British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium

Groundwater quality evaluations of mines McCreadie, Hugh; Smith, Rod 1993

Your browser doesn't seem to have a PDF viewer, please download the PDF to view this item.

Item Metadata


59367-1993 - McCreadie, Smith - Groundwater Quality Evaluations.pdf [ 1.72MB ]
JSON: 59367-1.0042228.json
JSON-LD: 59367-1.0042228-ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 59367-1.0042228-rdf.xml
RDF/JSON: 59367-1.0042228-rdf.json
Turtle: 59367-1.0042228-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 59367-1.0042228-rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 59367-1.0042228-source.json
Full Text

Full Text

Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  GROUNDWATER QUALITY EVALUATIONS OF MINES Hugh McCreadie, Rod Smith Klohn Leonoff Ltd., 10200 Shellbridge Way, Richmond, British Columbia, V6X 2W7 ABSTRACT Groundwater quality is an aspect of mine reclamation that is now receiving increased attention. The potential impact of mines on groundwater quality can be estimated by considering: mine water sources; groundwater flowpaths; waste characteristics; groundwater geochemistry, and environmental impacts. Primary groundwater flowpaths are within the more permeable geologic materials. These flowpaths can transport a significant mass of contaminants even though they generally comprise a small proportion of the materials. Impacts include potential degradation of water quality in local aquifers, lakes and streams. Groundwater assessments can be carried out in four phases. Phase I consists of a review of existing data that are used to develop a preliminary hydrogeologic interpretation and define a Phase II field program. The preliminary interpretation is verified and a groundwater monitoring network is installed during the field program. The Phase I and Phase II data are amalgamated into a Phase III report, which documents the analysis and presents estimates of future impacts. Mine personnel, in Phase IV, collect and compile monitoring data that can be used to check the model estimates. In this manner, potential environmental liabilities are identified and the costs of remediation and/or mitigation are minimized. 87 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  INTRODUCTION Groundwater quality is an aspect of mine reclamation that is now receiving increased attention. Regulations that will follow from the planned British Columbia groundwater legislation will bring groundwater more to the forefront in coming years. A mine's objectives with respect to reclamation include: − maintaining profitability; − protecting the environment; and − minimizing future liabilities and meet future regulatory requirements. Unforeseen environmental liabilities can affect a mine's long-term profitability. A seemingly large investment now can prevent larger expenditures that might otherwise be required in the future to remediate undetected impacts. An assessment of environmental risk includes a characterization of potential contaminant sources, groundwater flowpaths and discharge environments. As with all subsurface characterizations, some uncertainty is associated with interpretations of groundwater regimes. Problems typically result from conditions that were not anticipated. Therefore, quality control measures must be applied during groundwater assessments. A phased approach to groundwater assessments minimizes the quantity of unproductive data and clearly defines the data requirements. High risk elements can be identified and thoroughly investigated. MINE WATER SOURCES AND FLOWPATHS Tailings Management options include a variety of disposal methods from ponds through dry stacking. Mill reagents, heavy metals and weathering products that are resident in the tailings pore water can enter the groundwater system. If the tailings generate acid, the concentrations of some solutes will increase. Valleys are often the most suitable sites for tailings storage. Valley bottoms can be infilled with glacial, alluvial or colluvial deposits, which can be relatively permeable. Tailings water can migrate downward into a permeable deposit through fractures or discontinuities in a low-permeability layer. Figure 1 illustrates a typical groundwater flowpath for water that exfiltrates from a tailings pond. Waste Rock Waste rock dumps and ore stockpiles are also potential sources of heavy metals and other solutes. The main concerns are the residual nitrates from blasting and the weathering products of the freshly exposed rock. In some cases, waste rock generates acid water. Waste rock dumps and ore stockpiles are often sited adjacent to the mine on native overburden deposits. A large proportion of the water that infiltrates into a waste rock dump usually runs off the dump foundation and can be collected in perimeter ditches. A significant proportion of the water, however, can infiltrate into the dump foundation. Even waste dumps that are founded on glacial till can lose a significant amount of water to the groundwater system through the more permeable flowpaths in the till. Figure 2 presents a section through a waste rock dump that illustrates typical groundwater flowpaths. General Waste Most mines have waste disposal sites that contain mixed wastes, including reagent containers, lubricant containers, solvent containers and mill filters. Current disposal practices often include washing of spent containers. Infiltration through the disposal site can leach metals or reagents from the waste into the groundwater system. 88 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation    Reagents. Fuels and Mine Drainage Reagents and fuels are often stored in the plantsite area. Accidental spills or past material handling practices can lead to groundwater contamination. Spills that occur are generally collected in ditches but exfiltration from the ditches can enter the groundwater system. Drainage from the mine workings constitutes a large proportion of the site water-balance at many mines. Therefore, the quality and discharge point of the mine water are also key considerations. 89 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  HYDROGEOCHEMISTRY Hydrogeochemical processes influence the mobility of solutes in groundwater. These processes include precipitation/dissolution and adsorption/desorption. Table 1 summarizes the controls on these processes and their effects on heavy metal and cyanide mobility.  Redox potential is a measure of the oxidizing capacity of the groundwater. The redox conditions control the oxidation state of the solutes, which in turn influences their solubility. Heavy metals, for example, are generally more soluble and, therefore, more mobile in reducing conditions than in oxidizing conditions. Native groundwater environments are generally reducing, but oxidizing conditions can be created by mining activities causing increased recharge rates. The buffering capacity of the receiving groundwater and the pH of the infiltrating mine water also have a strong influence on solute mobility. Metals generally have high mobility only at low pH. Cyanide mobility, on the other hand, tends to be higher at high pH. Aquifer mineralogy can have a strong effect on solute transport. Carbonate in aquifer materials, for example, will tend to increase the pH of any acid mine water and cause the metals to precipitate. Sulphur, inorganic carbon, chloride, fluoride and nitrate ligands can form metal complexes, which have greater mobility than the free heavy metal ions. Clay minerals, organics and hydrous oxides in aquifers will tend to retard the advance of contaminants because of their adsorption capacity. GROUNDWATER ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY Information that is relevant to a qualitative groundwater risk assessment is available at most mines. Available data are reviewed to develop a preliminary interpretation and focus available funding on the most significant mine water sources and groundwater flowpaths. The data review is generally followed by a field program, data analysis and monitoring program. This phased approach to groundwater assessments facilitates cost control and enhances technical quality. 90 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  Phase I:  Data Review The available data are examined for evidence or inference of potential for groundwater contamination. The presence of high risk mine water sources, significant groundwater flowpaths and/or sensitive receiving environments indicates a need for further investigation and characterization. A preliminary interpretation is developed and investigations are proposed to test or verify the interpretation. A groundwater monitoring network is also proposed to take advantage of the equipment that is mobilized for the site investigation. Table 2 summarizes the categories of data that are useful in forming a preliminary interpretation of groundwater conditions at a mine. The data are usually compiled as part of a site visit and in consultation with mine personnel. Phase II:  Field Program At the conclusion of the data review, a preliminary interpretation will have been formed regarding the mine water recharge sources, groundwater flowpaths and groundwater discharge patterns. A field program that collects additional data on background conditions, mine waste characteristics and groundwater flowpaths is generally required to verify the interpretation and to install monitoring. The field program is adjusted as it progresses to accommodate new data. Table 3 summarizes the main activities of the field program. Quality control documentation is required for all field activities. Surface activities are a key component of the site investigation because a great deal can be learned about mine water recharge mechanisms and rates and groundwater discharge patterns and rates. The surface activities are often the most cost-effective part of the investigation. Cleanliness is a key issue in groundwater monitoring work. Drilling techniques that introduce drilling additives into the ground do not support the program objective, which is to obtain groundwater samples that will give a clear indication of the groundwater chemistry. Monitoring wells must be installed so that the groundwater samples are extracted from an identifiable zone with a minimum of disturbance to the groundwater chemistry. Several guidelines for materials are recommended, as summarized in Table 4. Quality control data must be collected for all installations. Because the usefulness of groundwater chemistry data depends strongly on low suspended solids content, the monitoring wells require development to clean and stabilize the filter pack. The main well development activities are surging, jetting, and pumping. Figure 3 illustrates the principle of well development. Phase HI:  Analysis and Reporting A hydrogeologic analysis includes an assessment of data quality, and interpolation and extrapolation of the database. The data that were collected during Phases I and II are plotted with time, in section and in plan. The data plots are examined for correlations with mine activities, precipitation, streamflows and any other known conditions near the mine. The data are also examined for corroboration. For example, water sample data should be consistent or behave as expected from one sampling period to the next. Data that correlate and corroborate are usually of adequate quality to define site conditions. An important corroboration is the "match" of the site data with accepted hydrogeologic theory. That is, interpolation and extrapolation of the data set are reasonable if the observed conditions can be modelled with reasonable input parameters. Hydraulic and geochemical data from across the study area and through time are required to adequately match a model to site conditions. The groundwater model characterizes: recharge mechanisms and rates; transmission characteristics; and discharge mechanisms and rates. 91 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  Table 2 - Summary of Data Categories 92 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  Table 3 - Summary of Field Program Activities   Each component of the groundwater model requires calculations, which must be based on sound hydrogeological and hydrogeochemical principles. The calculation method is chosen on the basis of model complexity, which is determined by the quality and depth of the database, and the required level of understanding. Preliminary assessments are usually carried out with hand calculations and represented in a fashion similar to Figure 4. Figure 4 summarizes the water balance and flowpaths of a simple groundwater model. The model can be updated and expanded as the database grows. A similar presentation can be prepared for mass balance. Computer analysis is generally reserved for complex models that are based on an appropriate database. 93 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation   After the data have been correlated and corroborated, a groundwater model is developed to extrapolate the existing data and estimate potential future impacts. Depending on the results of the extrapolation, a suitable monitoring program is designed and any additional data requirements are defined. A report summarizes the data sources, the data record, a description of the hydrogeologic and hydrogeochemical interpretation, the implications of the interpretation, and the recommended monitoring program.  94 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  Phase IV:  Monitoring Program and Data Management A monitoring program consists of collection and analysis of samples at prescribed frequencies from selected locations. Special measures are required to obtain groundwater samples of sufficient quality for a meaningful interpretation. Unlike surface water samples, groundwater samples are transferred into an environment that is different from their native environment. Changes that affect the groundwater sample chemistry upon extraction include temperature shifts, pressure decrease and oxygenation. Therefore, some chemistry parameters must be recorded in the field at the time of sampling because they are prone to change within a very short time. These parameters include temperature, pH, conductivity and redox potential. These field parameters are best measured in a flow-through cell. Another important component of groundwater sampling is cleanliness of sampling equipment. Cleanliness is central to a sound groundwater chemistry database because significant contamination occurs at parts per million levels. A sampling and handling plan is required to ensure that adequate quality control measures are implemented during groundwater sampling. Table 5 summarizes the primary elements of a sampling and handling plan.  A computer database and computer graphics are the most efficient tools for managing groundwater data. The database facilitates swift information retrieval and the graphics synthesize large quantities of data into readable "pictures" that reveal patterns and trends. The chemistry data evaluation generally consists of two steps: − data quality assessment; and − groundwater chemistry assessment. Table 6 summarizes the elements of a data quality assessment. The quality of the groundwater chemistry data is evaluated on the basis of data consistency and isolation of external influences. For example, high suspended solids in groundwater samples can lead to variable and unreliable groundwater chemistry results. A comparison of the pH, redox potential, temperature and conductivity that were measured in the field with those that were measured in the lab will reveal shifts that have occurred. The significance of any shifts in these parameters requires an evaluation. 95 Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation  After the data quality has been established, the groundwater chemistry can be assessed. Table 7 summarizes the elements of a groundwater chemistry assessment.  The groundwater chemistry assessment must consider both the presence of tracers and contaminants. Tracers are solutes such as sodium, nitrate and sulphate that travel relatively freely through the groundwater system and indicate the presence of mine water. The eventual arrival of a heavy metals plume, for example, can be indicated by a sulphate concentration that is significantly above background. Figure 5 illustrates a plot of cyanide (contaminant) and sulphate (tracer) in several monitoring wells along a groundwater flowpath. The elevated cyanide and sulphate concentrations correlate with a near-by tailings impoundment. The cyanide data corroborate the sulphate data.   96 Table 6 - Summary of Data Quality Assessment Proceedings of the 17th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Port Hardy, BC, 1993. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation   The cyanide and sulphate concentrations in MW-1 and MW-4 are about 30 times and 20 times groundwater and background, respectively. The cyanide concentration in MW-3, however, is only about twice background, whereas, sulphate is about 10 times background. This indicates that geochemical processes may be retarding cyanide transport relative to sulphate transport. Geochemical processes probably also account for the relatively large drop in cyanide concentration between the tailings pond and MW-1. SUMMARY A groundwater quality assessment can be conducted in four phases. A model that can be used to estimate potential future impacts is developed in Phases I to III. Data that can be used to check and refine the groundwater model are collected during the Phase IV monitoring program. Quality control measures during all phases of data collection and analysis are required to ensure that the collected data are usable and to ensure that the model adequately represents site conditions. Groundwater quality assessments are required to protect mines from unforseen liabilities, protect the environment, and meet regulatory requirements. 97


Citation Scheme:


Citations by CSL (citeproc-js)

Usage Statistics



Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML of your page to embed this item in your website.
                            <div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
                            <script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
                            async >
IIIF logo Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard. To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:


Related Items