CIGRE benchmark system. The research is further extended to incorporate the ac side harmonics into the AVM using the multiple reference frame theory. Traditionally, the AVMs are developed using state-variable-based approach. This thesis also presents a new parametric AVM for direct interfacing in nodal-analysis-based electromagnetic transient programs (EMTP), e.g., PSCAD/EMTDC, EMTP-RV, and MicroTran. It is expected that the proposed models and interfacing approaches will find their application in widely used transient simulation tools and will be appreciated by many researchers and practicing engineers worldwide. |
Genre |
Thesis/Dissertation |
Type |
Text |
Language | eng |
Date Available | 2013-06-21 |
Provider | Vancouver : University of British Columbia Library |
Rights | Attribution 3.0 Unported |
DOI | 10.14288/1.0073903 |
URI | http://hdl.handle.net/2429/44578 |
Degree |
Doctor of Philosophy - PhD |
Program |
Electrical and Computer Engineering |
Affiliation |
Applied Science, Faculty of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Department of |
Degree Grantor | University of British Columbia |
Graduation Date | 2013-11 |
Campus |
UBCV |
Scholarly Level | Graduate |
Rights URI | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ |
Aggregated Source Repository | DSpace |
Download
- Media
- 24-ubc_2013_fall_atighechii_hamid.pdf [ 5.07MB ]
- Metadata
- JSON: 24-1.0073903.json
- JSON-LD: 24-1.0073903-ld.json
- RDF/XML (Pretty): 24-1.0073903-rdf.xml
- RDF/JSON: 24-1.0073903-rdf.json
- Turtle: 24-1.0073903-turtle.txt
- N-Triples: 24-1.0073903-rdf-ntriples.txt
- Original Record: 24-1.0073903-source.json
- Full Text
- 24-1.0073903-fulltext.txt
- Citation
- 24-1.0073903.ris
Full Text
Cite
Citation Scheme:
Usage Statistics
Share
Embed
Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML
of your page to embed this item in your website.
<div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
<script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
src="{[{embed.src}]}"
data-item="{[{embed.item}]}"
data-collection="{[{embed.collection}]}"
data-metadata="{[{embed.showMetadata}]}"
data-width="{[{embed.width}]}"
async >
</script>
</div>
Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard.
To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:
http://iiif.library.ubc.ca/presentation/dsp.24.1-0073903/manifest