British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium

Soil fauna recolonization of high elevation mine spoils in southeastern British Columbia Lawrence, Joanne M. 1984

Your browser doesn't seem to have a PDF viewer, please download the PDF to view this item.

Notice for Google Chrome users:
If you are having trouble viewing or searching the PDF with Google Chrome, please download it here instead.

Item Metadata


59367-1984 - Lawrence - Soil Fauna Recolonization of High.pdf [ 169.84kB ]
JSON: 59367-1.0042092.json
JSON-LD: 59367-1.0042092-ld.json
RDF/XML (Pretty): 59367-1.0042092-rdf.xml
RDF/JSON: 59367-1.0042092-rdf.json
Turtle: 59367-1.0042092-turtle.txt
N-Triples: 59367-1.0042092-rdf-ntriples.txt
Original Record: 59367-1.0042092-source.json
Full Text

Full Text

Proceedings of the 8th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Victoria, BC, 1984. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation SOIL FAUNA RECOLONIZATION OF HIGH ELEVATION MINE SPOILS IN SOUTHEASTERN BRITISH COLUMBIA by Joanne M. Lawrence Introduction nutrient availability, soil aeration, and moist- The proper functioning of an ecosystem de- ure-holding capacity. pends on the efficiency of its component This study was set up to investigate the parts. In a terrestrial ecosystem, the decom- role that soil fauna play in the decomposition poser subsystem provides an important (and of organic material on high elevation re- poorly known) link between the decomposi- claimed land. The first and most important tion of dead organic matter (detritus) and the objective, therefore, must be to document in availability of essential nutrients for the pro- detail the recolonization of soil fauna on to duction of new organic material. It is a soil such spoils. It is then necessary to correlate community which is comprised of a complex the above findings with indicators of eco- organization of soil flora and fauna, which system performance, such as site productiv- process detrital material and convert it into jty and decomposition rates. Finally, this mineral soil. The process of mineralization, study is investigating practical methods of where decomposed material is broken down ameliorating the disturbed sites, to increase into its chemical constituents and made the rate of soil fauna! recolonization and site available for uptake by plants, is undertaken qual i ty,  thereby substant ia l ly reducing by the soil flora, or bacteria and fungi. This further management costs. process of mineralization is greatly accel- erated by the action of the soil fauna, who Site Location ingest and break down organic material, thus The reclaimed areas under investigation making   it   more   available   to   bacteria   and are located on the Westar Mining Ltd. Balmer fungi.   Soil   faunal   activities  also  stimulate mine  site  near  the village of Sparwood,  in fungal   growth   by   cropping   and   dispersing southeastern  British   Columbia.   These   sites spores, as well as improving soil aeration and are   located   near   the   summit   of   Harmer water status by burrowing and opening pas- Ridge, at an elevation of approximately 1,950 sages occupied by decaying roots (Marshall et metres. al, 1982). Four sites were chosen for study: three Mine spoils initially lack such a biolog- reclaimed sites which were two, five, and ical community of soil flora and fauna. To nine years of age in 1982 when sampling took compensate for this, newly reclaimed spoils place, as well as a nearby undisturbed sub- are treated with annual maintenance applica- alpine grassland meadow. Although the tions of a complete fertilizer. It is therefore natural meadow differed considerably from important to understand the functioning of the reclaimed sites in slope, vegetation, soil these disturbed ecosystems, to determine and microhabitat conditions, it was sampled when, if at all, a soil environment conducive to provide an indicat ion of  how a sel f - to vigorous and sustained plant growth has sufficient natural grassland ecosystem is been established, and costly fertilizer appli- functioning at a similar elevation and aspect, cations are no longer necessary. The incor- with essentially similar parent materials. poration of organic material back into the soil is of paramount importance, since it is Research Areas essential for the development of a soil profile This   study  encompasses  a   number   of with     such     desirable     characteristics     as areas of research: 75 Proceedings of the 8th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Victoria, BC, 1984. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation 1. Soil cores 2. Emergence traps 3. Innoculation sources 4. Environmental parameters 5. Earthworm introduction trial The five different areas of research will be outlined, with emphasis on work com- pleted to date. I.       Soil Cores The extraction of soil fauna from soil core samples taken from each of the study sites comprises one of the main sections of this study. Extraction techniques are de- scribed in Lawrence (1982). It is here that the majority of the important soil fauna are quantified and then identified. Major taxa extracted included:  - acari (mites)  - collembola (springtails)  - nematodes (roundworms)  - enchytraeids (potworms)  - insect larvae Quantification and identification of the samples is still underway. Acari and col- Iernbola appear to be the major recolonizers of reclaimed land, although Diptera larvae, particularly saprophagous forms, are also abundant. Similar results have been recorded by researchers in Britain and Germany. The collembola lsotoma notabilis is abundant on the two-year-old site, and was also found to dominate a two-year-old reclaimed site in England (Hutson, 1980). Prostigmatic mites were the dominant acarine recolonizers on study sites in England (Hutson, I960) and are quite abundant in the study soil cores on Harmer Ridge. Nematodes were numerous on the un- disturbed subalpine meadow, yet very rare on the younger reclaimed sites, particularly the two-year-old site. Stanton and Krementz (1982) found similar results on reclaimed sites in Wyoming, where disturbed areas (es- pecially stockpiled topsoil) supported signif- icantly fewer nematodes than undisturbed sites. Enchytraeids (Ijenleq, sp.) were present on the undisturbed subalpine meadow, yet absent from all reclaimed sites. This lack of a desirable earthworm population on these reclaimed sites led to the establishment of an earthworm introduction trial, which will be discussed later. 2.       Emergence Traps Not all soil organisms spend their com- plete life cycle in the soil, but may emerge as adults to breed; laying eggs back into the soil environment. Members of the Coleoptera (beetle) and Hymenoptera (wasp) orders may follow this pattern, although Dipterans (flies) are probably the most common. Larval forms are often saprophagous, feeding on dead and decaying organic matter. Insect larvae can make a signif icant contribution to the amount of organic matter decomposed in an ecosystem, particularly in the absence of earthworms. Emergence traps provide a useful tech- nique for quantifying the insect larvae pre- sent in a square metre of soil. The trap (described in Lawrence, 1982) collects any insect emerging from the soil at any time. Adult forms permit easier identification of larvae extracted from soil samples. Study sites were monitored for eleven weeks during the summer of 1982. Samples have been identified (tentatively in some cases) to the family level. Of the 62 different insect families tallied from all sites, 28 of these belong to the order Diptera. Dipterans are well represented on all study sites, par- ticularly on the subalpine meadow. Eighteen different Dipteran families have been recorded from the reclaimed sites alone, and although life histories are very poorly known, up to 13 of these families may include larval forms which are saprophagous, feeding on decaying organic matter. Other families may include larval forms which live as herbivores, parasites, or predators. The four most com- mon Dipteran families on the reclaimed sites include members of the family Cecidomyi- idae (gall midges), Sciaridae (fungus gnats), Phoridae (humpbacked flies), and Heleomy- zidae. These families all have larval forms which feed on decaying organic matter. Other major groups of insects are also represented in these samples. The most 76 Proceedings of the 8th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Victoria, BC, 1984. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation abundant beetle collected is a small pre- daceous rove beetle, belonging to the family Staphylinidae. Beetles are not well repre- sented on the reclaimed sites, although some predaceous ground beetles (Carabidae) and ladybird beetles (Coccinellidae) were col- lected at certain times of the year. Members of the order Hemiptera, or "true bugs", are represented on all sites by leaf hoppers (Ci- cadellidae and Cercopidae) and plant bugs (Miridae). These bugs are all herbiverous, feeding on above-ground vegetation. Most of the wasps collected in these samples are parasitic on other insects. Butterflies and rnoths are not abundant on these sites. The most numerous moth collected is a member of the family Gelechiidae. This insect feeds on above-ground vegetation and seeds in the larval stage. Figure I represents family diversity on all study sites over an eleven-week period in 1982. The Shannon-Weaver index of diversity (H’) gives an indication of the distribution of individuals among categories, families in this case. The index of evenness, J, expresses this observed diversity as a proportion of the maximum possible diversity. These indices cannot be calculated when the sample con- sists of only one individual, as is the case on the two-year-old site in weeks 2 and 4. This figure indicates the general trend of an increase in diversity over time as the season progressed, followed by a decrease by the end of August. Sites show a slight in- crease in diversity with site age, although the oldest reclaimed site is somewhat less di- verse than the intermediate-aged site. This may actually reflect the more heavily com- pacted nature of the spoil material on this older site. Most soil animals are unable to burrow and must utilize existing pore spaces (WaIIwork, 1976). The more compacted soil would be expected to have fewer pore spaces, and a lower degree of insect diversity. 3.       lnnoculation Sources On sites which lack a dominant earth- worm population, collembola and mites as- sume the role of the important decomposer group. The major means of dispersal for soil animals such as mites and collembola is that of wind or water; either in snowmelt or rainwater (Christiansen, 1964; Fjellberg pers. comm.). It is likely that on Harmer Ridge, the organisms travel downslope with the snowmelt. Since the study sites are located very near the ridge summit, it is believed that sources of recolonizers might be limited. The probable sources of innoculation are likely to be the subalpine fir/whitebark pine forest patches which have been left undis- turbed on and near the ridge summit. A number of soil samples were taken along a transect run through the largest patch of forest in June, 1983. Organisms extracted will be compared to those found on the reclaimed sites, to investigate the pos- sibility of the forest acting as an innoculation source. Without such a source, the rate of re- colonization by soil organisms and subsequent litter decomposition would be considerably slower than that already seen. Large disturb- ances on ridgetops may face such a situation in the future. If mine plans do not permit leaving small patches of undisturbed ground, an alternate plan may be to dump a number a truckloads of fresh (not stockpiled) topsoil in strategic locations on the newly reclaimed spoil, which should be revegetated as soon as possible after resloping. Some of this "in- noculation source" should be placed near the highest point in the reclaimed spoil, to allow for downslope movement of organisms. Placement of topsoil in moist microsite con- ditions (favorable to mites and collembola) such as those found in small topographic depressions, or behind rock berms or dumps, etc., is also desirable. These microsites may be easily created during the resloping pro- cess. 4.       Environmental Parameters The development of an ecosystem may be monitored through the production of vege- tative biomass and the decomposition rate of detritus, or organic matter. The soil fauna! community influences these processes through its various feeding activities, and subsequent effects on soil structure and 77 Proceedings of the 8th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Victoria, BC, 1984. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation Figure I Diversity (H’) and Evenness (J) Versus Time   78 Proceedings of the 8th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Victoria, BC, 1984. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation chemistry. A number of environmental parameters will influence the species composition and abundance of the soil community itself. Such factors include soil temperature and moisture levels, as well as particle size distributions. The species distribution and abundance of the soil organisms sample will be cor- related with the above-mentioned para- meters, using a multivariate statistical tech- nique. Data for a number of different envi- ronmental factors have been collected, al- though a summary at this point is beyond the scope of this paper. 5.       Earthworm Introduction Trial As mentioned previously, earthworms, particularly enchytraeids, were absent from soil cores taken from all reclaimed sites, yet present in the undisturbed subalpine meadow. Since the dispersal rate of earthworms is very low, it is expected that enchytraeids would recolonize these reclaimed sites ex- tremely slowly. The lack of earthworms on the sites is significant because the earthworm is probab- ly the most important soil animal, and its beneficial effects on the soil are numerous. Up to 15 tons of dry earth per acre may pass through an earthworm's body annually (Brady, 1974). Ingested organic matter and mineral soil are subjected to digestive enzymes and a grinding action within the animal. Earthworm casts, compared to the mineral soil, are higher in bacteria and organic matter, avail- able phosphorus and potassium, pH and per- cent base saturation, and cation exchange capacity. Holes left by earthworm burrows serve to increase soil aeration and drainage. The soil is mixed and granulated through the transportation of lower soil to the surface, and undecomposed organic matter such as leaves and grass down into the burrows (Edwards and Lofty, 1972). A number of factors affect earthworm activity. An optimum habitat is a moist, reasonably well-aerated soil, with an avail- able organic matter food source. Most earth- worms thrive best where the soil is not too acid. A high level of exchangeable calcium is necessary for optimum activity. The abun- dance and distribution of earthworms is af- fected by soil temperature and moisture, a temperature of 10°C being optimum for Lumbricus terrestris. Cold weather or dry upper soil conditions will drive earthworms deeper in the soil profile, occasionally down to a depth of 2 metres. In barren soils, a sudden heavy frost in the fall may skill the organisms before they are able to move deeper, and a good insulating soil cover is important in these circumstances (Edwards and Lofty, 1972). Workers in Ohio have been able to suc- cessfully introduce L. terrestris onto forested acid shale spoil banks, where these organisms buried or consumed the equivalent of 5 metric tons of leaf litter per hectare over a five-year period. The levels of exchangeable cations and available P in the mineral spoil were also increased (Vimmerstedt and Finney, 1973). German investigators con- cluded that on sites reclaimed for IO years, earthworms were the sole important decom- posers, removing over 70 percent of the litterfall (Hutson, 1980). Due to the absence of large inverte- brate decomposer fauna on these high eleva- tion reclaimed sites, this section of the soil fauna study was designed to experimentally introduce two species of lumbricid earth- worms, Lumbricus terrestris and L. rubellus onto a reclaimed site, to investigate both survival and effects on decomposition rates and certain soil characteristics. Their bene- ficial activities will enable establishment of a "self-sustaining" reclaimed site at an earlier age than previously expected, thereby reducing further management costs. This introduction trial was separated into two different experiments. The first trial, or "species trial" is simply investigating earthworm survival on an 8-year-old re- claimed site. Two different species of earth- worms were used, Lumbricus terrestris and L. rubeilus. A number of sexually mature worms of each species were placed at 10 innoculation points along a transect on the reclaimed site. Surrounding litter was placed over the worms to protect them from 79 Proceedings of the 8th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Victoria, BC, 1984. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation excessive ultraviolet radiation and drying conditions. The introduction was made in early June, 1983, and all innoculation points still showed evidence of earthworm survival by September of 1983. Here survival is in- dicated by the presence of established bur- rows near the innoculation points, and/or the presence of earthworm casts on the soil sur- face. These points will be checked again in 1984 to determine whether or not these par- ticular earthworm species have survived the winter. The second introduction trial was de- signed to test the effects of Lumbricus ter- restris on the decomposition rate of detritus, as well as certain soil characteristics. In this  case, five 1-metre innoculation plots were established on a 7-year-old reclaimed site in mid-June, 1983, and 100 mature L. terrestris were placed in each of the five plots. None of the detrital material was disturbed. In Sep- tember the detritus levels were checked, and although the treated plots had slightly lower detritus levels than the control plots, this difference was not significant. Detritus levels will be determined again in 1984, along with certain soil characteristics. It is expected that the major limiting factor influencing earthworm survival on these sites will be soil temperature. The worms must be able to migrate below the freezing level of the ground to overwinter, and they must be able to survive at sufficient depths to avoid extreme summer tempera- tures and dessication. In order to obtain a rough estimate of the depth to which the soil may freeze on these sites, a 1.8 m test hole was drilled on the 8-year-old site, and a plastic pipe con- taining small vials of water, spaced at regu- lar intervals, was inserted. The pipes will be lifted in May 1984, and the depth to which the water-filled vials froze and broke should give a rough indication of freezing depth. Food supply should not pose a problem, as these sites have roughly 260 g/m2 of above-ground detritus which would also serve as insulating protection against desication and ultraviolet radiation. The soil pH of these particular sites is approximately 7.2 (Fyles, 1980), which is op- timum for most earthworm species (Edwards and Lofty, 1972). If earthworms are indeed able to sur- vive on these high elevation sites, they may well prove to be a viable means of encour- aging the incorporation of detritus on the soil surface down into the spoil material. The rate of nutrient availability will be increased, and maintenance fertilization may be stopped at an earlier age, thus resulting in both a reduction in further fertilizer costs, and pos- sible future site amendments. Summary Although a great deal of work is still to be done in this study, research may be sum- marized in a number of points. 1. Acari and Collembola are abundant on all   study  sites,   including   the  youngest  re claimed area. 2. Enchytraeids   are   present   in   the  sub- alpine   meadow,   and   absent   from   all   re- claimed study sites. 3. Nematodes are very rare on the young- er reclaimed study sites. 4. Dipterans (flies) are diverse and abun- dant on all sites. 5. Inoculation   sources   of   soil   organisms are  likely found  in small  patches of undis- turbed subalpine forest. 6. A trial introduction of earthworms suc- cessfully survived the summer of 1983. It is likely that this study will indicate that a desirable decomposer population of soil fauna is developing soon after the spoils have been reclaimed. The development of these spoils may be further enhanced by establishing favorable microsite conditions, providing an inoculation source, and possible inoculating reclaimed spoils with larger de- composer fauna such as earthworms. Attention to a number of details at the time of reclamation may ultimately enhance the decomposition/nutrient cycling processes, en- courage self-sufficiency at an early age, and thus reduce fertilizer and other management costs. 80 Proceedings of the 8th Annual British Columbia Mine Reclamation Symposium in Victoria, BC, 1984. The Technical and Research Committee on Reclamation References Brady, N.C., 1974. The nature and properties of soils. 8th ed. MacMillan Pub. Co., New York. Christiansen, K. 1964. "Bionomics of Colem- bola." Ann. Rev. Entomol. 9; 147-178. Edwards, C.A., and J.R. Lofty. 1972. Biology of earthworms. Chapman and Hall Ltd., London. Fyles, J.W, 1980. "Vegetation and soil de- velopment on reclaimed mine land at high elevations in southeastern British Columbia." Unpublished M.Sc. thesis, University of Victoria. Hutson, B.R. 1980. "Colonization of industrial reclamation sites by Acari, Collembola, and other invertebrates." J. Appl. Ecol. 17:233-241. Lawrence, J.M. 1982. "The soil fauna of high elevation reclaimed sites in south- eastern British Columbia." Annual re- clamation report for 1982. B.C. Coal Ltd., Sparwood, B.C. Marshall, V.G., D.K. McE. Kevan, J.V. Matthews, and A.D. Tomlin. 1982. "Status and research needs of Canadian soiI arthropods." Ent. Soc. Can. 14 (1) Suppl. 5 pp. Stanton, N.L. and D. Krementz. 1982. Nema- tode densities on reclaimed sites in a cold desert shrub-steppe." Reel. Reveg. Res. I: 233-241. Vimmerstedt, J.P., and J.H. Finney. 1973. "Impact of earthworm introduction on litter burial and nutrient distribution in Ohio stripmine spoil banks." SoiI Sci. Amer. Proc., 37(3): 388-391. WaIlwork, J.A. 1976. The distribution and diversity of soil fauna. Academic Press, London. 81


Citation Scheme:


Citations by CSL (citeproc-js)

Usage Statistics



Customize your widget with the following options, then copy and paste the code below into the HTML of your page to embed this item in your website.
                            <div id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidgetDisplay">
                            <script id="ubcOpenCollectionsWidget"
                            async >
IIIF logo Our image viewer uses the IIIF 2.0 standard. To load this item in other compatible viewers, use this url:


Related Items