Open Collections

UBC Graduate Research

Open Space Programming & Use: A comparison of two Vancouver neighbourhood parks Yufe, Anita; Vogt, Megan 2009-12

Your browser doesn't seem to have a PDF viewer, please download the PDF to view this item.

Notice for Google Chrome users:
If you are having trouble viewing or searching the PDF with Google Chrome, please download it here instead.

Item Metadata


66428-yufe_vogt.pdf [ 7.95MB ]
JSON: 66428-1.0108278.json
JSON-LD: 66428-1.0108278-ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 66428-1.0108278-rdf.xml
RDF/JSON: 66428-1.0108278-rdf.json
Turtle: 66428-1.0108278-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 66428-1.0108278-rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 66428-1.0108278-source.json
Full Text

Full Text

         SEEDS Student Reports    1 UBC Social, Ecological Economic Development Studies (SEEDS) Student Reports             Open Space Programming & Use: A comparison of two Vancouver neighbourhood parks Anita Yufe Megan Vogt University of British Columbia LARC 543 December 2009          Disclaimer: “UBC SEEDS provides students with the opportunity to share the findings of their studies, as well as their opinions, conclusions and recommendations with the UBC community. The reader should bear in mind that this is a student project/report and is not an official document of UBC. Furthermore readers should bear in mind that these reports may not reflect the current status of activities at UBC. We urge you to contact the research persons mentioned in a report or the SEEDS Coordinator about the current status of the subject matter of a project/report.” Open Space Programming & Use: a comparison of two Vancouver neighbourhood parks DOCUMENT FOR SUBMISSION LARC 543-001: Environment and Urban Form Anita Yufe Megan Vogt  Contents Project Definition Open Space in Vancouver (west) The Role of Neighbourhood Parks Neighbourhood Urban Form Private & Public Open Space McBride Park & Jim Taylor Park Programming 	 Circulation Landscaping & Maintenance Use Comparisons Conclusions  Project Definition Agenda Social sustainability based on how open space programming influences intensity and quality of use Framework The relationship between open space programming and use as an indicator of the quality of urban space form and function Indicators Spatial analysis and observation of neighbourhood parks GOAL: Interactions Open space programs that promote interaction and neighbourhood building?  Public Open Space in Vancouver (west side) consistent urban open spaces across Vancouver’s west side• significant ‘natural’ open space - Pacific Spirit Park• major regional parks - Pacific Spirit Park, Queen Elizabeth Park• urban open space - sports fields, neighbourhood parks, schools, golf • courses, beaches Open space - park Open space - natural Pacific Spirit Park Queen Elizabeth Park Kits Beach Jericho University Golf         Course Musqueam Glof Course McBride Park Jim Taylor Park  The Role of Neighbourhood Parks Location:  within 800m of service population (+/- 5,000 people) Size:   2-4 ha (0.5 to 1ha/1,000 population) Programming: both active and passive recreation activities • geared for a variety of age and user groups• create a sense of place using unique characteristics of site and • neighbourhood typically includes multipurpose sports fields, playground, circula-• tion system for walking with seating, and general open space “serve	as	the	recreational	and	social	focus	of	the	neighborhood.”      (National Recreation & Park Association 1995) Neighbourhood Urban Form - Kitsilano 6700 residents • 90 hectares / 56 blocks (~73 people/ha)• 3 hectares of public park (3.3% of area)• low density, family-oriented• ‘traditional’ Vancouver grid premised upon 400m walking circles• Open space - park Mixed use commercial Residential - detached Residential - attached Residential - stacked Civic (Bayview Elementary                School) Alleys Local streets Collector Streets Arterial Streets 4th Avenue Broadway Street McBride Park A lm a St re et Neighbourhood Urban Form - Hawthorn Place 1500 residents • ~15 hectares / ~9 blocks (~100 people/ha)• 4.12 hectares of public park (27.5% of area)• medium density, family-oriented• University Neighbourhood Association• responds to the formal structure of the campus (Beaux Arts +Forest + Contemporary • landscape typologies) Thunderbird Blvd W es t M al l Ea st  M al l Jim Taylor Park M ai n M al l Open space - park Residential - attached Residential - stacked Civic (UBC buildings/function) Local streets Collector Streets  Private vs. Public Open Space - Kitsilano and Hawthorn Place Kitsilano extensive private space • neighbourhood parks provide significant • public open space some blocks have minimal public realm• alleys are under-used open space• Public Quasi-public Private Hawthorn Place private space largely patios or heavily land-• scaped buffers extensive public space• quasi or questionably public space creates • ambiguity throughout the open space realm 8% 30% 4% 10% 45% 16% McBride Park W at er lo o St re et McBride Park -	Kitsilano	-	a	‘traditional’	neighbourhood	park 1.71 ha (0.26ha/1,000 people) Origins 1911 donation from Provincial Government, named for premier Richard McBride• WWI war garden (vegetables)• Description two blocks on either side of Waterloo Street• one large open sports field and the other with a playground and tennis courts • surrounded by mature trees; established street trees border the entire park failed 2006 bid to close Waterloo to cars• 4th Avenue W at er lo o St re et Jim Taylor Park -	Hawthorn	Place	-	a	new	neighbourhood	park 0.5 hectares (+ approx. 1.0 additional pocket park hectares)(~1ha/1,000 people) Origins part of Hawthorn Place neighbourhood development (2001-2007)• Description intersected by main north-south axis of the UBC campus• public open space adjacent to local community centre and coffee shop• centrally located within the neighbourhood• Programming McBride Park field house - washrooms, caretaker’s cottage• soccer fields (x1) / softball fields (x2)• playground (x1)• tennis courts (x4)• General open space (unirrigated grass) Field House (washrooms) Multi-use sports field Tennis Courts Playground Jim Taylor Park active and passive spaces• strong connection to coffee shop and community centre, with welcoming plaza• playgrounds and checkerboard gathering space for play • opportunities for community events• seating encourages social gathering and/or personal reflection• General open space (irrigated grass) Community Centre Plaza Playground Circulation McBride Park peripheral circulation• minimal defined circulation within• Grass Circulation Routes Bus Stops Jim Taylor Park responds to the campus grid with paths that connect to the campus main axis• curvy secondary paths allow experiential interest for the user• paths contrast grid, have places for rest and allow for views into the park• circulation routes feel very public; rest areas feel more private• pedestrian oriented routes support biking, bike racks provided• adjacent collector street (Thunderbird Blvd) medium intensity slow traffic equals • safety for children and people Grass Circulation Routes Bus Stops Landscaping & Maintenance McBride Park Landscaping Elements mature street & interior trees - create residential feel, establish a canopy• Berberis hedge - separates sports field from 4th Avenue traffic• grass • highly maintained sports field - irrigation system, frequently mowed low maintenance grass on west side - no irrigation, rarely mowed lack of shrubs increase safety, reduce hiding places & maintenance• Maintenance high maintenance sports grass; everything else very low maintenance• Grass - unirrigated Grass - irrigated Hedge Street trees Interior trees Impervious surfaces Jim Taylor Park nice planting palette frames circulation and edges of the park• sense of enclosure and protection• shrubs intended to protect the bioswale may need more consideration• mature trees along central axis give it a strong sense of place and identity• SCALE 1 : 2,000 050 50 100 150 METERS N Grass - unirrigated Grass - irrigated Hedge Street trees Interior trees Impervious surfaces Use McBride Park Saturday October 31st, 2009 Weather: clear, cold Use: 3 individuals at playground• dog walkers using open space on west side• no organized activity on the sports field• runners and walkers on the sidewalk perimeters• Jim Taylor Park Saturday October 31st, 2009 Weather: clear, cold Use:  50+ parents and children celebrate Hallowe’en at Commu-• nity Centre, many dressed in costumes gatherings occurred around building entrance and        • playground children play in dry watercourse, fountain and run on grass• 0-5 6-10 11-25 26-50 51-100 101+ Saturday November 14th, 2009 Weather: Overcast but dry Use: frequent organized sport and recreational activities • children’s soccer games x6 = 100+ parents, children and spectators•  smaller children playing at the park• Use McBride Park Saturday November 14, 2009 Weather: overcast, dry and then spitting Use: ‘typical’ quiet day• coffee shop closed for renovations reflect lack of intensity and use• individual parents with children out for a walk, used playground but left • due to rain 5+ people moving by on the sidewalks and main mall axis• 0-5 6-10 11-25 26-50 51-100 101+ Jim Taylor Park The multi-use sports field is an important community feature for orga-• nized events to activate the space sports field most active on weekends in the neighbourhood, regardless • of the weather informal uses mainly around the edges and variety of programmed • spaces Use	Patterns McBride Park community centre and coffee shop programming significant for Haw-• thorn Place’s open space Main Mall axis is an important circulation route and populates the park • with passersby the secondary pocket parks are not as well used, perhaps because of • ambiguity of publicness the central grassy area is not as activated as McBride Park’s grass• 0-5 6-10 11-25 26-50 51-100 101+ Jim Taylor Park Landscaping & Maintenance high levels of maintenance, landscaping, and irrigated grasses are not directly correlated • with high levels of use shrubs define edges• provide aesthetics and visual interest• importance of trees• active vs passive• organized activities animate space, encourage community involvement and interaction,   • especially when ritualized and expected designation of active and passive play for different age groups• multiuse grass & programming should provide for a variety of types of recreation, for sport • or community based activities Circulation meandering circulation systems define destination rather than grass used for circulation• open edges help break down barriers to entrance• strong central axis pulls people through the park• Jim Taylor park is more interesting, diverse• highly connective, helps to emphasize pedestrian movement• Key Comparisons Programming Conclusions The	role	of	neighbourhood	parks? Size Proximity Programming Circulation Landscaping/Maintenance Use McBride Park Jim Taylor Park Interactions	&	neighbourhood	building? B A A A A A+ A+ A B A+ A+? A? Hawthorn Place has extensive public open space• It is set centrally within the neighbourhood• Programming limits organized recreation within the community• Extensive circulation and strong connectivity• High levels of maintenance... does it improve use? sustainable?• good informal use; could it be better used evenings/weekends?• McBride Park currently holds more day-to-day place in the community than Jim Taylor Park • based on the ritualized variety of organized activities    Jim Taylor Park achieves this in terms of social gathering, but could improve    in terms of recreational activities, other than/includ ing sports Old Barn Community Centre hold events that spill out into the park, creating social interaction• Jim Taylor Park has much higher levels of landscape maintenance and aesthetic interest than • McBride Park, however it is not better used Circulation in Jim Taylor park is more diverse and interesting but remains highly connective and • helps to emphasize pedestrian movement Ambiguity between public and private space can lead to under-used open space ‘dead-zones’ • where people may feel uncomfortable


Citation Scheme:


Citations by CSL (citeproc-js)

Usage Statistics



Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML of your page to embed this item in your website.
                            <div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
                            <script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
                            async >
IIIF logo Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard. To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:


Related Items