UBC Faculty Research and Publications

Western larch site index in relation to ecological measures of site quality Klinka, Karel; New, David Morley; Chourmouzis, Christine 2000

Your browser doesn't seem to have a PDF viewer, please download the PDF to view this item.

Item Metadata


52383-SSES041.pdf [ 117.88kB ]
JSON: 52383-1.0107277.json
JSON-LD: 52383-1.0107277-ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 52383-1.0107277-rdf.xml
RDF/JSON: 52383-1.0107277-rdf.json
Turtle: 52383-1.0107277-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 52383-1.0107277-rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 52383-1.0107277-source.json
Full Text

Full Text

Western Larch Site Index in Relation to Ecological Measures of Site Quality Introduction A silviculturist needs to know how productivity of all tree species under management varies with the ecological determinants of site quality, i.e., the environmental factors that directly affect the growth of plants - light, heat, soil moisture, soil nutrients, and soil aeration. A good understanding of this variation is necessary for making biologically viable, species- and site specific silvicultural decisions. Productivity of a given species is usually measured by site index (top tree height at 50 years at breast height age). Quantified relationships between site index of a given species and ecological measures of site quality provide predictive models for estimating site index for all sites on which the species may grow. Western larch (Larix occidentalis Nutt.) is an important tree species in southern central and eastern British Columbia. It grows mainly in the IDF, ICH, and MS zones on moderately dry through very moist sites and on poor through very rich sites. In view of this relatively wide ecological amplitude, a large variation in productivity could be expected. In the study summarized here, relationships between larch site index and selected ecological measures of site quality were examined, and a site index model using these measures as predictors was developed. Study stands and Procedure The study area encompassed the entire native range of larch in BC. The stands selected for the study had regenerated naturally after a major disturbance, typically wildfires, and were deliberately selected across the widest range of climatic (biogeoclimatic subzones), soil moisture, and soil nutrient conditions. The stands were unmanaged, uniformly and fully stocked, even-aged (ranging from 40 to 160 yrs at @ bh), and without signs of obvious damage or suppression. A 0.04 ha plot was established in each of the 315 study stands, the three largest diameter trees were cut and sectioned, and site index was determined from stem analysis data. An average height curve was computed for each species from sampled site trees for each study plot using Richard’s three-parameter equation and linear interpolation technique; the actual site index for each plot was then calculated as the average true height of site trees using the fitted equation. Allocation of stands into biogeoclimatic subzones was done according to biogeoclimatic maps. Soil moisture regime (SMR) and soil nutrient regime (SNR) were estimated using a combination of topographic and soil morphological properties as well as understory vegetation. Scientia  Silvica Extension Series, Number  41, 2000 Descriptive statistics were used to examine the relationship between site index and inferred climatic, soil moisture, and soil nutrient regimes. Inferential statistics were used to evaluate the strength of these relationships and site index predictions, and the model was cross-validated using independant data. To detect the strongest climatic influence on height growth, only stands on zonal sites were examined.  This study is the first to examine the effect of SNR and SMR interaction on larch site index. Results and Discussion Regional climate did influence site index of larch on zonal sites, with significant differences (α = 0.05) occurring between two subzone groups: low-precipitation IDF subzones and high- precipitation ICH and MS subzones. However, when comparing the zonal sites with equivalent soil moisture, no significant differences in site index were detected on very dry, moderately dry, and slightly dry sites between study subzones. Thus, it was concluded that precipitation, not temperature, limits growth of larch in the study area. Consequently, subzone was not considered a useful predictor of larch site index. Larch site index significantly increased from water-deficient to moist sites and decreased from moist to wet sites. On water- deficient sites, it increased from very poor to very rich sites; estimates of both actual SMR and SNR had both significant and consistent positive effects on site index on these sites. On sites where water was not deficient, the influence of SNR appeared to be marginal. A cross-validated prediction model based on field-estimated actual SMR and SNR accounted for 84% of the variation in western larch site index: SI = 7.9 + 0.0(ED) + 4.8(VD) + 8.4(MD) + 10.8(SD) + 12.5(F) + 14.1(M) + 7.3(VM) + 7.4(W) + 0.0(VP) + 1.1(P) + 3.4(MD) + 4.5(R) + 4.7(VR) Adjusted R2 = 0.84 SEE = 1.5 MSE = 2.1 where: ED - excessively dry, VD - very dry, MD - moderately dry, SD - slightly dry, F - fresh, M - moist, VM - very moist, W - wet, VP - very poor, P - poor, MD - medium, R - rich, VR - very rich, SEE - standard error of the estimate, MSE - mean square error.  Scientia Silvica  is published by the Forest Sciences Department, The University of British Columbia, ISSN 1209-952X Editor: K. Klinka (klinka@interchange.ubc.ca) Research: D. New (thenews@jetstream.net) Production and design: C. Chourmouzis (chourmou@interchange.ubc.ca) Financial support: National Science and Engineering Research Council, Weyerhouser Canada, Ltd., and Cranbrook Forest Industries, Ltd. For more information contact: David New (thenews@jetstream.net) Copies available from: www. forestry.ubc.ca/klinka or K. Klinka, 3036-2424 Main Mall, Forest Sciences Department, UBC, Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z4 When predicted values were compared to measured values on the test data set (n = 105), the constructed model (n = 210) proved unbiased in predicting site index. A paired t-test (α = 0.05) showed the regression model predicted a site index that did not differ significantly from the mean site index of the test data set.  The mean difference was 0.09 m between the predicted and measured site index (p = 0.55). Plotted prediction error values also indicated no bias in site index prediction, and showed that the model estimates of the test data site index were usually within ±3m of the actual measured values. The developed model, using field estimates of SMR and SNR, can be used to provide site index predictions for western larch throughout its range in BC to a satisfactory level of accuracy. Table 1. Edatopic grid showing the predicted site index values (m @ 50 yr bh) using the SMR-SNR model (n=315), ±95% confidence interval (m), measured mean site index, and SIBEC mean site index values according to actual SMR and SNR. Sample sizes indicated refer only to the measured and predicted site index values. 1SIBEC (Site Index Estimates by Site Series for Coniferous Tree Species in British Columbia 1997). 2NA - SIBEC estimate not available. 3ND - no data were obtained due to the absence or sporadic occurrence of western larch under some edaphic conditions. G46  



 	 G46 G46        G46   G46   !"   # $%&±'%( $%&    ) *%+ ,    ) ''%- ,  ) '+%( ,  ) '#%) ,     G46   !" & '#%+±)%& '#%+  '. '#%$±)%$ '.%# '$%) $ '&%'±)%* '-%. '(%) + '(%#±)%( '&%& '$%& ) '(%- ,  
   G46   !" ) '&%( ,  .- '(%.±)%- '(%+ '*%& .. '*%&±)%- '*%* '$%$ & +)%$±)%- +)%$ +)%' ) +'%' , +#%( /   G46   !" ) '*%+ ,  -+ '*%*±)%# '*%* +#%. -$ ++%+±)%- +'%* +#%) +$ +#%#±)%( +#%( +'%) ) +#%& , '*%+ 0   G46   !" ) +)%* ,  ) +'%- , ++%* '$ +#%$±)%- +'%* +#%( '' +-%)±)%& +#%( +'%* - +-%+±'%' +-%& +(%) 
   G46   !" ) ++%- ,  ) +#%' , '$%* ' +-%.±'%# +&%- +.%$ + +&%&±'%# +&%+ +.%' - +&%$±'%' +&%$ +)%) 	
   G46   !" ) '&%' ,  ) '&%( ,  ) '*%) , ++%# . +)%+±'%# +)%& ++%- ' +)%.±+%* '$%( +-%+ 1   G46   !" ) '&%# ,  ) '(%) ,  ) '*%+ ,  ' +)%.±'%& +)%.  ) +)%( ,    Reference New, D. 1999. Productivity of western larch in relation to categorical measures of climate, soil moisture, and soil nutrients. M.Sc. Thesis. Department of Forest Sciences, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC.


Citation Scheme:


Citations by CSL (citeproc-js)

Usage Statistics



Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML of your page to embed this item in your website.
                            <div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
                            <script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
                            async >
IIIF logo Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard. To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:


Related Items