UBC Faculty Research and Publications

The Health Impacts of Rail Transit Investment : Synthesis of Evidence and Methodologies to Date Frank, Lawrence D.; Hong, Andy Apr 26, 2018

Your browser doesn't seem to have a PDF viewer, please download the PDF to view this item.

Item Metadata

Download

Media
52383-Frank_Lawrence_et_al_Health_impacts.pdf [ 309.49kB ]
Metadata
JSON: 52383-1.0368618.json
JSON-LD: 52383-1.0368618-ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 52383-1.0368618-rdf.xml
RDF/JSON: 52383-1.0368618-rdf.json
Turtle: 52383-1.0368618-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 52383-1.0368618-rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 52383-1.0368618-source.json
Full Text
52383-1.0368618-fulltext.txt
Citation
52383-1.0368618.ris

Full Text

ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:*'+",'	%,!0)*,'%*7/*&*&#@*7&1	'&(*!$EI4ECDK95&0(*,(&$'*+* *+/+'&.&!&, '*%''-+*'-(!+-++!'&+(*,'$**(*'",4-&1, &'-.*'+,$	$, -, '*!,14!,1'&'-.*4&*&+!&#4,''&-,$!,*,-**.!/'&, *+-$,+&%, '+-+!&(*.!'-++,-!+',  $, !%(,+'!0-!/1,*&+!,!&.+,%&,+7 !+.*1,!%$1*.!//++,!%-$,1, !$$&&!-%!&*'/10,&+!'&>?7 &'%($,4, /!$$*-&+,</+,, *'- , *'&'-.*&0(&+'&&0!+,!&*!$+1+,%,', +,4/ !$'&&,!&, &!.*+!,1'*!,!+ '$-%!,', /+,7&+-(('*,', !&.+,%&,4&!$$.*!+4 &!&,*+4!#*-*4&1	'&4!'$*'2<$*'4&/*&*&#>, (*'",8+*!&!($&.+,!,'*?'%($,*.!/', -+$,+'*!$!&.+,%&,'& $, &(*'.!, !*$!,*,-**.!/&0-,!.+-%%*1,', 0(*,(&$!+,+(*!'*,', '-+*'-(%,!&7 (&$!+,+/* '+&-+, 1 .'**-**&,$1'&-,!&(*<('+,++++%&,',  $, !%(,+'*!$!&.+,%&,7+* (*'-1, +(&$!+,+/+!&$-!&, $!,*,-**.!/7'*-$$$!+,'(&$!+,+4($+**,'((&!07*7	'&&*7*&# .'&-,(*<('+,*!$+,-!+!&, 7 %!&(-*('+', !+(&$/+,'!&,!1'%%'&, %+&(*+(,!.+%'&, +#1*+* *+&,'!&*+, '.*$$-&*+,&!&'/1+,'.&, +,,', (*,!!&&* I, 4ECDK4DE*+* *+*'%*'++'*, %*!/**'- ,,', *,''*%&0(*,(&$'-+*'-('&, -+$*$,!'&+ !(,/&*!$,*&+!,!&.+,%&,4 $, 4&', **$,,'(!+7!&!&+', (&$!+-++!'&**'-(!&,', *+,!'&+6>? ,,'+,-15>? ','+,-15&4>?	'/,'+,-17 !+-++!'&!&, !*+,+,!'&!+!.!!&,'+-",+*$,,','(!4&+-",+*$,,'(+&'(('*,-&!,!+!&*+* %, ''$'17&,*%+','(!+4, %!&, %+/*6 $, 4)-!,14&/,*&+('*,,!'&, &'$'14&'&'%!.$'(%&,7 %!&(+&'(('*,-&!,!+!&,!!/*!&*+''<!&.+,%&,+4'<0('+-*+4&'&,*'$*'-(+$,!'&7&, +'&+,!'&4, %!&, %+/*.-$&*$('(-$,!'&+>( 1+!$&'&'%!?4+!+,,'+,-1('(-$,!'&+>'%%-,*+&**-+*+?4&('(-$,!'&+/ '&(*'.!, %'+,!&+! ,> '!*!*+&+%$$-+!&++'/&*+*'-&,*&+!,?7!&$$14!&, , !*+,!'&4, %!&, %+/*!&**,'**-!,%&,%, ''$'14,'$$,!'&4+,-1+!&4&,*&+*!$!,1'!&!&+7 +!&!&+*,''$+,*&0!+,!&$!,*,-**.!/,' $(-!-,-**+* 7ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:.$-,!& .!'-*$&0('+-*<+ $, !%(,+',*&+!,!&.+,%&,7!&*$&*'%'&+-$,!&!$!,,, !+(&$/!, +-(('*,*'%*7*&#8+,%,, 	$, &'%%-&!,1+!&7*7*&#(*(*, +,*-,-*4!&+,*-,!'&+4&+*!(,>+((&!0D?'*, !+!+-++!'&&+&,!,,', (&$!+,+&, !$!,,'*(*!'*,', %,!&7 !+%%'(*'.!+, +,*-,-*'*, !+*('*,7 +++!'&/+'&-,.!*,-$$1-+!&'',!&4/<+'&*&!&,''$7((&!0E!+, ('/*('!&,+$!+-+,''&.1, *+-$,+*'%, *.!/&((&!0F!+, $!+,'0(*,&$%*+7 *%!&*', !+*('*,!+!.!!&,'+,!'&+6>D? ,,'+,-15>E? ','+,-15&4>F?	'/,''*%, ''$'!$((*' +,'+,-1!& $, !%(,+'!0-!/1,*&+!,!&.+,%&,7 +,!'&!+'*&!21+,,!&, -!!&)-+,!'&+4, %!&, %+*/&'*$$', )-+,!'&+4'$$'/1&0($'*,!'&'!&!.!-$, %+7!&$$14, *('*,'&$-+/!, +-%%*1&$'+!&*%*#+7:57	 !*+,!+-++!'&+,!'&/+$1, '$$'/!&)-+,!'&+6>D?  ,&/,'(!+' .!'*$&;'*0('+-*<+!%(,+'*!$+ '-$'-+'&!&-('%!&+,-!+3 !+%1!&$-,*&+('*,,!'&!&*+,*-,-*&+*.!+4, &'$'!+4% &!+%+4'* $, '-,'%+7>E?  **, !+,'&,&,(+4+!&,!!&+4&%*!&'(('*,-&!,!+!&*,, *'- &/,*&+('*,,!'&+*.!+4, &'$'14&.&+!&,'$$,!'&%, '+3 %!&,'(!$, %+/*6 $, 4)-!,14&, (+1 '$'1'*!*+ !(7'&*1,'(!+/*!+-++!&**,'&/,*&+('*,,!'&, &'$'!+4&'&'%!.$'(%&,7'%', %!&+!&,!!(+&'(('*,-&!,!+!&$-%'*-*,$1,+!&'-,, !%(,+''<!&.+,%&,+&'<0('+-*+4+/$$+*-!&!+/!, '&,*'$*'-(+7 :595		$$(&$!+,+/*!&,*+,!&-&*+,&!&, -+$!%(,',*&+!,'&( 1+!$&%&,$ $, '-,'%+7	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	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:D7 	'/&/%*0!+,!&((*' +,'%+-*!&*!'&$,*&+!,+1+,%++!!$!,1&$!&#, %,'!&!.!-$<$.$!&,*.&,!'&+,-!+3E7 	'/'+, ,*&+!,!&.+,%&,-&*!&.+,!,!'&!%(,++,''(('*,-&!,!+'*(,!..*+-+ '!*!*+3F7 '/ ,0,&,*!0-!/1,*&+!,!&.+,%&,+-+!&!+($%&,'$'/*!&'%('(-$,!'&+& '/&, !+!+($%&,+(,!$$1%+-*&,*#'.*,!%3G7 	'/'(',&,!$ &+!&!*)-$!,1-,',*&+!,!&.+,%&,!&$-&$'/*!&'%('(-$,!'&+/ '*%'*$!#$1,'$!.$'&-+1+,*,+&$+'&%'*!&,!.,*.$'*-,!$!,*!&(-*('++3,/+%&,!'&, ,!&+'%*!'&+4*'*!% +!&$-& '/('($(*!.,*&+!,&, -+,*!*+ !(7 !%(,+',*&+!,!&.+,%&,'&,-$&(*!.*!%$.$+/*!+-++&*%!&&!%('*,&,,'(!71)-+,!'&+!&$-6D7 &*/ ,!*-%+,&+/!$$,*&+!,0(&+!'&!&*+'**+*!%$.$+!&&*'-&+,,!'&*+3E7 	'/'+, (*(,!'&'+,1&*!%$.$+*'++!&'%&*'-(+ &,*,*&+!,!&.+,%&,+*%3,/+$+'%&,!'&, ,, *$,!'&+ !(,/&+&+''%%-&!,1&,*&+!,!&.+,%&,4'*'&.*+$14+'!$!+'$,!'&&,*&+!,!&.+,%&,!+-&*+,-!7'%*+* *+*,*1!&,'(,-*+&+''%%-&!,1&+'!$!+'$,!'&!%(,+'!0-!/1,*&+!,!&.+,%&,+!&, !*+,-1+!&+7:5;5	+1 '$'!$(*!,'*+',*&+!,-+!&$-,/''-+*+>D?%'&,*1&,!%,*'+'*!*&,,*&+!,%*#,+>(,!.& '!5&*'++!&'%$.$+?/ & ''+!&,'*!,*&+!,5&>E?,,*-&*+,&!&'*,!&%'*( !*'-(+!&$-!&+&!'*+&', *+/!, +(!!-&,!'&$&+&, !*!+!'&<%#!&(*'++/ & ''+!&/ , *'*&',,'-+,*&+!,7 */++'%!+-++!'&*'-& '/', *%*!&,*&+('*,,!'&+*.!++- +*&1,%1!%(,,*&+!,*!*+ !(& '/, ,'-$!**'++!*&,+-<*'-(+7 &+,-1!&, !%(,',*&+!,!&.+,%&,+4!,/!$$!&*+!&$1!%('*,&,,'(,-*, *'$, ,', *%*!&+*.!+&, &'$'!+($1!&+ (!&,*.$(,,*&+7&*+,&!& '/', *+*.!+&, &'$'!+!%(,!*&,%'*( !*'-(+/!$$!%('*,&,7'*0%($4+&!'*+',&*$1%'* .!$1'&,*&+!,, &', *('(-$,!'&+-,%1 .+'%$!%!,,!'&+!&-+!&%'!$((+&', *, &'$'!+*)-!*,'++, ++*.!+7'/*!&'%*'-(+%1$+' .$!%!,++,', ++*.!++/$$77&', *%*!&'(('*,-&!,1'**+* , ,/+!+-++/+-+'%++!.%'-&,+',*.$,!&'$$,, *'- $,*'&!**+$!#, '%(++*&', *'*%+'$$( '&, &'$'17&', *'(('*,-&!,1'*-,-**+* !+, !&,*,!'&',*&+!,/!, &'&<%','*!2%'+',*.$, ,/'*#+1&*!+,!$$1/!, ,*&+!,,'(,-*,*!(&+&*!*+ !(7,,!'&*+!&'-$+,-!+'&, $.$'%'$!&,*,!'&, ,!+(*'.!&,!%=,*&+**$,!'&+ !(+,/&/$#&!#&', *%'++*.!&$'$*+&*!'&$++!!$!,1'&,*&+!,7ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',::5<5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+&',4(&$!+,++,*'&$1+-+,, ,'<0('+-*+&,'-*, *+,-!,',,*-&*+,& '/,*&+!,!%(,+'& .!'*&!*('$$-,!'&!%(,+(!! *'&!!+++77&*+0('+-*,'!*('$$-,!'&&&'!+'-$&,('+!,!. .!'*$,+'&/,*&+!,!&.+,%&,7,-!+*&, , $(,*%!&-&*/ ,'&!,!'&+,*&+!,!&.+,%&,%1*-'*!&*+0('+-*,'&'!+4('$$-,!'&&,*!*$,!&"-*1*!+#7;57	,!'&/+-!1, '$$'/!&)-+,!'&+6>D?  '+ '-$-,-*+,-!+'-+'&+&<-+*+',*&+!,&+!%(,%%*+'+'!,13+,+,-!+ .'-+%'+,$1'&-$,*+!&,+/ !$'&$1'&+,-1'-+'&%($'1+7	'/&**-!,!&%($'1+%0!%!2&/!&+! ,+3ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:	>E? 	'/&+,-!++!&+', ,'-+!&'&+(!!,*&+!,%*#,+>77(,!.& '!?&'&$*$141'-, 4$'/*!&'%4'*!+$+,.&, !$3&*+('&+,'/ ','+,-14(&$!+,+***,'('(-$,!'&+, ,$$/!, !&, '$$'/!&,'*!+6>D?, '+/ '*%'+,.-$&*$5>E?, '+/ '*+!+,'* *+,,'+,-15&4>F?, '+/ '&+ , $! ,'&%',!.,!'&+'*-+!&,*&+!,7 '$$'/!&+,!'&+!+-++ ', +,'*!+7;595 (&$!+,+%&,!'&%&1!*&,,1(+'.-$&*$('(-$,!'&+, ,&&*$$1,'*!2-&*, '+/ '*( 1+!$$1.-$&*$> . *'&!!++4'+4+&,*14$*$1?4&, '+/ '*'&'%!$$1.-$&*$>$'/+'!'<'&'%!+,,-+4(',&,!$,'&,*!!?7;5:54	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	'/.*4'$*-$,+*',&'&!0!&'%+&!&*+!&$1-&$,''*$!.!&&*,*&+!,7 '+'.*/! ,'*'+4$*$14!+$4&1'-, %1+ *+'%+!%!$*!,!+!&,*%+'$!%!,(*+'&$%'!$!,1&&!,*'%!&$'+*,',*&+!,77&&,!.!2!&&1', ++&+!,!.('(-$,!'&+,'$!.$'+*,',*&+!,'-$ .'&+!*$ $, &!,+7;5;54,/+*, ,'&'%!!%(,+',*&+!,!&.+,%&,'&.-$&*$('(-$,!'&+!+'%($07'*!&+,&4', *+!&,+&-+!&+++&!+($,**!$!&.+,%&,/ &$&(*!+!&*+5 '/.*!&*+++,'"'+&', *'(('*,-&!,!+&*+-$,!&'&'%!&!,+,', ++%('(-$,!'&+7,!+-&$*/ *&-&*/ ,'&!,!'&+,*&+!,!&.+,%&,+!%(*'.%($'1%&,'(('*,-&!,!+'*.-$&*$('(-$,!'&+7 ;5<5'%('(-$,!'&+, '- ,,'+!*,'+,-1*, '+/ ',#,*&+!,*-$*$17&+'%"-*!+!,!'&+1'-, &!&$-+('(-$,!'&,'+,-1-++'%+ ''$+(*'.!+,-&,+/!, &'(,!'&,',#(-$!,*&+!,4!&+,'+ ''$-+7, *(&$!+,+/*0!,'-,**-!,!&%($'1+, *'- &%&,/!, , !*%($'1*+7+'(('+,'&0,&+!.'1'*+* '&*+!&,!$&.!*'&%&,4!,/+#&'/$, ,/'*#&.!*'&%&,+/*-&*+,-!7 !+('!&,/+/$$,#&1, (&$!+,+-+%'+,('($+(&+!&!!&,,!%!&&*'-&, !*/'*#&.!*'&%&,+7-*, *4'*', ', +*+!&,!$&/'*#ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:&.!*'&%&,+,,!&+4!,!+('++!$,',+,(*'*%%,! &+%,'!&&,!.!2'*('(-$*!2(*,!!(,!&!&,!.,*&+('*,,!'&7&0%($/'-$ !$*&!#!&,'+ ''$'&, !*'/&4'*%($'1+!&&!&!#,'/'*#/#!&!,!,!.+7+,$14$$(&$!+,+0(*++*,!&,*+,+!&+,-1!&**-+*+-+$*<+$,&'$$,&&$12, *'- -,'%,**+1+,%$*1!&($!&%&1,*&+!,+1+,%+7 !+'-$$!&#,'&!&%($'1*+/ ''***+,', !*%($'1+7&(&$!+,+-+,$!&#!&**/!, *!.*8+$!&++', ,', *!&'*%,!'&4+- +'1/! ,4&'$$,7;5=5&$!+,+!&,!!+'%('(-$,!'&+, ,/'-$$!#$1(*'.!, *,+,'*%'+,!&,*+,!&+! ,!&,'(*<('+,,*&+!,!&.+,%&,+,-!+& $, 7,-1!& &+!&,*.$ !,+'*, '+, ,/'*#$'&&/*!$'**!'*+/+''&+!*$!&,*+,&!+-&*+,-!,',7 */+$+'!&,*+,!& '!*!*+'*('($/ '+ !,*'%*+,',*&+!,7;5>54	&$!+,+/*-*!'-+'-, '!*!*+4!77, '+/ ' .', *,*&+('*,,!'&'(,!'&+.!$$,', %-,!&+, ''+,'-+,*&+!,7(!!)-+,!'&+/**$,,' '!*!*+/ '+ !,, !* .!'**'%!&$-(&1 !$+>?,'(-$!,*&+!,7&$!+,+/*-*!'-+,'#&'/0,$1/ ,*!.+, !+ .!'*+ !,4+/1,'(',&,!$$1(!,$!2'&!,7&!,!'&4(&$!+,+/*-*!'-+'-,, (',&,!$ $, &!,+'%#!&, !++ !,7;5?54'%(&$!+,+/*!&,*+,!&!&.+,!,!& '/+%$$-+!&+++*!%(,-*!&,*&+!,'&+,*-,!'&'*-(*!&7 1!,*!$(*'",+!&/'*#!,1&+ !&,'&4/ *, &/+'.*!+&*$$1&,!.+*+-$,', !&,**-(,++,'-+!&+++-*!&'&+,*-,!'&&!&*+*&,(*!+,*, '&+,*-,!'&!+'%($,7 )-+,!'&/+/ , *, *!+/1,'!&$-+%$$+%($'+%$$-+!&++'/&*+/ &+!&!&+,-1,'-&*+,&%($'1*+4'*%($'1+4& '/!+*-(,!'&*'%'&+,*-,!'&'-$,, %7<57	,!'&/+-!1, '$$'/!&)-+,!'&6>D? 	'/4'*/ ,%, '+/'-$1'-%($'1,'!%(*'.-('&-**&,((*' +,'+,-1+!&4+%($!&4,'$$,!'&4&+,,!+,!$&$1+!+3(!!$$14*, *((*' +1'-/'-$$!#,'%($'1,'!%(*'.67 *-!,%&,&,'$$,!'&7 (,!$+%($!&'*+'&,*'$$'&!,-!&$+!&+7 +-*%&,'-!$,4&,-*$4&+'!$&.!*'&%&,,-*+7  !& *,'*  '-+ '$+4,*,!&+(!!%'*( !*'-(+7 !%!&'+$!&&'$$'/-(,'$$,!'&(*!'+,'(,-*&**&$'&*<,*%!%(,+>77$&-+?7 '&,!2 $, !%(,+',*&+!,!&.+,%&,+7 *++'%!&&+(*,!%(,+'*!$&&'&<%','*!2!&.+,%&,+ 7 ,,!+,!$&&$1,!$%, '+,',,*!+'$,-+,*$,!'&+ !(+4$-+,*!&4&*++', *(*.!'-+$!%!,,!'&+ECDJCIDD9 	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	'/.*4, 1%!,,, ,, !+/+0(&+!.&$'*!&,&+!.7$+'4!,/+&',, %'+,,!.+,*,1,'**-!,(*,!!(&,+7,/+$+'&',, ,, !+''*<,'<''*+,*,1'%+/!, !!-$,1,'* ('($$!.!&!&(*,%&,-!$!&+, , .&'(-$!++7!&$$14'&(&$!+,+-+,, ,*+* *+&$.*$*10!+,!&+$!&!&'*%,!'&, *1', *+-*.1+!&, *!'&'!&,*+,7 +0!+,!&,%1 .$'&*,!%$!&+&(*'.!%'*'&+!+,&,!&'*%,!'&'&,*.$ .!'-*4'*&,**!$!&.+,%&,7.*!&0!+,!&,'*.$-,!'&',*&+!,!&.+,%&, +&'&!&+'%+,-!+'.*!&, '*%&,!'&$!,*,-**.!/=, ++,-!+-+*'+++,!'&$+%($+'$$,,,/'!*&,,!%('!&,+7+* *+%1$+'-+0!+,!&,,'*,*'+(,!.$1!&.+,!,, ,+',*&+!,!&,*.&,!'&+7<5:5-+,!'&+*$,,','$$,!'&!&$-9	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	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',: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&$!+,+!+-++, ,*!'&+!*'&+!*$1!&, !*('$!,!$'&,0,+&*(,!.!,1,',*&+!,7'*-,'<'*!&,*+%1&',(,*+-$,+*'%', **!'&+, ,*%'*,*&+!,'*!&,&&.!*'&%&,$$1(*'*++!.7,& $$&!&,''&.!&!+!'&%#*+!&, +*!'&+',  $, &!,+',*&+!,!&.+,%&,+7&, +*+(*<('+,++++%&,'*'+!&*$,!'&,',*&+!,'-$'&-,,'%'&+,*,, *$,!.!%(,+'', '& $, 7.*$$4(&$!+,+*, ,%'*$'&!,-!&$*+* /!$$&,'&+-*&*$!2!$!,1*'++*!'&+7=5 !+'-+*'-(*'- ,,', *(&$'0(*,*+* *+'&, +-",', -+$!%(,+',*&+!,!&.+,%&,+'& $, 7 !+!+*$,!.$1&/*+* ,'(!&%- &*'+,-1!&,!%+' &!&, &'$'!+4,*&+('*,,!'&+*.!+4&+ !,!&%&'*%'*,*&+!,<'*!&,&.!*'&%&,+7*,!-$**+'+,-!+!&$--&*+,&!&.-$&*$('(-$,!'&+4&/,*&+('*,,!'&, &'$'!+4&'&'%!.$'(%&,+-**'-&!&,*&+!,7$+'4%'**+* !+&,'*!&+,-1%, ''$'!+,'-*, *,+'-,, *$,!'&+ !(+,/&'<!&.+,%&,+4'<0('+-*+4&'*( !'&,0,+7-,-*+,-!++ '-$$,'-!$'&(*.!'-+*+* 4-,%'*!&&'.,!'&+/'-$&!&*+4+- ++(,!$$1,*,**-!,%&,4'&,*'$*'-(+$,!'&4&$,*'&!'*%+'-,'%,,'$$,!'&7&1', (&$%%*+#&'/ ', *&$*1/'*#,', *'&+.*$', 0!+,!&+,-!+7 !+'&.*+,!'&-!$+'&(*.!'-+!+-++!'&+!$!,,, *'- , ,!'&$&+,!,-,+'	$, / ' .-&%'+,', +,-!+,',!&, 7*$1$$', (&$!+,+/**'%, -,', ,, ,%'+,/'*#'&, !+,'(!,', +&'%($,!&, 77+* *+!&!,, +!*,''&,!&-,'-!$'&, !+'&.*+,!'&&,'-*, *'$$'*,,',,*+,-1, '%($0!,!++-**'-&!&, !&,*!+!($!&*1&,-*'$!&#!&,*&+!,& $, 7'+-(('*,+- &&.'*4'&,0,-$!*&+&,'!&,!!&+,-!!&'&,*+,!&*!'&+&'&*&'!*&,,1(+',*&+!,!%(*'.%&,+7'*,+/!$$-&*,#&, *'- '$$'/-('*,+,''%!&0!+,!&,+,+!&+.*$*!'&+/ **+*  +&'&,'-*, *!$!,,, !$!,1,'*++'%($0)-+,!'&+&!&*+, ,*&+*!$!,1'#&'/$*'+++,-!+&*!'&+7 ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:))'"0940)*,'%&*+ (&$'&+!+,'DD0(*,+!&-*&($&&!&4,*&+('*,,!'&4(-$! $, 4'*( 1(+1 '$'14+'!'$'14&*!%!&'$'17!&*$&+*.+%'*,'*', %,!&7*"&.< *&!,''#&',+& &$, &!$+(,+', '-+*'-(%,!&7 (&$!&$-, '$$'/!&0(*,+6/*'5*'$3!557*(#,*"'")%'.+," ,(**'++'*&!*,'*	$, &'%%-&!,1+!& ''$''(-$,!'&&-$!	$,  ''$''%%-&!,1&!'&$$&&!&&!.*+!,1'*!,!+ '$-%!"!%*-*355*'++'*-(,!'&$&&.!*'&%&,$	$, !.!+!'& ''$''(-$,!'&&-$!	$, &!.*+!,1'*!,!+ '$-%!'1	(' 3!55'+,','*$+* & !&$$'/	$, &'%%-&!,1+!& ''$''(-$,!'&&-$!	$, &!.*+!,1'*!,!+ '$-%!"(%*(26%*(3!55+* ++!+,&,*'++'* ''$'&+(* !,,-*&$&&!&&!.*+!,1'*!2'&,)!'5(*,&''355&!'*&.+,!,'*4++!+,&,*'*%!*,'*4!$!*,'*&,*'*	$, +* !+**%&&,(!'('%3!55*'++'*'*!%!&'$'1&'!'$'1(*,%&,'*!%!&'$'1&!.*+!,1'&&+1$.&!***(/'3!55*'++'*(*,%&,'%!$1&'&+-%*,-!+'$$''!$@ .!'*$!&&!.*+!,1', ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:*"'%'+3!55*'++'*'!,*!+*'++'*'+1 !,*1@ .!'*$!&+,,$ !$*&8+	'+(!,$&!.*+!,1'+ !&,'&+1-*'3!55++!+,&,*'++'* ''$'-$!	$, &!.*+!,1'0+4	'-+,'&%."'*"13!55&**.&,!'&$$'/!.!+!'&'&**.&,!'&,!'&$&*&+,!,-,77(*,%&,'	$, &	-%&*.!+'"%%*"+355+* ++!+,&,-$,1'	$, !&+!%'&*+*&!.*+!,1ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:))'"0:40)*,'%%"+	#!$ "" !$#	"%#!### #)#(&'*% #&&!%%"&&!%)$ 	"#&&!%)"&&!&)$ 	"	#&&!&)"&&!()$ 	"	#&&!()"&'!%%$ 	"	#&'!%%"&'!()$ 	"	 	#&'!()"%&!%%$'ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:  	 !$! # ""   %&#  "!         	     ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:	  '#) '( , (#)  '&((!&&& '(+$+"*% -&&	 						 					ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:	 					  		   	!" 	 															 			 		 							ECDJCIDD9 	$, %(,+'!$*&+!,&.+,%&,61&, +!+'.!&&, ''$'!+,',:		 					 			!	"  # 	 		! 							 ’  	

Cite

Citation Scheme:

        

Citations by CSL (citeproc-js)

Usage Statistics

Share

Embed

Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML of your page to embed this item in your website.
                        
                            <div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
                            <script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
                            src="{[{embed.src}]}"
                            data-item="{[{embed.item}]}"
                            data-collection="{[{embed.collection}]}"
                            data-metadata="{[{embed.showMetadata}]}"
                            data-width="{[{embed.width}]}"
                            async >
                            </script>
                            </div>
                        
                    
IIIF logo Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard. To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:
http://iiif.library.ubc.ca/presentation/dsp.52383.1-0368618/manifest

Comment

Related Items